Based on 5.970 opinions finded in 3 websites
Based on 5.970 opinions finded in 3 websites
Nº 1440 in 2913 in Edinburgh, City of
Nº 189 of 413 British in Edinburgh, City of
Opinions
What a wonderful place! The service was great and the pie was amazing!
Claire Gudewich . 2024-11-19
MORE AT Google
A good cider to accompany haggis and tatties. What else?
Prune Eredit . 2024-11-17
MORE AT Google
incredibly cozy place! The staff is very friendly, the atmosphere is cozy, the food was without exception very tasty, we were in this pub two days in a row. Thank you for a great time!
Oleksandra D . 2024-11-16
MORE AT Google
Found the greyfriar while wandering around the area and introduduced by the story of bobby by the road corner. 1st time pub goer in Edinburgh, protocol was to find a table then order, pay and wait for dinner and drink to be served. Finally had the opportunity to try a traditional fish pie and dark ale. Pie had some chunks of haddock, salmon and shrimp in creamy herby potato base and topped with melted cheese-wished ratio was more on the fish side but still delicious. Serving was solo and came with a side of long stemmed broccoli and carrot spears seasoned well. Guiness ale paired well. Ambiance was great for a friday evening and service was efficient.
Rick Lu . 2024-11-16
MORE AT Google
Reasonably priced and delicious pub fare, and wasn't too crowded at lunchtime despite the iconic location. A lovely "Scottish" experience! Food was served incredibly quickly. There's a great selection of beer, and the bar staff are friendly.
Kelsey Thompson . 2024-11-15
MORE AT Google
Management couldn't do anything about it
Floris Gefken . 2024-11-15
MORE AT Google
was honestly really lovely, even though it was a bit busy but it was not too overwhelming and still a very lovely and cozy atmosphere to be in. food was brilliant as well, real big fan of the mac n’ cheese! personally could’ve been a bit of a bigger portion but that’s more a personal preference if anything
Ghost . 2024-11-15
MORE AT Google
Hi, On'8th of NOvember we had a dinner in your pub. When we paid Mr. Christopher charged us twice for dinner (I have got the receipts); he said that you reimburse one payment immediately, but we don't received nothing. Could you provide as soon as possible?
Marcella Guzzinati . 2024-11-14
MORE AT Google
Pretty decent place. Personel didn't seem to really notice you. Took some time for someone to come to us as you had to be seated by an employee (and they were not busy at all.) Also had to ask to order as noone came up to us after reviewing the menu etc. Nothing to extreme just slightly disappointing. Employees were nice enough though, just not very aware. Decent food though and overall not too bad!
Isabelle Engelhard . 2024-11-12
MORE AT Google
Good food, wide choice of beer, but service was a bit slow.
Michał Małachowski . 2024-11-10
MORE AT Google
Very nice pub with a cozy atmosphere inside. However, very pricey for drinks
Stacey Berkhout . 2024-11-09
MORE AT Google
I loved the food,service and the atmosphere,will go again
Tulay Godekli . 2024-11-03
MORE AT Google
Very Expensive for what you get. Forgettable food. Seems to be very geared towards tourists and using their name to draw people in. Can't recommend it. Lots of other great places nearby.
SM C . 2024-11-02
MORE AT Google
Really nice bar, food was tasty, pleasant atmosphere and the live music was great. The service was always very attentive, friendly and helpful, although on two different evenings we were asked to leave in a relatively unfriendly manner about 30-45 minutes before the bar closed, which seemed a little strange to us.
Hannah N . 2024-10-30
MORE AT Google
Very good restaurant, the welcome was perfect. The dishes were very good. Unfortunately the price is still high, but there is good value for money if you come to Edinburgh
Leal Q . 2024-10-30
MORE AT Google
Visited this place with my family. I was SHOCKED at how stand off-ish and rude the manager was. I came here once during the fringe which was a positive experience but this won’t won’t have me back. Seems like different people and was not impressed. Won’t be back.
