The Judge's Lodging Restaurant in York

This place is fantastic. Full of character as you'd expect from a building built in the 1700's. The staff are very polite and helpful. Although there is no parking on site, the car park is a 5min walk away with a discounted price.

A little gem in york! I visit the city a lot and have just found this venue. Really laid back and relaxing.Staff are lovely and keep the tables clean and tidy. Will definitely visit again.

Great location. Excellent staff, but my £50 discount code was impossible to use, despite 3 phone calls. Tainted our stay!😢

Fantástica comida Celebrando cumpleaños y aniversario de boda el personal era excelente que no podían hacer lo suficiente para nosotros el dormitorio era fabuloso solo vivimos bastante local, pero es un gran regalo! ¡Nuestro lugar favorito en York!

El peor almuerzo de domingo que he tenido. Mi amigo y yo vinimos para el almuerzo del domingo, estábamos esperando estándar de 5 estrellas como se describe. El asado era insípido, las verduras eran duras como la roca, ni siquiera podían cortar las chirivías. ¡Las ‘patatas asadas’ eran solo spuds hervidos! La carne de res era muy grasa y no agradable. Extremadamente decepcionante, podría haber hecho un almuerzo de domingo mucho más sabroso en casa. Literalmente solo carne y verduras hervidas en un plato con salsa acuosa insípida. Le dijimos a la camarera que no era agradable. Nuestra factura llegó pero no nos preguntaron cómo nos gustaría pagar y nadie volvió a nosotros con una máquina de tarjetas. Nos dirigimos a la caja, pagamos y nos fuimos insatisfechos y tan decepcionados.

Excellent service and great atmosphere

Just back from another fabulous stay at Judges Lodging, the hotel, staff and location are absolutely spot on

En general, después de un comienzo accidentado, esta terminó siendo la peor experiencia gastronómica que hemos tenido en nuestros muchos años de visitar York. La camarera que mostró nuestra fiesta de 4 a la mesa reservada fue muy agradable. Ella explicó que se quedaron sin un par de platos como ella nos entregó los menús. Ya que el Monu enumeró un excelente. 3 - curso Festivo Fayre opción de Navidad todos decidimos ir por eso. Cuando vinieron a tomar el pedido nos dijeron que la opción de Navidad tenía que ser pre-pedido por lo que no estaba disponible. Nos habían dado un menú que enumeraba las opciones para los 3 platos, y nos dijeron lo que no estaba disponible, así que después de haber hecho todas nuestras elecciones y luego nos dijeron que no podíamos tenerlo fue decepcionante ... la analogía que utilizamos fue, nos sentimos como gorriones que encontraron a alguien había sellado pegado alpiste en el interior del cristal de la ventana. Pedimos del menú regular y, aunque bueno en partes, la comida no era perfecta - chirivías en la ensalada eran tan duros que no eran comestibles, la lubina era sabrosa, pero tenía muy poco en el camino de la verdura, las patatas fritas eran como retales y la hamburguesa estaba un poco demasiado cocinado. Probablemente deberíamos haber hecho más de un problema de esto, pero no lo hicimos. Nos dieron el menú del desierto y le pedimos a la camarera que aclarara los detalles de la opción de panacota, que luego pedimos. Unos instantes más tarde, volvió a decir que no había panacota ni tarta de queso tampoco. Sentimos que la comida y el servicio no cumplieron con las expectativas, con opciones limitadas disponibles. El menú decía que un cargo por servicio del 10% se agregaría automáticamente a las fiestas de 6 pero el servicio era discrecional, así que nos pareció una propina si alrededor del 8% reflejaría el servicio y la experiencia que habíamos recibido Finalmente terminamos nuestra comida y pedimos nuestra factura... Llegó a £ 147. 75 para 4 personas, pero la camarera explicó que ya había configurado la máquina de tarjetas por £ 162. 50 , para incluir una tasa de servicio del 10 %. Explicamos que no estábamos satisfechos con un cargo del 10% por servicio y queríamos dividir la factura, así que pagamos £ 100 + £ 60 = £ 160. Eso representó un 8. 3% propina. Pagamos las £ 150, pero, cuando nos íbamos, el gerente nos respondió a gritos y nos dijo que todavía les debíamos £ 2. 50 ! Señalé que no era posible porque la factura era de 147 libras y habíamos pagado 160 libras, pero insistieron en que todavía debíamos 2 libras. 50 . Nos dimos cuenta de que exigían el cobro íntegro del 10 % de los servicios "discrecionales". Señalé que el menú decía que el cargo por servicio era discrecional y sentimos que la experiencia no había cumplido con nuestras expectativas. El gerente claramente no estaba contento y dijo que podía eliminar el cargo por servicio, pero en ese momento estábamos tan molestos por su actitud que tiramos £ 5 en la barra y nos fuimos jurando nunca volver. Hay mucho mejores restaurantes en York.

