Bella Italia in Sheffield

Came here for a meal before a show. Quiet atmosphere as it was only a Monday night but couldn't fault the service. Hollie was our waitress and was really lovely. The food was great too. Would recommend.

I've been a few times now and it's always lovely. My server Hollie was great about my dietary restrictions and super friendly!

Popped in for a quiet meal, the staff were very friendly and the atmosphere was lovely. Our server Hollie was very helpful when we had questions about the menu and provided excellent suggestions. I'd definitely come again

Good food for good price and friendly quick service - especially from Hollie. :)

Lovely atmosphere for a Monday evening. Food was great and fabulous service from our waitress Hollie. Couldn’t fault anything.

Great food and customer service from Hollie. 10/10

The service and food is great. Really nice place. Hollie did a great job

The food was great. Enjoyed my experience. Hollie was our server and she was great and enthusiastic

Hollie was an amazing servant and very friendly

Food was very enjoyable and the service by Hollie was excellent. My allergies were also catered for very easily.

Nice food, great service. Special shoutout to Hollie!

really nice food, hollie was really helpful and really nice :)

Lovely food and buzzing atmosphere, served by the wonderful hollie

Great service by Hollie, and food was great value for money

Food was lovely. Hollie was great and did an amazing job.

Hollie did a great job, made us feel welcome and the food was very nice too.

A nice restaurant with good food and welcoming atmosphere. Hollie was very pleasant and helpful, with a lovely smile. I recommend Bella Italia.

Great pizza’s and Hollie our waitress was lovely , enjoyed our evening x

Holly was our waitress was polite and good service

hollie was our waitress and offered very good service and was also very kind

Had a lovely service with Hollie XX very lovely atmosphere

Booked as a group of 10 (only 9 came in the end) for a team meal while visiting Sheffield for a weekend competition. Phone booking was a bit weird - pretty sure it's a robot/AI, so I was unsure if the booking had gone through but received a text confirmation. The meal started well with a friendly female waitress. Drink orders were taken promptly and delivered fairly quickly. The restaurant wasn't packed but busy enough to create a nice atmosphere. Food orders were also taken in good time and starters came out soon after, which everyone seemed to enjoy. Things went a bit downhill after that. After a reasonable wait, the mains all came together, but some were lukewarm as they'd obviously been sat while the rest of the meals were prepared. Not a major problem as we were all hungry but not ideal. At this point, our waitress seemed to disappear and was replaced by a male waiter. One of our group asked him for some garlic sauce to go with the pizza, but it took so long to come that she'd basically finished eating. We also ordered more drinks which were slow in coming and we had to chase to get all of them. Desserts were a similar story, taking a long time to come and at least one failing to arrive until we chased it. Overall it was a nice evening but slightly let down by the service. I was tempted to complain but in the end decided it wasn't worth it. I've given a slightly generous 4* as the food was nice and 3* felt harsh but the service and food temperature could definitely have been better.

Great birthday celebration meal. Great value for money and staff were most attentive.

Excellent Fabulous Food definitely returning 😀 Friendly atmosphere Waiters/waters. Couldn't fault anything. Beautiful xx

Amazing food and friendly polite waitress, I will be visiting

amazing service, lovely waitress

Hollie was a very good server and chatty. Nice food!

great customer service and helpful from Hollie

On a well earned break from Sheffield Hallam Uni Open day, Hollie was warm and welcoming as well as efficient and attentive. She made our visit to Bella Italia and the city of Sheffield all the more enjoyable.

Hollie was an amazing server, made the experience very enjoyable and made us feel comfortable throughout our time. Very kind and welcoming and made our visit to Sheffield Bella Italia the best I’ve had.

Hollie was really efficient and friendly, lovely atmosphere, definitely dine here again when back in Sheffield.

Hollie was lovelly , attentive and efficient

Had a great visit to the Bella Italia for some lunch. Our waitress Hollie was exceptionally welcoming and friendly. Was always happy to try help with food on the menu. Would definitely recommend visiting.

