Waggon and Horses Flaming Grill in Sheffield

Visited Waggon and Horses on November 1st and had a good experience. The steak and ale pie was top notch, and the pint of Thornbridge Jaipur was perfectly poured. The cask ale selection is always impressive, and I appreciate that they usually have a good pale ale available. The pub itself is a beautiful old building, with a cozy atmosphere that's perfect for a relaxing evening out. The location is also great, right next to Millhouses Park, making it a great stop after a walk in the park. I highly recommend Waggon and Horses to anyone looking for a great pub experience in Sheffield. The staff were friendly and welcoming, and the food and drink were excellent. We'll definitely be back!

I had lunch here on Wednesday 30th with my daughter in law and my baby grandson. My daughter in law ordered a pizza which was nice. I ordered the chicken pie and chips with mushy peas. However. The pie crust and pastry was so hard to get into, the chips weren't chips but potato wedges which were obviously heated up from before and hard plus they were cold. They tasted disgusting The only good thing was the mushy peas and even the gravy wouldn't even soften the pie. Very disappointed indeed. This is a place where I used to enjoy going to.

Dropped in for lunch & really enjoyed it. Fairly good menu, with vegetarian and vegan options. My companion & I both had sausage & mash, and it was a very good portion & I loved the inclusion of cabbage as a veggie side. My only criticism was that it came with a rich onion gravy & mine was more onions than gravy, but it tasted good. Staff very pleasant & helpful. It's on the edge of a busy park, so whilst there is some parking off-street, it is limited and in-street can be full. Definitely will go back.

100 x better than usual pub fare. Fantastic staff and table service to boot. Great choice of food and a really good local craft beer.

Had a family meal here with the Kids , service and food was of a reasonably good standard. We tried Haddock and chips, Fish pie, kids veggie burger and veggie pasta. All of it was of a decent standard. It was our second visit for lunch. This place is so convenient for Millhouses Park and even has a private gate from the car park directly into the park.

Great place to meet family and friends and have a bite to eat

Sunday roast post: I recently saw an article for the best roast in the city from the local paper claiming that X might be the best in the city. Clearly they didn’t visit the Waggon on a Sunday before writing the article. Then they would know that it IS the best roast in the city. You’d think if it’s a True North (of which I love all) then surly they’d all be the same? How wrong you are. Broadfield’s is very good too but, the Waggon, oh my! The Waggons 😙 🤌🏻 Because whoever is chef at the Waggon on a Sunday, knows how to treat a ‘tato / piece of meat. Plus mixing it up with fresh seasonal veg, it keeps you interested. I the lamb 10/10 same for the beef (and turkey at Xmas) However, I need to tell you about the pork belly. I have never liked pork belly. Chewy and something about the inch of fat has never sat right with me. My partner is mad for it and she always orders it. When it came I was like, “okay, I’ve never seen it like that. And what’s the crispy char all about? And why does it smell so damn good!?”. I tried some of hers. I still don’t like pork belly. BUT I LIKE THE WAGGON’S GOD DAMN PORK BELLY! If that’s not a compliment then I don’t know what is. From the varying images we have from our many visits gloating to friends and family where we are on a Sunday. THIS is the best Sunday roast in Sheffield. It’s quality, the right portion because you’re satisfied (and I’m a greedy git) tastes perfect and is cooked to perfection. Bravo 👏 Ps. If the chef changes then this review is null and void 😂 but I still ❤️ the Waggon

Usually such places offer an extremely limited selection for non-animal eaters. Not so here! The advantage of a limited selection is that the choice is easy. Here, I had a real problem – spoilt for choice! I went for the nori marinated tofu with creamy leek and potatoes and I'd recommend you do the same. It tasted delicious, absolutely divine! Loved it! And washed down with a nice pint of Stones bitter in a welcoming pub ambiance – what's not to like?

Absolutely amazing expirience. All. Staff were lovely and lively. Definetly going back to this amazing establishment!!!

Lovely lunch, although the beef was a little dry. Great beer selection. The wife was happy about pepsi Max instead of coke.

Excellent service. Dog friendly. Nice food , not particularly cheap but nowhere nice is nowadays. Excellent dessert selection

So great to have multiple vegan options that are done well. The vegan banana blossom & chips were delicious with plenty of rustic chips. They also served vegan red wine - the Shiraz. We will be back.

Visited this week, Sub standard pub food at restaurant prices. Poor quality, hardly any choice on the menu. Mediocre service at best. Used to be much better. Has clearly been a change in either management or ownership. Best avoid.