Resultó sin una reserva, fue afortunado de conseguir una mesa, buen servicio servicial en el bar. Muy servicial personal de espera. Comida pedida, así como dri adicional como todo lo que llegó relativamente rápido a pesar de que estaba bastante ocupado. La comida: Pedido en el menú festivo Cena de pavo asado. Lo que conseguí fue 1 chirivía pequeña, 3 trozos de zanahoria (sin cocinar) , 5 Brotes semi crudos, dos trozos pequeños de patata (piel) con un sabor un poco extraño. Cerdos en manta era en realidad dos piezas de 1 pulgada de chipolatas con un vago trozo de tocino. Gravy era ligeramente grasienta, pero tenía un buen sabor. ¡Sin relleno OMG! El pavo era agradable (una mezcla de carne blanca y marrón). En general muy caro tanto en términos de calidad como de cantidad - no volvería a pedir. Postre: Crema de frambuesa Brulee, se veía bien en el plato, pero era básicamente natilla líquida bajo la tapa de azúcar más delgada posible con 2 frambuesas frescas y un pequeño trozo de biscotti. La pregunta principal es... ¿pagarías 32 libras? 00 por la comida anterior? Mi amigo disfrutó de su vientre de cerdo estofado de sidra, pero estaba enormemente decepcionado con el pedazo de plástico (envoltura de filtros de cigarrillos) en su pinta de cerveza (aunque esto se intercambió rápidamente) Total de la compra 3 Pintas de Lager, 1 botella de Sauvignon Blanc, 2 Mains , 1 Postre £ 98 . 00 . No me malinterpretes, gran lugar, gran personal, mala comida (si tienes papilas gustativas que funcionan! )

Esta fue nuestra segunda visita a este restaurante. Nuestra visita anterior se estableció en un agradable comedor, la comida era buena y el personal amable. El dicho "nunca volver" era ciertamente aplicable a nuestra reciente visita. El comedor está ahora en un sótano, mal iluminado con un peldaño peligroso, bajo, sin marcar, el obstáculo final para navegar antes de entrar. Nos colocaron en la mesa 7 , junto a un armario que contenía equipos que requerían mantenimiento. Obviamente estaban esperando un trabajador, pero aún así nos colocaron allí, a pesar de que reservamos con 2 días de antelación. Nuestro almuerzo se arruinó por este trabajador emergiendo y desapareciendo durante nuestro almuerzo. Sus movimientos requerían que mi esposa tuviera que levantarse y mover su silla varias veces. Incluso él dijo que era un lugar ridículo para una mesa. El vino era bueno y servida a una temperatura apropiada. Nuestros entrantes; la sopa estaba bien excepto por la guarnición, un grumo de col rizada, apta para alimentación animal, pero una cuestión de gustos cuando se trata de consumo humano. El paté de caballa ahumada era pobre, servido en tostadas de masa madre, un crimen contra la cocina, con crema de rábano picante y sin rábano picante. No se suministró taladro neumático para cortar la tostada. El plato principal de "carne de vacuno cocinada lentamente Wellington", fue el descrito. El jus servido con esto era bueno. En general, el veredicto es que tuvimos una mala experiencia gastronómica. Como comensal habitual, me he curado de mi reincidencia, no volveré.

Thank you Judges for hosting our incredibly relaxed, professional and beautiful wedding. We booked Judges Lodging for our wedding breakfast and family celebrations. We had a very small wedding party of 25 guests. We had arranged a big party elsewhere on the night but wanted something intimate and relaxed throughout the day. We were quite set on having a very small ceremony and wanted to celebrate with close family with some lovely food in a beautiful setting. Judges really did fit the bill. We were able to book exclusive use of The Grey room as well as the Monkey room for a very small hire fee. Granted, organising the day had been a little tricky, communication was slow at times but we need not have worried. Tiegan was genuinely amazing and a credit to company. The way they set up and decorated the room was beautiful, we couldn’t have wished for it to be any better. Tiegan was also able to arrange for us all to have the 1711 menu which is what we were desperate for rather than the set wedding menu. The staff on the day were very lovely and attentive and kept our guests topped up throughout the afternoon. The food was exceptional and all of our guests thoroughly enjoyed it. The portions were huge, well cooked and very tasty. We were lucky to able to stay at the hotel on the night, once again the staff were lovely. The room was beautiful and breakfast the next day was delicious and much needed. We’re so pleased that we chose Judges Lodging for our wedding day. We wish the same could be said for the venue we chose to celebrate the night. Judges Lodging really did allow us to have the most perfect day. The staff were so lovely, the food was beautiful, the building is very special and we have wonderful memories to last forever.

