The Teller in Sheffield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Had a Wonderful Bank Holiday Sunday at this Venue. The vibes and Atmosphere were definitely worth going again for 10/10

Turned off the football after 70 mins due to a private party, wouldn't put it back on. Don't start showing the game if you don't intend to show it all! Would have gone somewhere else if we had known as that was the only reason we went in there.

Sat here to watch the football and they turned it off at 70mins and kicked us out for a private party, thanks guys…

Not what it used to be when it opened. Did have great food, doesn't now. Beer range is OK, but pricey for out of town Sheffield .

Don't bother trying to ring them on number ending 83. It's my number now and I am fed up trying to get Teller to advertise their new number instead of mine. They clearly aren't interested in attracting customers.

Lovely pub but food a disappointment. We had nachos - for £7.50 you expect a plateful but this was a small portion of floppy wedges, looked like one tortilla had been fried and then sliced into wedges. Not as crispy as expected for nachos. Toppings of cheese, jalapeños and soured cream blended into a nice mush but no guacamole or salsa as promised on the menu. Halloumi fries were nice but, again, a very small portion for £6.95.

Lovely bar.Great staff.Great bar in every way.

If I could I would give it 0. Try to contact them via the phone no response. I am trying to locate my little sister who are no frequency this bar. Their calls are screened and even though I left a voice note nobody has got into contact with me. Thank you for your help it will now be a police matter.

Good clean pub. Good for sport watching

Beer selection is limited. Unfriendly staff

Emailed this place with queries about gluten free menu choices. Didn’t receive a reply so didn’t go with my group of 6. Went eventually to another restaurant that replied to an equivalent email in 2 hours.

Great boozer Great staff Great chicken wings

This is a comfortable and relaxing establishment. It was my first time in The Teller courtesy of Yorkshire Wing Kings. The atmosphere, music, food and drink was well worth the visit.

The art of customer service has been lost here. Moody and disinterested bar staff. A polite request for the live tennis to be popped on was a real struggle. Flicked around 2 channels and gave up. Bar man seemed more interested in chatting to his mates. Used to be a decent bar.

Terrible experience. Felt like we were not welcome as soon as we walked in. Strange place. Certainly won’t be returning … EVER!!

Fab bar music staff will defo be back. Just celebrated my friends birthday there had such a blast.

A very grooving club, DJ was on fire, 90s jams, very nostalgic, for 40s and over

Seriously the best burger I've had in the UK. I always get the "personal cheesus", well done w/ extra cheese & pickles. I love the well-done option, for me it's the only way a burger should be. They put plenty of cheese & pickles (but I'd love an option to add even more!). I've only ever ordered thru ubereats and the cheeseburger is always perfect, nothing missing, just as ordered. A solid 5 stars (I'd give more if possible) for the cheeseburger alone, and how friendly / customer service oriented they are the 2 times I've called. Yet for me, the other menu items - at least what I've tried which are onion rings, chicken sandwich, 4 diff types of fries, onion rings, "buffalo" tenders, and chicken tenders - are sadly a let-down. We do onion rings differently in USA. I prefer a thin, light, crispy, seasoned coating on my rings (panko is usually the best), but S&P's are very thick battered + quite greasy. I tried them twice but won't again. Their fries are also too greasy + dry inside for me, as I like crinkle cut or true french fries w/ thin coating and moist inside. Chicken sandwiches are one of my favorite things in life, but sadly i've only had 1 good one in the 10 years I've lived here. Back home, chicken sandwiches are made w/ buttermilk fried chicken or a nice light crispy breading w/ very little seasoning, dill pickles, and never very greasy (and never, ever with lettuce). Whereas all the fried chicken I've had here is heavy, greasy, and with odd seasoning. Finally, the buffalo strips weren't marinated / tossed in a true buffalo sauce, but rather came with some sauce I didn't care for on the side so I didn't enjoy those. I know they're cooking for the Brits tho, not me, so I'm sure others enjoy the other menu items. In fact my housemate loves the naked fries, so it's a cultural and/or ethnic thing. It does make me sad the burgers are so amazing, yet I can't order any sides. I wish they'd be open to some input, since they seem to want to be regarded as "American" style food (it's anything but, save for burgers) - I'd be thrilled if they had different sides that were in fact more American, or at least prepared them a more authentic way. I got excited tonight as they had jalapeno poppers on the menu, but they said they don't have them in stock + prob won't carry at Sheffield. rather gutted, that might be the one side I'd love! U can't go wrong with poppers, please start stocking them. I promise to order 2 times a month if u do! If you're a homesick American, stick with the burgers & cheeseburgers. Otherwise, everything is quality, just not to this Californian/Texan's taste. I'd so love for that to change...I'd even be happy if they just stocked the poppers and maybe offered crinkle cut fries as well. If anyone made it thru my whole review (why is it so hard for us Americans to condense?!) you deserve a medal. Or at least a triple personal cheesus burger (tho I've only ordered the small since I'm worried about the cheese & pickle to meat ratio, I need all the cheese)!

