GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4.0

Based on 5.060 opinions finded in 2 websites

site_photo4

Nº 309 in 672 in Rotherham

Nº 49 of 103 British in Rotherham

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..mustladycauliflowercookedvegetablescheeseoldcreampotatoeseggscoffeepayporkmeatroastpuddingturkey

comment_iconOpinions

Went for breakfast which is good value but on this occasion the mushrooms weren't available

site_logo

Charlie Burns . 2024-11-16

MORE AT Google

We had to wait at the entrance for ages then placed at a table that was squeezed in a gap the waiting staff appeared after about 5 minutes to take our food and drink order we fetched our food which looked like it had been there all lunch time no drinks appeared so had to ask No sauces available as all the dishes were empty except the mint started eating my food and it was warm / cold carried on then the waitress appeared and asked if everything was ok I said it was not up to standard barley warm by then and she said do you want me to warm it up for you this is not should happen in the catering industry as I have worked in the trade for over 30 yrs I t was a stressing time for us as had hospital visit for my husband not good the waitress came back and said the chief would check the temps she came back later and said they would take off the price of 1 meal to compensate us not good we paid and left leaving 1/2 our meals we will not be returning to this establishment

site_logo

lorraine clayton . 2024-11-14

MORE AT Google

The food was ok but the Yorkshire puddings were very hard the larger was off don't know if it's a bad barrel or the pipes need to be cleaned.

site_logo

philip bolsover . 2024-11-14

MORE AT Google

Flies on turkey .waiting for woman to cut meat .over priced

site_logo

Andrew Mennell . 2024-11-13

MORE AT Google

Service was great , food was average, ran out of beef there was probably more on its way but i didn't get it, ran out of all gravy other than the veg option, same again there was probably more on its way but i didn't get it.

site_logo

bob “bob-1” one . 2024-11-11

MORE AT Google

Went for the all you can eat breakfast, Surprising to not see any Continental option ie cereals, fruit, croissants etc, Coffee is one cup only with no refills, Cooked breakfast no scrambled egg option, Hash browns were tepid, fried eggs snotty, bacon was very tough, Brown sauce was a cheap option and not very nice, All in all won't be returning 2/10

site_logo

Julian Perry . 2024-11-11

MORE AT Google

We were a party of six adults and two young babies so as grandparents we had our hands full. We were served by Paul who couldn’t do enough to help (fetching drink refills, taking group photos etc). Paul was friendly, cheerful, and efficient - a credit to the business. Food was good and plenty of it. Well done!

site_logo

Neil Hall . 2024-11-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Brilliant meal very generous with the meat all cooked well perfect temperature fresh best meal I have had in years with professional well spoken staff 10 out 10 would highly recommend 😀

site_logo

Debra Hollis . 2024-11-10

MORE AT Google

Called here for my birthday, we pre booked a table and where seated straight away. Within a few mins we had our drinks order taken. We went up to get food but no-one was serving, we waited about 10 mins but no-one came out so we sat back down as it was too hot, when we went back 5 mins later they were serving but the people in front had to ask if there was any more gammon which lead to another wait. There was also a wait for the vegetables to be restocked. I had the turkey and beef which were lovely, the Yorkshire puddings where dry and like cardboard, the cauliflower cheese was missing the cheese and this was a fresh pot. The mashed and roast potatoes didn't taste of anything. The gravy was ok but 3 pots where empty. When it came to paying we had to wait 10 mins for someone to turn up. We weren't asked how the food was or we would have said something. We have been before at a weekend and everything was lovely. Sadly we won't be going again

site_logo

Sara Adams . 2024-11-06

MORE AT Google

Kyle served up all the meats we wanted. Cooked beautifully. Darcy was very polite and attentive. Great evening with old friends

site_logo

Jayne C . 2024-11-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Breakfast was very good. Had a few ok (ISH) breakfasts the last few times, but this time it seems as the standard has improved/returned to previous. Service was good too!

site_logo

AD . 2024-11-03

MORE AT Google

Absolutely stuffed, we could barely walk!! 2 adults, 1 teen, 1 tween, 1 5yr old. Total £77 for all 5 of us plus a dessert each too.

site_logo

Munzoor Anwar (Bobby) . 2024-10-30

MORE AT Google

Carvery was dreadful, could not cut the roast potatoes or yorkshire pudding as they were so hard and dry! Bits all over the floor,didn't feel clean. Service poor, had to wave our arms around to get server's attention. Told staff about poor food but was just advised others had complained too! Won't revisit or recommend, sorry.

