The Hearty Goodfellow in Newark and Sherwood - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The food we all had was great . It was well cooked and a competitive price for Southwell . The only thing that lets it down is it’s not a friendly atmosphere as it used to be . The staff aren’t very chatty but not unfriendly .

Sat down outside in the beer garden for Sunday lunch, staff were lovely and friendly and very attentive. Food was spot on, best Sunday roast I’ve had in a long time! But the best thing really was the outdoor space, kids loved it, the whole garden is fenced off with a good gate so parents can relax. We are not local but we will absolutely be back!! Thank you!

This pub has the nicest chicken fajitas I have ever had and my veggie partner, who normally would be scathing, highly praised the vegetable lasagna. The bar staff were lovely, friendly and helpful - thank you for a very enjoyable evening.

A real gem in the heart of Southwell. Met by the very friendly Landlord who guided us to our table and advised on food choices for the day. The pub was immaculate , the decor relaxing and inviting and comfortably warm on a very cold day. Good qhaulity wine , not the usual vinegar, and the food was very nice. All staff were very pleasant and well presented. No one said "there you go " when the food was presented so one the whole well done to everyone at The Hearty Goodfellow We will be back for sure

Went in the Hearty for a quick drink after a walk, went to bar and started to order the drinks. We went to sit at a table in the corner which did say DEB 5.00, this was 4.30 sat down and a minute later the landlord shot over and rudely said that we can’t sit there as the table was booked. This upset our son who has learning difficulties and he ran out the pub. As of 5:00 when we left the table was still empty. This was absolutely disgusting and we will not be going to the Hearty again!

We stopped here for lunch on our way to York. We were warmly greeted when we walked in which is always nice 😊 We were directed to table options. Nice fire bursted to the welcome. An extensive menu so we were spoilt for choice. We opted for Brie and bacon baguette and fish finger baguette with the most delicious chips I have had 😋 Good sized portions and the food was delivered to us quickly and really good quality. We would definitely recommend The Goodfellow 👍🏻

Warm and friendly little pub. Great atmosphere, lovely staff. Excellent service, beautiful menu with lots of varied choices. Would definitely be returning.

Went for a meal here before going to Southwell Minster. It is a lovely place, with friendly staff and excellent food. Will definitely return if in the area again.

Six of us met here for lunch, in very pretty Southwell, which has a spectacular Minster. The real ale choice was good, matched by a lunch menu with several attractive options (including a two-courser), from which the scampi was a firm favorite. The staff were both friendly and attentive and based on the bill, it was very good value for what we consumed.

When I called to reserve an early (5pm) table, the young lady who answered was very pleasant On arrival, we ordered Steak & Ale pie Gammon Sea Bass All meals were delivered quickly, arrived piping hot, were well presented and very enjoyable My meal was Sea Bass, served on ratatouille with asparagus. The sea bass was a generous size, plentiful tasty ratatouille and perfectly cooked asparagus The gammon was served with a 1/6 wedge of fresh pineapple, a pleasant departure from a tinned pineapple ring Our friend enjoyed his pie & mash The pub was pleasantly decorated, smart and clean. Our opinion was the Hearty Goodfellow was a good find and we would eat there again

Great spot for meeting friends and having a good meal. We were visiting Southwell for the first time and catching up with some friends for dinner...we really enjoyed our evening in the pub.

A nice friendly welcome from the Staff Good selection choices on the Menu Great service Delicious Food served perfectly hot Timely service We had the Gammon and Fish and Chips Spotlessly clean throughout the establishment and ladies loos very pretty Recommend 100%

A lovely pub with a fabulous looking garden. I had an evening meal with my two children aged 11-13. The staff were very attentive and the food pretty good for the price we paid which was very reasonable, £48 for three main courses, two puddings and two drinks. If I’m being really picky I’d say the burger was slightly over cooked and the garlic bread not very buttery or garlicky. That said, the apricot crumble was delicious and the Pinot Grigio excellent. I would visit again.

