GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCall
desktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4,5

Based on 676 opinions finded in 1 websites

4.0Ambience4.5Cuisine4.0Price4.5Service
site_photo4
Score
OpinionsNoteTripAdvisor6764.5

comment_iconOpinions

I would like to have written a positive review but having both called and emailed to enquire if they have wheelchair access and an accessible toilet I have had no response and will book elsewhere. I can only assume that they do not or they do not want my custom. Very poor.

site_logo

Quest14906131001 . 2023-06-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

It’s reassuring to know that good local restaurants are doing well after the pandemic. We came for lunch and it was delightful. Everything was perfectly prepared, tasted wonderful and was served beautifully. Congratulations.

site_logo

cmasb . 2023-05-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Gilbey’s Restaurant was an excellent choice for the Red Kite Board Dinner. Sandra and Dace were very good hosts and everyone on the table for 10 enjoyed a very good evening. My liver pate was very good & others liked their salmon or soup. The main course of pork & crackling was good, my neighbours enjoyed their lamb & the steak was good. My cheese plate was slightly mean on the cheeses but my neighbours certainly enjoyed the whole meal. Please see photos. Would I return, I would hope to take my wife for a Sunday lunch, they are ver popular so Sandra suggested booking ahead on 01494 727242 or oldamersham@gilbeygroup.com

site_logo

Alistair N W N . 2023-04-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I was staying in nearby hotel that doesn't provide food on Mondays. They recommend here & wow it was fantastic. Great service & outstanding food.

site_logo

hchaff800256 . 2023-02-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Enjoyed a great evening yesterday with friends for dinner at Gilbey's. Gilbey's is a trusted restaurant that always delivers whatever the occasion. As always we enjoyed great service, delicious food and some superb wine. Recommend the Brandy cured Loch Duart salmon or the wild mushroom tartlet for starters. While the sirloin steak and the seabeam were just perfect for mains. We love Gilbey's.

site_logo

Peter M . 2022-12-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Really tasty food and very efficient service, we had a great evening. The cocktails to start were really good and we loved the whole evening. .

site_logo

Smartgang . 2022-10-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had the pleasure of eating here as part of a group function. The food was extremely good and the service was fantastic. I highly recommend the lamb! They were very helpful understanding of my wife's dietary requirements, which is often very awkward to bring up. Whilst not cheap, for the standard of food I would say this is extremely good value as well. The place is clean and clearly well looked after. Wonderful place, I just wished we lived nearer and could come more often.

site_logo

jamiepR6495TR . 2022-10-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A real pleasure to eat a meal that is so much better than the same old local restaurants. They really think through everything that goes on your plate. Lovely flavour, great cooking, and the service is always very friendly. The best example of a proper family restaurant. I've been to Gilbeys many times and always have a great meal.

site_logo

Richard S . 2022-10-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This was our first visit to Gilbey's which was for a special birthday meal. We managed to get booked at quite short notice for an early Friday evening treat. Our reception was welcoming and understated, being shown straight to our table. We started with a lovely raspberry cocktail followed by a beautiful beetroot tart which tasted as good as it looked, enhanced by a flower of apple. Main courses of pork and mackerel (different dishes!) were finished by affogato which was also delicious. All in all, a lovely meal but I would have liked bread to start with.

site_logo

TinyKong . 2022-10-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

First trip back to Gilbeys in a while and the experience was delightful. I opted for the Roast Beef Sunday Lunch special that was just that! Special! Plateful of fantastic food and vegetables beautifully presented. The ambiance & decor is top class and the service very attentive. Highly recommended!

site_logo

LexGoldman . 2022-09-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had an absolutely delightful evening at this Restaurant to celebrate an occasion with the family. We actually hired the small private room upstairs. A lovely atmosphere, food was superb and service was excellent.

site_logo

HarryBuckinghamshire . 2022-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

First visit to Gilbey’s and it definitely won’t be the last. Superb dinner! Top notch food and attentive service.

