The Newmachar Hotel in Aberdeenshire

Came for a spot of dinner, food was good and staff were very nice and helpful, i would definitely come back here if in town again

Amazing food, we had some of the fine dining when out for a family meal. Service was one of the best will definitely be back

Not good at all. Cullen Skink was a piece of leek and tiny piece of fish with a horrible bland sauce poured over the fish from a separate container....not Cullen skink...awful. Tasteless. Wouldnt go back. Very poor...it was empty ...on a Saturday...this tells you something.

Had a very enjoyable lunch here after friend's recommendation. Good, friendly service and great food at a reasonable price. Definitely come back again. Dogs allowed in too.

Very overpriced for average and best food. Would not recommend to any friends or family to dine here and would not be back.

Had a fantastic lunch here the other day and was very impressed. The food was delicious, good portion size, and at a good price. Plenty of choice and very friendly staff in a pleasant setting - highly recommend.

We had a lovely Sunday carvery lunch, great selection of quality accompaniments to the meat. The xmas menu looked very good also & some ice cream sundaes passed our table during lunch - they looked amazing.

Very friendly and attentive staff. Excellent food (especially the chips). We came here as it was dog friendly. Very nice atmosphere. Would highly recommend.

I came up to Newmachar from Perth to visit a friend and the Newmachar Hotel was a recommendation from her, being that I’d never been it had to be done! Upon arrival I was warmly greeted by a man called Mark and a young woman called Sophie - both of them were top class and knew exactly what they were doing. Being a newbie in the hotel bar I was made to feel very welcome, a great range of draught beers, spirits, the lot! I can’t fault this place and its staff at all, everyone was kind and friendly! If you’re looking for a grade A place for accommodation, food or just a drink (same here!) this is the gaff for you!! If I’m back up north I’ll be sure to pop in again, and I will be giving a high recommendation to my family and friends should they pass that way or fancy a little trip out of Aberdeen. Thank you my guys x

I was here for two nights. The rooms were spotlessly clean and very nice.. The service was very good. Me and my colleague had dinner which was very nice great service happy days would highly recommend absolutely faultless.I actually only had a burger but it was probably the best burger I have had and I’ve just returned from North America 👌👌

The Hotel has been refurbished; the rooms and lounge area are lovely. However, our rooms had not been cleaned at all well; crumbs all over the floor, cobwebs in the bedroom and our bathroom floor hadn’t been cleaned. Also only one towel in the room. The complimentary coffee ea tray wasn’t clean. That said the Hotel is smart and the two members of staff we met were very pleasant. I think the room cleaner must have been in a rush the day we arrived!

Excellent food and the service is good, nice restaurant and well set out . Plenty of Parking ………..

First of all, the hotel is way overpriced for what you actually get. The complimentary breakfast that’s promised and included in the price, wasn’t there. The room itself is nice however quite small, but the shower was covered in mould and the water was spitting out in all different directions due to the holes being covered in filth. The extractor fan was very dusty and gross. Overall it’s just too much to pay when realistically all you’re getting is a bed, could’ve stayed somewhere else for cheaper that offered more. Very disappointed as this was for my partners birthday and it wasn’t how i expected at all. We will not be returning.

Outstanding Sunday Carvery! Roast Beef was melt on the mouth and all vegetables were so tasty too. First time here and we will be back again soon. Great service from a lovely waitress. Well done everyone x

I went here for a family members birthday in august - the food was average at best and expensive for the portion sizes, the macaroni portion was tiny and tasted like the sauce came from a box. Went here a second time in September and had the ‘roast’. I can only describe the way it was served as a big pile of mess with cauliflower cheese sauce/ gravy everywhere. It tasted okay but all the flavours just became one. The staffing is also sparse, it takes a while to get served drinks. It’s a shame as it used to be really good - but will now pick a different option.

What a lovely meal we had this past weekend. Tasty food. Great service and a very welcoming host. Its been a long time since we were here but definitely won't leave it so long again!

