GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4,5

Based on 456 opinions finded in 2 websites

4.5Ambience4.5Cuisine4.5Service
site_photo4

Nº 649 in 2913 in Edinburgh, City of

Nº 5 of 12 Scottish in Edinburgh, City of

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH.. fishchickenold

comment_iconOpinions

We went just for a drink. I didn't like to gin cocktail, but it was not fault of the bar. Atmosphere there was nice :)

site_logo

kristyneckanejkrasne . 2024-04-28

MORE AT Google

Honestly the restaurant is just perfect The service is very fast, the staff is helpful, the meal is just perfect. I had a Highland chicken nugget 😉 My family had fish and chips and haggis a nugget too😍 For a very first evening in Scotland I am not disappointed to come to your place 😉

site_logo

Mael Kerspern . 2024-04-26

MORE AT Google

Really nice atmosphere, however very slow service, and the food was not the best either. Burnt chicken, and the fish and chips was very oily.

site_logo

Szörnyi Márta . 2024-04-26

MORE AT Google

The hype is real people. Great food and great selection of drinks. Will go again if we visit the area.

site_logo

Carson Heslop . 2024-04-20

MORE AT Google

Dream Pab great beer and whisky

site_logo

Sergio Moroni . 2024-04-12

MORE AT Google

Very nice place, friendly staff and quality drinks!

site_logo

Sotiris Papaleonidas . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

Absolutely love this hidden gem - the best authentic food in Scotland for a reasonable price, large portions too. Service is great as well - had to come twice in our trip we loved it so much!

site_logo

Teeghan McGann . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

I ate "The George Burger" and it was one of the best burgers I've eaten. It was very tasteful and the chef had thought about every little detail. I really recomend McGongalls.

site_logo

Sebastian Fahlander . 2024-04-03

MORE AT Google

Delicious food, great whiskey flights, awesome live music

site_logo

Sophie Cutts . 2024-03-30

MORE AT Google

The best bloody marys I've ever had. Veggie haggis to die for. Wonderful atmosphere, fantastic service.

site_logo

Anna Ronewicz . 2024-03-25

MORE AT Google

In for drinks - its ok not sure I'd say there was anything to make it stand out

site_logo

Grand MoFF . 2024-03-24

MORE AT Google

Beautiful pub on one of the main streets of Old Edinburgh. Large room with several seats which is not usual in places in this area. The beers are good, finally someone with Tennents on tap. The soups and pies are good.

site_logo

Michele Elia . 2024-03-23

MORE AT Google

A really nice pub but staff let it down. Doorman was aloof and miserable dealing with 50 yr old adults. Bar person was uninterested and again aloof. As an Edinburgh resident you need to remember that a percentage of your trade comes from locals

site_logo

David . 2024-03-17

MORE AT Google

My wife and I enjoyed a meal and bottle of wine here with our 2 dogs. The servers could not do enough for us and our dogs so why the star loss you'll ask. Well I'm gluten free and the options for me to chose from were very limited albeit the fried haloumi and nachos with bacon were very tasty!

site_logo

Liam Barry . 2024-03-16

MORE AT Google

Lovely place. Highly recommend it. Staff were amazing.

site_logo

Jaz Wood . 2024-03-15

MORE AT Google

Went here recently, the food was fab (recommended the veggie haggis spring rolls!). Lovely decor and the staff were nice. Only gripe is the website said the cocktails were £9.75, however when we got there the menu stated they were £11. Would come back nonetheless :)

site_logo

Miz07 . 2024-03-15

MORE AT Google

Staff and environment was welcoming food was excellent, recommend the pie of the day and the Scottish coffee

site_logo

Vicki Rahenkamp . 2024-03-13

MORE AT Google

What a wonderful spot! We were a bunch of Americans with crazy cocktail requests (that no other spot in Edinburgh would fulfill), but the folks here took the time to look up the cocktails and make it! So grateful. The men on our trip ordered a whiskey tasting and the employees were incredibly knowledgeable about which one to try as they were novices. The deep fried mars bar is worth the calories (at least once). Went back a second night during our trip and there was live music. Great atmosphere for drinks with friends!

site_logo

jillianbrodie02 . 2024-03-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Not welcoming for kitchen s timing.... We came two successive nights for dinner and a drink. Both times for a bit of time we ve been rejected. The menu for drinks is awesome and the place beautiful. The hospitality matters as well.

