New York Tavern in Rotherham - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

This was a fantastic pub to visit, with a laidback tavern vibe! The wooden design, vintage frames and name echoing the New York stadium contribute to this, staff were really approachable too. A good selection of ciders is available and I had a tasty Strawberry Cider, sitting comfortably and the counter is neatly presented!

Great real ale pub. No bells and whistles, no tvs, no gimmicks. Just a damn good pub serving a good range of real ales and ciders. No food served other than crisps etc

Good traditional drinkers pub no pool or fruit machine, has jukebox though and a decent range of whisky 👌 well worth a visit

Not my kind off place mite be for some

Great place. Staff and local punters were welcoming to us away fans. Drink selection was top too.

Still the best pub in Rotherham.

Love this traditional pub for its well kept hand pulled beer, Special Reserve. It's won an award too so not the only person who thinks it's good. Don't serve pub food only crisps , etc. at bar.

Great real pub with friendly regulars, bar staff and good beer from Chantry Brewery. Old school boozer with good well kept real ales and plenty of keg if you like that thing including their own Lagers. Shout out to Aiden the barperson who was extremely helpful in guiding us around the towns other venues as it was new to us.

You can see why this has been Rotherham’s Pub of the Year for 7 years running - a classic pub with a great range of Chantery ales, real coal fires, top tunes piped out which does not stifle good conversation.

Really nice old pub with a lot of history. Live music and a good choice of drinks.

Cracking pub, great beer and a great atmosphere plus very welcoming for away fans

Good beers Bar tender good Price's not bad

Great local beers and decent prices by today's standards. 1 star for food because they don't do food. Highly recommended

Just a wonderful Yorkshire boozer, I highly recommend the Mighty Miller, lots of choice, friendly, professional and efficient service, it's great. Get down soon they've got 2 Maggie's on, another wonderful pint.

Cheap and local beers served before match games. Pint of Chantry Pilsner about £3.50. Varying levels of business, but can sometimes be 2/3 deep at the bar on match days.

Lovely drink and great people as usual

A very nice pub serving an excellent range of beers. We travelled recently from Ipswich for football, only to arrive in Rotherham and find the game postponed. However because we had a wasted journey and we're soaking wet with rain and cold, the landlord very kindly bought us a round. Much to our surprise, the barman bought us the next round. The locals were all very friendly people and were kind and understanding of our fruitless journey. Disappointed at the postponement, but the good folk of Rotherham are alright. We will call again when the game is rearranged. Come on you blues....and you Millers.

Great Alehouse full character and.... characters......

Beer, the best pint in Rotherham always, never had a bad pint traditional and friendly.

Good beer, good prices, good music. Not too rowdy...one if the few decent pubs left in Rotherham

Really happy and impressed with the food the chicken was really tasty

I used to look forward to a pint of Mighty Millers, but now it is weak and lacks body. What was once 5.5% tastes more like 3%. The only beers worth drinking are the Diamond Black and the Iron and Steel. Used to be a brilliant little pub, but think I shall do the cutlers in future.

Great small pub 12 real ale hand pulls :) top class Chantry beers

Nice surroundings, friendly service, good selection of beers etc and a good price 👍

Old school town pub with lots of real ales. Nice atmosphere and friendly

One of the best pints of real ale in the town centre.

Good selection of cask beers, well priced. Friendly, good service

Great place great beer, my friends pub full of lovely people

This is what you call a proper oldy worthy pub, open fire . Friendly people and chris and bar staff fabulous. Real Yorkshire ales from chantry brewery tap . You will get a warm welcome Come give it a try .fabulous range of other beers and spirits. Match days packed , other times more comfortable. Juke box if you want any music on . Had some smashing times with family and friends . We held my two brothers birthday's there and we was dancing and singing the night away . My brother Paul was so proud of new York tavern and I'm sure he be stood having a mighty Miller at bar in spirit. Proper Yorkshire pub ..

Wide range of local ales and a friendly atmosphere. The ale is just great, Chris the landlord is fab.

