GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4.7

Based on 412 opinions finded in 2 websites

site_photo4

Nº 58 in 422 in Newark and Sherwood

Nº 2 of 10 Italian in Newark and Sherwood

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..pizzagarlictiramisubeautiful

comment_iconOpinions

Hugely disappointed. After being recommended by several people I placed a takeaway order. Wasn’t ready when arrived at the pickup time and when got home was massively unimpressed when opened the box, ended up having to put my own cheese on it!

site_logo

Chris B . 2024-11-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Just finished some delicious pizza with the kids and it was amazing. The kids definitely loved it too. The staff were polite and professional. The management were also very welcoming with smiles. The best pizza in town by far.

site_logo

Michael A . 2024-11-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Beautiful restaurant with such an interesting, varied and tasty menu. Staff were so helpful and attentive and accommodated all our needs. Pizzas made in the middle of the restaurant, made by hand and delicious. A scrumptious meal on pizza bread. A comfortable and homely place to eat, with tables tastefully placed. A regular eating place for our family.

site_logo

Rachel L . 2024-11-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great food, Frankie was our waitress and was so lovely! Needs wage rise ASAP! Pizzas were excellent and could tell they were home made.

site_logo

Phoebe L . 2024-11-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This is a fantastic place. The food is amazing, the services and the team all attentive. Nothing was too much trouble. The prices are reasonable, the portions are generous. Incredible. Can't wait to go back.

site_logo

Lena S . 2024-11-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Always enjoy going to the Rustic Crust, and now that the outdoor eating area has lovely heaters, it’s even more comfortable for a relaxing drink and meal!

site_logo

Cheryl Lowe . 2024-10-27

MORE AT Google

Best restaurant for miles around. Pizzas are excellent, staff are really good. Just go there, you won't be disappointed 🙂

site_logo

Jaime Martin . 2024-10-24

MORE AT Google

What a great place .our 1st visit and food and service was second to none . Definitely recommend and will be coming back for more . Thank you to your team they are amazing.

site_logo

Terry Rothery . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Great place, good atmosphere, and good service

site_logo

Mark Yates . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

Great food and atmosphere, a lovely meal out. Would highly recommend....

site_logo

Stuart Thompson . 2024-10-18

MORE AT Google

10/10 would recommend! Pizza was amazing! Had pistachio semifreddo for dessert which was absolutely incredible! Friendly staff! Would definitely come back.

site_logo

JaLeNe018 . 2024-10-06

MORE AT Google

Rustic has the best, most delicious pizza, by far, for miles around. Crust and toppings are excellent quality, we have never had a bad one. Restaurant or takeaway away, it is pretty much a faultless experience.

site_logo

Dan Whitt . 2024-10-03

MORE AT Google

The pizzas, and all the food, is incredible - our favourite in Nottingham by a long way and we’ve tried a lot! Great atmosphere in the restaurant, lovely staff and cocktails, always our go to for pizza!

site_logo

Christie Hudson . 2024-10-01

MORE AT Google

Booked your pizza truck for an event and it was brilliant. Everything from the amazing food, organisation, friendliness of staff, it was all perfect. Thanks so much - would absolutely recommend!

site_logo

Elyssia Kravaris . 2024-10-01

MORE AT Google

A lovely little find in a pleasant village. Stayed at a local air bnb after visiting spa. Lovely food and outdoor courtyard.

site_logo

Shirley E . 2024-09-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Incredible pizzas! So tasty and absolutely delicious. The pistachio cannoli is this months special but hopefully they'll make it a regular on the menu. First time visiting but will definitely be going again. Staff lovely and attentive. Just needs a bit of Italian music in the background.

site_logo

Anne Stevenson . 2024-09-20

MORE AT Google

Went out to collect something we bought on Marketplace and wanted somewhere to eat found this place. Brilliant, wish it was a little closer to home would be in there every week!

site_logo

Joanna Hillas-Smith . 2024-09-19

MORE AT Google

Incredible pizza, nice atmosphere and great service from Frankie. Don’t miss the tomato pesto on the side. Molto bene!

site_logo

AdamJ . 2024-09-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We went for lunch on a Friday afternoon. We had the 3 courses for £19.95 and the food was exceptional, some of the best food we’ve had and one of the best pizzas we’ve ever had. The portion sizes were big and very filling. Staff were friendly, attentive and really welcoming. Would definitely recommend and we’ll definitely be returning.

