The Old Mill in Mid Sussex - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I enjoyed the prawn curry, very flavoursome. Excellent service by Finlay, who was helpful and positive throughout. I will definitely be returning in the forthcoming future with my children.

This spot is great for casual night out, food was excellent, reasonable prices, very lovely front of house, thank you for making my experience going good.

Excellent ambience and service. Of course the food especially the fish and chips was so good, must try. Seating outside the pub was amazing.

We had family dinner that was delicious all front of house team were friendly service was brilliant thank you everyone we definitely come back again

Excellent lunch! We were a group of 12 walkers. Orders were taken at the table and food arrived promptly. EVERYONE was happy with their meal, without exception. The chicken fajitas were exceptionally good!

Lovely new menu. We tried the new starters, goats cheese creme brulee and beef brisket croquets as reccomended by the staff which were delicious.

Once again The Old Mill has delivered! Having had a few days away thought we’d treat ourselves to a Sunday Roast at the Old Mill. We hadn’t booked so (knowing how popular the Sunday Roasts are) knew we were taking a chance getting a table. Arriving at 5pm we must have missed the rush as we were warmly welcomed by Megan and shown to a table. The service was excellent and the food was outstanding. Two of us had Chicken Roasts which were amazing, and the roast pork was great too. Unfortunately the cauliflower cheese had sold out so we had pork crackling, pigs in blankets and stuffing as extras. We even found room for deserts which were top notch! A top meal delivered by a top team!

We booked this for Valentines lunch as somewhere new to try. The outdoor area with the running water is beautiful and we will definitely would like to come back when it's warmer to sit outside. We had a lovely warm welcome and were very impressed by the way it looked inside. The menu was great. One of the reasons we picked this pub was because my partner is fussy and normally struggles to find something on the menu. This was a typical English pub menu without trying to be fancy. The portion sizes and prices were great. The service was definitely the best we have had anywhere lately. Very attentive. 10% service charge was added to the bill but we decided it was worth more than that so gave more. We were given a Valentines card game to play and entered into a raffle too which was a sweet touch We will be coming back to try their Sunday roast soon 😊

It was my friends birthday and we decided to go to the Old Mill. When we arrived we were surprised to see how empty the place was, the lighting and decor is drab with cheap signage everywhere. The food was extremely underwhelming and probably straight from the freezer. The starters were ok. I had pork belly which was fatty, with cabbage and hard roasted new potatoes, weirdly served on a very small plate. My friend had a chicken burger which she said was dry as were the fries. She also had an ice cream which was fine. The young servers were very pleasant. We wanted to like our experience but we will not be going back. With a few drinks our bill was £100 (they put the service charge on the bill -unusual for a pub)

Our first time for Sunday lunch. There were 9 of us. Could not ask for more. The food was fantastic but the service was beyond. It’s been a long time since we have been so impressed on all fronts. Well done Dunnings, we will definitely be back soon.

I cannot recommend The Old Mill enough. Had a great night at their 'last Tuesday of the month open mic night'. Booked a table which was a great location to watch the acts. The performers were really talented and the staff very attentive (although we only had drinks and a few snacks.) Online booking email worked really well and was quickly responded too. A great night and looking forward to end of February one already.

The food choice is excellent, the portion sizes are better than the norm and the quality of the food was perfect especially the home made onion rings. The prices were below that of other restaurants and pubs in the area. We didn’t book but were made welcome with plenty of space between the tables. A perfect gem and amazingly friendly staff. I could leave it at that but I have to say that after the meal I thought I would read some reviews, there is a very, very small minority who gave two or less stars. This mainly based on the fact that service charge was added. That is disgusting to down score for this, if you don’t like the service then don’t pay but don’t criticise later. I do not work in the industry but I do know how badly the industry has suffered firstly with Covid and more recently the hike in energy costs and inflation. 10% added on to thank the staff for being attentive and being there to serve you is the minimum we should pay. Most people wouldn’t think twice if every item on the menu was £1 more yet that would be more than the 10 % service charge. Service charge is a pittance but means so much to the staff. Don’t knock it, pay it to thank them. Think what your poor score does to these people and the managers. I was disappointed that I could not increase the service charge. Well done to the management and the staff, you made mine and the family’s meal perfect. Happy New Year and see you soon.

