The Cornish Arms in Cornwall, Isles of Scilly

Massively overpriced lunch that did not live up to expectations. Apparently the two roasts that were had on the table were good, but the hake and mash two of us ordered that sounded delicious, was measly portioned and bland. For £27 it needs to be better. The soy butter sauce was watery and bland. The mash was oily and poorly made. The fish was cooked well but there was too little of it for that price. The barn-like dining hall wasn’t great either - last time we went (some years ago) it was still the old pub, and all the better for it. Won’t be back.

Excellent, friendly service. Food was delicious. Lively experience out if season. Thank you all.

Excellent service, excellent food, great place to eat, but they need to have chutney with the curries

We booked on the phone and informed that we would be bringing three big dogs as we were staying in an air B&B we couldn't leave them. When we arrived we were on a small table crammed in next to a family with nowhere for the dogs to get out of the way. The family were clearly unhappy about the dogs and the small girl, between fits of screaming and crying began kicking my elderly dog in the head. Luckily he is a bit daft and confused so didn't respond but if he had bitten he would have been at fault not the child. The Mother intervened quickly. I didn't want to sit next to screaming children and they didn't want to sit next to dogs. I think both parties should have both been informed. It was overcrowded with tables too close together, really noisy we couldn't speak to each other, food was bland and overpriced and a 10% service charge. My husbands tartar sauce had a crust on it and the peas were grey. I had mussels in a cider, sorrel and cream sauce it didn't taste good but the mussels were huge and plentiful. The staff were lovely, hardworking and helpful, nothing was too much trouble so we happily paid the 10%. It wasn't an enjoyable dining experience and we couldn't wait to leave. We wouldn't go back with or without dogs

The best non fussy pub around. Great food , lovely drinking institution. Really no complaints. I would recommend.

Lovely food both times. Staff very friendly. Dog friendly too.

Lovely meal, great service. My only negative comment is why are dogs allowed in. 3 tables all next to me had dogs. If I come again I shall ask to be on a table not near any tables with dogs

Food average at best. Service pretty poor waiting time for food abysmal. No apologies because no recognition of slip shod standards. Train your staff. Rojanos in Padstow was streaks ahead for a similar price point. Will not return until reviews prove they have pulled their socks up

Good atmosphere, service and food.

A pleasant visit, excellent food, good service friendly staff

Great food nice beer good staff

Called in for a light lunch. Tasty and nicely done. Pleasant service. Restaurant a bit large, lost some of the old style pub intimacy.

We had a fab lunch here. The staff are personable and provide fab service. The food is brilliant.

Fourth visit and last . Every time I try what looks like a great venue I get a different poor experience, there are many much better run pubs / restaurants. Don’t get lured in by the Rick Stein name , food is average at best , bar snacks very poor , embarrassing for a so called celebrity chef . Uninterested rude staff who work on the assumption that if you don’t like it tough ! There will be another mug along shortly

Rick's Cheesecake is one off the reasons I regularly visit his eateries. Today I lunched here once again the starter's and mains were really delicious. But cheese cake in a jar!!! You have to be joking? Remember this was on the menu there just after Covid, do we have another problem looming? Have booked the main restaurant on Sunday and the cafe next Thursday and Friday back here for lunch. Please say you have the real thing available.

A great place to stop, the restaurant area is bright and open, the menu is interesting and varied with a easy to navigate wine list and beers. Staff are attentive, friendly and provide very good service.

Pleasant experience in the Shepherds Hut. Excellent breakfast.

Staff great food fantastic Have had Sunday lunch today and a lovely meal on Wednesday Thank you for allowing our dog to visit also very important to us

We came in, hungry and chilled from our walk and sauna/sea dip, along the north coast. We didn’t book, however, the service staff were attentive and helpful, finding a spot for us to sit, and after a short wait at the bar, sipping some local beer and watching the world go by, we sat down to a wholesome meal of Pondicherry fish curry and a proper cornish hamburger (meat from Philip Warrens - as natured intended!). It was a fantastic meal in a beautiful restaurant, filled with laughter and people enjoying each other’s company, not to mention the culinary delights on offer. A lovely end to the day.

Great place that I really enjoy going to. However, you should always make a reservation as it is difficult to get a table spontaneously. Service is great and so is the food.

Pleasant staff and good food.Just too many dogs.

Popped in for snack, ended up having a relaxing lunch.

Visited in August. Excellent food and service. Easily the best food I have ever had. Ordered Cornish Arms Hamburger and Chocolate Pavé for dessert.

