The Gatsby in Dacorum

Very disappointed with visit to The Gatsby last night. There is obviously a problem with staff and maybe there is a change of ownership. Only offered a 3 course supper for pre-cinema meal. We allowed plenty of time - but still the meal was very slow. They need to change their pricing. We didn't have time for pudding - as the whole experience had been so so slow! Wouldn't recommend unless they sort themselves out. The toilets need a proper clean and a lick of paint.

Not too sure why this place has such good reviews, we traveled 35min to this place from a town that has around 20 restaurants just for trying “new place”. Food was average. Scallops were nice but the rest just very basic and much much less quality compared to any well run Turkish place. Beetroot dip was dry, pita soaked fried in oil very bad and would prefer fresh. Sea bass too much oil and butter- supposed to be healthier option of all bur really fatty all around. Lamb pieces (shish) very soft but also odd in texture at the same time almost seems like sousvied forever and then grilled rapidly. Didnt enjoy. Service was ok although wine was never topped up and took a while to get attention for the bill, another 7min to pay the bill.

Been to The Gatsby multiple times. Always excellent food, great service and a treat to have live piano music during the meal. Highly recommend.

We came for the set lunch which was excellent quality and delivered quickly with friendly charm. It was very quiet so I can't comment on service when it is full.

Cocktails were delicious, thank you Memet for the delicious recommendations and service. Would definitely come again.

Best spicy marg in town or even in hertfordshire no cap. The service by Memhet was top notch. I couldn’t recommend this place more. Thank you for your service. Expect our return shortly!!!!!

Thanks Mehmet for a wonderful evening of great food and service.

Mehmet provided 5 star service all night, made sure we had a lovely time and was very attentive to us!

We had a fantastic experience! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the cocktails were absolutely fabulous, and the service was top-notch. A special thank you to Mehmet for taking such great care of us—his attentive and friendly service made our visit even more enjoyable. Highly recommend, and we’ll definitely be back!

The best expirence, the food was stunning! Mehmet was our waiter and was so friendly, helpful and super attentive! Would highly recommend to anyone that's thinking about it ✨

Mehmet was great! Cocktails were also great!

Great service and excellent food

A lovely start to our evening - had a perfect host with our Amhtaz (sorry if I spelt that wrong!). Thank you!

Lovely cocktails, piano in background what's not to like.

We came for drinks before dinner and the service we received from Mehmet was second to none. It made our experience incredibly special. We’ll definitely be back !

We had a wonderful time at The Gatsby. We had brilliant service by our attentive waiter Mehmet, thank you for everything! We will be back! :)

Mehmet was amazing, super helpful snd really lovely. Would recommend to everyone, great place!

Amazing atmosphere. Food and service was on point 👌🏻 all staff very nice and friendly and especially thanks to Mehmet who was looking after us ensuring we had best experience.

We had a great time , food was best ever , staff made us feel like million dollars and the price was great . I can’t fault this restaurant.

Mehmet gave wonderful service, great professionalism, manners and personality. This added to the experience alongside a talented pianist to complete the meal.

Perfect lunch. Really tasty food and great service. Mehmet was very attentive. Good value for a two course lunch.

Mehmit was very attentive and polite, amazing service overall!! Would definitely recommend.

Lovely place, highly recommended!

The Gatsby was our go to place under the ownership of Nick for quality food, great ambience and fantastic service but no longer!!! Just awful!! Service is slow even when quiet, food below average and no ambience. The menu on the side of the building makes this place feel cheap. Many locals in the town feel the same and don’t understand why you would change such a successful business!!?? Thankfully there are many other good places to eat.

We had a lovely afternoon here. Perfect place for a catch up with family and friends. The atmosphere was so relaxing, the staff are very attentive. We experienced their wines, cocktails and some nibbles, all were really good. Would definitely recommend a visit.

Amazing sevice! The staff are so lovely. The manager mehmet is very attentive and lovely. Great atmosphere and stunning drinks ❤️

Amazing drink and service! Would highly recommend! :)

Amazing atmosphere and lovely staff! The manager was so lovely and gave us a free round of shots!

Amazing food and fab service. Wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend. Incredible service and cocktails from Mehmet. Will be back

Had a brilliant meal at the gatsby. Food was lovely and Mehmet, who served us, was really nice and provided excellent service. Would highly recommend !!

