Bagdale Hall in Scarborough

We had a wonderful two night stay at Bagdale Hall, lovely bedroom with a four poster bed, the room was spacious and had a lovely bathroom, the Hall is only 5 mins walk to Whitby town so could leave the car in their car park behind the hotel, staff very pleasent and helpful with a few ghost stories thrown in, unfortunately never saw any ghosts because the bed was so comfy we slept through the night, breakfast included and was delicious, loved every minute of our stay at this unique hotel

This was our first time visiting the area and this hotel made the trip! Beautiful unique rooms with magnificent fireplaces and four-poster beds. Breakfast was delicious and the service was spot on. Would highly recommend.

This hotel is situated on a busy road into whitby. We have stayed here several times in the past Top tip stay in the main hall if possible well worth the extra .Rooms are immaculate and a warm welcome awaits from hosts Allison and Mike .Breakfast is vast and delicious . Only downside was the payment card machine was not working and they would not take cheque or bank transfer therefore cash transaction only . A small price to pay to stay in such a lovely place. We dinnedout at The Edge on friday they serve the best steaks in whitby and saturday at Passage to India very lively place with vast menu and excellent service .For best views of whitby climb the 199 steps also lifeboat museum is well worth a visit

We have been going to the Bagdale nearly thirty years now We love the this place I has its own parking a nice little Bar The Manager Mike and his wife Alison a great people the Staff are great to very friendly Hotel the Breakfast are Excellent with a great choice

A lovely stay at the Hotel. A nice piece of history and atmosphere. Bar, Dining room, Lounge area fab. The fire places.......wow, can imagine them in full use when it was a home days gone by. Parking is very limited to approximately 9 spaces, so be prepared to have to find alternative parking. The only fault to find, and the only......A little more care needed on the House Keeping side of things in rooms. Thick dust on surfaces.(window ledges, top of light fittings etc) shower cubicle surrounds need a deep clean. However. these things did not spoil our stay and we will definately return at some point in time.

If you're looking for great service, rooms bigger than your house and a stay steeped in history, then Bagdale Hall is a must. Both our rooms had a large seating area and four poster bed with beautiful beams and huge gothic fireplaces. The staff were absolutely superb - very friendly and really couldn't do enough to make our stay perfect. The breakfast was delicious, it's right in the centre of Whitby so everything is walking distance and the building is stunning. We'd definitely go back.

Very bland food, service was unenthusiastic. Didn't enjoy it one little bit. And certainly didn't enjoy seeing the one star very poor food hygiene rating from Scarborough council that was published shortly after we had eaten there. Never again.

This is the restaurant in Bagdale Hall hotel. We had breakfast here during our stay at the hotel. The dining room has lovely period décor and a giant fireplace with interesting history. Window tables look out onto a tasteful statue / water feature. The breakfast is really nice, all freshly cooked to order. I'm not sure if they open for lunch, afternoon tea or dinner - hotel could advise. We really enjoyed our breakfasts here. I must add that the staff are really friendly too and will be able to tell you all about this lovely Victorian building.

Bagdale Hall this was amazing place very pleasant and also romantic the restaurant was well lade out and plenty of room the hall beautiful and the design of the place very much Victorian a member showed us around the hall the rooms very plessent its a great place to stay we have booked first weekend in December. the evening dinner was amazing the food well presented and the staff were polite and friendly we had a great evening we were staying for one night. The breakfast was well full of chose to pick from

We actually stayed in the annex just up the road called Lobster Hall which is an old converted school. Car parking for free was a real bonus but limited so get there early. Helpful receptionist, clean large room. The only issue we had was that the room was near the main door and at the bottom of the stairs which meant it was a bit noisy in the early hours when people were coming back late with the door banging and noise on the stairs. I would definitely stay again but would go for a first floor room

Bagdale Hall what a place to visit it was very interesting to visit the history about the [place is amazing and the staff full of knowledge worth the visit

Excellent location short walk to town etc, Large rooms with character either in hotel or we were in nearby townhouse with four poster bed and large bathroom. Breakfast served in hotel. Restaurant and bar.Free parking.

Both me and my wife visit Whitby around three times a year , we always stop at Bagdale hall.

Stayed in the annex No 4. Lovely building, clean, warm, sash windows but view we had was the only negative. Looking back onto the car park and up to the hospital. One at the front would probably been noisier but a nicer view.

