GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4.0

Based on 5.203 opinions finded in 4 websites

site_photo4

Nº 359 in 672 in Rotherham

Nº 50 of 77 Other cuisines in Rotherham

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..paypotatoescheesebaconmustcookedcauliflowerladysausageroastvegetablesbeautifulcoffeemeateggsporkpuddingoldturkey

comment_iconOpinions

I Add A breakfast Toby carvery today with my wife and grandchild and it cost me £32 And it was absolutely Garbage it was all Dry It Had been under the heat lamp to long They won't be seen me again

site_logo

Mick Twigg . 2025-05-18

MORE AT Google

Marked as delivered - but it was the wrong address. Driver callled me 4 times to say that he was trying to find me, I told him thee correct address but he then marked it as delivered.

site_logo

Gochi . 2025-05-17

MORE AT Just Eat

Lovely meat and roasties and delicious gravy, mash n stuffing not to my texture but watery for me, veggies cooked well.

site_logo

KERRY . 2025-05-16

MORE AT Just Eat

Has no Atmosphere, but for mid-week Carvey its worth a visit.

site_logo

Fraser Portwood . 2025-05-16

MORE AT Google

Portion size of the mac and cheese was pathetic, barely 2 tablespoons for 4 quid! Rest was ok but portions of meat were much less than you get if you eat in. Value for money just isn’t there

site_logo

Graham . 2025-05-16

MORE AT Just Eat

The staff here are brilliant, hard working, they can't do enough for you. Michelle in particular, is a lovely lady :) We look forward to seeing her when we visit! Lots of food options, even as a veggie :)

site_logo

billie christian . 2025-05-15

MORE AT Google

Disgusting attitude Disgusting food.. over priced garbage

site_logo

Justahumebeing . 2025-05-14

MORE AT Google

absolutely diabolical, had lumpy mash (mash it more next time) fatty meat (find better animals that are within weight) cold food (make it warm) overall disgusting. P.s tell the man with the sweaty forehead to wipe it cos them juices would have been good on that dry meat.

site_logo

harley wilkinson . 2025-05-13

MORE AT Google

We ordered two meat carvery’s with normal gravy’s, order was over an hour late, cold and we had two vegan gravy’s and two meat free carvery’s. Shambles!

site_logo

Andy . 2025-05-13

MORE AT Just Eat

Awful meal.tough meat,hard roast potatoes All food had stood for a while.No wonder ta bles were available. Service and staff very good.Worst Toby meal ever!!

site_logo

Tony Bevan . 2025-05-12

MORE AT Google

first tine ordering n i defiantly won’t be again, all cold n hardly any veg and i went for the £12.99 which was not worth it and got the cheesy mushrooms and if id known how small it wa so wouldnt have payed £3.99 as again defiantly not worth the money for the size, iv eaten inside toby but the dinner iv just had delivered is by far the worse takeaway iv ever had and its not worth the £20 its just cost me, sending dinners out cold n with hardly anything on they should be ashamed

site_logo

Sarah . 2025-05-10

MORE AT Just Eat

gorgeous food and great portions

site_logo

Amy . 2025-05-10

MORE AT Just Eat

Worst take away experience I've ever had - doesn't even deserve one star. - yorkshire pudding was missing - whole order was cold - roast potatoes were stale - whole meal made me violently sick Avoid this place like the plague, absolutely appalling.

site_logo

Amy Gee . 2025-05-09

MORE AT Google

The choice of vegetables is usually good but sometimes not as much variety. Needs to be more, a better range all the time. More green, leaky veg - kale, cabbage and spinach.

site_logo

N Pearson . 2025-05-07

MORE AT Google

We where greeted on arrival by Marie who was very welcoming , friendly and polite , we all enjoyed breakfast , worth coming back again 👍⭐️lovely .

site_logo

margaret frost . 2025-05-05

MORE AT Google

First time here Jy daughter and son in law love it so brought me Omg so many different choices of meat. I couldn't believe they do lamb. My absolute favourite 😍 and it was delicious but so was all the other choices of meat I would highly recommend this place it's the best 👌

site_logo

Alison Keeton . 2025-05-04

MORE AT Google

Extremely small portion, wouldn’t have filled a child. 1st time ordering, won’t be ordering again.