Food appalling, service a disaster couldn't even get our order right will not be visiting again, it used to be a lovely pub and food but has gone down hill big time, don't waste your time going

30th birthday party very relaxed atmosphere

“Cozy Coffee Cabin” Feel violated having been charged over £9 UK pounds for two canned soft drinks , and a small child’s soft drink . Unfortunately I was not there during the purchase - or I would have walked away . Rip-off Britain in full affect

This restaurant used to great spot for food unsure if under new terrible management and the food is horrendous . I order a burger with truffles ( addictions cost) and the pizza ( pizza was decent ) . The fries came separate in which took 20 minutes for my burger to arrive I then I had to ask for fresh fries and had advocate for myself . When I order my burger I specific said NO BACON as I had an allergy . Sent back by this time I didn’t even want to and had to request a manager and once again advocate for a refund . She didn’t even want to know what was wrong with my experience and the rest the people that also were unsatisfied . I told the manager I paid extra for truffle fries and I also needed that refunded - she turned around and I asked me if I had eaten them ? Like what? After just explained to you all your food was cold, uncooked fries from inside ( and which I don’t how it is possible as this frozen French fries ) , unflavoured, and you could have caused me an allergy , and she asked me that. I could not believe . This manager requires training because anyone with great standard of customer service skills to ease the experience tension would ask for an alternative and fully refund my whole meal with an apologise , which she did not . She told me I had to be more specific about my allergies . Disappointing as this is great spot but I will never be returning or recommend to anyone .

Good location. Great service. Kids menu. Seating outside. Real fires in winter. Part of True North loyalty scheme.

my first visit was a Sunday roast lunch, it was delicious so much better than Toby carvery, however on my second visit for dinner I ordered fish and chips the fish was good but the chips very terrible it appear soak in oil very brown as if it was refried, for those who eat with their eyes, it was not an eye candy, it basically did not look delicious, when I ask about the appearance the waitress said it was blanched but the chip was not described on the menu as blanched,, so they offer my friend and I fries instead

Much improved since my last visit. Friendly banter with staff and a pleasant environment. UPDATE: 12.1.24 - Decent selection of draft bitters and the log burner was a welcome bonus. UPDATE 13.7.24 - Called in for a decent pint of Stones. As a drinker, could I see myself spending 4 hours in there? No. But it's clean, welcoming and obviously works.

Had the burger. A little tipsy if you want a well done burger you'll need to tell them how you want it. But delicious when it came.

Very nice pub, will definitely go back when I'm in the area, the fish and chips were unreal.

I have visited this pub on two different occasions, for breakfast and for lunch. Both times the food was fantastic, especially small plates (tempura prawns and mini meze are worth the Oscars). Good coffee, decent choice of beers, very cosy for a relaxing conversation, good location next to the park, for a quick break during the walk.

Just had The Best Sunday Dinner! I had Pork Shoulder , Partner had Beef. Beautiful!!! Great service. Good selection of Beers. Will be back.

Held my mums wake at the Waggon and Horses yesterday... it was a tough day, made easier by the great staff team, the buffet was amazing, everyone commented on the presentation, quality and portion size.. Thankyou to all of you.. Hopefully will call again to sample the Sunday roast

Inedible food that was sent back after making me feel sick. Refused a refund. Disgusting enough to make me actually leave a review...

This pub was recommended by a friend. Great food and lovely service. They also allow dogs in too. Bonus!

Staff was attentive and able to recommend a good Sunday roast which was an astonishing £18. Children had the house burger for £14.50 each and they wouldn't recommend it. Very expensive meals out.

Another reinvention for this pub but looks nicer and the food was great. Just wish menus weren't so pretentious

The Wobbly Wanderers were here for a Funeral Wake. It is a large pub serving a variety of Beers & Lagers. The food was good.quality quantity and well presented. The only complaint is parking.... as it was busy we had to park in a raised section on the right hand side as you enter. It is a very tight entrance turn with a large high wall and narrow opening. Judging by the scuffs on the wall there's been quite a few scrapes getting in.

Our favourite Sunday roast place, after the meal we can have a walk around in Millhouses Park

Delicious steak pie, prepare to need to have a lie down after this!

They managed to squeeze in our group of 11 people at late notice after we were let down by Whirlow Farm. Really friendly waiters and waitresses. The food was the best pub roast I’ve had in years. Only complaint was I’d have loved even more of the delicious gravy. Very family friendly pub with the added bonus of being right next to the park. I’ll definitely be back.