Razz S . 2024-10-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Really good food and excellent pint
tony wheate . 2024-10-26
MORE AT Google
Lovely place, we feared it would be a tourist trap but it was one of the better pubs we visited in Edinburgh. Decent drinks and nice filling food, although their whiskies are incredibly pricey.
Eva Butkovičová . 2024-10-24
MORE AT Google
The interior is nice but I'll put it this way you wouldn't want to go in hungry. I'll be honest if could no stars I would We waited an hour for the food for the first dish and the carrots were raw me and 3 other friends came here the rest of the food was over an hour late. One of my friends waited an hour and a half and the chips as part of the burger were half cooked and didn't get her food until an hour and a half passed to say we all were disappointed is an understatement. I would not recommend it to anyone.
Shannon O'Shea . 2024-10-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
In the restaurant, you have to sit down and place your order at the counter. You take your drinks. The waitress gave us our dishes, didn't even really take us into account. She was not warm or smiling. Our table was wobbly. The dishes were good and hot.
m2as . 2024-10-23
MORE AT Google
Really nice place where to eat! I had the sausage and mash and it was delicious, my friend had the vegetarian version and liked it too! The team was nice and welcoming, bonus point for the location, very central and accessible! A good place where to have a nice meal after a busy day in Edinburg
Emeline Ind . 2024-10-22
MORE AT Google
Dinner was cold realy cold Very disappointed ☹️ would not recommend this to anyone
Mary Inglis . 2024-10-22
MORE AT Google
Lovely pub with nice atmosphere.Very kind staff.Toilets and floors could be cleaner but we visited on a busy Saturday evening so some sort of mess was expected
Krystal Mos . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Had a lovely lunch! Highly recommend the Haggis, neeps and tatties, and the steak and ale pie. Great location. Lots of history.
Gaby Guerrero . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Delicious food (in the picture the Nicholson Burger and Balmoral Chicken) and pleasant service, only towards the end you had the feeling that you had to say goodbye quickly so that other customers could take a seat.
Tine Fiege . 2024-10-20
MORE AT Google
Awesome place! The food, staff and atmosphere were all amazing. I highly recommend trying the Steak & Nicholson's Pale Ale Pie & the Cullen Skink. The food was so delicious!
Morgan McIndless . 2024-10-20
MORE AT Google
This bar was ok. Very very busy and difficult to get served at the bar. We drank outside as there was no room inside and people were waiting she's for a table. The beer was good (peroni) but they didn't have as good a selection as most other bars in the area. It was fun watching people getting their pictures taken with Bobby the dog across the road.
David “Ormy” . 2024-10-18
MORE AT Google
Stayed for a few drinks, all favorably priced. Service staff were all friendly - would definitely go back on a visit to Edinburgh
Justin Worthington . 2024-10-18
MORE AT Google
Great staff, nice ambiance, good food. I had the fish pie which was really tasty. We were here also in 2016 and came back now 8 years later to find the same quality of food and friendliness of the staff. Highly recommended!
Nienke Verboom . 2024-10-18
MORE AT Google
Excellent food and the atmosphere was good.
Kimberley Vis . 2024-10-15
MORE AT Google
Food and atmosphere here was great. The staff were lovely to talk to. Great story about the dog which I’m sure attracts many tourists like ourselves. Very busy atmosphere and definitely recommend the fish here at Greyfriars I loved it.
Ellie B . 2024-10-15
MORE AT Google
OK, I was really looking forward to trying this place out even though we ended up here a day or two earlier than we expected. We had some time to kill from an adventure nearby so we thought we’d grab some fish and chips while we waited. One staff member was a little bit rude as though we were a bother to them, but another staff member was awesome and made up for the other staff members lack of decorum. This was our first meal in Scotland, and we were really looking forward to it. It was good, but I have to admit it wasn’t the best I’ve ever had. Would I buy again if I was hungry?… yes. But I bet you there’s better fish and chips in Edinburgh Scotland and we hope to find it. still, the batter was very light and it was very fresh and very hot. I do suggest you try here especially if you like pubs and the pub atmosphere.
LiahonaDad . 2024-10-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Well, the place is really beautiful, and the food tasted good, but even though the restaurant was quite empty, we weren't served until after 30 minutes. Very unfortunate.