We’ve been there a few times in the last 18months and it was great. However the last visit in May was terrible. Staff were not attentive at all, and disappeared for ages. No one asked us how the food was. Some of the food he...

Arrival We received a warm welcome on arrival .Our room was spotless, neutral colours and clearly had been thought about. We were shown the breakfast area which in the late afternoon had breakfast set for the following day! Oh!oh! Dinner We chose to eat here...

Unfortunately 2 days before our friends surprise party a separate venue let us down - Even though Linda and her team were unable to accommodate - Linda contacted several alternatives within the industry and offered various options to assist us - I will definitely be...

the current menu is inventive and lovely choices. I had the monkfish curry, it was so good hence this review. my brother had the turkey rolled over haggis, with a superb shiny gravy. the venue is clean well spaced out and the staff seem to...

Awesome food and great service. Fully wheelchair accessible and play areas for the kids. Well worth the trip from the city. Chicken burger and fish/chips worth a mention.

Another lovely visit. Attentive staff and tasty food. My husband and I both had the carvery which unlike our last visit was served to us which was better in my opinion as it was better presented and stops you from piling your plate! Will return...

Had lunch here.first visit for us. Food and service were excellent. Will return again very soon. Highly recommend the place .

Stopped off for a roast dinner after a long walk. Great service with drinks within minutes and the waitress returning to order food quickly. We both had a roast dinner which came with mixed vegetables, cauliflower cheese, chipolata and Yorkshire pudding. The meat was nice...

Absolutely delicious meal and perfect service from the team on duty. Thoroughly delighted with our visit and will most definitely be back soon! Thank you Team Newmachar Hotel...you are doing a fantastic job!

Very disappointed with food. Very average in spite of reading good reviews, so decided to give it a try. Wouldn’t eat there again.

Over priced for kids £9 for a main and dessert. Felt roast dinner wasn’t anything outstanding and veg wasn’t great. Service quite slow

Absolutely fantastic meal. Ordered from the special menu and was not disappointed. Scallops were cooked perfectly and went amazing with the rest. Roast beef was so tender and the trimmings were all so so tasty. The staff were all so friendly and attentive. 100% will...

Very impressed phoned at 4 30 on a Saturday night on our way north and managed to get a table arrived early and were made very welcome haven't been here for a long time and were very impressed with new dining room and menu .staff...

First visit to this restaurant. Very impressed with the modern decor in the lounge, plenty of outdoor and covered outdoor areas. Staff were freindly and helpful. Menu was varied with plenty of choices. They also have an ice cream section. Small playpark in the grounds...

Visited as a table of 3 for fathers day. The restaurant has been refurbished since our last visit and has made a huge difference. The service and food could not be faulted. We had chicken satay and haggis bon bons to start followed by a...

Went here last Sunday for a roast. I thought the food was average and the wait time was too long so I posted it on my Instagram (@phatscrans - if you want to see it) and tagged them. The chef has been sending his friends...

Fantastic food - highly recommend! Went out for lunch yesterday with my friends and we all really enjoyed the food. This is one of our locals and first time we had been back since latest lockdown. Covid control was great, everywhere really nice and clean,...

two seems a harsh score, they service was great and the people were really nice but the menu was just not for me. I ordered the braised chicken, ham and leek pie... first off..what appeared was not a pie... putting a piece of obviously bought...

I have an intolerance of chillies, saw the teriyaki duck over fries and decided to share as a starter. This was a very large portion, easily enough for two sharing. Apparently the Bang Bang bit means heaped high with chillies. I put these to the...

A bit disappointed after my most recent visit as my last visit was so good. It was a bit like a tale of two halves. The good points were - newly refurbished dining area which is well designed and modern far nicer than the previous....

I’ve lived near by for so long and never gone, heard amazing things but it really wasn’t much of anything. Service was horrible, the staff didn’t seem like they actually cared at all. Food was so average and not worth the money at all. Drinks...

I ate here last night with family around 18:30 and we all agreed it was the best meal out we have had for a long, long time. 1. The food - It is difficult to put into words just how good our meals were. I...

