Ye Olde Mustard Pot in Sheffield

5* food and service. 2024 Update The Korean wings were a disappointment—boiled wings with sauce poured over them, tough to eat and lacking any standout flavor. The burger was far from the quality I experienced on my last visit. The bacon was undercooked, the patty overcooked, and the coleslaw left much to be desired. Giving 3 stars feels generous, but I hope this review prompts some improvements.

Called in today for just a light bite great selection of sandwiches followed by great food & service very welcoming thanx 👍

We are staying in this area for a week. Lots of family in surrounding areas. We met here for Sunday lunch and it was all delicious. Friendly staff, home cooked food, lovely portions, fantastic desserts. Another family meet up mid week we decided to go here again for lunch. The food was incredible again! We are a foodie family and we couldn’t fault any of the dishes. The pub also is lovely. Nice to see the fire going, dogs and well behaved children welcome. Really reasonable prices. I would recommend this pub without hesitation.

Lovely food and drink with a great atmosphere

Well off the tourist trail, you’re more likely to have a local point you to it rather than stumble on it yourself. I can’t speak to the hotel (never stayed), but the restaurant is one of my favourite places to stop for a meal and a pint when in the UK. If you’re in the NW Peak District, well worth calling in!

Signature burger was great, seated next to fire and even a couple of dogs laid on for the full pub lunch feel - excellent choice of stop.

Lovely old Fashioned pub... the type with low doorways and real fires. The bar and seating area are nicely decorated in keeping either the17th century building, but comfortable and clean. It's £4.50 for a Guinness zero, which I thought might be slightly high? A Sunday roast dinner starts from £15 (can't remember the pence). The roast dinner was very nice, although I wished there had been a little boat of extra gravy, and apple sauce for the pork too. I think they use good oil as the roast were very tasty, although slightly soft for my personal taste. I'm not sure whether it would be great for people with mobility issues, there were steps to the door but there maybe an alternative entrance. Good size car park. Close to some fabulous countryside, and reservoirs so good to walk off lunch. The only let down for me was that the woodwork paint in the toilets was very matt and was not kept clean... it was particularly filthy, and I suspected that the mop had not been rinsed clean for a while either. I saw something behind the cubicle door that may have been mouse droppings but didn't care to inspect more closely. Such a shame because everything else was lovely.

I must say a wonderful quirky pub that welcomes dogs and humans lol. Literally dogs are welcome here.Our overnight stay was an exemplary experience. The food is 5 star standard and faultless. The history of ye old mustard pot is listed on information around the pub.and has a wonderful storyline The locals and staff are so very friendly. A perfect short stay location. The staff go above and beyond to accommodate your every need. I personally highly recommend staying there and enjoy the wonderful food and give a 12 out of 10 for the wonderful warm welcome and experience they shared with us. Thankyou guys we will be back soon. TRIGG AND WORSFOLD family from Essex Southeast England.

Stopped off here for a quick coffee ☕ and chill after a long ride..... What a lovely place, plenty of parking, friendly staff, great outdoor seating and the views were amazing.... Would definitely go back here again 🙂👍

Wow. Beautiful olde pub. Quick service for some fish finger butties n chips. Lovely pint. What's not to enjoy. Thank you.

Very friendly service and excellent food. Very clean room and spacious.

I stayed here for two nights (Aug 24) and found the place to be really nice, location, accommodation, food and all the staff. If you're unfamiliar with the area then this is a great base to set off from and then to recharge your batteries in the evenings. I parked my car in the 'massive' carpark on the Friday afternoon and didn't need it until leaving on the Sunday, so many small walks to do for first thing and in the evenings and footpaths linking up if you opt for a day out walking. My room did need some improvements but was clean, tidy and nicely quiet. The beverage tray and bathroom smellies, you'll very rarely see these as good in most hotels these days - cookies and hot choc, chocs on the bed, shampoo and body wash, very nice touch indeed. Breakfast is in with the room cost and you'll be very pleased to sit down to it I'm sure, I opted for eggs on toast on both mornings but will be having the full English when I next visit towards the winter months, and I'm very much looking forward to that stay. Thanks to you all at Ye Olde Mustard Pot.