site_logo

Maria . 2025-05-04

MORE AT Just Eat

Came here today the food was not great which was very disappointing as it’s usually very nice. However the reason I have given a 4 star is because of the server Kevina she was so lovely and rectified the issue very promptly and nothing was to much trouble.

site_logo

Ami Elkjiri . 2025-05-04

MORE AT Google

Food was excellent and plenty of choice ,set us up nicely for our journey home ,Marie our server was polite and attentive to our needs . Will recommend to friends and family when travelling this way

site_logo

Kim Lane . 2025-05-04

MORE AT Google

breakfast was excellent well cooked quality ingredients everything fresh amd hot and geoendly welcoming staff

site_logo

Gemma Sayer . 2025-05-01

MORE AT Google

Lovely carvery. Good choice and excellent Yorkshire Puddings. Yum. 👍

site_logo

Mark Waghorn . 2025-05-01

MORE AT Google

Had a great meal great food ferry friendly staff karena and Michell amazing and rest of staff karena was my wateres so friendly and polite just the best

site_logo

Patrick Thompson . 2025-04-30

MORE AT Google

Welcoming staff and atmosphere. Never had any issues here always a good buzz having visited for breakfasts and dinner/evening meals. The fried eggs today were a tad oily mind but otherwise the usual spot on food.

site_logo

96barada . 2025-04-30

MORE AT Google

Lovely breakfast.Manager Marie was very helpful and attentive Atmosphere chilled and relaxed clean surroundings Value for money

site_logo

Steven K . 2025-04-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a lovely breakfast. Staff were really helpful and friendly

site_logo

Donna Garbutt . 2025-04-30

MORE AT Google

Excellent service nice hot food lovely staff great for kids

site_logo

Nicky Hogan . 2025-04-29

MORE AT Google

Beautiful well cooked food served by friendly staff in a pleasant, comfortable, well lit environment conducive to conversation and shared memories. Plan to visit again soon

site_logo

DIANNE MAUGHAN RAILTON . 2025-04-28

MORE AT Google

The majority of the meal was adequate, until I bit into the Yorkshire pudding and about 2 teaspoons of oil just came out of the pudding straight into my mouth. It was vile. Never had anything like it with other Yorkshire puddings either here or elsewhere. Threw everything away after that.

site_logo

Linzi . 2025-04-27

MORE AT Just Eat

After todays warm weather didnt want to be stood slaving away at the cooker, very filling wasnt a huge portion and given the roast potatos are extra they could've added more than 3 arrived well packaged and very hot very filling! Highly recommend

site_logo

Natasha . 2025-04-27

MORE AT Just Eat

Absolutely loved it!!! huge shout out to amazing team members Grace and Kacie who went above and beyond to deliver amazing service to a group of four, they worked fantastically in a fast paced environment to ensure that all our needs were met, absolute superstars toby carvery team should be very VERY grateful for the superb team they have acquired. Keep smashing it girls! 10/10 would DEFINITELY recommend.

site_logo

Liam Robinson . 2025-04-25

MORE AT Google

Food was just your average British breakfast but the service and atmosphere were lovely Marie at the till was kind and attentive and Sam in the kitchen did a quick and wonderful job

site_logo

folcon51 . 2025-04-24

MORE AT Google

Breakfast is good value for money

site_logo

Connor Mackenzie . 2025-04-24

MORE AT Google

Great price for breakfast, all you can eat and friendly efficient staff! Marie and Sam were great. Nice relaxed environment while we had to kill time.

site_logo

Carly Is offline . 2025-04-24

MORE AT Google

The Pepsi max I paid for did not come the gravy was only half filled the Mac and cheese tasted horrible and the chicken bits on top were dry the chocolate cake was gorgeous. You should ask people what veg they want on the carvery because of allergies

site_logo

Devon . 2025-04-24

MORE AT Just Eat

Great food but don't forget to book

site_logo

William Young . 2025-04-23

MORE AT Google

Food Missing.Cheesy Mushrooms,Pigs in blankets, Ordered Turkey and pork and only received 1 piece of pork.Not happy at all.