Was so disappointed when we heard that The Hotel was following Aberdeen lockdown rules and closing temporarily (but we think you’ve done the right thing) - we ordered takeout tonight for 4 of us and we were blown away!! The burgers were amazing, and the...

Our first venture out after lock down. Grant and the team have done a fantastic job creating a safe and very bonny outside eating space. Food great, service spot on and a very civilised environment to boot. Well done all at NH. #supportlocal

Went for lunch today. Food absolutely delicious. Best risotto I’ve ever tasted. Excellent service. Well worth a visit

Visited the hotel for food last night - they have had a refit which is lovely. Shame they have got rid of the fire and couple of comfy seats as you go in the door. Menu is now very limited and obviously relying on people...

Service was excellent, attentive and professional. There was a really good choice on the menu. The chef coped brilliantly with allergies. The food was delicious and looked so good on the plates. Every scrap was eaten and appreciated. This was a great experience from start...

Booked this hotel on Booking.com as needed a hotel on the north side of Aberdeen as heading further north the next morning. On arrival I was firstly taken a back, as I thought the hotel was shut - turns out the main bar/restaurant was being...

Great service, and delicious food. Went with another couple for the steak & grill supper on a Friday night. 2 had mixed grill, 1 butterfly chicken, 1 gammon steak. Everybody happy. Not long to wait for service etc. In the garden room as it was...

Went for lunch - myself, partner and 2 children. Ordered “ butterfly chicken x 2 - myself and partner, was rather disappointed, chicken was dry and very under seasoned, chunky chips took up 3/4 of plate along with a mushroom & tomato’. For £17 per...

Booked for supper but should have stayed at home.We were shown to a table for 2 next to a planter with high plants so we could not see the whole room. I had a view of an ice cream counter and fire exit, my wife a view of a door to the kitchen...We both ordered fish and chips... a safe bet you would think.Food arrived quickly which is not always a good sign.Battered fish was greasy and wet. The fish seemed to disintegrate rather than flake.Chips were not homemade but of the freezer variety.Just after saying we would never return my wife spotted the waiter scooping ice into a glass with his fingers......That just topped off the visit.

Great service & great food! The Sunday Roast was delicious, meat was tender and the portion size was great. Can’t fault it. Will definitely visit again. Much better Sunday lunch than most other places I’ve tried in Aberdeen.

Fab shared platter carvery. Three lovely meats... beef was melt in the mouth. Roasties, veg and a wonderful gravy. Just shared amazing home made onion rings to start. Think it has been recently refurbished looked great good atmosphere and great service.

Went out with my partner who’s vegan and stopped in past here.After seeing the menu, which only had 4 main course choices on it, beef, salmon etc, asked the staff member if there were any vegetarian or vegan options.Um, soup maybe?Needless to say we left. I’m no vegan but it’s 2019 and surely everywhere caters for this nowadays?Custom lost, wont be back.

Visited for lunch for the first time and will not be back. The woman serving was so rude to the point that we felt really unwelcome. Only one table taken in the whole place and when asked if we could have lunch she looked at us blankly and said yes but I’m busy ! Food was so mediocre. Awful chips. Haddock was so tiny it should have been a child’s portion. This place really needs to up its game. Looking at previous reviews we were served by the same older woman. No wonder place was empty

Staff reasonably helpful, breakfast ordered night before, following morning - no cornflakes, Oates or portage, breakfast arrived plates up on a cold plate, my scrambled eggs came as fried, streaky bacon and not what I would call normal bacon , potato scone hard as the table and one cup of machine made coffee - cost £12.00.

Popped in here on mother's day for food. The menu was a bit basic and limited, but it struck me as very expensive that fish and chips, or a burger and chips were £15.50.

We had been contemplating eating at this restaurant for a while and decided to go for lunch. We both had cheese burgers which were perfectly adequate. The base price for the burger was £9.50 plus an additional £1.50 for a slice of cheese which we found to be expensive. I had a glass of red wine and the bill came to £25.00. There were two other diners in the restaurant and they left shortly after we arrived. We felt the decor and ambiance of the dining area to be gloomy. The evening menu had additional dishes. The available selection of food is somewhat limited. Parking is available to the front and rear of the restaurant.