Not sure if it’s been taken over by someone but couldn’t have been more disappointed. Used to really enjoy the food here, but couldn’t eat what we had today. The aranchini was flavourless and came with a strange sweet chilli sauce. The terrine lacked flavour and didn’t come with any bread so was quite literally a slab on the plate. We had 3 roast dinners. Roast potatoes had never seen an oven in their life, boiled potatoes at best, and the Yorkshire puddings were very clearly cooked previously and re-heated. And the servers clearly didn’t want to be there. Although no one was particularly rude there was little to no enthusiasm. There are lovely fires, but don’t expect to get warm after a wet walk, the staff don’t seem to want them on. All in all, won’t be rushing back and won’t be recommending either.

Beautiful experience, allow dogs inside, and Erik was incredibly amazing, he was nice, helpful, recommended extra options, he went above and beyond. Thank you Erik, you made our day 🤍🤍

Good choice of beers, friendly atmosphere and helpful staff.

Sunday roasts can sometimes be done averagely in pubs but this was spot on. Delicious beef and pork belly, cooked well and all the sides were as you would want. The usual suspects for dessert but done well too. Special shout out for the staff, great service and super friendly.

Food and service excellent but background music too loud and inappropriate for dining. Needs to be more "easy listening" and quieter

A nice place and nice meal in the afternoon.

So welcoming . Staff were lovely and really friendly. The food was delicious and at a fair price . Most of all our dog was able to visit with us ...Great place ,would highly recommend visiting .

Absolutely the best roast beef I’ve had in years!! Everyone’s food was excellent & the service was brilliant 🤩 too

Our dining experience for five, including my mom in a wheelchair with rare dementia, was exceptional. The staff’s outstanding service, particularly in accommodating my mom’s needs, made the meal enjoyable. The food was not only delicious but also fresh. We had a wonderful time, and we’ll certainly be back for another satisfying meal. Thank you 🙏🏼

Good service and excellent food

Squeezed us in when we hadn't booked which was great. Food came quite quickly which good. Warm and tasty. Service was engaging. Two children's parties were running so you could say it is definitely kid friendly! Dogs around as well which was fine by us!

Didn't eat so can't comment on food. Great staff though, very attentive.

Okay, the Sunday Lunch review: The food is absolutely stunning, there is no denying it. Quality cuts of butchers meat, delicious roasted vegetables, perfect Yorkshire puddings. The ideal viscosity of gravy, with more provided when asked. You’re paying £16 - £18.50 for a roast. It’s pretty standard if you don’t want the average crap you could easily make at home. This is a cut above your usual roast that’s for sure and the quality of the meat is worth it. OKAY! Why 4 stars? Because they ran out of chicken and beef before we even ordered at 2pm!! Please sort this out! I saw another review mention this and thought surely they wouldn’t let that happen again. Chicken and Beef!! Literally the 2 biggest players in the roast dinner game. We were a table of 11 and they smashed it with the service. 2 younger girls I wish I got their names to mention them but they did really well (we were in Sunday 21st at 1:30pm so whoever was working then that fits the description lol) give them extra tips!! Dessert was delicious but again they’d ran out of crème brûlée. Increase your preparations to increase customer satisfaction 📈 You’ve definitely earned repeat customers - just make sure you have beef next time - you upset half of our table with that one! 🥩🚫☹️

Unfortunately at 1pm there was no chicken sunday roast left. I would suggest a smaller sunday roast be available for people with a smaller appetite, as it isn’t possible for adults to buy the children’s roast.

Very tasty food,not over the top, good value and very comfortable atmosphere.

Used to be an absolute belter , food was always decent and the pub was really lovely , since the developed the new restaurant both the food and service has gone down for me, overpriced and just average , shame as it used to be right up with the best in Sheffield but looks like they invested in the wrong areas, just my opinion but can only talk from my experience

A really nice pub with lots of character, large but broken up into lots of nooks and crannies. Unfortunately for me I was very let down by the food. I have food intolerances including wheat and milk. I was handed the Allergen menu which consisted of several A4 pages. However, out of all the food available there were only 2 items that did not contain either Wheat or Milk - these were chips and Tomato and Rocket salad which consisted of a bowl of tomatoes and rocket which was soaked in balsamic vinegar (I assumed it would come with the dressing separate). They were unable to provide me with a meal.

As usual the food and atmosphere at the waggon and horses was fabulous for our Christmas meal with mates. Ellen went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed and made planning the whole thing a dream. We’ll be back next year,

We chose the W&H as the menu catered for all of us. Unfortunately when we came to order here was very limited vegan options and the one we chose only had three servings available. When a menu claims to have vegan and vegetarian options available, it's very disappointing to not be catered for when you arrive for lunch. The one meat option we ordered was also not available. What we eventually ate was ok, but it wasn't what we wanted or expected. Pretty poor really. I rated a three as the waiter was nice, apologetic and possibly a bit embarrassed by having to keep returning to our table with bad news.