Tommy Morgan . 2024-10-12
MORE AT Google
Busy pub right next to the Grayfriers Bobby statue. Decent beer, friendly staff, good bar snacks.
John Nichol . 2024-10-11
MORE AT Google
We expected to eat in a historic, cosy place with pleasant, welcoming and friendly staff. Instead we were made to wait although there were free tables . The staff consisted of arrogant and adolescent and straight up rude individuals.
Miia K . 2024-10-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Friendly and professional service. British steak & Nicholson's pale ale pie - 5* Stovies - 5* Cider - 3* Cranachan - 2* Caramel biscuit torte - 4* Bramley Apple & Blackberry crumble - 2*
Rui Apolinário . 2024-10-08
MORE AT Google
We came here for the namesake to such a great classic Edinburgh story. Unfortunately we left very disappointed. After ordering drinks, we had them swapped on us with another couple sitting nearby which caused us to have to wait for new drinks. This wasn't even the worst of the night. From ordering our food to arrival it took 80 mins. That's ridiculous!! Despite them giving us a discount as an apology (only after saying we would have to leave before the food arrived due to another commitment) I still find this completely unacceptable. The excuse was that the kitchen staff were new and slow. To me, if this is the case and obviously known, they should have extra staff working or perhaps warn people of service delays when they arrive. There was a long line of people waiting when we left and we heard them being told 30-40 min wait times. I'm sure those people waited much longer. I would definitely steer clear during peak meal periods otherwise be prepared to wait and bring your patience.
Leslie Lahay . 2024-10-07
MORE AT Google
A great Sunday lunch just like it had been made at home comprising a well cooked Stovie and cider plus juicy chicken breast schnitzel. They were both perfect while enjoying the atmosphere of the pub and also be out of the wind to re-energise before further exploring around the Old Town.
Mark S . 2024-10-05
MORE AT Google
Nice, typical Scottish restaurant. Good food, kind staff
Thomas Droste . 2024-10-05
MORE AT Google
Two of my orders were missing part of the meal. When I brought it up to the server they just said, “We are out. You aren’t missing much.” That pretty much sums up this place. Unfriendly service. Mediocre food. “You aren’t missing much.”
Ethan Haynes . 2024-10-04
MORE AT Google
Cozy pub with dining facilities near Bobby's monument
Eveline Haenen . 2024-10-04
MORE AT Google
Its location made me worried it was a tourist trap and it was very crowded the day we were there, but the chicken pie was the best pie I ate in great Britain during our trip. Everyone appeared cheerful and happy to be there.
P E Henshall . 2024-10-03
MORE AT Google
Food was pretty average. Order had to be corrected, and then the short rib pie is the whole short rib including bone so there were bone fragments in it. Service was friendly but pretty slow and it was absolute carnage around us with people missing meals, kitchen sending out uncooked food, long wait times etc. It was expensive and there’s an automatic 10% tip added to the bill which I really resent when I don’t feel like the service is up to scratch.
Charlie L . 2024-10-03
MORE AT Google
Stopped in for lunch. I was surprised that we got a table immediately. Loved the biscuit torte dessert. Had the soup and some small plates items. Staff was friendly. The atmosphere was nice.
Henderson Cosnahan . 2024-10-02
MORE AT Google
Amazing fish and chips! Great variety of whisky!
Adriana Canales . 2024-09-30
MORE AT Google
Tasty, local food 👌🏻 Atmospheric place and very nice service
Joanna Piesiak . 2024-09-29
MORE AT Google
I thought this place was great - lots of food and drinks options available. Well-situated close to Grassmarket and the Greyfriar’s Bobby statue(s)! I had a pint of beer from Stewart Brewing Co. Would visit again; there’s lot of history here!
Brendan Cox . 2024-09-29
MORE AT Google
We waited over 45 minutes for two bowls of soup and when they did eventually come they were cold. A disaster
Ken Chisholm . 2024-09-28
MORE AT Google
Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, nice selection of drinks and enjoyed the food
Niels Claassens . 2024-09-27
MORE AT Google
Great pub, and they have Paulaner!