My wife and I went here for a meal, for my birthday, on the recommendation of a friend. Wow, what an amazing place. From the outside, it has a really warm and enticing atmosphere that makes you want to go there for a drink. We booked in advance, and that is worth doing. The restaurant is located in the cellars of the old Judges Chambers, and this makes for a real quirky and cosy place. The staff were absolutely brilliant and nothing was too much trouble for them. The menu was making you want everything on it, but in the end, I settled for a meat platter for 2, then the shredded beef burger, and finally apple crumble and custard. All with a beautiful bottle of red wine. As it was my birthday, I was surprised by the chef with a plate of brownies with happy birthday on them. I will end this by saying that this has to be one of the nicest restaurants, with the most lovely staff I've been to in a while. I highly recommend anyone to go here, you will love it.

Stood at the bar for 15 minutes, constantly being ignored people getting served ahead of me. Another customer commented on it to me. Absolutely shocking service. Never again!

Really pleased with our stay and will return

Encantadora ubicación en la sección de York con una zona de estar al aire libre cubierta muy agradable en la que se puede sentar y ver el mundo pasar. Lo malo son las opciones de bebidas alcohólicas disponibles. Solo puedo suponer que el pub está dirigido por un abstemio, ya que en una ciudad con muchas microcervecerías para seleccionar estas bebidas alcohólicas insípidas es francamente criminal.

Stayed in a lodge type room, couldn't fault it and as centrally located as you can get

Great inside in a cold wet day , cosy and intimate. Great outside on a fine day ,lots of comfortable seating , heaters blankets too.

It was absolutely chucking it down with rain so we dashed here. However the bouncer on the door asked if we were eating or drinking? We said just a drink. Then he said sorry the place is full and refused us entry! Only two of us but yet wouldn’t let us in out of the pouring rain…Your loss!!!

Had a late lunch here. Roast of the day - excellent even if they had run out of roasties!

booked in advance lovely building very noisy place earlier on went to bar and was told to wait after being ignored for a while decided we would order a drink whilst we waited at the side of a very busy bar - shame that wasn't actually offered when we arrived... I think it was the manager who then served us (lady potentially eastern European) - did not want to put the drinks on the table 'as you don't have a table' so how could she do that. Not our problem / fault after waiting for 10 minutes. Her attitude was brusque / rude and did not reflect my expectations of a restaurant that was highly recommended to us by a local We eventually were put in a small conservatory area right at the back - was an OK spot with a good view of the 'said manager' having a heated discussion with another customer for a long time - boy he was not happy and it looked like a battle of wills food was good but small portion - may have just been my selection. Had the sea bream and boy was it tiny - placed on top of 1.5 new potatoes and the smallest amount of wilted spinach. Good job my appetite is not massive Had cheese board for pudding - looked good at first glance but the cheeses (esp the oak smoked cheddar and brie) weren't great quality and all cheeses had been chopped into 3 - to make them look more I guess...? It was OK but the cheese let it down.. e.g. brie very firm and not at room temperature / not tasty The other serving staff were brilliant - but the 'manager' totally let this place down. 100% task focussed with no thought to customers which in a customer facing place is bad news surely... You are completely lacking a front of house who looks after your bookings and customers customers. Its a busy bar but given your compettition in York you might want to up your game I wouldn't bother returning

I believe rooms in the main building would be far better value for money than the room I had at the rear terrace.

We ordered then staff had a get together and we were ignored for at least 5 minutes. When you are charging £25 for 2 glasses of wine be more aware of your customers. Definitely NOT returning

Was really excited to try this place for a spot of breakfast as we were staying in York for the weekend. We had made a booking and duly went into the reception area. Stood around for around 5 minutes, rang the bell, nothing. A housekeeper was walking through reception and asked if she could help and she said that we needed to go downstairs for breakfast. Would have been nice for a meet or greet at the point of entrance, but never mind... We then walked into the restaurant area, the woman serving had her back to us and just told us to pick a table. We did that and then a very pleasant young man took our order when another blonde haired woman accosted him about where we were sitting and whether we were guests. The altercation made us feel very uncomfortable as we had made a reservation and were paying guests. Both women were rude and had an air about them. They need to take a leaf out of their younger colleague's book on how to treat customers. A smile can go a long way - even half a smile would have been nice and some pleasantries. Service aside, the breakfast was excellent and very enjoyable. The service would put me off going again though - plenty of other amazing eateries in York to go to.

Really friendly staff. Varied menu. Food good quality and served with a smile, thank you. Knowledgeable long serving staff who were able to talk confidently about the hotel part of the business. Will definitely visit again if in York.

