Miller & Carter in Reigate and Banstead

From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting. The staff greeted us with genuine smiles and provided exceptional service throughout our meal—attentive without being intrusive. The food? Absolutely outstanding. Every dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. You can really taste the quality and freshness of the ingredients... everything was perfectly prepared. It’s rare to find a place that nails both food and service so flawlessly. Highly recommend this gem to anyone looking for a memorable dining experience. We will be definitely be coming back!

We came here to celebrate a birthday and had such a fantastic experience! The food was absolutely delicious—standouts were the tender pork ribs, the fresh and flavorful prawn salad, and the creamy mac and cheese, which was a real comfort dish done right. To top it all off, we were surprised with a complimentary dessert for the birthday celebration, which was a lovely and thoughtful touch. Our server, Kate, was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything went smoothly from start to finish. The only thing we’d love to see improved is the non-alcoholic drinks menu—some nicer mocktail options would really elevate the experience for those not drinking. Highly recommend for both the great food and warm service—we’ll definitely be back!

Took our grandchildren and throughly enjoyed our meal. Service was extremely good and the food was excellent. Will returning for my granddaughters 18th.

We ummm and arrrrd about going in here due to it looking dead which is rarely a good sign, so we took the chance, HUGE MISTAKE, Well upon going inside it looked dark and dead on the inside, very few customers, but we sat down, took longer than acceptable to get sorted with drinks but after all that time of waiting we had our food order ready, this is where the issues start, The elderly lady that was serving us decided to tell me that we only do steak pink , despite the menu and being the customer and Bill payers we should decide not the person serving us, then my partner said no to any whatsoever seasoning on the fries, repeated several times to waitress, waitress went away, An age had gone by in an almost empty pub and we hadn't got any food, eventually our food comes, The steak wasn't as I wanted and wasn't pink like I was told it can only be served, it was actually closer to well done?, my partners fries were still seasoned and there was a yellow type liquid on the bottom of my steak and the plate which was off putting, didn't really like the taste and the fries were over done, Considering Mcdonalds do fries and steak burger for about £8 each, this at £25 each wasn't value for money or good service in anyway compared, Eventually my partners almost full plate and mostly mine should of prompted 'was it OK' nope nothing, waitress took ages to get the bill, we paid and vowed NEVER to go back but goto Mcdonalds in future where you get substandard food and rubbish customer service without the over priced food, also Mcdonalds staff do not tell you how you can or can't have your food cooked, so 1 up to Mcdonalds in this case, IF Wetherspoons or Mcdonalds is an option go there when in Redhill, AVOID here unless you like wasting money and feeling stupid later for it.

Perfect steak. My wife suffers with Coeliac disease and the lady who took our order could not have been more helpful. I wish I had noted her name but she did say she doesn't normally work Sundays. Thank you 😊

First time eating at Miller and Carter, our server was called Katie and she was fantastic, very attentive and was allergen aware. Lovely interaction. Food was lovely! No complaints and will be coming back.

We when hear for the first time.tonight the meal was outstanding the atmosphere was lovely and then the young waitress that served us college student was lovely and very helpful so thank u xx

Great experience food lovely, waitress Donna was always checking making sure we had everything and we was happy, very cheerful too.

Had the worst delivery? Will never order again. Over cooked/Burnt steak that should have just entered the bin lone been sent out to a customer

Had a lovely dinner this evening, food was good, not its usual potential as it was very busy. I have to give credit to Donna for a lovely evening, very polite, funny & attentive. What a lovely woman! Will be back soon without a doubt.

Absolutely disgusted with this order

Visited for mother's day, the food was absolutely delicious, more than happy.

My husband and I went for his birthday. It was a very cold evening and Nicky, our waitress made sure we were seated by the radiator. She was very attentive and kind. The food was excellent.

The food was amazing and so was the atmosphere. Our waitress, Katie, was amazing and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our night. Thank you!

Donna was amazing. Friendly & professional.

Donna was amazing, really made the birthday special with her care and attention. Great service and great food!

Donna was a fantastic waitress and was attentive and lovely throughout our experience. Wonderful food and kind staff, a fantastic night all round! Thank you

Food was enjoyable and service from our waitress Donna was amazing

Donna was very friendly and everything was perfect

Donna was absolutely brilliant🤩the best waitress we have ever bet been served by☺️

Amazing place. My first time at a steakhouse and the staff were lovely. Our server was very helpful and sweet (didn’t catch her name but had ginger hair?). Will definitely be back :)

Amazing service, as we had some really unique orders/special requests. Thank you Katie and team. Food was lush.