site_logo

Dean . 2025-04-23

MORE AT Just Eat

Best place we have been for a carvery in our area, and we've tried a few! Excellent service, especially from Grace and Matt. Highly recommend to anyone 👌🏻

site_logo

B Y . 2025-04-21

MORE AT Google

Nipped in for dinner, Server Frances was a ray of sunshine as normal, prompt and kind Frances is just the best! :)

site_logo

Leoni Templey . 2025-04-19

MORE AT Google

Plenty of staff who are happy to help. Food was hot, which is my main concern with a carvery so this made my visit that bit more enjoyable. Standard TC quality which I love so no concerns with the food. I'm not one who can face the king size portion as the standard plates are big enough to load up. I would revisit this TC again in the future.

site_logo

John Madigan . 2025-04-19

MORE AT Google

I ordered a chocolate fudge cake and it did not come I also ordered Mac and cheese that had no chicken pieces on top like it was supposed to. There wasn’t enough gravy I would have liked more, I didn’t like the veg or mash at all they tasted funny.

site_logo

Devon . 2025-04-17

MORE AT Just Eat

Mega breakfast and friendly staff

site_logo

Corey Wilson . 2025-04-17

MORE AT Google

Marie / Terri delicious food and excellent service ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

site_logo

Melissa C . 2025-04-15

MORE AT Google

They’ve forgotten the drinks and cakes for the meal we have ordered. When I tried to ring to speak to somebody no one has answered

site_logo

Joshua . 2025-04-13

MORE AT Just Eat

Had the large carvery... 4 different meat selection. Paork, Gammon, Turkey n Beef.... Plenty of vegetables selection.... Good place to visit

site_logo

chris beavan . 2025-04-12

MORE AT Google

Amazing breakfast good choice for every person's taste. Staff friendly and very polite especially Branden & Marie who made our visit there even better with their warmth and pleasant service

site_logo

Lorraine Merry . 2025-04-12

MORE AT Google

fast delivery of hot food, very nice

site_logo

Sandra . 2025-04-06

MORE AT Just Eat

Ordered a carvery meal for myself plus one for each of my grandsons too. We all enjoyed the food, it was fresh and just right for eating.

site_logo

Ian . 2025-04-03

MORE AT Just Eat

Darren is an exceptional carver. Excellent food, service and all staff are amazing 😊 Always clean, tidy and a great atmosphere 😊

site_logo

Ieva L . 2025-04-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a lovely Toby carvery it was really good and Michelle and Lewis couldn’t do enough for us and made out Toby carvery a really good experience

site_logo

karen mallon . 2025-04-03

MORE AT Google

Toby carvery breakfast ok but nothing special

site_logo

Nick H . 2025-04-03

MORE AT Google

The food was lovely and the staff very helpful

site_logo

crisi Finnie . 2025-03-30

MORE AT Google

Where do I start, what ver an hour late to arrive, meat missing off one dinner stuffing missing off one dinner, added in the notes the veg we wanted and received a load of carrots and peas, absolutely shocking. There was only enough meat to feed one person, you basically pay £33 for two dinners consisting of 2 slices of meat and the rest is just made up of potato and veg you didn’t ask for- don’t order delivery from here

site_logo

Stephanie . 2025-03-30

MORE AT Just Eat

Arrived after a busy day working in Doncaster. To avoid traffic stopped off to have dinner first. It was lovely. Team member greeted me at the desk and showed me to a table by the window. Took my drink order and explained where the conveniences were. Very friendly. Carvery chef was chatting and friendly. Lovely meat selection and scratchings. Very nice. Food was good, dessert was tasty (ice cream) and the shandy (was driving) was nice. Ready to continue my long drive down south. Overall a lovely experience.

site_logo

Heather W . 2025-03-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Absolutely lovely yourksire puddings great service

site_logo

x-ITZ-YATES-x . 2025-03-27

MORE AT Google

Food was good as always but Ordered J20 & bottle of 7 up and neither drinks turned up.

