Elsie's Pie & Mash in Greenwich - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

10/10 - REALLY ENJOYED!! ignore the other reviews this is the nicest pie and mash iv had in a long time!! 😊🙏🏼. Thank you 🙏🏼 xxx

Couldn't fault it except no mushy peas! High quality mince in the pies, not fatty/gristly - Portions were good for the price -- 5 stars

Came here when it first opened & it wasn’t too bad. Not the best I’ve ever had but ok. I’ve been back a couple of times in the last month hoping that my first of the two visits was just a blip. Alas, no it wasn’t. Pies are over cooked, big lump of unseasoned fairly bland meat in the middle of the pie. Gravy (yes I prefer gravy) not stirred through enough & still had granules swimming in it. Mash is ok but again needs a pinch f salt & pepper. Overall not a good experience but gave it a second chance. Won’t be giving a third. Appreciate costs have gone up but £8.90 for double pie & single mash seems steep given the quality being served up. An honest review that appears to be echoed by a few I’ve seen in relation to this shop. There are way better pie & mash shops around & this one needs to improve massively to be able to call itself traditional & compete with them.

Terrible pie, I thought I was eating paper. I had the vegan version, but even the pastry was awful. I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone, cheap but not worth it.

Very disappointing, not much flavour and meat clogged together in big lumps. Very unappetising! Shall not be returning

The shop itself is lovely , great authentic decor and comfortable seat's, but unfortunately the pies were awful, nothing like a traditional pie shop pie with what looked like a lump of something in the middle and just pastry at the sides , very dissappinted, everything else is fine but the pies need changing

The pies were dry overcooked no taste, meat clogged together, really poor I wouldn't order from there again