site_logo

Joseph Wiley . 2024-08-23

MORE AT Google

Come for the pizza and you won't be disappointed, however if you come JUST for pizza you are missing out. They serve the best pizza in the area, but the starters and desserts are way above the quality that you get everywhere else. The monthly specials are always incredible. Throughly reccomend

site_logo

David Beaumont . 2024-08-23

MORE AT Google

I’ve been meaning to do this review for so long! We have probably visited Rustic Crust over 20 times and every visit has been superb. The owners and staff are really friendly and professional, and the food is just perfect. We went last night and finally decided it was time to get the review out there!

site_logo

Rob Jones . 2024-08-22

MORE AT Google

I went to the rustic crust with friends, on the recommendation of another friend, to celebrate a birthday. The whole experience from booking to the meal was excellent. When asked why we were attending I said it was for a birthday, and they said they would put a birthday card on the table. A lovely touch! Our waitress Meg, along with the other colleagues provided a lovely evening. One of our party has coeliac and needed gluten free food. He was offered to have his pizza cooked in a separate oven to prevent cross-contamination. A wonderful consideration for people with coeliac. My friend said that his pizza was moist and very tasty, as many gluten free bases are hard and crisp. The food was delicious and the atmosphere friendly and professional. Will definitely return and have recommended the rustic crust to many of my friends. Excellent 5 star service and food.

site_logo

Richard S . 2024-08-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

lovely meal sat in a picturesque outside area! all the staff were lovely! alice our server was a gorgeous queen! yummy food and drinks! xxx

site_logo

Ashleigh S . 2024-08-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Amazing pizza. My other half said. Best pizza outside of Italy. So filling and flavourful. Highly recommend.

site_logo

Samantha Holland . 2024-07-28

MORE AT Google

Absolutely fantastic evening for a large group booking of 21! We had the buffet option which included 6 pizzas, salad, homemade coleslaw, Dips and filthy cannoli. All of it was top notch and so delicious! We were able to help ourselves to a box and take home any leftovers we didn't eat too. Drinks took a little while to come out after being ordered but it was super busy for a Wednesday evening and the staff were really attentive from waiting, to chefs to manager. Huge thank you from all 21 of us!

site_logo

Sarah Windibank . 2024-07-25

MORE AT Google

Heard about this place through positive word of mouth and thought it was worth a try. It very much did not disappoint. Good options of both food and drink, all of excellent quality. The quality of service was even better however. We were delayed sitting due to other customers overstaying, and without asking, Joe the manager (a consummate professional and all-round top bloke) comp'd a few items off of our bill. Our server Daniella was also of a top quality, up for a laugh and generally extremely friendly. Overall, I cannot recommend the "The Crust" more, and I shall be returning.

site_logo

Jack Williams . 2024-07-25

MORE AT Google

Fantastic food, very friendly staff and dog friendly in the covered courtyard

site_logo

James Price . 2024-07-21

MORE AT Google

All perfect: food, service, local 😍

site_logo

Justyna Lodzinska . 2024-07-20

MORE AT Google

one of the best all round genuine restaurants nothing to much trouble food fresh and well presented , staff always busy attending to the customers, any new staff are well trained polite and non pushy , always a good vibe, specials are worth a try, value for money, all the guests we have introduced have returned,

site_logo

Allan S . 2024-07-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We visited for my son in law's birthday- the venue itself is really lovely and the staff very attentive and helpful! The pizzas were the best I'd ever tasted - the staff helped us pick a selection and we all enjoyed them! The kids sure enjoyed the deserts too!! We will definitely be back!

site_logo

Suzanne G . 2024-07-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

pepperoni and goat’s cheese pizzas were great as was the atmosphere. But had to wait just short of an hour for the food.

site_logo

AJC 04 . 2024-07-06

MORE AT Google

Excellent service and food as always at the Rustic Crust thank you See you very soon

site_logo

Andy Daniel . 2024-07-05

MORE AT Google

What a wonderful restaurant. Fantastic food, great choice of drinks, a lovely setting and great service. It’s my third visit and I will return very soon.