Recently friends and family joined my Mum and Dad to celebrate their 60th wedding anniversary at the Newmachar Hotel. Understandably it meant a great deal to them and they were anxious that everything should be just right. This was not an easy gig for the hotel, my folks are Christians, tee-total and very particular in what they wanted.

Annoyed me when I asked if they would put a Liverpool game on the TV in the back room on the small TV while the rangers game was on. "this is a Scottish pub" yes but I'd prefer to watch the Liverpool game......didn't happen. Haven't been back since. But it reckons itself. Mediocre at best

Stopped here for lunch nicely decorated restaurant friendly staff, it was soup and sandwiches for us as we were in a hurry. Well presented

Stopped here for lunch before flying out of nearby Dyce. Had haddock and chips, sticky toffee pudding. Very good comfort food, friendly waitress, comfortable surroundings. Parking out front, and apparently some more parking out back.

Attended recently for burger night. Had high hopes and was really looking forward to it. There was a big crown of us who majority had burgers some off main menu. I asked if I could possibly have house burger but with chicken breast instead which was no problem. When it arrived I had been given a breaded chicken fillet. It was ok but nothing startling. Husband said his beef burger was pretty dry and tasteless. Chips were just frozen I thought be at least hand cut. Son had mac n cheese which again was quite poor and he hardly ate any of it. He was last be served out of everyone and given sweet potato fried and chips on his plate. Again bit disappointing but he ate them all up. I would probably attend again but not on burger night far better places to go and get a good burger.

Stayed two nights when attending a wedding in the area. Our room was clean, comfy and modern. Staff exceptionally friendly,. We got lost on the way and they patiently talked us in on the phone. They organised taxis for us and made sure we had everything we needed. Breakfast was delicious. We hadn't been to the area before and feel that this hotel was a wee gem. Brilliant stay, we'll be back.

Went for lunch at 1pm on a sat. We were the only people in the whole restaurant. This should have been a warning sign.

This is an attractive pub and restaurant with a good pub style menu. Food is well presented and well cooked. Not overpriced and good service

Very nice meal. Staff were all very good. Food lovely. We had a lovely evening catching up with family and enjoying a very nice meal with a few drinks.

We went for an evening meal as a family. Menu was good. Starters a little restrictive for a fussy eater, but good selection of mains and puddings. Food was well presented and very tasty. Would highly recommend

Stopped here for a meal with friends . Tho the restaurant was busy we were fitted in and service was friendly and prompt . The decor is a bit erm purple. The menu was varied with decent selections . Value for money was also quite good . We all had burgers which were very good as we were on a timescale . Tho we had a wee wait the venue was busy and we hadn't booked . Not to long tho . Would definitely recommend here.

We were there today for a carvery today at 12-30 the turkey was dry roast beef very red nearly raw . The gammon was the best of them all . Vegetables not very hot . Had to ask for cranberry sauce . , I went to the ladies toilet . There was nose pickings on the toilet walls . They were a bit run down as well

Niente di trascendentale, ma la sensazione di cose genuine. Buona la carne di manzo locale, buono anche il prosciutto anche se un po' salatello e infine gradevole la zuppa proposta. Porzioni di secondo a buffet, cioè fino a riempire il vostro stomaco. Che dire? Metto quattro stelle perché siamo in GB, in Italia ne avrei messe tre.

we went in and woman hoovering was really not interested,took her to go get us two teas,luckily the guy behind bar who i took as owner,told us we were to early for lunch,but he could rustle us up a bacon or egg roll,which he did and i have to say it was very good. don't let one person put you of though,give it a try,you might be lucky and get someone nice to serve you from the start.

Excellent meal. Was visiting friends in the village and we decided to have a meal here instead of driving home for food. Service was quick and with a friendly smile, food was delicious and we were very happy with the size of the portions.