site_logo

SHAREexperience75 . 2024-03-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent food, fantastic veggie burger. Friendly and helpful staff. 10/10 would be recommended

site_logo

Serena Borello . 2024-03-08

MORE AT Google

I was in Edinburgh meeting old friends, it just so happened that Scotland were playing France for the six nations meaning the atmosphere in the city was rather energetic. We looked for a quiet place and from the window we could see this bar had a lot of character and the menu was interesting so we went in and stayed for a good couple of hours. Staff were fantastic, food was amazing.

site_logo

Mister Daz . 2024-03-07

MORE AT Google

The staff are very caring and welcoming, and the food portions are very good! I had the veggie haggis, neeps and tatties. As well as a deep fried mars bar - both were amazing! I would definitely come back!

site_logo

Peter James . 2024-03-03

MORE AT Google

Very calm and comfy place, food is delicious (I recommend sausage in Yorkshire pudding) and Aino, the amazing waitress that served us, is the most sunny person i’ve ever come across. My boyfriend and I have spent 8 days in Edinburgh and we came here twice. Also the local is very clean, unlike so many in the city. Loved the vibe, the food and - most of all - Aino, really feels like sun in this rainy beautiful city.

site_logo

Elisa Turchi . 2024-02-24

MORE AT Google

Spent a wonderful afternoon in this pub. Cocktails were amazing. Nachos fab. Staff so friendly.

site_logo

Annmarie Rogers . 2024-02-21

MORE AT Google

A very nice and quiet place to taste a good beer

site_logo

Juan Francisco Carrera Fernandez . 2024-02-11

MORE AT Google

Whisky flights and the Rum Old Fshioned too. Staff were also nice.

site_logo

Scott Knight . 2024-01-20

MORE AT Google

Excellent place we had to visit and have a well earned bevvy. Extra fun due to the name as our family are true Harry Potter fans. Can highly recommend their different gin flights. A good way to test different types of gin to get an understanding that there are more than just classic GTs. Food was also good. We had to leave quite early though as we had under aged kids.

site_logo

Björn Ridell . 2024-01-16

MORE AT Google

Très bons cocktails avec un personnel très aimable. Très bonne ambiance

site_logo

Louise Lefevre . 2024-01-16

MORE AT Google

Only popped in for a couple of pre-dinner drinks......😊

site_logo

Fiona Reid . 2024-01-10

MORE AT Google

Muy buen Pub. Rica cerveza y buena comida. Una buena opción en el centro de Edimburgo

site_logo

Gabriel Aldazabal . 2024-01-03

MORE AT Google

Great bar to have a beer and à cocktail

site_logo

Justine EVANGELISTA . 2024-01-02

MORE AT Google

The place is very nice, the staff is super friendly (and knowledgeable on whisky and gins) and the food is good. Definitely one of the best Mac'n Cheese I've had in my life. Really loved the place!

site_logo

Julie Bélanger . 2024-01-02

MORE AT Google

Nice place to enjoy a drink. Whisky, gin and cocktails. Staff are very nice. In the old town close to lots of amenities and restaurants. Would definitely recommend. Didn't try the food so can't comment but it did look good.

site_logo

lynn houlton . 2024-01-02

MORE AT Google

Amazing service, best Bangers and Mash I've had to date, kudos to the chef!! Thankyou from Australia!

site_logo

Nick Wirth . 2024-01-01

MORE AT Google

Bon petit restaurant pas trop cher à Edimbourg. J'ai adoré

site_logo

nat_BN . 2024-01-01

MORE AT Google

Nice, cozy place. Good selection of drinks - include warm alcoholic drinks

site_logo

Pamela Ska . 2023-12-25

MORE AT Google

Nice drink and nice song. The envirolment was amazing! Very friendly workers. Really enjoy the time there, I strongly recomend to visit this place 😍

site_logo

Larissa D . 2023-12-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Stumbled upon this fantastic place while wandering Edinburgh on our first day. We were drawn in by the name and won over by the delicious drinks, phenomenal food, reasonable prices, and hospitable service. Highly recommend the fish and chips and the pie of the week!

site_logo

Rachel Streib . 2023-12-11

MORE AT Google

Chanced upon McGonagalls Gin and Whisky bar on the way back from visiting Edinburgh Castle. Was feel quite peckish, so I went in. The bar is nice with live music the night I visited. The staff were attentive and polite. The food is of a high standard and fairly priced. It's worth a visit if you are in the area.

site_logo

Tim Fisher . 2023-12-08

MORE AT Google

All the staff were really friendly. We popped in twice over a couple of days. We enjoyed not only the drinks but the food too. We had bangers and mash, chicken breast stuffed with haggis and the deep fried mars bar.