site_logo

Helen D . 2024-07-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Authentic Italian pizza. Slick service. A little loud in the restaurant as there are no soft surfaces to absorb noise. It would not stop me from returning. As welcoming to families as you would find in any Pizzeria or restaurant in Italy.

site_logo

Linda Moakes . 2024-07-02

MORE AT Google

I could not recommend this place highly enough! Visited in the evening with a couple friends and sat outside, the service was brilliant, very friendly and attentive we didn’t have to wait for anything. The atmosphere for a surprisingly busy Wednesday night was lovely. The pizzas are to die for! Honestly one of the best pizzas i’ve had in my life, and the Semifreddo was soo beautiful! Definitely will be visiting again!!

site_logo

Laura B . 2024-06-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

always a well organised restaurant, always busy, a gem honest quality food and super Service, quality costs, it’s not a commercial restaurant it’s fresh, have recommended many people they are now regular visitors, all taste catered for just ask the polite helpful staff

site_logo

Allan Smith . 2024-06-20

MORE AT Google

One of the nicest places i've been in a long time for food. The atmosphere is lovely, feels like you've taken a mini trip to Italy. The food is beautiful, fresh and delicious! The staff are polite, friendly and helpful. Thank you for a lovely evening.

site_logo

Sam Burgess . 2024-06-14

MORE AT Google

Lovely place, lovey food, bit on the top end of picing in my eyes, for what basically is a pizza, but cant fault the place, the meatballs are just amazing, well worth a visit, freindly staff, lovely atmosphere 😁

site_logo

Simon Pallett . 2024-06-08

MORE AT Google

Really nice place to visit for a meal - food was fantastic and a really nice environment.

site_logo

Emma Brocklehurst . 2024-06-01

MORE AT Google

Nice staff and great food, definitely will be going back

site_logo

Craig Bradford . 2024-05-27

MORE AT Google

Visited today for the first time with family and it won't be the last. All agreed it was probably the best pizza we can ever remember eating. So lovely and fresh, absolutely delicious. Family friendly atmosphere, relaxed, food arrived quickly and service was good. Excellent value for money for proper quality food- I'll never spend a penny at dominoes again! This is real pizza. My young kids are a good test- they love pizza but will soon say if it's not a good one, and they loved it here! A lovely experience that we look forward to repeating.

site_logo

Kate S . 2024-05-26

MORE AT Google

Beltin pizzas, Ross and Tom are gentlemen!

site_logo

Ben Lewis . 2024-05-25

MORE AT Google

At Everard's this morning..wow the best pizza I ever had. Thin, crispy with generous quality toppings. Wonderful friendly service too.

site_logo

Joanne Bayliss . 2024-05-18

MORE AT Google

Amazing food, friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Would recommend!

site_logo

J R . 2024-05-12

MORE AT Google

The initial greet was great, the food was very nice. Garlic bread was delicious! However we are probably being generous giving a 3* for the service. The garlic bread was a large pizza base which we intended to share. It arrived, but we needed to ask for side plates as it was just placed in the middle of the table and was oozing with butter. We were given plates and had to request napkins too. They did then suggest cutlery would be useful which they bought out and we used. When the pizzas arrived, no new cutlery or napkins. We asked for water as it was a hot day, a small bottle was bought out but no ice. Following the pizza they cleared our plates and asked if we’d like to see dessert menu, which we did. We were given the menu, but 15 + minutes later no one had been to take our order. The staff were often chatting behind the bar area. Eventually they came after we kept trying to catch their attention and took our order and we requested more water. 6-7 mins later out come delicious looking desserts, without any napkins and no water. Staff still chatting away behind bar, we resorted to sharing a tissue to mop the corner of our mouths after our food. Eventually we managed after finishing the desserts to catch their attention to bring our drinks. To sum up the food was lovely, but the service way below standard especially as it wasn’t very busy and would put us off visiting again