site_logo

Josie Price . 2024-10-29

MORE AT Google

Horrible food dry and hard to eat when we told staff they couldn't believe it and did nothing

site_logo

Nicky Watson . 2024-10-28

MORE AT Google

We called in without a booking on a Sunday tea time. We were told we could sit at the top end where there was a free table. Although it was busy we found a table, looking around I was shocked at how much food people had left on there plates and not eaten, thinking they must have over plated themselves. On a Sunday the price increases making it around £15 for head. For this extra price you have the option of Lamb, my partner asked for lamb and got the smallest slither that it really wasn’t worth it compared to the size of my beef or my son’s turkey. We stood in the queue for food for 15 minutes as service was slow (even though the staff appeared to be run off their feet). The vegetables were poorly cooked, the roast potatoes burnt on the bottom making them inedible. My beef was fatty and had a sinew running through it, so tough I couldn’t even cut it. I was now one of the people leaving food on my plate. We have eaten here before midweek and found it nice and good value, I would not return on a Sunday again.

site_logo

Leecky6413 . 2024-10-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Beverley was a great waitress! Service was fun and professional. It’s always great food and we enjoyed every bit of it. Look forward to returning.

site_logo

Colette C . 2024-10-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lovely as always, plenty of choices in meat, staff very kind. Plenty of choices in drink. Gravy’s and sauces all full, lovely

site_logo

Carina B . 2024-10-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ordered takeaway carvery on line. Disappointed with vegetables as only carrots,loads of peas, cauliflower, roast potatoes and gravy. If eat in get more choice. Was cold after a few minutes. Not much meat.Another visit. Ate in . Pleasant staff. Good meats and vegetable choice.Visited on October 13th. Pleasant staff. Good meat choice and vegetables. No sanitiser on entry or next to refillable drinks machine. Carver had no time for any conversation other than to ask size of carvery plate and what meat you wished to have!! On a repeat visit, carver pleasant . Quite a queue to get carvery but efficient service. Tables quite close together which disliked. Had cranberry sauce today.Good meats on recent visit . No apple sauce again Could benefit from having some ventilation.return visit. Good choice of meats and veg. Sat in airy part. Return visit and front of house staff very pleasant. Carver could benefit from customer service training. Return visit in March. Friendly staff. Ice machine still not working. Roast potatoes over cooked as too hard.Return visit. Was seated at a table in an area as requested. There was an issue with choice of meats as some ovens were not working. The first carver was very pleasant but another one came to take over and she was not pleasant. Other staff were very helpful. .Return visit on 21st August. Good meat choice. Carver only spoke to ask which meats we wanted. Could have been friendlier. Return visit in October 2024- staff welcoming and helpful. Better choice of vegetables on this visit. Some of meat off the carvery was replaced on request.

site_logo

Jenny Tann . 2024-10-24

MORE AT Google

Called about a year and half ago and the food was appalling Went today and what a huge difference The food was lovely and with excellent service. Only downfall please get rid of all the flies hanging around the food serving area. Bar waiting to pay was a little slow as well

site_logo

Sam Bannister . 2024-10-21

MORE AT Google

My wife sadly is in hospital after having a stroke. As my motorcycle training scheme is in Dronfield I thought I’d go and have a carvery. I told one of the managers Ami about my situation she was so nice and empathetic to my situation.( she was fantastic. ( my 1st 2nd and 3rd visit this week ) today I met another manager who says he normally does breakfasts. He was also very nice. Then I’ll move onto the food WOW I had a little bit of beef, gammon, turkey and lamb. Yorkshire put roast potato mash and all the veg then I had the best chocolate/orange sponge I’ve ever had in my life and I’m not exaggerating. I cannot speak highly enough about the whole experience. I intend to continue eating there. Thank you again. Mike Barlow Mike Barlow, Motorcycle Training Dronfield .

site_logo

mike barlow . 2024-10-20

MORE AT Google

Love this place and food is amazing

site_logo

Holly Woodhouse Kittycat . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Brilliant service from everyone, friendly, chatting and consistant. 😊

site_logo

Becci Britland . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Very nice atmosphere and friendly staff, little bit squashed in together in the dining area. Carvery had a good selection of vegetables, lovely roasties and for choices of meat. Good old British Carvery. Other options available to order

site_logo

Jacqueline Gresham . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Had nice carvery fri would try again

site_logo

Michael Sampson . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

All round quite good , only problem with this place is getting seated in the first place ! There is never anyone on the reception area ,where signage instructs you to wait to be seated ,resulting in large queues and people walking out .