Good real ale here ,open fire, pickled eggs, just as a proper pub should be, cheers.

Love this pub, can't be beaten,for choice of some great beers, ,great value ,what more can you possibly won't

Top spot for great beer and company

Great traditional pub and great real ales

Mid afternoon so a bit quiet. But a nice looking pub with some good beers

Nice enthusiastic staff with a very warm welcome

Great place to meet friendly people with the best chantry brewery ales plenty to choose from there be one for you on the bar to enjoy 😉

Bloody great....Cheers Bomber!!

Superb, friendly, welcoming pub that has some top notch real ale from the excellent Chantry Brewery. We don't go into town on a regular basis but since we moved to Rotherham a few years ago, this is a pub we return to whenever we do. There are other options of course, and it naturally depends on what you're looking for in a pub, but for a guaranteed welcome and a wonderful beer or two, with like minded people, it's hard to top The New York. It's not just for us real ale fans though and whatever your tipple I think you'll find the atmosphere most satisfying. If you're going to support any pub, as we all try and recover from arguably the strangest times of all our lives, I highly recommend you consider making it the New York Tavern.

Nice little old pub traditional cask ale and hand pulled ales. Log fires brilliant traditional pub recommend. Thank you Pete for making me welcomed. Another local pub for me

This is a very lively place on the weekend. Great atmosphere, great staff.

The best beer around. Chantry ales are the finest. Pop in and try some for yourself.

Great well priced drinks friendly clientele and at least 2 gorgeous bar staff

Brilliant pint. Beers all in top condition. Wonderful company. Great landlord Chris and team.

Lovely atmosphere.. Great beer..

Quality pub beers from they own brewery at good prices 👌

Fantastic place, great beers, great staff

Excellent beer and so cosy now they have real fires

Great pub, great beer! They do take out too.

Fine ales as usual from Chantry with the addition of 2 open fires makes it very welcoming

Always a good pint cheers Chris

Very homely, friendly and welcoming pub with a fantastic range of beers. Barman was especially helpful as he came and collected orders from our large group.

Great beer, great atmosphere. Always enjoy the banter with the staff

Absolutely classic boozer. Needs to be on everyone Rotherham Pub Crawl list.

Bare fitting and fixtures ,cheap beer.

Good Beer, Good Music, Good Atmosphere, Good Prices....... what more could you ask for?

One of the best pubs I've been in fantastic beers fantastic staff mk

Always a pleasure chatting with the locals in a proper pub.

Best pub in town fantastic beer

Superb range of excellent beers. Only £2.60 a pint. Good ambience and hygiene. Lovely clientele

Best pub in Rotherham. Beer great and company.

A fantastic real pub, please visit if you ever pass through Rotherham.

Lovely ale, friendly staff, good prices. What more could you ask for?

Home of the Chantry Brewery, the New York Tavern is quite simply the best alehouse in Rotherham. The beer is kept in excellent condition and cannot be matched for price. The interior is basic but comfortable and decorated with many pictures of local scenes. The pub is very close to the football ground and although the atmosphere is excellent on match days this is not the time to visit for a quiet drink. Food is not served this is your place to drop in for a pint.

I went in here whilst doing an overnight stop. The pub was populated with a healthy gathering of locals, even though it was a Tuesday night. A traditional oil school pub, basic and functional. The most important thing about this pub is the ale.The bar has a very respectable collection of local ales on tap. Definitely, one to try if you want to sample the local ale. All at good prices

This is an excellent old-fashioned pub, selling excellent beer at an excellent price from Chantry Brewery, which is also based in Rotherham. It has a selection of guest beer, and also a juke box. The staff and customers are very friendly. Give it a try!

Nice and simple decor, clean and tidy. Superb collection of draft beers and ciders, very large bottled beer range. Thoroughly nice

Second visit for an away football game. As you can imagine a local fans pub but it is very friendly and has great ales at a great price. Good place to stop for a drink and to soak up the atmosphere.