Three of us popped in for a quick meal due to having to catch a train. The girl behind the bar was on her own and the pub was quite busy. She was so friendly and helpful and didn’t get flustered. Service was very quick and food arrived under ten minutes. We had ham and egg and a fish finger baguette. The ham was thick cut, eggs done to perfection and the chips were amazing. The fish finger baguette was lovely. Freshly baked baguette and it was proper fish in batter. We didn’t have time for a pudding and the lovely girl behind the bar suggested we took them with us. She knew we were short of time and she quickly arranged this. The puddings came with custard and when we reheated them they were delicious. I’m sorry we never got the girls name behind the bar but want the owners to know that she is such an asset and worked extremely hard to make sure everyone was happy. We will definitely be back.

Just wanted some good food and a good atmosphere and we found it. Great little pub with a huge beer garden too. Loads of people but didn’t seem packed. Staff were friendly and welcoming and food was delicious….. all food eaten which doesn’t normally happen with us. Just a great relaxing couple of hours Prices were reasonable too

Perfect well kept beer. Top quality food. Excellent staff service with a lovely pub atmosphere . I’ll be back

We met up here for a family meal as it was central for us all, though still quite a drive for each of us. Really looked forward to it after visiting a year ago. The food was fantastic and the waitresses were lovely - very friendly and made us most welcome. Alas I cannot say that about the landlord who made me feel uncomfortable as soon as I walked in and said we had a booking for 12 people. He insisted it was 11 people - ok so we made a mistake but surely one more to fit in wasn't a huge deal, especially as the pub wasn't busy? The tables had not even been set up ready for us and three of the group were very young children so I didn't see it was an issue. Could he not have just said "oh the more the merrier, come in, welcome!"? NO! He made me feel quite stupid and he was definitely not impressed when we wanted to pay in separate groups at the end of the meal! We have done this many times with no problem. The standard of food at a place like this is an important factor as is the service and this was faultless BUT a landlord who makes you feel like an inconvenience is something that has put every one of us off from visiting again! Customer service means a lot and, if it is lacking, people will just go elsewhere. Please make your customers welcome Mr Landlord because they are your livelihood.

It was not the best experience for me and my family, who haven't seen one another for a long time. A place where we wanted to meet as it was central for us all, coming from different places. Firstly, the landlord very rudely said to my step mum it was only booked for 11 and there were 12 of us, ok our mistake, but wow can you seriously not accommodate for 1 more?! This initially made us feel very unwelcome. There was no welcome, nor was there any friendliness from him. He's supposed to be the landlord?!! The waitresses are an absolute credit to you; they were more than accommodating and couldn't do enough to make sure we were looked after and got what we wanted. Why they want to work for such an unpleasant landlord is beyond me. When it came to paying, we wanted to pay separately, as we were all separate families.. This isn't something that is new, is it?! Well, the landlord pretty much made us feel like such a burden for this and even had the audacity to speak to the poor waitresses awfully, saying they were messing the till up.. they did an absolutely amazing job and eventually got all of our money!!! Does he not know there's a living crisis? There was no thank you from him, or thanks for coming. We WILL NOT return. Disgusting customer service. Amazing waitresses and food, though!

3 course lunch just under £15...was amazing we will travel in future to have lunch here..had a takeaway aswell equally as good

Last Sunday,18th June, members of the family came over for fathers day and we decided to have lunch together. We phoned the Hearty Good Fellow and arranged to collect a number of caverys with beef and one with beef and pork. We have had takeaway carverys from other places before but all I can say of these are Wow!! If you are looking for a takeaway carvery that is piping hot and packed with incredible roast potatoes, various tasty veg, large Yorkshire pudding,creamy mash and tasty gravy then look no further. Everyone was of the same opinion, these meals were incredible value for money. On the following thursday we had takeaways from the lunch menu. Steak and ale pie, fish and chips and a couple of the Hearty burgers. All extremely tasty and up to a very high standard. The burgers have to be seen to believed, absolutely massive. If you are in Southwell and feeling peckish, do yourself a big favour and try out the Hearty. You will not be disappointed.

We booked for 24 members of a visiting choir on a Saturday evening and we were delighted with the food quality and service. We couldn’t fault it. Thank you so much for a great evening.

At the Hearty Goodfellow today for a music course in their function room so decided to have some lunch beforehand. Delicious sandwich (posh sausage baguette) and great service. Also the garden looks like a great play area for kids so will be back to try that out.