This pub is great. We had a lovely festive meal. Plenty of variety on the menu. The sticky toffee pudding was massive. I did have some trouble finishing it, especially after a great starter and even better turkey dinner with all the trimmings. Service was fantastic. Our sever Toulah was very kind and made sure we were well looked after.

We met friend here for a Christmas get together on a recent Sunday lunchtime. The menu choices were excellent, and we all opted for Sunday roast which consisted of two beef and two lamb meals. The food was excellent, with there being plenty of meat on the plate as well as a good variety of vegetables, all of which was very tasty, well presented and served hot. Three of us managed a desert which were also lovely. The staff were also very friendly and attentive. With a few drinks the bill was not excessive and we will certainly return when in the area.

We have just had our company Xmas party at the Old Mill , it looks so festive and pretty in the pub . We were immediately greeted and shown to our table and offered a drink . The Xmas meal was really enjoyable and lovely and hot . We were looked after all evening and had a great time , thank you to Lisa and Katie and all the staff and chefs

What a gem. Been a lucky local here for some time , but I'm leaving this review without any bias. Having worked in Hospitality for years I understand the graft and levels of professionalism it takes to deliver what they do down there. The unsung heros behind the scenes, head chef Ryan, Paul the grafter all the way to the KP. Next time you eat out, and enjoy your experience try and remember to tip the kitchen team. Ask for the chefs name and leave a review. They're awesome from front of house to back. Katie in charge of the team front of house Megan, grace, sophie, the beer whisperer Steve, Lauren and carol. Great family friendly, accommodating, leave with a full belly kinda place.

We cannot thank Katie, Lisa and the team enough. We had our Christmas Lunch for the Crawley and East Grinstead branch of Parkinson's UK today. The food was amazing, the service was superb, the team were so friendly and approachable and sympathetic to our members needs. For some of our members this is the highlight of the year and one of our biggest get togethers with almost 60 people attending. I cannot recommend The Old Dunnings Mill highly enough from the bar staff, to the waiting staff, and the team in the kitchen. Thank you all so much for making our event so special. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you all. See you next year!!

We loved the Christmas Party night on Saturday 2 December. Food was excellent, the pub looked very festive and Lisa, Katie, Megan and Finn did a great job looking after us. Thanks guys for a fantastic evening. 🌲

Fantastic setting , good rustic food , friendly staff & neck oil on tap , two for one steak night Thursday highly recommended

Absolutely fantastic Sunday lunch. The staff here are particularly friendly and accommodating, especially Steve the barman who gave us a warm welcome. As a vegan I really appreciate the range of options that don't feel like menu afterthoughts.

Wow. I had Bangers and Mash for my Dinner. I was really looking forward to this , and I had heard very good things about the Food here. I used to be a regular at the Pub, but hadn't been to Dunnings Mill or "The Old Mill for some time. It was great food, and it was the best Bangers and Mash I'd had in a long time. Staff were just great. I'd happily dine here again

Lovely atmosphere, nice old fashioned look, great place for our family gathering, recommended by my Auntie who lives close by.

Absolutely marvellous family meal, went for dinner with the family, had an excellent chicken kebab, lovely homely pub with good food. Was just what I was expecting, but somehow exceeded expectations, the bar staff- Sophie & Steve, were so welcoming and helpful, accommodating our every need Well done Dunnings!!!

Very friendly welcome especially as we had 2 young children & two dogs with us. Crayons & pictures to colour in, & wooden bricks were provided to keep the little ones entertained!! Excellent food. Thoroughly recommend for a family oriented meal out.

Decided to give this pub a try after reading excellent reviews,was definitely not disappointed! Food was absolutely wonderful,servers very friendly and professional! Bar staff were lovely but would like to mention one in particular Sophie! What an absolute little darling she is,so friendly,happy,a lovely kind genuine young lady ! Can’t wait to visit again

Emailed only two hours before for a booking for my parents, my two children and my two dogs and easily accommodated - food was delicious and served in a timely manner, good drink choice and staff were absolutely fantastic - so friendly and welcoming - couldn’t have asked for more!

Stopped for Sunday lunch after a bike ride. Tasty food & great service to go with it. I went for the pork - especially good with a cauliflower cheese add on. And always nice as well to have a pint of Old in the winter months. A great friendly welcome from new addition to the team Steve, serving at the bar, checking that all was Ok. A great stop.