site_logo

Jonathan Mottram . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Friendly, clean, great food, well worth a visit but wear elasticated trousers

site_logo

Amanda Brown . 2024-10-18

MORE AT Google

Food was fresh and delicious, staff polite and friendly

site_logo

Emmalou Landers . 2024-10-13

MORE AT Google

Sat at table 26 Sunday. It was super busy today we didn't book but got seated straight away. Server was really good and friendly. The Q for carvery went down pretty quick and the food when we got it was excellent. Everything nice and hot with a nice selection..pudding were also yummy. Server was Darcy. But all staff flying about. Tables cleared and reset in good time. Nice and warm inside with a comfortable atmosphere

site_logo

Nathan Emmerson . 2024-10-13

MORE AT Google

The food wasn't good. The meat was scraggy and not fit to eat. The vegetables was dried up and it made the carvery not good. The only good thing was the dessert. Totally dissatisfied and this experience won't make me return quickly. I should have complained on the night even with a voucher our meal wasn't valued for money. It is a while since we came as last time we had a similar experience will have to go to an alternative carvery in future and will not recommend to friends. I have booked our Tai Chi group in for Christmas really hoping for a better experience next time. Not a happy customer.

site_logo

Jane Cotterill . 2024-10-09

MORE AT Google

The lady Emma who looked after us was brilliant

site_logo

Mandy Waterhouse . 2024-10-09

MORE AT Google

My first time visiting a toby carvery and It actually blew my expectations out of the park! A really good selection of food on offer and all fresh, with very attentive staff and a nice atmosphere.

site_logo

Charlie Sakellariou . 2024-10-09

MORE AT Google

Quality of the food was diabolical. Rock hard dry potatoes, half the meat not available, not a full selection of veg. We'd experienced this before but thought we'd give this place another try but instantly regretted it. Have been to Toby Carvery in Barnsley and even though it's 30 mins further it is worth the trek as the food is 1000% better every time.

site_logo

Helen Stokes . 2024-10-07

MORE AT Google

Quantity over quality, roast potatoes too salty to eat. Ran out of bed doing potatoes before 1pm. Ordered dauphinoise potatoes but they have us loaded roast potatoes without saying, when we queried the dauphinoise they said they'd replaced because they didn't have any.

site_logo

Laura Dennis . 2024-10-06

MORE AT Google

For some reason, they had several seating areas blocked off even as it was getting full. Perhaps they just hadn't gotten around to opening them up yet, but we did have to wander around aimlessly for a seat for a while. The Bacon is a bit unnecessarily wet, which is a shame because the sausages are nicer. If they do use cheaper bacon, perhaps they could either drain it better or cook it a little longer, so it's crispy (that would go great with the pancakes) Similarly, the eggs could probably do with having some solution to them constantly running out. Maybe a big batch of scrambled alongside the popular fried would work. Very pleasant and welcoming server who took our order and in all fairness it was all of the standard you'd probably expect, and of course all very good value for money, too!!

site_logo

Ian Lamberton . 2024-10-04

MORE AT Google

Dry food, roast potatoes were dried up and disgusting like they'd been under the heater for hours, un friendly rude staff, looked at us gone out when asked if we could have a pot if gravy for them, and one meal came 20 minutes after the other two did & we all only ordered sandwiches! Ordered a pot of tea, wasnt even warm enough to brew it, absolutely Rubbish. Won't return

site_logo

I . 2024-10-03

MORE AT Google

It was grim. Usually love a toby carvery but it took AGES to get food (45+ in the queue) and there was hardly any veg choice. Flys everywhere in the carvery area. Didn’t feel worth the wait nor the cost. Had an upset stomach within 2 hours of dining there. Felt overbooked, like they couldnt cope with the demand, but lots of empty tables so a bit confusing as to what was causing the problems. I could see they were fulfilling lots of takeaway orders so maybe that was causing an issue, who knows.

site_logo

Callum McCann08 . 2024-09-30

MORE AT Google

It's a Toby. You know what you're getting. Generous breakfast buffet. Bacon was perfect. Sausages were great. Would've given 5 stars for service if I hadn't had to wait 10 minutes for fresh eggs to be cooked. But that's a risk at buffets. Will visit again. And recommend.

