Come A Casa in Sheffield

Lovely food .. No real atmosphere.

Food tasteless and uninteresting. Decor characterless. Definitely not worth the prices. Service was very good. Don’t recommend.

Made a booking for Saturday night for a birthday treat and it was closed. No call to cancel the booking and ruined the night and surprise

Visited on a Saturday night, there were four of us. Food was lovely, we all had starters and all had steaks. The steaks were cooked to perfection. Service was great, couldn't fault a thing. Really reasonably priced too. Definitely reccomend.

Good standard of food, and variety of choices Lovely, friendly staff

All the staff were very efficient and friendly

The sofa seats are very upright to the point that sitting is made unnatural. Service was good. The food was upsetting for me and put me off ordering salmon dishes from any restaurant. The pasta salmon had not just little bones but a whole piece of vertebrae. Disappointing. It’s been a whole year and I still can’t order salmon pasta from any Italian. Also onion in my friends carbonara?

Don't get to go often but the food and the service is always excellent

Take away pizza was alright but the size.. shocking.. smaller than frozen pizza from Iceland.

The food was really nice, however the selection for vegetarian dishes were poor. Please consider spinach and ricotta cannelloni or macaroni cheese (which I'm sure would be great for the kids too). Service was good and it was a relaxing atmosphere.

Food was fantastic, plenty of vegan options when requested. Friendly waiter, lovely venue.

Best Italian restaurant in Sheffield.

I suppose a good review is when you want to return to a restaurant that you have been to before. My wife and I went to Come a Casa for valentine's meal last year and this, and were not disappointed on either occasion. Lovely food with good friendly service. Would recommend to anyone.

This place is great! Atmosphere is cool and the staff are really friendly. I’m very picky with food, but everything we tasted melted in our mouths. I ordered the Avocado Gamberetti and Chicken Risotto and it was absolutely the best meal I’ve had in a while. Can’t wait to return to recommend to anyone looking for somewhere to eat.

Best restaurant I’ve been in a while. Absolutely amazing service, and the food is so delicious, me and my partner ordered the Crayfish salad and Fettine Della Mamma. Really enjoyed the food and wine. Will definitely come back here again!

Organised a meal for my sons 18th and I have to say the service really stood out. Haven’t been here since they moved so a long time We were upstairs and had pre ordered to save time Staff welcoming and efficient, looking after a slightly rowdy table of 16 they couldn’t have don’t more for us Food was good but not sure it’s worth 5 rating so it’s 5 for the service and 4 for the food Great little local restaurant definitely worth support

Smashing restaurant, great menu, wonderful staff. Definitely worth a visit. We had a lovely evening and will be visiting again soon.

Authentic cuisine in a cosey setting.

Great little restaurant that is local; great service and food what else can you ask for. Food was amazing.

Nice restaurant, very attentive and friendly staff but food was average, so on that we wouldn't go back. Im not saying don't give these guys a try as many other reviews say differently - it's just our personal preference. When other nationalities try to come off as another - in this case Italian, but they are not Italian, its a shame they don't stick with what they know & cook the food they love from back home.

Lovely family meal today. Very friendly and helpful member of staff. Each of our starters and main meals were delicious. The children's meal was a really good portion and they kindly boxed what was left so we could take it home. Would recommend. Thank you

Fantastic restaurant with the largest portions of pasta you'll ever see.

Had a good time with lovely food

Absolutely beautiful 👌 not a thing to complain about 😋 so very tasty 😋

Fantastic meal tonight. The food was gorgeous and the staff friendly and welcoming. Felt very relaxed. Would definitely come again. Thank you for a lovely night.

1st time eating here and really enjoyed the meal. Very friendly staff..great ambiance..definitely go again. Highly recommend.

Friendly and helpful staff. We really enjoyed our night, The food was lovely. They even bright out a little slice of cake and sung Happy Birthday to my daughter. Would highly recommend!!!

Great food and cozy place to go

Fresh high quality food and lovely environment with finest quality of steaks.

A good meal in a comfortable environment with friendly staff. A great local restaurant.

I ordered a pizza- it was like the base had been purchased - tasted very processed. The topping had previously friend onions placed on it, like those you get on a hotdog. Not nice. I had ice cream with choc sauce and hazelnuts for desert - hardly any nuts were on it and I specifically asked for extra nuts. No ice in my coke either. Won’t be returning which is a shame as I live close by and was hoping it would be great.

Lovely food, lovely staff. Such a nice place to go !

A really nice Italian restaurant. The food is lovely. And great staff too. Highly recommended.

