Silversmiths in Sheffield

We had a family get together for mums 90th birthday and I can honestly say that we all loved the Sunday lunch very much. We will be back in the near future to sample more of the menu. The staff were excellent and they helped us with the cake mum really enjoyed the day.

Absolutely horrendous. After having a series of good meals at Silversmiths we made the decision to return in celebration of my Mum and Dad’s wedding anniversary. It took a while to receive our drinks and then another hour until our food actually arrived. No one came to apologise for how long the food was taking or gave any explanation as to why the food was so delayed, despite us having waited over an hour by this stage. Upon arrival our meals (all of which were a Sunday roast) arrived entirely cold. All of the veg was stale, meat cold and even the gravy had gone cold. We were done at this stage and instead of being apologetic for the awful service, stupidly long wait and cold in-edible food the manager still expected us to pay for our drinks. We aren’t a family who ever complain at restaurants but we weren’t the only table sending our food back or complaining about the long wait times. This experience was bad enough that we will never return to a restaurant which was once our go-to for special occasions. Disappointing.

We ate Sunday lunch with you on Sunday and it was absolutely delicious. I had the celeriac and it had the right amount of kick. Beautiful range of perfectly cooked veg. I'm looking forward to visiting again

We really enjoyed it, the food was great and the staff were lovely, the meal was perfect so thank you very much, I would just say the lights were a little to bright. It’s become our new favourite restaurant and we will be back soon :) Thanks, Gabriel

When we arrived we were greeted by our waitress for the night which was a lady called Marissa. Our drinks orders were taken and within a couple of minutes our drinks arrived. We then placed our food order and also asked a few questions about the food on the menu to which she didn't hesitate to answer our questions regarding this. The food was unbelievable, the steak was the best I've ever had, My partner had the lamb and it was cooked to perfection. All in all, we had a fabulous night of beautiful food and exceptional service from Marissa. She is by far the best waitress I have ever had the pleasure of meeting and is a credit to the company. We will definitely be returning. Massive thanks to Marissa for her exceptional hospitality towards us.

My friend and I visited on Sunday for a roast and it was fabulous! We really enjoyed our time at Silversmiths, the food was delicious, great value and the service was wonderful. Thoroughly enjoyed our trip to Silversmiths and will be back!

First visit to Silversmiths, first visit to Sheffield. On street parking opposite, With a car park a short stroll had that of been full. Staff were fun and friendly whilst still being professional. Big mix of cliental, some people casual others dressed up. All welcomed with a sense of Silversmiths being inclusivity. Center piece was the food. Varied choice on the menu, superbly presented, much of it locally sourced. Silversmiths really are ambassadors for great food great service and Sheffield as a city.

We had a wonderful Sunday lunch, great portion size and wonderfully presented and the team were very attentive. We found it to be great value and will definitely be returning as we are only Doncaster based and go out for a roast most weeks!

Silversmiths offered a great experience - everything from the welcome, the service, the surrounds, and especially the food! We would highly recommend. We ate from the pre-theatre menu and the efficiency of service was second to none. We will definitely return!

Lovely food with great attentive staff

Since our visit I have recommended Silversmiths to a lot of my friends - the booths are the perfect cozy and snuggly table for 4 to get to know each other end enjoy some amazing food! I champion this place to anyone looking for foodie recommendations in Sheffield and honestly I don’t think there’s a single thing that you should change. Our servers that eve were really lovely too. Keep up doing what you’re doing we love you!

Had a gorgeous Sunday lunch, great staff and lovely atmosphere

Lovely welcoming staff, great service. Restaurant was clean and well presented. I’m disappointed in the lack of vegetarian options. The vegetarian options that were available were too small. The roast celeriac portion was too small, and I finished it in about 5 minutes. It felt more like a starter than a full meal. It was just vegetables with little to no protein, it left me feeling hungry as I left the restaurant. Please update the menu to be more vegetarian friendly, with filling meals. The food presentation was great, but it was lacking in taste.

Had the early evening deal. Starter of roasted carrots disappointing as they weren't cooked - just warmed up. Left most. Mussels for main OK, nice sauce bread and chips but several of the mussels hadn't opened yet we're served up to eat!

