GastroRanking-logo

The best restaurants serving Italian food in Plymouth South West

14 Restaurants on GastroRanking

restaurant_img
5.0

12 Opinions

location-iconPlymouth City Market, Cornwall Street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_213932takeaway_213932delivery_213932

I found this stall a couple of years ago and travel from Torbay to visit it. My favourire dish that I have tried so far is the crispy belly pork, which is just awesome. Massaman curry (peanut based) is great too. So many nice dishes.

restaurant_img
4.7

2004 Opinions

location-icon36 Mayflower St, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105434takeaway_105434delivery_105434

By far the best Italian restaurant in Plymouth, if you're looking for an authentic Italian experience (both in terms of food & the restaurant's atmosphere!) No other Italian restaurant that I've tried in Plymouth personally has even come close to replicating authentic Italian food like the food that they serve in Positano! The quality of the food is unmatched, and I am yet to try a dish that I didn't enjoy; it's very rare to find Italian food of this standard in Plymouth so it's no wonder that this restaurant is so popular & highly rated! A very nice touch is that they give you free bruschetta before you have your meal, and it's the best bruschetta I've ever had! The portions are huge so make sure you're hungry! Most of the pasta dishes I've tried have come piled high on the plate, and the Calzone was absolutely enormous! The prices are also very reasonable, and you definitely get your money's worth with the quality of the food & large portion sizes The atmosphere is cosy & welcoming, and they play a good mix of Italian-feeling music at a comfortable volume that doesn't inhibit your ability to have a good conversation with friends and family over your meal The staff are also very friendly & accommodating, which adds to the experience Booking a table can sometimes be a bit difficult because of how popular the restaurant is, especially on weekends but it's well worth the effort to do so!

restaurant_img
4.5

2925 Opinions

location-icon40 Southside Street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_103728takeaway_103728delivery_103728

Visited here as heard great things and my son is colieac so we had the choice of gluten free pasta! We were welcomed with a rude young girl who just said your upstairs , so we took ourselves up there . No menus given or asked about dietary requirements, all very strange. The atmosphere was awful, felt awkward and unwelcoming with very weird and obnoxious music which my son said made him feel like he's in a 2014 YouTube fails montage . Great that they have gluten free pasta and pizza bases which is very rare to find . Food overall was mediocre, filled a gap but definitely nothing to rave about,Lacked flavour . !!

restaurant_img
4.5

588 Opinions

location-icon41-42 Southside Street Barbican Pl1 2ld, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_332687takeaway_332687delivery_332687

A first visit and dubious due to previous reviews we judge as we find. Prebooked, arrived ten minutes early. We’re not greeted or checked in just walked past a couple of times by a member of staff then eventually waved at and pointed to a table. About another ten minutes and we were given menus. The table wasn’t clean or set. 35 minutes after our arrival the waiter arrived to take our order. A further ten minutes and our drinks arrived, wine poured and splashed over the table. The bottle slammed into the cooler gave the impression that the staff member wasn’t happy. Starter eventually arrived, Grilled Halloumi, cold. Melanzane alla Parmigiana hot tasty served in a chipped bowl. Mains, spaghetti bolognaise okay, about the same as I could cook. Saltimbocca, Veal with Parma ham and baby mozzarella. No sign of the mozzarella and fortunately the waitress noticed how tough the veal was that she brought a steak knife. Veal smothered in Cayenne pepper. Busy but lacking in atmosphere. Some staff attempted to save the day but the visit was lost. We ate as we were hungry and it was late in the day. The kitchen /staffing needs some serious sorting. Would we go again NO. Would we recommend this place NO

restaurant_img
4.3

2590 Opinions

location-iconUnit 4 11 Bretonside The Barcode, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_305888takeaway_305888delivery_305888

Great food, good for lunch. Better when it’s quiet and we prefer booth tables that are sometimes available. Ordered arancini, rustica pizza and cheesecake.

restaurant_img
4.0

1296 Opinions

location-iconBarbican Leisure Park, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105315takeaway_105315delivery_105315

Skeptical due to previous experience of being busy but the manager and staff were really friendly and hard working. We were worried about timings but it all worked out perfectly and the food was delicious! We wanted to make sure the waitress was given tip directly as she could be seen looking after so many tables and catering to everyone’s needs. We were made to feel really comfortable and were supported to use the perks via the app.

restaurant_img
4.0

918 Opinions

location-icon30 - 33 Derrys Cross, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_103966takeaway_103966delivery_103966

Bella Italia ya es un conocido que debes comer donde quiera que vayas. Pero este tiene el personal más amable y agradecido de todos los tiempos, particularmente Natalia, es muy amable, atenta y elegante. Ella se asegurará de que disfrutes tu comida y de que no falte nada; además, ¡siempre tiene una sonrisa en su rostro!

restaurant_img
4.0

310 Opinions

location-icon12 Brunel Square, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_196222takeaway_196222delivery_196222

Maria is the best. Excellent service and pizza. The best pizza I have had in England Perfect host Maria treated us so well and food was Delishous. Thank you Maria. Thank you Angelo Pizza best in England. 10/10

restaurant_img
4.0

40 Opinions

location-iconMarket Acenue, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104185takeaway_104185delivery_104185

Acabo de volver de vacaciones y quería un menú de 3 platos con una buena relación calidad-precio al final de un largo día de viaje. El personal estaba por cerrar pero eran más que dispuesto a permanecer abierto y luego nos hicieron sentir muy bienvenidos. las porciones buen tamaño y una excelente relación calidad-precio

restaurant_img
3.9

23 Opinions

location-iconGround Floor Portland Square Building University of Plymouth, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_321906takeaway_321906delivery_321906

Pizzas are so tasty! Considering how popular they get at lunch time, the staff are all really quick and friendly. Prices are also pretty good.

restaurant_img
3.7

1218 Opinions

location-iconPilgrims House, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_105295takeaway_105295delivery_105295

Excellent staff, very good food and speedy service. We went back twice. Good location too.

restaurant_img
3.5

1014 Opinions

location-iconUnit 16 & 17 Mills Bakery, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104193takeaway_104193delivery_104193

Legitimately the worst pizza I have ever eaten... Granted, this food was ordered via Deliveroo however it took 3 hours to arrive... 3 hours!We ordered the pepperoni pizza, sharer garlic bread and a child's Bolognese... The pizza was burnt on one side, raw on the other and had not even been cut and the cheese tasted like plastic. The garlic bread also had not been cut and tasted like cardboard. The pasta was blatantly old and not fresh as well as being bland and overcooked. I honestly will never eat food from this restaurant ever againThe only saving grace is that we were issued a full refund...

restaurant_img
3.5

746 Opinions

location-iconUnit 2, The Barbican Leisure Centre, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_104609takeaway_104609delivery_104609

excellent service. lovely tasty food. would recommend. thanks.

restaurant_img
3.4

101 Opinions

location-icon429A Crownhill Road, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_227601takeaway_227601delivery_227601

Friendly little boozer. Hidden gem. Takeaway next door which is ideal. Support your local!