site_logo

karen m . 2022-08-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Never been disappointed yet with a meal or service. Consistently good. Pork fillet just melted. Definitely recommend

site_logo

Chiefbottlewasher . 2022-08-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We found a very pretty restaurant with a terrace in Amersham high street while visiting the town last Monday and decided to return that evening to see if we could get a table. We were in luck and had a really lovely meal there. My husband had the 2 course 2 meal for £26.50 while I had the a la carte and chose Cornish plaice for £25.50 and a chocolate cremeau dessert for £8.50. His course was fish and chips and a delicious pudding, all beautifully presented. Service was excellent and we felt we were on the continent!

site_logo

Nadine T . 2022-07-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Meeting in a suitable restaurant for a large family birthday gathering we tried Gilbey's and were highly impressed with the food and service although the range on the menu was a little disappointing but well cooked nonetheless and the value for money was pretty good and all arrived together and well presented by the excellent chefs. Service was immaculate and we were all looked after very well considering large groups with elderly relations is never easy to get it all correct! Good wine choice available and apart from a limited menu was very good indeed.

site_logo

neilmorris75 . 2022-06-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We visited for Sunday lunch on Father’s Day. We all chose the roast beef which was absolutely delicious. Sandy and her team provided fantastic service as well. We can’t wait to go back!

site_logo

AnnieMB1981 . 2022-06-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We have lived in the area for 18 months but always opted for other places to try, because of their small and uninteresting menu. When we wanted to book at short notice and everywhere else was fully booked we decided to finally try Gilbeys. The...

site_logo

799Globetrotter . 2022-06-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Whilst things started well with starter, my main course, a lamb dish simply wasn't up to scratch. The meat was tough and overly chewy, not what I expected for the price I was paying. Three of us having 2 courses with only 1 glass of...

site_logo

Tony I . 2022-05-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Overpriced, scanty menu, charmless feel, no atmosphere - and pushy manageress on hand to direct you to the most expensive drinks. When I ordered an alcohol free version of mojito (ginger beer with lime) I was initially charged cocktail price and had to point it...

site_logo

sq4w3 . 2022-04-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Disappointing decline of a great restaurant. Been going to Gilbeys for over 25 years but this will be the last time. Very expensive, restricted menu choices and food well presented but poorly cooked.

site_logo

Dennis K . 2022-04-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We took our family out to celebrate our children's birthdays. We found the menu to be uninspiring and when the food arrived it was mediocre. The salmon starter was awful. Overly fishy and quite unpleasant. The steak we were served was of poor quality and...

site_logo

maryannm649 . 2022-03-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My partner and I dined here for Valentines day after seeing their offering of a 5 course tasting menu and looking for something extra special. I cannot fault a single aspect of our meal. As always, service was discreet yet attentive and we we're given...

site_logo

LegoMusicMan . 2022-03-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had booked and our table was ready. My daughter and I both had the set lunch, the starter was filling enough and the main equally delicious. Service was superb and smiley. Excellent choice.

site_logo

jin6x . 2022-02-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Took my mum for a special occasion and the restaurant was just as fantastic as our last visit . Food superb and such attention to detail !! Really really yummy , service was good and a pleasure to see new staff . Thank you for...

site_logo

Mermaid575 . 2022-02-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Have lived in Amersham for a few years and decided to finally try out Gilbeys for our 20th anniversary. Lovely relaxed lunch with great service; attentive but nor overbearing. Great food and surprisingly filling; no space for dessert which is very unusual! Would recommend for...

site_logo

fairreviewer25 . 2022-02-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Wonderful lunch, food amazing and the service provided by a lovely, informed lady called Dace. Management - please get your other staff to be guided by Dace

site_logo

david_9999a . 2022-02-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

It has been some time since visiting Gilbey's and I was really impressed. The staff were very polite and friendly, the atmosphere warm and welcoming and the food delicious. We had a very pleasant evening and would highly recommend a visit!