We stayed here for a short break in a family room. I rang before arrival regarding parking and the man who answered was really professional and helpful, there was ample close parking which is valuable in Whitby, the room was pleasant and comfortable, it appeared really clean but we did find a pair of gloves under the bed so perhaps the hoovering could be a bit more thorough, breakfast was lovely, the main building has a unique charm given it’s age and history, you couldn’t really pick a better location

Having just spent two nights at this hall I can truly say that we came away very relaxed. The main reason for this,I believe is the fabulous staff,so accommodating and pleasant. The room we had (room1)was big clean and plenty of hot water with a nice cosy feel. It was a special birthday for my husband and we both appreciated the good wishes from everyone.

Had a lovely weekend at the Bagdale for a special birthday. The room was clean, fresh and comfortable, dated but it suits the age of the building. Breakfast was great, well cooked, plenty of local produce and the service was excellent. Rather disappointed that the hotel does not offer any other meals during the day, an evening meal would have topped the weekend off!

Very pleasant stay nice four poster bed in my room. Rooms very clean and tidy but the hotel could do with a bit of TLC.Plenty of free parking.

Having overdosed on fish and chips, we decided to visit Bagdale Hall for a more sophisticated meal. There was a four or five course menu offered, so we decided to opt for the four courses, but weren't asked by the staff what we wanted. We chose starter, main and dessert, with amuse bouche and sorbet, and declined the cheese, assuming that was the fifth course. However, when the bill arrived, it was for five courses so we queried it, to be told that the amuse bouche and sorbet were the fourth and fifth courses. I have never encountered this type of charging before and was a little miffed. However, the food was absolutely delicious and still pretty good value for £30 per head.

Just visited the newly opened restaurant at Bagdale Hall. What a fabulous meal we had. Everything was spot on from the food to the service also a lovely atmosphere. Will definitely return. There was nothing to fault.

After having trouble finding somewhere with a table on a busy Easter weekend, we managed to book a table at the hotel restaurant (we had previously stayed here before so knew of its existence). We had an aperitif in the bar while perusing the menu and the friendly barman took our order then called us to sit down shortly before the amuse bouche was served. Food was good and service was friendly. On the pricier side of average but probably what you would expect at a large hotel.

Hi just had 2 nights stay at bahdale hall.frienfly staff,very clean and foods really good. HOWEVER ! Room 15 beautifully 4 poster bed really nice bathroom.just happens to on a really busy main road and only single glazed windows!!! You can't hear the tv because you wouldn't turn it up in case you disturb the other guests .I did complain and they said if I ever get return they would give me another room, apart from that I couldn't fault it.

Just come home from the Bagdale Hotel in Whitby superb friendly staff we go there four or give times A Year great hotel superb a Food .had a great time at Goth weekend

To be clear, we never actually got to eat here. Here's why. Our guest house recommended the restaurant and as it was my birthday we thought we'd try somewhere nice. There was a menu outside which said you could have a three course meal on Tuesdays and Fridays for 18 pounds and the food sounded good, so we booked for that Friday evening. On arrival (after standing at reception for a few minutes and being completely ignored by staff) we noticed the menu and the deal had been taken down. We asked the waitress when at our table. She said they didn't have all the food on that deal but would check what they did have. While she was gone we heard a male waiter say that the food he was holding was for 'the old couple in the corner'. I think that was very rude. Our waitress returned and told us what food remained available on the three course deal. When I commented on the goats cheese not being available ( leaving mainly fish dishes that I'm allergic to) she said the cheese was cooked in the same batter as the fish anyway. Eh?!! We left. We took away the impression that the restaurant was unprofessional and misleading.

We ate here on our last night in Whitby, on the recommendation of our guest house. The service was friendly, efficient and helpful. We had scallops and deep fried goat's cheese as starters, followed by mussels in white wine, garlic and cream for my husband. I had sea bass. Desserts were cheese selection and ice cream. Accompanied by a bottle of house white wine. Food was delicious, hot, well presented, portions generous. Selection of Yorkshire cheeses with apple, celery, biscuits and almonds would easily serve two. Only critiscm I thought pan seared sea bass was a little over cooked. A couple on the other side of the restaurant were celebrating their wedding anniversary (congratulations to you both) and generously shared their celebration cake with us. Thank you.

This was my third visit to this restaurant and again I wasn't disapointed. It was my husbands first visit (I've been for leaving meals with colleagues from work) we had the set menu. They don't scrip on quality or quantity and you get a varied menu for a set one. Will definitely go again

Los martes y los viernes ofrecen una comida de 3 platos por un precio fijo razonable. Sólo hay una elección de tres platos por supuesto, pero que nos vino muy bien. El vino de la casa a un precio razonable, también. El hall es un lugar muy entretenido, y el servicio fue excelente. En general, una experiencia muy agradable.