I didn't realise this place was a tapas place until I saw it on here. Mind you we did visit on a Saturday night so pretty much no one was eating. Got served pretty quickly and got a seat pretty easily. Hard to really judge the place as it was coming towards the end of the night so things were dying down a bit.

Tell em Again at the Teller was awesome

Nice bar great atmosphere and friendly staff Comedy night #tell em at the teller ever fortnight which is a great night

Excellent staff and delicious food. Had tomato and avocado on sourdough. Staff very helpful and friendly.

Free comedy night on a Tuesday thats amazing! Fantastic nibbles too only 4/5 items on the menu but why do more if you do them perfectly!? Have to say a cracking little hidden gem of a pub/bar will 100% be going back again!

Comedy on a Tuesday night was good and busy. Sat outside as it was only comedy inside. Bar staff were friendly and service was quick. Will go again.

Really poor burger. When it arrived it was cold. Really poor quality.

Good food, although it was a bit early for them to have run out of Jackfruit Wings. Great for a sports bar but I'm more a real beer and old wood kind of person.

I just ordered from here on deliveroo Im soo disappointed The total was £18.66 This was for a burger and onion rings The burger is so small , not even barely warm whitch was £9.75 And the onion rings are stone cold for £4.50 i expected them to be reyt nice I really feel i have just wasted more money on food Deffo sick to what i know from now on 😑😥😥

We ordered from there on the 03/03/21 - the burgers were outstanding. A++ definitely heading back there once this lockdown is over. Would highly recommend the food and the staff were just lovely.

Ordered a click and collect on wednesday and just wanted to say that it was great! My burger was perfect, fries were amazing and a big portion size! The onion rings were so crunchy! They even threw in a free coke zero and sauces!

Very slow service when collecting. We were told to collect so made the trip out and waited 25 mins for them to actually hand us our food!

Best burger I've had in Sheffield.

I visited here a while back but have only just got around to writing a review. This place is weird, only had drinks but I did not like the atmosphere and its overpriced. I did not eat here but if you are vegan then there is nothing so don't bother. I would not return. Another protentiouos and overpriced place in Sheffield. Like the city needs more of them.

Ordered a takeaway in lockdown 3.0 and it was amazing! Trying somewhere new on Deliveroo can be a bit of a gamble (even if you know the place food doesn’t always travel well) but honestly the food was so good. Will be ordering again! Can’t wait for the bars/restaurants to open up again because I shall deffo be adding this to my must visit list! Well overdue a Abbeydale road bar crawl!

Great burgers from @slapandpickle.

After hearing amazing things about the burgers here (and seeing so many amazing pictures on Instagram!) me and my partner finally gave them a go and ordered last night. We where luck to get the BOGOF deal on Uber eats (Tuesday-Thursday not sure how long for!) so both had the Personal Cheesus burger with onion rings each and shared some naked fries. The burgers are so tasty and juicy, honestly best cheeseburger I have ever had, great amount of sauce and pickles. Onion rings where spot on and the fries are fab. I can't describe them but they are like V shaped? So if you got loaded fries it would hold all the sauce and toppings. Genius. Really loved it - please give them a try if you are fancying a local takeaway in lockdown!

Second visit since Slap and Pickle opened here at The Teller. I am a 65 year old mega fussy eater who does not eat burgers.......well I've been converted! We all had different burgers, all were amazing. I could just eat fish of fries, so naughty, so nice. It isn't cheap but it's true what they say, you get what you pay for. We had fried to share between three of us and there was more than enough, all have good appetites! Now it was cold in there, but in current situation when they have to leave door open we accept it.

Nice pint of Gamma Ray, friendly staff.

Decent place, we didn't get what we ordered but it was bloody lovely and the staff were clearly rushed off their feet and very nice. Saw someone else said the place needed a carpet which initially I thought was an odd comment but then realised what they mean - it is deafening in there after everyones had a fw drinks. The acoustics + drunken cackles are a bit jarring.