site_logo

Carol Morris . 2023-12-06

MORE AT Google

What an amazing experience?! We came in because it was listed as a place that offered both whiskey and gin flights and not all of our group likes whiskey, but what we did not expect was the level of quality, quantity and service value we received! We came in right around 11am and stay until nearly 2:30 and were never rushed or shooed out the door. The staff were so fantastic and friendly. Offered us recommendations and pairings. It felt like you were welcomed and wanted throughout the whole visit. The 5 of us enjoyed flights, cocktails and nibbles. Highlights were the Dessert Flight (some very surprising whiskies on there), the Rivers and Oceans Flight (loved all 3 offerings and the tonic pairs were great) and the SCOT EGGS! Honestly, it was the best jammy egg- just perfect!! We will be back!

site_logo

Tracy Green . 2023-12-04

MORE AT Google

Amazing drinks. Bramble is new favorite drink. And the BEST vegan fish & chips! The batter is insane. I would come back to Edinburgh just for these. I’ve told everyone I know about it!

site_logo

Cali Carter . 2023-12-02

MORE AT Google

What a great find, staff helpful and friendly, we spent two evenings at the Gin & Whisky Emporium with live music on the Monday evening, would highly recommend.

site_logo

R P . 2023-11-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great place,ambiance,friendly staff,food was yummy!! Had the haggis stuffed chicken wrapped in bacon! Would definitely recommend!!

site_logo

liz simmons . 2023-11-29

MORE AT Google

Lovely place, been there twice now about a year apart through travelling for work, excellent food, service, drinks and atmosphere. Place is great inside and great value for money. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a casual place to eat or drink in Edinburgh centre.

site_logo

Jack Chaytor . 2023-11-19

MORE AT Google

Great ambience and an amazing whisky list with 40+ single malts (and blended of course) to choose from! Their "whiskey flights" (essentially your own whisky tasting with three different sorts) comes highly recommended!

site_logo

Erik Ask-Upmark . 2023-11-18

MORE AT Google

I ate there twice, the servers are smiling and friendly, the food is excellent and local, the alcohol and cocktails are tasty

site_logo

rom lla . 2023-11-13

MORE AT Google

Very nicely decorated, staff are friendly and helpful. The gin trays are 😘😘. We went on a Sunday night, they had a singer on.

site_logo

Jess . 2023-11-07

MORE AT Google

Only group in the restaurant today at around noon. Took about 10 minutes for someone to speak to us. The two servers were chatting the whole time and neglecting us. They asked us how everything was when billing us out… we said the service could have been better. The server then laughed at our honesty. Extremely rude and will not be back.

site_logo

Jesse Phillips . 2023-11-07

MORE AT Google

Cozy spot with great cocktails and food.

site_logo

Chad Rogers . 2023-10-31

MORE AT Google

It was the most perfect Burger i have ever had. 10/10

site_logo

Anna Kaczmarek . 2023-10-28

MORE AT Google

Good food and drinks, great service.

site_logo

Robert Finneide . 2023-10-27

MORE AT Google

Wonderful food and drinks. I took a soup of the day(garlic and tomatoes) and it was truly one of the best soup I have ever eaten. However the waitresses could have been more smiley! :)

site_logo

Delphine . 2023-10-23

MORE AT Google

Must visit for any tourists! Visited for partners birthday weekend away and they really made everything special for us and her !

site_logo

Rauno Riener . 2023-10-21

MORE AT Google

Chouette pub où nous avons déjeuné. Bon burger, bon fish and chips et bonne « pie of the day » (poulet oignons). On a passé un bon moment.

site_logo

Céline . 2023-10-15

MORE AT Google

Delicious Cullen skink, cool decor, and friendly service.

site_logo

Denise Gierhart . 2023-10-14

MORE AT Google

All was going ok until we didn’t get service after 2 rounds because apparently we were drunk when we were only having a laugh the waiter didn’t know the difference between drunk and having a laugh we clearly wasn’t drunk shocking

site_logo

Un T . 2023-10-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent choice of drinks, beautiful surroundings, with helpful & friendly staff.

site_logo

Darren Weatherby . 2023-10-07

MORE AT Google

Todo estuvo muy delicioso, nos atendieron amablemente y el lugar es increíble, seguro regresaremos

site_logo

Tania Gonzalez . 2023-10-04

MORE AT Google

Fun place! Loved the whisky flights. Service was good.

site_logo

Kaitlyn Crews . 2023-10-01

MORE AT Google

We stopped in here for a few drinks, and a small bite and left with such a wonderful experience. They had great drinks and the macaroni and cheese was absolutely delicious. The service was great. The location was great. Just overall a great spot to stop if you’re in the area.

