The Nottingham House in Sheffield

I've visited the Notty House over the last few years and I've always enjoyed a pie from here.

The pub has had a refurbishment recently and it's great! Very much a British pub at its best. Fantastic choice of beers and lagers and the pie and chips is excellent. Staff are really attentive and friendly. A great night out.

Only been in the car park but it's good vibes

The pub was very busy and bustling and really cold in there, especially in the ladies toilets. The staff were really lovely and friendly. The food wasn’t so great, it was served on chipped plates and barely warm. There was some kind of white ceramic in my pie which put me off. The wild mushroom, chestnut and ale pie was ok, would’ve probably been better if it was hot. The portion sizes were generous. I probably won’t go there again

Giving 3 stars for food because, while i was unhappy, my family was liking it. My vegan pie was not the best and it looked not as well baked as the others, which upset me. We waited an hour for our order and the lady serving us was quite rude to me two times, even though I just asked about the wait time. We didn't complain in person as it was a busy day, so instead I'm sharing here.

Top quality pies with so much choice. So much gravy and big portions. Veggie options are good too (I.e., without just bulking them out with potatoes). If you don't like pies this isn't the place for you.

Great warm welcoming atmosphere delicious food and all round great vibes

Great pub, delicious pies and really lovely staff

Very spacious covered area outside. Only had one beer here.Very dark inside.Really good pies and chips.Very filling. The tables outside need wiping down after it rains People still want to sit outside even when it's a little cold.

Awesome pub. I played a gig there and absolutely loved it. They make their own home made pies and I can safely say that they are the best pies I have had in Sheffield. the landlord is an amazing guy as well, always happy to help and ensure you have a great time. I highly recommend visiting this pub.

Was OK, pies were nice but not the best, not even the best in sheffield. Staff were brilliant!! The place was freezing!! So were the Mushy peas. Probably won't go back.

Cozy pub, nice atmosphere, generous portions with plenty of gravy and chips on the side. enjoyed the pies with a pint and had a great time.

I heard a lot about the pies and it did not disappoint one of the best pies I've ever had.

Quite simply the best pie in the world! I lived up the road from this place during uni and now always make it stop #1 whenever I’m in the area. I have tried most of the pie menu and not once been disappointed!

Really tasty food! Only downside is that pies are now 13.95 which seems a bit steep. Totally understand about inflation/rising costs etc - a pie was £7.95 back when I was at uni - but I feel portions have also got smaller. Great place though, a Sheffield classic.

Great pies, a lot of fillings to choose from. The chips were a little bit too crispy but overall a really tasty, filling meal.

Good food and ale, slightly scruffy pub and toilets, however 4 men leaning on bar never stopped swearing, the staff never even stopped them, it spoiled it for me and my family. Not going back it’s a shame because them pies a very good

Twice been in and missed my mate Crax Twice

Good pies, nice beer - would recommend!

Limited menu, but large selection of pies! Totally delicious and generous portions. Good ambience and super friendly staff. Great range of drinks, including several nonalcoholic options. Parking in a very small carpark nearby or on the road.

I've been to Notty House many many times during my PhD, and I was really looking forward to bring my family after graduation. Unfortunately, it was not the nicest experience. The food (4 pies with chips) took an hour to be served and when it arrived, one of the pies was ice cold, like it wasn't heated at all. Unfortunately the cold pie was given to my mom, who didn't say anything until much later so she wouldn't bother me. The staff was a bit rude and although I would understand it if the place was super crowded, that wasn't the case, there were several empty tables. I'm sorry it was like this and that my family didn't enjoy the amazing experience I've had here before.

Not enough non alcohol beer selection.

Fantastic pies and ales combined with a great service! A must visit!

Waited 50 minutes for food, went and asked about it to be told they “must have lost the ticket, but can stick it in now”- they could see the table markers they give you from the bar, I can’t understand how at 4pm on a Thursday a ticket was lost and I had to ask for a refund instead of being offered it. The wait here for food is usually quite long but to not even get food after it is disappointing.

Best pie in Sheffield. Great vibe

The best food possible,, absolutely loved it 10/10

Amazing food, great choice of pie fillings, generous portion sizes. Would have been nice to have some more non-alcoholic beer/cider options for the designated drivers.

Best pies 🥧 we have had in many years. Proper pies with actual meat inside!!!

Lovely meal and welcoming of our dog. Good atmosphere with a nice mix of clientele.

Great food, good value pies, worth the wait, but it was a long wait, and we weren't warned!

Fabulous pies Gorgeous flavour combinations

Can't go wrong with a notty pie. Used to come here quite a bit, frequented by locals/ students and all. Very chill place, that sells great food. The flavours change every so often, so we loved trying the different ones. Very generous with the filling and also sides.

Visited on a Monday lunchtime so I couldn't comment on atmosphere. But the pies, chips and mushy peas were excellent. The staff were spot on, excellent service. Only four stars? A little pricey for pub grub in my old tight opinion

Nice pub, only called in for a few minutes.

Proper homemade pie with different varieties.

Best pie & chips in all the land.