Birthday treat for my Birthday, provided by my daughter and son-in-law. We have used this restaurant a few times before and have never been disappointed. Excellent service by pleasant efficient staff and we all had lovely meals. We shall use them again

A lovely little Italian restaurant in the centre of chapeltown. Overall five stars just four stars given for food as the calzone just didn't meet the mark. Parking can be tricky in chapeltown as the car park at the rear now has pay and display charges. We did book a table, it was quite busy. We had starters, mains, sweet and wine everything was served with a smile. Food Prices are reasonable, drinks are a little steep. Toilets are clean and accessible. Atmosphere was good we sat in a booth at the back which was a little more private. We would eat here again.

Delicious food served by very pleasant, personable staff. The complimentary liqueur was a nice touch.

Great food and friendly staff which provide a superb experience and are very helpful. Family friendly and choices for everyone. Would highly recommend if you want to have a excellent meal.

Great little Italian resturant. Good for family meals or for large groups. Service is fantastic.

Fantastic food and drinks, friendly polite service, good value for money, great all round atmos.

Brilliant food, best this last whole year. Worth going out of your way, but usually full so book a table.

Went as a group to celebrate a birthday. Food and service were excellent even though we were in a large group. Staff were lovely and helpful and couldn't do enough. Thank you for a lovely evening.

Outstanding service, top quality food you won't be disappointed. Had mussels and lobster ravioli from the specials board..and Steak pizzaiola and pollo gamberetti, were faultless and delicious!!

Food is amazing quality, great value for money and the staff are superb.

Went for meal and the food was lovely , the staff were very kind and attentive. Will be returning for sure

We visited this little Italian over Christmas period to break up the turkey feasts. The service here was brilliant, always attentive, and polite. We had bruschetta and calamari to start. Good portion sizes, toast was a little burnt but not enough to put you off. Carbonara and calzone pizza for mains both had very homemade feels to them. The calzone seemed on the small side but was very tasty. chips pirchased on the side. Choc fudge cake to finish. Again, a good portion was shared by two.

Really great food and excellent service.

Had the pollo in bacon ,onion and cream sauce was beautiful for mains. For starter had the garlic bread with cheese and tomato, home run again .

We came last night and had the best meal ever. The service was excellent and the evening was perfect.

Excellent service and food. Would definitely recommend

Great quality food, attentive staff. Good beer. Decent prices considering the global climate.

First visit & will certainly go again. Staff were friendly, food was delicious. It was my friends birthday & they brought her an ice cream treat with candle & sang happy birthday to her. The only thing missing was some background music.

Absolutely brilliant. Fantastic staff who are very attentive. Great atmosphere that's not loud with good lighting. Then the food; delicious. The portion sizes are just right and far beyond any Italian dish you think that you can make at home.

We went for my daughter's 18th birthday. They accommodated us bringing the birthday cake earlier in the evening. Was great to see them joining in and singing happy birthday when they presented the cake to my daughter later on. Both the meal and service were fantastic. The 2 waiters were so friendly and the food was spot on, so well done to the chef. Would definitely recommend and will be back.

Best chicken risotto I have had out , partners steak cooked to perfection. Service fabulous , we will be returning

Nice food, very friendly and welcoming. Nice ombience.

Great food - the staff managed to squeeze us in after arriving without a booking and we're so glad they did!! The food was absolutely delicious and the waiting staff were so attentive. Thank you all so much!

First time we've been won't be the last great meal very friendly and polite staff thoroughly recommend it

I think that Italian food is my favorite kind of food. It is a high energy food. There is action going on all around the plate. It is a fast moving and passionate food. The whole time you are eating the food is alive. It is fast and passionate and energized. So this restaurant in my town, Casa Italian Restaurant is perfect for my Italian food loving soul. Their food is of course also made with great energy and passion.

Lovely place to eat with a genuine Italian flavour. The fish stew, was dry and not recommended at all, not a soup at all. However the lasagne a great taste, fresh and hot. The staff are friendly and efficient, would recommend for a nice meal in the area!

Decided we needed to celebrate the life of a member of family that died today. First visit after hearing good reviews.Excellent service from the start the food was lovely and tasty we had 3 courses. And a couple of drinks. We had an excellent visit and we will certainly be back.Thank you.

Lovely Birthday family meal last night, lovely food and very attentive staff, excellent service

Great staff nice and friendly,well informed about drinks and menu Food well presented and delicious we had pudding which was just as good lovely surroundings and even got a free lemon shot. Brilliant experience would highly recommend

Went last night Friday 22nd July for a 30th birthday meal,first time visit for the 5 of us, had a lovely meal , couldn't fault it everyone really enjoyed the food, atmosphere & friendly helpful staff . Would definatly recommend to anyone and will be happily paying another visit soon hopefully , so nice to have a lovely local Italian restaurant.

Good quality food at reasonably prices

Really enjoyed our visit. The food ticked all the boxes and the service was great too, friendly and accommodating. A great touch by the waitress to secretly ask us first before offering the kids some sweets. Thanks for having us, see you again!