site_logo

Blazing100 . 2021-11-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We never fail to have a fabulous meal here with excellent service. We went with the whole family for a celebration in September and as a couple again last week. The food is tasty and delicious and the set menu offers great value for money....

site_logo

165gg2019 . 2021-10-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent restaurant. The service and food was fantastic. Able to book a table very easily online. Thoroughly recommend the place

site_logo

PigeonPower . 2021-10-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

So disappointed having eaten tonight at Gilbeys in Old Amersham. We have eaten here several times and been so impressed and were really looking forward to our dinner. However, tonight’s experience felt like we were in a completely different restaurant. We had raved to friends...

site_logo

pavl0s . 2021-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Visited the restaurant for the first time on Saturday. We were seated in the extremely pretty courtyard area. Although busy, we could not fault the service. Our waiter Michael, was superb. Starters of kedgeree and pate were absolutely delicious. Best pate I have ever eaten. We both had a steak for main course, cooked exactly as requested. The meal was not rushed, making for a thoroughly enjoyable evening. We will be returning and highly recommend !

site_logo

Stace0774 . 2021-08-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Disappointing evening at Gilbeys. Sat down at 7.45 and by 8 our starters had been served and cleared. Asked for mains to be delayed “a lot” but they arrived by 8.20. So a two course meal finished in well under an hour; this might be a personal bugbear but it meant the meal (an anniversary) didn’t feel like an event at all.As for the food……obviously the starters were prepped well in advance (see above), so were ok but not startling. The belly pork main was tasty albeit about 50% fat, whilst the duck would have benefitted from a jus/gravy/sauce. Not bad food but given the level of cooking aimed for, a bit disappointing.Two glasses of wine and two courses each - £100, inc service……..not good value

site_logo

jezzah75 . 2021-08-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Just celebrated our 25 wedding anniversary at Gilbeys with 17 family and friends. Sandy the manager was absolutely fantastic, she and her team went above and beyond to make this a special celebration. The food was superb. So many compliments from our guests and the whole gilbeys team did such a great job.

site_logo

NickyPHughenden . 2021-08-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The lady that served us was very friendly and having not booked we were delighted to get a lovely table inside. I enjoyed the Kedgeree, whilst my partner had the belly of pork (which according to her is the best she has ever had). Enjoyed the overall experience and felt the price represented value for money. This is a great restaurant the deserves all the excellent reviews it’s received.

site_logo

MrGJC . 2021-07-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This was a special treat to take a relative to a favourite restaurant of hers for her 80th birthday. She has been a number of times, and had previously always enjoyed herself. We arrived separately this time, and as I arrived, the staff were muttering under their breath because she asked to be seated outside when they had, mistakenly, booked a table for us inside. She is very concerned about Covid and would not have booked an inside table, but they were adamant and did not consider they could be wrong. From the outset, the staff were bad tempered. The food was bland, with the starter mainly inedible. £9 for an open cheese sandwich on a half baked crumpet is overpriced. When we came to pay, although we ordered from the early evening fixed price set menu, our individual dishes were priced without the set menu reduction. The waitress, still cross, disappeared inside the restaurant with my credit card, and seemed unable to operate the card reader. By that point in the evening, I wanted to leave so badly I didn't even question the bill. If it hadn't been a birthday celebration, which I didn't want to make any more upsetting by starting an argument with the waiting staff, I would have asked for the "voluntary" service charge to be removed, and the bill to be corrected. Very disappointing evening and we will not be going back.

site_logo

Roam64459861208 . 2021-07-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Gilbey's probably doesn't need even more favourable reviews, but it is so unfailingly well worth visiting that it would be unfair not to repeat what has been said before: excellent food, with now a much enlarged open terrace that provides a really good venue for summer lunch in the shade of a massive umbrella. Always friendly service has survived the stresses of lockdown, as has the quality and variety of the food and drink on offer. And in how many restaurants is the (very good) house sparkling wine one that they actually make themselves? Irregular visits over a number of years have always resulted in the feeling of a lunchtime well-spent and the most characterful high street in Britain provides a much needed walk afterwards too.