Good food. Hollie was very hospitable.

Hollies was an outstanding waitress

Lovely lunchtime meal. Hollie served us and was very friendly and helpful :)

Really nice trip out, myself and my partner enjoyed our meals. Couldn’t ask for more. We were served by Chloe and Kyle.

Chloe was a great server, lovely food

Great service by declan, will be back definitely! Thank you

Me and my wife went to Bella Italia, Sheffield - St Paul's for a belated birthday meal. It was our first time going to a Bella Italia. Picked it by the reviews on Google Maps. Reserved our table via the app. A big shout out to Declan our server! Even though the restaurant was really busy and he was run off his feet, he was very attentive and he made our first time there extra special. The meal was fantastic and the atmosphere was really romantic. Lovely view of Sheffield Peace Gardens at night. Will definitely be back on our next visit to Sheffield!

My worst experience of Bella Italia to date. Rude inattentive staff, the manager said the table wouldn't be ready for ten minutes so sent us outside in the cold even though the restaurant was less than half full with loads of tables set. Food took ages to come out to the table, by that time we were the only ones left. It's still hard to get the staff's attention even. For a birthday meal with my family we all left unhappy. Would potentially make me never eat at one again even though I have had great experiences in the past.

Great service and atmosphere (thank you Hollie). Food was ok too

Wonderful service from Hollie. Food was amazing and atmosphere was lovely. Would definitely recommend

Absolutely great service from Hollie at St Paul’s in Sheffield, very friendly and helpful!

Great experience, Hollie made us feel very welcome.

Served by Hollie. She was so lovely and food was delicious, very nice experience!!

Lovely meal with the family at Bella Italia. Really tasty food and fantastic service from Hollie.

Hollie was great and made us feel welcome.

Great food and excellent service from the lovely Hollie - thanks for a fab birthday lunch experience. Couldn’t do enough for us, was a first class service

Holly was great throughout the service. Great food, would recommend.

Very nice food and great service from Hollie

Service was extremely slow and the restaurant was half empty. It took an hour for the starter and 40 minutes for the mains to arrive. Manager seemed disconnected.

Desserts were rubbish, otherwise all great.

Great place for food, good range of options on the menu and all really tasty. Good portion sizes too.

Had a great experience here, the food came quickly. Our waitress Chloe was very friendly and made our meal all the more enjoyable!

Great experience, enhanced by our lovely server Chloe, who was extremely helpful! She was efficient and really good with timing and any questions we had. Would definitely recommend visiting.

Our waitress Chloe was very pleasant and efficient in serving us our 3 courses. The food was very nice, definitely would return.

Had a lovely time! Our waitress Chloe made it particularly enjoyable 😊

Great service. Chloe was polite and helpful !

Hearty, good quality post-work grub! We had 2 courses and all was delicious, particularly the gamberoni was spectacular. We were served by the friendly Declan who was attentive and helpful throughout. We will be back!

A lovely, cosy Bella Italia which ticked most if not all of the boxes. I ordered the ribs which was not too bad, although a bit too sweet for my taste. The cook of the ribs was excellent though, juicy and tender and falling off the bone. The highlight of the evening was probably the service. Conrad, (I think that's how you spelt his name, sorry Conrad!!) was attentive without being suffocating, helpful without being pushy and quite funny to top it off. Service alone deserves 5 stars, but I unfortunately have to take away a star for the ribs. (I know, I know why come to an Italian restaurant and order the ribs, but hey if its on the menu it isn't all my fault is it? Haha!)

Food was fine. Nice waiter. Only the feeling that we had to leave quickly because the dessert was collected and we were immediately asked if we wanted the bill.

Dylan’s service was great. Deffo recommend :)

"A fantastic dining experience! The food was delicious, but the cocktails were the real highlight – expertly crafted and full of flavor. The service was outstanding, with Hollie providing friendly and attentive care throughout the evening. Highly recommend this place for a memorable night out!"

