Tregarthen's Hotel Restaurant in Cornwall, Isles of Scilly

Food was tasty but the seafood/fish portions were tiny for the price paid. £13 for a tri-scallops appetiser with each scallop no bigger than a 10-pence piece. Shouldn’t these scallops be left in the sea a while longer? The Thai monkfish main course was also tasty but at £25 was tiny. I understand that I will be paying a premium for the stunning Isles of Scilly location but expected more from a high-quality restaurant that is supposed to be showcasing the best in local seafood. I politely gave this feedback to my waiter but no attempt was made by the hotel management team to discuss this feedback before the bill arrived.

Very enjoyable evening had many laughs and many beverages and met with excellent well mannered and polite staff especially the young girl behind the bar who’s name I believe was Skye and the food was very tasty and well textured however the portion size let me down after paying £28 for a main I would hope for a little more then was given

Excellent cooking. Good professional service. Of 4 high end restaurants on Scilly this is the least expensive and only second to The Star Castle, not the historic atmosphere or quite as good a culinary experience.

We went in early evening for a drink & to see what the hotel was like. Two Irish Coffees = £18, which we thought bit steep, especially as it was made without sugar. Perhaps the barman had never made one before. The bar was on the edge of the dining room & the whole place looked as if it was aimed at coach parties.

We ate twice at this restaurant. Most of the other establishments in the area were fully booked for the two nights we ate here and we have dined at Tregarthens on a few occassions in the past. There were plenty of items on the menu to choose from. Vegetarians are catered for which is good for me as I do not eat meat very often. The toasted tofu started was large and I enjoyed it. The fish and chips were good sized portions and tasty. Plenty of accompanyments came with our meals. The lager, pale ale and wine were all flavoursome. The staff were excellent. Very friendly, polite and efficient. 5 stars!

We hadn’t booked anywhere for an evening meal and thought we would try here as everywhere else was full. We enjoyed a glass of wine in the comfy sofa seats with a beautiful view over the harbour, ordered our food, then when it was about ready we were shown to a table. The food was absolutely delicious and cooked beautifully. We returned to the comfy seats after our meal and had a couple more drinks to end the evening. Staff were polite and attentive but also friendly and relaxed.

Only able to have one evening meal here as they are not running full dinner service so far for 2021. The meal we had was very nice and the staff friendly and efficient. We stayed here so had breakfast each day which was excellent.

Went for a meal with friends & booked a non residents meal. What a surprise? We thought we were on Master Chef!I don't normally like salmon but this was so well prepared and presented the wife had to stop me kicking the plate. Thank you Chef!Also thank's to the attentive Scottish Maitre'd and fantastic Plymouthian waitress

Booked in advance, information stated that fish/seafood on menu. Arrived at 12:30pm—crab was only fish option on menuAdvised already sold out!!Service - disjointed.Wine not chilledSalt cellar-didn’t work, advised that many didn’t, would have thought this problem was easily sorted.Poor atmosphere, poor attention to detail.,

V. disappointing, for somewhere next to the sea, where was the fish? No lobster, no langoustines, no mussels, no oysters, no soupe de poisson, no plateau de fruit de mer, in fact no fresh fish at all. There was crab on the menu, but when we ordered at 12:40 on a Monday it had all gone. There was little atmosphere and the staff were unhelpful.

Covid clearly affecting the food on offer at this hotel when we visited this week. Lukewarm watery leek and potato soup and only two hot meals to choose from, lasagne or scampi and chips (of the McCain oven chip variety). We were so surprised having seen a number of good reviews but so far every other restaurant or cafe we have visited on St Mary's has served fantastic fresh food. Waiting staff were friendly and helpful. This meal was a real disappointment. With such fantastic views they should be pulling in the customers with a fresh menu that reflects the best that the Island has to offer.

We were staying at the hotel on a DBB basis so had breakfast and dinner in the restaurant for four days. Breakfast was wonderful with a good selection of juices, cereals, fruits and pastries and a varied cooked selection made to order. It really was an excellent start to each day. Dinner had a good selection of dishes with added specials and didn’t disappoint at all. We have big appetites but could only just manage to finish most nights. Service was top class and every dining experience was memorable. Thank you!

