The Piebald Inn in Scarborough

This is a fabulous pub with great service and was dog friendly. The food was excellent and would definitely recommend. In fact, we loved it so much we went twice in one week! They have lots to offer for everyone and they even have poochi pies! Thank you we will definitely be back!

Lovely spacious king size bedroom with everything you need Spotless with quality bedding and towels Would stay again without a doubt The pies were fantastic and good value for money

Lovely people and atmosphere, attentive, helpful and very nice food. Waited about 20 mins for our order to arrive, piping hot and very tasty. Very spoilt for choice with 52 varieties of pie including vegetarian options. Home cooked chips were great. The portions are huge but you do have the option of a take home doggy bag. They have pies for dogs to eat too !

4 of us visited with our dog. The food was amazing and really good sized portions too. They even have a pie for dogs which Shadow thoroughly enjoyed. We have never seen such an amazing choice of pies. We will definitely visit again next time we are in the area.

Try something different with typical Yorkshire quantity and quality, go to the Piebald. I had the Moroccan Lamb Pie, with vegatables and chips and it was excellent. My wife had the Fish Medley which was just as good. Good quality ales, good friendly service. What more could you want and all at a reasonable price. The Tops

On arrival staff we're very helpful and friendly. From seating to actually getting the food was 1 hour so if you have young children best bring something to entertain them. The pies we're very nice homemade with thin crust and lots of filling. A great pie! Home made chips, could of done with more. We sat in the restaurant, this was a dog free zone. Decor was tired with food stains on walls.

Amazing choice!!! Pie chosen was delicious! Service was good. Would definitely go back. Slightly expensive but I felt worth it. Dog friendly

We really enjoyed it here, I had the Irish Draught (steak & Guinness), and wifey had the Welsh Cob (lamb). Portions were hugh and very flavoursome. Staff were attentive and friendly, I thought the prices were a bit steep, but other than that, no complaints.

I had the fish pie and it was great. Loads of salmon. Everyone else had meat pies that were loaded to the rafters with big chunks of meat. No complaints from any of us

Absolutely spoilt for choice with their very extensive selection of pies! We were so impressed! The pies were delicious! We loved the option to eat half and take the other half home, think great for those with a smaller appetite. I had The Cleveland Bay - wow! I think really there would have been enough for me for three meals! Their chips were fantastic too! Initially it seemed a little on the expensive side but the quality of the food and portion size made it worth every penny! My pie was jam packed with super soft tasty meat! The service was great too, really warm and welcoming. You can take your pets too, but for me with horrible allergies I loved the fact that there was a doggy free area as well. Also if you’re not a big pie fan, I noticed they had other things like lasagne, fish and chips etc so they really do cater for everyone! Would highly recommend.

52 delicious pies to choose from. They are fully loaded with filling, no air or gaps when you take the crust off. The chips were tasty too. The servers were really friendly and helpful. Book if it's a busy day.

What an amazing friendly pub/restaurant. The selection of pies is unreal. I went for the steak and Guinness pie it was excellent, served with a choice of potatoes and veg topped off with delicious gravy. Can’t wait to go back

Looking for a dog friendly pub to eat out whilst we were staying at The Bay in Filey and came across The Piebald Inn. Huge variety of pies which were amazing. They were packed to the brim and so tasty. They even did a pooch pie for Angel which she enjoyed. The staff were lovely. Couldn't recommend enough 👌

Called for lunch.Had one of the huge variety of pies .Was absolutely delicious,very well cooked and massive portions.Staff where extremely helpful and we will be returning when back in the area .100% recommend.

Extremely busy, so unfortunately the service was slow, but it was worth the wait as normal! We ended chatting to some lovely visitors. We all had different pies all turned up very hot and absolutely delicious 😋- the only reason for 4* and not 5* was the fact it was very slow and appeared a little unorganised, but the food was spot on and we left feeling very satisfied 😊

If you ever find yourself in the Primrose Valley/Filey area and you fancy an incredible meal, with the best pint, in the most friendliest of pubs, you gotta pay a visit to the Piebald Inn. 52 pies to choose from and untold ales. I had the Connemara - Corned Beef hash, in red stock and parsley with cheesy mashed potato mixed through. My wife had the The Irish Draught - Steak braised in Guinness and onion with mushrooms and thick Guinness gravy. Both came with chunky chips. Oh, and the gravy was divine. There were ten of us in our group and everyone ate everything. Plus the The Pie Pub Company Bitter is the best pint I have EVER had. In addition every member of staff we spoke to was incredibly friendly. I would walk back if I had to, and I live over 60 miles away!!

