The best restaurants serving British food in Scotland

Bar staff friendly but wasn’t in the mood to be listening to chef loud, swearing and acting like the big man while playing pool. Very unprofessional. I’ve worked in hospitality many years and felt so uncomfortable sitting there.

I decided to have dinner at the hotel because I arrived tired and it was a pleasant surprise! I was very well attended to and the food was excellent, at a very good price! I ate a starter of breaded mushrooms that were perfect and a main course of a steak that was perfectly cooked with peas and fries that were also perfectly cooked. There are good options for beer, beer and wine. Excellent service and cuisine!

We heard this was a very good restaurant and chose it for a birthday celebration while visiting Edinburgh. The restaurant is small and as we were trying to take our seats, a woman came in with a large dog and made it impossible for us to get to our seats for several awkward minutes. The dog yelped periodically during our meal. Just off the dining area there is a tiny children's play area. What a ridiculous idea! The night we were at the restaurant, the children in the playroom were screaming and it made it impossible to have a conversation. I don't know if the staff was ever going to say something to the parents, but when it was really unbearable, we asked if something could be done. After a staff member said something to the parents, the noise calmed down a bit, but never entirely. The food was good, but the unpleasant ambiance of a yelping dog and screaming children took away greatly from our experience. If we wanted this, we would go to McDonald's. This is not an inexpensive restaurant and we expected more.

Nice to have the vegan options. The place is in an old church building and it was freezing cold we had to keep our coats on and the place looks a bit dated.

Toilets are very dirty, not cleaned mess in first two cubicles. Staff swearing in front of customers staff having breaks off shift talking about other members of staff in earshot of customers not a great look.

Coffee was warm half of it was on the saucer and the waitress never said sorry or replaced it ,Toast was also cold

service and food as always 100%

Had a nice overnight stay with my partner. I upgraded our room to a superior one but it looked out onto a wall which was a bit of a shame. I think the pool and spa facilities could be upgraded, I'd also seen the photo of the outdoor jacuzzi and was really excited to use it but was told you had to pay extra for it which was a bit gutted about. Really liked the bar area and staff were very good. Quite isolated if you don't have a car but hotel staff helped us get taxis. Would return if spa area was improved. But the grounds are beautiful and decor is lovely.

I ordered the deep-fried pizza and chips with cheese. Both tasted good, but the portion of chips and cheese was too small for the price, and the cheese-to-chips ratio wasn't great. Overall, it was okay, but I’m unsure if I’ll return due to the small portion size.

Pepperoni pizza last night, gave me the shits all day today, I will not be back...

Just had a munchy box for 2. Absolutely brilliant. Loads of food in 2 boxes, really nice chips & kebab meat. Service was quick and friendly. If I lived closer I'd be in every week.

Absolute joke of a place! It took over 2hours for a delivery and when I called to enquire how much longer I only got a poor reason. Called again and I could only talk to a young girl as the owner wouldn’t speak. Food was just warm and no apology was given by driver either. Will never recommend!

Initial thought The Witchery was too dark but my eyes adjusted and I realised its for effect. Staff were very courteous and friendly our waitress was lovely. The food came in a timely manner but we never felt rushed. All 3 courses were excellent and the house wine was very good. Its a bit expensive but worth it for the level of service and the quality of the food.

Always friendly staff. My opinion hasn't really changed. I personally really like the Carrick Stone....I am in there regularly.

Lovely place! The food was so tasty and fresh, I highly recommended the langoustines. Staff were friendly and the views were so nice too