GastroRanking-logo

The best restaurants serving Italian food in Central Sheffield Yorkshire and The Humber

38 Restaurants on GastroRanking

restaurant_img
5.0

71 Opinions

location-icon1-3 Leopold street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_318252takeaway_318252delivery_318252

My wife and I chose the Cod special and the Lamb special. Both were filled with flavour and beautifully presented. The service was very friendly and efficient. We will be returning.

restaurant_img
5.0

48 Opinions

location-iconUnits 16-17 Orchard Square, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_322043takeaway_322043delivery_322043

We sat outside on a pleasant day and enjoyed two prosecco in the pedestrianised area. It was a good place for people watching and the staff were very friendly and efficient.

restaurant_img
5.0

35 Opinions

location-icon21 London Road, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_322469takeaway_322469delivery_322469

Great little place. Friendly and unpretentious, everything was cooked fresh. Service was relaxed and attentive. Good food, nice wine, highly recommended.

restaurant_img
5.0

10 Opinions

location-iconWharncliffe House 44 Bank Street Wharncliffe House, Sheffield S1 2DS England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_266104takeaway_266104delivery_266104

Hemos estado aquí varias veces y la comida siempre es excelente. La presentación es hermosa y las opciones son diferentes e interesantes. Definitivamente lo recomendaría para café, desayuno o almuerzo. ¡Esperamos volver después del cierre!

restaurant_img
5.0

6 Opinions

location-icon946A City Road, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_332624takeaway_332624delivery_332624

We order every couple of months and this time had a Toppolis mixed kebab. Masses of juicy chicken and lamb with a ton of doner meat, loads of salad, a pile of chips and 2 pitta breads - it's for 2 people but 3 or 4 could easily share it. It's always tasty and we can rarely finish the lot but it's sooo good!!! Easy to order online and any special requests are never a problem. Lovely friendly staff in the shop too! We will keep going back as long as it doesn't change!

restaurant_img
5.0

1 Opinions

location-iconAbbeydale Road, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_321520takeaway_321520delivery_321520

Piacere is a delight. It's a tiny family restaurant with a simple , straightforward style, and a focus on making sure the food is exactly as it should be, and the service is relaxed and friendly. The Polpette meatballs are a perfect balance of the richness of the spiced sausage and the sharpness of an authentic italian tomato sauce. Main courses when we visited were pastas and risottos. The softness and lightness of my paccheri pasta complemented nicely the earthiness of the beef cheek in the Genovese sauce. My friends were equally enthusiastic about the Carlona and the Risotto Salmone. We like the fact that we were able to bring our own wine. And we loved the idea of a (Treviso) strudel on an Italian menu. We will be back !

restaurant_img
5.0

1 Opinions

location-icon295-297 shoreham street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_328979takeaway_328979delivery_328979

The best in the town Very friendly staff Pizzas are amazing 😍😍😍 Nice food and fast service and delivery Highly recommend

restaurant_img
5.0

840 Opinions

location-icon343 Glossop Road, Sheffield S10 2HP England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_248546takeaway_248546delivery_248546

got a pizza and parmesan truffle fries delivered it was amazing 10/10

restaurant_img
4.8

1557 Opinions

location-icon1-3 Leopold Street Grazie, Sheffield S1 2GY England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_254700takeaway_254700delivery_254700

We were gifted a voucher for my birthday and honestly it was the best experience. The food is spectacular and the drinks also. Would recommend to anyone who wants authentic, quality Italian cuisine in the heart of Sheffield

restaurant_img
4.8

74 Opinions

location-icon6 Orchard Square, Sheffield S1 2FB England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_247233takeaway_247233delivery_247233

Nice food and big portions for a really good price. Staff were also very kind and helpful. Will definitely be coming back if I'm in the area again

restaurant_img
4.8

220 Opinions

location-iconUnits 16-17 Orchard Square, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_322046takeaway_322046delivery_322046

Ordered via UberEats, the 2 Quattro Stagioni pizzas arrived very cold, very small amount of ingredients on the pizzas, just not that good. Wouldn’t recommend especially for this price, far better alternatives out there!

restaurant_img
4.7

196 Opinions

location-icon280 London Road, Sheffield S2 4NA England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_265183takeaway_265183delivery_265183

Wonderful meal, great service. Look forward to returning to this authentic italian pasta place. Great value.

restaurant_img
4.6

1707 Opinions

location-icon34-36 Cotton Mill Walk, Little Kelham Kelham island, Sheffield S3 8DH England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_268706takeaway_268706delivery_268706

Stefania was our waitress and she was fantastic! We had a great meal and she recommended a great white with our meal! Would come again!!

restaurant_img
4.6

198 Opinions

location-icon289 Glossop Road, Sheffield S10 2GZ England, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_251391takeaway_251391delivery_251391

A lovely little restaurant! Wonderful food for cheap prices, and a lovely atmosphere

restaurant_img
4.5

1455 Opinions

location-icon12 Norfolk Row, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_69440takeaway_69440delivery_69440

I made a reservation and visited. It looked very busy. I was able to have a drink first in the waiting room before eating. The seats there were not wide and while my partner was explaining the drinks to me, the young male employee told my partner to sit down, which made me feel bad. I understand that you are busy. I understand the crowded situation, but I didn't want to drink after seeing his behavior. I was wondering if I should eat here because of the rude staff. Since it was a celebration event, I persuaded them and started eating, and the other staff members were also friendly and in a good mood. I also enjoyed the food. I never encountered any staff when ordering food. If I don't meet the staff when I visit, I would like to visit again