Bella Italia in Sheffield

We were in Sheffield to see John Bishop just up the road and we didnt make plans to eat so we walked around and everywhere was really busy, so we saw Bella Italia in the centre of Sheffield and it was dead!!! We went in and asked if they had a table for 2 (i repeat the place was dead!!!) and he asked if we had booked and did that thing contractors do, ie suck in their breath. We were then told that they may not look that busy (again it was dead) but they were due to fill up after 5pm and be really busy. We were then told that as long as we were quick and wouldnt be more than an hour then we could have a table. We were starving so we were showed to a table. Now we were there til after 5 and it got maybe half full. That was the negative, but made us feel rushed and if it wasnt for the fact we were really hungry and everywhere else was busy we would have left. For the good part the main meal we had (didnt dare have starters or pudding due to being told we had to leave after an hour) was delicious. Also our server "Dylan" was lovely. To this end we always leave a tip even if it is added on to the bill, but the initial guy on the desk on entry made us feel like we werent welcome and so we didnt leave a tip at all. To be fair, we were that annoyed if there was a gratuitous on there we were going to ask for it to be taken off.

Amazing meal and great service from Chloe 😊

Amazing meal and service from Chloe!!

Evening meal. Ordered the spaghetti with meatballs, and the Gamberrotti. Service was fine, the meals came quickly, but the pasta was clearly overdone, and not freshly cooked to order. The quality was just average to poor, and we wouldn't recommend, despite the fantastic review's. portion size was good, but the meal was overpriced for what we got.

Lovely meal, Chloe was wonderful!

Chloe was amazing, we had a lovely time and would most certainly come again! Thank you for looking after us Chloe ☺️

Chloe was absolutely amazing! Fantastic service and a wonderful night. Cant wait to return

Chloe was fantastic, very quick and efficient service and catered to our needs!

Amazing service from Chloe, food was great.

Lovely trip to Bella Italia this evening, didn’t have a booking but staff were very accommodating. Chloe was our server, she was very friendly and made sure we enjoyed our meal.

We had a meal here prior to a theatre visit. The food was excellent and our waitress was friendly.

Came for lunch with my friend on a Saturday afternoon, restaurant was nice and relaxed and food was gorgeous! Conrad and Kyle were great!

conrad was absolutely amazing and lovely would definitely come again

Conrad is a good man give him a raise and bonus.

Relaxing evening on a Friday, service was prompt and serve Conrad was very attentive!! Food was lovely, although a bit too much tomato to bread ratio on the bruschetta - thank you for a lovely evening

Conrad at Sheffield Bella Italia was very attentive and friendly. Gorgeous meal with quick pre-gig service.

Served by Conrad, very efficient very pleasant, very accommodating.

Last minute booking for food before going to Sheffield City Hall. It definitely didn’t disappoint. I had Chicken Milanese and my husband had Calzone. Both were very enjoyable. Finished with the lemon cheesecake which was exceptional. Our server Conrad was lovely.

Delicious gluten free food! Over 24 hours since I ate and had no reactions. Thank you to the chef for the tasty and safe food! Conrad provided excellent service throughout. Will be visiting again :)

Amazing service by Hollie making sure everything was perfect and running the place on her own.

Really nice food, great service from Conrad who has been fantastic throughout

Absolutely lovely, we had to go to the theatre afterwards and that was understood clearly as they made sure we got everything in time! Lovely lovely food!!!!! Great attention to allergies!!! Lovely staff, Hollie was exceptional and so welcoming!!

Holly was an amazing severe was very quick and efficient and lovely to talk to. Overall food was amazing and would definitely come here again!

Hollie was a great asset to the team

Holly was great very attentive and friendly

Very nice meal and good service

Hollies was the perfect host very attentive and professional nothing was too much trouble

Hollies was polite, professional and fast! Delicious pizza delivered with a flourish and a check-in to make sure all was well. Highly recommended.