site_logo

Rach T . 2024-05-11

MORE AT Google

A Slice of Heaven 🍕 I recently had the pleasure of dining at Rustic Crust, and I must say, it was an experience that exceeded all expectations. From the moment my wife and I stepped through the door, we were warmly welcomed by the owner, Camil, whose passion for hospitality shone through every interaction. Camil's attentive service truly made us feel like part of the family. Throughout our meal, she checked in on us regularly, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. Her genuine care and attention to detail were evident in every dish served. Speaking of dishes, the pizza dough at Rustic Crust is nothing short of divine. Each pizza bite was a symphony of flavors, perfectly balanced and expertly crafted. It's clear that the chefs here take great pride in their work, using only the freshest ingredients to create culinary masterpieces. But what truly set Rustic Crust apart was the unexpected gesture of generosity from Camil herself. Not only did she provide us with outstanding service during our visit, but she also went above and beyond by gifting us some complimentary pesto to take home with us. It's this kind of personalized touch that transforms a good dining experience into an unforgettable one. In conclusion, I wholeheartedly recommend Rustic Crust to anyone in search of not just a meal, but an experience. From the warm hospitality of Camil to the delectable dishes served, this charming pizzeria has truly won me over. Make sure to pay them a visit—you won't be disappointed.

site_logo

Hijaz . 2024-05-05

MORE AT Google

Please open one in West Bridgford guys. Pizza Express is terrible and you'd absolutely kill it here. We are crying out for a great pizza restaurant!

site_logo

R . 2024-04-27

MORE AT Google

First visit tonight, and will definitely be back very soon. All the food was special and delicious, great portion sizes, especially the tiramisu which was enough for 2. Rounded the meal off with espresso martinis which the barman stated were a good choice... He was not wrong as they were first class. Our server, Meg was absolutely superb. Very attentive, made sure we had everything we needed, very friendly, and really made our experience at the restaurant. We had a lovely evening to remember. Like the atmosphere in here also. See you soon and thank you.

site_logo

Craig Newton . 2024-04-20

MORE AT Google

Absolutely amazing place to eat! Our server, Jess, was lovely and polite and the food was outstanding - Thank you so much!

site_logo

Luke Hemingray . 2024-04-14

MORE AT Google

Beautiful meal at the Rustic Crust. Our first visit, welcomed and made to feel special enjoying our anniversary evening. Attentive staff and gorgeous food. Thank you we will definitely be back x

site_logo

Tracy Ingleton . 2024-04-13

MORE AT Google

Booked Rustic crust today for myself and my partner as a recommendation from a work colleague and I must say she was not wrong!!! We ordered the Margherita and goats cheese pizzas and they were insane! Absolutely loved the flavours, the base and the crispy bits on the crust! We also had a side of homemade pesto dip and coleslaw! Both just as amazing. As we enjoyed it so much we then ordered two desserts; Filthy Cannoli and carrot cake with ice cream. Incredible! The staff were so welcoming and friendly and felt so comfortable!! Honestly this place is worth a visit! You can also bring dogs and sit in the garden! Thankyou!

site_logo

Erin Mordey . 2024-03-30

MORE AT Google

Fantastic visit today. Pre booked and table ready for us as soon as we arrived. Didn’t struggle to find parking even though the local car park was closed. The wife commented that her meal was the best meal she has had in ages. Staff were excellent and we were made to feel welcome and comfortable on arrival. Being very busy (Good Friday)they still had time to make sure everything was ok. I found the meal fantastic and better than any of the food we had while on a recent short break in Italy. (Yes we did go off from the tourist areas to find restaurants). The portion sizes are very generous and the tiramisu was outstanding. The wife also commented on how good the coffee was but I was too full to try. All in all an excellent meal and very good value for money. Will definitely visit again soon it’s just a shame it’s an hours drive away otherwise I would be visiting more often. Thank you RUSTIC CRUST.

site_logo

Chris Smith . 2024-03-29

MORE AT Google

delicious food and brilliant service 👍 will definitely be visiting again 🙂

site_logo

Helen Stevenson . 2024-03-22

MORE AT Google

Booked for my dad’s birthday, we had an incredibly warm welcoming from the team who wrote a personalised birthday card for my dad, the food was exceptional and the service was fantastic! My dad even said this was his favourite birthday meal so far and that he wants to come back for next year :)

site_logo

tom offiler . 2024-03-21

MORE AT Google

Amazing service even when they’re in a rush they called us back for the order food is lovely too always go here