Lovely food, beautifully presented and excellent friendly service. Warm and cosy restaurant with old-fashioned quality and good service. Great sea-food and steaks,also nice choice of vegetarian options

Precioso edificio antiguo y muy nostálgico, llamada si vas al parque, a una corta distancia a pie de la estación de ómnibus.

El menú ofrece una amplia variedad de opciones. extravagante La lista de vinos es excepcional. La comida es excelente. El servicio es magnífico. El entorno es Tudoresque. Aparcamiento gratuito está al alcance de la mano.

Acabo de volver de la Bagdale Hotel en Whitby personal amabilísimo vamos allí cuatro veces al año o dar gran hotel una comida.

Reservamos un regalo especial para nuestra familia por lo que se anunciaba como una nueva cena de Año y baile. Lo que nadie ha mencionado, pero lo que oí hablar, el personal era que la banda no había convertido y no había baile. Esperamos que...

We went here Saturday night when we were on a weekend break, the staff are very friendly and helpful if not a little over worked. We had a drink in a small and intimate bar whilst browsing the menu, my starter was meant to be prawn and crab salad! There wasn't any crab and the prawns were tasteless in a bland mayo, my husbands starter was tiger prawns in chilli sauce, it was in fact prawns floating in a dish of Luke warm butter. Main courses weren't much better, my mushroom risotto was a bit like porridge in mushroom soup! To top our disappointing meal, the tables were being turned around for breakfast around us at 9.30. It felt like a school canteen with hotel prices . It's a big shame because the building has great character and much history, but the food and lack of class let's it down.

We had a really lovely three course meal in Bagdale Hall. The atmosphere is overall excellent: beautifull restaurant hall without any music and only a mild chatter of fellow customers around you. Perfect for those relaxed evening dinners! The food was really good. We had vegetarian options and they were delicious! Wine list was also very comprehensive. The service in Bagdale Hall was truly amazing! The pace of the servings, information presented regarding the food and wine and the happy attitude, everything was perfect! If you want to have a fine dining in beautiful and relaxed atmosphere, then The Bagdale Hall is your choice!

A lovely hotel, but you can get things a bit cheaper. It really depends on what you want. It has a great location and the architecture is truly stunning.

Had a excellent meal, food was amazing and the service was impeccable by the lovely lady who waited on us.

Stayed in the hall this weekend in a four poster room on a stay one night get one free. It was a gorgeous room and beautiful breakfast. Word of warning through have stayed in the house just up road that is also part of bagdale and it is awful so if staying here make sure you're in the main hall

After enjoying several morning coffees and an anniversary dinner here we took the plunge and booked a two nights for the price of one break.Not at all disappointed.Room 1 was very comfortable, with every appointment needed.The room is huge, with 4 poster bed, settee and armchair.There is a huge fireplace, not in use anymore, a desk and even a whole table for tea and coffee supplies. There was also hot chocolate, water and biscuits supplied.Plenty of power sockets to charge phones etc.Wifi was adequate rather than good.However I was aware of a presence in the room, n my husband was asleep in bed.The second night the TV switched itself on at 130 in the morning. It was on a different channel and a different volume to where we had left it.Meant my husband had a fitful nights sleep.Although the Hotel is in a building more than 500 years old it is very nicely appointed indeed.There is free parking a few yards away. A little tight, and it must get full at times.Such a good location, easy level walking to the station, buses and plenty of shops and restaurants, even in January.

Stayed here for a couple of days, thoroughly enjoyed the hospitality of the owners who immediately make you feel right at home. The restaurant is great, fabulous food, but does have a bit of a dentists waiting room atmosphere when it's quiet. The access to the hotel could be an issue for some less mobile users, as the entrance to Reception is on a busy side road and the Car Park is up the hill away from the Hotel. Suitcases have to be lugged down 50 metres to the hotel and it's so busy, you couldn't park in the side street for longer then 30 seconds.

I can recommend Bagdale Hall if you want a character hotel. The building is an authentic Tudor hall. The rooms are all very big, many having four poster beds. The breakfast is extremely good. Staff are all very friendly and service is excellent.

This meal was absolutely wonderful. Prawns with garlic butter for starters - beautifully succulent. Thai fish cakes for main - delicious and panacotta for dessert was splendid. We will return. Fantastic service, beautiful food & good value food. What more can you ask for???

We have been going to The Bagdale for over twenty five years And we still love going we go at least four times a Year short Breaks five day Breaks .the Food is Excellant and has a great Little friendly Bar the staff are great and do anything for nothing Is to much trouble the rooms a very large with four poster beds And Chesterfield settees and all very comfortable a great location as it is on the flat part of Whitby in the town Centre .