We've enjoyed previous visits here, but it will no longer be our go-to for a pre-cinema meal or Sunday lunch. Having booked in advance and requested our favourite bar table halfway up the stairs, we arrived to find no table. We were only given the main menu, no bar menu. However, we'd already decided on the burger, which we ordered. Long wait for service. Requested salt/pepper/mayo. Another long wait. Staff generally inattentive with poor grasp of English language. On settling the bill, my wife queried the total and asked to see the bar menu, which advertised lower prices than those charged. We were then told that the printed menu prices were 'old'. On protesting this disparity, we were reluctantly given cash refunding the difference, although the obligatory service charge remained. I gather the Gatsby is under new ownership – a shame, as it no longer offers the service and quality of experience enjoyed under the previous owners. The loss of its appeal is perhaps summed up by the replacement of the splendid period 'Great Gatsby' wall graphic by a photo of the more modern DiCaprio. Berkhamsted has so many good eateries which we shall turn to in future – Gatsby has lost its magic.

Our 1st time visiting the Gatsby restaurant since the new owners have taken over. The menu is primarily Turkish. We had the Pre-theatre 3 course set menu, which offered good value. This is offered 4.30pm- 6.30pm Monday to Saturday. We visited early on Saturday evening, the restaurant was mostly full. Service was good. Pianist playing background music added to ambience.

The Gatsby has been a favourite of ours for many years but this was our 1st visit since it changed hands. They are redecorating so we sat in the bar as the restaurant was closed. It was a little chilly but the warmth of the welcome and the attention of the staff certainly made up for it. The food was delicious and I cannot wait for our next visit. I am so happy that our favourite restaurant is still good, in fact better than it was.

Popped in after the cinema just to look at the menu. It was just late afternoon so very quiet. Liked the look of the place and the menu so decided there and then to eat here. Very attentive but not over attentive staff. We were seated by a radiator as it was a cold day, noted and thank you. We had the set menu. The food was well served and delicious. We were thrilled to have ‘happened’ upon such a lovely place to eat. Planning a follow up outing with friends at a busier time to enjoy everything this gem has to offer. The four stars for atmosphere was only because not many people want to eat at quarter past four!

Mehmet and the team were great! Food was amazing.

Just had a wonderful evening here for my nans special 80th birthday . Couldn’t fault the food or service all amazing thank you so much. also they best spicy margaritas 😁

Our waiter Memhet was superb and looked after us. A brilliant evening. We will definitely be back. They slayed

First time at the Gatsby for our daughter’s 40th birthday. Just a wonderful night, staff, food and place above expectations. Thank you for all your hard work, we will be coming back.

We came here for my 40th birthday last night, there were 10 of us in total, and we had an amazing time. The food was absolutely delicious, everyone's meal was beautiful and could not be faulted. What really made it special however was the service - it was fantastic. All the staff were friendly, efficient and really couldn't do enough for us all, even engaging with my younger daughter and having her in fits of giggles. Thank you for such a wonderful birthday evening!

Amazing atmosphere delicious foods

Love this Restaurant food Delious

Gorgeous upscale venue with dance and music performances. Very professional staff. Such a shame it's outside London, although that is probably why it can afford to be a lush experience.

Amazing food , lovely people definitely come back !

Great taste and lovely atmosphere. All the staff made us feel welcome and special thank you to Mehmet who was attentive the whole evening despite being a busy New Year’s Eve. From the starter to dessert, everything was spot on. Especially the beef bourguignon was to die for! I would definitely visit again and would recommend anyone reading this review.

I would highly recommend The Gatsby, the food was great and had so much flavor, so many options available and also the food is halal so everyone is catered for! The staff were amazing, Mehmet especially went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed from starters, mains, deserts and drinks. The live entertainment and the atmosphere was amazing. Definitely a must visit restaurant! Thank you to everyone at The Gatsby who made New Year one to remember!

We had a lovely lunch yesterday. The fish pie was excellent although I could have done with some veg like carrots and broccoli. As it was a festive week they had a band playing jazz which was nice but a little too loud for lunchtime conversation. However I'd definitely go again before going to the Rex.

Though the cocktails were nice, the dinner we had was rather lacklustre. We were warmly welcomed and service was friendly, if a little uncoordinated between the staff. Mixed mezze starter was delicious, if less generous in portion size than most Turkish restaurants I know. I had the burger, which was perfectly good. Most of the party went for moussaka. Apparently the veggie moussaka wasn't up to much, and it certainly didn't look appealing. The venue itself is very attractive, clean, and comfortable. It's just a shame the food didn't really live up to it.

Website said there was a live pianist on Saturday nights. Arrived to be told this had now been changed to Sunday. Update your website to avoid disappointing your customers!!!

came on sunday 15th Dec. Just the two of us, last minute booking We had been recently too so were looking forward to coming again The roast was excellent I had the roast pork shoulder and my wife had roast chicken breast The portions were decent, the food was hot and the veg fresh Treacle tart and coffee to finish The service was attentive and swift. The usual background piano music to accompany and the restaurant had a good busy buzz to it Under previous ownership the price of a sunday roast was quite prohibitive it is now much better value for money and good quality We'll be back

Went for 60th birthday meal. Setting and staff were both very good. Unfortunately let down by slowness of food coming out and when it eventually did, was cold. There wasn't any shortage of bar and waiting staff, so issues presumably were in kitchen.