site_logo

D . 2024-09-30

MORE AT Google

Will never return.. the lady who took us to table was lovely the server was awful came on Friday ,group of 4 adults and 2toddlers .think Beverly took a dislike to us as when she bought us the bill and I had the nerve to tell her I had a£15 off voucher and we wanted our card stamped she grabbed the tray back like she had to go 5mile to rectify it.she could have asked 1st if we had any rewards ..I will stick to our local toby in Rotherham where the staff are fantastic make you feel welcome and have some banter and have a great laugh with us . Debra Lynn and tc

site_logo

Debra Mccann . 2024-09-30

MORE AT Google

No staff. Service very slow , No body on the bar to serve drinks. No body to fill up carvery. No lamb, just a bone, tiny piece of dried up pork, turkey ran out last dregs of gammon, new beef roast brought out as it had run out and a huge queue for carvery

site_logo

STEVE t . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

Been coming here for 8 months every two weeks. Just feel the service has dropped. Only having one chef serving at the carvery. Very long wait each time and it gets worse each time we come . Please put two Chefs on to serve Sunday Carvery 😊

site_logo

Julie-Ann Jones . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

The worst Toby Carvery we've been to. After driving 3 hours we were looking forward to lunch. First impressions were a filthy front door that looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a while along with a grumpy customer that had already left after queuing. We sat down and service was okay until we got to get our carvery. A long wait for what was really just meat, potatoes and parsnips which were burnt. No carrots, no broccoli, no red cabbage just no proper hearty veg. The only options were cabbage, mashed potato, mac and cheese and cauliflower cheese with parnsips. Being dairy free really sucks when you get somewhere with no bloody veg. I did make my comment known but I'd already been waiting ages in a queue so didn't fancy waiting longer for someone to cook me plain cauliflower.

site_logo

Katie Drinkwater . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

I visited tonight with friends. Im not from this area and can honestly say I'm glad. The worst experience at a Toby carvery No yorkies, we were told a 5 min wait. 15 minutes later the Yorkshire puddings turned up.... well the pancakes did. Absolutely awful. Completely flat. There was no lamb, no beef, no Carrots (apparently there was a sign on the door to notify us of this) But I can honestly say it was the worst and poorest variety of vegetables I've ever experienced in a Toby. No Carrots, no parsnips, no red cabbage, no brocoli, but 4 types of potatoes. So if you want a plate of potatoes then you'll be happy.

site_logo

Salena Marshall . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

Food choices were limited and meal was not really that cheap. Service took quite a while but the servers were nice.

site_logo

Jess Mitchell . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

Came on Sunday. Really pleasant experience. Like to say extra thanks to Sam who made sure I had a very good experience always keeping the deck was well stocked

site_logo

S3phty . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely family meal and the staff couldn’t be more helpful

site_logo

Emma Bright . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely breakfast today even when was really busy food was still great

site_logo

paul Rowley . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Michael was so helpful when I got lost and my phone had died. He helped me charge my phone and I got to enjoy a glass of wine whilst it was charging!

site_logo

Pete Keat . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Service was bad. Late and cold food and the waitress was slow and angry.do not recommend

site_logo

Xxiixxx Xxiixxixx . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Have been here a few times. Always a welcoming atmosphere, food and service always great. Would definitely recommend

site_logo

Kell B . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Absolutely love it here! Perfect food and service every time! 🩷🩷

site_logo

Heather Woodhouse . 2024-09-28

MORE AT Google

Lovely staff ,Beverley who served us was absolutely lovely

site_logo

Lyndi Stone . 2024-09-26

MORE AT Google

Incredible food, beef falls apart like butter in your mouth, stuffing so nicely cooked that it is soft underneath with a crunchy layer on top but not wet like slop like many carvery’s. Such a wide verity of veg and sides like macaroni cheese, cauliflower cheese. The service so delightful and attentive by such young staff. Especially the young lady with the many piercings. She was so happy and inviting to us. Table service of drinks and the order. The staff are lovely and the atmosphere warm, modern but not loosing its historic look like the building

site_logo

Charlotte Bingham . 2024-09-26

MORE AT Google

Very Very disappointed was looking forward to a nice meal 40 minutes waiting for my starter when it arrived it looked like a handfull of leftovers had been squashed into a bowl and it was cold left it on the table went and paid for it and the coke I had and left will not be returning

