Based on 300 opinions finded in 2 websites
Based on 300 opinions finded in 2 websites
Opinions
What a fantastic place.The staff where wonderful and inviting.The food was very good.We also had the pleasure of meeting Alex who was there.We will be returning.
Allison E . 2024-09-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We have stayed at The Star before, eaten in the restaurant a couple of times and enjoyed it, but tonight we had a disappointing experience. The food was okay (nothing special) but the service was all over the shop. I began to think we were invisible. We would have liked a cocktail and pudding, but despite trying to catch wait staff’s eyes and a couple of desperate waves, we were ignored. The table behind us, who finished their main course way after us, were brought dessert menus, but we were forgotten. In the end we just got the bill and left. No ‘how was your meal?’ Nothing. We went into the bar and had a cocktail there instead. I think someone needs to oversee the service. It was all very strange.
Sue O . 2024-08-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Our third visit for lunch at The Star. Having previously eaten in the cosy bar area, this time, we sat in the sunny courtyard. Once again the set lunch menu was excellent with something for everyone. The food was beautifully cooked and presented. Service was excellent. As an added bonus on our previous visit in June, I had the pleasure of encountering, the delightfully charming and friendly, Alex Polizzi in the corridor. Not surprisingly the hotel is very tastefully decorated with quirky touches throughout. We will certainly be back.
Garry M . 2024-08-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
5-May The Star At Alfriston: Visited for Sunday lunch as a party of 3. The dining room is really beautiful: very calming, and a perfect mix of traditional and modern. The Sunday lunch was exceptional, with thinly sliced, perfectly medium rare roast beef. Generous portions and very tasty indeed. Service was absolutely charming: perfectly attentive, friendly, interesting (never starchy). Superbly well trained, obviously. We left very happy, full / satisfied, and feeling spoiled, exactly as it should be. Highly recommend and hope to return.
PennyPurples . 2024-07-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Another beautiful lunch at the Star. Each time we have eaten there the food and service have been faultless and the staff charming and welcoming. We will be back....
Jane L . 2024-06-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Star is beautifully furnished and I expected its cuisine to glimmer in the same way. I booked us in for lunch! I was wrong. Firstly, a strange grim manager struts about, who wouldn’t go amiss at a dowager’s ball, but certainly goes amiss in Alfriston, where locals and tourists trek in from the chalky terrain of Cuckmere. As I stepped through the door, he ran his eyes despairingly down my gardening jeans, torn, grubby and from M&S. I dreaded him. The younger and presumably cheaper staff were lovely, joyous creatures, overseen by this vinegary character. We tucked into some pleasant grub but fell for a few tricks of the trade … I ordered Chicken Milanaise and it came, with tomato aioli (which I suspect was mayo mashed up with some purée). The promised fennel and endive salad was a tottery, unseasoned frizz. My aunt and husband ordered asparagus with poached eggs. This was a ‘main’ for £20 odd quid. “That might not fill you up,” the waitress observed brightly. “You could order some sides?” My husband’s wallet seemed to grow lighter … The ‘side’ was a bowl of pretend ‘real’ chips, you know the ones with a neat disc of potato skin at the end but which still lack any fibre. If you’re going to give us asparagus and boiled egg for a ‘main’, then charge us for a ‘side’ then at least please make the chips real ones … I could go on, but the grub was fine, the surroundings beautiful. I guess I get bored with smoke and mirrors when it comes to good food
Fiona R . 2024-06-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
What a lovely old hotel Nice atmosphere Very smiley friendly staff We would love to come back to stay one night And experience a evening meal
Explorer825341 . 2024-04-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
So we were very excited to have lunch here. I think the hype was a bit too great though, as we expected excellence, and that was perhaps a mistake as we left underwhelmed. The restaurant is beautiful, staff are friendly, and the ambience was great. Unfortunately the service was very slow. We weren't offered a drink for 10 minutes. Then it was a while before we were able to order, and so we didn't get anything to eat except a little bread for an hour. When we did receive it, it was a bit forgettable. I had gravadlax which was small and dull, followed by hake which was tasty but a bit over salty. My wife had bean and kale soup, huge portion, oversalted, and burrata with tomatoes, under-flavoured. Kids had pasta and chicken milanese. Apparently the pasta was tasty, chicken wasn't. No alcohol, well over £100. So basically it seemed like the chef hadn't tasted to check flavours (sounds rude I know). Such a shame as the restaurant is beautiful. We wouldn't return.