Nicely good evening meal. Great atmosphere and restaurant.

Very good food and great service.

Just a stop off for a drink. Really liked the look of the place. Seems very popular. One to revisit.

Saved up super treat for our holiday. Arrived on time and seated. We had our cockapoo with us and there was not a lot of space for her, but she eventually settled under the table. But even when she popped out she was greeted by every member of staff with a warm smile. We had a sharing starter, which was epic. Then steak for our main. Well... we asked for medium rare and it was perfect. The fries were perfect. The salad was fabulous. We had a portion of onion rings, these were the nicest onion rings had in many a moon. The staff were attentive, but not overly. We were given time to enjoy our surroundings, feel like we were not an imposition (as is found at times, unfortunately). All in all a fabulous experience for us. Thankyou all.

Had the steak it was lovely, peppercorn sauce was exquisite

The prices are very expensive for a pub . Portion sizes wasn’t brilliant and I cannot understand the 12.5 % service charge. It’s a pub with expensive food. Pay your staff more and shouldn’t be paying a service charge. We paid it but didn’t get the best waitress service. We are local and couldn’t be a regular customer as it’s too expensive for drinks . When he goes to these places in Europe etc and goes on about the locals eating out. They can because nowhere charges like this. Gravity should be at the customers discretion. We paid £14 for service charge. Absolutely disgraceful.The fish curry you get 1 small piece of Hake and curry sauce and rice with a popadom . Not great value. £4.95 for a portion of chips . £4.94 for a large bottle of water. Not great .

Nice place to enjoy lunch, dinner or a pine. The food was good not much though on the plate for the price you pay. Will be good to have more fish options not on curry or sauce simple grill , fried. Service was excellent and the atmosphere lovely.

Bog standard food at high prices & small portions. Vietnamese salad was so, so overpoweringly bitter & citrusy, fish Goujons had absolutely no taste, and the chicken dry. I had really high expectations from this place but unfortunately felt totally let down. Then to add insult to injury, a 12.5% discretionary charge is added to the bill which appears compulsory however I asked this to be waived. Service was pleasant but not exceptional. Nothing special. Find somewhere better.

Brilliant pub. Sitting in the beer garden against the backdrop of St Merryn, listening to local singers and drinking decent beer all made for a superb pub experience. Good customer service also!

Lovely place to eat. Lovely friendly staff. ☺️

As usual food a service excellent

A terrible meal here, 2 out of 5 of the meals were cold and the rarebread sausage and mash was terrible. The sausages tasted like frozen wall sausages, split down the side and taste of mushy and barely any pork. I'm not sure if they were an emergency replacement, if so that's as shocking. We won't be back.

Lovely location. Pleasant service. Sat in the Rick Stein beer garden and ordered their pizzas from smartphone App. (We could also have sat inside the dog friendly restaurant but chose the garden area.) First class pizza made to order - and that’s from someone who isn’t a pizza-lover. Will come back to sample the indoor restaurant as well. Very dog friendly place as well. Prices fairly average for this area. Impressed.

Service great Food amazing Only negative - dogs in restaurant 🤬

Average at best. Like an early gastropub from 15 years ago. Poorly grilled halloumi when there are two big green eggs in the garden. Pizza with a soggy bottom. Disappointing, maybe try The Marriners.

On Tuesday 20th August around lunchtime, I had the displeasure of dining at a restaurant bearing the name of the so-called “celebrity chef,” Rick Stein, and I must say it was nothing short of a culinary disaster. To think that a chef with such a reputation would attach his name to such a dismal dining experience is utterly shocking. Let me start by saying that the young lady who served us was as helpful as she could be, given the circumstances, but her hands were clearly tied. The menu was rigid and inflexible, with no room for even the slightest deviation. It felt as if everything in the kitchen had arrived vacuum-packed and pre-prepared, leaving no possibility of adjusting any dish to suit the customer’s preferences. On the rare occasion that they did attempt to accommodate a request, it was as if the chef was doing us a personal favor—a laughable notion, considering the subpar quality of the food. I ordered the dressed crab, which turned out to be a sad excuse for a dish. The crab itself was so minuscule that it must have been the smallest crab in existence, accompanied by what they dared to call a green salad. This “salad” consisted of a few lifeless, drab lettuce leaves strewn haphazardly on the plate—utterly uninspired and unappetizing. The only extra I managed to procure, after much effort, was a sliver of smoked salmon from the children’s menu, which was laughably small. My partner, a fan of bangers and mash, was equally disappointed. Every bangers and mash aficionado knows that three sausages are standard, yet at Rick Stein’s restaurant, you’re lucky to get two—and not just any two, but the smallest, most pitiful sausages imaginable, paired with a meager helping of mash. Our friend opted for the Vietnamese salad, which supposedly contains only 250 calories—no surprise there, as the portion size was laughable, barely filling two tablespoons. Thankfully, I had ordered fries, or we would have left the restaurant starving. If this is the level of food that Rick Stein is willing to put his name on, I can confidently say I will never be returning. Our friend, a local, seemed equally disillusioned, which is a shame. In stark contrast, we later visited the Inn on the Shore at Downderry, where we experienced excellent food and service. Despite not being a celebrity-endorsed establishment, the staff there bent over backwards to accommodate our requests, even when we deviated from the menu. No pretentiousness, just genuinely good food, great service, and stunning sea views—a truly refreshing experience. Rick Stein might want to reconsider the quality control in his kitchens if he wishes to maintain any shred of culinary credibility