Como mi esposa y yo viajamos desde Inverness a Aberdeen que estábamos buscando un sitio para cenar, nos encontramos con el hotel por casualidad Newmachar puro.

Visited for Sunday Roast, the staff are lovely and couldn't do more for you. The food was amazing, best Sunday Roast in a long time. Excellent Service.

Maravillosa comida de alto nivel. Una decoración preciosa. A un precio razonable. Dolorosamente la lentitud del servicio. Elegimos al asador, así que podíamos comer y salir, pero el chef no sale de la cocina para las edades, a pesar de preguntarnos si podía servirnos. Sólo...

First time I have eaten here, met up with friends for evening meal. Good choice on the menu, friendly staff and I enjoyed what I ordered.

Fantastic food Great staff Reasonable prices The setting is very pleasant Nothing is to much,the service was excellent.

have been here a few times with friends for lunch went here on a Wednesday not too busy. Excellent service, choice of food and a nice place to eat. Several different menus to choose from all keenly priced. Would recommend this restaurant to all kind of diners

Went here with my son and his partner for a evening meal. Wednesday evening is burger night and you get two for £12.50. Although we had the hot dogs which were huge we will be going back to try the burgers as they looked amazing.

I planned an afternoon tea party and cocktails for large group at this hotel for my sisters henny and I need to comment on how perfect everything was. The service we received on the day was great and the food was top class. The room was set out lovely and the organisation was great. The staff were so friendly and made it a special day for us all. Would highly recommend this for small or large groups. Thanks again for everything!

Welcomed and taken to our table, drinks ordered and time given to order, food delivered timeosly and was excellent quality, hot and very tasty, we had three courses and time was given to enjoy with subsequent courses delivered with no undue delay, staff were attentive and pleasant and we did not feel rushed. Ambiance was good and although busy did not feel crowded.

Went for lunch with friend service was excellent food was Top Class the burgers there are awesome worth a visit

My sister got married here yesterday and I just feel the need to comment on how nice everything was. The wedding meal was delicious and very well presented. The place was set out lovely and the organization and running of the wedding by Sheena & Andy was very professional. The staff were very friendly and worked really hard to make the day special. Some family members stayed at the hotel and commented that the rooms were clean and comfortable.Well done to all and thank you.

Nice place to stay on way to Airport after touring the highlands - staff very friendly and welcoming, food was tasty. Room was clean and nicely fitted out - bathroom modern and worked well - nice hot shower

Here I go again!!! You would think I would be beginning to learn not to go out for meals but I must always think, go on this time it will be better!!As I have said before I am a vegetarian and always get so peeved with what we are offered. The menu here had I think 3 or 4 options for me which is better than normal so I opted for the Thai Green Curry after the waiter’s recommendation. We waited for quite a while after we had placed our order, no big problem as we were busy chatting. Our dishes came, all made out to look impressive I suppose with all the usual separate dishes which basically are there to make you think you are getting more than you actually are!! No need and just a palaver if you ask me!! Anyway my Vegetable Thai Green Curry consisted of 3 HUGE chunks and I mean HUGE of courgette (or it could’ve been cucumber it was hard to tell!), I think the chef must have lost his knife! and about then the tiniest slither of yellow pepper possible (must’ve found the knife for them), swimming in a green pool of yogurt type, very tasteless sauce! Another dish containing a tiny amount of rice, not nearly enough to soak up the runny tasteless sauce and in any case I never got a spoon to transfer the runny sauce from dish to dish!! Oh and the nan was nowhere to be seen so asked the waiter who returned with a tiny square sandwich type bread, which I think could well have been a Warburtons thin!!! So yet again no I was not happy and no I didn’t say anything, fed up with it, and basically does anyone care…..no! Oh and that will be £13.95 for that offering. Also the booth that we were seated at the pad on the seat was ripped to shreds!!Needless to say I won’t be back!