PITN . 2024-04-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Beautiful village, lovely Inn. The Star is a lovely building and beautiful inside. The staff were really sweet and attentive, couldn't have asked for better service. The food was fantastic, well worth a visit. A very pleasant couple of hours on a Sunday afternoon
paulgN8999AR . 2024-03-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Turned up without a reservation after finding a way around the flooded roads & were welcomed with smiles from the very friendly & professional staff. Lovely cozy, atmospheric lounge, beautifully & tastefully restored. Enjoyed a superb lunch with Wine & Beer (Harveys Old Ale on tap) Great value. Great Service. Great Food. Alex even popped over to say Hello, the perfect host.
horndeanhermit . 2024-02-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
First time here as Rathfinny not open on Mon. Very impressed. Super staff, smily and efficient - Alex would be proud. Limited menu but 2 courses each was plenty. Food carefully cooked, full of flavour. Wine at £10 per 175m, is toppy but it was ex. Atmosphere and decoration blends the old and stylish perfectly. We will return.
K9890WOmike . 2024-01-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A beautifully decorated pub/restaurant and hotel. Guest car park at the back is a great bonus- just buzz for entry. The lady who greeted us, showed us to the table and took our coats delightful. Restaurant wasn’t busy at all. We ordered drinks & main course - Sunday lunch- roast beef was perfect served with veg , a small Yorkshire pudding and roast potatoes on the plate- gravy and horseradish on a separately. We finished main course and male waiter took the empty plates away. We probably waited 20 mins and then asked for dessert menus. We ordered desserts and coffee/ again lovely but once again we had to ask for the bill and there was only one waiter who was setting up tables. Bill came, reasonably priced for great food. We asked how we could get out coats and was directed down the hallway where they were hanging up to choose from. The bar areas in the front cosy and tastefully decorated with interesting art. My only criticism is waiting service slow and not really attentive in the restaurant- took over 3 1/2 hrs for 2 courses and had to ask twice.
Diablo6 . 2024-01-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Disappointing lunch after looking foreword to this as we enjoyed our visit here same time last year.The staff were ‘frosty’ and unattentive like we shouldn’t have been there ( they couldn’t find our booking but at the time we arrived no other customers were there). Asked for a pot of tea with extra milk, tea & pot of hot water arrived but by the time I realised that they hadn’t brought milk the waitress had gone. Had to go and find the waitress to ask for milk. When ordering I lunch asked about vegetables - meals didn’t come with them I was told - just garnish & so I had to ask for vegetables ( this information not on menu). Lunch arrived, vegetables were lovely- my chicken was dry & over salty, my son’s beef he said was okay. After one bite of the chicken I decided I really didn’t like it but no waitress around to complain to & by now busy with more customers. No one came to ask if everything was ok. Very overpriced & poorly cooked meat, I did tell the waiter how poor my chicken was when he cleared our table & that I couldn’t eat it ( my son ate some of it & agreed that it wasn’t nice)but couldn’t get any one’s attention to complain. Bill came & again I voiced my complaint, the response of the waitress was just excuses & condescendingly said she’d take the 12.5% service charge off. Shame as the log fires are lovely & the pub in a lovely location but very disappointed today
ItsNiceOrNot . 2024-01-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely food, beautiful surroundings, elegant understated table settings. The staff are lovely people, and wonderful service such a major improvement form my plast visit. Drinks in the bar were a reall joy, the barman was friendly and skilled. We were lucky enough to meet Miss Polizzi who was charming and such fun but a consummate professional. As last time the food was wonderful nicely presented and tasted great. The food & drink service was excellent this time a real improvment on my visit in november ( the hand over between shifts this time was seemless unlike November) it totaly made my birthday and my four friends whow i dinned ith all had a wonderful afternoon
roger n . 2024-01-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had a fabulous time at The Star.The service was excellent everywhere and we were able to relax by the fire after dinner. Thanks to Hayden for the excellent pint of Harveys he keeps.
