Based on 295 opinions finded in 2 websites
Based on 295 opinions finded in 2 websites
Nº 192 in 255 in South Derbyshire
Nº 50 of 60 British in South Derbyshire
Opinions
Called in for the first time after a visit to the nearby Arboretum..pub was pretty quiet but was cosy & welcoming..we had a lovely lunch followed by coffees in comfy armchairs by the fire. The chef came out & chatted to us for a while & the landlady was so friendly too..this venue is just what you hope for when you visit a country pub & I’m sure we will be back!
Ann Martin . 2024-10-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Sunday dinner with family. Mum had risotto , everyone else had lamb or beef. The meat was wonderful and the Yorkshire puddings enormous ! Service was very attentive and quick even though they were very busy. Carol and her team looked after us and we had a lovely time. Food is brilliant value and deliciously. You'll never leave hungry here.
Mark N . 2024-10-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Last time I came here was around 6 or 7 years ago, last night I'd reserved a table for 5 of us to celebrate my birthday and a friends anniversary; the food lived up to how I remembered it.... proper, homemade food with a great portion size (if you're greedy like me!). Personally I had the lasagne which was very tasty (and piping hot, so don't dive straight in to it like I did!), others had liver & onions, sea bass, lasagne and the meat and potato pie. All of which were very much enjoyed. Value for money I felt was excellent and the staff were very polite and courteous. Will most definitely be back again soon to this cosy, warm and friendly pub.
Kyle M . 2024-09-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
What a lovely pub… very quaint !! We had never been before, but we went for Sunday lunch today for Father’s Day, and it was absolutely beautiful!! Delicious food, all freshly cooked, and beautiful presentation. Lovely friendly staff, nothing was too much trouble at all !! Will definitely be going back .
Connector44672135761 . 2024-06-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fantastic food and lovely staff . I never get a bad meal here and everyone always is welcoming and attentive to your needs . I’ve looked at some reviews on here which shocks me as I can’t see how they can be true ! I have always had the same consistent visits here . And I would say if there was any issues with food or whatever they would just sort it out as they’re that kinda People . I dine out most nights with work and visit hundreds of venues a year and I can honestly say this is a lovely , Friendly Pub , Oh and they love Dogs 🐶 so that always gets my vote x
Harper . 2024-04-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
It was a midweek visit so didn’t expect it to be busy and it wasn’t so there was zero atmosphere. The food was good, however experience was disappointing. The front of house lady was really quite rude and made us feel like we were putting her out. and that everything was too much trouble !! There was no customer interaction and she basically, just did her job to the minimum. A smile or a little bit of friendly chat would have been nice rather than feeling like we shouldn’t have been there and she couldn’t wait for us to go. The chef was very friendly and the young girl who was serving was also friendly and helpful . Unfortunately, we will not be returning !
Annon . 2024-04-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Always great quality food , good portions at rears reasonable prices. Good village pub with a choice of real beers to pick from
Mike . 2024-04-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
If you want to feel unwelcome, like youre an inconvenience and argued with for daring to ask to order food then this is the place for you. Was told there was a 15 to 20 min wait for food but what the older, long haired female member of staff with a very ignorant attitude meant to say was that we would have to wait 15 to 20 min before we could even place our order. Guessing this one needs to learn communication skills and basic customer service. However busy you may be, being rude and raising your voice is totally unnessary.
Andrea M . 2024-03-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Absolutely 💯 value for money, Monday is chippy toppers night lots of different choices to put on your homemade chips! Or rice if you prefer service is always brilliant food is all homemade and cooked fresh to order can not fault it can not recommend enough,Thankyou!
Kerry S . 2024-03-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Came in for the Monday night chippy topper night. Amazing value the food was amazing. Friendly waiting staff. Will definitely come again
Jordan P . 2024-02-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent service and great quality of food at a fantastic price. The pub in a quaint treasure in this beautiful village
davidrP2439IL . 2024-02-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely food and great service. Good atmosphere with friendly servers and chef. The food was amazing and tastes delicious. Definitely recommend!