site_logo

O7232JRmichaell . 2021-07-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We chose to eat early in the evening and found good value. Unfortunately the food just seemed to miss out on the high standards we were expecting, but it was pleasant nonetheless.

site_logo

MICK0950 . 2021-07-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I deferred my birthday from Jan to Jun, and celebrated with my family at Gilbey's for Sunday lunch. The outside seating area was delightful, the food and drinks were all delicious, and service was excellent. Very highly recommended.

site_logo

helenabB7052TY . 2021-06-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We decided to book a table for 2, not stayed in Amersham before and Gibleys was convenient to our hotel. Meet and greet was efficient and the menu looked good. I chose the 2 choice set menu as its was £23.50 which was reasonable but mainly I wasnt paying £33 for a 10oz steak. I had the ham hock terrine it lacked a bit of seasoning but was ok. The jelly stuff with it did nothing to the dish as it was just sweet. Then fish and chips. Chips were excellent but the fish although cooked well was under seasoned for me. Overall it was ok value wise for what I had.

site_logo

DJX135 . 2021-06-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We could not fault the wine list, the menu was fairly limited and the service would be below your average restaurant. The waitress was always having to ask her Manager and when she addressed us, she was incredibly short and unenthusiastic.

site_logo

nicholaspP8145DB . 2021-06-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

had a lovely evening meal for two - was a bit worried about being seated upstairs but it was really lovely and service still great upstairs too - food is fantastic, so tasty and beautifully presented, great wine and the waiter was very professional. Have missed not being able to come in lockdown and will definitely be back - the outside area looked lovely too and has been done up a lot

site_logo

denmacca . 2021-05-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We ate at Gilbey's last night; the first time in ages. It was fantastic; the restaurant itself is quaint, colourful and has a great atmosphere. There is also a large seating area outside. A varied menu with something for everyone including a good selection ion vegetarian options. The wine list is comprehensive and reasonably priced. We are looking forward to returning.

site_logo

Stewart1269 . 2021-05-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Loved everything at Gilbeys tonight Great service and exceptional food. Well done for giving a perfect evening.

site_logo

Y7546XBdavidm . 2021-04-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We booked for Sunday lunch with family and the weather gods were with us and it was a pleasant dry day. We all logged in on our phones at the entrance, but at no time were we asked if we had done so, in fact, we saw folk just walking through without having checked in ..presumably contact details from booking were sufficient? However, the staff were excellent, the food delicious snd plentiful and we saw cleaning of tables, chairs ands menus. We were happy with the measures in place and had a very enjoyable lunch.

site_logo

WendyC234 . 2021-04-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

You have to try Gilbey’s even just for the starters! Crumpet with avocado and feta - delicious! The mains were equally as lovely, fish of the day, mussels, cottage pie. Service spot on!

site_logo

clare66uk . 2021-04-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very good food but am fed up with only dessert option always being sorbet. Also the fact that they couldn’t offer a plant based milk for coffee when you are sitting outside I thought rather poor! The heaters weren’t on as they had run out of gas! Please folks don’t cut corners for vegans!

site_logo

paolabF5452TGn . 2021-04-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

An excellent evening in every way. From the friendly voice taking our booking to the eating of our Christmas pudding. The staff were efficient and friendly and made us feel welcome. The food was delicious and well presented.

site_logo

MrQuiet1949 . 2020-12-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had been told by a number of friends to eat here, although they said it lacked atmosphere, we had been advised that the food was exceptional. What a huge disappointment from the minute we arrived. Not only was the greeting from a rather obnoxious maitre d' insincere but despite it being only half full and the table empty, we were made to wait almost 5 mins to be seated in a rather narrow entrance.Our guest's starter was under cooked, as were the vegetables in the main, and the only saving grace was the quality wine list. It is difficult times we are all living in but the atmosphere was staid and we found the service to be unacceptable. If, like us, you would travel quite for this experience, I would save the taxi fare back to London next time and donate it to charity.