Always good service and food at Dunnings,Steve the new barman was very welcoming and attentive even though he was very busy with a large wake that was taking place in the restaurant. We look forward to coming back soon.

Went to Standen for a walk, then decided to drop in to dunnings Mill for a drink, but when we saw the Sunday roast’s decided stay and eat. Scrummmmmmmy roast 😋

Nice Harveys beer served up by a very helpful & cheerful bar person (Steve). A good roast pork dinner with excellent vegetables and lovely roast potatoes. Perhaps a little stingy with the meat. And watch out for the automatic 10% service charge. Not undeserved, but be aware!

Stopped off during our bike ride and found the pub to have a real Friday buzz about it. The heated/covered seating area was great for this time of the year. The service we received was superb with Steve behind the bar being particularly helpful and friendly! Will visit again soon.

I came to this pub unplanned. I had an amazing night and the food was great. Highly recommend!! What really made the night for me though was the staff. There was a young called Sophie behind the bar who was welcoming and I have to say is a real asset to the pub. Thank you Sophie for making me welcome. Can’t wait to come back soon!!

Fantastic place! Just been as a family of 4 and my goodness what amazing service and Food. Firstly served by a lady called Sophie at the bar who was very welcoming and very bubbly with such polite conversation !! We walked in and felt totally welcomed !! 5 Stars to Sophie. Will deffo be back!

Popped in Wednesday evening and enjoyed a lovely pint of Harvey's old ale, (one of our favourites at this time of year) in charming surroundings and great, friendly bar service from Steve

Lunch with my family; in three weeks things have changed but not for the better. The menu was new but also the quality of the food was much lower and disappointing as I love bringing my family here.

My husband and I had our joint 30th birthday party at the pub and it was excellent- the service was outstanding and they couldn’t do enough for us on the night, from setting up the room with decorations to ensuring we had everything we needed....

Great pub , with plenty of character. We had a good variety of lunches between six of us . Steak and ale pie , chicken skewers, cajan chicken burger, haloumi burger and a panini. All were plentiful and delicious. Also we had a good variety...

Two glasses of white wine....£16??? Might as well have written "p*** off" on the glasses! What a shame. I won't buy any more alcohol in this pub.

Terrific food and terrific service! It won't disappoint. We had the Sunday lunch and a burger. All cooked to perfection. Will definitely visit again

Good beer and average pub grub. They automatically add 10% service charge to the bill (just two people). I consider this to be bad practice in the UK.

Thank you, to the lovely young lady who offered us coffee while we were on standby in our ambulance outside the pub carpark. Very much appreciated, and with that sort of hospitality, we will be definitely making a trip back for a meal in the...

Huge thank you to Lisa and her team for a truly splendid Birthday Tea Party on Friday. Nothing was too much trouble, sandwiches, scones and cakes were delicious, service from the team was on hand all the time without being intrusive in any way. Can't...

We organised a very successful birthday afternoon tea party for 15 guests. The staff at the Old Mill were so helpful and very friendly and contributed to a very enjoyable time. The sandwiches, cakes and proccesso were also delicious. Thank you so much.

Great venue for lunch with an extensive and exciting menu. Fish and Chips is a must but my family had a rump steak (quite good) as well as the fish finger sandwich. Great food, nice dining room. Even though it was busy, service was great....

Met my friends for a few drinks. We sat outside on the decking area and you can hear the water flowing lovely ambience. There’s a self-serve water barrel for dogs. The staff were very friendly.

Last minute decision to go to go out for dinner so we hadn't booked. The staff were very friendly, especially Megan. Even though it was busy the food arrived in a short time & it was very tasty. A good evening out.

Very good food. Service was also on point. Staff were friendly and attentive really could y fault it will definitely be returning.

Haven't been here in a while and I must say it is better then ever. I was passing by so stop off to make use of there friday fish and chip offer to takeaway. Wow the food was amazing, the size of the portions was...

Love this pub / restaurant. Wonderful food and great service. We went here for our anniversary and the meal was so good. For good pub food, it does not get better than this . We will be back.. Thank you

This pub is an absolutely fantastic place to eat,drink. The staff are amazing. Food excellent. The land lady Lisa is such a diomand. She ensures punters,staff are happy. We enjoyed the inside and the outside areas with photo opportunities with the mill. Thank you Lisa...