Great pies and a good range of options

My friend lives in Sheffield suggest me this pub. Their pie are amazing, definitely better than chained pie restaurant I tried before. Their chips are surprisingly good even they are sides only, mushed peas and mashed potato are very nice too. Pie with sides ~£12.5 Pints ~£6

What a comprehensive menu of pies either with Mash/chips and mushy peas. The food is second to none, there pies are outstanding. Good choice of beers , will be returning .

Pleasant surroundings in a nice area of city.

A Sheffield must. Never disappointed by a Notty House pie: range of pies including some seasonal and veggie/vegan ones, crispy chips, great portion size and perfect with Hendo’s and a drink. My failsafe favourite is the (vegan) veggie mince and onion.

Absolutely Fantastic, best Pies in Sheffield!

Amazing food and generous portions. Waiter was really friendly despite the many customers. Will definitely be back!

Great selection of pies. Usually busy and you can't reserve a table unless you have a group of ten people.

Lovely pie and chips. We dined early on a Friday night and were served early. The music could have come from my Spotify account (I'm 63 years old). Staff friendly and efficient. I'll visit again

A proper pub. No airs or graces. Just great food, excellent drinks selection and traditional pub atmosphere.

In Ireland, going to the pub for a pie isn't a thing so we wanted to find the best pub in Sheffield for a pub and a pint, and I think we found it. The pies were very tasty and the service very fast. We come to Sheffield once a year for a football match and I think we'll be returning here.

What a great idea, specialise on one type of food and do it well. The Nottingham House have a good range of pies to cover all tastes including vegetarian and vegan (not sure about gluten free). The pies we had (3 different types) were all very tasty, with the mash and chips being good too. My only criticism is that one of the pies could have been hotter and the plates were very cold, so the food cooled down quickly. Overall, a good meal and excellent beer as well!

Really tasty pies with chips or mash, mushy peas & gravy.....!

Great pub, amazing pies! Popped in here on Friday night and it’s karaoke night - really fun crowd belting out bangers!

Amazing pies, really good drinks priced brilliantly. Wish they had put ten bob in the lekky meter though... it was freezing in there...

We had the beef and ale and beef and Guinness pies, we all said they were the best pies we ever tasted. Generous portions too. The chips were very tasty, not sure how they were cooked or what they were cooked in but again very good. The barman was also very friendly and helpful. I will definitely make another visit even though I will be driving a very long distance. I highly recommend you visit you won’t be disappointed by the pies. Only suggestion would be the pup could do with a little spruce up, not fancy but a little upkeep. P.s. our intentions were to take pics. to show family back home but we were too eager to eat😂

Food is amazing, I don't like pie. But I do like Nottingham house pie. Staff are always great.

Best pies we’ve ever had!!! Ever!!!

Was told on ordering it would be 45 minutes for a pie, bit long but not ridiculous. Chased it up after an hour and was told it was "about to come out" and it still ended up taking 1 hour and 20 minutes from ordering. Would expect at that stage some sort of partial refund at the least, but nothing was really offered and the apology was halfhearted. Not the first time the wait has been excruciating (you're lucky if it comes out in less than 40 minutes), and the pies, whilst good, aren't good enough to justify waiting that long every time you go. Try The York up the road or the Punch Bowl in Crookes, service is infinitely quicker, tables less grimey and the pies are just as good!

Amazingly simple menu of pies with chips or mash. Pastry is to die for. Chips were like best ever chip shops chips. All utterly delicious. Vegan mushroom and chestnut pie best pie partner had ever had, included vegan gravy. Atmosphere and service great.

Chill pub, good food , big portions , and vegan and vegetarian options available. Great for a gang of friends

Great food, Nice ambiance & Staff were friendly. Just be mindful it can get very busy, you have to wait to get some seats and food was very late. But the food was delish so its Ok.

Four of us visited, for a meal and drinks. A massive thumbs up for the pies! Woukd highly recommend 👍

What’s not to love Best pie or should I say pies in Sheffield! Worth a trip out to Broomhill. Cracking pub love this place

Great little pub, and the pies are the best I’ve ever had

Best pies anywhere homemade chips and mush peas. Can't go wrong !

First time we've ever been in here ,,, absolutely loved it ...friendly festive and cosy ....grand pies, chips and mushy peas too .😋👊...definitely will come back !

Went with friends tonight, excellent lively pub and great food, efficient and nice staff would definitely recommend the only glitch is getting a table, hey ho

Great pies, lovely staff, honest local with decent prices.

The pie is to die for !!!! Tried the Steak and red wine one ❤️❤️

Great food, long wait on Sunday but food is worth it. Only walk ins available on Sundays but was worth it. Great food.

Great pies Poor selection of beers

Tout est excellent : cuisine, ambiance et cadre

Four of us went here.All had a different pie and they were all delicious. Chips were really good and big portions. Would go again.

Decent pies in a cosy pub atmosphere for good prices.