Great food friendly service. It's pretty damn good.

Staff were fantastic. Attentive and friendly. Sunday lunch was ok. A limited menu which is ok as we went specifically for a Sunday roast but it took quite a long time to arrive, the portion was small for the cost and the food was cold. With a limited menu and a half full restaurant I found it surprising. We won’t return, the food let the serving staff down.

We hired the upstairs room and it was fantastic. A perfect space for a group of around 12 and the food and the service was outstanding. I can’t recommend this pub more highly. Just fantastic for meeting up with a good bunch of friends for a fantastic night of food, drink and laughs. Special mention to the staff who were brilliant.

Excellent service, food staff are very helpful and friendly

An exceptional meal with even better service thanks to Marisa. She was kind, attentive yet not intrusive- an asset to your team Silversmiths. The meal a three course- was outstanding- every mouthful, highly recommend the chicken and salmon for starter. I did mean to ask what you had done to the lemon accompanying the salmon as it was like nothing I’d ever tasted- but I loved it. Thavk you we will return soon

Excellent Sunday lunch celebrating Gina’s 90th birthday. Many thanks to all the team.

Terrible service food minimal drinks slow rip off & staff whispering talking about everyone not pleasant experience will not return

Beautiful Sunday roast dinner...tender rare beef and plenty of it...lovely friendly staff and great value for money. Home made lemon meringue ice cream best ever

Horrendous, waiting for the table, ran out of chicken at 2pm so ordered a veg dinner and was charged for the cauliflower dinner but didn’t bring the cauliflower…had to walk up and ask for drinks, roast potatoes like grey rocks from a building site Beef was great but overall will never set foot in this place again Terrible

Fantastic food . Had the salmon for starters , mussels in creams sauce , carrots with Parmesan cheese, and chocolate mousse . One of the best meals I had on my life . Well cooked, presentation top. I would recommend to everyone

We found Silversmiths to be the best pre-theatre restaurant we have used. The menu was good and varied and our choices were excellently cooked. We shall be back!

We booked Silversmiths for my daughter’s Hen Party. The bottomless brunch was amazing from start to finish . The staff were really friendly , attentive and professional the food was lovely. The cocktails and drinks were exceptional and plentiful would definitely recommend. We will be back , thank you Silversmiths

My husband and I absolutely love Silversmiths, it is our favourite place to go in Sheffield. The food is always delicious and we love that the menu is interesting and changes regularly. The staff are always friendly and the atmosphere is lovely. We have been going for years and never had anything less than an amazing experience.

Delicious food and great friendly service

Good food, good ambiance, as always

What an amazing little restaurant, food was beautiful, reasonably priced for such high quality food and the atmosphere and decor are lovely. Highly recommended

We had the early evening menu which was fine. Will return and try the full menu.

Silver Smiths Restaurant made for a fantastic choice for date night with my partner. From the moment we stepped in, I was captivated by the dark, moody décor which created an intimate and inviting atmosphere. The presentation of the food was beautifully done, with creative flavour pairings that I truly enjoyed. Each dish was well thought out and delicious, making me eager to return and explore more of the menu. While I appreciated the cocktail I ordered, I found it a bit too sweet for my taste. Additionally, sipping through the straw was tricky as pieces of the crushed fruit kept blocking it. However, this was a minor issue and more of a personal preference than anything. The cleanliness of the restaurant was impeccable, and the staff were incredibly warm, professional, and attentive, which made the entire experience feel special. Overall, I had a lovely time and will definitely be coming back for more. Highly recommended!

Visited for the pre theatre menu. The food was absolutely gorgeous and the staff were friendly and attentive. Very good value for money too.

We had a really lovely meal, with delicious food, in a welcoming and friendly environment. There was an issue with one of the mains, however the staff dealt with that well, providing a new main and taking the cost of the main off the bill altogether. It was pretty noisy in the restaurant with a lot of people also eating. This reflected the restaurant's popularity but did make conversation feel slightly more challenging across the table. Overall it was a very positive experience, at reasonable price for the quality of the food, and would be well recommended!