site_logo

Sightseer732428 . 2020-11-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had heard a lot of good things about Gilbeys, however we unfortunately did not have a great experience.Slow service - we were there 1hr 30 mins and had mains and shared a pudding (which we were about to cancel as it took so long)Food was fine but not amazing and very over priced for what it was.Wouldn’t return.

site_logo

326vickil . 2020-10-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

we had a lovely lunch in the garden with friends. delicious food. great service. i'd higly recommend.

site_logo

aiazotti . 2020-10-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We booked for a family lunch with our two boys (aged 4 and 2). The food was great and service was brilliant. Great place for kids too!!

site_logo

872kamn . 2020-10-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Amersham is not huge, and the restaurant was easy to find, next to the Memorial Garden. The welcome was friendly, and I was soon seated. The à la carte menu is a bit pricey, but the set 2-/3-course menu offers good value for money. The two items I chose (see below) were delicious.The waiting staff were attentive and helpful.The old building has been tastefully modernised, and the seating was comfortable.When I was there, the credit card machine was not working, but I had the impression that this did not happen often.

site_logo

RodneyfromLondon . 2020-10-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We booked for a wedding anniversary coupled with a birthday treat whilst we could still get out and about during the current covid situation.Food was absolutely delicious and very generous roast dinner portions. Staff were polite and observed all the current regulations. Only one person walked through the restaurant not wearing a mask but they may have had an exemption. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal and the ambience and we congratulate the staff and especially the chef for a delicious meal and a lovely lunchtime.

site_logo

WendyC234 . 2020-10-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

One of the finest duck dishes I have had. Incredible duck meat and crispy parts with the juices. The unique addition of walnuts to the walnut mash made a difference to what could have been just a plain potato dish. The Chocolate délice was also on par with the main course. I'm not sure if the menu stated the cherries in the Chocolate délice contained alcohol but it would have been nice to have stated this on the menu.

site_logo

AnonymousSky . 2020-09-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We have eaten in Gilbeys for many years and it was our first choice to support local restaurants during August. We also took my mother who hadn’t eaten out since March. It is easy to move around without being near people and with a restaurant this is usually packed with tables and people it was lovely to have more space. Service is as always friendly and professional. And the lemon tart as always - delicious. However, I have always had a hard choice of selecting my choice as there is always - for me - more than one thing I want to try. So far so normal, but then later my husband said he also had the same issue. We are very different eaters when out so it was a little disappointing. The daytime menu looked much more exciting but only available in the evening 6-7pm. We had the parfait which was creamy but very runny, and the stone bass which had an interesting texture but the taste was drowned out by the pumpernickel bread. Two lots of fish cakes, offered as starter and main course, which were ok, a little dry. Best was the lemon tart and sticky toffee pudding. Just to point out that both mum and I selected the fish cakes as main course as neither of us fancied any of the mains. We are both fish lovers and the only fish on the main was accompanied by a chicken stock! Anyway, we hope this is a hiccup and we will continue to book Gilbey’s.

site_logo

GJBean . 2020-08-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went to gilbys last night . Very disappointing meal . Peach and fennel starter bland and tasteless. My daughter had vegetarian main course again bland and tasteless . Pudding Elton mess . No meringue in this Eaton mess , just a bowl of cream, really unpleasant . Been to this restaurant before and liked it but would certainly not rush back .

site_logo

robjE5688FY . 2020-08-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A very pleasant meal served efficiently with a smile. A very warm day and they could do with more ventilation.

site_logo

V2883MOchristopherp . 2020-08-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My husband & I recently had lunch at this lovely restaurant for the first time. We chose the set lunch menu. I had the grilled peach & fennel salad, fish & chips & finishing with Eton mess for dessert. We liked the ambience & decoration in the restaurant ;low beamed ceilings & comfortable seats with cushions. Service was friendly & prompt. The set lunch was even better value with the ‘Eat out to Help out’ discount which reduced our total bill by £20. We will return !