Great service even though busy today.

Had the signature burger and it was amazing , cost around 15 pound was served with lovely crispy fries but the burger it's self was amazing, could feed 2 people it was the big, will be visiting again

Food tasted reheated and pre-prepared, I.e. not fresh. The least I expect when I pay for someone to cook me food is that they make it fresh. I couldn’t pinpoint a single fresh element, other than the under-seasoned garnish for the disappointing Wellington, which was a strange concoction of crispy dough and old pork, wrapped in a cheap imitation chorizo. I was pleased that the establishment saw fit to comp the meal, but it just shouldn’t have happened. The atmosphere is lovely though. Just be cautious with what you order (I wouldn’t go with anything too complex - stick to pub food and you may get something fresh).

Really enjoyed our visit here a few days ago. Nice atmosphere, excellent food and good selection of drinks. Staff were friendly and welcoming.

Brilliant little pub great food, amazing drinks options and the staff are fab.

Thank you to Waggon and Horses for their excellent hospitality during our niece's christening, we enjoyed the experience so much seven of us came back for dinner and drinks in the evening. The beer selection was fantastic, the food was great and the service was outstanding. Highly recommended!

Best Sunday dinner out in a long time

Can't praise this place enough, food, atmosphere, service all great xx

Absolutely gorgeous Sunday meal well recommended

Basically a restaurant, not a pub. Was made to feel very awkward for just stopping in for a drink. We live 2 minutes away and hoped it might be a nice local. Sadly not. The food fine but not nice enough to go regularly and can’t stop in for a drink so a bit pointless really. How this place is run by the same brewery as who runs the broadfield baffles me. Go and take some notes

Convenient for Millhouses Park. Reasonable food.

Our favourite place to meet for Sunday lunch. The staff are fantastic. We usually visit in a large group with small children which can be quite hectic but the staff are always so patient and accommodating with us! Nothing seems too much! The food is always delicious, we love the nut roast. The kids menu has lots of options and is great value - the ice cream with an endless list of toppings is a firm favourite. We have tried lots of different pubs in Sheffield for Sunday lunch but we always end up back at The Wagon and Horses! ':

Nice Sunday dinner here. Perfect for family's with alot of kids.

Only popped in for a drink whilst walking. Made to feel as if we were intruding. Won't be rushing back, plenty of other places that will be happy to have my money!

I remember driving into Sheffield for years and years thinking how nice this pub looked as I drove past and one day I'd like to visit it. Well after about 30 years that day finally came on my birthday this year. We were in the area and thought what the hell and went to the Waggon. It's a lovely pub inside and out, really nice layout, great ales to choose from. Left the bar, went around the corner and there's a roaring log fire. Bonus! And the staff actually tended to it. And just when I thought it couldn't get better, we chose to eat bar snacks. Talloy chips, pork jowls and Henderson's onion rings. Oh my god they were so good, really filling and incredible value for money. It's a great bar and I cannot wait to go back again.

My wife and I pop in to this well established pub once per week for a drink and the staff are so welcoming and always treat us well.

Excellent Sunday roast, meat and vegetables cooked to perfection, and first class service. Thank you!

Great menu ideas with poor execution. On the two times I've visited the food has never been as good as it sounds, or as the high price would suggest. Lovely atmosphere inside most of the time, but for the price I would expect quicker service (not a 1 hour wait between courses like I had last time) with well-seasoned and fairly portioned food (the tiniest bit of gravy on the pie, a stingy scoop of ice cream with the brownie). It's really disappointing, the ideas and the atmosphere are there but the service and food are both unsatisfactory.

Lovely pub cosy and friendly,,and goes good gluten free food .

Really disappointing experience yesterday unfortunately. Entered the pub from the car park and sat down at one of the many empty tables on the road side of lower level, to be quickly ‘told off’ and sent to the check in point. Then we got sat in the far corner at a very small table despite lots of tables being free in the main and area. We ordered dinner and drinks which was fine. Our Sunday lunches arrived very quickly before the kids burgers, which we had to wait c5 minutes for. And drinks arrived after all dinners which was a shame. Quality of the food was ok, except spare Yorkshire puddings we’d ordered for the kids were COLD and very oily. The biggest disappointment was the kids burgers though, which turned up and were TINY. The burgers were no more than 6/7cm in width and the bread bun had been cut into quarters (two of the sides of the bun had been straight cut with a knife). We checked with the lady who’d served us (who was excellent) if those sizes were normal - she checked and apparently they were. I’d hope that we weren’t mislead, but if the portion size for kids burgers is as served, maybe a note on the menu stating toddler size might have stopped us ordering it for our 10 year old! Won’t be rushing back as felt massively underwhelmed by our visit.