site_logo

Niamh Edmunds . 2024-03-02

MORE AT Google

Where do I start.., as soon as we walked in we were amazed by how big the place was and the authenticity of the place! It’s absolutely stunning. We were treated warmly by Ryan one of the chefs and shown to a cosy booth. The whole team are amazing, very friendly and professional and nothing was too much trouble. I took my autistic son with me and they were wonderful with him listening to his feedback. The meatballs for a starter were an instant hit and very tasty . The pizzas (a vegan one and a chefs special), were also amazing. Quick service, the food arrived hot and beautifully presented. A big plus for myself was the fact that all the wines were labelled to show if they were suitable for vegetarians/vegans which many restaurants don’t do! The ambiance makes you feel you are in an Italian restaurant. The owner of the restaurant even stopped to say hello and she was lovely and genuine along with the head chef and manager. We decided to take two pizzas home with us and we were impressed by the quality after warming them through at home . We will definitely be back to this absolute gem and hope to try dining in the courtyard next time.

site_logo

944philipg . 2024-02-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fantastic food, amazing service and great atmosphere. Very reasonable prices! Will certainly be back!!

site_logo

stewart Barlow . 2024-02-23

MORE AT Google

Had a takeaway from here for the first time last night. Best pizzas we have ever had ! We are frequent visitors to a wood fired pizza van but Rustic Crust knocked their pizzas out of the park ! Garlic bread wasn't to our liking but it was free as we spent over £20. Highly recommend

site_logo

Maddy Stanton-Wales . 2024-02-22

MORE AT Google

First time with friends,nice place and atmosphere - we had a garlic bread to start with traditional pizza mushrooms and garlic. Whilst the food was very nice ,the garlic bread was unfortunately burnt around the surface, edge - we did inform the waitress who apologized and later removed the starter from our total bill ,very good . if we are being honest, even our main pizza was a little burnt but still acceptable. Table service was excellent

site_logo

Glyn Franks . 2024-02-19

MORE AT Google

What an amazing little spot of a pizzeria, first time trying this place after seeing it on Facebook on a Saturday evening. I can’t give my hat off enough to how polite the staff were from the moment we walked in to when we paid our bill. As for the food I have never tasted a pizza as delicious as these, we eat out a lot at restaurants and nothing tops these! We will be back 100% we’ve already rebooked. The only thing I would say is we wasn’t aware that the dips were an extra cost, we asked for some mayonnaise (2 pots) and when the bill came we was charged £1 a pot, I do think sauces should be free as they are at all the restaurants I go to.

site_logo

abiwww . 2024-02-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Just a great place to celebrate a special birthday when there was 23 people in your party. Pizzas were brilliant, very organised for how many of us there was, would definitely recommend.

site_logo

Go34343982100 . 2024-02-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Visited for valentine's day, the food and service was absolutely fantastic we even had the choice of dining from the set 3 course valentine's menu or the main menu, we opted for the valentine's menu it was absolutely fantastic from the impressive sharing starter right through to the dessert which I had tiramisu which along with the pizza is one of the best I have ever eaten. The service was great nothing was too much trouble, we will definitely be returning very soon. They also have a Fab cocktail menu.

site_logo

sonia H . 2024-02-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had 2 delicious takeaway pizzas from here can tell the quality of ingredients even though it was busy with valentines dinners they still smashed it out the park. Look forward to eating in, in future.

site_logo

Lawrence Dyson . 2024-02-15

MORE AT Google

We had a beautiful valentines night at The Rustic Crust. The food, service and atmosphere was just perfect. Thank you.

site_logo

Matt Hamilton . 2024-02-15

MORE AT Google

Highly recommended, amazing food, great friendly service! Authentic Italian cuisine, amazing desserts, filthy cannoli's and the homemade tiramisu were to die for :)

site_logo

Luke B . 2024-02-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fantastic restaurant. Delicious food, pizza was delicious and the Filthy Cannoli dessert was outstanding and the staff were super friendly. Will definitely return!

site_logo

Rajesh Bithal . 2024-02-14

MORE AT Google

Started with some delicious cocktails. My nduja starter was unbelievable too. Overall had a delightful afternoon. Will be back to try chef lloyds meatball marinara for sure.

site_logo

George V . 2024-02-10

MORE AT Google

Wow! Some of the best genuine Napoletana Pizza I have had in the UK or Italy! How the place isn't packed with a cue for tables down the street on a Saturday I really don't know! Our new favourite place for pizza. The Tiramisu was also fantastic, subtle but all the flavours. Burrata cheese was amazing too. Good size portions (pizza size spot on for a Pizza monster like myself) and good service too. In a lovely little village with other interesting shops also. Not had a meal out this good in a long time!