Ordered Green Thai curry & Seafood curry l, both of which were of very poor quality, limited ingredients & one lukewarm. When we complained the manager was very unfriendly & challenged our request for a replacement!! Would not recommend.

We have had coffee here several times during our holiday. Staff always lovely, very helpful and friendly. We had lunch one day. My greek salad was superb, probably the best I have ever had. I would have liked a chunk of bread with it and will need to ask next time. My family enjoyed their sandwiches.

Tregarthens crab Sandwiches used to be so lovely. Had lunch today crab pittas so disappointed. Crab was all watery i expect had been frozen didnt even finish it. Will stick to Juliets Garden in future where the crab is fresh

2 years ago after many years dining here while on holiday, we had our wedding meal here with our family. We were extremely disappointed. The food was cold & service atrocious. We were very reluctant to return. However, we saw the post about Sunday lunch & decided to give it another try. We were not disappointed this time I’m pleased to say. The food was beautiful, service was excellent & the views amazing. We did pass on our compliments and will definitely return. So glad that things have improved

We had a really enjoyable stay here. The staff were extremely helpful and friendly. The breakfast was very good, will cooked and with plenty of choice. We thought the evening meal was really good: the options were all enticing and the belly pork we had for our main course was excellent. The service was good too. Our bedroom didn't have a sea view, bit this didn't matter as the comfortable hotel lounge looks out over the harbour: a beautiful view. The bedroom was comfortable and the bathroom clean and modern. The hotel is ideally placed for sight-seeing, being close to the inter-island boat trips. We would highly recommend the hotel.

On an evening which included a Christmas Fayre it was disappointing to find that there was no beer on tap and bottles of beer were priced at £5 each. This results in Tregarthen's having too large a profit margin in my view.

Tired looking hotel. Poor customer service. Lack of care. Manager who doesn’t care. A beautiful location. Could be so much better.

Only had a cup of tea here, but the setting is lovely with superb views over the sea. Staff were efficient.

Food was well presented and good quality. Excellent value as well. Staff were numerous and very helpful, attentive and friendly. Surroundings just lacked something and every time you looked at the window while the view was awesome the windows were dirty or fully of mould.

It's in an ideal location, with wide sea views from the restaurant and the lounge, as well as from many of the bedrooms. Book a sea-view room if at all possible! The building has been extended several times and finding your room can be a bit baffling at first! It's clean, comfortable and quiet, with excellent food and excellent staff.

Für Auge und Gaumen ein Schmaus, nette Bedienung, kurze Wartezeiten, angemessener Preis, gern wieder.

Ate here last year and had a nice meal. There was nothing nice about the meal we had this year. The white wine came up warm, although strangely the table water was chilled. My duck was over cooked and chewy. It had an uneatable leathery skin and a tasteless sauce. How the cook managed to massacre the vegetables like that I do not know. They only had to be boiled or steamed.

Great food, very fresh and plentiful, lots of choice and different menu each day. Staff are wonderful and very attentive, highly recommended.

Whole hotel needs a really deep clean. Room was small and tired, though the bed was large and good. Food and cooking poor to average (breakfast and dinner once during the 3 night stay). Extraordinary full afternoon tea, not in a good way. Doorstep sandwiches. One filled with smoked salmon, grated cheese (nasty) and caramelised onion chutney, just did not go together. Ginger parkin cake and carrot cake where huge slices and dry. Massive scones were ok but the cheap jam spoiled it. Staff very friendly and helpful but in need of basic training!

Very good breakfast and a varied dinner menu, well resented served by attentive staff . Pleasant dining room with lovely sea views

Had a lovely, substantial Sunday roast at this hotel last year and booked again this year. Admittedly should have checked menu first as no roast on offer. My husband and I ordered from the very limited menu ( 3 starters, 3 mains, 3 desserts and were bitterly disappointed in the quality of the food and portion size of the main course. Vast restaurant was virtually empty as a result and a waste of a beautiful view and potential. Shan't be going back!