Nick Bender . 2024-09-27
MORE AT Google
30 years ago we had dinner in this pub, we returned with pleasure and found the friendly staff, the same warm and relaxing atmosphere, good food and excellent beer!!
Silvana faussone . 2024-09-27
MORE AT Google
Very busy traditional pub,didn't eat here but aye at their sister pub previous evening which was lovely
Karen Conroy . 2024-09-26
MORE AT Google
Super touristy, bad service, and even worse food! Nachos with fake cheese!? Terrible!
Lauren Woods . 2024-09-25
MORE AT Google
We ate there 2 days ago. We weren't notified that there was no swede available for the haggis neeps and tatties before we ordered, so when the food arived with roasted carrots instead, we brought it up to the chef who was passing, to be rather flippantly told there's a national shortage. We should've been told when ordering. Also took you about 20 minutes to bring us the bill after we'd asked for it. The food we had was very good, but the service was sadly lacking. Overall, poor, and I wouldn't return any time soon.
jonisilk . 2024-09-21
MORE AT Google
We couldn't eat at this pub as they couldn't tell us whether or not their food contained what my girlfriend is allergic to. I deduce that: either they don't know what the ingredients of their dishes are, or they didn't want to check.
Mattia Turra . 2024-09-20
MORE AT Google
Fantastic pub with scratch made food. We tried to go back for a second time but it is so popular our group of 5 was a bit much to squeeze in. Highly recommend you give it a try. Great selection of cask ales, cocktails, beer and scotch as well.
John Henry . 2024-09-20
MORE AT Google
Quite busy at the time. The sausage and mash was OK but the fish pie I had was mediocre at best and the vegetables horrible. It was quite expensive as there is a mandatory service charge. Food was not good enough to warrant the high food and service charges.
Alison Biddle . 2024-09-19
MORE AT Google
Greyfriar Bobby’s Bar had great food (fish & chips), don’t get me wrong. However, we got our food before we got the tap water drinks we ordered. I had to get up and chase our waiter down to get any attention for the waters or additional drinks we wanted to order, to which another worker told me “he’s busy, he’s busy” as we watched multiple other tables be sat, served drinks & food while we sat ignored.
Emma Barrett . 2024-09-19
MORE AT Google
Bobby, the Scottish version of the faithful dog Hachiko, was a faithful dog who lived in Scotland before the Japanese faithful dog Hachiko (1923-1935), and after the death of his owner John Gray in 1858. It is said that she sat next to her master's grave for 14 years. The pub is located right in front of Bobby's statue, and the pub is also named after this loyal dog. I had a steak pie and a fish cake, a croquette-like dish filled with minced fish and potatoes, and both were delicious! ! The store staff are generally friendly and provide good customer service, but they were so busy chatting with each other that they often didn't notice us, so it was difficult to call for someone. However, the atmosphere inside the restaurant and the food were delicious, so I highly recommend it.
ひばり . 2024-09-18
MORE AT Google
What a friendly happy place don’t miss out and enjoy the atmosphere and make sure you rub Bobby’s nose. Such a good boy. Our wait staff was lovely. Shout out to Triona and Lee ❤️❤️
Jaydee . 2024-09-16
MORE AT Google
Essen und Getränke am Tresen bestellt, Essen wurde nach 20 Minuten an den Tisch gebracht. Fisch und Chips ok, Lamb/Haggispie in Kartoffeln etwas gewöhnungsbedürftig. Ambiente britisch Pub, Bedienung effizient.
Helmut B . 2024-09-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Settled in the background of the Bobby monument, handsomely stands the Greyfriar's Bobby. Whether you fancy a cask ale or incredible food, this is the place to go. I had the massive beef meat pie and it was superb. Great spot for friends, family or the solo traveler to stop and recharge. HIGHLY recommend.
Derek M. . 2024-09-14
MORE AT Google
Great bar in a great location. Went back for food and it was brilliant. Great service too.
Mark Robinson . 2024-09-13
MORE AT Google
Great food, friendly staff, would recommend
Amanda Chritchlow . 2024-09-13
MORE AT Google
Food was excellent. Ordered the shareable appetizer and a side of haggis neeps and tatties.