Billie Jo F . 2024-02-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent service friendly staff, happy couldn’t do enough for us. It was a party of 10 people for a birthday meal . Food was excellent served all together piping hot .Even the owner/chef came to see if everything was ok . Would recommend anyone that has not been give it a try . Thank you The Smisby Arms for a wonderful night .
K1470WGjanew . 2024-02-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Best food I’ve tasted for a very long time and great value for money…super friendly staff and landlady
Jane G . 2024-01-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We have just had an absolutely beautiful Christmas dinner cooked to perfection. Home made and served piping hot. Great friendly service . Can’t fault it and highly recommend.
Carol A . 2023-12-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great atmosphere, brilliant staff and food was excellent, couldn’t fault the service, very generous with size of meals
Kath T . 2023-12-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food always good, staff always friendly and accomodating. Landlady always makes an effort with my little boy which is nice.
Joseph D . 2023-11-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Booked a table for 1 pm. On arrival was asked what drinks we would like and also asked could we order quickly as the chef wanted to leave early. Why did they take our booking, we were the only people in the restaurant. When we go out with friends for lunch we like to have a leisurely lunch and a drink. Will not be returning although the food itself was very good.
Annette H . 2023-11-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food good value for money. Atmosphere isn’t pleasant. Staff appear to work hard, with excellent customer service skills but owners don’t speak to them respectfully which made for an uncomfortable experience to have to witness. Shame really because it’s a nice location, nice local pub. Don’t think I’ll be returning anytime soon.
Odyssey49887681285 . 2023-10-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We went for the first time last night and the meal was nice the atmosphere in the restaurant was awful the lady behind the bar was having goes at the two young ladies that were trying their best as soon as the chef shouted They stop taking orders and run and get the food to take to the tablets for the customers .I take it there were short staffed .my friend was also there and went out for a fag and she heard the chef shout at them saying they were awful at their job .I felt sorry for the young girls as they couldn’t get anything right what ever they did in the time was there and were both crying I’m just glad my son didn’t go for a job there when we seen one on indeed .
Kimlorraine70 . 2023-09-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
once again superb food at the Smisby arms, we go alot to the Smisby arms and it never fails to impress the quality of the food ample portions it really is first class.
Geoff W . 2023-09-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Avoid this dreadful place like the plague! . Went for lunch today with my family and asked if I could add beef to the mushroom stroganoff, totally prepared to pay extra . Whilst sat in the restaurant with just 2 other customers, the chef and 2 old cronies decided to berate the request and went into a tirade for 5 minutes about customers who try to engineer his menu and he could do without the hassle! How a backstreet boozer can take this attitude is beyond me. Deserves no business and a lesson in customer service! When I asked for beef I didn’t expect to have beef with the chef. What an amateur ! Just lost best part of £100. No one in the pub, dark dingy hole and we’re in a cost of living crisis Seriously needs a visit from Gordon Ramsay
mrsdebbieday123 . 2023-08-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Heard many good reports about this place but it did not live up to its reputation. Underwhelming and mediocre food to say the least. The real disappointment though was my daughter’s fish and chips…Quite frankly, the fish stank. I have never smelled anything quite like it before. Upon quietly and politely telling the landlady that it smelled ‘off’ and was inedible, I was told that it was ‘fresh from Grimsby 2 days ago’….! My daughter’s meal was swapped for an alternative (slightly more expensive - which we were charged for!) but it has put us off ever returning unfortunately. There are much better places to eat locally.
Firebug2773 . 2023-08-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We visited “ impromptu” for lunch mid-week. What a really smashing experience. Perfect variety of main-courses served with a smile and excellent value for money. Made our standard poodle Percy very welcome. All in all, an extremely pleasant surprise. Deserves to be well patronised & well worth a drive out for lunch, and I’m certain, dinner.