We visited Silversmiths for the first time in quite a while this week and I'm delighted to say it was absolutely fantastic. The food on the midweek supper club was spot on. The menu isn't the widest but understandable for the midweek market and prices very favourably. The quality of it was spot on. The pig cheek starter was delicious and definitely better than it sounds! The pan fried chicken was cooked to perfection and an absolutely delightful main. The Thai influenced seaweed cod was a big flavour hit and very well received by my wife. The carraway fries were a pleasant side too and something a bit different. The service was spot on and the food was beautiful. Special mention to the behind the scenes and the customer care. I had an issue with a gift voucher but they sorted this out in advance of our visit with no fuss at all. This was greatly appreciated. The only thing I would tweak is the background music, but maybe that was just us. The music wasn't 'wrong' in any way and I couldn't name the tracks. Personally I would have gone for something a little softer/instrumental/more background. All in a delightful meal out and very well looked after by the team at Silversmiths. Don't overlook this gem which is a little bit hidden in the city centre.

Brilliant atmosphere, beautiful decor. Brilliant service. Food was nice ,what you could find on your plate .came out starving very little food .

First time at this restaurant. Have attended for a date night on a Wednesday at 7pm. The outside of the building is beautiful, and the dining area is beautiful. Apon entrance, we were given a warm, friendly welcome and shown to our table. 2 things missing of the menu and disappointed that no pints of lager were available. All I could have was bottles of beer, which was more expensive than a pint. The lemonade and coke were off as well. Starter was a 3 out of 5. The pork crackling was rock hard. Couldn't bite through it. Main was 4 out of 5. Had to pay extra for chips. Pudding was 5 out of 5 but could have done with bigger portions.

My family and I enjoyed an excellent meal here to celebrate my daughters graduation in July. We had a lovely evening, the food was very good with some interesting options (never encountered deep fried mince pie before but it was amazing!) and the service first rate. Will be sure to visit again next time we're in the fine city of Sheffield !

Really below average food. Waitress looked put out when pressing whether we had anything to say about it and I said it was just really average. Id wanted to come for some time because of the rave reviews but I can’t believe they’re all genuine after that. They did call ahead and say they don’t have two of the four meats available.. completely fine I was having beef anyway which they had. On arrival no cauliflower cheese (assuming it’s store bought?) and no discount for it missing. I was so disappointed by the food that when the bill came I didn’t even argue the missing food, what difference could it have made to frozen potatoes, poorly cooked beef (overdone), and batter mix Yorkshire puddings. The nicest thing on my plate and the only saving grace was a lovely carrot! I never eat puddings but I needed one today. That was ok but obviously a tray bake. I cook well, I expect for a restaurant to at least match my own cooking. Was really looking forward to it and would usually give at least twice before making my mind up but with food like that I wouldn’t return unless it was free and I’d have to be at a loose end even then. Nice place (decorated) really poor food, very overpriced, do not recommend.

Really below average food. Waitress looked put out when pressing whether we had anything to say about it and I said it was just really average. Id wanted to come for some time because of the rave reviews but I can’t believe they’re all genuine after that. They did call ahead and say they don’t have two of the four meats available.. completely fine I was having beef anyway which they had. On arrival no cauliflower cheese (assuming it’s store bought?) and no discount for it missing. I was so disappointed by the food that when the bill came I didn’t even argue the missing food, what difference could it have made to frozen potatoes, poorly cooked beef (overdone), and batter mix Yorkshire puddings. The nicest thing on my plate and the only saving grace was a lovely carrot! I never eat puddings but I needed one today. That was ok but obviously a tray bake. I cook well, I expect for a restaurant to at least match my own cooking. Was really looking forward to it and would usually give at least twice before making my mind up but with food like that I wouldn’t return unless it was free and I’d have to be at a loose end even then. Nice place (decorated) really poor food, very overpriced, do not recommend. Oh forgot to add, VAT is additional when the bill comes too!

This is a favourite and did not disappoint when we went for a celebration dinner. I had the best vegetarian meal I've had in a restaurant and the coffee mouse for dessert was perfect. The food is interesting and experimental and almost always excellent. The service is efficient and discrete. Looking forward to going again soon.