Oh my days !! Went in for a gin and tonic to see some friends who were staying there, they had an absolute shocker of a stay, food diabolical and just so disorganised.

Good menu and good food, very helpful and friendly staff. Superviews over St Marys harbour although the decoration is a little tired

Stopped by for a snack with friends after a decent walk. Sat on the terrace in the sun with a glass of something cold and passed an enjoyable hour just watching the comings and goings around the harbour. Food was good although a bit pricey ( it was a hotel after all) but would return to try somrthing else on our next visit.

We Have stayed here quite a few times. It has changed. The manager needs to pay more attention to the restaurant. The food was not up to standard. The evening meal was poor, not good value for money and there was not enough especially if you have been out walking all day. We were served one piece of carrot and 2 florets of brocolli which were each the size of a 5 pence piece. When we asked for more vegetables the chef sent the embarassed waitress out to say if we wanted more veg we would have to pay for it. We asked to speak to the chef but he declined to come out of the kitchen all evening. The waitress was embarrassed further when I asked for a side plate she said they did not have one and offerred me a dinner plate. Every morning we had to ask for plates, bowls, milk, orange juice etc. The location is great and the staff are friendly enough. I left two messages for the hotel manager to contact me to discuss some of the issues we had but he also failed to contact me before I left 3 days later. He needs to smarten up service and the food in the restaurant. I will be disappointed if he replies to my review because he should have addressed these issues while I was there and I know he was on duty.

My wife and I arrived at the hotel to celebrate our Sapphire Wedding Anniversary having booked some six weeks prior. It was exactly 45 years to the day that started our honeymoon on St Marys, so of course I had researched all hotels and restaurants prior to choosing the best as advertised.

A day's visit to St Mary's should have involved lots of walking and outdoor activities but today was wet, windy and foggy. With its elevated position overlooking the harbour we spent a good part of the afternoon watching the world go by, warm and dry. The manager was extremely helpful in advising us about our travel arrangements and as a result, we were able to get the ferry back to Penzance because our return flight had been cancelled!

Very very poor quality, overpriced food which we had to wait ages for ..... how they stay in business is beyond me .... do yourselves a favour and go somewhere else

Great service for tea then drinks.

We had dinner here whilst staying nearby. The menu is fairly short, I think four choices for each course. Even so they had already sold out of one of the options and we arrived early. The staff were all pleasant and did their best to be helpful. However, there seemed to be no one in overall charge and at times things were a bit chaotic. The food was tasty, but the portions were small. Also I would say the decor is a little tired and could do with a makeover. It is a shame as this place could be good, but didn't quite hit the mark.

Been visiting Scilly for over 40 years so have seen Tregarthen's through many incarnations.

Thank you for a lovely evening, food excellent and staff accommodating. An anniversary outstanding family meal

Wir hatten jeden Abend Halbpension und waren zufrieden, auch wenn sich manches in der Woche wiederholt hatte. Die Kinderspeisekarte könnte facettenreicher sein. Außerdem soll/muss man das Kindermenu vorbestellen..

I am so impressed and have been there twice already! Menus change daily! Nothing boring here and much better than good!

Visitamos este hotel en nuestro último día, ya que el tiempo no era muy bueno, y la mayoría de los lugares para comer estaban llenas de gente en la misma posición. Sin embargo, la zona del bar era muy espaciosa, con muchos asientos. Parecía un poco caótico en el bar, pero tuvimos nuestro orden y pasamos una agradable pocas horas aquí antes de la Scillonian izquierda para Penzance.

Tregarthen's Hotel, we choose to visit to celebrate the actual anniversary dinner. We were not disappointed,staff very pleasant, food excellent with plenty of choice, and when served just perfect.

We had a very enjoyable and excellent lunch on the terrace enjoying the great views if the harbour and outer islands. A good menu with very well prepared and served food with an excellent bottle of wine. Not the cheapest but much better value than some other places in Hugh Town and superb views.

The biggest letdown of our visit,6" hair found in my meal,apology non existent,terrible attitude to customers by management,will not be going here again.