IanM223 . 2023-07-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Needed a family lunch venue and because I had been to Smisby Arms several years ago I suggested we all meet there. I phoned at 0930 that morning to advise them that there could be up to 12 people arriving around 1215. When we arrived the first issue was no wheelchair access and as one of our party is wheelchair bound that caused a bit of a problem. The worker let us in to the lower dining room by opening the back door. We had to stop in that room as there were steps up to the bar area. We made the necessary adjustments to tables and i went to order drinks. The worker asked me if we had booked and I informed her of the phone message. She then said for a party of our size we should have pre-ordered. Our party was 9 people. At this point feeling unwelcome and unwanted I asked if we should go elsewhere and the worker said no.I proceeded to buy drinks and took them to the table. The table, chairs, cutlery, glasses and chairs were "sticky". The serviettes and cutlery stuck to the table and if you leant on the bar or the table the same happened to your arms. To keep things simple we all ordered fish and chips. lovely, good portions, well cooked, thrice cooked chips which were smashing and perfectly cooked chips. Good grub shame about the attitude, disabled access and they need a new cleaner.
karmishaw . 2023-06-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Been to this establishment on several occasions, bar manager, bar staff, waitresses and chef are absolutely outstanding never had a problem UNTILL the landlady is on shift, she is rude, arrogant and disrespectful never met a woman like her ……. It’s a shame as she’s the only person who lets the place down. I won’t be returning whilst she is still there under any circumstances!!!!
785kerryh . 2023-03-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A welcoming old pub, with tasty food and well cooked. Staff were friendly and even though they were very busy nothing was a problem for them.
julie1948 . 2023-02-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A friend suggested we meet up for a meal and a catch up, and they thought the Smisby Arms would be a good idea. I rang to book a table and was told they could just squeeze the two of us in for 6.45. I don’t eat out very often, so this was a real treat, and it’s lovely to have a meal cooked. On arrival, a few minutes early, the bar/waiting staff seemed slightly pressured, but it was a Saturday evening and we were served drinks before being told which was our table. It was right next to a back door which staff needed to use on several occasions. The table adjacent had a family who were about to leave but the significant amount of dropped food from a high chair next to mine took a while to clean up. The wait time between serving staff visits to the table increased as the evening went on. Sometimes two came at once. The wine did not arrive in time to be consumed alongside the food. The vegan choice of Provençal vegetables was very disappointing - thin, watery tomato based sauce wrapped around a bowl of slightly under cooked mixed veg, with zero seasoning. No salt, pepper, garlic, herbs… very bland and hardly French. The lady who appeared to be the bar manager had an aloof and slightly rude air about her, though the younger waiting staff were polite and friendly, and though they seemed to be trying their hardest, service was at best chaotic, not just for us but other customers too. We were served by three different staff. The ‘manager’ was abrupt when I asked about vegan dessert options, saying ‘you won’t be about to have cream or custard with it’. Cramped seating, poor knowledge of menu items, very disorganised staffing, tasteless and overpriced food. When we finally got the bill (the ‘manager’ had to confirm with us which items we’d had). We took it to the bar to pay, rather than wait another 15 minutes. I left the table first, as I’d been asked to move by staff wishing to use the door behind, and waited up the steps for my friend who was putting on a jacket. The ‘manager’ said ‘Are you alright?’. I didn’t realise she was talking to me so she said it again, rather rudely. I explained I was waiting for my friend. When asked if everything had been okay, we politely only mentioned the wait times, and the ‘manager’ retorted defensively and rudely, referring to the younger waiting staff, saying ‘Well, I can only work with what I’ve got’. Disrespectful, unfriendly, rude, poor attitude. I can’t remember the last time I felt I might leave a review for anything - I’m not a complainer - but this was a shambles, a waste of time and money. Will not be returning, sorry.
FredBandB . 2023-02-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited this pub on 28th December around 4.45pm.Was told not serving food till 5.00pm not a problem enjoyed drinks beforehand. Owners were very friendly food came out very swiftly 2 lasagne and 2 fish and chips excellent food . overall a good experience only visited there a couple of times before but will certainly go back there again soon. WELL Done to all the team that work there !
ian m . 2022-12-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Well I have to say you can’t beat real pub grub and this certainly hits the mark! I had liver and onions cooked to perfection with some roasted boiled potatoes and vegetables was very nice indeed. My partner had gammon and chips very big portion. My friend had chicken supreme unfortunately that was very bland. They managed to get us in at 1:45 pm but they stop serving food at 1:30 pm. So was in a rush to get us served. Bit strange in this day in age as most pubs serve all day now. Lovely traditional pub but no Guinness… I don’t think I’ve ever been in a pub that doesn’t serve Guinness 😵💫 (can) = no thanks. There was 2 Real Ales on, updated Madri & peroni on draft. Was nice coal fired on.. All in all good. Thanks
Dj-mule . 2022-12-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food that I had was not worth the money I paid. I complained to waitress but no one came to me. No veg with the main meal unless you pay extra.