A very warm welcome. Excellent choice of food with a selection of 3 differing menus. Food was of very high quality and tasty. Service was friendly and efficient. I would highly recomend. Thank you.

In Southwell for a visiting choir trip to the Minister and had a meal with my husband and another choir member. Welcome was very warm and friendly. Menu varied and all sounded delicious. We chose gammon, big and a small plate. Extremely tasty and well...

Called on off chance to eat today. Restaurant very busy, always a good sign, but were managed to get somewhere to eat. The two young ladies that welcomed us were lovely and friendly and a credit to the establishment. As it was a Sunday, it...

My wife and I meet up with family once a month at different pubs around Newark and without a doubt this was the best we have had. Great food, great selection of drinks, outstanding staff and very competitive pricing. We will definitely go again next...

I visited with a group of friends. The food and the service were exceptional. Very good quality and reasonably priced

We dined here with friends yesterday evening. The menu is quite short and standard Pub food , but it was very well executed and the quality was very good. We had steak and ale pies, gammon steak and sea bream, all of which were delicious....

The Hearty Goodfellow in Southwell is a lovely and atmospheric pub. We had Sunday lunch - the beef was lovely and the vege, roast potatoes, etc were just as nice. We finished up with rhubarb crumble, yum. Only one problem: the prices quoted on the...

This was our first visit to the Hearty for a while and we wondered how it would be under new management . We had a delicious lunch (the steak pie was especially tasty) which was nicely presented . Staff were friendly and helpful. It was...

Food was amazing and as for the venue...it has beautiful decor, great hosting and facilities that smell like a spa 😉- every little detail is taken care of here. Wonderful and friendly - highly recommended!!!

Excellent food, between us we had Whitby scampi and an halloumi burger, they were both delicious, wine was good, friendly efficient staff

Went in for Father’s Day and honestly had just a lovely time. Pubs, increasingly so, can be a little hit-or-miss these days but we were made to feel welcome. Had a good chat and a laugh with ever-so welcoming landlady, Lisa. Decor is cosy, though...

Four of us went for a Birthday lunch for my husband and we were very let down. two of us had small fish and chips one had large, we couldnt tell the difference all were small. Fish was dreadful, none of us could tell what...

This is a friendly, well-run pub. We chose it for Sunday lunch. The sign outside says local food, and the cooking followed through on that. It was good quality, really enjoyable and all home made. Very good indeed, and excellent value. I can imagine coming...

We enjoyed a drink in this traditional and comfortable pub which was served by friendly and welcoming staff. It looks like the large beer garden at the rear is family friendly and a great place for a summertime tipple.

Not bad little pub not a bad pint aswell only thing is the pub closes at 3pm-4pm so they throw u out but what is the point ?????? its 2022

After visiting the local National Trust workhouse today (17th February) we dropped in at the highly rated Hearty Goodfellow for dinner. Can't really comment on the beer as I was driving. Service was good. As we sat down we got presented with the menu and...

Visited today for 2nd time , on our wedding anniversary. Had a great meal at lunchtime, the homemade pie both the chicken and Steak are out of this world. Excellent friendly service, warm and friendly pub. A great British pub to be proud of.

Called in with two dogs for Sunday lunch …no problem seated in 15 mins and roast beef was top notch …will call in again as daughter at uni campus there

Celebrating our 50th wedding anniversary was made all the more special by the Goodfellow’s tasty food and wonderful staff (a shout out for Lauren). 9 months ago we booked Alchemilla in town for this celebration only to be let down the night before! The friendly...

This pub has a good choice of food and drink. I suppose, more importantly, you get a very friendly welcome and proper old fashioned service. They made me a superb BLT sandwich whilst the kitchen was closed!!! Very kind. Visit this pub, the whole experience...

We thought that we would treat the family to an evening meal here and the food was very good, well presented, tasty and fairly priced, as were the drinks. However, the front of house staff provided a very disappointing standard of service. We waited 35...

This is the second time I’ve eaten in the Hearty Good Fellow and the friendly staff make you feel so welcome as soon as you walk through the door . Yesterday evening I had the Olive with dips starter which was large enough for a...