I had a vegan pizza and my fellow dinner had a steak pie. Both delicious. Lovely to see a mix of family, some playing the pubs game and on people with well behaved dogs. Would definitely go again.

We chose the Waggon and Horses as the venue for the wake following our dad's funeral. We really can't fault our experience. Ellen and the team were so accommodating, flexible and supportive right from the start. We had half the pub for our sole use, with our own toilets. The room and the toilets were clean and the room had a cosy feel yet easily accommodated a large number of guests. The cold buffet looked and tasted great. We were looked after really well at what was a very difficult time.

Excellent place for meeting up. Plenty of parking. Enjoyed it.

Staff brilliant nothing too much trouble 👏

My dads funeral Reception - excellent venue and service

Just the best pub in Sheffield if you're looking for traditional pub setting with a tasty modern menu and music, and the best roast dinner on a Sunday 😊

Great pub the staff are sooo friendly, very knowledgeable about the beers and have great rapport with all the customers. Have tried the food twice pizza burnt and no pizza cutter as apparently 'they have been stolen' and burger (one beef and one chicken) both dry and served with burnt chips. Not being awful but we are chefs so know the difference between good bad. Anyway we still go and have drinks as the team are welcoming and the options on the bar are varied and served well. Clean and tidy inside and out.

Great Sunday roast. Nice, cosy seating inside, good for larger groups.

Foods decent but not much choice

Brilliant staff service and food.

Unfortunately, not the best food. Although their pizzas are good, maybe avoid the roasts. Great service though and lovely pub.

I recently visited for a meal with my family. I chose to come here as on a previous visit I was blown away by the food, there were so many vegetarian and vegan options. However, I was very disappointed by the lack of options I had to choose from this time. Don't get me wrong, the food tasted lovely, but as a vegetarian, I had perhaps 3 meal options to choose from. The service was spot on but I perhaps won't visit for food again.

Visited after a family memorial service and arrived very early but staff were extremely kind and found us a table. Excellent food and service. Lovely relaxed cosy atmosphere . Would really recommend.

The place itself is nice but why 3 stars? £5 for a pint of coke, or so we believed, plus the sausage rolls didn't taste like sausage rolls. They were very mushy. I ordered a pint of coke and half a lager and was told it was £7.50 or thereabouts. However, checking the bank account this morning, it wasn't that much.

Excellent pizzas and staff were so patient and friendly with two grandchildren. Would definitely recommend.

Impromptu Sunday lunch - absolutely delicious food. Quick and very efficient service too which is a winner with a 5 year old. Adults had beef shoulder Sunday lunch and my son had the pizza. Would highly recommend

Was there for a wake but a fantastic pub nice atmosphere lovely staff

Great place for a nice meal and relaxed environment. Limited menu but the food quality more than makes up for it.

We had Stones Bitter & Wine very good I had Chicken Tikka my partner had Chicken Chorizo also very good what I couldn't understand was that on the app I booked a table from 8pm till 9:30 pm and we had finished the main by 9pm and just after 9pm the server asked if we wanted to see the desert menu and we said yes he came back to be exact 9:10 pm and was told that the kitchen had closed at 9pm how can you book a table for food till 9:30 pm when it doesn't serve after 9?

We held my Father in-laws wake here yesterday. From the first email to everything being prepared and ready for when we arrived it was all perfect. Thank you, it made a very stressful time much easier.

Came here with my parents to reminisce on where they used to live. It has changed a lot since we’ve been here before but service and food was amazing we’ll worth another visit

Lovely interior, good bar-selection, and a pleasant garden, bit of a smell of drains however

I wasn’t overly impressed. Ants all over the tables outside and my food was a little disappointing. The steak arrived lukewarm, Mac and cheese lacked flavour and I was given the wrong salad. The service was great but I probably won’t be coming back any time soon.

Our go to for Sunday lunch when we can't be bothered to cook! Booking available but usually can drop in

Very nice place with good food an beer !

Decent pub grub in a comfortable setting, not too pricey.

We used the outdoor cafe area, rather than the pub. Had a good coffee, milkshakes, and smoothies out facing the park. Would happily come back :) Friendly staff were preparing the drinks outside and open for a chat... Which made the service a bit slow. The menu looks extensive and looking forward to come back for lunch soon!

Fabulous little country pub, service was excellent food was amazing and staff very friendly and attentive to everything.