Really good food with plenty of options.

Very un professional owner poor service would never recommend to anyone

Very nice and old place to visit.

We won a meal for two in a raffle when we attended a show about greasy Vera's in Sheffield. The food was superb! I had lamb tagine it was delicious and for afters jaffa cake also superb. My partner had scampi followed by bailey's cheesecake also thoroughly enjoying both. Will definitely return for another meal.

I’ve contacted the pub to make a booking for my wedding anniversary for me and the wife I got messaged confirming my booking but in the same conversation I challenged the online web price. After a telephone conversation with the owner she said she wasn’t willing to match that price and was going to speak to the company and get back to me. From then on the communication stopped until my friend phoned to book a room for himself in this conversation he asked about my booking they said I wasn’t booked in !!! Within 30 minutes of his conversation I was contacted by text saying they’d been very busy and in this time over 2-3 days someone else had took my booking. A very poor customer service very un professional I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone from my experience.

Popped in for a nice pint... Unfortunately I seemed to be a nuisance as the bar staff were very busy chatting.... And God forbid you ask for an IPA..... Hint if you are in customer service maybe smile and be polite...

This place is amazing,we are definitely going back here

Lovely little pub and very dog friendly

Popped in for lunch, food, drinks and service brilliant, definitely coming back.

I will be honest it got a 3 stars mainly because of food and drinks, which were good and well priced. The room we had was very run down and couldve been done with a good clean. There were cracked tiles in bathroom and the towel rail was hanging off. In the room the curtain rail was half off at one end, and at least one electric socket didnt work. It wouldnt take much to improve things and hopefully they will. Not long as new owners so maybe a lot to do to get on top of things.

I was due to stay here on Friday 19th of July with my daughter, unfortunately we were unable to due to her getting Covid. So i gifted my other daughter and her boyfriend a night away. I am, as are they, absolutely disgusted in the service that they received during their stay at Ye Olde Mustard Pot. It was evident that the room had not been cleaned, their was dust on the widow sill, urine on the toilet seat, empty toiletry tubes in the bottom of the shower and dirt on the radiator and floor. The maintenance of the room wasn't much better with a broken light and paint peeling from the ceiling. They did speak to a member of staff that was quite abrupt and they did get their room change but, it is about first impressions and the massive inconvenience. Which is not good enough for a hotel, let alone one that charges £85 per night. It is just not acceptable. That is not the worse part, when they went down to breakfast they were approach by a female member of staff. Who said the following: "you ready for breakfast? Sounded like you need some energy and the bed is very squeaky isn't it? I didn't know what was going on when I first heard it. This place may as well be a brothel." Absolutely disgusting, even a male member of staff was shocked that she had spoken to them like it and her response to him was "it is ok, they are young" No-one goes away to a hotel to be treated be treated in this manner, very little regard for the inconvenience and embarrassment. Just a final word. I have stayed in 1000's of hotels all around the world and I have never had an experience like this (from cleanliness and staff behaviors and I think they seriously need to do something about it. After reaching out to this company, there was no acknowledgement of unprofessional behaviour and not even an apology! Stay away!

Beautiful country pub food amazing and service spot on

I spent 1 night hear for business. The owners take real pride in their service, and it shines through. The pub is located only 25 minutes from the centre of Sheffield and a taxi will cost circa £35. The location is quiet and situated in the rolling hills of the countryside. The food was good too and the landlord was kind enough WhatsApp the menus ahead of time. I had traditional pub meal for dinner which worked well, and the free Full English Breakfast was great fill most appetites. The rooms are basic but cosy and very clean. The bed was comfortable, and the location is second to none if you are looking for a quiet spot. The landlord went out of their way to accommodate our needs and even provide a lift down the road. If you are looking for a pleasant short stay with access to the city centre of Sheffield or the rolling hill you really can’t go wrong with this spot.

Nice dog friendly pub, food was great

Absolutely superb in every way, we were a large group, the food is so good, absolutely delicious. The service was spot on, everyone served at the same time which is not easy with the huge group we were, never wanted for drinks, cannot praise this place enough A+++++++++++++

This is a great period pub. In stunning surroundings. The staff are friendly and helpful. And the food is tasty and well sized portions. Definitely going again soon.