Stayed again at the Bagdale hotel this weekend for the Goth weekend .Firs time we have been for this great experience will go next year and the Hotel was as good as ever Managment and staff can't fault them

The Bagdale Hotel, well what can I say? Not anything bad that’s for sure, we arrived early on the Friday on a Goth weekend so parked our car in their car park and popped in to just let them know we had arrived. We were told we were in a certain room however another room on the next floor down was available so if we wanted to change we could, the receptionist Alison suggest that we have a look at both rooms then pop back and tell her our decision, so we did and opted for the alternative room.The room was located in the annex next door but don’t be put off the room was very pleasant with four poster bed (yes anyone reading my other posts on other hotels would see I’m not a fan of 4 poster beds) but this was not over powering in the room and we had adequate room to move around it as the room was large and spacious with a large bathroom complete with bath and a shower over it if required.I must say I have stayed at plenty of hotels over recent years but the staff here must have been the most pleasant I have come across (not that I’ve come across many with unpleasant staff) but everyone just seemed to want to go that extra mile to make our stay pleasant. A special thanks must be given to Alison who any request wasn’t too much (and believe me my partner does have some strange requests at times). The restaurant and bars are both pleasant as were the other guests when on a Saturday evening after dinner we ended up having several drinks and laugh and joke to the end of the evening.The hotel is well located within easy walking distance of Whitby town centre and the pubs and restaurants there.All in all we had a very enjoyable weekend, Thank you all at the Bagdale Hall

It’s not the first time we have stayed at Bagdale No 4 and almost certainly not the last.On this occasion we had a 4 poster bed in a large room with on-suit facilities. Free wifiBreakfast is taken in main hotel and offers the famous Whitby kippers as one of the alternatives to a full English breakfast.Off road car parking is a big bonus in Whitby.The hotel has very friendly and efficient staff where nothing seems to be a problem. In our case we had a minor problem with room which we reported but really didn’t expect it to rectified during our stay, however it was fixed within 3 hrs. Great service. Thank you

We were staying at Bagdale Hall so ate in the restaurant on the first night.The service was excellent and the food was really good.Particularly good was the goats cheese starter and the belly pork main course.The moules were tasty too.

Maybe its my own fault for pre-judging but did not find this place to be anything special and as such found it to be a little pricey. Had black pudding for breakfast which on the first morning was triangular (really?????) and was pretty awful. Much better the second day. Water in bathroom was scolding hot, why have it that hot? They're asking to get sued for unnecessary injuries. Shame. Is a lovely building but they could do so much better.

we had a short stay in whitby north yorkshire and stayed at the bagdale hall/lodge.It was very close to all the attractions, next bus and train stations.We stopped in the lodge which is just a short walk up a hill and has it`s own private car park.Our room was very nice with shower/toilet etc and very cosy.

Wonderful hotel beautiful rooms in the main hall, excellent food and plenty of choice. Very friendly staff and welcoming stayed at this hotel twice and will be visiting again! Love whitby

My brother in law & his wife were staying at the Hotel we decided to eat there one evening. I am 69 we are all of a similar age & well travelled. The Restaurant was in excellent decor with period furnishings (genuine not reproduction) very comfortable with an good atmosphere. The service was very professional & unhurried with several knowledgeable staff serving with a smile & humour. The meal was first class wonderful flavours & presentation, we complimented the owers & the staff (including a visit to the kitchen) on the fine meal we had enjoyed. It was agreed between the four of us that the whole evening was one of the best dining experiences we had ever had !

The best food you could hope for. Watch out London it was as good at the top restaurants ! The staff we wonderful. We will be back.

Having dined at Bagdale on Christmas Day 2015 and been very happy with the food I couldn't believe the difference...I visited with 2 friends who had travelled from East Midlands and expected on the Tour de Yorkshire day/bank holiday weekend a packed restaurant but at 1:30 pm there were only 2 other diners.One friend is vegetarian the other gluten free. On the phone I was told that they could construct a roast dinner around the gluten free aspect. One of us had a small bowl of Tomato and Basil soup - cost £6. Other two had the trio of Goats Cheese which was both nice and well presented, I think was £9 each.For main course, the vegetarian friend chose the Goats Cheese, charged at £16 for a few more bits on the plate than the starter. The roast dinner was comparatively reasonably priced at £12 and two of us opted for a combination of beef and pork. The pork was the thickness of a pork chop served with soft Yorkshire pudding, barely cooked broccoli, carrots, mashed potato and roast potatoes that were so tough and leathery they could barely be cut or chewed. The potatoes had the texture of having been reheated possibly several times and guessing cooked on a previous day or so.The gluten free construct turned out for the main course to be leaving out the Yorkshire pudding and gravy. At the start of the main course we were asked if everything ok, at that point as had only just started eating only mentioned how terrible the roast potatoes were. The lady serving us said oh dear, she would go and tell the chef. We never saw her again!My friends chose a sweet,again priced about £8/£9 eah. We thought the portions were miniscule e.g. the pannacotta came as 2 small circles about 3cms in diameter. We had a bottle of Prosecco (as we were celebrating 3 birthdays) plus 3 soft drinks. The bill came to just over £106. Not somewhere I will be returning. I am ashamed that my friends drove a 300 mile round trip for that.