SIMON K . 2023-12-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely food, beautiful surroundings, elegant understated table settings. The staff are lovely people, but the service was appalling. We had to ask twice for bread and for the time it arrived with all finished of this course after we finished our main course we sat there with dirty plates in front of us for sometime. We eventually asked somebody to clear them away who then stacked the dirty plates on the table in front of us. Some basic training in foodservice would be good. We then sat there for a rather long time waiting for the desert menus which we had to ask for in the end, we just had coffee Which we took in the lounge area so that we could sit in front of the fire as by then the room was rather cold. Yes I go back because the surroundings and food are lovely, but I definitely think there is room for improvement with the level of food service
roger n . 2023-11-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent bar lunches, with dog. Efficient, friendly service. Lovely fresh bread. Excellent food. And dog water and biscuits, so he loves it too. My new favourite lunch venue
Harry4Sammy . 2023-10-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
An enjoyable birthday lunch, seated in the courtyard. Food was great, staff were friendly and the sun shone.
Gloggs2018 . 2023-08-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had an absolutely delicious & beautifully presented meal for 12 to celebrate a “big” Birthday. All aspects of the food, wine and service were impeccable and the team went above and beyond to make the evening special and ensure everything went smoothly. Varied menu catered for everyone’s tastes, including a vegetarian and the price was very good value given the high quality, service and location.
Hackettshome1 . 2023-08-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Beautiful 9.2/10 Check out the star alfriston on TripAdvisor as a lot of people including myself have left a review on there for the restaurant and definately gives a better idea of the quality. The courtyard is very special and the food and service was really really good Expect slightly high prices as it is recommended by the Michelin guide and the food we had was really good but maybe only missing that standard by a tiny bit however we only ordered the spaghetti cavolo nero and the fish and chips. Would definately go back there again. Service and ambience was up to michelin guide level.
GregMoseley . 2023-08-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Went to The Star for a special birthday lunch. We were not disappointed. The food was simply lovely, a particular mention must be given to the mackerel starter which was the best mackerel ever according to my partner! The staff were friendly and efficient. Planning our next trip!
Joan P . 2023-08-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were staying so had 2 dinners and 2 breakfasts. Everything was wonderfully cooked and presented. In particular, the beef shin tortellini were stand-out incredible. I'd have them again any day. The mackerel starter too was fabulous. Pork main came with pollenta which to my mind was a mistake although the pollenta was decent. The first night we had to pre-order and lots of us had cheese (choice of 3 from 5). This didn't work as the various (different choices) cheeses were distributed incorrectly. I asked my waitress what cheeses were on my plate and she didn't know. But a small mistake. 2nd night, we ordered there and then and got what we ordered. Wine waiter was a bit serious but helpful with ideas. Breakfasts were fantastic with a superb cooked menu. The mushrooms cooked in butter with garlic and lemon on sourdough was a plate from heaven. Fabulous freshly squeezed juices and very good coffee. All in all, top notch and 5 stars without hesitation.
jw6969 . 2023-04-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We made a reservation for 19:00 , we arrived at 18:40 and were told that the restaurant would not open until 19:00 but we could take a drink in the bar , we were shown to the bar and left unattended for 20 minutes as passing staff repeatedly told us “ we will be with you in a moment” ,not the best start to an evening, I might add the bar was empty of guests at the time. Our meal was very disappointing,my wife ordered slow cooked pork and I had Chicken ,there was very little other choice since there were only 4 dishes on the menu . The presentation of the dishes was a complete shock,the pork dish ,served in a bowl ,looked as if it had been dropped on the floor and then scooped up onto the plate,my chicken was reminiscent of a 60’s transport cafe lunch , this is listed as a5 star dining experience, We both felt our food was bland and lacked taste ,my chicken was dry and felt as though it had been pre-cooked and reheated ,vegetables and mashed potatoes,all crammed onto the plate ,not at all attractive to look at,my wife thought her dish lacked spices and was disappointing Service and personnel are good in the restaurant although ,it’s very obvious that the staff are inexperienced and rather nervous , we were never asked if we needed anything during the meal , although having finished our very good deserts and had requested the bill, a waitress came and asked if we would like to see the desert menu This is the third time that we have dined at the Star ,the previous visits were also underwhelming,we put these down to start-up ,and, post Covid, teething issues but this last visit will be just that,ie,………”The last visit”.