Excellent place to eat or stay .

Toyed between 2 and 3 stars but the unnecessarily greasy chips knocked it to 2 stars. Just an average meal in an average pub. Nothing more. Nothing less. The menu isn’t particularly exciting.

Had a lovely meal for 14 of us. We pre-ordered our choices which meant hardly any wait at all for an order that size. Good choice of gluten free on the menu as well as both my daughter and I have coeliac disease

Under new management with improvement plans. Food was excellent, the rooms I am sure will be refurbished and then it will become a great place to stay

Had a lovely Sunday dinner with the family. Good service, friendly staff and good beer garden with a bouncy castle and climbing frame for the kids.

This is a beautiful pub located in wonderful countryside. We have eaten several times over the last couple of months from breakfast to dinner and would recommend you give the new owners a try. Great customer service, tasty food, great value for money and we’d recommend.

Lovely blue cheese stuffed burger at the Mustard pot with fries salad and slaw. Good beer great service, worth a visit.

Made to feel very welcome, attentive staff, food was lovely, will be back

Woz about to order cheesy chips and gravy informed now price gone upto £10 absolutely ridiculous it cost a pound to make Got cod n chips n mushy peas 4 same price Takin the piss !!!!

Stopped here for Saturday lunch whilst passing - staff were great and very friendly, food was excellent, and good selection of cider and wine *****

Very friendly welcome and a great menu for dining. Gluten-free fish and chips was available and delicious! The chef's special pie of beef curry was fantastic and a great change from standard beef and ale. Really pleased we popped in on the way to Buxton.

Lovely old country pub with really nice food and great friendly staff would definitely recommend to others

Country pub conveniently located near a number of walks/activity start locations. Food has always been good, would reccomend the moule frites they sometimes have on. Beer is a little pricey (£6.50 a pint for Neck Oil IIRC) but I'd rather them charge the extra quid and stay open. Lovely quiet beer garden at the rear, large car park so a good spot to start your drives into the peaks if you're into that thing..

Stopped in after a walk round Langsett Reservoir. Had a pint and lunchtime snack bites. Onion bhajis with mint sauce and the loaded fries with curry sauce were fantastic. Making plans to come back to the Peak District and stop here for lunch again

Lovely food and great service! Nice country pub!

Great place to eat drink and sleep. Frendly and helpful staff. Will stay and eat there again.

Lovely pub that was able to provide a private room for a family meal which was ideal for our two young kids. Service was friendly and prompt. Food was delicious and there was a fantastic range.

Lovely Sunday dinner, would highly recommend.

Absolutely beautiful place & fantastic food.Well worth a visit.

Lovely Sunday Lunch with all the trimmings plus tasty dessert (apple crumble with custard). Good service and we will be back.

we booked a meal for yesterday , can only say what a fantastic Sunday roast , very happy with portion size , quality , taste and service , we will be back.

Went for Sunday lunch after a hike. We felt welcomed and warm. Food was well priced and you got a large portion as well. The food tasted very nice and I would go back again.

Had a Sunday roast. The food was very good and hot but we had to ask for some extra gravey as it was a bit dry. i will definitely go back

Enjoyed our meals but it's a dog friendly pub so probably won't be back because of that.

We have been meaning to visit this Pub for ages and we are so glad we did! Beautiful pub inside and out, the food was absolutely delicious and the staff friendly and helpful. Great selection of ales which you can tell are well looked after, so good we didn't want to leave! We will definitely be back!

Ooh loved the cosy pub, bumped into it on my hike and the chunky chips were incredible.

I visited Midhopestones while cycling from Edinburgh to London in June. Ye Olde Mustard Pot was one of the highlights of the trip. The food was great, the room was great and the location was beautify secluded. The staff were incredibly kind, and accommodated my unreasonably early breakfast request. I remember the experience so fondly and will definitely be back.

Lovely atmosphere open fires, wood burner great staff food great so many different types of seating chairs sofas ect

Seriously going downhill sadly and the ladies bathroom is still in serious need of repair. And electric heaters in the open fireplace? Not at all inviting Won't be going back

Lovely place. Staff second to none .food out this world and Ale 🍺

A warm welcome when we walked through the door with our dog. They have dog towels at the door so we could wipe her down. Open fire and good food definitely going back.