Enjoyed our work Christmas meal here very reasonably priced no deposit was required was able to add to booked numbers at late notice. Nothing was too much trouble for the exceptionally friendly staff excellent customer service.

We had a delicious meal . We were not rushed & if we wanted could've had plenty of time between courses . We had about 5 mins between starts & main & then 10 between main & Dessert.I had the scallops , followed by the steak , then finished with the panda cotta . All very tasty . My other half had Thai beef salad followed by steak & finishing with sticky toffee pudding which he assures me was fantastic.

Called in for a drink. Staff we're friendly and helpful with enquiries we had for a future booking. Looking forward to revisiting to sample the food. Had a chance to view a room....beautiful!!

As we were in Whitby visiting friends we all went out for a meal on Saturday night at this lovely restaurant we were lucky enough to get the last table as we hadn't booked in advance, i must point out that the veg with a meal is not included in the meal you choose but as an extra which we found to be disappointing because the meals are not cheap by any means, the food itself was very nice but we have eaten in better and cheaper places i think by being within walking distance from the centre of Whitby reflects in the prices, won't be going back any time soon.

Absolutely stunning, food was amazing and the service was even better. I recommend this place so much, Sunday lunch also really really good!!

My husband and I have had lots of wonderful meals at the Bagdale, but Saturday was terrible!!! we both had French onion soup which was just gravy with onion in ,we both had fish pie which was watery and tasteless, this is not what the meals used to be like!!

Really lovely stay here on Saturday into Sunday. Room was big very clean. The hotel has an additional building but we stayed in the main hall. It's really very authentic with many of the original features. The room was modern and comfy. Not drafty or creepy. Though the hotel was expensive (£180). The food was really nice we ate in the restaurant.

All good, nothing to complain about at all, room spotless, food lovely, staff lovely, ambiance great, really charming and olde worldy

Beautiful place, stayed for the new year.Staff very polite and helpful, stayed in the main hotel in 4 poster room and utd was more than we expected very roomy and spacious would recommend and will be going back again for sure.

We were staying in Ruswarp for a Xmas week break and deceided to book for Xmas day.We were not dissapointed,6 courses for only £75 which we struggled to eat.Staff were very friendly and the ambiance was good,not many many Xmas decs,but we new it was Xmas.We always go somewhere on Xmas day for dinner and this was by far the best value for your money.We also came back on our last day in Whitby and had our last dinner,was not dissapointed.

I have twice this December been part of a group Christmas meal party, The first was early, there were no decorations to be seen which give atmosphere to group Xmas doo's. The meal was very nice, but lacked the traditional sprouts, veg was in short supply and more had to be requested.The second occasion the decorations were sparce but nice, the food was good but again lacked traditional veg, we were about to ask for more when we were asked if we wanted more. The staff were pleasant but service was very slow, taking 2&3/4 hours for the three courses, we had to skip tea & coffee or we would have missed our transport home.

A group of us ate here on December 10th. Starters ok, main course variable: lovely thick slices of turkey, delicious sausage wrapped in bacon, but then - stuffing ball and roast potatoes dry and the vegetables arrived half-way through eating the main course. If 'al dente' means raw then the cauliflower was thus, together with ok carrots. Christmas pudding good. Staff were very friendly and helpful, the dining room is beautiful, but £19.95 for quite an average meal was excessive. Had a pub Christmas lunch next day for half the price and it was far better.

Lovely old Tudor style hall. Beautiful interior. Lovely service, with amazing food and a good choice of food and wines on the menu. Lovely ambiance..... Very special indeed!

Nice if you want somewhere special, well looked after at the table, food was good. Reasonable prices. All round good experience.

Centrally located, homely, clean, pleasant smelling friendly well maintained hotel. Bar and restaurant both provided brilliant service by the very competent staff who looked after us very well. Recommended.

What can I say - food, service, ambience and wine list all perfect. Impressive on all counts. Definitely the best meal we had in Whitby.