Stopped in for an outdoors lunch whilst waiting for the ferry home as The Atlantic Terrace was full. Glad we did, food was fine, views were great, staff friendly. A nicer quieter spot to enjoy and very convenient for the ferry home.

Had dinner here as a non resident this evening and was most disappointed, little more than ordinary pub food at inflated prices . Could not use the excellent terrace in this wet weatherService was excellent and so was the wine

A lovely place for a cup of tea after a stroll around the Garrison walls. Superb when the sun is out, sat on the terrace overlooking the harbour and the off islands.

Stayed in standard room with sea view for 6 nights, lovely room with very nice bathroom, pleasant staff, 1st class English Breakfast. meet on arrival via Shuttle Bus by member of staff who carried our bags to our room, on departure bags arrived at the Shuttle bus without fuss.We are fit 72 years olds but some people may have a small problem with the flights of stairs, if so make sure you have a lower level room. But don't be put off by this all the staff are very helpful and pleasant. Well done Tregarthen's Hotel

We were residents. Really good cooking. Good but not excessively choice. Staff attentive and competent

So impressed with the quality of the service and food this year. It's always one of my first choices when dining out for lunch. Kelly the manager goes out of her way to give customers the best experience. And for fussy eaters like myself they catered for my every need. And it was delicious! For those who haven't visited Scilly before, the view from Tregs is outstanding. A great place to watch the local gig race with a jug of pims as the sun sets. I've not stayed in the hotel, but I can definateoy recommend the restaurant! So thankyou to all the wonderful and friendly staff, I will be returning!

It seems there have been problems here. We visited St Marys over Easter and had a meal booked for our first night on the island only to find that when we turned up we were told they were not doing food and our meal had been cancelled.We were told they had tried to contact us but had not succeeded. The next issue was in having to do a mad run around the town to find somewhere to eat. We were lucky that another hotel could fit us in, all credit to them.

Lovely place to sit and view the sea while you wait for the ferry. Shame about the quality and service. The coffee was overpriced and took 40 mins to be served, it was delivered spilt in the saucer. Lunch was greasy, salty and burnt, I mentioned it to the waiter and he just said I will let the chef know. One member of staff's voice was so loud it was all we could hear, by the time we left we knew how much takings they had banked that day and all about that evenings function setup.

A very disappointing lunch with friends who were here for the first day of their holidays. The food was distinctly average at a high price. The sandwiches were cut as doorsteps (no diagonals here), and my halloumi burger was £11 worth of banal. The chips/french fries were black. The setting was tired (the grass wasn't cut, the tables dirty, and the tables were not cleared quickly so that seagulls had a field day). The metal fixings on the hotel walls were all rusty and had stained the paintwork.Go somewhere else.

Tregarthens have supported CHSW for many years and provided a superb wine tasting dinner for our latest fundraiser. The organisation was excellent, the Chef provided a lovely menu and the staff team made the evening run really well. Nothing was too much trouble and together we raised £537 for CHSW, as always Tregarthens did a great job, thank you so much!

This hotel needs some English speaking people working in it , ordered our food and the staff had no idea what we were ordering ,hence we didn't get what we ordered and it took ages as the chefs were arguing out loud .

The food is always very good at Tregarthen's at lunch time with fresh sandwiches and the usual offerings. The best thing if the weather is kind is to sit outside and enjoy the views. The interior is a little dated but OK.

Cream tea for two ordered. Came on one plate but two cups for the tea. Scones average. Sparrows a nuisance. One stole the shortbread in one swoop.. Service not friendly.

We went to Tregarthens because the menu looked impressive and the hotel looked smart from the outside. The meal started well - the starter was excellent (langoustine bisque for my husband and a platter for me). However, we'd gone for the crab linguine, which was very disappointing - watery and tasteless. Also, the decor looked very clinical, not cosy at all when compared to some of the lovely pubs on the islands. I find it hard to recommend eating here when there are so many nicer places to go.