Hi there, I'm trying to call to book a table in February but it's not ringing through. How do other people book a table here?

Everything to like about this pub. Cosy fires. Great food. Ample parking. Lovely reservoir/Woodland walks.

Campervan stop over.. booked a meal for 3 people. Pub wanted to charge £15 for overnight parking.. took my business elsewhere,

Visited for lunch with friends. Hadn't booked, table for 7 found for us. Staff are friendly, place is cosy. Food was served quickly and was fresh. Only two vegan options (burger and a roast veggie sandwich), both were delicious to be fair. I love that there is a separate allergens frier for GF/DF food so no worries about cross contamination. Would absolutely eat here again if we're ever passing. The carpark is huge as well so handy for a group of us meeting there in different cars.

Lovely characterful pub serving good food

Third time here and food was fantastic

We went with our friends from Yorkshire Pennine Centre for our Christmas meal and enjoyed it very much. I'm sure we will be going again.

To sum up - asked for a table for two and a high chair, asked if we'd booked? No, so seated at table with no number, given menus and told specials .....then nothing. After 10 min of being ignored, went to the bar and asked if it was order at the bar? Yes is that okay? Would have been lovely if we'd been told that 10min earlier. Order drinks and two Christmas specials, that were advertised all over the pub. Tab set up but had to wait at the bar for my drinks even though there were two staff behind the bar and the pub was quiet for a Saturday afternoon - food came out quickly and the young lady who brought the food and cutlery was lovely, that was the only positive. The food was poor - warm not hot, not even the roast potatoes were home made, lumps in the sea of instant gravy (see pictures this is the pubs signature "Christmas special"). I'd have complained but nobody came to see how we were getting on, asked if we wanted anything else or desserts. Finished our food as it had been a long day and we were starving. The food wasn't inedible just in par with a frozen supermarket Sunday dinner and way below what I would expect for the price and location. Went to the bar where 2 members of staff were serving one couple 4 drinks between them and a 3rd was drinking a coke behind the bar and ignoring me. Once the other couple had finally been seen to I asked to pay the bill with the same member of staff that had seated me. Table number? I said that I had no idea as the table didn't have a number....yes but which table did you sit at....you seated me I replied. As the pub was so quiet she quickly solved the puzzle and I paid the bill....only then was I asked if everything was okay? Not, when we were ignored for 10 min after being seated, while we were eating, when we'd finished, when we weren't offered desserts.....once we'd paid. Went home and had cake instead, we'll drive further and go somewhere with better service and food in future. Never going back! Avoid!

Ordered steak pie and it was as dry as a bone and pastry was like concrete. Told server who did nothing about it - still got charged even though I didn't eat half of it - thank goodness for gravy!

Good food lovely staff But I was in great company. So added to the ambience.

Lovely pub, nice pint of Landlord, roaring fire and a tasty hot pork sandwich.

Only just put the fires on when we were in-very cold inside

Lovely 'country' pub, good food & attentive service, would definitely recommend

We had a family gathering here, 32 of us. Seating and service were both good. We all had a lovely afternoon.

Very friendly staff who helped me when my car had broke down. Couldn't ask for nicer staff.

Only stop here for a drink lovely pub with a great beer garden

Excellent food and service. Great surroundings. Lovely and perlite staff. The only thing that would of been better is if the other half had paid. A big thumbs up

A great pub/restaurant in the countryside! I went there with a friend and spent a lovely afternoon at an outdoor table, eating, drinking and enjoying the view. Good service from the waitress and bartender. A lovely place to spend a warm afternoon.

Fish & chip supper. Crispy, tasty & plenty on the plate. Bit too oily…. But not bad for a wet Tuesday night!.. got a slice of lemon which was a good touch… but no garnish of salad was ok. Was cold outside… and not to warm inside?… no fire burning… but a electrical fan heater was provided to warm up a table of 6- which proved to be Pretty useless! Country pubs work best in Autumn with a welcoming fire.