site_logo

Adrian . 2025-03-26

MORE AT Just Eat

Not too busy but in the daytime as we went for a breakfast but the food was lovely

site_logo

Jamie Thomson . 2025-03-24

MORE AT Google

Booked a table for six for Sunday lunch was crammed into a booth was so cramped couldn’t cut my food,food was ok no mash potatoes though,on arrival waiter a young lad was a bit rude eventually took us to our table,I politely asked him if someone could clean the seating as it was covered in peas and carrots to which I’m convinced he gutted about my request ,The food is ok the staff behind the carvery counter come across on the rough side and generally the customers need to learn how to dress vest and shorts in March well suppose it’s better than the mid week hi vis brigade that go in

site_logo

Gary P . 2025-03-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went late Sunday, they’d run out of mash due to equipment issues so this was a little disappointing as mash is an essential on a Sunday lunch in our household. Despite this, food was yummy and the Yorkshire puddings were great!

site_logo

Shanlf 9915 . 2025-03-23

MORE AT Google

Amazing service , best Sunday dinner I've had 😍

site_logo

Lauren Morley . 2025-03-23

MORE AT Google

Really good carvey today, Waitress Michelle went above & beyond with the service. Would come back just based on her service.

site_logo

Alexandra Poole . 2025-03-23

MORE AT Google

Pigs in blankets Chocolate fudgcake missing, Reportered

site_logo

Dean . 2025-03-22

MORE AT Just Eat

Usually OK but terrible food. Very limited. Rude female chef now on 2 occasions. Scruffy food counter. Very very diddapointing

site_logo

Cain W . 2025-03-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food was lovely mostly fresh produce kept getting brought out good value all though unfortunately there coffee option isn't nice at all very bland seems like been sat in the pot for a while and slightly cold would prefer instant and make with boiling water then coffee sat in a pot or coffee machine for customers to use at breakfast

site_logo

shaun ash . 2025-03-20

MORE AT Google

It came absolutely FREEZING wasn't happy. Considering we paid £27 odd for 2 large meals there wasn't much that come in eacheal but ALOT of pigs in blankets WOULDNT RECOMMEND DELIVERY AGAIN EVER

site_logo

Lynn . 2025-03-19

MORE AT Just Eat

love food from Tobys amazing as always

site_logo

Laura . 2025-03-18

MORE AT Just Eat

Excellent food and great delivery service.

site_logo

Michael . 2025-03-16

MORE AT Just Eat

Initially I wasn't going to leave a review but I feel it important for staff to have critical feedback. Firstly let me start by saying the review is not a reflection of the food. We have been here many times and never had a bad meal. Today at around 2pm me, my fiancé and our almost 8 month old came in for a meal, we have recently started baby led weaning so we are feeding our daughter the same things we eat. Naturally she is still learning so she is not the cleanest eater. She was eating some turkey and dropped a small amount on the floor (please be aware that most of this was picked up by my partner, we both have previously had hospitality backgrounds so we know how frustrating it can be to deal with a messy area). Once we had finished our meals, my fiancé heard the manager (didn't get her name but she was wearing a green jumpsuit) say "I hate dealing with customers with kids, they don't ever clean up their mess" and I think the lady that she said this to saw that we had heard it because she laughed awkwardly and started a different conversation. This really upset my partner as she had made an effort to clean up only leaving a tiny bit of mess on the floor. I seriously wish I'd taken a picture to demonstrate the miniscule amount left on the floor. I said to her that I was going to raise a complaint there and then but my she was really upset by the comment and didn't want me to do that so we left, and sadly we will likely never visit this branch (our closest) again as both of us have genuinely been put off by this one completely unnecessary comment. I would have rather she brought us a hoover or a dustpan and brush and asked us if we didn't mind to sweep it up. To clarify, leaving any mess behind at all is not acceptable as the waiting staff are already incredibly busy and we have nothing but respect for the job they do as we know just how hard it is.

site_logo

Ross Wells . 2025-03-16

MORE AT Google

Good nice food went for breakfast. My service women was Marie she was amazing

site_logo

Jane Brookes . 2025-03-11

MORE AT Google

Wonderful time and the server was Marie she was amazing

site_logo

Trish Flanaghan . 2025-03-11

MORE AT Google

Bacon barely cooked and Too much pepper in mushrooms, be nice to see black pudding on the breakfast menu!

site_logo

Jacob Warr . 2025-03-11

MORE AT Google

The best carvery from a toby pub ever delicious great staff great service

site_logo

john butterworth . 2025-03-10

MORE AT Google

Food was very spicy! I don’t know why?!