Jayne S . 2022-12-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
First time here, parking is very restricted so if there were lots of you then you would struggle but thqt seems to be the way for Smisby. We came for Sunday lunch, sadly there is no vegetarian option you can only order a meal from...
Elmo1989_03 . 2022-10-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Such a shame excellent food was spoilt with poor service and late apology. We were greeted with a very awkward welcome advising we had been booked in for 5pm rather and 8pm, but when questioned we got told this was the temp who had booked...
SophieP1879 . 2022-10-07
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Good and service is out of this world, amazing food served with a smile. Highly recommend anyone to try this place
robhS3534LL . 2022-09-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We chose this place for a family get together evening meal. The place looks nice and cosy from outside and the inside is equally so, there is hardly any space to move about though. Our table was booked for 7.30. We arrived way before our...
PatrickThanditravels . 2022-09-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Very friendly welcome. We ordered our drinks and food, and sat outside in the sunshine. Food served quicker than expected, it was hot and tasty. Good grub in a friendly pub, what more could you want?
oldrector . 2022-08-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I have read these negative reviews and confused as to why people are writing these malicious reviews about the landlady. I come here with my partner montky and have done for the last 4 years and the couple that run it are amazing and can't...
margaret511 . 2022-08-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Is a lovely country pub with fantastic food. Shall be visiting again well worth The Visit. Fantastic fresh hot food. The service after ordering my food was quick and no complaints at all about anything.
robert d . 2022-06-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I can honestly say I have been coming to this pub for the past 6 months and the land lady and staff are absolutely amazing! Very friendly and cater for all. Always feel welcome and the atmosphere is relaxed. Please don’t be out of by...
476tarrynd . 2022-05-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
As an employee for a FTSE 100 company and having to entertain a sales director for the evening the pressure was on me and I was unsure where to go for and evening meal. After a few discussions, he suggested a village pub (after all...
X6267ROdeanr . 2022-05-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I can’t believe some of the reviews wrote on here and I feel that we must write a review .We have been visiting the Smisby arms for at least ten years sometimes 3 times a week and can honestly say we have never had a...
457mitch . 2022-05-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We went to the smisby arms today for food with the family, nothing was to much for the staff they even did a menu to our child's needs food was very quick to be served lovely delicious food piping hot! Puddings was lovely we will...
Claire B . 2022-05-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Someone in the kitchen knows what they are doing , the food was excellent The attitude of the landlady however completely quashed that Damn rude & almost goading in her comments towards us Plus a full on audible rant with the kitchen staff Never experienced...
Casualitalian . 2022-04-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Me and my wife booked a table on valentines/our anniversary evening. Our one night away from the kids in a long time. This place was recommended by somebody we knew. However he was a regular drinker there and friends with the landlord. We placed our...
lucazk2022 . 2022-02-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Absolutely brilliant place. Been here several times now. Every single time was absolutely outstanding, food and atmosphere always top notch. Staff always go out their way to help out, very professional and caring. Thank you :) see you again soon
U792BVmelissah . 2022-02-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We went here for lunch and I must say that the food was excellent. The portions was more than generous and the staff was really welcoming and helpful. I've recommend this place to a few people who are going to try it themselves.
Brooky735 . 2022-01-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Go out of your way to come along to here and benefit from the conscientious chef and extremely well kept cellar. The they cater perfectly for carnivores and us vegans at the other end of the spectrum.
jennyhO8755EZ . 2022-01-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I came here one evning due to my motorcycle breaking down. Leanne was lovely. Great personality and easy to talk to. She knows exactly what shes doing and makes things run like clock work. The same can be said about Carol. Lovely person and very...