I called to book and found the person booking to be rude and impatient. When our food arrived mine was very undercooked, light on filling, with a mass of soggy slimy pastry and the new potatoes were old and blackened where they’d been soaked too long. Nobody came to check whether our food was okay and when I finally told them, they just said that they’d mention it to the chef - didn’t seem particularly interested. I am disappointed as this has previously been one of my favourite places to eat but it seems to have gone seriously downhill in quality and service. I’m hoping it’s a one off but as somewhere I’ve visited many times, it’s a real red flag to me now - very reluctant to recommend it any more to my holiday let guests.

We visited in March 2024, in celebration of my niece's birthday. We all opted for the famous pies, and none of us were left disappointed!! Melt in the mouth beef encased in a buttery homemade shortcrust pastry, served with delicious proper hand-cut chips and meaty gravy. The staff were all very friendly and welcoming. We all look forward to a return visit.

Parked our motorhome here overnight- had a fabulous pie dinner! Absolutely gorgeous- 52 pies to choose from! The chips were also amazing!!!! Definitely recommend !

Booked table for 7 to celebrate a birthday, food was amazing and staff lovely and service great . We will be back as so many pies still to try. Dogs enjoyed their pie too.

Absolutely fantastic in a wonderfully quaint location. I cannot recommend the Piebald enough. The food, service infact everything is amazing. This was recommended to us by a family friend and boy were they spot on. Please folks, words fail me, just go for a visit

Our recent visit to The Piebald Inn near Filey was nothing short of delightful. The welcoming staff made both us and our furry companion feel right at home. The highlight of our stay was the impressive selection of over 50 pies, with plenty of vegetarian options to choose from. The dog even had a poochie pie made just for her. The large clean room provided a cozy night's rest, ensuring we were all refreshed for the next day's adventures. For a charming, dog-friendly getaway with pies galore, The Piebald Inn comes highly recommended.

Great pub. Good range of beers and the pies are unbelievably good. Enormous range of beers, huge piece of pie. Not to be missed!

Insane pie menu, although only 50 available when we were there as the other two had already sold out. Not a problem. Only issue is how to choose between them all! I had one of the lamb pies and the husband had one of the seasonal game pies. Both were incredible. One of us had chips and peas, the other had mash and seasonal veg. We also opted for extra gravy. Pies were proper pies, with base, sides and short crust lids. Meat was cooked to perfection. Huge portions. No idea if they did dessert, we were too full to even ask! But they do special doggy pies so your furry friends can eat there too. We weren't aware of that and had already fed our girl, which I'm sure she was disappointed about. Although £20 for a pie might initially seem a bit steep, it was worth every penny. Great, friendly service too. So good that I'm considering driving 2 hours from my home to go back!

Great evening at The Piebald! Booked a table online in the dog friendly area, when we arrived we were greeted with a friendly smile and a cheery hello. We placed our order I had the Moroccan Barb - gluten free for me with chips and seasonal veg and my husband had The Chestnut horse new potatoes and garden peas. We were not disappointed. No room for pudding although I was tempted by the gluten free chocolate fudge cake. Thank you

Visited for Mother’s Day. Food was fantastic but service was very poor. Restaurant wasn’t overly busy when we were there but no staff were about to order drinks or cutlery for my child in the dining room. When we finished the meal no one came...

Visited for Mothers Day and would happily revisit. Lovely, friendly and attentive service and great pies (and chips!) Obviously a great selection, really tasty, large portions and good selection of veg. Decent kid portions as well The only improvement I would make is it is...

Called on way to Filey bay village on mother's day with wife on off chance they had table, got table and what a surprise, absolutely gorgeous pie dinners and big portions but most of all staff were brilliant and friendly, will definitely call again.

Our first visit in the camper.What a find outstanding food ,incredibly talented motivated staff a real asset to the pub.Great selection of hand pulled beer and a big plus for me a dining area free of dogs which is a win for me.we will see...

My husband booked the pie bald inn as something a bit different for a Mother’s Day treat and my young son came along too. On entering we were greeted by lovely staff at the bar and then shown to our table in the restaurant part....

We have been several times before and wanted to take our friends, the food was as ever delicious and we all enjoyed it. I would like to make a special mention to Joe who was looking after all the customers on his own as he...