Lovely traditional pub serving great local produce food. Plenty of car parking spaces and also dog friendly. The Sunday dinners are excellent

I stayed for 2 nights. As an American tourist I met some of the nicest people I had ever met in my life! The food was absolutely fantastic - who would have thought Green Chicken Curry in the English countryside would be so delicious!? The Haloumi Fries were mind blowing ly delicious, served with a kind of sweet chili sauce. I spent lots of time in the bar area including staying until midnight on a Saturday night drinking pint after pint and buying rounds with some locals. They were extraordinarily kind, and even offered me rides to my destinations the next few days! Every single one of the ladies behind the bar was professional and kind. I do not have any pets, and in fact I am mildly allergic to pet dander, so I knew sleeping in a place that allowed dogs could be problematic. I had antihistamine pills with me in case I got itchy eyes, hives, or any other issues. Surprisingly I never needed them in my two days there! My only negative, if you can really call it that, was that I noticed a crack in the toilet bowl in my room, which also would cause occasional water leaks (clean water) on the floor around the toilet. But I had no real impact on me, just figured it was something that could be fixed, especially considering it looked like the flooring in the bathroom had been replaced relatively recently. My only recommendation would be one or two slightly more modern amenities, like some sort of device charger with USB ports on it that would make it easier to plug in international devices and charge them up. Great food, great people, great drinks, great rooms... If you're expecting some kind of posh people acting like an English stereotype you're not going to get it. This isn't dinner and a show. I was an American looking for authentic experience in a rural English town and I 100% got it. Humanity at its finest.

Excellent menu, very good choice of ales, service first rate. Outside garden and seating area. Large car park Second visit steak and ale pie excellent

Great spot for lunch and a pint when walking in the area

Give out free meat. Went for a Sunday dinner with the family and me and my wife are Vegetarian so i had the veggie Sunday dinner and she had a Sunday dinner without meat and to t surprise they coat exactly the same and cost the same as the Sunday dinners with meat. Therefore i realised that the meat must be free. Its crazy that in 2023 places still can’t fully accommodate for Vegetarians, i mean how hard can it be to change the pricing system.

On a rainy evening, such a warm welcome to a party of six plus dog. It's rare these days to find places that wholeheartedly welcome dogs. Thank you.

Reopen now and great menu plus excellent choice of beer. Didn't have time for the Sunday lunch, which looked fabulous, so just had chips and gravy... delicious 😋

The food is always lovely from here and at an excellent price. Their is a wide variety of drink behind the bar. The pub is very lovely and what you would expect from a country pub, full of character features.

Quick stop for lunch, not a stop over.

Had a meal here, absolutely beautiful. We both had ribeye cooked exactly as asked & the chips 😋 best we've had in a long long time. Thankyou for a pleasant visit, very friendly staff

A group of 7 of us had our evening meal here on two occasions whilst staying (elsewhere) in Midhopestones for a week. We had booked a table for the day we arrived and the meal was so good we booked again for 3 days later. On both occasions the 7 of us ordered a variety of meals from the good choice provided on the menu (of both mains and desserts). We all thought the meals were excellent. The food was delicious, well presented with generous sized portions. The staff were friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere was comfortable. Highly recommended. Would definitely visit again if we were in the area.

Very disappointing visit to the Mustard Pot today. The three of us went today for a late Sunday lunch at around 4.00. The place was pretty quiet given the time and we had high expectations given our previous experiences. We have been previously and, despite on our last visit them running out of Cauliflower cheese and messing up our deserts, we left really pleased and satisfied. This time, however, all of the food was really cold and the, what looked like aunt Bessie’s, roasties were a little on the raw side. There as plenty of veg and the staff were friendly as always but the food was a real let down. When we mentioned the food was cold they offered to ‘warm it up’ but, to be honest, who goes out for a Sunday lunch warm up? I could have Sunday lunch warm up at home for free!!!…. The bill came to £68 for two meat and one veggie Sunday lunch, two still waters, a coke and 2 small white wines… this, we thought, was reasonable. However, we begrudged paying the price given that a) we had to rush the food because we were starving having waited so long and b) we had to rush it to save it getting even colder (I think they forgot it was out to be served given that it took so long and was flat cold). They did send out some warm gravy on request which was a bonus as the original they sent out was flat cold…the warm gravy made the food more palatable. All in all, really disappointing, really disappointed with the offer of a warm up for £68.00. Probably won’t go again which is a shame, the place is nice, staff are friendly and inviting….

