Plesters Restaurant in Sheffield

Brilliant find. We stayed locally on a biking trip and stumbled upon Plesters by chance. Tried the Salt & Pepper fish starter and Fish Stew main on night one. Enjoyed it so much we returned for Black Pudding starter and Steak on night 2. Everything done to order with only one front of house and one chef so you need to be prepared to wait ......but it's worth it. Highly recommended if you are in the area.

Another perfect experience, this one was valentines night. Lovey restaurant, hosts and food. Reasonably priced , what more can you ask for.

We go regularly and have a brilliant experience every time. Food is excellent and the chef and host are friendly and welcoming.

Fantastic food. The Jamaican Salmon is superb. Friendly service. Our 3rd vist and would definitely recommend but you must book.

Excellent meal with friends 😋 Service also very good @ a reasonable price.

Lovely food, cooked well. Friendly staff

Our first time dining out here. The food was out of this world ! Service and atmosphere excellent. We will definitely be back ! Highly recommended.

Recommended this place to my daughter who booked today for an anniversary meal. I was surprised by the response she got from Geoffrey and Pansy. So disappointed as Glynn Roden thinks so much of you both and we both have had great service and really enjoyed meals there. Not very good customer service from you both of you apparently and that was only trying to book a reservation.

We booked over a week in advance but 6 hours before our booking, we got a message saying that our booking was cancelled. So disappointed. 🙁

Love this place. We were asked to use the hand sanitiser as we sat down. For me, this was a WINNER!! I have OCD about my hands, so I was more than impressed! We went using a Groupon, and the food didn't disappoint...

Had groupon voucher for 2 courses but paid supplements Food freshly cooked good 👍 Service quick and friendly Enjoyed meal ribeye steak melted in mouth very tasty The Negatives would be the portion sizes and the lettuce used as a side could have used mixed leaves not a fan of iceberg ? Also offering of condiments etc

Intimate dining with the kitchen right out in the corner. Excellent food and when the appetizer I wanted was out they made me something close from scratch. Great food and great service.

Very nice evening,food was very good

Fantastic food and service will be going again

Arrived at Plesters for 6pm booking no one in. Front of house service not friendly at all. Having originally got a groupon voucher for mid week brunch value £20 on booking was told they were not doing brunch anymore so if we wanted to pay £15 we could book for evening meal. But out side the restaurant there was a sandwich board which was advertising Sunday Brunch for £7 ? When bill arrived we had an extra charge of £23.65 for the meal. We paid but won’t be going again

Gorgeous place with fantastic food and atmosphere. Friendly efficient And will definately visit again xx

Lovely restaurant great service and excellent food !

Beautiful food and restaurant I haven’t wanted to go out much due to illness but what a lovely night good food brilliant staff n lovely relaxing atmosphere did me a world of good. Thank u so much we will be back

So popped in to Plesters, lovely little place Jeremy is an amazing host and Is on top of the front of house. His partner in the kitchen is totally on top of her game and is sending out quality food presented really well. Top night and good value

Outstanding food! Plesters only have a small selection of dishes, but do them all really well, coupled with house wine at £10 a bottle, its easy to make it a regular haunt. The service is friendly from the Mum, Dad and Daughter who helps out, its an asset to the area.

Friendly welcome. Their first brunch time opening! Good selection of dishes, all freshly prepared. Pleasantly busy but not overly so. Lovely atmosphere. Clean, bright contemporary decor. Bar area for drinks. Definitely will go back. Eager to try their Caribbean dishes.

Hidden gem. Wonderful food and service.

Excellent reception, service and food as always

Had a meal one Saturday night. Good prices, friendly service, tasty food.

Me and my wife visited plesters last night for the first time we both had the cajun spiced chicken,prawn and chorizo starter and then I had the fish stew my wife had the chicken wrapped in ham in a creamy mushroom sauce everything we had was absolutely delicious,the service and presentation was also fantastic and would highly recommend this little gem of a place and we will definitely be going back very soon.

After walking past Plesters for years, finally took the plunge and visited and was not disappointed. The Black Pudding starter was delicious, the Steak perfectly cooked medium rare and a delicious home made Bakewell Tart. Topped off with a fantastic bottle of Rose. Lovely food, friendly service and a nice atmosphere. Definitely will return to try some of the other dishes. Thank you!

We had a very nice 3 course meal tonight....including a bottle of wine, Well prepared , clean n tidy Restaurant and Good value for Money 💰 Thank You

Had a meal last night the best Mussels I've ever tasted. Fantastic Service and a delight to see the Chef cooking too. I would Highly recommend 👌

Food was lovely service good and it was nice to see your food being cooked.

Nothing too much trouble and excellent food

Have visited numerous times as just on our doorstep but booked in for the Valentines menu this evening. Absolutely fantastic as always, everything cooked to perfection and the service was brilliant. Highly recommended, what an absolute gem.