We arrived for lunch and promptly greeted by staff, shown to a table, offered drinks and lunch menu. There was a variety available to suit all tastes. Good food, great service and reasonably priced. Well done Newmachar. Keep up the good work. Look forward to a repeat visit soon.

A last minute decision to eat here on a Saturday evening.lovely decor and a very cosy feel. Good choice of food.some lovely twists on some classics like the stovie Bon bons my parents had. For being busy,we didn't wait too long for courses. We were so stuffed, we couldn't do dessert(next time) average pricing and lovely staff.we will be returning :)

Good menu selection of no-nonsense meals at reasonable prices. Generous portions. Good service. Only criticism is about the number of non-working lights (both in the main restaurant and the gents) and general gents toilet maintenance. Definitely hope to return next time we're visiting family in the area.

A few of us met for a meal, staff was very nice, food was lovely, I had the bruschetta very nice i would say it was slightly over priced for what was on the board, (only one piece of bread and previously my friend had been a couple of weeks before and she had two pieces of bread)and I think it would of been better on a plate as when trying to cut it the board was moving about.(just something to think about)

My wife and I decided to travel to Newmachar and try the local hotel for dinner . We were not disappointed as the meal was excellent and freshly cooked to order. The staff were very friendly and attentive . Drinks were reasonably priced and the bar has a good selection of spirits and beers

I recently visited with my sister and were slightly disappointed as they were still offering a limited dish selection due to the time of year.There was a dish on the menu called chicken McFarlane that we were unsure what was. Our waitress told us that it was chicken stuffed with a cream cheese/olive and asparagus served with a basil cream sauce. On her recommendation we both decided to go for this and we were so glad we did. It came beautifully presented with mash and roasted vegetables with extra sauce at the side in a jug.I have to say that this is one of the best dishes I have ever tasted and told the waitress that they must keep this on the menu. It was £15 which some may class as slightly pricey for a lunchtime but it was worth every penny.I will certainly be visiting again soon for another Chicken McFarlane.Compliments to the chef!

We have been coming here since we moved to the area a year ago and it is always a good experience. The menu has a good selection, there is a nice atmosphere and the prices are reasonable. They also do a good loyalty scheme for regulars which is nice. I would definitely recommend this place to a friend.

We ate here on a Sunday night and was impressed by the menu and with the meals we chose. Only downside to the evening was the service was slow. We had to ask to pay our bill three times. Not a big problem but felt as if staff were more intrested in watching the karaoke that was in a different room.

Recently visited Newmachar Hotel to celebrate the birthday of a family member and had a great day. Very friendly staff and décor was nice. A few negatives, bathroom tap in the gents toilets was broken and purple flowers in the restaurant area were full of cobwebs.

Arrived for an evening meal with friends. Greeted by a very nice friendly gentleman wearing a shirt thatArrived for an evening meal with friends. Was greeted by a gentleman wearing a shirt embossed with the words Boss. Very friendly and professional. Handed over to another gentleman, taken through function area in bar to dining area through double doors. It was clear some sort of function was to take place that evening, this was not mentioned to us. Disco music then started and double doors were closed, this did not block out the noise of the DJ.The menus looked very nice and upmarket. We ordered the 'posh monkfish scampi'. Firstly monkfish is called poor mans scampi and secondly there was nothing posh about it. 6 pieces of breaded fish in a tiny basket, a dollop of pea purée and a portion of skinny French fries. McDonalds fries are better than those we were given. If it's to be posh then what about real chunky chips as opposed to cheap frozen fries. Plates were stone cold. Asked for vinegar and sauces, I'm still waiting for that. Off and on through the meal we were interrupted by and annoying waiter checking all was ok. Asked for latte and Irish coffee, both sent back as were cold and it was obvious that they couldn't make a proper Irish or latte. ( must mention that they did deduct coffees from the bill).On leaving the dining area we didn't know how to get out as there was a race night taking place and our only option was to walk over the race mat and ponies, move chairs out of the way and try to get out of the bar.It is very obvious that a lot of money has been spent on the place, ladies toilets have clearly had a lot of work but sadly the old Formica doors don't fit with the new decor.Clearly trying to be a gastro pub but sadly falling way short of the mark. Food was ok but not what it professed to be on menu and £15 for 6 bits of breaded fish and a handful of cheap fries was a bit much.