Visited as a party of 6 and had a wonderful evening. The food - obviously pies, were excellent. We all choose different types of pies ( and there was plenty of choice) served with a choice of chips, potatoes or mash, and peas or vegetables....

Get yourself in for a great experience, Staff know there stuff, and polite unusual in this day and age. Well worth A visit. Don't be afraid to bring your dog

Great little gem! Pies are huge, tasty and variety to please everyone’s taste. Service was excellent and Joe our waiter was pleasant and friendly. So glad we decided to stop and eat here whilst on a long weekend in Filey. Would definitely recommend

Superb wide variety of pies to choose from, which were in generous portions and very tasty. We stayed the night in a large, comfortable room which was very well decorated (no scuffs on walls). Breakfast in the morning was anything from the menu. Again generous...

Stayed overnight in the motorhome having booked in for dinner. Pies were amazing and huge portions. Proper homemade chips too. Staff were fantastic and the dogs were so relaxed in the bar. Definitely recommend and we will return! 5 star food and service. Thank you.

Brilliant pub, 52 pies on the menu so something for everyone!! Huge portions, everything was freshly cooked & homemade. Husband said it Was the best pie he'd ever had! Joe our waiter was brilliant! Very friendly & attentive, couldn't do enough for us which is...

We stayed here can recommend this Inn for its food its staff and last but not least the room we stayed in So clean modern and spacious loved every minute of our stay and Breakfast is just Fab Would recommend this as one of the...

52 pies on the menu!!!!! Definitely Pie heaven. My partner who is gluten free has not had a pie in years and there was more than one choice of GF pie. He chose the game Polo pony and it was a joy to see him...

Burns night on 25th January 2024 was the best one yet. Fully booked, excellent menu and head chef John Sylvester gave his funniest speech yet and his bagpipe playing is exceptional. Roll on 2025.

Delicious pies The option to eat half and take the other half home suited me fine Pastry, filling and gravy all perfection Chips also tasty, and 4 vegetables Not the cheapest meal, but the pub is warm and service is satisfactory

Terrible went in for a drink with my wife,1 cider and 1 hot chocolate had ro wait 5 minutes for a hot chocolate,why?,tasted awful asked for refund had to wait another 10 minutes for this no apology or nothing 1st and last experience will not...

Absolute gem. We found this place by chance and were so pleased we did. All the staff were lovely and they do 52 different homemade pies plus other things. Portions are huge and delicious. We tried 4 different ones and they were all gorgeous. We’re...

Excellent service and food. The place was heaving, but the staff, especially Joe were really attentive and helpful. Huge selection and I do believe I had the best steak pie I have ever had, although all my friends thought their choices were divine too. We...

Our first visit to The Piebald Inn and we weren’t disappointed. Both the food and service were excellent, especially Joe who went the extra mile to assist one of our party’s requests. We look forward to visiting again in the near future. Thank you to...

We stumbled across The piebald inn as it was just down the road from where we were staying. What a great find, 52 pies on offer and the hardest thing is choosing one! We both made our choice and as the title says, massive pies....

The pies were exactly as we remembered them fantastic, before the move to this location. Fantastic range of pie fillings and alternative meals all delivered hot and together. The whole group enjoyed their choice. Drawback although on our visit it wasn’t an issue but as...

We had our evening meal there last night. The pub itself is very warm and the staff were lovely. The pies were amazing, along with the chips and sides. Lovely and clean, just a lovely place altogether, will definitely be back

We stayed here for my husbands 50th birthday as he loves the east coast. The room we stayed in was immaculate and had everything you could need.The staff are so welcoming and accommodating, nothing is too much for them. The food is always amazing here...

This was our fourth visit over the last couple of years and it didn’t disappoint, it’s become our place to eat when we visit this coast. I’ve tried a different pie each time & last night was the Moroccan Barb lamb one. The meat was...

We were told about this place some years ago by my Father-In-Law. But never really venture up this way for a trip. After staying in Scarborough, we decided to make the trip to this pub for one of our evening meals. And I'm so glad...

You just have to visit this place. We have had one of the nicest meals in a long while. The pub has a lovely welcoming warm atmosphere, very dog friendly and excellent friendly, welcoming staff. The choice on the menu was vast, but the pies...