DanTheTravelMan . 2021-12-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
As always the food was excellent also the service. We all thoroughly enjoyed our meal. Happy Christmas 🎄
54Happytraveller . 2021-12-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I have had Sunday lunch here twice. First time I had steak with red wine and Stilton which was lovely and the next time I had a lamb dinner. I asked if I could have stuffing with this and there was no hesitation. Four of...
Enjoyeatingnicefood . 2021-12-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My partner and I attend for our usual monthly date night(18/12/22)we sat in the snug for a drink but quickly ask to be seated as there was a Christmas party in the restaurant area.The language was absolutely awful all f's and c words and shouting.I...
margaret511 . 2021-12-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited in November 2021 for my auntie’s birthday and it was unfortunately quite poor. We have visited previously and the overall experience has been middling at best, but this particular was our final visit. I have respect for new staff as it’s not an easy...
harryggarlick . 2021-12-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Just had yet another wonderful Sunday lunch perfect crispy roast potatoes and beautifully cooked vegetables. Lovely old style country pub. With friendly athmosphere and efficient service. Can’t wait to see you soon wendy
Aphroditrwendy . 2021-11-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Sunday lunch, absolutely first class, cooked to perfection served by friendly attentive staff. Would not hesitate to recommend. A big thank you to all the staff a real feel of professionalism and pride in their work. Will be back soon Kind regards David Hick
davidhA2337SN . 2021-11-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Sunday lunch today and very disappointed! This is the second time we have been for Sunday lunch the first time was fantastic great service and delicious food! Today was a complete disaster!! The starters were good, the main course was awful! Lamb that you couldn’t...
Roam47259956933 . 2021-10-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
On arrival given a table that was cramed in between two tables of four no conversation was private you may as well been sat on a total strangers table with them that close may I add that this was a pre booked table so not...
Page222 . 2021-10-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We went to the smisby for a family meal, the pub itself was very clean and gave a warm atmosphere. We didn't book (though sometimes its advised to as can get busy). We probably was there around 5pm. We were seated by a gentleman and...
Neo_Angelo . 2021-10-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Six of us visited this pub today and the food was excellent with good portions well- cooked and presented. We commented that we had recently been to other restaurants in other areas which charged more for dishes not as expertly cooked. We also appreciated a...
barbara_nunn . 2021-10-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Party of 6 ate here last Sunday. Have eaten here in the past and food was good. However this wasn't the case on this visit. All the vegetables were hard and consequently few were eaten. The only meal that was ok was fried fish and...
Sara D . 2021-09-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We have just been to The Smisby Arms, our first visit after Covid restrictions; felt very safe and we were seated and served very quickly. Food and drink was served quickly and efficiently and was of good quality with generous portions, not a stellar experience...
Spike1969a . 2021-09-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I normally try to lighten up my bad reviews but I’m not feeling that today. When you order Ham Egg and Chips you expect the food to come as described. The menu says Gammon, but you get sliced ham from a deli counter. Every single...
MacauleyHorton . 2021-09-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Saw the good reviews and thought it would make a lovely place to stop off after a fab walk around the nearby arboretum. Food was good - good sized portions and tasty. Only spoiled by the really tense atmosphere caused by staff (father and daughter?)...
B6258SZjanetd . 2021-08-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Travelling from York to Swindon & stopped in this little gem of a find for lunch. Hubby had sausage & mash, whilst I had meat & potato pie, topped with short crust pastry ... ABSOLUTELY delicious! Think we will be adjusting our future & frequent...
JillBrw . 2021-08-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fantastic homemade food. Plenty of choice for Carnivore or Vegan. Really tasty Friendly staff. good value for money. Will definitely visit again to sample the other dishes.
lynda246 . 2021-07-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Tasty well cooked meals and plenty of it. Staff were very friendly and accommodating. Would highly recommend.
julie1948 . 2021-07-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Carol and team were absolutely lovely and accommodating. Food was delicious and we couldn't of have been more welcoming. We will definitely be back and recommend to everyone.
X7752ITrebeccak . 2021-06-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited twice in a week because we were so impressed. Excellent food, great value and a friendly welcome! Sunday roasts were excellent - so much choice and large portions! Great with the kids and so accommodating. Thank you!