On my rare visits to Rotherham, which in the main closed down years ago, I am pleased to report this pub upholds the traditions of a proper pub. No pretences here, just good beer. There is a fine selection of draught beers and they promote local brews to boot. All beers seem reasonably priced. Well worth a visit, but do not expect salubrious or luxurious surroundings

Chantry Brewery's finest. A good range of their own ales and loads of guest beers and ciders. Bottles from around the world. A real old tap room experience. Chris the landlord is a great guy (don't tell him I said so!!) Well worth a visit if you're a real ale fan :)

Great pre match pub, plenty of beers to choose from plus the odd lager. Even though the pub was packed service was quick with four able bar staff serving. No plastic glasses here , the ideal old fashioned pub for home and away fans to have a couple of pre match sherberts.

Top notch, great atmosphere and at £2.20 a pint I really cannot complain. Serving my favourite bitter Chantry Brewery's Iron and steel this local pub is definitely one of my favourite drinking places!

Plenty of choice of the usual drinks but also includes Chantry Brewery Ales which are excellent. Great jukebox too!!!

Excellent and very wide range of real ales, bottled beers from around the globe and Whiskies. Clean and tidy; a proper old fashioned drinking pub!

Cosy little boozer serving the best real ales in Rotherham with a great selection of bottles from around the world, including some of the best Belgian ales.The bar staff are friendly and know how to look after their beers.Good jukebox as well!After a visit stumble about 200 yards to The Cutlers - another pub with great real ales.

What a selection of beer from all over the world! As well as locally brewed beer, their selection of Belgian beer is excellent, from Duval and Chimay all the way to the almost elusive |Kwak!

If so, you now know where to come...Chantry breweries keg offerings always there plus lots of guest beers and some bottled "off the beaten path treats". For example a geuze lambic (you don't see/taste those often) plus fruited lambics (more common), American craft beers, and Schienkeria Rauchbier (smoked beer) when I was there.Food? Not so much but good pork pie & pickled eggs - what more do you need?This is a drinking pub and a beer drinkers exploratorium...

Excellent choice of beers from the local Chantry Brewery and some guest ones too. Most £2.10 a pint. Friendly locals welcomed away (Brighton) footie fans. I usually get annoyed when I am given a short measure but foamy heads are the norm in these parts and it seems churlish to complain when the beer is this cheap compared to down south! Chantry Old ale and Stout my favourites!

If you like real ale then this is a pub to visit. The beer is so good that I now compare all other beers with the ones served in this pub. The local Chantry Brewery supplies at least five excellent beers, Mighty Millers and Diamond black are my favourite beers. Don't expect too much in the way of food pickled eggs nuts crisps and pork scratching on menu all day and on match days you can get a Pukka Pie.The price of all regular reals ales is £2.10 a pint (a bargain). Great view of the New York Stadium.

This is our local and since its been taken over by our local brewery its even better. Good choice of beers and good prices. Always a warm welcome from the landlord.

Great local real ale, brewed in Rotherham, great prices! Mighty Millers beer is a favourite. Happy customer

The New York Tavern is just outside the town centre, but worth the short walk if you like choice and value when looking for real ale. Their bar is always well stocked with beers from Rotherham's own Chantry brewery, as well as a few other offerings from further afield alongside several real ciders delivered on draught. The pub itself is unpretentious and perhaps not the best inside, it fact it can look a little cold on occasions, but all real ales are always on at £2 per pint and as the quality is always high, it has to be worth a visit. Couple this with a walk across to the Cutlers Arms across the road for two great pubs offering real ale, you can't go wrong.

We visited this pub on our way to the football match. Rotherham United located in the vicinity. The place has five beers from the local Chantry Brewery plus other guest beers including San Miguel. We had a drink of Iron & Steel Bitter. It was exactly as it say “an easy drinking true Yorkshire session bitter”. If I was living locally I would have drank the first pint down straight. The Tavern is wedged shaped but once inside there is enough room with comfortable bench seating with chairs and tables. It is a short walk from the town centre or station. I was so impressed with the place and the drink that I had to write the first review.If you're an away fan then this place is a must for drinking.£2 a pint for ales it is a no brain-er.