site_logo

Peter Davies . 2024-02-06

MORE AT Google

First time I’ve been here and all 4 of us enjoyed our pizzas! Nice restaurant with good service

site_logo

S Torre . 2024-02-05

MORE AT Google

Absolutely the best pizza!Lovely friendly staff, never disappointed. The atmosphere is warm, comfortable and inviting. The food is just beautiful. Very authentic Italian food, and amazing that you can buy supplies to take home.

site_logo

Joanna V . 2024-02-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Delicious Friday lunch - lovely friendly venue greeted and seated with a smile. Patient and attentive service. Good to die for. Amazing 2 and 3 course lunch menu and the pizza meatball sandwich (can’t remember Italian name - sorry) was absolutely delicious. Soft drinks this time but wine and cocktails are always exquisite. Thanks to your brilliant team xx sorry too delicious to stop for photos!

site_logo

Keri T . 2024-01-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Been here a few times now and cannot fault at all. Staff and service is fantastic, food is always delicious and well priced. Will be back soon and would definitely recommend.

site_logo

Katy B . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Such a lovely restaurant. Real Neapolitan pizza and amazing quality ingredients. The staff are always really welcoming and the atmosphere is welcoming and warm. Would highly recommend the pesto and burrata as a starter, it’s such a delicious combo. And the proper pepperoni pizza is the best pepperoni I’ve ever tried. Could not recommend this place more.

site_logo

veronicacM6828TT . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We absolutely love this place its our go to for any family night out together . Its pizza's are as good as any you will find anywhere. Proper Neapolitan fired pizzas and the homemade desserts are just fantastic. The staff are always welcoming and attentive. If they have them on, you have to try the Bruschetta with aged balsamic ..and the chocolate mousse.

site_logo

Chris V . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The rustic crust has such delicious food, refreshing drinks, attentive staff and passionate owners that I have had my birthday meal here 3 years in a row. The overall atmosphere in the pizzeria is so inviting and friendly that I get so excited every time we make a booking. This is advisable as they’re often booked up quickly especially if you want to secure a time. The pizza is some of the best I’ve ever eaten. All made fresh to order from the kitchen which you can see from the restaurant, a lovely touch, many topping options for that touch of preference. Starters and specials that are so yummy too. I can turn into a meal of many courses very quickly! Always great to see lots of people visit including families and children and they’re made to feel just as valued and special as the adults. The tiramisu needs its own special part of the review, quite simply I can only describe it as SENSATIONAL! It’s full of flavour and indulgent but remains light and creamy from the first to the last spoonful. See picture :) Can’t wait to go again soon and I hope others will give it a try for the first time or a repeat visitor.

site_logo

slbevan . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

What a find! This Italian is the best place for food and a must if you are visiting in and around Farnsfield. We booked a table with friends on a Sunday lunch. The atmosphere as you walk in is friendly and welcoming. The pizza is to die for and the desserts are not to be missed. I got waaay too excited about the food that I didn’t take any photos apart from the cannoli. staff are super friendly and the food was delivered piping hot and without too much of a wait. I normally always have some constructive criticism when having a meal but I cannot fault this place. I’ll defo be returning with more friends and family to share the love about this place.

site_logo

Joanne C . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I really do enjoy eating here and have been many times. My experience is that the staff are always very helpful and we have been looked after well. The restaurant is very clean, amazing decor and atmosphere. The food is ALWAYS top quality and incredibly tasty. Drinks are just as good with lots of choice for both alcoholic drinks and soft drinks. Lots of very close by parking on side streets, also the restaurant is good for accessibility and on one level.

site_logo

priestland . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I am pleased to have been able to be a pizza stalker since before the restaurant opened. I am glad to see the staff have been very well trained. For those who haven't been before the ambiance is rustic yet cozy, the service is attentive, and the attention to detail in every aspect of the pizza-making process is evident. This pizzeria's commitment to using proper 00 flour truly sets it apart, making it a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast seeking a top-tier culinary experience. Highly recommended!

site_logo

O7894MIdans . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Hands down, the best pizza you’ll ever have. So much so, that whenever you go out for dinner anywhere else, you’ll refuse to have pizza because nowhere else compares to The Rustic Crust. It’s incredibly priced, the drinks are amazing and the desserts are to die for. Make sure you book in advance though as tables book up quickly.