Cornish Arms, not gonna develop any kind of arms at this place other than malnourished, ordered the fish cakes off the main menu, should have been on the childs starter menu, two bits the size of a 50 pence piece and 8 rocket leaves, fuming

Super friendly, extremely welcoming, and also very dog friendly. Good selection of drinks and soft drinks also.

Me the wife and son had a meal here today, service was amazing and very helpful, food was amazing. I had the smoked salmon starter, fish curry main and steamed ginger pudding. Could fault any of it. My wife had the lobster special and described it a "unreal" they even do a free seafood taster plate which is amazing for my 9yo son as it can be very daunting for kids trying new food. Highly recommend. Lovely place.

Just returned from our first visit and it certainly won't be our last! From the attentive and engaging staff, to the attention to your allergy requirements everything was amazing and that's before we've even got to he food! What a brilliant idea it is to allow children to sample seafood, to give them an opportunity to taste it, without it being overwhelming and scary, genius! And then there was our meal, just wow! If you can, try the lobster, it's out of this world! Highly recommend The Cornish Arms, we couldn't fault it in any way at all.

Nice food and drink in a local pub. Expensive and overpriced for what you get. I’m sure the head chef would disagree but as I am from central London I know what I’m talking about.

Pub food, nothing i’d put my name to (Rick Stein). Waited almost an hour for mains…lovely and helpful stuff though!

Wonderful food great atmosphere

Lunch as a family of 5 with 3 young kids. Service was quick, attentive & friendly. Restaurant was nicely done whilst still retaining a relaxed atmosphere. Food was all on point. Would definitely return.

What a mistake eating here was. Seven people eating, two meals were cold, one unimpressive and one terrible. The terrible was the sausage and mash for £18, it appeared to be microwaved mash as it had a film on the potato, the rare bread sausages must have been out and it was a walls sausage replacement, breadie mush. I'd go for a beer but we won't be eating here again.

Wonderful meal in a lovely, clean,well organised family friendly pub. Looking forward to going back

We've been coming here for years and always enjoyed our food. Today was no exception, the steak was lovely. I've given 4 stars though as my chips were pre-salted, and there was no veggies or salad on the kids burger except for a bit of lettuce. This seemed a bit 'McDonald's' like, a tomato or a few peas on the side of the kids dish wouldn't cost much? I know lots of kids might not eat it and it ends up in the bin, but is that a reason not to offer them at all? I would have thought someone like Rick Stein could make something on the side that kids would find both tasty and nutritious?

We went to the Cornish Arms for dinner to celebrate our wedding anniversary. It was a great experience and the food was wonderful. The staff were excellent and even though we had an "incident" at the table, the staff didn't make us feel unwelcome or awkward at all. They couldn't have been kinder. In fact, when they found out it was our anniversary, they treated us to a surprise that we both really appreciated - it was very unexpected. Kindness in spades. Thank you. Look forward to dining with you again in the future.

Exceptional food, lovely place to stay and really friendly staff! We will be back again!

Star of the show for us was the manager. Very welcoming and charming. And so was the rest of the staff... Food was really nice too. The tomato and chilli soup had a warm kick to it, if the scallops hadn't have been so fantastic I'd have eaten half of the bowl. The mussels and fish curry were superb

Really great food. Beautiful pub. Fantastic staff. Love it. And the best pint of Proper Job you can find.

Delicious lunch in a lovely pub garden. Lovely place for a drink and pizza 😀

Always pop in here when the wife has a mooch around the shops, turned Into a family tradition

Popped in for lunch,pre booked, great atmosphere, in a word beautiful.

