The best restaurants serving Italian food in Sheffield Yorkshire and The Humber

A lovely little restaurant! Wonderful food for cheap prices, and a lovely atmosphere

I have been to vito lots of times over the past 12 ish years and I have never been disappointed! I would recommend Vito's 100%

For people in search of best experiences, a truly gem, taste, service, ambient, you are there to be enriched and surprised.

Visited for the 1st time on a Saturday evening. Was very busy but the service was still excellent. I have a chicken dish, which if anything was too large!! but really nice. My son had a calzone which again was really good. Value for money was excellent considering the city centre location and will visit again when next in Sheffield.

Been with friends for dinner .Had a nice evening. Amazing staff,made everything to make sure we are happy with the service and food.Well done to the waiters and the kitchen staff❤️ Personally I was not very impressed maybe because I was expecting an authentic Italian cuisine and taste like in Italy.I wouldn't put the Italian flag on this restaurant BUT I would put both flags l,the mexican and italian. The portions are quite big as you can see.The ingredients are good quality .The best dish from my perspective was the steak 🥩.The fish dish was better with more chilli flakes ,but again this is just my personal preference. The restaurant is clean and very cozy. I would recommend this place to try it out and don't forget to tip x

Really nice Italian in crosspool Sheffield, food was wonderful and staff were friendly, make sure to take cash, as its a cash only establishment!! I was caught short and had to run to the ATM. But very nice would go again!

Excellent food, lovely surroundings, will definitely come again.

Lovely food .. No real atmosphere.

Hello ia was a regular costumer of cinque terre restaurant which now is changed to colosseo restaurant the food still the best so is the prices but what is to let you down the service no waiters at all the chef services the food and the place was very small before but warm now i gone the other day to get a take way pizza and is turned in a cottage they have cut it in half and no one would feel comfortable eating there so just stick with take way

Esto era una comida para llevar brillante tenía kebabs absolutamente de primera comida. Entrega rápida y comida deliciosa, mucha carne de donador.

Amazingly quick service and super friendly staff, the food was amazing as always and such a reasonable price. The restaurant is itself is in a lovely location and the atmosphere is really welcoming friendly and just made for a really nice meal out! Thank you for the lovely staff and food😊

i wish i took a picture of the food! But it was just too damn good the second it was delivered to my table (i couldn’t help myself) the presentation, the smell of all the fresh ingredients and let’s not forget about the taste of this awesome italian/ mexican food! I highly recommend the El paso chicken steak 🥩 🍗 with the fried egg, rice and chips. came all sizzling on a hot plate. will definitely be coming back and don’t even get me started on the well made cocktails (spoilt for choice) 🍸 🍹

Food was amazing. Will definitely be coming back. Andrea was serving us tonight and was lovely and made sure everything was a great experience. Thankyou!!!

Fuimos a Akentannos anoche (9 de mayo de 2025). La comida era absolutamente deliciosa y el servicio era impecable! Este pequeño restaurante en Sharron Vale Road es una joya absoluta. Tiene un ambiente tranquilo encantador a pesar de que está bastante ocupado cuando fuimos un viernes por la noche, y es perfecto para la conversación y genial para parejas que quieren una comida íntima. Hay un montón de opciones vegetarianas, veganas y sin gluten, recién cocinadas y una delicia para comer. El servicio fue perfecto. Las dos camareras que nos sirven eran muy amables y dispuestos a compartir información sobre las raíces sardas de la comida y el vino sardo encantador. Tenían el equilibrio perfecto de atención y dejarnos solos cuando no estábamos pidiendo nada activamente. Te dejan mucho tiempo para terminar tu comida y no te apuran, creo que fuimos los últimos en llegar el viernes, pero todavía no nos gustaba irnos! Sin duda volvería a ir de nuevo y recomendaría este restaurante cualquier día.

Traditional lovely local Italian. Been coming for years. Always fantastic. Staff really friendly. Definitely recommend!