site_logo

JeanB526 . 2020-08-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

It was ok, but i'm in no rush to return. There are plenty of other eateries locally with better locations, food and service. Nothing special.

site_logo

G670TYpaulp . 2020-08-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A month ago I had booked a surprise party to celebrate my wife's 60th birthday, that morning we found that some of our party had contact with cv19 and our numbers shrunk from 16nto 9, however we enjoyed a wonderful meal, I would rarely claim anything as perfect but it was extraordinarily close, the service the food and the atmosphere made it a very special occasion.This was always going to be a special meal,but in hindsight, it marked the moment when so much changed.Thank you for such an excellent memory, II look forward with great anticipation to the day you reopen and we can again enjoy the excelence that marks Gilbys as something very special when we can celebrate putting this present time behind us.

site_logo

tonyharvie . 2020-04-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Warm and welcoming with a good menu. Went for a birthday celebration lunch with friends and everyone enjoyed what they had. The service was good, they took late arrival of one of our party in their stride and managed to serve her while we were all still eating.

site_logo

Catherine w . 2020-03-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had a party for 11 guests in a private upstairs Dining Room. The room has a maximum capacity of 12. It is beautifully decorated with pale blue decor and candles. Pleasant room temperature and nice atmosphere. Some useful convenient coat hooks . Comfortable chairs and good quality cutlery-an often neglected point elsewhere.Only disadvantage is for staff who are attentive but have tricky job to carry food upstairs from kitchens. The food was excellent. I had a plain looking but very nice soup followed by Gilbeys famous fish and chips . Other people chose mussels or risottos. To conclude , for a private party at a reasonable price Gilbeys is very hard to beat.

site_logo

537Wiggyness537 . 2020-02-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

4 of us had booked to go to Gilbey’s in Amersham on a Saturday evening. Slightly rocky start in terms of welcome and service; our friends arrived ahead of us and were seated. It was a very cold evening and I was wearing a coat that was too big and heavy to put on the back of the chair. However, the waiter had disappeared without asking about our coats! I stood there for a few minutes, but then had to go to find him to take them - not a great start.Having ordered in a timely fashion, our starters arrived without any delay. All 4 of us really liked what we had ordered; things were looking up.Oh dear, our optimism didn’t last too long.2 of the party had ordered the same, vegetarian, dish. Both found it extremely bland; 1 bucked it up with some salt, the other asked for some Parmesan to put on it. Both agreed it was only marginally better, but didn’t want to make a fuss and complain.Halfway through our main courses a group of 10 people arrived. This is a tiny restaurant, with the tables VERY close together. These people were obviously celebrating something, had obviously already been drinking and came in shouting and yelling without any regard for fellow diners.Why, oh why would a restaurant as tiny as Gilbey’s take a booking for 10 people and seat them within inches of 2 tables with 4 people on each. GREED. The Prosecco corks were popping as this group walked in - they were obviously going to have a fairly large bill and other diners could just lump it.It was now nigh on impossible for us to talk.To add insult to injury, when the waiter came to clear the plates he asked if the food had been ok, but he obviously wasn’t at all interested in the answer because when the 2 people who had found their dish bland told him this there wasn’t a flicker of acknowledgement and it was very obvious he hadn’t passed the comment on when we paid the bill - without waiting for dessert or coffee. We couldn’t get out of there fast enough.Thank goodness for the nice chain restaurant a few yards down the road, which was very happy to welcome us in for coffee and dessert when we explained what had happened!!

site_logo

Lesley L . 2020-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I met friends for dinner on a Saturday night. The staff were charming, the ambience delightful, but....My starter was the goats cheese panna cotta which was very pleasant and I then chose the duck dish from the main menu. This was amongst the more expensive items on the menu. The dish arrived beautifully presented and the duck perfectly cooked. However there was just one small slice of the ducks breast and was totally overwhelmed by the accompaniments. It was a ridiculously small portion of the main ingredient.