Chris Dillard . 2024-09-13
MORE AT Google
Great pub good food a d friendly staff.
Michael Sweetman . 2024-09-11
MORE AT Google
Went I in afternoon, not overly busy, expensive but expected due to location and tourism
Mally Dent . 2024-09-10
MORE AT Google
Great food, good live music, cool atmosphere. What else do you need?
Gergely Kőrössy . 2024-09-09
MORE AT Google
So went to this pub with my wife while visiting scotland (im from portugal), and a pink hair waitress refused to serve after i asked for a coffee and a drink (she just had served drinks to a guy before me). I hadnt had anything to drink before and I was not rude or impolite. I felt i was discriminated, I loved my trip to scotland its a shame in so many nice people there was someone like this.
angelo leonor . 2024-09-07
MORE AT Google
A fun bar- restaurant with delicious food🥰🥰 with a few gluten free options!!!
cynthia scott griffin . 2024-09-07
MORE AT Google
We had a fantastic experience! Came for early dinner and the place was packed. We’re lucky to get a table. Because it feels like such a tourist spot, out expectations about the food were not very high, so we were very pleased when we loved everything we ordered (including the haggis appetizer - try it!). Plus it’s a beautiful, historical building in a fun location.
Molly Snow . 2024-09-07
MORE AT Google
This was the second visit for my wife and I to the Greyfriar's Bobby site on our recent visit to Edinburgh but the first opportunity we had to venture inside the Bar and grab a meal with our Scottish host Patricia. The atmosphere was spirited but not loud or disruptive in any sense and the decor was very well done in traditional pub style. Our service was excellent as well and a tip of the ol' Scally cap to Runkun & Hope who waited on us and also took time to chat up with us tourists from the States in some nice friendly patter. My wife and friend had the Puy Lentil - Vegetable pie and I had the excellent Mac n' Cheese. The food was so tasty and was served hot & promptly. Stopping into the Greyfriars Bobby's Pub was definitely a highlight and well worth the stop on our last night in Edinburgh. Don't miss the opportunity to stop and sample everything inside the pub - it's well worth the visit if & when you're visiting "Auld 'Reeky" ps.......the sticky toffee pudding was delicious as well!!!
Ken Vachon . 2024-09-06
MORE AT Google
Cozy bar with 2 different areas, one for food with table service and a cozy room where you have to get your drinks yourself. The food and service were very good.
S Gottwalt . 2024-09-04
MORE AT Google
Great beer just avoid the food. It tastes nice but the portions are a joke for the price
Chris Smith . 2024-09-04
MORE AT Google
Overrated pub, it was very noisy inside and we had to wait a long time for a table, but the service was very nice and helpful.
jaga staja . 2024-09-04
MORE AT Google
Proper scottish atmosphere, all what a tourist needs!
Nora Gagane . 2024-09-03
MORE AT Google
Love my stovies, great vibes Girls serving us were amazing even though they were very busy
Linda Patterson . 2024-09-03
MORE AT Google
Lovely bar. Food was lovely and staff were excellent.
cat cullen . 2024-09-03
MORE AT Google
Great local beers and Gin. Food and atmosphere perfect on a warm afternoon in Edinburgh.
Steve Walker . 2024-08-31
MORE AT Google
A place to quietly eat typical Scottish food
DANIELA PAEZ ALLENDE . 2024-08-30
MORE AT Google
Have been to Greyfriars Bobby twice and loved it both times. Nicholson's Fish and Chips and the mac and cheese were great. Great pub environment.
BillC33 . 2024-08-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Busy affair, otherwise excellent location near the cemetery.
Jeroen Admiraal . 2024-08-29
MORE AT Google
Nice pub with good food if you can get a seat! Very popular and overcrowded throughout history!