Been to this place for food for more than 8 years. No concerns about food but had a bad experience with one of the staff today. Ordered for two takeaway pies today and was informed that it would take 5 minutes. Waited for about 15-20minutes and was trying to ask one of the staff for update. The lady who originally served us was nice and helpful, but when I tried to ask another female staff for help, she was rude and said "I cannot help you", I have explained I was promised for the 5 min wait and now it has been 15-20 mins, she said it was not her problem. She did not even offer to check with the kitchen - so I would rate 1 star for the services and think this lady who was standing at the till at 14.25-14.40 would need some serious re-training for her customer service skills. She was wearing a grey T shirt. The lady with curly long hair was lovely and was the person who served us in the beginning. Food wise, no issues. It is all because of one bad staff and hence this review. Photos submitted for evidence that we have actually been to this place.

Disappointing , mash was very lumpy ,peas luke warm ,pie was not very warm. took 50 mins to come and was starving at this stage, so decided to eat it !

Lovely cosy pub with the best pies I’ve ever had, no exaggeration. Nice and flaky pastry, delicious fillings and a choice of mash or chips. The mushy peas are excellent as well! There are also several vegetarian/vegan pie options (if they don’t run out - try to go early if you want choice). Would highly recommend!

There's usually a wait but the pies are good and the mash is palatable.

My son told me about this place he had mentioned the quality pies so we all went to try and give them a try and boy we weren’t disappointed they were excellent. The four of us all had different pies you could have chips or mash with peas and a gravy boat I chose steak and ale and it was delicious.

Very pleasantly surprised. Went for a meal with our son as it was close to where he lives. Only pies, but an excellent range including a vegetarian option. Service was friendly and efficient. The pies themselves were delicious. My only possible complaint would be that the serving of mushy peas could have been larger but it was nice to have proper mushy peas instead of what you get elsewhere. I would highly recommend Nottingham House.

Got to Notty House early. Long queue for food but was able to place order promptly. Solo bar staff member but was efficient and friendly. Recommended Moonshine to go with Steak & Ale pie. Good combo. Pie was hot and went great with crisp chips. Plenty of gravy. All nicely seasoned and very tasty. PS The steak pie was very well filled with tender steak. Fattest pie I’ve had yet!

Great choice pies with great fillings. Good portions. Had to wait an hour for food and no apology. Our order was taken and the 20mins later told our pie was unavailable so had to make a second choice. I was ignored at the bar. Good job the food was great

Friday 3pm couples tea.. Ordered food then after 30mins was told our pies were not available. Went to bar and was left waiting while staff walked about carrying on other duties, eventually served when a member of staff was shocked i was still waiting. Our alternative pies came to our table 1hour after we arrived and we were starving. Great food, fabulous selection of pies. Absolute rubbish service. No organisation, no apology. Will return only because of the great pies.

The day we went the selection of pies was scarce but it just shows how popular the place is. Great crispy pie casing and the pies are always full! The chips are also nice, not greasy. The only thing was that this place was busy and staff didn’t seem quick to clear tables but this is a great spot to visit otherwise. Another downside is no gluten free option, I would lobe to bring my family / friends but unable due to allergies.

ordered the halloumi and vegetable pie and got food poisoning :( the person who ordered the same pie as me felt very unwell the next day too, but my friends who got other pies were fine. such a shame as it was tasty and had been looking forward to going for a while

Fantastic pub, good layout with great atmosphere, kind of student style clientèle but still a great pub abd the pies are to die for! Can't fault them!

I love this place a great pub with loads of atmosphere great staff and the food is top class. You have to get there early or you may not get the pie you want.

Good food good service just to much noise for a ADD person like me

Brilliant pies !! Highly recommended

Not the most appealing from the outside or inside, but the atmosphere is great and, obviously appreciated by the, mostly, student clientele. The staff are really kind and caring, but the best part is the variety of pies that they provide, with chips or mash and peas. Hendersons always available. 😋

Well this was a great experience if you fancy a pie , staff friendly food great I would come again definitely 👍 £12:50 and a hearty portion plenty to choose from on the menu as long as it’s pie with mash or chips and peas .

Great pies. A very enjoyable midweek lunch.

Están preparados para servirte PIEs acompañado de patatas y guisantes. El servicio es rápido y es económico.

Steak red wine and bacon pie was unreal, gravy could've been a bit thicker but still good

Had lovely time very friendly atmosphere.

Nice pub, great food, friendly staff,nice atmosphere

Genuine Home made pies to order. A great variety including vegetarian Lots of chat and no TV. Beer average.

Really appreciate the beef pie, a true pub where spend time with you affects, there's billiard table and darts to play with

Quality pies will be back again

Pie, chips, peas and beer all excellent

Affordable, approachable staff, possibly the best pies in Sheffield. Had chicken and chorizo and it was fab. Gravy could’ve been a tad thicker but still tasted great

Came to Notty house with my housemates for pies, their pies looked amazing! Being gluten free I could only eat chips which were nice. Its only chips that get fried so they're gluten safe. It would be amazing to see some gluten free meat and vegetarian/vegan pies to be on offer, even if they're handmade and frozen, also gluten free gravy? I'd love to eat a pie !! 🥧

Should change is name to nottingem pie house