site_logo

Mary H . 2019-12-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very impressed. Visited Amersham Old Town for their late night opening which in itself was a fairly quiet but pleasant occasion. We popped into Gilbey’s and were lucky to get a table for two as we hadn’t booked. The food was very good and well presented, finishing with our first Christmas pudding of the year. The staff were just right, attentive without being obtrusive, and we particularly liked the young lady who attended our table.

site_logo

MrQuiet1949 . 2019-12-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Looked forward to welcoming our friends for lunch after our last visit a while back, BUT disapointed. Smae charming service and crisp white table clothes but the traditional sunday roast a bit of a let down. Beef was very rare. Yorkshire pudding to big for its own good as a single item, other veg very average. My wifes fish was apparently very good. Maybe they had an off day or just get bored with serving sunday lunchtime.

site_logo

Colin D . 2019-11-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

When I'm down south I quite often go here for meeting friends and family. The food isn't cheap but it is good. They are always friendly and never disappoint!

site_logo

mentpup . 2019-11-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ambience very good, cosy and staff really welcoming and efficient. Service good and very helpful. Food excellent although the portions of duck could have been more generous than half a breast! Locally brewed beer super.

site_logo

Netgezien . 2019-11-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a pleasant lunch at this establishment with good food, friendly staff and reasonable prices. Would recommend if you are in the area.

site_logo

jameshC1481PC . 2019-10-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We saw this restaurant by chance and booked it.

site_logo

772jesperb . 2019-09-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Whenever we come to this restaurant, Pip is absolutely brilliant always making sure you are being well looked after We will be wanting to return quite soon for the fantastic food, great quality and great restaurant atmosphere

site_logo

MartynaAshford . 2019-09-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Last time we came there was an Asian-European fusion menu that we did not care for. Now, it is back to its modern European roots. Excellent all round. Ham hock terrine as a starter was delightful. Lightly fried sea bream and (separately) a pea risotto were equally wonderful for mains.

site_logo

cmasb . 2019-09-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent service, fantastic food and lovely environment. What a joy to be in a quiet restaurant, that hasn’t followed the trend of making it has hard as possible to hear/speak to anyone.

site_logo

MeribelUk . 2019-09-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

It would be easy to overlook Gilbey's but that would be to do yourself out of a top notch meal in a small, cosy restaurant that has stood the test of time but has not just rested on it's reputation but continues to try and bring a fresh approach to seasonal eating.

site_logo

really_razamataz . 2019-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Beautiful restaurant. Staff are experience and great at what they do. Good selection of wines, varying in prices. Pea and lettuce soup is really tasty and the lamb also very good. I’ve been here quite a few times and I’m never disappointed

site_logo

Gigicham . 2019-09-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Tasty food & friendly service. The menue covers vegan, vegetarian, gluten free & are happy to help if someone has an allergy

site_logo

12pk34n . 2019-08-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Been coming here for years, on and off. This review relates to a trip I made to Gilbey’s a couple of weeks ago for dinner with my wife and a pair of our friends.

site_logo

TrippoDicko . 2019-08-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My husband and I wanted somewhere which had good service and great food. Gilbey’s has a lovely atmosphere, attentive staff and delicious food. Plenty of choice on the menu. A first class meal

site_logo

bucksfamily4 . 2019-07-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I love Gilbey's Old Amersham. I've enjoyed lots of meals here over the years but this was my first visit since the recent refurbishment. I like the contemporary, light look. We visited for dinner with friends in July and ate inside at a lovely table near the fireplace. As always service was welcoming, charming, and efficient.

site_logo

Monkeyhumble . 2019-07-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went there with my colleagues from work enjoyed a few pints. Had a great time with no distractions. The staff where lovely and friendly. Will return for another sesh

site_logo

jamesmay_help . 2019-07-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The two wondrous elderly ladies I came with were treated like queens and everyone was so considerate and the fish and chips and other food was fresh and delicious!