site_logo

john o reilly . 2024-09-26

MORE AT Google

Paul our server was brilliant and lovely when we went for breakfast yesterday

site_logo

Rachael Sarson . 2024-09-25

MORE AT Google

Well... Where do I start. Our experience was terrible from the very start. We were stood waiting for about 10 minutes before we were greeted and taken to a table despite it being a very quiet evening. When we were ordering my partner enquired about what was in the vegetable bake as there was no information on the menu, the server responded with "I don't know" and made no attempt to find out. The meat on the carvery was extremely dry, the Yorkshire puddings cold and looked like they'd been left for ages. The roast potatoes were luke warm, dry and also looked like they'd been left out for ages. The stuffing wasn't entirely cooked. The gravy wasnt hot and also looked like it had been left. Now I understand it wouldn't be as fresh as if it was a busier evening but the state of the carvery was terrible. Now although our drinks were brought to us whilst we were waiting the table next to us were halfway through their food before the server brought them empty glasses for the refill machine. After we had finished eating we waited 10 minutes and the server never came to our table so we went to pay at the bar. Stood waiting for 5 minutes before having to get someone's attention. The entire experience was terrible and it was one of the worst experiences I've had eating out. I definitely would not recommend eating here at all.

site_logo

Daniel Green . 2024-09-24

MORE AT Google

Brilliant service, Paul was excellent. Great service 5 stars

site_logo

Paul Priest . 2024-09-24

MORE AT Google

Great place for dinner with family. We visited Tuesday lunch and the food was excellent as was the service from everyone

site_logo

Bayleigh Tallett . 2024-09-24

MORE AT Google

In the last two visits within a week, First time it was a Sunday food look old not fresh didn't taste the best staff were run off the feet can't fault the service, today I visited hoping for a better experience the pub was not busy service was good but again the food was not upto much, the meat was dry, the roast potatoes were extremely dry amd the mash potatoes so lumpy I actually thought it was a roast potato because I stabbed it with fork I could pick it up, the food look like it had been out for ages, really am disappointed with it, having used various toby carvery outlets for years I certainly won't be returning here unless they sort it out sorry

site_logo

Mary Marsh . 2024-09-23

MORE AT Google

The service was fantastic and we were looked after by Paul and couldn't fault it. 5 stars

site_logo

Anna Rowley . 2024-09-23

MORE AT Google

The bar staff was extremely rude, the one with black hair that works at the bar, very impatient as they ran out of tickets but thought it was so hard to explain that you could just wait with ur receipt. Likes to stare too and give unprofessional looks. The food was lovely however but will not be coming again. She needs a lesson on politeness and professionalism.

site_logo

Madeleine Taylor (Madi) . 2024-09-22

MORE AT Google

I have visited this carvery numerous times before, and the quality has normally been very good. however, on this occasion, the vegetables were very dry, having been under the warming lamps too long, and the roast potatoes were extremely hard to cut and eat. I even soaked them in gravy, but some were just too tough. The meat is usually very good quality, but the portions have got a lot smaller.

site_logo

Ralph Richardson . 2024-09-22

MORE AT Google

Great breakfast and all the staff were very friendly

site_logo

Cristina Rodriguez Gomez . 2024-09-21

MORE AT Google

Great value for money. Appreciate the fresh vegetables instead of the frozen veg you often get. It's hard to leave room for dessert but well worth it to fit a delicious chocolate fudge with cream in.

site_logo

Donna Humphreys . 2024-09-21

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely meal at this Toby Carvery, the lady seating (Amy) was amazing especially with our 2 year old bringing her some colouring sheets, our waitress Janell was also amazing, she helped us understand what we could have due to food allergies, and finally our carver Dylan was very happy and gave us great portions of meat, will definitely be returning soon

site_logo

Taylormia Murphy . 2024-09-21

MORE AT Google

*** Edit: I was contacted by the venue who were really helpful in talking through the issues. Doesn't change the experience of the night but great to see a the restaurant make a real effort to understand your poor experience. After sales - 10/10 *** This place was disgusting. The food looked like it's been left there for hours. The Yorkshire puddings were pancakes and floppy, the pork was dry and gray. The sausages were burnt completely. The beef looked so old I couldn't bare to try it. Gammon and turkey missing completely. Veg all watery and soggy. Gravy stale. How on earth can a dedicated carvery place get things so badly wrong. Burnt, bland, cooked badly, left for too long. Service was none existent as well. Left for long periods of time with no access to order drinks or deserts for kids. Tried to pay the bill, no one around. Tried to go to the bar to pay, no one even at the bar. This is by far, the worst restaurant experience I've ever had. I've taken videos of the Yorkshire's, the Burned sausages and meat as well as the carvery area that was filthy and empty. Am happy to send them before I stuck them on a YouTube video to review. Honestly, this was so poor.