We come to the Piebald every year when we stay at The Bay in Filey - went last night for our pie treat and was as amazing as always! Beautiful pastry with lots of filling accompanied by fat tasty chips and the best mushy peas...

The. Best. Pies. Ever. I really don't get the people saying it was expensive or that they could cook better themselves or that they just wanted a "standard" pie. Ignore these reviews. The whole point of the pub is to serve a vast variety of...

There are 52 pies on the menu, a lot to choose from. The portions are large and a bit on the pricey side. There are some unusual fillings. The food is very tasty and the service friendly although we weren’t offered dessert or coffee. We...

Was excited to try this place. But the system for service was confusing. In the bar areas we had to Check in at the "reception" get seated. Once we had ordered we were told we would be taken to a different room once the food...

First time back to the Piebald since I last reviewed it in 2017 and am glad we went back there. The place has had a nice spruce up but still holds on to the nice friendly atmosphere. Very friendly attentive staff and the choice of...

We called in today for a drink and potentially a piece of takeaway pie. We perused the list of 52 pies, I can't knock them because I haven't tried them but some of the combinations seemed a bit wacky. The price for a piece of...

As locals we went for the first time as we don't eat out . As a liver transplant recipient I don't drink alcohol & neither does my partner , yet we always recommend them to friends & family as guests. None of these weird pies...

This was well run greated immediately shown to our reserved table. 3 staff we dealt with were very friendly. Very fast service, food was good and affordable will definitely visit again. Booking system was also easy and a nice email 24 hours before to say...

Amazing place to stay, rooms are very comfortable and well equipped. Food is spot on, I will be returning with friends and family. Staff are very pleasant and welcoming. I will highly recommend to everyone.

Lovely selection of pies, maybe a little pricey for some. Great you can pack up what you cant eat. Restaurant was very hot and noisy, not somewhere you would spend hours and hours.

If you like pies, and leaving a restaurant full this is for you. 52 pies on the menu both of ours (Cleveland Bay, and Wonky Donky) were excellent. Staff friendly service very efficient.

Super friendly and accommodating staff, nice atmosphere, welcomes kids and dogs. Huge tasty portions - we were stuffed - really Homemade products. Exceeded my expectations, so Thankyou!

We booked a one night bed & breakfast stay & also an evening meal in the restaurant. We were upgraded on arrival because a bigger more luxurious room was available. The room was fantastic, king-sized bed, all facilities expected, all immaculate. Staff welcoming & friendly....

Absolutely fantastic food. Pies to die for. Huge portions but you can have half and take the other half home! Excellent real ales and efficient, friendly and attentive staff.

great friendly place. staff were really good, especially the front of house guy. the pie board at the front is a good touch. dog friendly to. pies were great, good size portions and served with loads of veg. highly recommend and will be returning

We stayed at the Piebald inn yesterday, the room was fantastic, the staff were friendly and helpful at all times. We also ate our tea at the piebald, my pie was about the best I have ever had. My Friend had the 5 bean chilli...

THE BEST Pie I’ve ever eaten! Took my family for Saturday tea, the pub was warm, friendly, and welcoming. A great selection of proper ales and huge choice on the menu! Highly recommend if anyone’s in the area! Definitely be returning to eat more pie!

As before when we went, lovely smiley and helpful staff, and food was just delicious. I had the Mountain and Moorland veggie pie and it was so tasty. Very welcoming to dogs too our two small dachshunds were very settled and went to sleep under...

Visited this Inn during a recent stay in nearby Filey. Booked in advance (recommended as there was 12 of us!). Were met and seated promptly. Staff friendly and helpful. Had pre-ordered the pies in advance but were not hurried to have them served as cooked...

The pies are fantastic, we chose to have ours packed up, so we had half in the pub and took the other half home. So many to pies chose from, wished we lived closer. Stayed overnight in our camper, breakfast next morning was also very...

Excellent evening here, staff were incredibly friendly, food was excellent. The best pie we have ever eaten. We asked for a packup on one of the meals, (they cut your pie in half before serving and give you a box to take it home in)....

We enjoyed a lovely meal choice of pies was excellent We hadn’t booked but was accommodated with a table in the returaunt The young man and young lady who served us were so lovely and helpful Had a lovely evening on the last night of...

I had visited The Piebald earlier in the year with friends, on that occasion I had The Native Pony. It was so good that I then planned my whole 50th Birthday Celebrations around going back for another pie, let's be fair why would you not...