Stanley B . 2023-04-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A real disappointment. Service and ambience were great but let down by average food. I had the burrata to start….it wasn’t burrata but mozzarella. It had no soft texture whatsoever and to the tune of £12.
M5305RRhannahc . 2023-03-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had a birthday dinner in the restaurant for my wife with our two sons. We were all very happy with our meals. Delicious. Plenty of staff, pleasant, attentive without being intrusive. Will definitely be going again.
davidpC3076UZ . 2023-02-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Star Inn has special meaning for my husband and I as we got married there (when it was under the previous management). This was the first time we were back since then (5+ years) and we had wanted to try it since it re-opened. We went in wanting to try the set menu but were told that they don’t serve it on a Sunday (not mentioned on the menu outside). We ordered the beef and while we were waiting we were served a half a slice of bread each with hard butter (being famished we did ask for another half slice each….which at least arrived with spreadable butter). The meal itself was disappointing. We ordered beef and imagined we would get a thicker slicer (what you normally get in a pub) and was given something resembling thin bacon. My beef was ok, my husband didn’t enjoy his. There was a small milk jug (the jug was probably size of a clenched fist) with gravy…only it was half full so we had to ask for a second just so we could get enough for the food. Then there was the potatoes. The poor roast potatoes. They were so hard we struggled to cut them. We couldn’t quite figure out how they managed to make the potatoes rock solid. We did complain, got extra vegetables and 10% off the bill. The staff did ask if we wanted to see the dessert menu and I couldn’t help but laugh while saying “no thanks”. Overall it was a poor experience, overpriced and we can’t say we will recommend it to anyone. Safe to say we won’t be back either.
Raftofotters . 2023-02-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fantastic food and service. Newly refurbished hotel and restaurant. Food was amazing, and the staff all so polite, friendly and helpful. Will definitely return and would recommend a visit, if you can book a table
836emmah . 2022-12-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely place. Warm and welcoming. Friendly staff. Food is great. Open fires are lovely. There is a lack of atmosphere though which is suitable if your are attending the local church (which is nice I might add) but it needs just a little classical or jazz music in the background or maybe a piano or a harp - just something.
davidoN9941QA . 2022-11-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We missed our boat at Newhaven and decided to drive inland to Alfriston to wait for the next crossing. The bar at the Star was warm and welcoming with a lovely smell of old wood, the staff were particularly polite and friendly, only slightly marred by a rather bossy woman who rebuffed my elderly friend's enquiry about the menu with a patronising "just a moment, darling" ! We ate over the road, possibly not up to the standards of The Star, but their restaurant was probably booked out anyway.
RBM056 . 2022-11-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Not worth the hype or cost. Food was pretty good, but not up to the standard we would have expected. Have had as good Italian food in decent pubs. Service was a bit awkward - felt like we were at a catering training college. Beautifully designed and detailed decor and building.
Mike N . 2022-11-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Pleasant setting, attentive service, good but not exceptional food well presented. Not great value compared to competition but as expected although thought they were taking the Mick with a Bloody Mary at £12. But .....we asked for ice cream instead of crème fraîche with our...
816cameronf . 2022-10-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Saturday lunch in the bar was as good as we hoped it might be. A lovely room with ancient wood beams and tasteful modern tableware. It was a mistake to order the cheese and onion toastie followed by fish and chips - either one would...
sussexrowmark . 2022-10-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
First time to The Star recently. While staff were professional, the manager on duty let the team down the night we had a meal there. When asked when we left how everything was( so after receiving full payment) I provided polite feedback I felt they...
carolinedM6596RW . 2022-10-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had arranged to meet with friends and have afternoon tea. Normally we would visit one of the tea rooms in Alfriston but thought we would try the Star Inn instead. We arrived at approximately 2.50 pm and were greeted by friendly staff and a...
bowarm . 2022-10-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
This hotel is in a lovely Sussex village in a National Park and has been recently renovated. We have been staying in the area for several months and chose it for dinner last week to celebrate our wedding anniversary. There is a really lovely dining...
smudgecirencester . 2022-09-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited for Sunday Lunch 21st August. most expensive Sunday Roast ever, that even the lowliest carvery would knock spots off. The beef Sunday roast consisted of 2 ultra thin slices of beef (amazed you can cut beef that thin unless its pre packed slices at...
ivor b . 2022-08-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We have tried 3 times to like this restaurant but have given up. One time the starters were superb but the main course (beef) was tasteless with an unpleasant thin, sweetish gravy. Another time the food was just passable but the service too new and...