site_logo

Damien . 2024-09-21

MORE AT Google

Last couple of times visiting potatoes vegetable dry laid to long and uncovered

site_logo

jacqueline barker . 2024-09-20

MORE AT Google

Went mid week 7pm, vegetables were overcooked, parsnips burnt,peas hard...gravy area was covered in spills,very disappointed

site_logo

Sue Whitham . 2024-09-20

MORE AT Google

This is the first time I have seen a chef have to fetch the food as he is serving and he has to keep stopping serving customers to do takeaway meals that people phone up for expect to wait in que a while half the staff are running around busy the others have not got a clue my beer was on the bar for 20 minutes I am a cripple that's why I did not go up to bar crazy p.s my son's a chef even he was shocked takeaways are normally done in kitchen

site_logo

Peter Thompson . 2024-09-19

MORE AT Google

I went here tonight and it was dreadful. Waited ages to be seated, had to ask twice. Waitress was nice, but drinks came after we had started eating our carvery, again we had to chase them. Carvery was dreadful, dry meat, poor selection of veg, all running low. Gravy ran out so only dregs of gelatinous, lumpy gravy. Why is there Mac and cheese at a carvery?? Will not return.

site_logo

Claire Keel . 2024-09-19

MORE AT Google

We were one of the last arrivals for a carvery on the Sunday, after a long day so we’re really ready for some food! We were greeted by Paul who was very helpful and accommodating both for me letting me view the meat that is available for carvery beforehand and for my girlfriend who is a vegetarian providing her with an alternative to meat :) The food was good apart from the pork, but didn’t let it spoil in overall as I was still stuffed come the end. Would once again like to give a big shoutout to Paul making out experience great near the end of what I’m sure was a long day for him, we will be returning!

site_logo

Jack Bedford . 2024-09-17

MORE AT Google

Used a Groupon to visit. Nice pub and setting, had a late night carvery. Food was ok, it was right at the end of the night but the staff were excellent. Would definitely visit again.

site_logo

Justin Swain . 2024-09-17

MORE AT Google

Food average but please clean the windowsill as mouldy and off putting

site_logo

Jennylee Wingfield . 2024-09-16

MORE AT Google

Amazing visit. Lovely food and spacious car park

site_logo

Jeff Epstein . 2024-09-15

MORE AT Google

Lovely place for a Sunday Carvery, advisable to book in advance, to avoid a long wait, especially for the Sunday Carvery, brilliant selection of meat, veg and all the trimmings..

site_logo

Trevor Hooton . 2024-09-15

MORE AT Google

Very busy on sun night which we expected. Food was generally good - I waited for the lamb. The carvers did very well keeping up with the demand and were pleasant. Sam did a great job maintaining the deck and filling up quickly . Disappointing to see tables in the upper bar area not cleared all the time we were there - doesn’t give a good impression but I suspect the main focus was the dining areas and maybe they were short staffed.

site_logo

Helen Towers . 2024-09-15

MORE AT Google

If I could leave 0 stars, that's exactly what they'd get. It took ages for someone to greet us on arrival to take us to our pre-booked table for 4 people. The manager was more occupied by the party of 28 people (yes 28) than anyone else in the restaurant. We only saw one poor lady waiting on tables which is ridculous on a Saturday evening. We went to the carvery area and I will list out the issues: 1. The meat: the pork looked like it had been cooked for 3 days as it looked dry and like you could knock someone out with it. The turkey was replaced with a full one from the kitchen which one of our party had, and it was stone cold which baffled us - how the hell could it be cold when it was fresh from the kitchen? The beef looked dry and like leather and had fat running through it - one of our party had this and couldn't even cut through it. 2. Yorkshire puddings: I was given the last one that was sat on the counter where everyone's hands had been. No thank you! 3. Stuffing - this looked like it had been sat out for a long time as it was black and dry. We asked for fresh which was brought out and they said oh it's just the way it's cooked - dry and disgusting. 4. Potatoes - the roasties were rock hard and we couldnt cut them. The scalloped potatoes tasted ok but were rock hard. 4. Full onions in gravy - raw in the middle. 5. Veggies - all dry and hard. 6. Mac and cheese - dry as hell. We refused the pay for that nonsense, so the waitress went to speak to the manager who didn't even come to speak to us - and left the poor lady to sort us out. She was the only good thing about the restaurant. The manager should be ashamed of himself, as should all the chefs! Get the picture? For a Toby Carvery, a carvery specialist, to be so bad, how the hell do they stay open? Avoid at all cost!!