site_logo

Sharon G . 2019-07-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Last ate here in 2011 - I would say the food has deteriorated in quality. This time we sat outside, which was lovely, service was efficient. We were both very disappointed with the food. The squid and prawn starter had 1 prawn and everything seemed to be deep fried ! There are too many flavours on the plate, a fillet of bream (the waitress said it was sea bass) was ruined by a romesco sauce (not needed) and strange potatoes !

site_logo

BernadetteAmersham . 2019-07-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Celebrated my parents 50th wedding anniversary here. The room was decorated beautifully and the food was delicious and first rate. Service was excellent.

site_logo

SuH441 . 2019-07-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a meal to celebrate our anniversary, the menu was varied and the food really good although it did feel like we were put in the corner blocking the fire exit! Also, due to the confines, depending who is dining at the time; the atmosphere might be a bit loud with the tables so close.

site_logo

Arlric . 2019-07-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent service and delicious food, served in a beautiful setting. Could not have asked for more, loved the birthday chocolate in my pudding!! Cannot recommend highly enough!!

site_logo

Helen M . 2019-07-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Birthday party. 3 of us got food poisoning and we each ordered the same dish. We reported the incident the next day with no subsequent feedback. Then reported 4 days later and still a serious lack of ownership.

site_logo

. 2019-06-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I visited with my wife, brother, and sister - my sister has eaten here several times, and recommended it. The menu was appealing, the food presented nicely and perfectly cooked.

site_logo

petermbenglish . 2019-05-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food was pretty uninspiring. Felt pretty uncomfortable as we were squashed in and our table too close to others. It seems that if you are a couple and not a larger group expect a squeezed in a corner or walk way or by a door. Our small table wasn’t big enough for our plates which had to hang over the table! Felt a bit like we weren’t welcome.

site_logo

E1728 . 2019-05-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I don’t expect such an expensive restaurant like this to employ such inexperienced and poor waiting staff.

site_logo

lorab386 . 2019-05-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Took my lovely girlfriend out for her birthday.

site_logo

kevinnZ2177UP . 2019-05-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Despite accidently reserving at table at the Eton eatery of the same name a window table was offered to us at Old Amersham on our arrival. Our drinks order was immediately taken and served; our mains of fish and chips, perfect sized potions, also promptly delivered. Pudding was delightful: Yorkshire rhubarb panacotta with honeycomb.

site_logo

Midlifecries . 2019-05-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Gilbeys is based in a pretty building in the centre of Old Amersham. Friendly staff and good service. Wide range of wines and good non-alcoholic cocktails. Competitive fixed price lunch menu.

site_logo

Jon W . 2019-05-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I took my wife and two surprise guests to Gilbey's on Friday 3rd May to celebrate her birthday.

site_logo

stuart949 . 2019-05-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Thank you Gilbeys for another wonderful Sunday lunch. We came for my daughter's 25th birthday - just 6 of us for a family meal. (8 years ago, she used to work as a waitress for you. The standard is as good today as it was then). As usual, the food was delicious. We all enjoyed every course.

site_logo

EricaCcccccc . 2019-04-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Table clothes, clean shining cutlery great food charming service, and in 'Bloom Time ' what's to want further. A lovely day out ( well 4 hours actually ) in old Amersham a splendid time

site_logo

Colin D . 2019-04-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The fixed menu lunches are fab , the food is beautifully crafted and presented , the staff are relaxed and friendly

site_logo

Helena0213 . 2019-04-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Service fine starter ok but main course adequate at best. Disappointing. We were upstairs in a very pleasant room but in a comparative market the offering feel short of the mark.

site_logo

. 2019-04-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Warm beer that we didn’t order, forgot to place main course order, eventually arrived 45 mins later - fish not cooked and we left hungry Are you sure you want to take the chance?

site_logo

. 2019-04-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food was simply delicious ! Ingredients were fresh and superbly presented and the taste matched the expectation. Along with great friendly and professional service what else could you need. Will definitely be going back, and very soon!

site_logo

. 2019-04-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went with my wife yesterday (Wednesday)evening to celebrate my birthday.

site_logo

. 2019-04-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Similary restaurants in South East