Donna was exceptional sever .xx

Spontaneous dinner out which didn’t disappoint! Attentive and friendly staff and expansive menu. Our waitress for the evening was Donna and she was wonderful! Always made sure we were ok, with drinks and meals coming out in a timely manner. Meal quality was really good too, would definitely recommend the caramel biscuit torte if you have room!

Donna was great provided fantastic service, very attentive

Always friendly service and amazing food!

great service from adam had a smile on his face the whole time food was lovely

Absolute device food, Camembert mash is a winner, Donna was our waitress and she couldn’t have been more tentative, lovely conversation and had a laugh

What a lovely afternoon. Wonderful food and great atmosphere. Our waitress Donna was brilliant. Very attentive and helpful with suggestions. Great demeanour. A credit to Miller & Carter. Steve

Good food and service. Nikky, was fantastic and really friendly service.

Lovely service and amazing food. Had the ribeye as recommended and did not disappoint. The camembert starter was delicious.

First time visiting a miller & carter in about 6 years, Was blown away by the food, absolutely amazing, cooked exactly as requested, Katie was fantastic, checked to make sure everything was as we'd liked and just made us feel very welcome, really appreciated her service, The venue was very clean and well laid out, Many thanks definitely will visit again soon, Joe and Sarah.

Some plates of food came out cold, had to send two plates back. Our waitress was very good and endeavoured to resolve our problem. Love M&C restaurants

Donna served us and was an amazing host. Chatty , friendly and was very happy. The food was amazing and the merlot was delicious. Thank you Donna x

We ordered a sharing platter with 3 different steaks, also with bone marrow over beef brisket that was absolutely yummy,served with onion loaf which was like hash browns minus the potato. Yummy! Then we had salad which was weird as it was a quarter of a lettuce with the choice of our dressing on it in wooden bowl (basic) but if that's how they do it then so be it! We then just shared a sticky toffee pudding and omg WOW it was served with dates pureed on plate with ice-cream. Service was ok but the lady we had serving us must have had about 8 tables to serve. But the food was pretty good so thumbs up if you a steak head! Get yourself down there.

Sunday 2nd March 2025 - We went this evening to have the Sunday sharing board (our first time getting it). We waited about 45 minutes for the food. Overall, it was decent; the chicken was cooked well, but being served on the bone, it was a bit picky. We had the lamb served pink (there is also an option to have it served well done, but I wouldn't recommend), and it was okay but just kind of tasted like a normal steak. The Ribeye itself was nice and cooked properly (we got Medium, as recommend), but we agreed it is the wrong cut for this type of menu item: a Sirloin or Rump would be a much better option as they are less fatty/more consistent with where their fat is. The sides were very nice: crispy roast potatoes, camembert mash, sauteed greens and a yorkshire pudding each. The Beef Dripping Gravy was indeed unlimited, but fell short of expectations for some reason - it tasted more like the Red Wine sauce than the regular Beef Dripping Gravy, we thought maybe it was a slightly different version exclusive to this dish? For anyone after a Sunday roast sharer, this is a good one and I would recommend trying it, I would say it is worth the price considering how much and the quality of what you get (£65.50 makes it £32.75/person, which is on the higher side for a decent Roast dinner). I think we'll personally stick to the steak in the future.

Excellent meal and service by Donna, table was a little small for the Sunday Roast sharer, but we coped.

Visited with my partner tonight and had the butchers block. The service by Donna was amazing, drinks and food arrived quickly and was delicious. Service 10/10

Donna was amazing and very helpful, she made our trip here very special and we’ll definitely be back, thank you so much Donna!!!!

Katie was a fantastic server, very attentive even on a very busy Saturday evening. Made sure we were topped up drink wise and made sure we were all sorted with our food throughout the evening. Thank you Katie 👍🏻

Food was bland steaks not much flavour if it wasn’t for the sauce it would have been terrible. Was our anniversary and had a horrible meal didn’t get much service after ordering and once our food arrived, we wanted a drink but didn’t get approached again. Really wouldn’t recommend to anyone I heard good things which is why I came but won’t be coming back that’s for sure

We had a meal here early Saturday evening with Donna as our waitress. She is very helpful and friendly and gave us recommendations for the food which tasted great. She was also brilliant with our son. Highly recommend the restaurant and thanks Donna for being fab.

Awful! Special birthday and despite my daughter having photographic ID (student ID) the waitress wouldn’t accept it. My daughter’s steak was just fat, waitress was unapologetic, and on her phone. We paid and left - leaving half the food and will never return! Appalling!