Food was delicious. Not many people in when we arrived so served really quickly but it did fill up while we were eating. Hollie, our server, was very friendly and attentive.

Food was good and served quickly. Cocktails tasted nice and strong! Our server was Hollie and she was nice, polite and friendly towards us. Would come back 😊

The food was loverly ,service and politeness is very good ,hollies is very happy and polite good manners.

Food was delicious didn’t have to wait long for food the mozzarella stick were amazing definitely recommend and the service was amazing staff are so friendly

Brilliant place. Although a franchise, it's very personal. Staff brilliant. And they do gluten-free which is important to me

Great place! Hollie was a brilliant waitress!

Food was lovely and the service was great! Shout out to Hollie who was a great waitress and very attentive to us.

great atmosphere and service from hollie!!

Just a note to say thank you very much Chloe for such wonderful service. Friendly, considerate, and professional. I wish you every success and happiness, the Northern Irish lass.

Our waiter, Declan, was so friendly and welcoming. The meatballs starter was a bit of a small portion, but the rest of the meal was excellent. Well worth the visit!

Had a lovely three course dinner here this evening !! Our waiter Dylan was really accommodating and our meals were super lovely all round. He made sure to ask if there were any dietary requirements/allergies and was really polite and friendly. We couldn’t go out for valentines since my boyfriend wasn’t feeling great, so the fact that today was so lovely was just brilliant! Thank you Dylan and the rest at Bella Italia!! 🥰💗

We went for a girls night out and our waitress Chloe was lovely! She made us feel very welcomed and comfortable and gave us as much time as we needed! Would definitely go again!

The food was amazing and Chloe was absolutely lovely!

Dylan my waiter was very friendly and efficient with service. The whole experience was amazing and would deffo come back

Dylan served us. The was excellent and the service was too.

Good service from dylan, lovely food

Friendly staff great service great food definitely recommend the ribs and double chicken pizza

Lovely meal and excellent service, thanks for Dylan.

Such nice food! Definitely going to return. Great service aswell from the waiter Dylan!

Very nice food and Chloe the waitress was so lovely and patient with us.

We came to Sheffield for my 35th birthday and booked in the restaurant prior to seeing a show. Dylan was brilliant. We all felt so welcome and he looked after us. The service was speedy, food was delicious and Dylan was so friendly which is hard to experience in these times! Thank you, we will return!

Chloe was lovely and looked after us, food was great to

our waitress ordered our drinks and food quickly but when the food arrived, both the calzone and carbonara were cold and underwhelming! our waitress Hollie then asked us to write a review about her and in return she would get us free shots and within the same minute she had disappeared and didn’t provide us with the other end of the request. (we then found out from another table that she would win a bottle of wine if she gets a certain amount of reviews) It was a shame that it didn’t meet our expectations and we ended up leaving within the hour.

Had a lovely waiter called Declan very nice and polite and was great service.

Very poor lunch experience, place was nearly empty, even so, service was really really slow, at the end I had to get up and ask for the bill, dirty cold plates still sitting on our table waiting to be cleared Food itself was two types of pasta, when served they both had that dull look of food left standing too long, not freshly made by someone Won’t be going back

Hollie was gave outstanding service, so friendly and added to the whole experience. She was eager and attentive, couldn’t ask for a better service. great atmosphere. Would reccomend

Holly was really friendly, she was every patient as we had quite a few people in our group, the service was really quick. overall a really good experience. Would definitely recommend.

We had a great experience at this restaurant, the food was excellent and our server Hollie was lovely.

Hollie was a great waitress, very accommodating for my friends birthday and made sure we were happy throughout. Crayons also supplied for our child so everyone was welcome! Food 10/10

Amazing . Hollie was serving us and she was so polite and attentive. Would definitely come back here just because of the service ! Food was delicious 🥰🥰

This was the worst meal I have had in years. Hollie our server was pleasant however that is the only positive. The starters were tasteless and the cheesy dough ball stack was laughable. The pulled beef pizza tasted fine but the meat was full of gristle. We ordered an affogato for dessert and the server tried to convince us we were wrong when we asked for a second scoop of ice cream despite it being clearly stated on the menu that two were included. Additionally the table we were given was squished next to the bar. This meant staff were constantly brushing past us and often stood complaining about their day to each other right next to us. This did not create a relaxing environment. I would never recommend this restaurant and won't be returning.