You’d do better to get rid of whatever that thing you’re calling a manager attempting to run your pub… The food was downright disgusting, chips undercooked, steak so grisley I couldn’t even put a fork into it all whilst charging extortionate amounts, naturally sent it...

Ben the legend is a legend, great atmosphere in pub, good vibes all round and great chats! Nice to get old mout, not everywhere has it so thanks for this!

Me and my partner visit here quite frequently on Sunday’s as the roasts are the best in the area. Unfortunately on our visit last Sunday the staff were not as attentive as they usually are, often having to ask for more drinks, sauces etc.. This...

We enjoyed a late Sunday lunch at The Old Mill. The food was fantastic and the service from Katie and the team faultless. Best Sunday lunch in East Grinstead. Well done!

We visited on Sunday for lunch 10 family members . Most had Sunday lunch. We have visited before for Sunday lunch and have been very happy on this occasion I think the Sunday lunch was missing vegetables. When we came to pay the bill we...

Mother's Day Meal We had a fantastic meal, served by wonderful staff who were run off of their feet as it was very busy, but nothing was too much trouble for them. There were people of all ages there as it was Mother's Day from...

I organised a table for 22 persons for a mixed group after a local 2 hour walk and I wasn't disappointed. From the welcome to the table service, the staff were spot on. The food was very good and good sized portions too. Definitely visiting...

This year it was my job to organise Christmas lunch for the Crawley and East Grinstead branch of Parkinson's UK. Many are of our members are living with Parkinson's and were accompanied by their family, friends and carers. It's always a tricky job to arrange...

Sunday lunch for a group of 12 friends. Great service started with Katie who dealt with the booking and pre-order before the day. Lovely cosy atmosphere, plentiful good food, friendly service from Lisa and her team. We will be back!

Visited as a family of 6. Not very impressive as we parked, as pub is covered in scaffolding so couldn’t see any outdoor features in the dark and it was raining. Not their fault I hasten to add. Also an extremely large marquee just outside...

Everything was just perfect - food, service, atmosphere, value for money, helpfulness. I arranged a family Sunday lunch for 21 people from all over the place and had struggled to find somewhere to accommodate us, but Dunnings were so helpful with the booking, emailing prior...

We were house sitting in East Grinstead and decided to try the old dunning meal as they had the novelty of a dog menu 🥰 Stanley our 9 year old chocolate lab had the chicken soup, followed by the fish cakes and topped off with...

My Dad and I went for lunch here and we were very impressed with the food and the service. We had a very warm welcome form the staff. I had the starter of crab, avocado and smoked salmon (photo shown) and it was lovely. My...

Really good food, small but definitely enough and very good value for money. Fish was very light and beautiful. Cheeseburger really tasty, sausage and mash really hot and full of flavour. Chocolate fudge cake a little dry but still very nice.

Last week my wife & I went on Sunday for our dinner, my wife had roast beef & I had fish & chips. Both meals were piping hot and large servings of delicious food. We went again on Thursday for the 2 steak meals offer...

We went to Old Dunnings Mill for our anniversary meal and thought it was amazing. The food was superb and the staff friendly and attentive. We had the nacho platter to start and I have the burger with cheese, bacon and jalepenos for toppings, my...

My wife and i had dinner here last Sunday and the atmosphere here is just so relaxing. The food was really delicious and the food portions are generous. I had prawn cocktail to start and for the main course Lamb Shank with meat cooked so...

Lunch today with husband and sister, amazing lunch, freshly cooked food. Friendly staff, and smiling faces. Lovely experience.good price.

The food is delicious, varied and reasonably priced, the staff are friendly and polite one of the better places to eat locally.

My wife, daughter and I went for lunch for my wife’s birthday. The staff were efficient and friendly. The food was delicious, plentiful and reasonably priced. We will definitely return in the near future as it was such a good experience.

I had been meaning to come here for a while but never got round to booking it. I was very impressed overall with how lovely this pub is. The very fact they have a menu for dogs along with dog g&t really made it for...

This is the second time I've eaten here as a big group with family. The first time was excellent and I did not write a review, so this time with the visit be as good as the first I will take this opportunity to say...

Where do I start. Without waffling on the singles night event hosted here is a revelation. They hosted the first one a couple of months ago and it was amazing. Clearly I'm not the only one in my 20s that's been crying out for somewhere...