Dropped in for lunch on the way across country. One of our party had known the pub from long ago so we were unsure if it was what we were looking for. No need to concerned it was marvellous. We were greeted warmly and shown to a large table next to an open fire. Everything was right, the decor, the service and the food. Would recommend without hesitation.

This pub used to be our local many years ago. Tried it for a tea out with family. Lovely girls serving. Still learning but doing a great job. Really lovely food and plenty of it. Great singer on Tom Masters. Well worth giving it a go. Hope the new landlord can keep this pub going. Will definitely be returning. Had a lovely evening.

Nice atmosphere , good food. Large portions Staff were obviously new. But never the less they were pleasant and helpful Will definitely go again, Thanks for a nice meal

Went for my daughters birthday after seeing the new adverts for the "Grand Reopening." Walks in, sat at the bar for 10 minutes while bar staff chat to the regulars. Sat down with our drinks ordered food, this eventually came as a dry burger and cremated bacon on top with a cheese slice, and extremely greasy onion rings. After finishing our mains we were hoping that the desserts would make up for the disappointment, however nobody came to clear the table, so another trip to the bar to get somebody's attention. We ordered two Eton Mess and one Sticky Toffee Pudding. Sticky toffee pudding was cold, and the Eton Mess was made with cream that had gone off, this was paired with the locals effing and blinding at the bar, despite there being families sat eating. Really disappointed as we are local. Will not be going again anytime soon.

Was pleased to see this local pub had reopened and after ringing to check they were serving food, we visited last Sunday evening. Unfortunately I cannot say anything positive about it. First problem was with drinks order, no tonic and no Bitter, that should have sounded warning bells. We picked up the menus from the bar and a member of staff told us that several items were unavailable as they had been very busy. she gave us a handwritten list of all dishes that were off. We ended up ordering Gammon and burger, I also ordered a sweet at this point to ensure they didn't run out. The meals when they arrived were very average, staff seemed disinterested. Another party arrived and sat at a nearby table making their choices from the menu. they moved tables because of noise from above and we asked if they had been told that numerous dishes were off, they hadn't so called a member of staff to enquire. They were then told that they had stopped serving as they had run out of food. They had been sitting there with the menus for about 15 minutes. When my sweet failed to appear, we had to remind a member of staff that this had been ordered. The chocolate brownie, when it eventually arrived, was very heavy and barely warm. Needless to say we shall not be visiting again. They probably had been busy, it was an unusually warm weekend but not unexpected. No use having grand reopening if you can't follow through.

Don't think of visiting this place as it is now closed down. Apparently there was a fire in the kitchen and the owners have closed the whole place whilst the brewery looks for new tenants

Ye Olde Mustard Pot is a great place to eat and drink and the staff are awesome , Dave the landlord goes the extra mile to make all customers happy . I have stayed there overnight in one of the guest rooms and never feel pressured to get up early for breakfast or to leave

Went with family for Sunday lunch. Sat in sunshine in lovely garden with our dogs. A few dog water bowls were thoughtfully left out. The food was excellent, lovely thick slices of juicy turkey and pork. Really good roasties and Yorkshire pud. The star for me though was the fresh veg selection. Carrots, cabbage, sugar snap peas and cauliflower, all just the right side of al dente. Highly recommended

We went for lunch as we do once very 6 to 8 weeks. The menu had changed, so we went with what they had. We ordered 3 starters, olives, humous, and goats cheese. We also ordered steak apiece.

Visited here a few times over the years and have to say we have had a variety of experiences - thought we would come back and give it another go and glad we did - we chose off the set menu which we thought had nice choices and very good value - our starters were bruschetta with advacado and roasted vine tomatoes, tempura king prawns with chilli jam - delicious - mains - pea and mint risotto and linguini with coconut ginger pine nuts and mango salsa both were absolutely gorgeous all washed down with local beer - only thing we would say is the service was a little slow - maybe if this is going to be the case letting customers know would be helpful - the food was well worth the wait - definitely will be going back