Having arrived at 5 to 8 (kitchen closes at 8pm) on a Sunday, we were expecting to be turned away, however with a quick check with chef we were seated and served! The only change to the Sunday carvery would be that it was served from the kitchen- no problem at all! My partner had a starter, pate and oatcakes. Looked beautiful and he thoroughly enjoyed it, could have done with an extra oatcake or two to finish the large portion of pate. We both chose meats from the carvery along with all the trimmings. I did wonder if the meat would be dry having been served all day but when it arrived it was delicious, fresh and hot, along with all its accompaniments. An extra jug of gravy was also brought to the table, a nice touch. I had the rolo cheesecake for desert which was also lovely and a very generous portion. Overall, a great meal with great service despite our late arrival. We were made to feel very welcome despite being the only customers left. Not rushed at all, we were made to feel relaxed and left to enjoy our meal in full.

Was pleasantly surprised with the nice decor and ambience. Good friendly service and food brought at ideal intervals. We had a variety of different dishes between diners and everyone was very happy especially those with fish and chips! Puddings were all beautiful and home made, not bought in cheesecakes etc like some establishments, also home made fudge served with coffee, nice touches. I would definitely recommend a meal here and I will also look forward to returning :-)

Given the hype for this restaurant I must admit I was excited to visit. Have to say that it definitely didn't meet my expectations. A group of nine of us visited on Saturday for a leaving meal. Upon booking a box of chocolates had been promised for the member of our party who is leaving her job but the chocs were nowhere to be seen. Service was fine and quick and the waitress polite. Our starters were OK, however the main course wasn't so good. One of our party had ordered seabass which came out late and raw. It was replaced but we were disappointed as to how this could happen. Another of the group had fish but it was very, very greasy!Dessert was the biggest disappointment, however. I ordered a Mars Bar Sundae and was presented with a big, long spoon. As the dish cost £6.25 I expected a nice big pudding. What came was pretty rubbish. A small dish with 3 scoops of chocolate ice cream and half a mars bar broken up over the ice cream does not make a sundae, especially one costing what it did!On the whole, I'm left feeling fairly indifferent towards a restaurant I was really keen to visit.

If i could have gave this a zero star i would. Arrived for a meal, meal took ages. The gravy tasted of water, I couldn't chew the "roast beef" and my mums macaroni was completely tasteless.

A group of Ladies got together on a Wednesday night and chose to eat at the Newmachar Hotel, 7 for 7.30pm a good time as the restaurant wasn't very busy, menu had a good variety with plenty to chose from. We all chose a main with a view to hopefully having room for a sweet, everyone said they enjoyed their main course and several managed a sweet and if not a liqueur coffee or plain coffee, prices are fairly reasonable but it was pointed out to me that the sweets were a little a little dearer than some places we have visited. A good night none the less and would definitely return

Warm friendly welcome as we entered and shown to our seat by friendly chatty staff who are obviously well trained and up on their subject. Not a huge selection on the dinner menu was made up for by quality and varied choice. The presentation is worth a positive mention. Well worth a return visit. http://www.newmacharhotel.co.uk

Being on the main road to Aberdeen and just at the north side of Newmachar makes this place easy to get to.The menu had a good selection of local dishes that will appeal to tourists eg haggis ,Cullen skink .The meals were of good quality and well presented ,many on slate dishes which adds to the presentation.Although good I felt many could not be described as being made freshly on the premises and a good proportion were typical pub lunch style .Overall good but not exceptional

We were catching up with family and met at 5pm, the restaurant was very busy as it was a Sunday & the carvery was on. The service was quite slow but we had plenty to talk about so we didn't mind until we had to get our bill & they took forever & by then the place was pretty empty. Nevertheless the food was beautiful, quite pricey for pub food but it was posh pub grub we felt. Would go back again.