GastroRanking-logo

The best restaurants serving Italian food in Castle Scarborough Yorkshire and The Humber

8 Restaurants on GastroRanking

restaurant_img
5.0

201 Opinions

location-icon43 Newborough, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151268takeaway_151268delivery_151268

The best bar in Scarborough. We moved to Scarborough in March and visit here most weeks. We have met new friends and love the place. Best negroni cocktails there are. Dog friendly too. Best ice cream. Love the place ❤️

restaurant_img
4.5

1493 Opinions

location-icon4 Harcourt Place, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151214takeaway_151214delivery_151214

Lovely meal, staff so friendly and helpful. Food was great (as good as we remembered) and reasonably priced. Would definitely recommend, but booking advisable.

restaurant_img
4.5

31 Opinions

location-icon36b St. Nicholas Cliff, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151357takeaway_151357delivery_151357

Decided to call in for a cup of tea as it looked quite cute and appealing. How wrong we were! The woman serving was very unprofessional and not making people very welcome apart from the shady undesirable looking locals at the reserved table. She was openly talking about customers when they were sitting outside and talking about passers by. At one point stating I am in the wrong business as I’m not a people person. We did agree on that. She is rude and very disrespectful for a business owner never mind a lady !! Give it a miss and go to the very cute friendly places along bar street towards town

restaurant_img
4.5

1480 Opinions

location-icon24/25 Newborough, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_153590takeaway_153590delivery_153590

Visiting Scarborough, stopped at Pomodoro for lunch. Friendly attentive staff, great food, reasonably priced. Would come here all the time if I lived locally!

restaurant_img
4.2

4802 Opinions

location-iconNorth Wharf, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151250takeaway_151250delivery_151250

Tasty food, but slightly overpriced for what it is. Amongst the best pizza around. Dedicated and helpful service without too much fuss.

restaurant_img
4.0

507 Opinions

location-icon33 Queen Street, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151220takeaway_151220delivery_151220

We went to Scarborough to see a band in the open air theatre August 2024. Came to this restaurant for dinner and had such an authentic and delicious meal, as good as we have had it Italy. So good that we are still talking about it now, in October. Would love to come back. A side note to the wonderful owners: Hope you guys enjoyed your trip to Liverpool!

restaurant_img
3.9

985 Opinions

location-icon36-37 Newborough, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_151230takeaway_151230delivery_151230

Absolutely vile. Starters came out all at wrong times, 15 minutes apart from the first to the last starter (there was only 5 adults) . 3 out of 7 of our meals had pepperoni slices on the pizzas and we all said that the pepperoni tasted rancid, like gone off manky smell. out of 5 adults not one of us finished our food, the other two meals were bambino pizzas and even though they ate the majority of them I tried a bit and it wasn’t very good, just like cheddar cheese thrown on some dough. It wasn’t particularly expensive but you’d hope that an Italian restaurant could get the basics right, pizza and pasta at an Italian restaurant should be safe choices. Not a good experience and won’t be going back. Let the staff know that as well. After the starters came out all at different times we asked the staff to please make sure that the mains came out all together to which they said of course, straight after the so called chef came out to apologise, but then proceeded to tell us that it wasn’t her fault and basically tried to tell us that it didn’t matter and that it is what it is, I cannot stress enough for people not to go there, I’m really not that fussy, but tonight’s experience was shocking

restaurant_img
3.5

7 Opinions

location-icon7 St. Helens Square North Yorkshire, England
Italian
outdoor_seating_310579takeaway_310579delivery_310579