Natalie N. . 2024-08-28
MORE AT Google
We were lucky enough to walk in and get a table, especially as it had started raining! It's a lovely old pub with lots of character. The food was nice and enjoyed by my family members, I sadly couldn't eat there due to my dietary requirements, but, I was pleased to see there were some gluten free options available. Prices were reasonable considering the popular location. The waiting staff were lovely and attentive; the barman however could do with some customer service skills. The one downside I didn't like, but, I feel this is in a lot of places these days, there are no drinks prices on the menus. I was shocked that 1 larger, 1 bottle of water and 2 J20s close to £20. But maybe that's the going rate these days?!
Louise Record . 2024-08-28
MORE AT Google
Great location for great food. I love the classic pub look and feel. Highly recommend the Steak and Ale pie. All the servers were kind and helpful.
Judith Steiner . 2024-08-26
MORE AT Google
Iconic pub at the top of the hill from grassmarket, Old fashioned cask ales and solid beer choices all around. Very good live music also.
Danno . 2024-08-24
MORE AT Google
Was shocked to walk in and get a table. Guinness was tasty.
Kyle M . 2024-08-23
MORE AT Google
I camerieri Runkun, Chris e Hope sono stati davvero molto gentili e super scrupolosi sulle nostre allergie nei diversi piatti. Ottima esperienza
Jet37126145054 . 2024-08-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had lovely time at this Scottish pub. The Beef shin pie is amazing! SUCH A BIG PIE! Our server Runkun and Triona are very friendly, giving us recommendations, definitely top service!
Sofia Berveno . 2024-08-21
MORE AT Google
The service was quick, polite and efficient; the food was excellent.
Sofia Viganò . 2024-08-20
MORE AT Google
I liked the fast service, delicious food and beer. I will definitely come back again when I'm in town. I appreciate it perfectly.
Ramunas Milasius . 2024-08-20
MORE AT Google
Great welcome! A warm and typical English atmosphere. Thanks to wini & runkun for the hospitality, kindness and the patience (as tourist Its not always easy)!
Lisa Bnd . 2024-08-19
MORE AT Google
Perfect welcome and service! Thanks to Wini and Runkun :)
Laura Bonnarde . 2024-08-19
MORE AT Google
My steak pie was good carrots cold, but wifes breaded chicken was dreadful. Very expensive for poor food. £6.75 for a pint too. Shall not be back.
FUNKspex . 2024-08-18
MORE AT Google
Ate in bar area. Ordered stovies, haggis, fish and chips, abd culken skink. All very delicious. Only complaint fish and chips advertised with mushy peas, as the cheapest item on the plate I would have preferred more than a dessert spoonful, the gave me more in tartare sauce. Sorry I didn't get a photo.
Stay01495454550 . 2024-08-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had such a fun time at this pub after going to a Fringe show around the corner. The atmosphere is really great and the bar tender, Eric, not only gave me and my friends excellent drink recommendations, but we also had such a laugh together. Sadly he does not have his own stand-up show so you'll just have to come here for the entertainment!
Lillian Clark . 2024-08-16
MORE AT Google
Really good pies, good beer range
Steve Loney . 2024-08-16
MORE AT Google
Popped in for a drink as we were with friends who hadn't been in before. Steady place, lots of people eating so food must be good. Friendly bar staff and a nice historic spot.
Missy G . 2024-08-14
MORE AT Google
We ordered fish and chips, stovies and mac&cheese and cranachan as desert. The food was very delicious. The staff were helpful, friendly and with smiley faces. Atmosphere is nice. The only downside was that we waited for almost 30 minutes for a table and it took too long to have the food afterwards. It took 40 minutest to have the food after the order. Not sure we were unlucky with the timing but I was told by the staff that it would take 10-30min usually If you are not willing to wait, I recommend you look for faster options or simply ask how long you will have to wait for the food.