Visited recently, seems the menu has changed to just burgers etc. Nice but average burger and loaded fries, this and a drink cost me nearly £20. Way too over priced. Also was freezing inside...

I visited The Teller a couple of weeks ago, purely because the venue I planned to visit was full. And, needless to say, I wasn't disappointed. The food was excellent, the service was friendly and the atmosphere was relaxed. Will almost certainly be calling in again.

Drinks are lovely and in a brilliant area of Sheffield but can no longer comment on food quality as the kitchen has changed.

Lovely staff and a vibrant atmosphere

Quality service during lockdown... Needs a carpet tho. Beavertown on tap

The Teller is a friendly and welcoming bar, it's modern and clean, with a fab range of drinks, in the current climate it is also very covid aware. I will definitely be coming back and highly recommend it. Five stars without a doubt.

Great food. reasonably priced wine

We were greeted by abigail upon entry. She suggested some cocktails to suit our preference and they did not disappoint. We enquired about dinner and were sat to nice table the second waitress hatti gave us a great low down on the menu and explained the process of the menu which was described as local, fresh and innovative. The menu was as described and we thoroughly enjoyed our. Eal and the experience overall. I would recommend for any one looking for the new hot spot to eat.

The place itself is odd in terms of layout, the decor isn’t very inviting and it seems cold and a bit drab. It seems a strange mix of restaurant and bar but doesn’t achieve either really well. The food choice was small, and this is clearly intentional and not an issue in itself. But we were informed after ordering that some of he dishes we ordered weren’t available and so we substituted (and to the credit of the staff were given a 10% discount for the inconvenience!). The food itself seemed oily. An ambitious menu that just wasn’t executed well, or so it seemed. Dishes were either bland or too oily and didn’t actually look appetising - we left feeling disappointed that we’d spent money and had such a poor quality meal. I’d say that it could possibly be clearer how to order and what sort of food it was but that’s a minor issue. Staff were friendly though! I feel that there was an effort made to ensure a good experience but this was ultimately thwarted by all the above 🙁

As per most reviews about the Teller the service was great with the staff being fast and effeicent once seated, although getting seated was an issue. The food was the real let down here with poorly executed flavour combination and far to much salt being used or added to already salty (cured) meats. Its a shame as the venue is nice, a little cold (temp), but design and layout are great. My overarching opinion is the Teller doesn't really know what it wants to be - the bar/restaurant idea isn't going to work with aloud boisterous bar atmosphere and the restaurant goers suffering with having to shout to be heard. P.s. stay away from the artichoke heart tarte tatin, truely one of most disgusting dishes I have ever had to taste.

The Teller was close to our Air BnB so we walked over and found that many tables had been reserved, yet the place had few patrons at the time. It soon became clear why. The food is excellent and very reasonable. We will reserve next time as we are here for several weeks. If the service would have been better, I would have rated this place Exceptional. Found the wait staff a little aloof and non attentive.

Imagine the noise in a swimming pool and the cold breeze that wafts you every time the door opens along with what they call small plates which at best were luke warm and tiny. Bad choice by us - we had tried for 3 weeks to get in - just a let down. Seats are hard canteen style and upholstered bench, but the food - menu is tempting but don't be, you will remain hungry, not be able to chat and have spent a lot of money trying to make the best of a poor experience. Think the place has no clear identity but does attract a lot of drinkers not eaters.

This is the second time I’ve been here. The first time was great, the second excellent. A brilliant selection of small plates, great drinks, and stylish surroundings. Loved it. Can’t wait to go again.

This place is an excellent addition to Sheffield’s foody hotspots. The small plates menu was imaginative and perfectly executed and the service was spot on, knowledgeable, attentive and accommodating. We will definitely be back!

I can't in all honesty give it fewer stars because we left without eating here. First they denied that we had booked a table despite my friend having had a conversation with them when she did so. When I went to wipe the crumbs off...

We booked a table for Saturday evening and from reading previous reviews expected it to be noisy. I had called the restaurant a week before going to request a table in the snug so that we were not in bar area. Despite saying that they...

Interesting concept but, for the prices and the (small) portion sizes, the small plates really have to deliver on flavour and we found the food to just be ok. Service was good though and the venue’s quite nice but not sure if it’s supposed to...