Stunning. 10/10! We were welcomed immediately, given a great table and our server was super lovely. Our son requested M&C for his special birthday dinner and the staff here certain made it extra special by not only noticing his birthday badges and making a fuss but by bringing him a special dessert and singing Happy Birthday. The food was divine. Great quality, cooked to perfection, hot and delicious! We’ve been to M&C twice before but in different locations and this Salfords branch was the best experience by a mile. Thank you. We will certainly be back!

We had Donna as our server tonight and she was amazing. Super energetic, friendly, kind and respectful. Food was amazing 5/5⭐️

It’s always a great atmosphere and always great food here. The service was great too! Beatrix was lovely and professional, made us feel very welcome. Every member of staff was smiling every time passing by so very nice!

Food was fantastic, reception was a little slow to be seated, not even acknowledged and told will be seen when ready, but service at the the table was great. Looking forward to the next visit...

Donna was amazing, lovely service

The quality of the food was outstanding, staff was very open to accommodating our children in terms of changing/adding items on the younger guests menus. We also had a vegetarian in the group who was pleased with the selection considering it’s a steak house. The whole group had a fabulous night and will be back to eat there soon.

Amazing valentine's meal. Excellent, friendly and attentive service from Donna in particular. Great venue for special occasions.

Matt rocks! Well managed restaurant, excellent food and service

Wagyu steak was amazing, tasted great and cooked perfectly medium. Cauliflower wings starter were amazing, and mango pavlova was very good and light. Atmosphere was great and server Jeanie checked up on us many times to ensure everything was up to standard.

Lovely food as always and 10/10 service from Donna

Donna was amazing!! So friendly and provided a great experience. Will definitely return!

Had a fantastic lunch at Miller & Carter Salfords! I was thoroughly impressed by the exceptional quality of the food and the outstanding service. The dishes were not only delicious but also beautifully presented. A special shoutout to our waitress, Donna, who made the experience even better with her warm and attentive service. She was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. Highly recommend this place for a great meal and top-notch service!

Went for a lovely celebration dinner on Friday. First time at the salford branch. The food was nice and Donna looked after us so well and was very attentive. Will definitely be back again

We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and left feeling more than satisfied. We decided to treat ourselves, and this place did not disappoint in the slightest. From the moment we walked through the door, we were greeted with a warm and friendly welcome. The staff were incredibly polite, attentive, and courteous, making us feel right at home. We were quickly shown to our table, and our drinks were served promptly, giving us just the right amount of time to peruse the menu and decide on our meals. The service was seamless, with staff checking in without being intrusive. When the food arrived, it was clear that a lot of care had gone into its presentation—it looked as delicious as it smelled. The flavours did not disappoint either. The steaks were cooked perfectly to our requests, tender and full of that rich, meaty flavour. The burgers were a standout too—juicy, well-seasoned, and bursting with taste. One particular highlight was the beefy, dripping sauce that accompanied the meal. It was packed with depth of flavour but subtle enough not to overpower the dishes. We couldn’t resist staying for dessert, and that decision was well worth it. The tiramisu was simply divine—light, creamy, and perfectly balanced with just the right hint of coffee and cocoa. From start to finish, the experience was delightful, and we left feeling thoroughly pleased. We’re already looking forward to our next visit and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience.

Beatrix was the best server very nice evening had by me and my husband

We had a wonderful time made all the better by the lovely Beatrix

The food was excellent the service was faultless thanks to our waitress Donna. She couldn’t have done a better job and even gave me a free birthday desert!

Food here like the other M&C is exceptional. However this one restaurant seems to struggle when busy and we were left waiting to ask for the bill for over 15 minutes, which considering you should be able to grab a waiter frequently as they walk past, they all seemed to vanish. So we had no choice but to leave the table and pay at the front.

Really great meal and service! Thank you jeanie who served us tonight

Had a dinner date night . It was our first time at the restaurant and it was excellent service. The staff were brilliant and didn't stop moving at all. They moved like a true team . The only downside was that the creme brulee didn't have the crisp sugar top that it should have. Excellent chateaubriand the sautéed greens were brilliant perfect amount of crisp.

Outstanding service by matt, thoroughly enjoyed our evening!!

Beautiful meal and good atmosphere. Many thanks to Matt our steak expert for suggesting to go medium with the ribeye as it made the fat marbling deliciously soft!