Due to timing our lunch was a bit 'tricky') but the food was delicious and great value. Very nice staff. We'll be returning Very soon

Darci and Ella were great hosts would definitely recommend

Popped in for late afternoon drink. Wonderful. Magnificent decor. Excellent service. Beautiful background music. Perfect.

The meze was great and steak exceptional. Service was really good and has a grand atmosphere. Not convinced it offered value for money. Especially for non meat-eaters. Penne arabiatta or vegetable skewer are things any student can cook. Surely, you can offer something more exotic, especially at your prices?

Amazing place Amazing and welcoming owner!!!

First time back at the Gatsby since new owners. On a positive note the Sunday lunch was the same as it always was absolutely delicious! On arriving for a midday table we were pretty much ignored and had to go into the main restaurant to find someone. The person incharge was in the office looking at the internet. There was a photo shoot taking place (slightly odd when the restaurant was booked for customers) the photographer was swearing which was inappropriate as we had young children with us. They did however leave after 10 minutes but adding this on to the non welcome it was rather disappointing. We had to ask for the really loud music to be turned down, the waitress was apologetic and said it wasn’t meant to be that loud or Rocky !! Shame as first impressions count so we won’t be rushing back.

I went to the Gatsby a few weeks ago Prior and thought it was great. Having went again this Friday very excited as they had a singer advised and organised a girls night.. to then turn up and they have no entertainment as advertised. Really disappointed

Ate here pre a Rex cinema visit. Excellent waiter service, very polite, very exact, willing to please. Had carrot & cauliflower soup - absolutely delicious and creamy, followed by seabass - delightful. Would highly recommend

Had a great pre cinema meal on Saturday night. Food was great - portions on the set menu just right. Mehmet was very attentive and we had a lovely evening!

Great atmosphere and top service from all the staff. Very welcoming, and the quality of food was excellent - definitely worth the price. Our waiter was Mehmet, and he was very attentive and professional. Would highly recommend this place! Can’t wait to go back! (They very kindly gave us a birthday treat too.)

Had lunch at the Gatsby yesterday and served by Mehmet who was excellent. Food good, service really lovely and great place to eat - especially as I was going to the cinema later.

Food was amazing service was quick a d efficient

We enjoyed a fabulous company brunch catering for 100 staff. Lots of options to choose from on the brunch menu and all with perfect poached eggs!

First time here. We had awesome cocktails and the wine was excellent. We had a starter of mushrooms in a garlic cheese sauce with bread which was delicious. Our waiter was Mehmet, who was brilliant, totally attentive and nothing was too much trouble. Definitely coming back to try the full menu!

Enjoyed a team breakfast brunch this morning. The food, service and hospitality was excellent. There were over 80 of us and nothing was too much trouble and everything was perfect!

Went to the Gastby and had Mehmet as our server and we received amazing service for the entirety of our visit

We chose the Gatsby for our wedding venue and it was the best decision we made! It was incredible from start to finish. The staff were so attentive and made sure every detail was exactly as we wanted it. The communication throughout was great, and we felt a lot more relaxed with the planning knowing everything was in hand. The food was exceptional. It can be tricky to produce quality food at scale but every dish, every canapé and every cocktail was perfect. The value for money considering the level of detail and quality was mind blowing. I cannot recommend the Gatsby and their team highly enough. They made our day the best it could possibly be. Thank you so much for everything!

We hosted our wedding reception at The Gatsby this weekend and it was incredible. Ollie was great with our prep and getting everything sorted and set up on the day! The food was incredible, Head Chef Matt helped us create a great menu for a winter wedding, with many compliments that the food was the best they had ever had at a wedding. The team went above and beyond to make sure us and all our guests had an amazing time! Everything was exactly as we planned and the team added lots of special details. Our suppliers all commented on what a great experience the team provided for them and said they were made to feel like family and would recommend the venue to anyone looking for a venue in the area! Can't thank you guys enough, we had the best time and will see you very soon :)

Was invited to a wedding. The venue was super nice. The service was amazing, staff were very friendly, will be visiting again soon

Beautiful restaurant and bar with attentive service. Mehmet goes out of his way to make guests feel welcome. Highly recommended.

Fabulous food, service & atmosphere! The staff were on the ball & Mehmet was very welcoming. Cocktails excellent with some new editions as well to try. Well done all at the Gatsby.