Dogukan CAN . 2024-08-13
MORE AT Google
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Review of Greyfriars Bobby's Bar If you're looking for an authentic corner of Scotland, Greyfriars Bobby's Bar is a must! Located a stone's throw from the National Museum of Scotland, this welcoming and charming bar will win you over from the first moment. As soon as you enter, you will be surrounded by a warm and traditional atmosphere, enriched by historical touches that pay homage to the legend of Greyfriars Bobby, the faithful terrier symbol of Edinburgh. The interiors, with their dark wood and soft lighting, create a relaxing and inviting environment, perfect for enjoying a meal or a drink in good company. The menu is a true ode to Scottish cuisine, with dishes that highlight local and season. The fish and chips, crunchy and tasty, are among the best you can find in the city. Don't miss the traditional haggis, even if you've never had it before: here it's prepared to perfection, with intense flavors and a modern twist that makes it irresistible. The selection of craft beers and whiskeys is equally impressive, with options for all tastes, from beginners to connoisseurs. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to suggest the best pairing for your dish or tell you the story behind each label. Finally, the location of Greyfriars Bobby's Bar makes it an ideal starting point for exploring Edinburgh. After enjoying a lunch or dinner here, you can easily stroll towards the Castle or continue your visit to the National Museum. In summary, Greyfriars Bobby's Bar is not just a place to eat, but an experience that will make you fall in love with it all over again more than Scotland. Highly recommended!
Christian Caretti . 2024-08-13
MORE AT Google
These schedules may not be completely accurate on special days. Please always confirm with the restaurant
Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian
3725 Opinions
Quite an outlier rating review, given the general high rating the restaurant has received. This is a personal experience, some might not mind it and some will, entirely subjective. Our group visited this restaurant expecting a pleasant experience, but a few key issues left us a bit disappointed. Here's a breakdown of our experience: 1. Service Speed: Orders arrived promptly, which was appreciated. 2. Food Quality: I ordered chips—average and unremarkable, earning a neutral 3/5 for the food itself. Had I ordered anything else, I would be able to give a more balanced rating for the food, e.g. whether I liked it or not. But chips are generally always average wherever you go. 3. Views: The views were good, but similar to other restaurants on the same street, so this wasn't a unique advantage. Concerns: - Bill Payment: Being told we couldn't pay bills separately because the staff was busy caused significant inconvenience for our large group (7 of us, 6 having ordered smth). While this might be understandable in some cases, it isn’t standard in most restaurants and left us puzzled. - Tipping Practices: The bill included an "optional" tip from the start, we received the bill with the tip already included. Indeed, in the bill, there was a section that said that the tip was entirely optional, but the action of adding it from the very beginning to the bill definitely creates social pressure for you to tip. When we asked to separate the bill/pay for what we ordered separately, one worker helped, but when one of us asked about the charge appearing on the card reader, we were told it included the tip, which was now mandatory to us because they went out of their way to accommodate us. This comment seemed to our group, quite a puzzling one, given it is common practice to provide the separating of the bill/paying separately in restaurants and a service that does not take long, I would say it took maximum around 10 minutes to complete. This undermines the optional nature of the tip and felt like forced gratitude. I believe many would understand that social pressure to tip in these circumstances. Finally, i understand that paying separately is not guaranteed in all restaurants, absolutely valid, but the comment does leave one feeling like we were being somewhat unreasonable requesting to pay separately at a busy period. While the staff's workload is acknowledged, these practices—especially the implied obligation to tip—left a sour impression. Dining should not involve coercion or attitudes suggesting standard expectations are a special favor. Improvements in policy and transparency are necessary to make the experience more enjoyable. With regards to the reply, I would like to confirm that we did indeed not arrive with a reservation. If a reservation would have been needed or accommodating us meant a lot more effort, I believe we could have been informed of it and perhaps made another decision under those circumstance. As I mentioned in the first paragraph, a review is personal, subjetive, some after reading this will mind what happened, but still decide to visit, but remind mindful of what happened to us and avoid certain things, and still have a great experience. This is a recount of what happened to us and how we felt, it does not mean that you will feel the same way. Recounts of things are always through the perspective of that person, this is my perspective and what I recall happening, the other Party might remember it differently, who you decide to take as truth is a matter of your own critical thought. This review has been edited.
826 Opinions
Didn't use the rooms but the meals were excellent and the service was great very tasty and plenty of choice highly recommend
1879 Opinions
Cutest place we visited. Very comfy seats as well. Delicious, varied selection of cocktails. Very friendly, patient staff.