992nicl . 2021-05-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Some friends of ours took us out for Sunday lunch at The Smisby Arms and what a great place. Tucked away and actually nothing to look at from the outside, it is lovely and cosy inside dating back to the 1600's. The menu is brilliant,...
tuxpanfan . 2020-10-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited on a Saturday evening. Excellent food , well kept ale and courteous and professional staff. Liver and bacon and salmon were both excellent. Would be a regular of we didn't live 160 miles away. That said will visit again when next in the area.
NickW753 . 2020-10-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Wanted somewhere different and new for our lunch. Read the reviews , recieved a few good reports from friends. Tucked away in the heart of the village. Nice chatty regulars and really good staff. Well looked after by Mick. Good menu and specials board. We...
TB16 . 2020-10-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Warm, cosy and friendly atmosphere. Food was fresh, and quickly prepared. Large, but not overwhelming menu. Attentive staff and a vast selection of drinks. Lovely little find and no complaints at all! Will definitely be returning to try more of the menu!
740laurynj . 2020-09-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
It's a lovely little pub/restaurant. Very friendly service and the food was amazing. Definitely recommend
pippamiller1 . 2020-08-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I wish I had registered previous reviews!! The one that reported that no-one wore masks!! 5 family members went for dinner on a Saturday night. It says on the door that staff wear PPE and alcohol gel available . NO-ONE wears a mask and one...
Hallbell . 2020-08-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food was lovely and portions big but main plus point was the good service with a smile. Will definitely be going back!
Allan H . 2020-08-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
me and my partner came for our 3 year anniversary. We rung as the babysitter was late but they were fine, when we arrived the staff was so nice. We ordered starters and mains and the food was amazing, my partner had chicken and i...
addymac33 . 2020-08-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I chose the Smisby Arms for Sunday lunch based on their reviews and I was going to be in the area.Parking is limited, about six spaces but people park by the side of the road. This place is old, 1600. There are steps into the bars and dining room. The room I was in and I was grateful to see very comfortable chairs, old people appreciate this. There were just four people in this room, and a two and a four came in after me. Normally I suspect his place would have been packed if not for Covid-19. The bar tender was a young attractive woman, she was polite and efficient but not what you would call welcoming. The background music was more for people in their 20's although the clientele were in the 50+ range. Non of the staff wore masks and guests were not required to wear masks. I had one in my pocket just in case. The male waiter used hand sanitzer frequently and was thorough cleaning down a table for the next customers.On the specials board there were several steak dishes.I ordered the home made pate to start. It was definitely home made, served with toast quarters a bit of salad and I think a home made chutney. For me the pate was bland, It lacked complexity. I would've liked some more salt and pepper, some brandy or cream or bacon flavour if had been poached wrapped in bacon strips.For my main I ordered a trio of roasts of the day, pork loin, lamb and topside beef.I asked if the pork came with crackling, unfortunately not. The amount of food is huge. On my plate was a slice of each meat, a large Yorkshire pudding, some roast potatoes and boiled potatoes. On top of they was a plate of steamed vegetable, and a jug of gravy that I felt needed some more flavour and juice from the roasts. Everything was served hot, I do appreciate that, I like my food hot. The meats were a disappointment for me. I strongly suspect they were not roasted that morning. They were some what dry. All the vegetables were very good.The Smisby Arms is a lovely pub, the price is very good value for money and the portions are generous. I feel so sorry for places like this that are trying to make it through the pandemic. My only suggestion would be to cook the roasts on Sunday, and together more flavour into the gravy to make it richer.I would return to the Smisby and try the home made fishcakes and one of their steak dinners.
covidhostage . 2020-07-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Was a very pub but had very good reviews. Not a chain. Menu fabulous, staff lovely. I had peppercorn chicken with the most amazing proper chips. Friend had garlic chicken. Both dishes were delicious. Will go again when in the area
suehK6274CI . 2020-07-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
7 members of my family have just had a great evening at The Smisby Arms A lovely warm welcome from Craig the owner, and Mick the bar manager. Delicious food.Excellent service from all the staff. A friendly happy atmosphere. Everyone was delightful with my 2 year old great niece.Many thanks we really enjoyed ourselves .