We arrived today for a two night stay. We had to amend our original booking date due to hospital appointment for an operation & we received an upgrade which was a kind gesture from the hotel. We have paid £ 280 for b&b for two nights which we consider expensive for Sunday & Monday nights in Whitby in October. However, our room is very nice with feature four poster bed & nicely appointed bathroom. Our big disappointment is that the restaurant is closed both nights of our stay & we were not advised of this. We now have to find somewhere to eat. We don't really enjoy fish & chips which are readily available in Whitby. The lady on reception suggested some alternatives which we shall try. She has been very courteous & helpful & doing a very professional job. I asked if there was a Duty Manager to discuss our concerns with & she advised me there was no one available. I trust we shall be contacted by the Duty Manager but the planned birthday celebration is somewhat disappointing as we have to eat out & have paid what we consider a high price for our stay.

We had a meal in the restaurant with friends and we had a first class meal good service and the Bagdale is a great old hotel with bags of history.We returned for Sunday lunch a week later and had a very good and tasty meal, well recommended.

The staff were great, the building was beautiful inside and out, and the food was wonderful! We had a mackerel starter and pigeon breast on pea and black pudding risotto, and were very impressed. I had rhubarb three ways for dessert (a nice taste of summer on an October evening) and my husband had an excellent cup of coffee. We were impressed and will gladly visit again.

Finally tried this place for my husbands birthday. The building is beautiful, amazing interior and huge fireplaces, very cosy and warm on a cold winters night. The staff were very good, we didn't feel rushed at all. The food was lovely and not overly expensive. Look forward to going again.

I took my mother to Bagdale Hall restaurant for dinner to celebrate her birthday weekend last night. I cannot praise this restaurant enough. The historic building is stunning and sympathetically decorated. The dining rooms are cosy, private, and atmospheric. We enjoyed a bottle of champagne and an excellent 3-course meal and I still got change from £100, which, in my books, is brilliant value. The seafood cocktail starters were tasty and plentiful. The mushroom and truffle risotto, which I ordered as a main course, was particularly delicious, and my mother was equally happy with her beef dish. Our cheese board was also varied and tasty. We got the impression that the table we had been given was ours for the evening, and the lovely waiting staff could not have been kinder or more attentive. Having been upset by the rushed, rude, and unprofessional service we'd received at another -- bafflingly highly-rated -- Whitby restaurant (and piano bar!) on the harbour-front the previous night, Bagdale Hall was an absolute breath of fresh air. In a culture where staff are increasingly encouraged to herd diners in and out as quickly as possible, and to make as much money as they can, with little care for the quality of their customers' experience, I am grateful that restaurants like Bagdale Hall still exist. Thank you to the fabulous staff for such a special night. Along with Ditto, this is now my favourite place to dine in Whitby. I will be back, and I would urge all visitors to Whitby to try a meal here, give honest feedback, and move this lovely place up the Tripadvisor ranking. It deserves a *much* higher rank than it currently has.

Amazing food, would recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting Whitby. The wife loved the sticky toffee pudding.

A lovely old building, good service & food much better than one would expect in a hotel. The big plus is parking - a real problem in Whitby now.

I styed here this week for 1 night with my husband. The receptionist was helpful . We were given room 15 which was an annex room. When we went into our room we were horrified to discover dirty floor towels & cleaning equipment still in our room. We phoned reception to let them know and they removed the items. In the bathroom there were dead flies on the floor and the towel rail was thik with dust. The cups which were provided to make tea in were filthy so we had to change them for clean ones at reception. Breakfast was basic and lacking any fresh fruit and there were no pastries, ham/cheese etc. we would not recommend to stay here. We made reception aware of faults but they still asked if we had any problems when we were making payment and leaving. We were just glad to be out of there. There are lots of other lovely hotels close by but unfortunately they were fully booked!

We had dinner here on the Sunday of August Bank Holiday weekend. Having read some lukewarm reviews on here we weren't going to go, but our B&B hosts said there was a new chef and recommended it. I'm very glad they did.As soon as I saw how the menu had been put together I knew I was going to love the food (you can see it on the restaurant's website). For starters we had a lightly spiced vegetable soup and a pate - both delicious, and beautifully but not fussily presented. For mains we both had pork belly which was OMG fantastic. The portion sizes were just right erring on the side of generosity, none of that nouvelle cuisine malarkey with two asparagus spears and a drizzle of balsamic in the middle of a huge white plate.We couldn't manage desserts, so just sat there grinning happily and finishing our wine. I liked the wine list very much: there were a couple of types each of red, white and rose wines all at £16 and then the usual more expensive stuff. We were umming and aahing over which white to have, so the waitress brought us a glass of each on the house to try. Nice touch.I can't fault the service, it was just right and pleasantly informal and friendly. The bill came to about £70 and I would gladly have paid half as much again for food of this quality.I wish the whole staff team every success, they deserve it, and hey Chef, take a bow :-)