We went to Tregarthens as my family came to Scilly to bring my gran to celebrate her 87th birthday, having looked forward to it all week we got to the restaurant where the staff seemed very untrained and unorganised, after we'd ordered food we still had to ask for a drinks menu, the bread that followed was lovely. The starters were lovely but the birthday lady decided to wait for her main. The mains that were lovely were the tarragon chicken, steak and crab salad but sadly my Gran ordered the vegetable chow mein... I wish I'd taken a photograph it was huge and dry just a mass of noodles and dry veg it had no flavour and no sauce. My poor gran ate a little veg but left 90%of the meal. When plates were cleared we told the staff it hadn't been nice and to be fair they asked if she wanted anything else. However we'd all finished and had a young child to take home. Then when we went to pay at reception tether asked how it was and again Dad mentioned that the birthday girls meal had been inedible and they didn't take it off the bill, offer a free drink, apologise or even recognise it was the ladies birthday. It was such a disappointment as everything else was lovely but the untrained staff and lack of understanding or kindness was a dampener on a much anticipated night. As a local person I'd be hesitant to take family back again.

Son and girlfriend ate there. Since 1985 we have salivated over the menus posted daily at the gate post, but as we stay on the off-islands, never eaten an evening meal there, so we weren't surprised when they booked a table at Tregarthens when we recently all stayed on St Mary's. However the linguine was a disappointment and the girls couldn't mix mojitos. Granted they were so bad they didn't have to pay for them! They came back to our holiday home really disgruntled and as a result I felt they were cheated of their special meal out.

We enjoyed breakfast and dinner while staying at Tregarthen's on a half board basis and would definitely recommend d this restaurant to anyone visiting the island. The food is beautifully served with generous portions. The staff are welcoming and attentive without being intrusive and the atmosphere adds to the dining experience. We would specially recommend the seafood and desserts,

I went there for dinner. I sat outside on the terrace with the beautiful view on the sea.I had grilled tiger prawnsand linguine with tomatoes and crab.A glass of prosecco as well.It was good and what I was looking for!I read some reviews not really positive but I decided to give it a go and I would go again.I am Italian and the pasta was well cooked and tasty as well as the prawns.Price affordable.I would go again!

The service was excellent: attentive without being over-bearing. Food was excellent. I had the chicken livers on ciabatta as a starter which were sublime. My wife had chilli prawns and colleague had garlic prawns: empty plates confirmed how much they enjoyed these. For the main course I had crab and prawn linguini- not as good as the starter, but our colleague had this last night and said that it was superb. My wife had crab salad - I've never seen so much crab on a plate: not surprisingly my petite wife couldn't finish the dish but the expression on her face showed how much she enjoyed it. Our colleague had John Dory - I tasted it and it was really succulent and tasty. Both of them had no space for dessert: I had lemon posset which was a perfect end to the meal: really sharp, sweet and light. They have two menus: a standard menu and a daily one: the latter as long and as interesting as the former. Wished I were staying longer, as there was much I would have liked to try!

The chef is a star. especially with evening dinner specials. Lobster out of this World with two days notice! However, the staff are polite and charming, but have no idea how to provide service to restaurant customers.

Have stayed at the hotel on a number of occasions but latest visit was for a cream tea which is very reasonably priced. The staff are friendly and efficient and will serve you in the lovely garden overlooking the harbour and sea. A lovely place to spend an hour or so.

Went here for lunch with my friends found it was a great experience and the food was fantastic and the prices were not bad. Also walked to top of hill were the bell is great views

I m waiting 25 minutes for the tea set n the reply was they r so busy ...... think twice before u visit if u r in hurry ..... but the scones is nice .....

Lovely food, excellent quality and great service at a busy time. Fantastic views from the terrace and staff went out of their way to help a large group sit together.

We decided to have a Cornish Cream Tea whilst on Holiday in the Isles of Scilly. The foreign waiter had difficulty understanding our requirements but was very pleasant. Very disappointed with the cream teas though as the scones were devoid of any taste, and although the cream was plentiful it seemed very soft and weak for clotted.