Poor experience. No greeting on arrival. LED to the table and given menus. Immediately told no Pork or Lamb available due supplier failure !Starters not mentioned on the menu so I enquired and told the restaurant find that customers having the main course only is sufficient? I asked for bread or olives whilst we were waiting for the main course - All to no avail as nothing was available. Desserts were available but no costs shown on the menu. The main course was enjoyed, but the overall experience including gravy dropped on my trousers was not good. We ear out regularly and found the service here strange including staff tickle tackling behind the bar when we complained. The restaurant were told we would not return and they agreed to £7 compensation being deducted off the bill for my trousers to be dry cleaned.

What a wonderful evening we had. the staff were so attentive but not intrusive. They have a fabulous mixologist and the food was exquisit. Chef even accommodated my vanilla allergy with a special dessert for me. I'm so pleased we chose Silversmiths to celebrate our anniversary

Went for a bottomless brunch and found plenty of pros and cons. As someone with a baby they were lovely and 'let' me have soft drinks in the deal - should be included anyway. GF options were available, always good as I'm coeliac. The main downside was the portion size. I'd expect a decent meal for any brunch, let alone bottomless. This was served on a side plate and the food barely touched the sides. Even the extra halloumi portion was essentially one slice of halloumi. The service was friendly and we weren't left wanting drinks.

Great food and so good to eat somewhere with innovative menus rather the the same old choice. Excellent value with supper club and Sunday special deals but would pay full price for a special occasion. Staff always attentive and knowledgeable. Always a treat.

Fantastic service and excellent quality food 👌

Great food, brilliant selection of drinks and very pleasant service. Would return.

Excellent service and food quality all around, great value for money and you won't be disappointed!

Had a wonderfully tasty 3-course supper club meal prior to visiting the Lyceum Theatre. The food and service was excellent and would definitely recommend.

Had a fabulous lunch with my family for husbands birthday. Food was delicious, very friendly staff providi g excellwnt seevice. lovely ambiance and super background music. Will definitely visit again when in Sheffield!

Had the 3 roast sunday lunch. One of the best I had in sheffield

Very interesting and tasty meals, completely different from the standard menu you tend to find elsewhere. Limited menu but well worth trying.

Really enjoyed the well priced mid-week supper club using a voucher purchased for a big birthday... Friendly staff and the food was devine. If you can elavate a sprout to something edible and delicious then you're doing something right. Will definitely visit again.

Excellent pre theatre meal. Innovative menu and well cooked and presented food. Very good prices. Friendly, helpful staff.

Myself and my friend loved your bottomless brunch experience on Saturday. The young girl (blonde - sorry I don’t know her name!) that served us was very attentive and friendly and made sure our drinks were flowing throughout our booking. It was our first time at your restaurant and definitely won’t be the last! Thank you

Excellent quality food, Good value Lovely staff

Really nice place, amazing food, and great service. Cheers.

Great food in a smart little place. Nice people. Recommended!

My new favourite restaurant especially with supper club and theatre ticket discount. Cured salmon was exquisite with capers and germinated onion seeds. Cod with green Thai was beautiful then the sticky toffee pudding with sesame Ice cream and Szechuan peppercorns was amazing. Bryony looked after us beautifully.

We had a delicious meal and fantastic service when we visited Silversmiths. Highly recommend.

A very rushed Sunday service. We waited 50 minutes for our mains (which was preordered) and then was hurried by the waiting on staff as there was a table booked afterwards. One of these times the waiter reminded us a table was booked on for 2 while we were waiting for our preordered desserts. It’s not child friendly so children dessert options. The meat on the roast was either cold or minimal. Wouldn’t recommend there are nicer Sunday roast places in Sheffield

The a la carte food is amazing. Soo good in fact that neither of us took photos! I started with melt in the mouth tartare, then cod, and finished with treacle tart seasoned with mushroom power. Approachable, friendly, though discrete service added to the great experience. Will be back soon.l

Super friendly service and super tasty food! Fabulous place, a cut above most places we’ve been to. Highly recommend.

My Wife and I attended Silversmiths on Saturday 13th July 2024 as a celebration of recently being married. We were welcomed in to the restaurant by waitress Marissa who, from the outset and throughout, was extremely friendly and professional. The service in general was quick and the atmosphere inside was great. The food was spectacular- I had the Southern Fried Chicken Burger and my wife had the monk fish. Both were delicious. The cocktails were also great- I had the old fashioned and my wife had the Yorkshire garden. Please pass on our thanks to Marissa and staff for their hospitality and service ( the complimentary prosecco was much appreciated).