Absolutely lovely food and great service from Joe, very friendly and informative on the food selection and as a vegetarian it was a very good selection. A lot to offer for all dietary requirements 🩶🩶

We visited the Piebald Inn for a friends 50th Birthday, 12 plus of us plus 2 dogs descended upon the pub, and they were so accommodating, we were all seated together, our meals had been pre ordered and although they were very busy, they fit...

The pie and chips were lovely, vegtables a little watery for me. Service very good and very friendly staff. The pie was way too big for me and I ate far too much as didn't want to leave it due to the amount of money...

Stayed a night in this lovely pub, the room was large, contemporary and comfortable with a garden. We had everything we needed and more in the room it was lovely. We tucked into a pie each on the night, very filling and tasty! As was...

We stayed in the hotel for three nights bed and breakfast, and ate in the restaurant every night. The staff were great. The food at breakfast and dinner was lovely, hot, tasty, presented nicely, and promptly served. Room four is a beautiful garden room, with...

We had a lovely meal out for my sister’s 21st birthday. The place is cosy and welcoming and the staff are caring and they are more than happy to help. Thank you to Joe for making it extra special. We would recommend this place and...

Great food and friendly staff , stayed in a camper van in the car park, would go back .lots of choice

Pre-booked a dinner for 2 plus took our dog as well. So much choice regarding pies! Fun way in which the menu is shown by showing how much of a particular pie is left! The food was good, very large portions which you would expect...

Came for a late lunch, almost all the pies were available, so difficult to choose from the many delicious options. Enjoyed it all, home-made chunky chips and pastry just the right thickness. Friendly staff, and plenty of space for the dog.

Fabulous pies, we all had different ones and they were all great, very tasty, homemade chips, fresh veg. Staff were friendly and attentive, can’t wait to go back

Not cheap, but the pies are very full and tasty. Great value for money. The staff are all incredibly friendly and helpful. We had a great experience and will be returning next time we're in the area.

Unreal food , we all had a different pie and they were all scrummy! Only 5 minutes away from primrose valley and not full of flies. Great service , yummy food and full belly’s

We came for the food and left with a new favourite place to eat! The choice of 52 pies is incredible! I had The Dapple and it was absolutely amazing 🤤 fresh, home cooked, great portion size… I honestly can not complain about anything! The...

What a huge variety of pies! I had the Shetland Pony and it was so delicious. Cute little pub attached too, and great service. Joe was very friendly and helpful!

Taken me nearly fifty years to find the perfect pub and here it is. Great, knowledgeable and most importantly, friendly colleagues. Quality ales and belly busting pies - take home boxes provided. No arguments in our group, every one got a corner piece! Dogs welcomed...

Fabulous food and great service Thank you. No wonder you have rooms there - I need to lie down now!

What a fabulous place to visit, the staff were lovely the food was absolutely fantastic and the wine was gorgeous 😍 try the pies they are to die for!! We had such a brilliant night, camper van friendly and dog friendly 😊 🥰

Fabulous pie I had the messara and it was very tasty my daughter enjoyed her meal too. Service was prompt and friendly highly recommended

Stayed here last night in the carpark on the way home from an 11 day trip round Scotland ( been here before so made sure we ended our trip here) amazing as always, pies were fantastic even got a poochy pie for our dog and...

Absolutely unreal pies here… excellent service, really banging pies, nice beer garden to sit outside and enjoy a drink in. The restaurant is nice and big, air con was a life saver! I got the Welsh cob and it was absolutely next level. Honestly the...

The pies we had were excellent, of that there is no doubt. However, the meal left me feeling uncomfortable and bloated which I mentioned at the bar, to be met with the reaction that this was a standard thing for most customers. I fail to...

We can’t really understand the negative reviews because our meal was lovely and the staff were very friendly. Would definitely recommend and would definitely return.

We ordered our meal at 5.30 pm our condiments and crockery arrived immediately by 6.30 pm we was still waiting for our food both staff and the manageress passing our table multiple time never thought to ask us if we was ok at 6.35 I...

The vegetables where cold the pie was nothing special as it never came with a base the mash was very watery the gravy was like an oxo cube in a serving dish my wife's salad was not fresh at all the food for both of...

Visited solo , heard good reviews about the good, the food fid not disappoint but that thing with the red hair and tattoos over her arms needs to be sorting her attitude out towards customers. Very rude when I was asking how I pay and...