We stayed here for a friends wedding, the room was spacious and well appointed with a fantastic view over the harbour.The food served for the wedding breakfast was superb. The chef's truly excelled.

we enjoyed our stay.Wonderful food.lovely views from our room overlooking the harbour.very helpful reception who had to deal with cancelled flights and re arranging accomodation

I took friends here for a three course meal and I thought that the food was excellent, especially the sea bass which I had as a main. Service was prompt and efficient. The one shortcoming is the ambience, rather functional (although comfortable) furniture and very bright lighting. The hotel has undergone a recent change of ownership and further improvements are planned.

I didn't go so I cannot comment on the premises, we sat in the garden which had a nice viewWe had a cream tea, which at £6 each was a little steep. The scones were ok I couldn't decide if they were dry or just short. Plenty of clotted cream and jam though

Breakfast is buffet style but do not expect a large choice. Evening meals were excellent with plenty of choice.

We had lunch on the terrace on a sunny afternoon. Very good food, nicely served with a lovely view over the harbour to Bryher.

Worse meal of the week.We actually only went because it was the only place we could find serving mussels. Unfortunately they were tasteless.The pasta meal was bland, but not as bad as the atmosphere, which was stale and stuffy. I personally thought one of the waitresses was watching in case was did a runner, which she did from a distance as she only ever visited the table to offer sweets, no mention of another drink to to replace the 4 empty glasses on the table.Couldn't leave quick enough and certainly won't return.

We ordered lobster 48 hours in advance of our visit and it was a great disappointment. The flesh was fibrous and recently cooked (when we had specifically asked for it to be served cold) and the salad seemed to have been "dressed" several hours earlier. When we asked for fresh salad they told us they had run out of salad leaves! Admittedly they said we didn't need to pay for the meal but it a big disappointment.

Wonderful hotel,friendly helpful staff. Delicious meals definitely fine dining. Nothing was too much trouble. Thank you a lovely special break.

Waiing on our boat for Penzance, we decided to have coffee and lunch at this hotel. We are glad we did! The service was fantastic as well as great food! I ordered steak, beetroot,goats cheese salad. The steak was tender and juicy and was well presented! My husband opted for the chicken burger with extra sweet potato fries. The sandwich was on a homemade roll with bacon, cheese and tender charillgrilled chicken fillet. Both meals were outstanding and filling. Service was sharp and precise.

One of the best hotel experiences in recent memory. The staff are just fantastic and very helpful! As a family with small children we have been made very welcome and the support has been great. The food is out of this world and has certainly been a highlight on our little holiday! Honestly, I am struggling to find negatives, probably because none exist. WE WILL BE BACK WITHOUT A DOUBT!!! Fantastic!!!

I went to Tregarthen Resturant, while waiting for the Ferry back to Mainland. Ordered Cream team and it was soft and fresh scones with excellent cream and fresh fruits and Jam. Its airy and clean and good waiting spot before catching up the ferry.

The evening food here is just lovely. The waiting staff are spot on. We had a fabulous evening and a very nice breakfast too.

Very slow and non attentive service for drinks and food. Menu items were missing and not informed to us until placement of order. Positive point is the lovely view over the bay if you are lucky enough to have a table by the window - We did.

Dropped in for tea hoping for sandwiches, but no luck. Cream tea was excellent though, with bucket-sized cups. The scones were enormous, light and fluffy. We decided not to risk the fearsome gulls and ate inside.

We have been to this hotel many times purely for drinks and coffee, we haven't eaten here but just love the polite, attentive staff. The lounge bar is comfortable and the views are great. It is so nice to enjoy hotel facilities and feel welcome despite being non residents of the hotel. Also the free wifi is the best quality on the whole of St Marys!

Friendly service and a great spot to watch the sunset. We didn't eat, so can't comment on the food. Dog friendly outside, and fine with you taking your dog with you to the bar – not sure about the restaurant area. Decor perhaps more appealing to older guests – but lovely friendly staff, reasonable drinks, and would visit again.

Popped in for lunch after walking around the Garrison but decided to have a cream tea instead. It didn't disappoint! We sat outside and enjoyed the views while eating 2 warm scones, 2 pots of jam and a large dollop of clotted cream with some fresh raspberries and blueberries. All of this washed down with a large pot of tea complete with extra hot water, plenty of milk and decent sized cups and saucers. Good service from friendly staff.