Had breakfast with fiends before our day in York and was first rate and the service from the delightful auger hope that's the correct spelling was brilliant all cooked to requirement nothing to much trouble will definitely go again

Sat at a table for 30 minutes and got no service. No one cleared the table from the previous users. No one offered us a menu. We even asked a waitress to take out order and after waiting a further 10 minutes we had to leave. Instead we went to Nicholson's around the corner who had much better customer service

Sat down outside with family last Wednesday lunchtime, the place was quite busy but by no means full, were ignored by waiting staff (we managed to collar one for a menu, which took a couple of goes). As we were being ignored, after ten minutes we decided to move to the inner circle bit at the front, & were ignored again (we managed to talk to a few different staff members who said someone would come over), but after twenty minutes of waiting & trying to make eye-contact (the waiting staff seemed to be excellent at avoiding this), we decided to leave it & go elswhere. A shame as the food (when it appeared from the kitchen for those lucky customers who weren't being ignored) looked good. Expected more from a city-centre restaurant.

Lovely setting with a good pint of Guinness.

At this price I expect better quality. We had the barrier-free room with a separate entrance. The room is nicely decorated and well equipped. But it wasn't completely clean. In addition, the entrance to the staff rooms is directly in front of the room and so you are not undisturbed and when we went to breakfast there were delivery boxes piled up in front of the entrance. The service is friendly but cold and distant. The breakfast wasn't good. The location is very good because it is close to the train station and centrally in the city. But that also means that it is not quiet at night. Here you could ensure better insulation of the windows, walls and doors. I didn't sleep a wink the second night. Because there's a club around the corner and nobody seems to mind drunk groups standing on the street and screaming. All night. In addition, the house is noisy and I can hear every step across the room. You could even hear the squeaking of the desk chair in the next room. There are plus points for the fact that we had yoghurt and crown flakes as well as to-go cups for coffee available because of our early departure.

Lovely boutique hotel with a lot of steps. No air-conditioning in the room. Very few staff all seemed to be working in the bar/ restaurant on the ground floor. Comfortable bed and well equipped bathroom...not a great view which was on to other bulidings

Stopped here for a couple of beers and a bite to eat on a sunny afternoon. We sat outside and watched the world go by. Good service and great beer. Very enjoyable.

Caesar salad is £15, £17 with chicken added. I ordered it with chicken, my mum without. Her salad was a lot of lettuce, one egg cut in half and some anchovies. When we ordered, we got asked if we wanted to remove the anchovies which would have left her with essentially nothing as a meal. No croutons, no parmesan, not even more than a single egg. Absolutely shocking for the price. I added the chicken which at least made it more of a meal, but it was very bland and quite fatty/textured

Friendly and helpful staff whilst having a drink for my Wife's 60th yesterday👍!

Excellent place to stay as so near York Minster, shops and the Shambles. Lovely room, superb extras and friendly staff.

Great place to stay had a great breakfast menu and evening drinks, no access for any vehicles including taxis, so will need to drop off at the top of the street on double yellows and walk luggage to the hotel, nearest car park is 10min walk through the park

Our room had a really uncomfortable bed. Myself and my partner did not sleep well at all for the 2 nights that we stayed. The mattress was sunken on one side and didn't give us the support we needed. We attended a family wedding, and the staff on the day were excellent. A special thank you to Bella, who looked after us and kept the children of our party entertained, we couldn't of asked for more at all. Bella is definitely a credit to the hotel, and deserves a payrise. The breakfast service wasn't the best. We waited some time for the table to be cleared from the previous customers, I then had to ask for the table to be cleared and then again to order our breakfast. The staff just need to be a bit more attentive, as they didn't realise that we were different people at the table. Overall it was a pleasant experience, but for the money we paid, I would have expected better service at breakfast time.

Very nice clean hotel with lovely comfy beds, great staff and a nice breakfast. Couldn't ask for more.

Unusual entrance, cellar bar. On entrance you are greeted with a bricked archway then into a more modern room. Large flag stones on the floor. Wheelchair accessable with room to manoeuvre. Staff were friendly and polite. Beer was good but a little expensive. Enjoyed my visit.

Lovely place to go for drinks and lovely food!

Although we have dined in the upstairs restaurant in the past, on both occasions we ate here during a recent visit to York we chose The Cellar Bar. The setting isn't as grand as upstairs but the food was delicious and the menu varied. The service was excellent even though they were very busy on one of the nights.

Really nice hotel in the heart of York. You are literally a 5-10 minute walk away from everything in the old city. Room was very nice (room 3, the doctors office) a coffee machine in the room stocked up with pods was a nice touch. Staff were fantastic and helpful, and the breakfast each morning was superb. Zero complaints. We will return.

We had only used the downstairs restaurant, I had pancakes I’m for breakfast it was 10/10 the staff were quick and attentive. Service, food taste and quality was 10/10. Zero complaints

Lovely hotel / restaurant / bar. We were downstairs in the casual dining bar area. Very atmospheric cellar type space. Beautiful area out front but a bit too cold for us tonight. George was super friendly and very efficient. Great service. We'll be back.