site_logo

petermikeman . 2024-01-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This is one of the best Italian restaurants I have ever been to. The service was one of the nicest in the world and the food didn't take long to come after ordering. Most of all the waitress was very nice and helpful the food was excellent and extremely nice I couldn't have asked for anything else. I loved it.

site_logo

Rachel Eyre . 2024-01-17

MORE AT Google

Xmas meal for work not great but venue ok in itself I didnt pick the place so cant moan too much lol it was ok staff good and polite

site_logo

Steven Mills . 2024-01-07

MORE AT Google

Love the food, atmosphere and the staff are always fantastic

site_logo

patricia smith . 2023-12-30

MORE AT Google

We came in over the Christmas break with our family to pickup a takeaway, whilst we waited we sat and had a cocktail in the courtyard outside as we had our dog with us.. The lady (I believe was Mrs Crust!) was so so accommodating...

site_logo

oh16 . 2023-12-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Enjoyed a lovely early dinner with our friends and children. Really nice atmosphere, food is fantastic. Lovely owner and staff. Place looks amazing.

site_logo

Markopolo . 2023-12-29

MORE AT Google

A true gem! Pizzas are amazing the owners are always so welcoming and service excellent

site_logo

Claire Bailey . 2023-12-24

MORE AT Google

Such a lovely little family business! Always had great food here. Recently had the truck out to our business Christmas party too and was again perfection even from the truck. Restaurant or truck would recommend!

site_logo

Goodgrub99 . 2023-12-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Love this place. 1st time tonight but not the last. Especially loved the coleslaw which is very hit and miss everywhere i go; this place has the best !

site_logo

Natalie Mitchell . 2023-12-21

MORE AT Google

Great pizza and coffee. Tiramisu was slightly on the dry side but had lots of flavour. the cannoli was great and the pistachio gelato was very nice. Not sure where you get your coffee beans from but your barista makes amazing coffee. Please share where your coffee beans are from if you can. They also do a nice small shop at the front selling Italian groceries. Will definitely visit again. Ps please come early as got quite busy on a weekday. We didn’t call to book. Overall excellent place!!!!

site_logo

Tsu Kuan Teoh . 2023-12-04

MORE AT Google

Always happy at the Rustic Crust. Friendly and accommodating service. Pizzas are super. Lovely

site_logo

Robert Limbrey . 2023-11-29

MORE AT Google

Absolutely great service. Impeccable food. Water to die for. Absolutely great value for money. Staff were incredibly friendly and very nice. Incredible staff. It was ridiculously clean and well looked after. Smelled like a new car inside. Vibe was great. Garlic bread was garlicky and...

site_logo

Russell W . 2023-11-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A wonderful meal celebrating a family member's birthday. Delicious food, great service. A relaxing and clean establishment. I'm sure we will be back again.

site_logo

Sarah Lines . 2023-11-19

MORE AT Google

Having just returned from Sorrento and Amalfi Coast, I can honestly say that I enjoyed tonight’s pizza more than any that I ate in Italy!! Delicious!! Thank you! ❤️🍕❤️ Ps my 90 year old dad LOVED the cherry semifredo!!! ❤️🍒❤️

site_logo

Lynn Kawalec . 2023-11-18

MORE AT Google

Amazing as always, food superb just want u want from an authentic pizza place PIZZA!!! Happy with the choices as always l, my 4 year old loves that you do steak on the kids pizza no need for chips or spaghetti, cannot fault the food, the only niggle would be if the waiting staff were a little more attentive when it came to drinks but it wasn’t a problem at all!! Lovely meal as always!!! Great village restaurant!!! Thankyou