Popped in early morning before travelling to the airport. No problem about being a non resident at the Hotel. Nice welcome, excellent breakfast, good service. Lovely views across the quay and sea front from the restaurant.

Popped in about 11 today having seen their notice board advertising all day cream tea, all day means after mid day, shame, after walking round the Garrison really fancied some clotted cream, staff seemed a little uninformed.

There is nothing nicer than sitting outside at Tregarthen's looking over the sea and harbour enjoying a cream tea. Everything is nicely presented and the staff are very attentive.

As a non resident of the hotel, we were treated like royalty, the perfect level of polite service with none of the obsequious fawning some pretentious places think appropriate. They reserved my preferred table, adjusted the menu to suit my conservative tastes and delivered an exceptional rump of lamb and a hake risotto. The souffles were also perfect. Whoever trained the staff deserves a star award, as does the chef. Thank you to all who made this meal memorable.

Decided to pop in for a coffee on the way back to our camp site as we spotted the views from the terrace. Staff were most accommodating despite our somewhat bedraggled appearance in full walking gear. Great value and extremely friendly staff. Only wish we had longer on the Scilly's so we could experience dinner service. The menu looked fantastic! It really is a testament to the staff when customers simply popping in for a coffee are treated just as well as those staying in the master suite and eating 5 course dinners a night. Keep up the fantastic work!

Liked,The views.The friendly helpful staff.Menu selection was very good.Presentation of the meals..Quality of the ingredients.Disliked.Nothing found to dislike.

Super meal, minimal menu choice but beautifully prepared and cooked. Waiting staff attentive but slow. Good job we weren't on a hurry. Sit and have a drink in the lounge first and coffee there after too. Great vista.

Staying last year in Tregarthen's hotel I know the quality of the dinner. This year we go back only for diner but again it was a surprise in a good way. All rowers enjoyed the dinner as it was well cooked against a reasonable price. Besides the service level was according what you expect.

I wouldnt want to knock this restaurant because theres nothing really bad about it but there is also nothing that really shines. The hotel itself is a little dated, the restaurant is okay though I asked for a table with a view (the main reason for going there was to watch the sun set) and we were given a table with a view (mostly) of roofs, and a very dirty window at that so that was a bit of a disappointment. The food was nicely presented and quite tasty but no great shakes. The waiting staff were efficient.Probably overall experience is what I would expect from most hotel restaurants so as, it seems, there aren't a lot of restaurants to choose from in St Marys, I wouldn't rule out eating there again.

We stayed here for 4 nights last year and ate in the restaurant the first night, it was excellent food and my husband still mentions the fish dish he had now. The breakfast each morning was great you could have the full English or just order parts of it, which was good, the room was a little small but as we usually use a room to get washed and dressed and to sleep in it was no big deal. We had a fantastic view over to Tresco (which did cost us) but was lovely.The reception were fantastic and very helpful (some how our luggage went to sent St Martin but it was soon back in our room).overall we loved the isles of Scilly, the people and are going back for a week this year

We decided to try the hotel for lunch with our children but came away hungry and disappointed. Th atmosphere was like sitting in a church. Very very quiet, feeling uncomfortable with 2 chatty Young children. We ordered, or at least tried, but everything we picked was unavailable. I opted for mussels in an ale and herb sauce and I received mussels in cream and garlic. My husband had a Steak salad, tasty but small. The children's option was to choose 5 items from a selection. When it arrived the the cucumber sticks were actually wafer thin slithers , more of a garnish than part of the meal. The apple was forgotten, when we requested it it was served as they cucumber was. The homemade chips were obviously frozen chips and came in a bowl no bigger than you would serve sugar in. We were not offered any condiments and there were no members of staff present to ask for any. Overall very disappointed.

We logeerde hier tijdens het GIG weekeind in mei.Ontbijt en diner perfect!!!Zeer mooie locatie, kamers klein maar prima.