We have visited a few times previously but just for drinks. Deciding to eat in the cellar bar was a great decision! The food was excellent, and the portions were generous. Staff were friendly and very professional. The decor was cosy and sympathetic to the age of the building. Cannot praise this restaurant enough. We will definitely return for a meal when visiting York again.

Breath of fresh air in an overcrowded York. Nice place to take clients even on a weekend, a hidden gem. We had a sunny day so enjoyed a drink first in the courtyard opposite the old post office. Maybe the time of year but nice to sit outside in York without too many awful loud hen parties taking over the place. Classy & we noted dog friendly, too. The food was very nice & not your run of the mill pub food.

On arrival there was no one on reception, we had to ring bell 3 times before someone appeared from the depths below. We had booked a character room, Rm12, for one night stay which we discovered was on top floor at end of wing which meant being directed via a maze of stairs up narrow stairways to room. Room was less than described (double character?) We would class it as standard double in many other hotels. the wardrobe door would not close properly with one of the handles loose & only held in with a Philips screw. The bathroom was adequate with a jacuzzi bath & corner shower. The bath did not have any grab handles which would create problems for aged or persons with disabilities should they prefer a bath (my wife needed my assistance to get out of the bath), the plug was not operational (remote type plug with rotating handle) so there was a rubber plug supplied. The extractor fan was not working so we left window open for demisting plus ventilation. The tiling on the floor was missing grouting in quite a few places & what was there was grimy, the radiator had a bottom fitting loose exposing plasterboard behind. My wife visited reception cloaks which was unventilated and stale smelling & noted that systems difficult to flush, if at all, the hand washing facilities seemed to be timed to prevent excess water usage The entrance door handle/lock needs replacing as it is difficult to rotate & open the door. We didn't stay for evening meal as we preferred to eat out. Staff we met were pleasant but obviously not enough on hand. Overall the hotel is what it is, showing its age, but in need of a lot of minor maintenance. It is well placed in the centre of York for all attractions, & according to reception, is busy with full bookings for the coming week.

Brilliant restaurant. Perfect food - treat yourselves

Good lunch on small plates on offer and service was ok

Really excellent city centre small hotel. Lovely rooms, some with Minster views (which is worth the extra cost) and a peerless location.

Sat outside on a sunny night,food and service was excellent

We had our reception at the judges lodging, a beautiful, well taken care of building, in an amazing location a lovely 8mins away from the registry office through the museum garden. From the our first enquiry the staff were exceptional, we felt very welcomed and taken care of. Tegan, the wedding planner was outstanding. All aspects of the reception were considered and any anxiety was addressed quickly and professionally via email and phone. Generously, we were offered a free tasting menu, upgraded our room and offered our guests a discounted rate with here stay. We felt that everyone working at the Judges lodging put 110% from the general manager, reception, bar, cleaning and kitchen staff. The food on the day was delicious and service impeccable. We couldn’t recommend the Judges Lodgings enough.

I had hoped for so much better for my first trip to York and an evening out with work colleagues. I waited at the cellar bar for ages to be served while a team member folded napkins, ignoring me and discussing how many bookings there were. Another team member served somebody and disappeared, leaving me waiting for the only person who was already pulling two pints to serve me. When we sat down nobody came to see if we wanted menus so we helped ourselves. Eventually someone noticed us and took our order. I have to say the vegetarian offering is awful, I ended up with: flavourless red humous with dry pitta bread, hard fried courgette nuggets and a badly dressed side salad. My colleagues were all underwhelmed by their burgers and fries/greasy wedges. It’s not fun having to write reviews like this but our food was overpriced, bland and poorly presented food.

Paid a lot of money for a two-night stay. Thought we would get what was shown online (quaint, bespoke room with a lovely tub). Was led through the Cellar Bar to rooms out back; 5 feet from drinkers on terrace (no privacy at all), modern room, no Ambiance, shower-only, and a bathroom light that doesn't turn off and no door to block the light. Very disappointed with high price and expectations not met. Can't speak for the lovely looking rooms in the actual building. We had several meals at the Cellar Bar; excellent food and decent prices. Update: The door banging from the kitchen is all day. The exhaust fan is aimed straight at the Rosemary room - it's an awful smell when they are frying fish. The noisy smokers and Cellar patrons makes sleeping challenging. No luck until after 11 p.m. The courtyard foot traffic affords no privacy, so you are in a dark, closed down, room with little natural light. We are looking forward to going home tomorrow.

Nice and big room, very friendly and supportive staff.

The staff were friendly and accommodating, the location was great, the food was well presented and delicious, and the hotel room was spacious and comfortable with coffee, tea, hot chocolate and fresh milk available. Our room had a great view of York Minster.