Sincere thanks to the staff at the Hearty Good Fellow from one who struggles to eat. They proved most sympathetic and very helpful. The landlady/chef went “above and beyond” to ensure that I was fed appropriately. All proved most welcoming at the Good Fellow which...

We visited Hearty Goodfellows as we in the area for a weekend with friends. We honestly had the best food and service- top quality. The small but quirky pub had a lovely atmosphere and the landlady and bar staff made us all feel so welcome....

Lovely family run pub. I visited for dinner and a pint several days in a row when staying in Southwell to see family. Great draught beer selection. Food good honest pub fare - beef pie, steak and Stilton salad and chicken caeser salad all very...

Sunday 31st October - great Halloween themed get together for lunchtime roast - Nutroast for us veggies was fab!! Thanks to all staff who accommodated us and looked after us in the cosy function room.

The landlady was very welcoming to all, despite multi-tasking on all fronts, a busy pub. A great atmosphere for families and all generations. The plateful of food was piping hot and can only imagine that her husband in the kitchen was juggling and multi-tasking too...

Visited today as part of Bramley Apple 2021 Festival. Had the pork and dauphinois potatoes which was delicious followed by bramley apple crumble and custard. The staff were very friendly and welcoming. Would recommend.

On arrival I sat down and my arms stuck to the sticky table. One of our party ordered steak well done which was cooked medium at best and arrived 10 minutes after the other meals . I ordered Southern fried chicken burger which consisted of...

After being in Southwell for a few months I stumbled across this pub in which I was welcomed with open arms the girls behind the bar were amazing and the food was great! Thanks a lot. I will be back.

Took friends for an evening meal and all four had different dishes! All were very good and the beer was excellent. Good , friendly service and a nice atmosphere! Will go again!

I don't like to put negative comments but so sorry to say the meal I had was terrible. I had the beef oinion pie... Something was very amiss with the taste. Tasted like a sweet and beef was over done. I can honestly say it...

We were staying locally in a B & B We had no car till it was returned to us the next day we asked a local who recommended the Piano but it was fully booked We walked to the Hearty Goodfellow It was not busy...

Myself and a friend decided at the last minute to eat out for a change and that was fairly local. I booked the reservation and found out about their current Covid-19 restrictions, which they advised me on at lunchtime for that evening. No problems with...

We had dinner there on a Sunday evening with my son and his girlfriend who are students at Brackenhurst and spent the night there in my friend's motorhome. What a fantastic find. The pub is in the quieter part of town and it is absolutely...

We booked in for Sunday Lunch and we’re able to sit outdoors The staff were friendly and amenable . The food was hot and served quickly I prefer to add my own gravy but it arrived with gravy already on . Maybe because of Covid...

We decided to start our walkabout in reverse starting at the bottom of the village and so glad we did. Been to Southwell a few times but always stuck to the main street.but Southwell has more to offer,The Hearty Goodfellow is a traditional pub in...

Very enjoyable time spent with group of pals. Staff looked after us well setting us up to watch the football

Excellent place with great staff and an even better pint. Fish and chips are amazing and the pints are even better

We had the best pub roast dinner we had ever had. My husband had pork which was really tender and I had a gorgeous nut roast. They came with lots of veg, superb roast potatoes, batter puddings and gravy. We couldn’t fault it. The staff...

Went for Sunday lunch for the second time in 2 weeks, lovely home cooked food and great value, All the staff are friendly and Landlord and Landlady are very welcoming and you get a great pint too ! What’s lovely is our dogs are welcomed...

Compliments to the chef the fish and chips was delicious! Highly recommend. Lovely venue, definitely would visit again

I hadn’t seen my family since xmas so when they came up to visit the idea of going to a new pub for a meal was suggested and the hearty goodfellow was chosen. Inside was empty (warm outside) so we had the freedom to sit...

We sat outside on a sunny night and had fish and chips. The food was great and Lisa made us feel welcome. Food and drinks was ordered and payed for from your phone . Will be back on another sunny evening .

The trip to the hearty was our first since lockdown lifted. Despite it being a big change Lisa and the team had adapted well. The table service and app ordering worked really well and beats standing at a crowded bar. The drinks all arrived quickly...