site_logo

tahneelynn . 2023-09-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A very cosy Pub with good food and drinks. Especially the flair of the Pub and the whiskey tasting is worth it.

site_logo

FullOfSunshine . 2023-09-24

MORE AT Google

The staff was lovely and helpful, the pub looks great and very homely. Loads of space for all incoming visitors. The food, unfortunately, left something to be desired. The Highland chicken was very dry and chewy and the watery whisky sauce just barely made up for it. Food left aside, it's a great place for cocktails and other drinks!!!!

site_logo

Akalisette . 2023-09-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great place, service and delicious drinks !

site_logo

Daria T. . 2023-09-16

MORE AT Google

Todo excelente especialmente la atención del mozo que nos atendió. Lo recomiendo mucho

site_logo

M Laura . 2023-09-03

MORE AT Google

Personnel nice. Fast and good service. The decoration is well. Many choice of Whisky Scottish Cullen Skink soup is very good.

site_logo

aline68500 . 2023-09-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The food is excellent and they were kind enough to accommodate us on the bar table for dinner

site_logo

Denis Juliette . 2023-08-30

MORE AT Google

Absolute Empfehlung. Leckeres Essen, freundliches Personal und ein tolles Ambiente. Hier wird er Dram so serviert wie man es sich wünscht (siehe Foto). Einfach richtig gut.

site_logo

Insel Insel . 2023-08-27

MORE AT Google

Best vegan fish&chips, please try them, they sound weird but are sooo amazing!! Very tasty cocktails as well!

site_logo

Natascha De . 2023-08-26

MORE AT Google

Best food I’ve had in Scotland - So tasty and fresh :) I had the Highlander Chicken and someone else had the pie of the day. Our plates were spotless by the end The staff were so friendly and asking if we needing anything

site_logo

B D . 2023-08-26

MORE AT Google

Sehr schön, leckere Getränke, gerne w👍

site_logo

Elvira Hartmann . 2023-08-24

MORE AT Google

Nice place, lovely staff, and very tasty fries with garlic mayo.

site_logo

Katerina O'Connor . 2023-08-20

MORE AT Google

Sehr gute und umfangreiche Auswahl am Whisky und Gin, leckeres Essen (Pub-Food). Tolles Ambiente.

site_logo

Andy Kracht . 2023-08-17

MORE AT Google

Super service. Copieux et prix raisonnable

site_logo

BLANC Mathieu . 2023-08-13

MORE AT Google

Shauna, the singer, was amazing and drew us in off the street. Only got to hear her for one song though. So talented! Thank you!

site_logo

Aileen McGregor . 2023-08-10

MORE AT Google

Neil was such an excellent server. Really looked after us when it was obviously pretty busy during the festival. Our food was good. Our drinks were good. Service was swift snd attentive. And it wasn't too expensive. Great choice. Especially if you get Neil.

site_logo

Brightoncardinal . 2023-08-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a reunion with friends here yesterday. We had a great time and would recommend food and drinks. I can recommend the deep-fried Mars bar and the cocktails.

site_logo

Nick Shaw . 2023-08-06

MORE AT Google

Neil was a super friendly host. The food was great. The drinks were good too (real ale would be better than keg) All in all, we're delighted we stopped in there

site_logo

Nigel Summers . 2023-08-05

MORE AT Google

Great food and good service. Went there two nights in a row! Dogfriendly!!!

site_logo

Colette Notenboom . 2023-08-03

MORE AT Google

This spot is great for friendly atmosphere, nice food and a hugs selection of drinks. It definitely deserves a visit!

site_logo

Roving661910 . 2023-07-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Amazing selection of gins as well as other beverages. Had the salmon which was excellent 😋

site_logo

Sonofgus Tasha . 2023-07-24

MORE AT Google

L'ambiance du bar/restaurant est agréable. Grand choix de boissons et cocktails. Les plats étaient bons, notamment le mac&cheese. Par contre, nous avons eu des frais de service de 5 £ ajoutés à la fin bien qu'ils ne soient annoncés nulle part sur le menu. Dommage

site_logo

Marie S . 2023-07-21

MORE AT Google

Rustic and interesting. Really good gin cocktails and it is very comfortable inside. We got lucky and got to listen to live music. Really worth a stop.

site_logo

VKM85 . 2023-07-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Hier ist alles gut - schönes Ambiente, netter Service, leckeres Essen (Burger&Fish and Chips) und gute Getränke :-)

site_logo

K P . 2023-07-15

MORE AT Google

McGonagalls ist ein sehr gemütlicher Pub mit live Musik und einer tollen Auswahl an Whiskys. Das Essen am Abend ist zu empfehlen.