A excellent hotel, very friendly staff. The breakfast was very good.The deals of 2 nights stay for the price of one, in November until March is well worth it! The hotel is a few minutes walk to the centre of whitby John & Karen Doncaster

First this is a review of the Hotel and Breakfast NOT a review of an evening meal at the restaurant.The room was in the Bagdale Annex around the back, and was a very nice comfortable room. Spacious and well presented. The main hotel and dining room looked amazing with its old school furnishings and decorations.The accompanying breakfast was excellent, a decent selection to choose from both hot and cold. Hot food is made to order and the full english was spot on.The staff are very friendly and do an excellent job.On a side note we chose this hotel for it's location to the Cinder track, which is just up the road. The hotel allowed us to store our bicycles in the garage overnight which made it an ideal choice.

The hotel is spotlessly clean, full of character and a wonderful experience. We had a lovely, very spacious, room with a four poster bed (not our cup of tea but it certainly went with the character of this 16thC location) of a standard size - we would have happily dispensed with the four poster for a king, or even a super king, bed. The staff were very pleasant and helpful. The dinner was good and the breakfast was 'up to scratch'.

My wife and I decided to give Bagdale Hall restaurant another chance after reading the improve reviews on Tripadvisor. It had been 4 years since our last visit and we had been regulars to this restaurant.The setting of this historic place is second to none we have tried in Whitby and we have tried almost all the restaurants. Steeped in history sets a fantastic scene. The service was very good but to be fair there were only 6 other guests at 8pm on a weekend evening which gave me a insight on what was to come. Our starters of prawn cocktails had had excellent recent Tripadvisor reviews were soon on our table and we thanked our waitress. If you could imagine a 1970's version but assembled with boxing gloves on you would be just about there. The taste was no more impressive as it consisted of bland prawns, pea purée (`very little of this) decent smoked salmon and heaps of Iceberg lettuce.Our main was chicken for my wife and sirloin for me. The chicken was dry and tasteless and my £21 steak which I asked for rare was medium and about 1/2 inch thick. Not what we expected. The waitress looked embarrassed when she asked how our mains were. Not wanting to cause a scene I just said ok. I did not want to ask for another rare steak as I have never had a sirloin so thin so a replacement seemed pointless. The garnish served with our mains was dreadful. Large chunks of lettuce heart and awful dressing. Balsamic tomatoes cold and undercookedOur bill was £85 in total of which £5 was for a waitress tip and £80 for food and drink. The bill should have been £5 for food.Avoid this place like the plaque if your quality of food is important when paying for top end dining in Whitby. On telling our hotelier about our experience he said all the locals avoid Bagdale for the same reasons.Bagdale, change your chef and keep the rest.

The restaurant is room is stunning, with huge fireplaces. The food is also extremely good (as is the wine).

Stayed over night in the hall. Room was clean and staff friendly . Breakfast was disappointing as it was rather cold they were busy and maybe this was why .

One of ten restaurants we visited during our stay in Sleights, We, six of us, went there last year and enjoyed the food and atmosphere but this time we were all slightly disappointed. The surroundings are pleasant enough but there was nothing special about the food. An average restaurant.

A friend and I called in to the bar for a drink around tea-time and were greeted by a lovely young lady who was very pleasant and friendly who was working behind the bar.The place is a little dark and dingy on the interior but nevertheless staff make up for this with their cheeriness!

Well worth a vist good food good service nice clean rooms staff are very helpful good location for all attractions

This is very much a hotel restaurant. The menu was ok, and the service was lovely. It is a fine historic room. The wine list is particularly good value. We had an excellent well priced Pinot Noir. I would not say this is a destination restaurant, though the chef seems to be trying.

Fantastic stay nothing to much trouble great choice for breakfast superb Evening meal in the restaurant, friendly and welcoming staff Clean and spacious room great power shower

Our B'n'b recommended this restaurant which is just a few minutes walk away.We didn't have to book, got a nice table by the windows. Delicious mussels to start, followed by excellent pork belly, cooked to perfection. When paying the bill we were told since it was Wednesday there was a discount - result! The following night we went back and had good old fish and chips - so big we couldn't consider pudding. Again, the meal was delicious. Service was very friendly too!