Recently visited the hearty. Had a very rude welcoming upon arrival, seemed instantly like we weren’t welcome. After ordering fish & chips we were shocked at the cutlery we were given. A wooden spoon and a wooden knife! When you pay £11 you would expect...

Had a takeaway from here in August, my daughter had scampi and I had fish & chips which we shared. The scampi was about the best we’ve ever had, cooked perfectly. The food was really good quality and good arrangements for phoning through and collecting.

We were doing a treasure trails map and it took us past this pub so we stopped in the rules were great and straight forward the signs were helpful and the staff were greatWe followed the 1 way system and due to the lovely weather we sat outside in the beer garden we ordered a BLT, a fish finger sandwich and a kids sausage and mash all were very nice and very filling we happily sat having a drink after whilst our son played on the climbing frame.Very nice and we felt very safe thankyou

Lisa White, Will & Hannah, pubs closed since March & you’ve nailed it!!! Most haven’t opened yet but you were ready & organised! Thanks to all your team, friendly as always, a great job done, we’ve felt happy, safe, had a great time 😊

Situated in the heart of Southwell is this wonderful Inn.It was my fist visit, and I was made to feel extremely welcome.I had a very tasty bar snack and washed down with a very well kept pint.The place was cosy and well maintained.

Me and the family enjoyed a beautiful Sunday lunch which cheered us all up after our walk in the cold weather. Will definitely be coming back.

Although its a long while since I went here I remember it very well since although the bar was very busy since it was a saturday evening we still got well looked after. There were 9 of us and yet all the meals for both courses all arrived at the same time even though it was the same people doing the bar serving and the food serving. All the poeple were extremely polite and were willing to change things from the menu for us. The food and price was also very good, We'll be back there in October for sure.

When you walk in the family atmosphere hits you. The owner and her mum were sat planning their new podcast (Middlemarsh)! Has excellent fish and chips with mushy garden peas and best tartare sauce I have ever tasted. Can't wait to go back!

Nice pub with plenty of parking, great food and staff all very welcoming and friendly. Also great offers on meals. Would definately visit again if in the area

Lisa and Will, thank you for the lovely evening on 31 December , the food was amazing and service excellent again....!!!!

I went here today for Boxing Day as part of a large party. I won’t be eating here again. My daughters starter came and it wasn’t vegan even though it had been labelled vegan on the menu. I would have been understanding about this as accidents happen especially at busy times so it would have been fine apart from the fact that the staff member I spoke to was completely unapologetic and dismissive. He was quite rude, maybe if it had of been an allergy or religious reasons he would have taken it more seriously but my daughter feels strongly about the reasons she is vegan and surely this should be respected too. Then despite raising this the main course that had also been labelled vegan on the menu came and this again wasn’t vegan. Again not even an apology. I wouldn’t go here again.

Had a lovely Sunday roast today after a visit to the Cathedral. The service and the atmosphere was great with a good choice of food. Even better was the availability of both a gluten free roast and gluten free treacle sponge pudding!!

What an amazing little find this was to meet up with family . perfect in every way. Landlady one of the best, staff very pleasant food amazing.

Called in for lunch on Fri 29th Nov. We had our dog with us and were told we could sit anywhere! The lady behind the bar & serving meals was lovely, friendly and polite. The beer is well kept (Everards Tiger & Titanic Plum Porter). We opted for the lunch deal which is a starter and a main for £12.95. I had a large bowl of crispy whitebait with homemade tartare sauce and a wonderful steak pie which must have been made with suet it was so rich and moist. It came with proper chips and red cabbage which was a welcome change. I didn't eat for the rest of the day as I was so full and people who know me know this doesn't happen often! My husband had deep fried brie followed by a homemade burger and chips which looked fabulous and he said was full of flavour. We would definitely visit again next time we're in the area. Thank you!

