GastroRanking-logo

The best restaurants serving Italian food in Plymouth South West

14 Restaurants on GastroRanking

restaurant_img
4.8

12 Opinions

location-iconPlymouth City Market, Cornwall Street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_213932takeaway_213932delivery_213932

I found this stall a couple of years ago and travel from Torbay to visit it. My favourire dish that I have tried so far is the crispy belly pork, which is just awesome. Massaman curry (peanut based) is great too. So many nice dishes.

restaurant_img
4.7

2018 Opinions

location-icon36 Mayflower St, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105434takeaway_105434delivery_105434

Best experience, the food was amazing, the place had good vibes all about it. The value for food is incredible. You must book a table.

restaurant_img
4.5

2945 Opinions

location-icon40 Southside Street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_103728takeaway_103728delivery_103728

By far my favourite place to eat in Plymouth, always has been! Amazing food, quick service, the waitress was so friendly and attentive, I'll always come back! Update - Still the best eatery in Plymouth!!! Update 2025 edition - Still fantastic, still the best, still keep coming back! 🤝🏽

restaurant_img
4.5

600 Opinions

location-icon41-42 Southside Street Barbican Pl1 2ld, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_332687takeaway_332687delivery_332687

Second visit after such nice meals the first time, I chose the carbonara as I had this on the first visit and really enjoyed . This time it was completely tasteless. My wife and daughters meals were very salty and my granddaughter’s spaghetti bolognaise was nothing like a bolognaise with hard carrots and crunchy celery! My granddaughter has a severe food allergy and we are always worried about eating out but as we had eaten here before, and she hadn’t been poorly we were happy that she would be safe. There was nothing suitable for her in the starters section so she chose to have a dessert instead as part of the set meal. Half way through she alerted me to the fact that she had a small piece of plastic in her sorbet. I was a little bit horrified but didn’t say anything and thought,,, these things can happen. After a couple more spoonfuls and a larger piece of plastic I told the waiter and he took it off me and apologised saying it must have been from the sorbet container. No gesture of goodwill offered, not that we would necessarily have accepted but not good service and certainly WONT be going back!

restaurant_img
4.3

2725 Opinions

location-iconUnit 4 11 Bretonside The Barcode, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_305888takeaway_305888delivery_305888

Elsa was absolutely amazing, extremely fast service, extremely polite, nothing was too much trouble, absolutely amazing experience. The food and staff were lovely.

restaurant_img
4.2

343 Opinions

location-icon12 Brunel Square, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_196222takeaway_196222delivery_196222

Came in for the Nutella pizza today, and will be back for the great vibes of the restaurant! Kasia and Grace W were so polite and knowledgeable especially with allergies. thanks so much!

restaurant_img
4.0

1319 Opinions

location-iconBarbican Leisure Park, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105315takeaway_105315delivery_105315

Staff were friendly, but let down by gross incompetence within their team. Note, the restraunt was no more than one third full. After 45 minutes our starters arrived, with the unwelcome news that our main courses were also ready and did we want them all together. No we didn’t and we were assured they would be remade. A further 45 minutes passes and our, presumably, original main courses arrived. Two lukewarm pasta dishes and a burnt pizza, a sheepish looking waitress declares these will be on the house. Food was edible and my son ate his burnt pizza. We also had a birthday voucher for £15, so the whole experience of dinner for three cost £30. However, it was nothing like the pleasant evening out we had planned. We will be striking this place from our list of eateries.

restaurant_img
4.0

918 Opinions

location-icon30 - 33 Derrys Cross, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_103966takeaway_103966delivery_103966

Bella Italia ya es un conocido que debes comer donde quiera que vayas. Pero este tiene el personal más amable y agradecido de todos los tiempos, particularmente Natalia, es muy amable, atenta y elegante. Ella se asegurará de que disfrutes tu comida y de que no falte nada; además, ¡siempre tiene una sonrisa en su rostro!

restaurant_img
4.0

40 Opinions

location-iconMarket Acenue, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104185takeaway_104185delivery_104185

Acabo de volver de vacaciones y quería un menú de 3 platos con una buena relación calidad-precio al final de un largo día de viaje. El personal estaba por cerrar pero eran más que dispuesto a permanecer abierto y luego nos hicieron sentir muy bienvenidos. las porciones buen tamaño y una excelente relación calidad-precio

restaurant_img
3.9

23 Opinions

location-iconGround Floor Portland Square Building University of Plymouth, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_321906takeaway_321906delivery_321906

Pizzas are so tasty! Considering how popular they get at lunch time, the staff are all really quick and friendly. Prices are also pretty good.

restaurant_img
3.7

1222 Opinions

location-iconPilgrims House, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105295takeaway_105295delivery_105295

We arrived at 12:00, which is listed as half an hour after opening, yet the doors were locked. It was meant to be my 16th birthday lunch so I'm very disappointed :(

restaurant_img
3.5

1014 Opinions

location-iconUnit 16 & 17 Mills Bakery, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104193takeaway_104193delivery_104193

Legitimately the worst pizza I have ever eaten... Granted, this food was ordered via Deliveroo however it took 3 hours to arrive... 3 hours!We ordered the pepperoni pizza, sharer garlic bread and a child's Bolognese... The pizza was burnt on one side, raw on the other and had not even been cut and the cheese tasted like plastic. The garlic bread also had not been cut and tasted like cardboard. The pasta was blatantly old and not fresh as well as being bland and overcooked. I honestly will never eat food from this restaurant ever againThe only saving grace is that we were issued a full refund...

restaurant_img
3.5

750 Opinions

location-iconUnit 2, The Barbican Leisure Centre, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104609takeaway_104609delivery_104609

Went for lunch with my friend and it was lovely. The staff was very friendly .

restaurant_img
3.3

101 Opinions

location-icon429A Crownhill Road, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_227601takeaway_227601delivery_227601

Friendly little boozer. Hidden gem. Takeaway next door which is ideal. Support your local!