Honestly the best pizza I've ever had.. give them tips because they deserve every penny!

The food at The Cornish Arms is lovely and a good selection available. However the service is so slow, waiting for over an hour between courses. And then changing a service fee seems very unfair when the service was so poor. The restaurant is very load and can barely hear eachother speaking.

Brill food and staff were excellent.

Excellent Service & Food. The starter, we had Camembert for Two with new potatoes, red onion pickle and grilled sourdough. Followed by Main, Grilled Lobster and Dressed Crab. The staff work like a well oiled machine. Very relaxed, professional and happy. Special thanks to Emily and CoCo, a real life angel :)

A bit hit and miss if you order to the outside tables I found on two occasions. Maybe they need an upgrade to the ordering platform they use. Better to not bother and order at the Bar.

Would love to have been able to review, however can't owing to unfortunate experience with whom I think may have been the Bar manager. Does Rick know who represents him? I have been coming to Padstow and enjoying the hospitality of the Cornishmans arms for very many years (starting with my own Mum & Dad in the 70s). We had decided to have dinner if we could get in the bar at 6:00PM, we also have a dog, and would normally eat outside, however this Year it was wet. I went in to see how busy it was and whether a table was free in the bar, one was I asked a very pleasant bar man if it would be OK for a dog in the bar and to have dinner, all ok, until on turning to go and get my wife was curtly told by another man, more a manager that no food in the bar would be able to be served to us. Also told that this was Rick's idea, as thought strange for a pub not to serve food in their bar!

Food and service are excellent 👌

Good food, friendly staff but expensive, contents of finger bowl spilt over one member of the party and still charged 12.5% service charge for 5 people!

Food review - we were all in agreement that it was good quality pub. It was a bit canteen like with lots of tables crammed in one large room. Although they were positioned cleverly, it did feel a bit overwhelming and cramped. Service was rapid. Pricey but not overpriced. A pleasant experience.

Strange arrangement of available menus regarding times and whether you want to eat inside or outside.

Have just got back from a 5 star experience at the Cornish Arms. Food was lovely, Beetroot fritters were delicious. What made the whole experience was the service by Sam our waitress. She was outstanding. Thank you Sam.

Camped in the area for a week. Frequented The Cornish Arms 3 or so times. Also, the atmosphere for one of Englands Euros games was fantastic. Staff were polite and the ale was lovely. Definitely will be using the pub regularly, if we're in the area again.

We only went there to eat. The food was very tasty and, above all, a change from English cuisine. Also previous service.

The best food ever have had during our week away! We booked our table a few days before visiting and had an early evening slot. Service was excellent and the food was amazing. The children ate the steak from the kids menu and adults had the beef and a chicken burger. Beetroot fritters and pil pil prawns to start were also amazing. Would definitely recommend and book before you go

Chaos, ordered at just after 6pm pizzas arrived before starters at 7pm. Waitress seemed surprised when we asked where our pil pil prawns and four scallops. Eventually pill pill prawns arrived, had to remind waitress again about scallops. 20 mins later a single scallop was presented to us. In the end had to ask for refund, which took another 15 mins of negotiations. No apologies. Its a pity as the pizzas were nice, though a bit cold and the pil pil prawns were very good. Table next to us also had to ask for a refund.

The original Pub facade still exists, but now turned into a food machine. The place has lost its soul, but hey ho, nothing lasts forever, good default stop if you have a family, but I won’t be going back unless it’s the dead of winter. Token posting of some photos, but cant get excited about this place any more

Chose from the pizza menu after asking for it, when nothing quite appealed from main menu. Pizza was tasty and enjoyable and pudding was - enjoyable. Service was pleasant.

We have been here on numerous occasions, normally in May and October. Food and staff very good. Went 2 days ago at 2pm for lunch as lobster on the menu, only to find it was sold out, which was disappointing. Had kidney starter and crab main, which really enjoyed. But still came away disappointed.

Had food & drinks, prices not over the top (for Cornwall).

The food here tonight wasn't great, it was excellent. We had the Scallops and Clam masala as a starter, both meals were superb. The rump steak was cooked to perfection and the accompanying salad wasn't ordinary - loved the hint of thyme. Again, an excellent plate of food. I really couldn't fault the food or the staff. There's no doubt we'll be back, probably tomorrow night. Thanks and keep up the good work. Definitely a night to remember.

Nothing more than the opposite when it says a friendly atmosphere here. Myself and my partner stopped here and asked if they served cream teas, but the look of disgust which was shown on the member of staffs face serving behind the bar which she then just laughed and answered "no" pulling a face in front of other customers. It made us feel so uncomfortable, unwelcome and embarrassed we left.