site_logo

danika slater . 2023-11-16

MORE AT Google

Lovely place, warm and inviting. Service staff were good, bit too long at the end to bring a bill, but until then they were fab and couldn't fault them. Food was the let down, there are 2 issues. 1) lack of children's options.. we really struggled to find something our 3 year old would eat. He doesn't like pizza. Add a spagbol or at least chips to your menu.. even if its just a kids portion. Paying £50 for a meal out and then having to cook at home is not a good thing. 2) BURNT. The food was patchy burnt, if you got a not burnt bit it was delicious. But the burnt flavour lingers in your mouth. Left with food unfished and still hungry as really off put that lingering flavour. The food was quite clearly burnt in places, this should have been pulled up in the kitchen and by the wait staff. This place has the potential for greatness, but its menu and lack of quality control had left us very dissatisfied. And still hungry. Update. in response to owner; Hi Ross Thanks for replying to me, due to the long winded nature of google reviews this won't be a back and forth but i wanted to clarify a few things based on your comments. 1) Burned is burned... yes Neapolitan style pizzas' should have leopard spots, but this was not that. you can't hide behind "authenticity" when you leave a pizza in the oven too long 2) My child does like pizza, but this was his first time trying "proper" pizza, please add chips to the menu.. i get your point about a spag bol, but some potatoes or chips would ensure even the fussiest of kids can enjoy a meal, comparing your restaurant to plenty of other (ignoring chains at your request, this took over 20 minuet's of searching btw.) you will find almost all of your counterparts offer some sort of kids menu or potatoes based side/starter/meal which would of have been enough. I wont address your personal attacks as that would bad form. however, if you did take the time to check my reviews you will find well balanced reviews where praise or criticism are clearly detailed and i am always happy to elaborate or explain. Yes i generally frequent chain restaurants as i am financially challenged, however you will also see independent restaurants reviewed and most of these get glowing 5* reviews. If you had served chips (even if just to kids) and the pizza wasn't (let's call it well leopard spotted) i am certain we would have had a lovely meal. your restaurant looks fantastic, it was comfortable and your staff were very friendly. Wishing you all the best. Kind regards

site_logo

Joe Everington . 2023-11-15

MORE AT Google

Very chill place, good drinks and beautiful pizzas.

site_logo

Marta I . 2023-11-08

MORE AT Google

Always wanted to visit! I have known Camille & Ross for many years now and have always admired their passion for what they do, although not on the tools on my visit their team were spectacular and the passion shines through the food was delicious so good I didn’t take a photo of my pizza as I had to dig In immediately! Visit its ace Nuff said .

site_logo

Tom Bower . 2023-11-05

MORE AT Google

We visited rustic crust this evening for our dinner, what a wonderful experience!!! Delicious food, relaxed and charming atmosphere, beautiful restaurant with exceptional service! Thank you, We will most definitely return ❤️

site_logo

Craig Sansom . 2023-11-04

MORE AT Google

We sat in the cosy courtyard, with our dogs, under the cover of a wisteria-covered pergola, which sheltered us from the rain very nicely. The pizza was to die for and the staff were lovely - even bringing fresh water and treats for our very...

site_logo

Kat M . 2023-11-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Top notch, always great pizza. Thanks for the basil

site_logo

Ce A . 2023-11-01

MORE AT Google

Amazing pizza, got it on collection due to being ill but we're all better again so we're going there for a second time for a lil date!

site_logo

Fraser Hannah . 2023-10-25

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in East Midlands

restaurant_img
4.5

2906 Opinions

location-iconMain Street
Italian
outdoor_seating_192149takeaway_192149delivery_192149

Absolutely lovely experience. Exceptionally kind and helpful staff, good quality food and plenty of it for what you pay. 100% recommend

restaurant_img
5.0

44 Opinions

location-iconStaythorpe Road Rolleston
Italian
outdoor_seating_332164takeaway_332164delivery_332164

Fabulous array of delicious tapas food. Lovely cosy setting with very friendly and helpful staff. Will definitely be returning soon.

restaurant_img
4.3

250 Opinions

location-icon10 Queen Street
Italian
outdoor_seating_190593takeaway_190593delivery_190593

Lovely cafe with staff to match but the coffee was as weak as you know what which is a shame because the cafe itself is really nice. A new coffee machine required!

restaurant_img
4.0

790 Opinions

location-icon
Italian
outdoor_seating_206983takeaway_206983delivery_206983

Hi she gave me a dip for my pizza you should give her a tip and you should give her 5 stars from rudy and Cruze

restaurant_img
3.9

1795 Opinions

location-icon46 Stodman Street
Italian
outdoor_seating_155579takeaway_155579delivery_155579

An authentic pub with great atmosphere and fantastic upbeat and attentive friendly staff. Great pies. One step up into the premises and one step into the toilet area for those with access issues. Good size and quality meals.