We went here last week as part of a week's stay at Whitby. We had our wedding reception here back in 2003 and it was great to revisit. The staff running the show were really friendly, chatty and enthusiastic and the place hasn't changed a bit (Which we liked). It was steak night (Thurs) when we visited and we had two steaks and a bottle of wine for a steal. Top quality steak too and i'm not even that keen on steak! Would recommend.

Visited bagdale hall on a number of occasions , had a lovely meal every time ,pleasant surroundings , staff very friendly .

After much research this looked the best hotel/restaurant and we certainly weren't disappointed, only wish we had gone before our last night. Staff, surroundings and food were all top class, and considering this was a Sunday evening this was even better, as commonly Sunday service can be a little less 'special' in other venues. No hesitation in recommending for a quality romantic meal within a reasonable budget.

What a fabulous choice we made dining at this wonderful restaurant.the atmosphere was perfect for our 40th birthday party.The staff welcomed us in and took us to our pre booked table,they gave us menus and left us to choose the dishes of our choice,no pressure and no one rushing us.The staff was all pleasant and helpful and happy to answer any questions asked.The food was cooked and served to a high standard and we was given ample time between courses to allow our food to digest.We were very happy at the reasonable prices both for the food and wine.We would return and eat again at this unique place.

Excellent food and great value for money based on the quality of taste and presentation. £47 for a family of 2.5 with soft drinks and 3 courses (child shared our main but had own ice cream pudding). The goats cheese starter was excellent and we had 1 pork and one beef roast main coarse - superb meat from quality local butchers and ample portion of veg and juicy gravy. Pudding was excellent with our choices of white choc panna cotta with strawberries and sticky toffee pudding both superb. Staff very accommodating and very old style building dating from 1500's really adding to ambience. All in all a great choice and made our little one feel very special.

It has been quite a while since our last meal at Bagdale Old Hall. We all had an excellent meal! The sirloin steaks on the 'special' menu were 'special' Very tender & tasty! The sea bass fillets were also excellent. The only improvement we could make with the maim course would be chunky chips but that is a personal preference! An ancient building that has retained a lot of its charm! The desserts we had were also very good.

You certainly have to wear a shirt and dress for this place. Beautiful place with a grand dining room like something out of Downton Abbey. I had chicken liver parfait for the first time and will certainly be ordering it again. We both had pork belly mains but Gemma wasn't a fan of the mash, bit too appley. Not knocking the food, the quality was amazing and all locally sourced which was a nice touch. At the time it was the best cheesecake I'd ever had and I love my cheesecake. All round nice evening and would recommend for posh or romantic dos.

We were staying in Whitby over the bank holiday weekend and based on TA reviews decided to book this restaurant. We were a party of six and dined at 6pm. We were the first party in the restaurant, but, as time went on it got very busy, however, we didn't feel rushed and we still received excellent service from the waiting staff despite the restaurant being full.We had chicken liver pate, and salmon and prawn cocktail to start, this was accompanied with what we presumed was warm homemade bread rolls which we all had.Our mains were fish and chips, steak, pork belly, chicken and sea bass, all food served piping hot and well presented. Not all our party had room for desserts, but those that did had the cheese and biscuit selection.We wouldn't hesitate to return again.

My husband and i dined here one evening after seeing great reviews on fb and heard they had a new chef. We had 3 courses, i had the sea bass as a main which was served with mussels and queen scallops which just melted in the mouth. Dave had the steak which he said was thd best he'd ever had. We both a mouth watering desserts which were fit for the queen, over all a 5* meal at a reasonable price. The staff were lovely really friendly and pleasent to chat too. We will definitely be making a return visit.

Four of us had a wonderful meal on a Saturday evening when a large party was also in the resturant . I need not have worried as from the moment we walked through the door we were treated to the ultimate in service. Friendly , bright , well trained staff looked after us. These girls managed to wait on large party and look after us impeccably.The menu was just the right amount of choice and boy, it was delicious. We all enjoyed everything . It was a rare occasion where we felt relaxed and had received exceptional service and food. Thank you. I will certainly be recommending Bagdale to my business customers.

nice place to stay although the lodge is noisy when the sea gulls are perched on the roof all night , the room itself was very accommodating nice clean bedding good size bed and well stocked had drinks tray, good power shower, trouser press. The location allowed us to park the bike right up to the building but there is ample safe parking around the rear of the hall . Breakfast was especially good and the staff were great and very cheerful. The weather was dreadful and really pouring down but the staff were waiting in reception to welcome all the guests coming from the lodge ready to take our wet coats and seat us for breakfast. alla in all a very good place to stay ...apart from those pesky seagulls