site_logo

Amy Hodgkiss-White . 2024-09-14

MORE AT Google

Really friendly and helpful staff, and the food is really good! I really liked the apple pie for dessert!

site_logo

Amy Clarke . 2024-09-14

MORE AT Google

BEST TOBY CARVERY IVE BEEN TO. The customer service was amazing, the food was cooked to perfection..Everywhere was clean and tidy with no waiting times for a table.

site_logo

archie . 2024-09-13

MORE AT Google

Friendly and welcoming staff and delicious food. The carvery here is excellent. Brilliant service and lovely meal. Highly recommend.

site_logo

Alexandra H . 2024-09-13

MORE AT Google

Absolutely love Toby carvery for a Sunday dinner. Enjoyed our recent visit with our friends.Every thing was just perfect. 🤤 See you again soon.

site_logo

Paula Muzyczka . 2024-09-13

MORE AT Google

The two staff, Paul and Justine were great. Very friendly, dealt with any issues and a credit to your company

site_logo

Shane Spence . 2024-09-11

MORE AT Google

Went yesterday afternoon Thought it was old pub but Toby carvery. My husband wanted wrap not available. Woman with yellow top on entrance duty rude and surly! Ordered carvery x 2 young girl with face full of metal eventually came over to take order . Collected my food beef 2 slices FULL OF FAT see photo Horrible cheap carvery won’t EVER return Dried rotten cabbage on display near till! Asked if all ok I said how fatty beef was Oh sorry said young girl full of face metal didn’t ask if would like another slice! Walked off! Roast potatoes deep fried? Left from lunch? Just horrible. Completely put off

site_logo

Wendy Hick . 2024-09-11

MORE AT Google

We were served by Beverly who was very polite friendly and professional, and the meal was excellent cooked to perfection

site_logo

Neil Q . 2024-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

There is a great team here always attentive and polite. We go here every week and would recommend the place to anyone wanting great food, atmosphere and fantastic staff.

site_logo

Lynda Glossop . 2024-09-09

MORE AT Google

We booked well in advance a table for 8 adults and 2 children. When arriving we were greeted well and show to bar as we were a little early. The bar staff to say it simple were hopeless. Serving drinks in red hot classes more concerned about talking to other staff. We were show to our table tucked away in a back corner squashed next to another large booking to leaving us much room at all and very noisy. Most of our party accept to adults staying with children went a got their food. When the other two adults went the queue was unbelievable. It took a solid 20 minutes to get served. Only one chief carving meat. No lamb, and veg was very low. By the time the two of us returned to table everyone one else had finished their meal. One receiving the bill it was wrong with teams on it that we hadn’t had, this took another 15 mins to sort out. The reason why we booked the Toby Carvery was to remember our grandsons heavenly birthday. His other grandparents had come over from Boston USA. The whole experience was awful. No senior staff on all young people who really don’t seem bothered or had little training. Your reply is not correct. You have us mixed up with another table. Our bill wasn’t split 4 ways. I paid the bill all in one transaction… this just proves my point… you don’t know what happening right under your own roof.

site_logo

Dapper Words . 2024-09-09

MORE AT Google

We had planned on having a carvery on Saturday evening. We purchased drinks and were shown to our table. However, when we went to get our meal, we were horrified to see several flies flying around, and landing on, the food. When we brought it to the attention of the person serving, we were told “Sorry. There’s nothing I can do about it.” Rather than risk being ill from eating contaminated food, we made the decision to dine elsewhere.

site_logo

Sue Hutton . 2024-09-09

MORE AT Google

Went for lunch with my boyfriend and was greeted at the door within seconds of arriving by Amy who was very welcoming. Our waitress for our visit was Taylor Mia she was very polite and attentive. 5star experience will be returning again

site_logo

Alex Ford . 2024-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Me and my family had a fab time, the food and service was amazing, we had Ellie as our server who was very helpful and attentive once we’d been sat down. The food was delicious and our carver Taylor Mia gave us very good portions and the the veg deck was all there and amazing, will definitely be back soon love everything

site_logo

Darcy G . 2024-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Taylormia was our server, lovely service. Lovely atmosphere, great service would come again. Carver Kyle was great, and helpful.

site_logo

Trail27299713400 . 2024-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We went this morning as a family because we hadn't been before. The service was slow and with no interaction. The food, where to begin? Everything was over cooked apart from the beans and tomatos which where watery. The pancakes where so rubbery they would of bounced if you dropped them. Overall disappointing especially for £39.