hazel s . 2020-07-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We stumbled across this pub purely by luck when our daughter was invited to a party in the village. We decided to call in rather than go home. Initially we were told that it was fully booked so we ordered drinks and sat in the bar. A few minutes later the landlady asked if we still wanted to eat as she had a table free for an hour. We took her up on her offer. We knew nothing about this bar restaurant. Our starters arrived; I had the stuffed mushrooms, four mushrooms stuffed with cheese served in a tasty tomato sauce. My description is rubbish, it was delicious and massive for a starter. My partner had the home made fish cakes, two huge home made fish cakes with a side salad and chilli sauce that he said was delicious. My main course was broccoli in a cheese sauce topped with dauphinois potatoes. It was piping hot which meant I had to try and eat it slowly but it was so tasty I found it quite frustrating lol My other half had fish and chips. Again a massive portion of food. We weren’t rushed at all for saying they needed our table. The service was impeccable. I would recommend it to anyone who likes good home made food, and it wasn’t expensive.
paulaw659 . 2020-03-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The beer choices were good, the meal was great - great choice on the menu, more on the specials board and more again on a steak menu. Starters were huge, mains good - all excellent food. But, waiting staff were not good - not welcoming, one diner out of our party of eight, has disability and asked for meat to be cut in the kitchen before presenting it - was told that the chef said no it would spoil the dish; waitress asked can someone else cut it up for you?! So another party member had to cut up the meat like a parent for a child. All members of party so angry, stunned by attitude of waitress. Also, the male staff member came to clear away and just asked are you done then? On sharing this tale with other friends the unprofessionlism of the staff has been noted by them too.
96lellyc . 2020-02-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food was good (apart from onion rings!) but unfortunately service was not. Had to ask for someone to come & take our order & no-one came all evening to see if we wanted more drinks - had to get up & get our own. Seemed very short staffed.
traceydonisthorpe . 2020-02-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Smisby Arms was a recommendation and we had our family reunion there. The converted pub was clean and warm, with a friendly atmosphere. The starters were, like the rest of the food, well presented. There is enough food for the bigger appetite and very tasty, too. The mains were also large portions and, like the first course, extremely flavoursome. The desserts looked nice but we were too full to taste anything other than the creme brûlée and the cheesecake. Both were equally delicious and enjoyed in the relaxed surroundings, along with a few drinks.
C6728XAfredc . 2019-12-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We called in on the off chance and we were given a cosy table for two in the corner, service was quick, Sunday lunch (Lamb with no extra supplement) was excellent, fresh and hot! Highly recommend - thanks Martin & Lou.
Smurfy2013 . 2019-10-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Food not as good as usual, service abysmal, served by a sweaty little man, and practically no other staff, always loved this place and the service, when the older lady, think her name was Sarah, was behind the bar, hopefully just on holiday, and the service improves
571robertu . 2019-10-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We didn`t book and were lucky to get a table for Sunday lunch. The pub is full of olde world charm and although quite compact we felt comfortable. The home made pate starter was delicious and our roast beef meal was very enjoyable. Thanks.
kathy b . 2019-10-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
No atmosphere, food disappointing (steak unbeatable) and staff wasn’t had no costumer service skills
George L . 2019-09-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Took my wife here for our wedding anniversary. Wasn't disappointed. Wide range of food available, including a good vegetarian selection (which pleased the missus). Didn't have to wait long before food arrived which was superb. Best meal I have had in ages.
Martin H . 2019-09-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Amazing pub wide range of beverages head chef was a top guy not surprising really as all the best lads come from the West Midlands. Not sure about the one star reviews I’ve encountered seems like some very false and negative people. All the best for the future.Yours sincerelyNigel holte
nigefromaston . 2019-08-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Booked meal for 7:30 pm on a Saturday night. Meal arrived after chasing at 8:50. The gammon was dry and over cooked along with the chicken curry which only had roughly 6 pieces of chicken in it. To be fair when asked if the meal was ok they did replace the gammon and we were not charged. Having been here many times in recent years we won’t be rushing back. They did apologise for the lateness of the meal due to being short staffed. Why were we not advised that it might be late? A bit of communication would have helped.