site_logo

Maryam . 2025-03-09

MORE AT Just Eat

Shocking service today. Food was cold, no mash potatoes and meat portions was ridiculously small.

site_logo

Katie Moffatt . 2025-03-09

MORE AT Google

Doesn't get a whole lot better than this for dining. Thank you to all of the staff at T.C. Rotherham xxxxx

site_logo

Dinky . 2025-03-07

MORE AT Google

missing the extra yorkshire puddings we ordered.

site_logo

Katy . 2025-03-07

MORE AT Just Eat

Marie was the lady who served us and was really friendly and helpful!

site_logo

Amy Daly . 2025-03-06

MORE AT Google

Slight issue but the manager sorted straight away. Lovely breakfast warm and plentiful.

site_logo

Faith Shaw . 2025-03-06

MORE AT Google

Lovely breakfast! Fresh and hot!

site_logo

laurakeen94 . 2025-03-06

MORE AT Google

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Truly Unforgettable Experience Walking into Toby Carvery, we expected a warm, homely roast dinner. What we got instead was a fever dream with Yorkshire puddings. Our evening was graced by Madame Zelda, a waitress who doubled as a psychic and part-time phone enthusiast. She took a “come and go as she pleases” approach to service, frequently disappearing to check her messages in the kitchen (possibly performing tarot readings for the roast beef). At one point, she shouted our order across the restaurant, because nothing says fine dining like a public broadcast of your meal choices. When the bill finally arrived (after what felt like an entire astrological cycle), we suspected it was incorrect but were too scared to ask. Over at the carving station, we encountered Mortdecai the Meat Miser, a man who looked as though he had seen things no human should. He did not speak. He did not smile. He merely mechanically sawed at the gammon, his hollow eyes betraying a deep and infinite sadness. And the food? Well. The meat was fine. The peas had been exorcised of all moisture and crumbled into dust. The roast potatoes were an abomination, somehow both overcooked and undercooked, wrapped in an alien-like skin. The macaroni cheese was simply macaroni with a vague memory of cheese. The roast parsnips? Lethal. If dropped from a height, they could kill a man. Adding to the ambience was a clientele best described as “varied”, and a mystery woman in loungewear, who may or may not have worked there. She had no uniform, no identification, and an air of casual authority. Was she a rogue diner who took matters into her own hands? We may never know. And yet—despite the questionable food, unsettling service, and general air of despair—we are giving this visit a solid five stars. Not for the food (obviously), not for the service (good lord, no), and not for the atmosphere (which was actively distressing). But for the memories, the unintentional comedy, and the sheer absurdity of it all. Would we return? Absolutely not. Would we talk about this night for years to come? Without a doubt.

site_logo

Epps Again . 2025-03-05

MORE AT Google

as usual the food was great with it being sunday there is a vast price increase for the carvery why

site_logo

geoff tonks . 2025-03-05

MORE AT Google

I'm a regular here, mainly breakfast, never disappointed, wide choice of food, relaxing atmosphere. Thanks Sam & Marie. Staff are really friendly.

site_logo

Lee . 2025-03-03

MORE AT Google

Tasty food a lovely Sunday dinner

site_logo

Linda . 2025-03-02

MORE AT Just Eat

Cold, late, poor quality and items missing

site_logo

Jayne . 2025-03-02

MORE AT Just Eat

Michelle and Marie went way beyond our expectations and satisfied with the 5* service! They deserve to be the best customer service advisors! 💪🏽 No beef left for our carvery at 14:30. Came in and there were no Beef ready, all meats available but not beef. Said will be in 20min, Waited 20min and still not done and not ready at all. It was ready in 40min. Was very sad about that, but lovely staff members Michelle and Marie M&M how they call it, undersood our experience and treated with drinks. They went beyond our expectations. This was much better experience!

site_logo

Saimanta Cernikyte . 2025-02-27

MORE AT Google

the food was fantastic, however could do with a bit more gravy only have a quarter of a Pot full

site_logo

Rebecca . 2025-02-26

MORE AT Just Eat

Excellent food lovely staff Marie & Matt,

site_logo

Kenny Gilberthorpe . 2025-02-25

MORE AT Google

Arrived early and we were seated straightaway. Waitress was very polite and helpful

site_logo

Sarah Burgan . 2025-02-24

MORE AT Google

Went to Toby carvery Rotherham today 23/02/25,food was lovely,we go regularly and always happy,all staff pleasant look like they enjoy their work,our waitress was Grace,lovely young lady,very polite,not seen her before,maybe new,nothing too much for her, will visit again soon.