Venetia020 . 2022-08-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
we just had a fabulous lunch, cheaper than very poor standard neighbours yet outstanding food. Brilliant service, gorgeous outdoor garden, incredible food and drink. Heavenly home-made focaccia with olives, and sun-dried tomatoes @ £2!! You are kidding me? That dish alone was worth the trip....
jessjelly . 2022-08-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were intrigued to visit the Star Inn having seen the process of renovation on television. Were initially disappointed because we could not eat in the courtyard because of the weather, but the dining room was elegant and comfortable. The lunch menu is not huge...
Andrew B . 2022-08-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had previously tired to book for lunch via the website and were unsuccessful but decided to visit as we had watched the TV programme and was so impressed with how the hotel had been renovated. When we arrived the manager spoke in a rather...
LizDeonarain . 2022-07-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We live in Durham but were visiting my daughter who wanted to treat us so she chose The Star restaurant. The village and hotel are beautiful as is the restaurant. We were booked for 6.30 pm last evening. For starter I had a small portion...
Richard H . 2022-07-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My husband and I booked a table in the courtyard for lunch. At 1:30 it wasn’t too busy so we were able to choose our own table (which I noticed later was the one in the photo on the website). The waiting staff were polite...
DJH60_12 . 2022-07-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Arrived for lunch at 1pm for 4 of us parked in the car park no problem - to be greeted with a warm welcome - offered table inside or outside - selected inside by the log fire a very nice touch winter or summer -...
Journey36010319185 . 2022-06-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
To be honest, the new owner has raised the bar from a previously struggling old pub. However, don't go there expecting a pub experience. This is now a posh hotel with a bar. Nothing wrong with that and it is beautifully done. We were charged...
steve r . 2022-06-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We three had a Fantastic lunch of Frito Misto , salad and pork Milanese with chips -sunny in the garden fab service and fab fab food 💕💕💕
Trek13885211571 . 2022-06-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
During our stay we had lunch in the bar, dinner in the restaurant and breakfast and drinks in the courtyard. Everything we ordered was beautifully presented and perfectly cooked. All staff were excellent.
janegt2014 . 2022-06-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The struggles to convert the building and cope with the COVID pandemic are well known . We had lunch on jubilee Friday 3rd . Courtyard dining with a creative simple menu and excellent drink options . What stands out is the attention to detail and...
01kenny . 2022-06-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Went for a drink May 31st We had one glass of white wine and one Tomato juice - that's all.We were charged eighteen pounds 50p! What a rip off. It is after all just a small hotel in a pretty but small village- hardly the...
Keith A . 2022-05-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Anyone who owns an old property should visit The Star in Alfreston. It is a shining example of making the very best of a dilapidated listed building with the best possible taste. Alex Polizzi has achieved a stunning make-over with this rather difficult property. Unsurprisingly...
Jenny H . 2022-05-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I must admit I was pretty impressed that our order was taken by The Hotel Inspector herself - Alex Polizzi, who was buzzing about chatting to everyone. (unfortunate that the last reviewer missed out). This was our second visit for dinner. It was a Wednesday...
Longfur . 2022-05-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The location and hotel/restaurant are extremely and tastefully done as one might expect. We had supper at The Star, in the Dining Room. The service was very good and we had an attentive, very polite waiter/waitress. The food was pretty good, well cooked and locally...
James W . 2022-05-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
On arrival we were warmly and professionally greeted after a nearly three hour drive from London , due to heavy traffic and diversions Not having eaten since breakfast, and arriving mid afternoon. Instead of unpacking, we went straight to the lounge area to order drinks...
VENETIAN2015 . 2022-04-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We are staying here so expected a superb menu and service. What we got was a menu with only 4 choices for each course - boiled potatoes only with no other potatoes offered and my husband’s veal escalope was a fatty mess - the same...
Gillian H . 2022-04-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My wife and I stayed overnight this Easter, the accommodation and service excellent. Breakfast very good but I think the chef must of been away for the evening, our fish main course was disappointing, one overcooked the other tasteless, not up to scratch considering the...