Everything was amazing. Donna was caring and attentive and very polite. Thank you

Lovely food, been several times. Amazing service from Donna thank you, extremely friendly and professional thank you Donna

Beatrix was a lovely waitress and we had a great family birthday meal

We had the £28.95, 3 course meal each. Fillet steak and sirloin respectively. Both seasoned to perfection, cooked to our choice. Apple and rhubarb crumble and custard for pudding. Id score this a 5 out of 5, there were some minor points that Im probably too picky about, so Im focusing on how lovely it all was. Beatrix the waitress was awesome. We are going again soon.

Beatrix was amazing as always- so attentive, extremely friendly she always has a smile on her face and nothing we ever ask for is ever too much! We regularly visit this restaurant and we love her as a waitress (so do the children) thank you!

Gorgeous burger and wonderful dessert

Had a lovely meal food was superb the service was great

The food was absolutely amazing and delicious but I think what made the experience better was our waiter Reece, he was extremely kind and patient, he was always smiling when we saw him and at the end of the night he even engaged in little conversation with us as we were paying. It was very welcoming. 10/10 customer service

Donna was very friendly and efficient

The food was great and Donna was so so attentive and took good care of us. Will definitely be returning.

Love coming here. Food is great and Donna is always so friendly and provides amazing service!! Thank you

Donna was a fabulous host. The food was perfect! Best steak I’ve had here in a long time

Jeanie was an amazing hostess, very friendly. The food was delicious, the portion sizes are waaaaaaaay too big for lunch but we really enjoyed!

Donna was fantastic! So friendly and welcoming! Food and drinks were delicious

Food amazing very clean restaurant

Reece looked after us and he was very attentive and gave us a great service. The food was brilliant too. Thank you

Kerry was marvellous. She knows how to look after you. Well recommended.

Lovely dinner with great service from Donna! :) Very accommodating and helpful, great food, including desserts :))))

I was served by the lovely Donna. The service and food were excellent! I would definitely recommend to a friend. 10/10 experience, will be back soon!

Donna was brilliant. very friendly and efficient

Donna serves me everytime I come in here and she is amazing. Very polite and always welcoming.

Had a great meal with the family, service by Kerry was fantastic!

We had a fantastic meal at Miller and Carter. Donna looked after us so well, friendly, kind and attentive service. Meal was at a lovely pace and we had a throughly lovely time. We will be back.

Really lovely meal for our anniversary. Thank you to Donna for fab service

1st time ever at M&C - absolutely fab experience - steaks were cooked to perfection - everything was perfect. Lovely staff. Cant wait to return again!!

Lovely service, really delicious steak. Thanks Donna our waitress

Lovely meal served by Donna, very enjoyable

Super impressed having made a last minute decision to eat out to avoid any more Christmas food. It wasn’t busy when we arrived but within an hour it was full and there were queues at the door. We were served by Elli, she was clearly rushed off her feet but was very friendly and super efficient. We both ate the Dirty burgers, absolutely delicious but the winner was the beef dripping gravy … what a combo! We will be back that’s for sure.

Amazing food! Really enjoyed it

Christmas day lunch was overpriced and poor quality. This is the third year we have been to this restaurant for Christmas lunch. In past years it has been very good but this year it was terrible. The waiting staff, whilst pleasant, did not seem to know what they were doing: we were brought food we did not order, and the wrong bottle of wine was presented. Fortunately this was noted before it was opened. The main course was cold when brought to the table. We were expecting slices of turkey, instead we were given a roll of turkey wrapped up in a small rasher of bacon. It was dry and inedible. The vegetables were undercooked and hard. Dessert was an apple tart. It was tough and difficult to cut let alone eat. It was accompanied by the smallest scoop of ice cream I have ever seen. The coffee was great!!! Won't be going again, ever.

Unbelievable service from Donna , picky bunch cantered for everyone 10/10

Donna was lovely very helpful, amazing service

Our waitress Donna has been absolutely incredible, our party had a nut allergy and gluten free dietaries, she explained everything we needed to know She was also so professional, friendly and really informative. Couldn’t recommend her enough

Visited with family. Donna our waitress was fantastic. Couldn’t do enough for us. Food was lovely. Will definitely be coming back. Would highly recommend

Our host Jeanie, was an absolute delight. Jeanie was an excellent host and catered to both my partner and I needs. Made me feel very at home and comfortable. The food was devine and my partner and I will certainly be coming back here on our date evenings and will be requesting Jeanie for her superb hospitality and care towards her customers! If your ever at Miller and Carter salfords request this lovely lady! 🫶🏼