Sandra C . 2019-08-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Ate here for the first time in a year or so and service and food was no where near as good as previous.
Dave W . 2019-07-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Although it was fairly quiet we were forgotten about twice! The waitress forgot to take our initial order after we were shown to our table. We had our mains and when the plates were cleared asked for the dessert menu. We gave up waiting and eventually and asked for the bill! For three adults and a child the bill came to £80, just for mains and sides, two alcoholic drinks and 5 soft drinks. The food was okay pub food and we pretty much cleared our plates. We giggled amongst ourselves to overhear a loud conversation at the bar between the chef and a customer, when the chef was telling her how much he was sweating!!
Lynsey H . 2019-07-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
First time visit. Waited 15 mins before we prompted waitress for order to be taken, then went to table next to us as she assumed we had been served already as we were there that long! Asked basic questions regards the menu, but didn't know without checking. Food arrived in good time and was lovely. Waited ages for dessert. Eventually called waitress over and asked what was the hot pudding of the day. Didn't know so went and checked and came back. Then zero service. Like the table next door we gave up and went to the bar and paid up. Would give it one more go as food was nice, but oh, the service! Msg to owner... Train your staff!!!!
RichinLeics . 2019-06-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely food, hot and tasty. Not too expensive, varied menu and friendly staff. A characterful pub, lovely open fire (in the cold weather).
julie1948 . 2019-06-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Amazing food! Just expecting typical 'pub food' but was very wrong! We ordered faggots and were very impressed with the enormous bowl, carrying three enormous faggots and gallons of onion gravy. The food was actually too hot to eat, I always think that's a bonus and was delicious. Being greedy and having a day off from Weight Watchers went for puddings as well! Beautiful warm chocolate brownie with a jug of cream with so much cream in it even I couldn't finish it.
Jann B . 2019-06-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A party celebrating a family birthday 30 of us went to this lovely pub and from start to finish the whole night was fabulous. The food was faultless and beyond expectations of pub food. many of us having different dishes but all was beautiful and everyone commented how fantastic it was. The service was outstanding and staff very helpful and kind. Thankyou to all for a superb night. We will be back.
lewis10058 . 2019-06-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Pope’s I’m on the off chance they could fit us in
donnagarner . 2019-05-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Found this gem of a place while staying in the local area with my partner, we didn’t book a table just turned up and was fortunate enough to get the last unbooked table so glad we did the food was amazing and portion size huge partners fish was like a whale and my gammon was amazing would definitely recommend this place
Johnnysimpson84 . 2019-05-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Amazing food and friendly staff would definitely recommend to others, and we will definitely return!!
Ambassador774041 . 2019-05-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Been today for a birthday meal and we all had a great time, the food quality was spot on and myself I could have eaten all of the meals that was ordered as all the food was excellent
adamskiigoodwin . 2019-04-07
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A friendly pub with amazing food. Excellent range of food available and relaxing atmosphere. Never rushed to leave.
Steve G . 2019-04-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Similary restaurants in East Midlands
2288 Opinions
What a brilliant idea pop your self down seven wells etwall charity Xmas tree were you can buy a gift for a young child for Xmas well done to Sara and team
382 Opinions
Booked for my birthday very dissapointed, freezing cold, smells of damp toilet seats all loose smells of fusty damp ceiling taped up looks ready to fall down had to leave sorry couldn't stay and eat there menu was restricted any way. Definately won't be returning
215 Opinions
They didn't ask us to pre-order. There were 14 of us, seated at 2 tables - a table of 10 and a table of 4, which wasn't ideal. We had to wait over an hour for the main course, then over half an hour for dessert. The food was lovely and well-presented when it eventually arrived. If we go again, I think we should pre-order and also ask for the table layout to be different, so that we can all sit together.
131 Opinions
We love this place and come here regularly. First time ever I wasn't happy. The sausage meal was tasty but the veg were dire. Grossly overcooked tiny bits of carrot a few gratings of red cabbage and the tiniest bit of broccoli that would have been more appropriate for a toddler trying new foods!