Chloe was excellent, the food was unreal and it was lovely

Beautiful place with lovely stuff. They’re not just serving food; they’re creating an atmosphere that’s just as important as the taste of the dishes. An Italian restaurant is all about hospitality, warmth, and a smile. A waitress Hollie makes every visit an experience. Someone like Hollie becomes an ambassador of the Italian dolce vita!

Have a delicious meal, our waitress Hollie was lovely and attentive. Very much enjoyed.

Holly was amazing even though it was super busy and gluten free option are amazing

food was lovely, our waitress chloe was amazing and made our experience even better

Chloe was a wonderful server, and we were in and out quickly with minimal fuss as requested. Wonderful food & location is superb! Thanks again ☺️

Yeah was excellent great customer service she is a credit to you

Leah was really helpful and provided great service

Lovely service from Hollie at Bella Italia. She was really helpful, very friendly and approachable. Food was excellent and quickly served, menu varied…great restaurant with a happy atmosphere. Overall very impressive

Hollie was lovely, super attentive and really helpful with recommendations. The food was also really good, I had the pulled beef pizza. Defo recommend!

We came in for a meal before our show and Leah was lovely and made sure we were in and out in plenty of time.

our waitress Leah was lovely, great experience!

Lovely meal and very attentive service from Hollie, nailed the flat white!

Hollie was amazing by the way, great waitress.

The food was very tasty and our server Dylan was friendly and helpful

Amazing ! I was so surprised I ate there in Sheffield yesterday. As a coeliac I was incredibly impressed by the choices available, I opted for pizza & it did not disappoint, not only the best tasting pizza I’ve had but exactly like everyone else’s 😋 thank you & a big shout out to Holly so friendly & helpful. Best wishes with your studies & future teaching ..

Had a lovely meal at Bella Italia; our server Hollie was very friendly and the food came very quickly.

food was good for the price, had a great waiter dylan, who was very friendly and made us all feel welcome, reccomend coming here, and would definitely revisit

Great Service by Hollie and food was lovely

Hollie was a lovely server. Very attentive.

Always a great meal here, the restaurant is well laid out and the menu choice is great. Hollie is always friendly and professional, always a pleasure to see her.

This waitress Hollie is literally the GOAT

Very nice service our server was a young lady named Hollie, food was good and fair for the price.

Had a lovely two course meal from the set menu, served by the very friendly and helpful Hollie. She managed the group of 10 of us really well and the food arrived in a timely fashion.

Great service, Hollie was chatty and very lovely

Great service, really great crew. Much appreciated the engagement, especially from Hollie! Would recommend

5 star food, 5 star service! Lovely atmosphere in the restaurant. Clean and tidy and the decor was comfy/cosy vibe. Our server Hollie was happy, smiley and professional. Nothing was too much and she was really efficient. Food was delicious and hot, no complaints. Hollie told us if we downloaded the app we would get £10 off! Bonus! Will definitely be returning again

A great experience, Hollie is always friendly and professional.

Absolutely fantastic night ! Food was excellent, served quick and hot, our waitress Hollie was absolutely fantastic and a good laugh to boot, waitress and waiters with a sense of humour are far and few between but this one was an absolute gem ! Give that one a raise !

Hollie was our server. It was amazing. Great food and great service. She communicated amazingly with us and ensured everything was great. Deserves a raise.

Had a great time with friends, Hollie our waitress was really friendly and helpful. Try the spicy sausage it's great

We absolutely loved our experience at Bella italia our server Hollie was absolutely amazing. Hollie was very welcoming and made sure our experience was a good one. Definitely recommend coming.

Had a great meal, Dylan was very friendly and provided excellent customer service throughout. The food was very nice. Highly reccomend

Good food, friendly staff. Reasonably priced. Thank you

Very nice atmosphere, food and service especially by Konrad, definitely recommend! Especially as you can use UNiDAYS here too.

Beautiful location, very friendly staff especially Hollie!😊