The best restaurant l've been in for a long time

Lovely place to eat ...upstairs is good for accommodating larger groups

Authentic Italian. Really enjoyed our visit

Plenty of menu choices for each course and the food/service were excellent. Nicer new venue as it's bigger so no feeling of being squashed in. Highly recommend.

Good nice. Cheap and cheerful. Service brilliant.

Friendly helpful staff, really tasty authentic food lovely ambience cannot praise them enough

Excellent good food and service at a reasonable price. We'll worth a visit. Second time as good as first will be back

Not good value. Very disappointed. Had a meal for our 37th wedding anniversary tonight. Starters were very nice. Waited a while for main course. Plates not attractive. I had a chicken in cheese sauce. No accompanying vegetables or anything else on the plate. 4 potato pieces in a little tub is all that came with it. Tasted ok but not appetising. My husband's meal much worse. A huge platter with a small lamb shank and a lot of tasteless sauce. This was served with some horrible gloopy mashed potatoes. Had to give him my potatoes as his food was so sparse. All for £20. So not worth it. Service appalling. Almost non existent. Cannot honestly recommend this restaurant. Been looking forward to going since we moved here. What a shame.

Average at best! Tagliatelle came & looked like it had been kept warm for an hour, which is about how long it took to come. Overcooked mussels & overcooked venison. When we complained we were constantly told 'but we're busy & have a big party upstairs.' Totally unprofessional of the staff to repeatedly call one of our party 'darling' when we questioned the quality of food & service. After the table was cleared another member of staff came. We showed her a photo of the vegetables served as a side order & told her we would put the picture on Google reviews. Her reply was 'oh no, please don't do that'. The ones in our party who had the salmon & steak enjoyed those dishes. That was 2 people out of 6. We won't rush back.

Recommended to this restaurant by a friend. It didn't disappoint. Beautiful food.

What a fabulous find, the food is amazing, fresh, full of flavour, delicious, the steak one of the best I've had. Friendly, attentive service extremely good value. Definitely will be returning.

Came here on friday to celebrate a birthday! Warm and friendly staff! Absolutely beautiful and fresh cooked food! Everyone in the party enjoyed it! Will definately be booking again!

Just popped in for a coffee and cake, delicious, very clean place will try out the evening menu soon

Really lovely nice to have somewhere local for fab food

Visited for a family birthday meal, excellent food,fantastic staff outstanding service lovely atmosphere will definitely be going again xx

Found the decor unwelcoming dark. Coffee was "OK-ish" and cake had long straps of human hair on it. Will not be returning .

Called in for a lovely morning hot drink this morning , first class surroundings and staff ⭐⭐⭐⭐

lovely food, me and my boyfriend come here all the time!! the lasagne is my favourite :)

Our first visit to come a casa good service. food was nice and hot when served

Great atmosphere, lovely attentive staff. And most importantly really nice food and plenty of it. Will be back again soon.

Lovely food great place to eat.

Gorgeous food & the staff were very attentive, we had an enjoyable night out

Excellent meal and service last night, our first visit, there will be more.

Everything about thus place is brilliant from the friendly staff to excellent food

Had a collection from Coma Casa and the quality and freshness is just like eating in. No corners cut and definitely freshly made. We will be eating in and or having more collections in the near future. Real treat.

Beautiful Italian restaurant. Moved recently and hasn't lost it's charm.

Rushed to vacate table for next service

Fabulous place with great food, huge portions and very attentive staff.

Another fabulous meal, I can't wait to go back, I can't fault anything and the staff are brilliant.

Hi there we came on 30th October for my husbands 60th birthday we had a great time the staff were very helpful nothing was too much trouble the food was delicious and we had a fabulous meal and a lovely time we also got free shots when we paid our bill we will definitely be coming back soon your's sue

Very friendly staff Lovely food Reasonable prices

Absolutely fantastic meal here, I had the most wonderful Steak with onion, tomato, sweet chilli and courgette sauce, couldn't fault the food at all, the staff were also super accomadating to my brothers needs with his food, absolutely 5 out of 5!

Ordered here last minute last night when craving some carbonara and they absolutely did not disappoint. It was all beautiful, we had two pizzas and my only gripe was that they were too small because they were gone too quickly we wanted more haha! Even my fussy child was eating my pasta and asking for me for more. It was all fresh, tasty, still piping hot when we had got it home. Everything tasted great and we will definitely be back! Lovely suprise to have this so close to home.... Not ideal for my waistline but hey ho!

Best pizza ever had - and staff friendly in authentic Italian restaurant

Brilliant place with amazing food and fantastic, friendly service. We had breaded mozzarella to start and it was amazing! The pizza was brilliant too. This is such a gem in Sheffield and the staff were super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend! Great value.