The restaurant was lovely, our server Hollie was amazing and went above and beyond for me and my boyfriend on our valentine's dinner date

Lovely food, really good garlic bread

Hollie is a fab server (enjoy ur wine😁)

Hollie was really helpful and friendly. The food was lovely!!!!!

Hollie was really polite and efficient waitress. We really appreciated her kindness and service. Thank you Hollie

Hollie was lovely, really looked after us at our table!!

I came here with my partner for Valentine's Day. Our server was called Hollie, she was really polite, she took our orders very quick and made sure we were satisfied. Very wonderful experience

Great service, Hollie greeted and treated us with fast, friendly service, couldn’t fault her

Hollie was a brilliant waitress very friendly and helpful.

The food and drinks were lovely, very tasty. Our waitress for the night was Hollie who was very fast and helpful. Great Valentine’s dinner, would definitely recommend.

Our server Hollie was fantastic, the service was very quick. The food was lovely (vegan spaghetti & meatballs). All-round nice dinner.

Hollie was a brilliant server but we was a bit put off by being told we only had the table for 1hr 15min. Felt very rushed so couldn’t enjoy the evening as much as we wanted to. We came previously and loved it and hollie served us there too. During the booking process a time limit should be given.

Came in for a valentines meal , our server Hollie was lovely and attentive. Starters were nice but had carbonara for main and it almost tasted like a microwave meal.

Came here for valentine’s day.Atmostphere was great , nice and warm and very quick service. Was served by hollie who was very helpful. Lovely girl 😁

Hollie was very attentive, a credit to your organisation. Asked if our food was okay, recommended products, was a memorable experience.

Server (Holly) was super nice, gave us some free shots on Valentine’s Day 🙌🏻 xxx

Hollie was lovely with excellent customer service! Couldn’t have asked for a better experience.

Hollie was ace 😁 had a great time

Hollie our waiter was brilliant and made us feel welcome

Great food and great service from Hollie ♥️

Great service. Food was nice. Hollie was great.

Great quick service from Hollie on V day

Lovely service and food. Thank you Hollie!

Had a really nice Saturday evening meal here. It was actually quite quiet and nice. Our server Hollie was also super nice.

Very chill and Hollie was super nice

Great service from Dylan! Nice food and great atmosphere.

My family has a nice meal. Conrad and his colleagues did a good job looking after us.

The food and service was amazing , our waitress Hollie was amazing and was very accommodating to say we came in with 30 mins till Kitchen closes

Fantastic service and brilliant food and drinks

Hollie was great! Thanks so much for everything!

Amazing staff, great night! Thank you Dylan!

Great service from our server Dylan. He was friendly and helpful - even slightly changing a dish on the menu to suit my mothers tastes.

Great customer service, Dylan was our server and he was lovely, going above and beyond checking in to make sure everything was okay, the food was fantastic, I can’t wait to go back again

Enjoyed our meal,good gluten free options. Excellent service from Dylan.

Fab lunch. Dylan (our server) was brilliant

Amazing food, great wine selection and Chloe and Wik were amazing

chloe and wik were the loveliest servers, they made us feel so welcome and their service was amazing, couldn’t recommend enough

Amazing service from Wik and Chloe. Lovely meal and they went the extra way to help us out! Would defo come back

Chloe and Wik were amazing, we got free wine for our staff do. Thank you!

The food was amazing and Chloe and Wik was so kind.

Beautiful food. Amazing vegan options. Hollie offered amazing customer service and was very polite and attentive. 10 out of 10 for customer service