The lamb was sublime! Wonderful veg on the roast. Plenty of gravy. Lovely service. Would highly recommend

Went there for our anniversary dinner. The food was great and the cocktail was delicious. Loved everything about it made our anniversary special. The staff were amazing and so kind and welcoming. The atmosphere was amazing and made the nice perfect.

We had a fabulous time. Staff greeted us happily, they were courteous and especially helpful when I asked questions regarding the Béarnaise Sauce. Food was really nice, we all enjoyed it. Restaurant had a nice ambience and lighting. I can’t remembered being asked about how the steak was to be cooked, for me it was perfectly cooked, but if my wife had it, it would have been too raw for her. We were surprised about the Black Forest Gateaux, was expecting some cake, the dessert that came out was still nice, we all thoroughly enjoyed it, but we all said maybe a round piece of chocolate sponge in there would have made it perfect for us. My daughter really enjoyed the soft shell crab and my wife has never seen violet potatoes before, which were lovely. Look forward to visiting again

The staff were amazing, and the drinks were all prepared very nicely. I'd say the cocktails were the best part of our experience, the ingredients were lovely, and they were presented perfectly. It was nice to go to a classy brunch where we could hear each other speak as the music wasn’t too loud.

Excellent friendly prompt service from staff. Delicious food , we had mains and desserts , all so tasty, will definitely return and recommend too x

Silversmiths is a cracking place. Great service and wonderful food.

My friend and I had a lovely time at Silversmiths restaurant on Saturday. We both had the open steak sandwich which was delicious and the steak was cooked perfectly. The cocktails were lovely and the service was excellent. I have been to Silversmiths a few times previously, so I knew how good the food and service was, but my friend had never been before. She thoroughly enjoyed herself and said she would definitely go back.

Superb bottomless brunch, great food, drinks, venue, lovely friendly staff. Highly recommended and will definitely return.

Had a really nice dinner on a Friday night at Silversmiths. Great wagyu rib starter and a lovely monk fish main. Was too full to have a dessert! Would definitely go back. Friendly service and good value, good quality food!

The atmosphere was lovely and the establishment was nice and clean. We found our experience lovely. Can't beat the price and service.

It was nice here. I came here a while ago. I came with my family and the steak was lovely but it was a bit of a small portion. The atmosphere here was not very good but overall I enjoyed coming here.

We had an excellent and reasonably priced mid week evening meal from the supper club menu. The service was very good and we all enjoyed our meals. It's a bit of a gem in the heart of the city and close to uni accommodation so visiting parents can treat their children.

Booked my parents in for a pre show meal on their wedding anniversary, paid for with a gift voucher. I emailed and the reply was very prompt and helpful (thank you Chris). My parents loved the food saying it was very veggie friendly, the service was fantastic and the cocktails were delicious. My dad even said it was the best resteraunt he's been to in Sheffield. Thanks for looking after them, Silversmiths.

Had Sunday Roast with friends. It was my first time having Sunday Roast, and it was amazing. Highly recommended by my English friends as well. Nice desserts as well. Love the atmosphere and very friendly staff. Would highly recommend the place.

Food was beautiful, great choice of drinks and cocktails and matched by excellent service 5⭐️!!

We visited Silversmiths for lunch on Sunday 28 April 2024. We had such an enjoyable occasion; the food was exceptional and the flavour of dishes, meat and vegetarian were delectable. The waitresses were attentive and very friendly; it was no problem accommodating the pram! The atmosphere was relaxed and provided a really enjoyable dining experience. We have recommended Silversmiths to others and we look forward to dining with you again soon.