We are a local group of friends who have eaten here a number of times. Today was the last. 2 of us ordered steak pie and were happy to wait the 25 minutes we were advised it would take. On arrival, one of us had a steak pie, the other a warmed up pork pie. I do not eat pork and luckily, cut open the pie before eating. I was offered an alternative but I refused the offer. My friends steak pie was only warm and too salty. My other friend had the small fish and chips which was a portion cut in half with barely cooked chips and soggy batter. This place will keep going as tourists will continue to eat here once. For us locals, there are many other places to take our custom on a regular basis.

Lovely place, old but nicely done out.

Amazing place . Great location close to all York has to offer

Only sat outside for a drink.really nice with some heaters at front if a bit chilly. Like most places in york you order from your table. Great place to sit back and watch the madness of the bank bar across the road

Great pub, we sat outside and ordered to our table from the QR code. Drinks came relatively quick. Nice friendly staff

My large fish was anything but large, I've been going to the judges lodgings for 40 years plusses and that meal I was sent was a descrace.

I want to visit York again just to stay here. Overwhelmingly one of the nicest hotels my wife and I have ever stayed in and the service was just top notch. I wouldn't stay in York without Judge's providing the bed. Best of the best! Food was pretty amazing as well

The decor inside is lovely. Food is average . Went because seafood paella was on menu which was ok

While one group was well served, the other waited for ages to get a menu, water and when asking for a wine list, they got that, the one with 70GBP upwards per bottle. Luckily the other group told us "hey, there is a drinks menu with wine around 35-40 GBP)... by the time they eventually stopped ignoring us, half of the dinner menu was not to be had anymore. The chocolate delice... well there was still enough dark chocalate to cover one but the other had to do without. If the restaurant (on a Friday) had been full, or if you could not calculate because there was no mandatory booking, then one might have understood. But with booking, how could your larder be half empty by 20h30? On a Friday? Really a pity, because we did get something to eat, just not our first choice, and that was delicious! So if you come, come early and bring some patience along. Then you dine well in wonderful rooms.

Loved this little gem when we arrived in York perfect place to sit back and watch the world go by, didn't have food but what we saw looked well presented I would be looking to stay here on my next visit to York as the location is perfect

A terrific little hotel in the centre of York. My partner and I stayed here for 2 nights in early April and we were thoroughly impressed. Our booking was unexpectedly upgraded to a “character room” on the second floor, facing the street directly above the entrance. The bed was large and comfy, and the beautifully designed bathroom featured an enormous bathtub as well as separate shower. The room overall was spacious, cosy, and spotlessly clean. And a complimentary G&T was a great way to be welcomed! Breakfasts (included) were great and all freshly cooked - you can choose from full Englishes, eggs Benedict etc as well as a continental selection. Throughout our stay, we were really impressed by how attentive and thorough the staff were, and when we asked about restaurants in town we got some fantastic recommendations from the team. We highly recommend this B&B right in the middle of old York. Thank you for a great stay!

Booked a table for drinks for a big party of 17 for an hour and a half, Judges lodgings were more than happy to help over email for this request.

Great spot for a drink whilst in York.

Excellent all round. Definitely recommend and will be back.

Chose because of its great location. Over-rated rooms. We stayed in the Clifton suite. No dressing table. Sink plug stuck so could not use. Rickety old bed with summer quilt too cold for March. There are no shelves in the bathroom, so it is difficult to place our wash bags. We ate in the hotel's 1711 restaurant, which was poor. We were given two meat hors d'oeuvres, I don't eat meat, so the waiter said he would replace one with an alternative, but it didn't arrive. The asparagus starter should have been in bearnaise sauce with a poached egg. It came in a prebaked pastry tart with goats cheese and mushroom? It lacked flavour, and the pastry was overcooked. We questioned it, and the waitress checked and apologied as the menu had not been updated! Then they did bring a vegetarian hors d'oeuvre. For mains, we had Sea Trout with Samphire and Jerusalem Artichoke, fish overcooked and sauce poor, there was a raw charred piece of leek too hard to eat. Wine expensive, but we chose a Barolo, so that was good. Service was not managed and run by young, inexperienced staff. It's disappointing for a restaurant that should have been fine dining.

Lovely location, beautiful hotel every one very helpful, but room we had at the side of hotel was not good, disturb early morning and late evening.

Popped in for a drink, nice decor in the cellar bar. Good service and we sat outside in the sun.. Very pleasant. Can't comment on the rooms or restaurant .

Went for lunch for my wife's birthday while staying in York. Food was Very Nice. We shared the Asian Platter. The Pouisson could have done with being portioned really. It was a bit fiddly and difficult to eat really. Having said that it was beautifully cooked. Lovely meal and good value for money.