site_logo

Kristina E. . 2023-07-15

MORE AT Google

We spent both of our two nights in Edinburgh here and didn’t regret it :-) great service, great drinks and great food! Would definitely recommend.

site_logo

Lena Schmitz . 2023-07-15

MORE AT Google

Excellent food and great selection of drinks. Price was good given the food and location. Service was pretty inconsistent, the food came out quickly and was quite good but I had to get up from the table and go to the bar to get a drink because after the food arrived the staff seemed to be absorbed in other tasks and pretty much ignored me.

site_logo

EEpotter . 2023-07-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very comfy and cozy place, great cocktails, a good selection of whiskey and live music in the evening

site_logo

Merel van de Weem . 2023-07-13

MORE AT Google

We spotted this gem on our way to Diagon Alley with the kids and went back to try out the food. We have dietary restrictions and they were awesome with gluten free and vegan options. Great atmosphere and very friendly and helpful staff. Highly recommend.

site_logo

Carrie B . 2023-07-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

On a day visit to Edinburgh we visited to have a meal on the last night of our holiday, I had haggis, neeps and tatties, the others had highland chicken, burgers and fish and chips, followed by a deep fried mars bar, service was quick and friendly and food was fab!

site_logo

bod1000 . 2023-07-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had a few hours free and stopped in here to sample some whisky. We did that, plus we stayed for some delicious Mac and Cheese and the Deli Board. The servers were extremely nice. We really enjoyed the whisky flights as well as the food we had. I am sorry we did not get to come back on this visit, and try some more of their menu items. I genuinely enjoyed our time there.

site_logo

Mobile317771 . 2023-07-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This was a great lunch spot! I got the haggis, neeps (turnips), & tatties (potatoes). We also tried the haggis spring rolls and the shortbread cranachen. Everything was delicious! Servers were very nice too.

site_logo

Kelli K . 2023-06-29

MORE AT Google

Best haggis I had in Scotland over my 5-day visit. Very nice staff and great atmosphere.

site_logo

Aurelien T . 2023-06-28

MORE AT Google

Unfortunately, I slipped outside of the bar, which had absolutely nothing to do with them, and I went in seeking a plaster. The young lady who helped me was kind and sympathetic to my injuries. I write this as a thanks to her, and as...

site_logo

secondhandpoet . 2023-06-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ein ganz tolles Lokal ,sehr leckeres Essen ,sehr nette Mitarbeiter

site_logo

Anja Meyn . 2023-06-18

MORE AT Google

Absolutely gorgeous place, quirky and original with friendly staff. Food was amazing as were the cocktails. I'm coming back with Family in August and we will definitely have this on our list

site_logo

238jacquil . 2023-06-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great range of food and drink available, presented beautifully on wooden menus. Staff were efficient but not overly friendly. Plenty of spacious, comfortable seating. Toilets were clean but were quite a walk down some stairs.

site_logo

Nalani P . 2023-06-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We ate at restaurant as part of a group tour. Food was ample and tasted great. I would come here again on my own. Service was the best we had while in this city.

site_logo

Eugene Roering . 2023-06-05

MORE AT Google

Nice little find in Edinburgh. Decent atmosphere and also not too dear

site_logo

Ron Norman . 2023-06-04

MORE AT Google

Was a really good find. Had one of their whisky flights and an Old Fashioned to drink. Good whisky selection there and knowledgeable bartender. For food, had the Scottish Egg and smoked salmon starters and both were good. Would say 4.5 rating rounded up. Would recommend trying this place.

site_logo

Dave Hong . 2023-06-01

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian

restaurant_img
4,5

2749 Opinions

The Piper's Rest Public House
location-icon3 Hunter Square Royal Mile, Edinburgh EH1 1QW Scotland
Scottish

This place is an ideal venue to watch the 6 Nations rugby and to get food. The table service is fantastic and would definitely recommend.

fishchickenold
restaurant_img
4,5

759 Opinions

The Bonnington
location-icon284 Bonnington Road
Scottish

I was pretty baffled at the experience I had here this week- I understand that this is a pub environment however, frankly, it's quite a nice pub, and I had been looking forward to coming here for food

fishchickenold
restaurant_img
4,7

1057 Opinions

Seeds For The Soul
location-icon167 Bruntsfield Place
Scottish

Overall it was a nice experience but I wish they pay more attention to the ingredients they use! It feels better if vegan food is also healthy for instance the mango chutney over the falafel was basic

fishchickenold