Interesting and varied menu, beautifully presented. Quality & taste were 5* Great neighbourhood restaurant, worth crossing the city for.

First, a few good things to say about The Teller - the menu is really interesting, lots of unusual choices and the food was delicious! The staff that served us were polite and friendly. This place has the potential to be really great, but there...

This is a bar/restaurant environment and if your looking for a quiet meal this is not the place to be! If you want an incredible meal with a lively atmosphere this place is perfect! My husband and I went out on a very rare night...

My husband and I booked in advance to dine at The Teller on a Saturday evening. Our first night out since having our third baby we were hoping for a nice cosy meal. On arrival the whole place was heaving and there appeared to be...

Visited for the first time last weekend with my boyfriend, for a couple of drinks. It is advertised as a restaurant and bar however the format of this place doesn’t seem to work, for one it seems too small for it to be both. We...

Expected better . The food and service was pretty average to be honest but the concept is more exciting than the reality .

Valentines day trip to this newly opened restaurant, think it opened mid December last year. The tasting menu was on reading filled with courses that are firm favourites of mine (duck/steak/langoustine/dulche de leche). Initially on being seated we failed to receive, unlike every other table...

We had an enjoyable couple of hours sampling the tasting menu, complimented with paired drinks. The food was excellent and the service was good. More information about the food being served would have been a welcome bonus, but it didn't detract from the experience.

The format of this place is spot on. Relaxed, with some formal touches that make it feel special. The food is good, with the potential to be great. The principle behind many of the dishes is sound but often the flavour is underdeveloped or unbalanced....

We took the kids for a Saturday late lunch (2:30ish) and it was brilliant. Look at the size of those croquettes! And I can promise you that each on was jam packed with delicious, slow braised oxtail. Had an Australian shiraz to go with that...

Me and my girlfriend went for dinner on Thursday 13th February after noticing a new place had opened and online the menu looked interesting and diverse. The Keg beers were all off due to them not being delivered, we opted for a Birra Moretti as...

I first wrote a review back in January with a rather happy description of the small plates and the service but a lack of enthusiasm for the desserts. Went back today and was delighted to find the feedback had been noted. The 4 deserts we...

Excellent, no faults what so ever, staff are faultless 👍👍

Nice addition to the street, a bit early to tell if its gonna be great, but early signs are good. Nice selection of beer, clean loos, a place to sit and they do slightly upmarket pub food. Just the one downside that there weren't enough staff serving beer and they haven't got the 'who is next to be served' sense yet, so I've dropped a star. I would definitely be using it a lot if it was closer to home.

Lovely food. Won't hesitate to go back

As with many other modern gin bars they don’t sell the market leading Gordon’s Gin , or decent tonic water . Not everyone wants to drink new pretentious flavoured gins and flavoured tonic water, that are effectively alchopops ... When I ask for a gin I want the market leading brand of a good London Gin .

The food here definitely surpassed expectations, very tasty and interesting! The staff were great too.

Great atmosphere and really good food

Think "the Teller" is a great addition to local food & drink scene. Sells unusual dishes, proper high standard cooking using high quality local ingredients, small plates but full of flavour, stuff you can't buy anywhere else. Also pleasant place to hang out & have a relaxed drink or a coffee. Not snotty or pompous.

This is more like fine dining than tapas, and it's fantastic! Great to see a really good vegan menu as well as meaty options. Portions are delicate, so don't go expecting pie and mash! Food like this is so much work and the chef deserves praise for the ambition and effort.

Great food, great atmosphere. We loved it.

My husband and I came to try the food as we'd heard so much good stuff about it. Rhe menu is perfectly crafted, not too overwhelming, and the idea is you order 2-3 small plates, and can share if you wish. We ordered a selection of dishes and they were all fantastic, amazing flavour combinations and beautifully presented. The atmosphere is great, the music appropriate and not too invasive and the staff were helpful, efficient and chatty. We loved it. Well done Sam!

Surprised and delighted by this place. Tapas style dining (small dishes that come out when they’re ready) but not tied to a particular cuisine. I was told that dishes regularly change based on what quality local and seasonal produce the chef can get, and they all have some sort of original twist. We had six dishes between two of us, plus a dessert each. Who knew mushroom ice cream could taste so good?

Nice place. Great location and good beer

Outrageous prices for the quantity

Delicious tapas to share. If you are a early bird, great menu and very good price. Different menu... and nice personnel...

Had the best Sunday Lunch I’ve had in ages, so much so I’m heading back today for another!