The best restaurants serving Italian food in Scarborough Yorkshire and The Humber

Durante nuestras vacaciones de abril de 2025 en Scarborough, estuvimos encantados de descubrir Crema e Cioccolato en 43 Newborough, una recomendación que agradecemos. Leonardo y Daniele nos dieron una cálida bienvenida en su encantadora tienda llena de carácter. Su pasión por el auténtico helado y la conversación hicieron que nuestra visita fuera memorable. El helado era de clase mundial, y solo desearíamos tener más tiempo para explorar el resto del menú. Una parada aquí es una visita obligada, y mientras esté cerca, visite el Market Hall justo al otro lado del camino. Scarborough está lleno de sorpresas, y esta es sin duda una de las mejores. Gracias chicos, sigan con el gran trabajo!

Ordered through the Foodpenny app, excellent service. Will order again in the near future :) Plan to tell my friends about this Takeout.

I've been here three times now and have enjoyed it every time. The cafe is clean, tidy, really nicely decorated and the staff are welcoming. It's somewhere you want to go into and return. I'll be going again as soon as I can!

Amazing amazing! If you have coeliac disease this place is a dream. I had a gluten free pizza tonight and it was so good! Scarborough doesn’t have many gluten free restaurants so this is a hidden gem. Not only did it taste great the staff are really friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend!

Great place can see why it’s busy. Food was brilliant and the staff were lovely. Would definitely recommend and return.

Este lugar es una joya absoluta. El personal amable más atento que no podía hacer lo suficiente por usted y la comida italiana más deliciosa increíble que he probado. Las porciones eran abundantes y cocinadas a la perfección. Recomiendo encarecidamente a cualquiera que ame la comida italiana

We booked as a large group for our lads rugby tour (nearly 50 people) and I can’t fault the restaurants assistance in catering for such a large party on a bank holiday weekend. Everyone commented on the fresh and tasty food and all the staff worked really hard. Food did take a while due to such a large group to accommodate but everyone said they’d rather wait & have it made fresh and flavoursome like it was 👏. Everyone had a fantastic meal. A huge well done to the team and thank you.

We stumbled on Pomodoro by chance, as we were trying to escape Scarborough’s beach and arcades area. This is really an excellent, reasonably priced Italian restaurant. Both my spaghetti bolognese and my partner’s Quattro formaggi pizza were delicious. Service was attentive to our needs and friendly. Good for families with children.

We were only in town for the night and called last minute for a table, we were squeezed in last minute, the food and service were amazing, we'll definitely be back when next in Scarborough.

We stayed at the Paddock nearby and took a walk to Amir and Kamys. Before we even walked up I heard a group of young teenagers being polite and having a laugh with the owner. Both the owner and the young boys were polite and a credit to the local area. The chef gave Frank our frenchie a bit of left over Donner meat and he was so happy. The pizza was lovely and the service was even better. Prices were reasonable as well. It’s a shame we don’t live more local as we would be in a lot more! Thanks for the lovely food and Frank says Woof :)

Wonderful food and excellent service! We booked a table of 8 late in the day but they managed to squeeze us in. Two of us had the Fillet steaks and they were cooked to perfection (one rare and one well done), kids had pasta ( Lasagne, Carbonara and Penne Salmone) all freshly/home made. Others in our group had a Calzone and a veggie pasta. Everyone really enjoyed their meal, finished off nicely with some delicious Profiteroles that we took home. Great atmosphere and the owners (Chef and front of house) and the waitresses were lovely and very friendly. Highly recommended.

Simply put a mistake was made with the order and it was completely wrong - this can happen, but it shouldn't. It was our anniversary, so it put a dampner on it. We then ordered something different from the menu. One saving grace was that the food we did eventually get was very nice. However, I would have expected better customer service for the inconvenience and mix-up. In my opinion, the bill should have been discounted as a matter of courtesy, and it wasn't. For that reason, I can't give a higher rating.

One of the best Italian restaurants we have ever been to. Food was superb. Prices very reasonable. The Service was impeccable.

Visited this nice looking cafe for a spot of breakfast with my Partner as we thought it was nice looking. I will keep this short and sweet,the lady serving us from extremely rude and unprofessional and at one point told some customers to go outside as she brought there order out and then proceeded to gossip/slag them off to her “mates/friends/locals” in full view of other customers! Avoid this place at all costs as this lady should not be working in a customer service environment and the person who has employed her should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves!!!

One of our favourite restaurants in Whitby we go back every time we visit as it’s a wonderful good, atmosphere and the food is excellent.