Visited and used a private room at the rear as a ‘night before the wedding’ get together Nice bar selection friendly staff and lovely food

Our daughter was away so popped in for Sunday Lunch Today as neither of us could be bothered to cook ! We planned to go as a couple but when we arrived two of friends and their children were there so we joined there table ! We all loved the food 5 of us had fish and chips my mate being GF said it’s the place place in Southwell for Gluten Free Fish and chips she highly recommends! The fish was top notch and fresh with beautiful hand cooked chips and proper old fashioned mushy peas ! My husband had a traditional Lamb Sunday dinner and proclaimed it was delicious well cooked and “Hearty” no pun intended ! The staff who served us were lovely xx Well done guys will be back soon !!

We went to the Hearty for a family meal, the food and staff were amazing. We had a Fillet Steak and Fish and Chips (GF) all great value..,

I was taking part in a service at Southwell Minster, and during a break, myself, my husband and our two daughters were looking for a place to have some lunch. We tried The Hearty Goodfellow as it has a car park, and as I am currently walking with a stick, we need to park near to the restaurant. When we enquired if they had a table, the owner, Lisa, informed us that they were full, but that she really didn't want to turn us away, so she would see what she could do. Seeing my stick, she gave me a chair to sit on while she found us a table, and a short while later she came back to us and said that if it was ok with us, she was going to let us use the function room, and one of the waitresses took us to it. We had the whole room to ourselves, and it was a beautiful room with a nautical theme, and lots of pictures on the walls. We were very well looked after by the staff, the food was absolutely delicious, and upon leaving, Lisa gave us all a free pot of ice cream to enjoy during the service, which was also delicious. They really couldn't do enough for us, and we shall certainly be coming back and recommending The Hearty Goodfellow to friends and family. A huge thanks to Lisa and her staff for a wonderful experience.

We were guests of the owner today for Sunday lunch and it was absolutely gorgeous.

My husband and I ate here for two nights while we were visiting Newark Antiques Fair on 9 and 10 October.

The Hearty Sole function room and pub bar,Really friendly staff, great party for friends, warm and welcoming and good food.

Just back from the Hearty Goodfellow!! Very busy and thanks to Lisa, Will & their team a fantastic meal. The best Sunday roast in Southwell!

Terry and Ina had an unforgettable visit with a brilliant welcome from Lisa and the staff. Sunday lunch was outstanding. Generous portions, fresh produce and the staff were very welcoming. Can't wait to go again. Thankyou to Lisa and the staff. Hope to see you very soon.

Love this pub as it is full of character & plenty of tables outside if you fancy dining outdoors.

Finishing of the last night of our holiday and what a great meal we had here , food was excellent the home made pies and mussels a must . The land lady was very attentive to our needs and couldn’t be more obliging and also made our dogs very welcome . A group of local ladies made us feel welcome too a gem of a find and well recommended.

Seay lunch had to wait over an hour for our meals after having ordered. And that was just for a small party of 4. Once the food arrived it was very tasty and hot but the wait was far too long. You got the impression they had taken on too many people for meals than they could handle. Too slow and we were not kept up to date as to why there was such a delay. We were very very disappointed as this has not been a problem in the past also the gents washroom was appalling unclean especially the hand basin. You got the impression that this had not been deep cleaned for some time. I do not normally complain but this was unacceptable again staff have not kept on top of the cleanliness with is unforgivable in my opinion. We will not be returning anytime soon.

I would give this place 0 if I could. Service is the worst I have ever experienced. Waited nearly 2 hours for food with so little communication. Staff seemed to actively avoid us. Would never return. Shocking

Good location, fairly large car park with nice beer garden. Very friendly welcoming staff and fish n chips pretty good.

The food looked nice, but we were just in for drinks. Nice seating area outside, friendly staff, inexpensive snacks menu looked good value for money!

Simple menu and that's great, the food is amazing cooked and good range of beers. Definitely a place where I would go back in Southwell.

We stopped in for lunch half way through a long drive home on bank holiday Monday. Nearly all tables were reserved for a busy service but the lady who welcomed us took a lot of time to make us feel comfortable, including sorting us out with a high chair and heating up our toddler’s pre-prepared food. That continued throughout the meal and nothing was too much trouble - the service was prompt, efficient and super-friendly, which makes such a difference.

Called in after a visit to Southwell Workhouse. Recommendation, TripAdvisor where else?

OMG do not waste your time - it's grotty, the food is poor and the service non-existent. Do yourself a favour the Saracens Head is just up the road and its 100% better