Alex J . 2022-04-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Arrived in the bar area and asked a member of staff if we could sit outside and was told we could. Made our way through to order lunch from the tables outside and was stopped by possibly the rudest man it has been my experience...
tonyaG5019UO . 2022-04-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Star hotel is everything you would expect being part of the Politzi chain. It is beautifully designed/decorated with such detail right down to the door knobs. Our room was light, airy and very comfortable. Big bed, rainfall shower with expensive bathing products. The bar...
880kerryg . 2022-04-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We visited for an early lunch on a lovely sunny day in mid March. There were some occupied tables in the courtyard but not all were taken but we were told quite bluntly we couldn't sit out there (no explanation given). We agreed to eat...
12AlisonG . 2022-03-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
After seeing the TV program we had to visit when staying with friends nearby. On a beautiful bright afternoon we sat in the lovely courtyard and was served by some staff who were smiling and friendly but others who were efficient but curt. The food...
tezzatime . 2022-03-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Michelin starred prices for gastropub/bistro food. Service is very good, friendly and down to earth with a hint of formality. Wine list starts at £26 for a bottle of decent plonk, and very quickly goes much higher. Menu - nice sounding dishes, but man, those...
Bashthebox . 2022-03-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent food, ambiance and service. Nothing was too much trouble. The staff were very helpful. Would certainly recommend it.
Jacqueline N . 2022-03-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Saturday night dinner. Exceptional quality of food. All 3 of us, all 3 courses. Expensive yes, outstanding yes.
PamelaM89 . 2022-03-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We've been meaning to try the revamped Star Inn and the decor and ambience are excellent, avoiding any twee touches. The staff on arrival were really helpful and the bar area was fairly busy for a dismal Wednesday. Glad to say the menu was brief,...
ChesterLeStreet . 2022-02-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had a lovely stay over at this beautifully renovated hotel the room was spacious light & comfortable There are so many nice touches throughout the hotel Alex & her mother have definetly left their stamp well done. Breakfast was fabulous cattering for all tastes freshly...
John G . 2022-02-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were greatly disappointed with our visit. Outrages prices, not at all one would imagine in such a place. Staff and service awful.
EveF257 . 2022-01-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Poor service and over-priced terrible food. It is such a pity as the ambience of the hotel which we saw on television was lovely.
David K . 2021-12-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Ate here whilst on a 2night break at The Star & what a delight dinner was. We had pre-booked our table before arriving & good job we did as by 7.30 it was full. We were swiftly seated by a charming gentleman, before Alex Polizi...
places2seeplaces2go . 2021-12-07
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We stayed at the hotel for a weekend and ate in the restaurant both nights. The food was delicious extremely good quality and beautifully presented . The staff we very friendly , attentive and nothing was too much trouble. The menu was varied with a...
alisonh118 . 2021-11-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food was amazing and the rooms are extremely tastefully done. The only warning I can give though is be prepared for your wife to turn into a jibbering bell-end when Alex turns up to your table to take the initial order. Great place - would...
daveoZ9397RV . 2021-11-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Many a happy time at The Star, Alfriston. My elderly mother-in-law thought by chance we would have lunch last Tuesday. Great gated car park and beautifully renovated, so we parked, but said to my mother-in-law I would check in for lunch. To my surprise, the...
Jeannette A . 2021-11-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
High Quality food that is not OTT. Served in a well appointed restaurant by kind and attentive staff.
ashley C . 2021-11-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I've been thinking about this since our visit to The Star last week for Sunday lunch which had been organised by a friend. I don't really like giving negative reviews to venues given they have had a seriously tough time. However, I think in this...
MarcB194 . 2021-11-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
.... And the proprietor has the effrontery to lecture others in the hospitality industry on customer service?!? I would suggest she turns her snark a little closer to home. Some three weeks ago, we booked a table at The Star, for a special birthday lunch....
lordstokes . 2021-11-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Booked The Star as a last minute treat for my husbands birthday. Check in was very easy and Receptionist was very friendly and efficient. We were shown to our room by Michael the Porter, who carried our bag for us and was a really friendly...
EssexEmily . 2021-11-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We booked into this hotel overnight and it was a wow factor .olga and Alex has worked so hard it was unbelievable but we'll done to you both and all the hard work that has been done by all .wonderfull hotel service to a high...