Central location, amazing rooms, and great service! All staff were lovely and went above and beyond at check in. A surprise upgrade was the cherry on top.

Just called in for a drink for my friend birthday lovely place nice atmosphere and busy and nice staff

Arrived - checked in - Room was cold -= rang reception - told after a few attempts to get through to someone that we had to push a button and turn a knob ! had to ring again after 30 mins as room was still cold - again took a few attempts to get someone to answer the phone. was told someone would come down and check - he told us the heating was off and would be switched on and would be warm very soon. another 30 mins and radiator still cold - we were booked for a ghost walk and dinner at a local restaurant so we requested a replacement room - which turned out to be 3 floors up from courtyard level on the top floor and I have had a replacement hip and a recent shoulder operation. this was a double room for me and my son so he was not happy. We arrived back at the hotel around 9.30pm and settled to have a drink in the bar when we were urged to go back to our original room and that the heating was now working - so we finished our drinks hastily and went up to the top floor to pack up again and carry our cases back down to the courtyard. the room was warm and I ordered a bottle of wine as it was too much bother to go back to the bar again. I don't believe paying almost £200 was value for money for the room / service we received and when i told the guy on reception on checkout of my ordeal he wasn't sympathetic and proceeded to charge me for the wine with no reduction to the room rate for our considerable inconvenience - so not very happy at all.

Fabulous Hotel Amazing rooms Just so lovely

Good coffee and cake. Very comfortable.

Exceptional Hotel . Brilliantly located . Staff very accommodating.

sunday lunch - 2 small roast potatoes, 1 small parsnip,, 1 minuscule carrot, 1 cauliflower florets, 1 small yorkshire. beef ok not the greatest for £17

We were disappointed at our recent visit. We were seated and told to order at the bar, but we weren’t given any menus so we had to go and find some. The toasted teacake came with no butter or jam, which we had to ask for and then we had to ask for a knife, by this time the teacake was cold. The cheeseboards all contained different amounts of crackers and grapes that were well past their prime. We had to ask for cutlery which we finally got but were thrown on the table and we were certainly an inconvenience when we had to ask again for serviettes. On a plus note, the coffee was nice. A very disappointing experience.

Served by a lovely young man who took note of my allergies and checked with the kitchen, he left us with our menus in case i needed to change my choice, it was nice he left all our menus so as to not make me feel self-consciousness being the only one sat with a menu. A lady then appeared and tried to take our order, i explained the young man had gone to check with the kitchen, she then asked what i had ordered and upon telling her she was insistent nothing would have mustard in it, i explained veggie sausages often contain mustard but she was adamant theirs did not. Just as she had finished trying to convince me the young man returned confirming their sausages DID contain mustard. She was clearly annoyed and rather than apologise to me for an action that could KILL somebody she stormed off. We then heard her telling the young man off for leaving the menus, the way she continued to speak to him was totally unnecessary and to be honest pathetic, trying to make herself feel better for HER mistake. The venue is nice, the food was good, the price was as expected BUT the behaviour of this lady means we would not return nor would we recommend it. Some real allergy awareness is needed, some management training wouldnt go amiss either as speaking to staff in such a way is unacceptable and to do it withing hearing distance of customers is appalling.

Lovely greeting from staff and very well looked after, food was amazing and lovely and hot and good portions, we had a magician that came over to the table and he was absolute amazing and made the evening! On the downside tho didn’t like one of the waiters who was working for Judges, he didn’t serve our table but recognised him from the Owner of the Algarve Restaurant, very arrogant, rude obnoxious man and couldn’t believe he was working at Judges and pray that he doesn’t bring down the reputation of Judges as such an amazing restaurant and all round pleasure to dine in. My advice, get rid of him he is bad news as we even witnessed him upsetting the staff and was also rude Steve the Magician. We had a bad experience with him at the Algarve Restaurant in Potters Bar and so have many others so been warned don’t be filled by him! Thank u ❤️

We came on the 15th November for my daughters 21st Birthday. I feel its trying be something it's never going to be , it's extremely expensive for what you get . The food was cold and was served at different times (really confusing). My venison carpachio wasn't thin and was too fridge cold and black garlic purree was a sour and grey . French onion soup greasy and over season and no cheese croute served . The duck main was cold and under cooked and the cabbage parcel was inedible. The food looks like the chef as just copied from a book and his not capable of executing it . There is much better places about for the same price range . Sadly we won't return.. Service was OK but very nervous

Cold food, no sign of chef to apologise. Front of house staff struggling to cope and hung out to dry by chef and management.

Totally terrible meal. Cold food, cold plates, staff unable to cope. How this restaurant has acquired the accolades it has...is beyond me.