site_logo

Simon Sayell . 2024-09-08

MORE AT Google

Staff clueless as how to work blue light discount. Majority of our food was cold, lumpy, watery and vegetables were unidentifiable. You could have played marbles with the peas. Long wait at an empty bar to be seated. Only helpful member of staff around was Kate. Will stick to Moorlands in future.

site_logo

lcmorton21 . 2024-09-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Meat are not refill always, even arrived at 6:30. How to supply good food to customer until the closing time 10pm?

site_logo

Carlton Chan . 2024-09-05

MORE AT Google

Pretty decent food. It's a carvery at the end of the day so isn't cooked just for you, but it's very good and excellent value. Staff are always great.

site_logo

Howard Saunders . 2024-09-05

MORE AT Google

We was taken to our table straightaway. There was no waiting for our orders to be taken and staff was very welcoming and polite. There was just one issue which was my own fault. I do have mobility issues and the table we was sat at had steps to get up to it. They could see I had problems walking and was not offered a table where you did have to use steps

site_logo

Barry Normington . 2024-09-04

MORE AT Google

We visited Toby Carvery with friends yesterday and, unfortunately, had a disappointing experience due to slow and poor service. Despite the restaurant not being overly busy, we waited 40 minutes just to place our drinks order. After that, the delays continued as we had to wait for our drinks and to place our food orders. The constant waiting detracted from what should have been an enjoyable meal with friends. We understand that sometimes restaurants experience unforeseen delays, but this experience left us feeling disappointed. We hope to see improvements in service in the future.

site_logo

Paulina Bomba . 2024-09-02

MORE AT Google

I attended this restaurant with my partner today and experienced a low blood pressure episode and collapsed in the queue awaiting the buffet. The staff were lovely and reassuring, checking routinely on my wellbeing. The food was beautiful and very tasty. Very nice and welcoming stay during our time - over something that could have gone much worse, I'm very grateful towards the staff. Many thanks team.

site_logo

Emily Hill-Green . 2024-09-01

MORE AT Google

You know exactly what to expect and they deliver. Timing is key when the spuds are under a heat lamp (after 7 pm and they're dry) but fir the price and quantity? Fine by me! Service friendly and not pushy leaving you to eat in peace

site_logo

Sam B . 2024-08-30

MORE AT Google

The macaroni is so tasty. Meat well done. This is the best in the neighborhood

site_logo

Emmanuel Oyelere . 2024-08-30

MORE AT Google

Went there with a group of friends from work and the staff was very friendly welcoming and the vibe was just amazing and the food was just outstanding

site_logo

David Miller . 2024-08-29

MORE AT Google

The beef and turkey was lovely, lamb was chewy, no pepsi max or diet pepsi and we had already paid for 3 bottomless drinks. The chef on the carvery was really lovely and our waitress was lovely too. The issues were with stock and organisation. They had no pasta or chips for kids' meals.

site_logo

Carly Dunham . 2024-08-27

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in Yorkshire and The Humber

restaurant_img
4.0

8 Opinions

location-iconHoliday Inn Rotherham
British
outdoor_seating_170820takeaway_170820delivery_170820

Fish & Chips with pea source, all not very exciting to end the business day on however the staff were very attentive, had a smile and nothing was too much trouble.

restaurant_img
4.0

19 Opinions

location-iconAldwarke Road
British
outdoor_seating_222361takeaway_222361delivery_222361

the staff are so trained and professional a great atmosphere the place is a good little pub with a lot of beer to chose from. The Beer great value and the food is amazing home cooked like it should be. The chef does a great job excellent experience

restaurant_img
4.0

2542 Opinions

location-icon11 Doncaster Road
British
outdoor_seating_173720takeaway_173720delivery_173720

Really nice food, good portion sizes, quick services. Lots of parking too

restaurant_img
4.0

79 Opinions

location-icon51 Rockingham Rd
British
outdoor_seating_174115takeaway_174115delivery_174115

Went in tonight ordered 2 very curries and 1 fried rice beef was very tough and chewy curry sauce bland and rice not cooked enough will never go again very dissatisfied overall 😑

restaurant_img
4.0

11 Opinions

location-iconCentral Road
British
outdoor_seating_197059takeaway_197059delivery_197059

Excellent food, drinks and prices. Great location away from Main Street. Fast friendly service and really enjoyed it. I had an excellent club sandwich and then a freshly baked scone. There’s a great choice of cakes on display Would definitely recommend