Warner1234 . 2021-11-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
For Sunday Lunch we opted for just two-courses. For starter, a thick, flavoursome Tomato & Basil Soup for my husband and the Housemade Pappardelle Pasta with Pheasant, Wood Pigeon & Mallard ragu - both of which were absolutely delicious. For the main course we both...
495linw . 2021-10-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited the STAR in Alfriston as I'm an Architect and Alfristons always been a place of interest. After dining in one of the local pubs , we decided to venture into the STAR after a winder around this lovely charming Village . A few comments...
P5674OOmimia . 2021-10-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Just popped in for a drink on my birthday. Beautiful wine and reasonably priced. The place was lovely especially the library. It's been refurbished in a really aesthetically pleasing way. Very eclectic and creative designs. Girl in bar was so lovely and encouraged us to...
MargueritedeValois . 2021-10-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited for Sunday lunch as we were happy to see a new venue in the area. So look, it’s not bad. The space is lovely, the service was good (but not great), there is a superb wine list. But here is where it jars: £32...
R436GQjom . 2021-10-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We stopped here for a coffee while visiting Alfriston, the venue has been very nicely refurbished but service was frustratingly slow, I slipped on the floor and really hurt myself, apart from being offered ice for my knee they did not seem bothered about the...
vegan1234 . 2021-10-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited the Star Inn on a busy Saturday afternoon. Happily settled in the library and ordered our cream tea. Scones delicious. Jam and cream plentiful. Jam particularly divine. Waitress said their chef makes it himself. Such a comfortable space in which to relax. Waiting staff...
MargaretR416 . 2021-10-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Friends managed to book a table for last night. What a wonderful treat! Fabulous food; fabulous staff; fabulous decor. Our waitress had a particularly good manner. Yes, it’s expensive, but it was worth every penny. Every mouthful was sublime. So lucky to have this in...
AFE5 . 2021-10-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Popped in for a cocktail which was lovely. Was disappointed not to be able to book dinner as not staying at the hotel, hope to go back another time for dinner.
melaniehU62LC . 2021-09-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A group of us popped in for a drink in the courtyard with our dogs. The drinks were lovely and well presented, and we were offered olives as, due to staff shortages, they were only serving food for residents - which we understood. One of...
barbaram145 . 2021-09-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
One hour drive from Horsham to visit the newly revamped Star and well worth it. Beautiful surroundings, professional and friendly service, great scones and coffee and, a brief conversation with Alex the owner, who has done a marvellous job in this hotels transformation. She and...
colinpauldavies1 . 2021-09-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Star allows nonresidents to have coffee from 11 am on Saturday mornings( may be different during week). Very comfortable on the terrace. Excellent coffee and service. There is a service charge so no need for tips. Interesting that the expensive italian floor tiles are...
Girlbabar . 2021-09-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Far to expensive for what little food you get,well over priced dearer than London,must be paying for all the makeover And work that’s been done
Janetmountjoy40 . 2021-09-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
No food being served to non hotel guests. Terrible front of house. Waited over 20 minutes for scones and coffee. The coffee was forgotten. No apology or engagement from staff.
markbM5662MH . 2021-08-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A warm welcome as we came in. Professional friendly staff. A gorgeous Sunday roast in beautiful surroundings. I can’t wait to visit again.
jonQ4683GU . 2021-08-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Came today have 3 questions 1 why oh why Alex doing waitress cleaning tables etc 2 the staff not welcoming need to speak too 3 no lunchtime menu we were offered olives etc but never came .
Stay456733 . 2021-08-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Just came back from a fantastic Sunday lunch at the Star with friends. We sat as a six out in the central courtyard. A Perfect, comfortable setting and we received excellent service throughout. Possibly the best Roast beef I've had in a long time, melt...
dking0203 . 2021-08-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We made an unplanned visit to The Star for lunch after a friend had raved about it. We weren’t disappointed! As a Sussex local I’m slightly wary of our heritage listed buildings being mucked about with but in this case its a triumph. Surprisingly extensive...
lizhW471UD . 2021-08-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Beautifully refurbished building. A pleasure to visit and enjoy. Went for Sunday lunch as a non resident and ate in the dining room. The menu was non fussy with 4 choices for each course. As pescatarians my husband had the scallops and I the mozzarella...
