The best restaurants serving Italian food in Holy Trinity Guildford South East

I discovered Pasta Out during lockdown, so unfortunately there was no availability to sit down and eat within, but the golden side to this was that I discovered their lovely take away service. The pasta is absolutely beautiful, so much so, that I will only have dry pasta in the house for emergencies only. There is a great choice of freshly made pasta and if they don't have any left, they will make it for you there and then. Easy to cook and beautifully fresh, soft and tasty. Highly recommended.

Medicore food, service and setting. Nothing wrong with but also nothing to draw me back. It felt like I was in a tourist restaurant in a capital city, just a repeat pattern. Maybe I was expecting more because of the reviews, but just a bit meh compared to other italians in the area.

We went to Blue Sardinia in Guildford for Valentine’s Day but unfortunately it was a disappointing experience. The restaurant had a set menu priced at £65 per person but the options were quite limited. Since it was Valentine’s and everywhere else was fully booked, we decided to give it a try. The portions were very small to the point that we had to order extra starters just to feel satisfied. Thankfully, they allowed it. Even so, the food was underwhelming, lacking the quality and flavour we expected for the price. The service was also slow and despite asking twice for something, it never arrived. We were not the only ones feeling this way. We could hear other couples complaining about the portion sizes and the menu choices. One couple asked if they could order something other than what was on the set menu and when they were told no, they decided to leave. As they walked out, we overheard them saying they would just order a takeaway at home, knowing they would not find a last-minute table elsewhere. The staff were polite and the atmosphere was pleasant but overall it did not feel like good value for money at all. I had specifically chosen this restaurant for an Italian dining experience but the only pasta dish available was mushroom lasagna and there was no pizza on the menu. The mushroom lasagna was truly disappointing! Honestly, even a Tesco Ready Meal would have been more enjoyable. It did not feel like a true Italian experience at all. In comparison, Positano (another Italian restaurant in Guildford) is miles ahead in terms of food, service, and authenticity. As for dessert, every option on the set menu included fruit, which was disappointing as I do not eat fruity deserts. I am not sure what the menu is like on a regular night, but overall, I was not impressed. For the price we expected much better. Unfortunately, it was not worth it and based on this experience, I would not recommend it.

Went on Christmas Eve. The food was great and so was the service. Pino was friendly and gave the best recommendations! Highly recommend.

Excellent service and pizza, would be a good place for a drinks later to

Visited last weekend with family and friends. Notes from our visit1. Please clean your toilets. Sinks flity...2. Chefs should be wearing hats and kitchen uniforms. They shouldn't be working with their Jean's...NOT HYGIENIC3. Menu is very good, but the execution of the dishes are horrible. Eg: brushetta should be on a toasted bread, tomatoes should be room temperature not ice cold from fridge...4. You shouldn't be serving food on a chipped plates.Such a shame as they have a lovely concept and menu but lack of care and management. We wont be returning.

If you want a guaranteed great pizza this is the place. Shelley the manager is brilliant and the food is always amazing. Pizza No.5 is excellent especially good with 3 chilli mix added. First rate.

Quality of food was very poor. My daughter ordered steak and it was the most driest and rubbish steak I’d ever seen. They could do a more decent job at a burger van. Similarly for me the lamb rump was undercooked and cold. Would not recommend to dine here unless you really prefer undercooked and cold rudimentary food.