We have eaten here many times. All have been really nice. The restaurant system has changed. Unless you book the 1711 you are literally sat in the bar with people drinking around you which was very noisy. The staff however kindly asked if we would like to move to the conservatory as it was quieter which we did. We ordered our food, my husband ordered a burger, unfortunately this arrived raw. We called over the waiter who immediately apologised and took it back to the kitchen. I had finished my meal (which was very nice) long before his came back. When it did come back it was very dry. The waiter couldn’t of been nicer, he took the price of his meal off the bill and also offered us another drink on the house. Quite a disappointing night apart from the lovely waiter who is a credit to this establishment.

Given the glowing articles about the new chef @ 1711 and the exciting 'fusion' fare on offer, we were gobsmackingly disappointed. From the flat (on tap) Coke, horrible Malbec and French Onion soup which more closely resembled cheesy salt water, to the overcooked scallops, we should have foreseen the disaster heading our way.....the 'signature' ox cheek main bordered on inedible and the seafood risotto was lacklustre, small in volume, cold and noticeably absent of seafood - apart from a very unappetising octopus tentacle strewn over the top. It's been a while since I've sent food back, but once told the Chef couldn't even have been bothered to be in attendance at Friday night service, it made sense that the restaurant was completely empty. A lovely Russian waitress was our only saving grace but WOW - the kitchen staff should feel utterly mortified at sending out that food. And at £28.50 on average for a main course it's a costly error to make. WALK ON BY I SAY ;(

We enjoyed catching up with old friends over lunch here. The young waitress was charming and we were well looked after. We could not however get over the cost of £13 .50 for a large glass of red wine - not the best quality I hasten to add! Surely this is well overpriced?!

Went for lunch in the Cellar Bar and had a wonderful experience. The food was excellent and the service provided by Sam enhanced the whole experience. She was professional, courteous and above all very friendly. We have been to Judge's Lodging numerous times, usually for lunch. We sit outside if the weather is nice but, if not, the Cellar Bar provides a very pleasant atmosphere and we have never been disappointed.

This evening, my sister and I enjoyed an excellent meal (a feast really), at the Judge's Lodging restaurant. We found a quiet, comfortable table in the back. The starters we chose: tempura prawns and camembert with flatbread were absolutely delicious. Potato soup for the next course was a perfect way to warm ourselves from the cool fall weather and the entree we chose was the steak, Thawaites ale, and mushroom pie with seasonal vegetables and chive mashed potatoes. The entire dish was cooked and paired to perfection. The only thing better than the food was the service! A special thank you to our wait staff, Connor T., who was incredibly attentive and wonderful to chat with. We would highly suggest stopping by if you are in York. We plan to come back every time we're in town.

Family meal, ordered two starters haloumi fries good portion also the beetroot falafal, embarrassing size of four pieces for £7.50. Chicken bugger not nice, small fish and chips average the steak and ale was good. Service sadly wasn't great, had to chase them up to pay the bill. All in all, a miss for us, with so many places to eat in York we wouldn't go back.

Ordered the chicken bites with fries for my son and the chicken was extremely overdone as were the chips. The chips were also overcooked on the dishes ordered by my wife and I. As a result, after trying one he couldn’t eat any more. Why on earth did the chef allow these out of the kitchen?Shame really as we’ve eaten here before but sadly won’t be going in again.

Not the best experience, we had to ask for the table to be wiped, the young lady behind the bar was VERY rude, " I haven't time to wipe tables, " it's ok we will do it, she slamed through the doors and literally through the cloth, adding that she doesn't get paid to do it. We wiped it ourselves. Prior to this we ordered several drinks one being a bitter lemon, the barmaid didn't know what it was. however the young man was very friendly and quick to clear glasses.

Absolutely gorgeous food and wonderful staff and service. We had an amazing meal in the conservatory where there was room for our dog to be with us without him being in the way.

We had a fabulous meal in the Cellar bar. The steak was incredible. We also had fantastic service from our waitress Holly who was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be coming here again on our next trip to York.

Amazing food, clearly prepared with passion. Presentation, taste, quantity and service where exceptional. Oh and the room is grand, you instantly feel special! I'll highly recommend. I had the ox cheek and scallops can't wait to go back again. I'll highly recommend.

Friends visiting York from overseas wanted to get together for a birthday celebration and a long overdue reunion. There were 10 of us including a child under 10 and a pregnant lady. We were all staying locally and needed a central point to have dinner....

I had a lovely time here visiting with my friends. Our server Aga was super attentive and had a fantastic sense of humour. Her recommendations were amazing as both mine and my friends food was delicious. Nothing was ever too much trouble and she truly...

Our Sunday dinner of Yorkshire pudding, roast and vegetables was wonderful. Well worth the price. The service was also very good. Theo, our waiter, was friendly and very professional. He was prompt with taking our order and our food was delivered in good time. Highly...