Mashanannafanna . 2021-08-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Absolutely fabulous in everyway. Excellent food, wine, service and an elegant, warm welcome from all. Refurbishment stylish yet relaxed throughout - beautifully done - Just what we need in Sussex. In the words of Arnold Schwarzenegger, "I'll be back".
nicholas p . 2021-08-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Popped in for a drink on the way home from a day at the coast. Told it was residents only. We had walked through to the courtyard and were seated at a table. The waitress asked if we were staying at the hotel so we...
martinsadler . 2021-08-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were really excited to try The Star especially after seeing how experienced the chef is … but sadly the encounter was average at the very least … upon arriving we were lead by the waitress to a bar area crowded with multiple tables …...
pollenca . 2021-08-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Having read the very critical Sunday Times review, we approached our long-booked stay with some trepidation. However, the critic must have caught it on a bad day soon after it opened as we found everything to be excellent. We ate in the restaurant 2 of...
DCZ213 . 2021-08-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We've been meaning to try the revamped Star Inn for a while. The inn only re-opened in June (under new ownership by the Polizzi's) but the restaurant I believe opened relatively recently, so I imagine they are still in the soft-launch period. It was only...
brightoncb . 2021-08-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Stayed for 2 nights and ate in the restaurant both evenings . The staff could not have been better - attentive , friendly and efficient . The food was delicious - seasonal dishes . The home made pasta was a real highlight. I could not...
Roam742999 . 2021-08-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Me & my wife visited today just for drinks, we were warmly greeted by Alex on arrival who showed us to the beautiful courtyard, a stunning area to enjoy our drinks. We had a look around the Hotel including the library/bar area, restaurant, toilets, car...
gglover1 . 2021-07-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I’d take Marina O’Loughlin’s scathing review of the Star in the Sunday Times with a pinch of salt. Putting room and food prices to one side (you know what they are before you visit) she says she’ll go back “when the foliage has grown over...
JCBrighton75 . 2021-07-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Similary restaurants in South East
6 Opinions
I have already reviewed this in the main hotel site. The drawing rooms are lovely, comfortable chairs, beautiful view, BUT the food and wine by the glass were truly awful. Very poor quality and very expensive. Never again.
205 Opinions
We moved to Pevensey recently and The Red Lion is our new “local”. It’s warm and inviting, the staff are lovely and the food is always brilliant, portion sizes are good and quality of food is on point. Prosecco deals would be amazing as it does put us off slightly the price of a bottle compared to Tesco next door but if you want a night out then it is what it is! We are regulars and enjoy our time here. Music on a Friday/Saturday night would be great instead of Sundays but that’s just us im sure others like it on a Sunday.
2477 Opinions
Unwelcoming staff. We were told that we had to order food & drinks at the bar. Other tables in the restaurant had very attentive table service, so we were unsure why we were treated differently. A member of our family party had someone else’s fish dinner spilt down his back. This obviously stank & was very uncomfortable for him. The staff member disagreed that it touched his back and said it landed on the floor. This wasn’t the case, as other diners saw exactly what happened. We had to ask for an apology, which was given, although very reluctantly. We waited an extremely long time for our food, even though it wasn’t a particularly busy night. The desserts were wrong and we were told that we hadn’t ordered the ones we’d asked for. We were made to feel like we were in the wrong. Tiger Inn - you have lost some loyal customers. It has ruined our evening.
1780 Opinions
This country pub had been on our list for ages and so as it was my birthday weekend we booked for Sunday lunch. We'd checked the menu before booking so we knew the roast was pricey at £24 for the roast beef. We usually pay between £16 and £20 elsewhere. Unfortunately, when it arrived it was disappointing. There was plenty of thinly sliced beef but I found it very fatty and chewy. There were fewer vegetables than expected, half a carrot, 3 very small, very hard roast potatoes and a pile of kale. The Yorkshire pud was large but mainly soggy. The gravy was delicious. Also elements of the dish were less warm than others. The pub is lovely and had a good drinks menu but we were seated in the bar area and had to listen to staff discussing their rotas at length. Perhaps if we'd been in the main restaurant area or outside we'd have had a better experience. Maybe consider your portion sizes especially the veg. We didn't stay for desert.