What a great place to come to especially if you have a venue going on like I went to everything was just great the food service was great the staff was amazing..Except one staff did drop abit of gravy on my shirt by accident but you know accidents do happen and it didn’t over shadow the rest my evening…

Was here for my brothers wedding. An amazing day all round. Food was amazing, service was amazing they literally did everything they could and more to make the day run smoothly and to ensure everyone had the best time. Will definitely have to come back during normal circumstances. Thanks for having us.

An absolutely perfect wedding venue, loved it 🤩

We have been going to the Gatsby for many years, and last night was our final one. We go every year as a family for a birthday celebration, we sat at our table and were handed menus, we all made our selections and ordered (most of us went for the fillet steak as this is their signature dish) about 10 mins after ordering we were told they only had three fillet steaks left!! (7pm on a Friday! Ridiculous !! ) so we had to all sit there are work out who is getting steak and who isn’t! This was a very awkward situation to put us in! Then as the evening progressed service was slow, and trying to get attention of a waiter/waitress was an impossible task! If the restaurant had been busy you could understand it, but there was only one other table and the rest of the place was empty! (This speaks volumes!) Last year our bill was £850 and this time it was £540 the difference being down to the restaurant! No fillet steak and slow drink service, this cost them a £300 loss of revenue, very bad management. To top it all they put service on the bill!! So if nothing else they have a good sense of humour!!!

Brilliant venues, I’ve visited a few times for dinner with my partner; having the new management I can confirm the food, staff and service has been second to none. I would happily recommend this place to anyone Berko.

Been here for a wedding and the food and atmosphere was great

Went to the best wedding here absolutely amazing service and food

Everything was perfect. I attended a wedding here and the food and service was perfection, 10/10 would recommend.

Absolutely amazing service from the Gatsby, my brother’s and sister in law’s wedding was perfect, the service, the attention to detail, nothing could be faulted. The slow cooked pork belly was unbelievable !! Would definitely return and recommend to anyone wanting to host an event :)

Amazing venue, and the staff is absolutely incredible!! Cannot recommend it enough

Such a lovely place! I performed at a wedding here and it was brilliant. The staff were so lovely and helpful. All the guest really enjoyed themselves and the cocktails were also amazing! Margaritas are a must try!!

Food is incredible, drinks were super quick and delicious. Orla and Frankie were excellent and attentive waitresses. New management are very friendly and accommodating! Very excited to return

Really amazing atmosphere and friendly staff with great tasting food

Very lovely experience. Recommended

New management are very friendly and make you really welcome. Food and drink excellent, beautiful surroundings. Staff are great, still my favourite

Great surroundings and atmosphere. Amazing cocktails and delicious well presented food. Staff friendly and attentive

Amazing food & cocktails and the staff are lovely :)

We visited tonight for my dad’s 60th birthday the service was absolutely fantastic the food was great 👍🏼 Mehmet and the team was friendly and helpful what a special evening . Such a calm vibe .highly recommend well done 👏🏻

Amazing food, lovely stuff and great atmosphere

The staff where lovely and the management was great, everyone loved the food would definitely recommend to all my friends

everything was perfect, the food was amazing, service was fast and no mistakes on orders, the atmosphere was really nice, nothing too loud

Amazing food, lovely cocktails and spectacular service. It’s everthing we hoped for and the prices were reasonable. Will definitely be coming again. Special thanks to İlknur, Zafer and Kayra

Went there and had an amazing experience, all staff were kind and friendly and the food was delicious.

Such a lovely place with the most amazing food! So happy with my visit here and will definitely be coming back! The staff are so so kind and make sure i’m well looked after. Overall one of my favourites by far.

Quality of the food much reduced since my last visit pre pandemic. Overcooked sea bass and poor hallumi starter. Overall quite disappointing

We were lucky enough to attend The Berko Brunch at the Gatsby on Saturday, what an amazing time we had. The venue is wonderful but the best part is the staff , truly fantastic so warm & friendly - great food that all added to the wonderful atmosphere. The entertainment on the day was amazing from the dancers greeting us to the sax player & magician whilst DJ playing to be finished off with a singer Cannot wait to attend again.

Amazing venue with great friendly staff. Food and drinks very good value. We will be back 🥂

Wow what a place this is, from the bar staff, to the waiting staff, to the management team who are so lovely and found time to introduce themselves to myself and my partner, I don’t have a bad word to say about this place! Wonderful team in a gorgeous setting & atmosphere with delicious food, will without doubt be back here soon!

Oh no, The Gatsby has changed hands. The menu has changed, as has the food options. It is now primarily Turkish, save for a couple of original options. We found the service slow and confused, we arrived in good time for lunch and to go to the Rex for 2o’clock, we told te waiters we were going upstairs and they brought mains and starters together… not what we were expecting. My companion told the waiter her dish was like warm and he said don’t worry I’ll do something about that… he didn’t. It was a miserable lunch experience.