This is the 2nd over 25's singles night held at Dunnings Mill and was great fun. There is nothing else of this kind in East Grinstead and is much needed! I went with a couple of friends and it was really busy with a fab...

We had a really pleasant visit today. We were made very welcome by arriving just before mid day by a lady. We were then served by a very young lassie and a lovely chap from Scotland. Great service, good food and good value.

Superb pint pf Harvey's . Good food and excellent table service from Becky. Perfect Monday evening and we were not forgotten even though the quiz was on

My Husband, Son and Daughter arranged a birthday party for me at The Old Dunnings Mill. We had the outdoor terrace as it was a nice day and opted for an afternoon tea buffet with Prosecco and Beer. The service was excellent and the decking...

I start by saying 3 our of our 4 meals were very nice. However, it was a hot day and all I was looking forward to was a salad, asking at the till if that was possible I was told only side salads were available!...

We visited for the first time last night and the food was amazing and the staff were super friendly! 2 of us had the steak which was cooked perfectly (I always have mine blue and half the times restaurants over cook it) and the fish...

This review is a bit late but better late than never, back in March we arranged a Sunday lunch for a special birthday for my mother in law and the restaurant could have not been more accommodating, from arranging the ordering of the food in...

We were a party of around 20 who booked for Sunday lunch and requested the outside covered area...which was ideal. Prior to the event we had liaised with Katie who was extremely helpful and communicated well, especially as our numbers kept changing. She advised us...

Lovely meal today at our favourite pub to take my father to. He loves the Harvey’s beer and the pie that is on the menu. He’s chooses that every time. I had the fish and chips which was freshly cooked and delicious. Served by the...

I visited the Old Dunnings Mill on 1st May at 1215. I called to make a reservation on the previous evening which was handled politely and efficiently by a young-sounding chap. I asked for a quiet table, and when I arrived with my elderly Mother...

Came here with my friend had a lovely meal and Sophia was our waitress and what a lovely accommodating girl! Very polite and helpful! Definitely will be coming back 😊

Before I went on this trip I checked out this resturant via trip advisor and I felt because I have many food allergies, that this place would be one of the best to eat and I was not wrong. Upon arriving and asking what was...

Had a great evening at dunnings mill, the food presentation and portion sizes we very good which echoed onto the service aswell, nothing was too much! Thank you Paul,Katie and Grace for a wonderful evening!

A perfect evening with friends, delicious food and great service from Carol - an asset to the venue!

What a splendid evening we have had for our friends Birthday, many thanks to Carole who looked after us! We will certainly come back very soon!

We enjoyed another fabulous meal yesterday. Warm friendly staff and surroundings. Lovely piping hot food with minimal waiting time. We'll be back soon.

Came here for a late lunch with my girlfriend, we sat outside in the sunshine which was lovely. I had sausage and mash and omg it was so good! I got 3 sausages which usually I think you only get 2 anywhere else? They were...

Excellent pub with a atmospheric interior and lovely garden. We enjoyed a wonderful lunch, all five of us having different mains and being really impressed with the quality of the food. First class attentive service too! Would highly e recommend.

Had a brilliant time with friends. Such a lovely pub, very friendly, especially Joan. Will definitely be back.

Met some friends for lunch today, food was great and the service was attentive and friendly, thank you Joan.

Amazing food and Joan the waitress was so friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend this lovely venue. I had the fish and chips and it was delicious!

As always, warm welcome, excellent food and service. Good atmosphere, and service with a smile. Will return soon.

Absolutely delicious Sunday roasts (lamb and pork) with all the trimmings. Generous portions, very attentive and charming waitress(Skye) . We ate the lot without hesitation. Compliments to the chef. We'll be back!!

Just had the best Lamb steak ever on the specials deal. Cooked to perfection by Tom and the service and bar staff are all very attentive. Great place to relax and enjoy good food and real ale

Excellent food and staff x quiz and poker night x lovely atmosphere x Dogs are welcome x and a warm fire to sit by x outside heating x beautiful settings x

We arrived at the Old Dunnings Mill having not booked a table on a Sunday lunch time but they had a table for us near the bar. The service was fabulous - thank you to the Scottish man who was amazingly able to tell when...

A great pub with excellent service, a wide choice of drinks and superb food. Highly recommended and I will be returning soon