site_logo

Lynn Shaw . 2025-02-23

MORE AT Google

Never ordering from them again. £13.99 (plus delivery (expected)) for a table spoon of peas & carrots, small ‘wedge’ of cauliflower, 1 roast potato, 2 massive dollops of mash, more than enough stuffing to feed the whole family (which is clearly stated on the order as NO stuffing), scraps of beef and gammon (not enough to cover a child portion), a cold crispy Yorkshire pudding in a bag, warmest thing was a pot of gravy.

site_logo

Patricia . 2025-02-23

MORE AT Just Eat

Absolutely excellent food and a really great delivery driver. Everything top notch, once again, from Toby Carvery. Thanks very much.

site_logo

Michael . 2025-02-23

MORE AT Just Eat

Lovely food, staff always working attentive and friendly especially Michelle always makes you feel welcome.

site_logo

francesca winter . 2025-02-20

MORE AT Google

Friendly staff. Just had a drink. No problems.

site_logo

Andy Harrison . 2025-02-17

MORE AT Google

It's OK just average carvery nothing much to say. Meat was a bit tough.

site_logo

Arnie Eyre . 2025-02-14

MORE AT Google

Great breakfast, plenty of choice

site_logo

Natalie Louise . 2025-02-13

MORE AT Google

Delicious breakfast all you can eat in a nice environment. Staff very friendly special shout out to our servers. Will defo be coming back

site_logo

Leanne Bott . 2025-02-12

MORE AT Google

We were served by Marie and Kevina , very good friendly service , we will come again .

site_logo

Julie Thurston . 2025-02-11

MORE AT Google

Came for breakfast. Very nice. Friendly staff. Marie and Kerina excellent

site_logo

Susan Adey . 2025-02-11

MORE AT Google

Great staff. Marie and kerine was really helpful and kept checking up on us

site_logo

Jessie Chapman . 2025-02-11

MORE AT Google

Marie was really nice and friendly.

site_logo

Tyler Walker . 2025-02-11

MORE AT Google

I was greeted by marie who welcomed us in she took us to our table and told us all how it worked kevina ask how our meal was and made sure we was happy Marie came back and helped clear the table asking again if everything was ok I felt the staff worked hard and cared about the guest I would recommend this toby as all staff members are very welcoming and courteous

site_logo

Pauline Omara . 2025-02-11

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in Yorkshire and The Humber

restaurant_img
4.0

2871 Opinions

location-iconSheffield Road
Other cuisines
outdoor_seating_189990takeaway_189990delivery_189990

Food was lovely, came out hot, even though the pub was a little busy we wasn’t waiting too long for food! Great service too!

restaurant_img
4.0

1588 Opinions

location-icon16 Union Street
Other cuisines
outdoor_seating_191689takeaway_191689delivery_191689

Contemporary pub after refit beer could be handled better

restaurant_img
4.0

1300 Opinions

location-iconBawtry Road
Other cuisines
outdoor_seating_215191takeaway_215191delivery_215191

Great pub. Good food during the day and great evenings out at the weekend. They keep it fresh with regular renovations and has a good outdoor seating area

restaurant_img
3.9

915 Opinions

location-icon133 Bawtry Road
Other cuisines
outdoor_seating_211309takeaway_211309delivery_211309

Just called for a drink, 1st Ale tasted stange, so picked something else. Quite expensive pints, cheaper places in the village. Barmaid not very chatty so prob wont bother again.

restaurant_img
3.9

154 Opinions

location-icon84 Westgate
Other cuisines
outdoor_seating_173722takeaway_173722delivery_173722

Tuesday 4th February 2025 Tonight we came into this great old fashioned real ale pub A propper locals pub with unspoilt bar and interiors of pub for a great range of real ales kept well When in Rotherham, this pub is a must to visit. This pub is good, and even though the barman was not very nice with photos took its understandable.