Been coming to this pub for years, and I recently visited twice over a week’s holiday. Disappointed to discover the food has gone massively downhill, portions have been seriously reduced, service was rushed, and prices are astronomical for what is really quite average food. Our Main courses came before our drinks. We asked where the starter prawns were from, we were told ‘Bangladesh’. The experience was so disappointing - this used to be a highlight of my holiday, but there is better food available nearby.

Excellent food and service, I had the half lobster with chips.

We had a wonderful meal here at the Cornish Arms, owned by Rick Stein. The pub itself is very cosy and the staff were so warm and friendly and made a big fuss of our golden retriever (dogs are made very welcome). The food was absolutely delicious, cooked fresh and served perfectly, definitely worth every penny and affordable too. The garden area is very inviting and perfect for a summers evening drink. I would definitely recommend trying here.

Lovely food, great service. Blue cheese sauce was a winner with me! Made a fuss of my dogs

I have been coming to the Cornish Arms for many years and have thoroughly enjoy the food. I have been very happy to see vegetarian and vegan dishes added to the menu. However, last night was a huge disappointment. The spaghetti was so overpowered with garlic it was inedible. The menu didn’t even mention garlic. Others in my party were also disappointed with their curries. So disappointing 😒

Rural, great food and great smelling hand lotion 👌

We only called in for a pint and Pizzas, Good beer, good pizzas, helpful friendly knowledgeable staff and a great atmosphere.

Very nice decor inside the restaurant, attentive staff. Felt like it was over priced for standard pub food. Felt like you are just paying for the connection to the name rather than the food......

Celebrated my birthday there with 8 people eating. All enjoyed the delicious food and excellent ales. We didn't stay in any rooms overnight so cannot comment.

A well run pub and restaurant in beautiful gardens and surroundings. One of the best I've visited.

Fabulous tasty well cooked food at a fair price considering the quality. The service is exceptional too, well timed between courses and not hurried although we did have a time slot, we had as long as we liked. A must visit when you're in the area. Well done all.

Very disappointed with the food both our steaks were undercooked and cold in the middle, the replacement were not much better and my pet hate cold plates. Disappointed with lack of seafood on the menu.But the staff were very friendly and mangers did take the steaks off the bill. Shame as we been coming here for years as a end of holiday treat but not again.

Staff and food is great here, especially the eye roll inducing deserts!!! Despite it being a pub, you still get quality food that won't leave you bloated or ill. I always have to pay a visit for the quality and service. They also allow dogs in as long as they are well behaved.

The beer is drinkable nothing special about it.

We went there for a treat for our holiday and must say it was fantastic the staff was so friendly and the food was amazing. Would recommend anyone going there for a treat .

Great location but poor table service. Staff had a very good “head down” approach. Food was ok but expected much better. V disappointed.

Sadly, we went to lunch on Monday, the 10th June, and it was poor, we had the Lamb curry, Lemon Sole fish bites and a Hamburger, and it was all disappointing. The bun on the burger was stale, the rice was microwaved and there was too much gristle. The salad for the lemon sole bites was rotten and wilted. An all round poor effort and lack of attention to detail. The staff were friendly but manager ignored us when clearing tables. You pay Rick Stien prices for food that you could get in a Harvester. Not that I would ever eat at a Harvester.

Nice food, great service and a very pleasant place to be. And very dog friendly too.

Have stayed in constantine bay for three years running and each year have gone for dinner at Cornish arms. Food this year was even better than previously. Fantastic friendly staff. Excellent food and reasonably priced beers even if wine is slightly more expensive. Lovely local pub the added outside wood fired pizzas excellent too. Especially the crab and chilli. Last night tonight and had a meal inside and did not disappoint. Thanks to all staff will be back in a few weeks

Very over priced, I expect a little due to the Rick stien name but come one. Camembert has basically exploded and was cold by the time it got to us. Main where nice but had to lot to live up to for the price tag. Staff were lovely, shame they seemed overrun most of the night.

Great staff but slightly underwhelming food. Sadly not quite what we expected.

We have been year on year on but the food tonight was poor we have had better in our local j w lees pub for much less than the cost here. Very disappointed staff fabulous but it's lost it's charm service was poor we waited quite a while and listening around people weren't happy with their food. I think because it's Rick stein they can charge more than usual but for us we have another booking which we will be cancelling. Food has really gone down in our opinion the pizzas outside look better value