Really excellent meal. Service food and ambience were great. Would return any time

Attended on Saturday 11th May with 7 others for the bottomless brunch. We were booked in for 12:00 which at the time of booking seemed quite early. It probably still was as we were the first in. We arrived just before and was promptly shown to our table. First drinks order taken dead on 12:00 and by 12:10 the first one had gone and we were ready for another. Great choice of drinks and the food was absolutely gorgeous. Quality, quantity, taste and presentation 10/10. The food was preordered and came 20 minutes after we arrived. I now understand why we could only get in at 12:00. By the time we came to leave the place was full. Quite strict with having one drink at a time (no “double parking”) which I totally get. The waitresses would take another drinks order if you were reaching the bottom of your current drink. Was great to have the 15 minutes reminder as we were nearing the end of our time slot. Great drinks, food and atmosphere. Would definitely recommend.

My wife and I visited Silversmiths for an evening meal. I've got to say the food was amazing, the atmosphere was great and very friendly but I can't rate the service high enough. The servers couldn't have been better. After the meal, we thought we'd enjoy a cocktail... the one I wanted (a manhattan) wasn't on the menu, so they goggled it and made it for me. Honestly, if in the area I would highly recommend.

We had a wonderful time at Silversmiths on Saturday, the staff are fantastic and the food was delicious. Our only feedback would be the choice of cocktails were not our ‘cup of tea’ but that is purely personal preference. The bonus was that we could have a spirit and mixer as an alternative which you don’t get in many other venues. Overall, a great experience and one I would happily repeat and recommend to family and friends.

Sent first meal back it was cold . Second came back the same apart from the Yorkshire pudding . Lamb not cooked left half of it in my napkin so raw and full of fat. Sorry will not be back . Service was lovely.

Delicious 3 course meal- every dish well thought out and presented. Particularly enjoyed the celeriac starter. Service was friendly and attentive and it was nicely busy for Thursday evening. Great. Would go back again.

Great place and drinks on the bottomless brunch keep coming at a good pace , 100 percent recommend .

The quality of food was outstanding, All cooked to order and served piping hot. The portion sizes were really generous and it all tasted amazing. The service was excellent, all staff were very attentive.

Took a work party of 12 for supper club. Food was really nice, came quickly and was enjoyed by all. Service was good and all the staff very friendly. I would definitely come again. We all had a really lovely evening together at Silversmiths 😊

Superb experience for my mum for her birthday. We experienced their tasting menu which was 4 course and an intermission which was an incredibly culinary experience. The service by all the staff made us feel welcome and comfortable and the atmosphere throughout the evening was delightful.

Lovely Restaurant where we always enjoy their Sunday Lunch. As a Family of 6, we enjoyed mains of Lamb and Beef, followed by Desserts. Good selection of Wines/Beers and everything was good quality served by attentive waiting staff. Already looking forward to our next visit, thank you 👍

We were visiting Sheffield from tha USA and had eaten at Silversmiths 18 months ago and was hoping it would be still going. We returned this week and really enjoyed the ‘dining club’ idea, and again the food was excellent. I wanted to return again in our nine day stay but the wife wanted to try other restaurants (but secretly wanted to return to Silversmiths). As in all good marriages we compromised and brought three family members with us for an excellent Sunday lunch (kudos to the sticky toffee pudding). Fully recommend you to anyone within earshot. Whoever’s cooking, my advice would be to hang onto them.

Excellent food, lovely service. The supper club is particularly good value for money.

Came for Sunday lunch prior to going to the cinema. The welcome, the food and the service was faultless. The Sunday lunch menu is a showcase in how to do dining out where the emphasis is on quality, yet is also great value for money We would all recommend Silversmiths.

The mid week menu at Silversmiths was ideal - 5 or 6 choices for each course and all at reasonable prices. The food itself was tasty and delicious, with a wonderful Asian fusion. The portion sizes were very good too. It is unusual for us to order three courses as we get full after two. But we had room for a pudding, which was great as I got to sample the best rice pudding I have ever had. The service was brilliant and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. We can’t wait to return and sample more. My wife took photos of her food - Pork tenderloin with dauphinoise potatoes followed by chocolate delice with orange ice cream.

Wonderful food and great service from a small independent restaurant.

Lovely food, friendly service. We will definitely return in the future.

Really nice food and nice environment

A hidden gem in Sheffield City Centre to shout about, nice food and nice service from the team

Incredible experience. By far the best food and restaurant in Sheffield. Tasting menu on a Saturday is superb value and absolutely delicious. Stuart and his staff were incredibly attentive and knowledgeable. 5 stars all round.