Please read reviews under restaurant former name Surf and Turf, I wrote it there too as many others. It's excellent and I highly recommend it. The standard of food and service as well cleanliness are more than high.

We visited this restaurant a couple years ago when it was called Surf and Turf. The lovely staff is the same and the high standard of food, cleanliness and service was the same as we remembered it. There is a bit problem with parking as...

We have visited this restaurant a number of times, but I felt the need to add a further review - there is simply nothing I can fault about Plesters. The food is always cooked to perfection, the service is spot on and the atmosphere is...

Excellent food, and great value for money. Comfortable dining and relaxed atmosphere, with great attentive staff.

Absolutely beautiful place little hidden gem we travelled an hour to get here after reading the reviews and did not dissapoint at all beautiful food and service was excellent thankyou to all and how pansy delivered all the food on her own as the restaurant was busy simply wow cannot wait to return 10 out 10

Pansy consistently produces great meals. Am amazing relaxed venue. Love the food, ambience. Try it, you’ll love it too.

Superb food matched by a fabulous atmosphere to boot, if god created anything better he definitely kept it to himself.

Would recommend this place absolutely fantastic service the food is homemade and scrumptious. Jeremy the owner made us feel really welcome.

Very nice little restaurant serving high quality food with great service. The open kitchen shows the confidence of owner chef Pansie. Highly recommended for any party size. Already rebooked! Good location for accessing a few pubs afterwards.

This was our first visit to Plesters, and what struck us was the charm of the restaurant. Beautifully decorated, tables and chairs not crowded on top of each other, but just how lovely and calm the atmosphere was. I had the brie as did one...

Excellent food and first class service resonably priced

I posted the review below on Tripadvisor after our first visit to the wonderful Plesters. Now, after our second visit I feel I must whole heartedly endorse my comments. Everything spot-on from start to finish. You must give this place a try! What a fantastic place! We accidentally happened across Plasters whilst out drinking in the Heeley area of Sheffield. Formally, Surf and Turf it is now known by the family name of Plesters. Table for two and a bottle of house white, (which was on offer and very nice) and we ordered a starter and main each at £19 per person. I had Black Pudding with Quail Egg and dressing and my wife had Caribbean Cod Gougons with dressing. This food was so tasty I had to tell the waiter/owner just how good it was! For mains we had Jerk Salmon and Surf and Turf which were equally amazing, full of flavour and very good value. We shared a desert of Chocolate Cheese Cake and fought over every forkful. Two starters, two mains, one desert and two bottles of wine: £63. It’s a husband and wife business and is very, very well organised, neat, clean and tidy. Can’t wait to go back but we’ve told so many people about it we might not get a table! Booking is advised as opening hours are reduced due to covid restrictions.

Lovely place to eat with a special deal of £19 per person for a starter and a main course with a half price wine list even though the house wine was still £ 10 so not what I would call half price but if your wanting a lovely meal out this is a place you must try the only down side can be the waiting times if busy .

Well run restaurant the food is always good

We accidentally happened across Plesters whilst out drinking in the Heeley area of Sheffield. Formally, Surf and Turf it is now known by the family name of Plesters. Table for two and a bottle of house white, (which was on offer and very nice) and...

Fabulous friendly restaurant. amazing food and service. was great to see food all being cooked from scratch, definately going back

We were gifted a meal during lockdown. Contacted Pansy who honoured the meal to suit us when reopened. We finally got to use it tonight and what a fabulous little place this is. Cosy and welcoming with first class service and the food is superb....

We were met by Jeremy who made us very welcome.The menus were well presented with a variety of choice.I had the fish goujons and then the sirloin surf and turf whilst my wife had the mussels followed by the sea bass. All the courses were...

This was the fourth or fifth time we'd been to Plesters (formerly Surf and Turf). The restaurant was busy but felt quite safe. We were asked to sanitize our hands while we were waiting to be shown to our table. The menu is not extensive but there is something on there to suit everybody. Food is cooked fresh to order and is, as always, delicious. Fabulous place with great staff. We'll continue to return.

Lovely little family buisness, newly decorated, food is always amazing. Great service. We have been to this restaurant a number of times. We love it

Excellent food and attentive staff, very busy due to the excellent food they serve so booking is definitely recommended to avoid disappointment. Can't wait to go back again for some more surf and turf cooked to perfection.

Very good food. My favourite are mussels on white wine. They also have very good specials now... The steaks and lamb are amazing too.

We visited Plesters (formerly Surf and Turf) in Sheffield on 3rd July 2021. It really wasn't a surprise to find that the service, quality of food and atmosphere was as good as it ever was. It is such a pleasure to be able to go...

My wife and I have used our second Groupon voucher today and although the name has changed the same great food and service still exists. We had two different starters and mains and all 4 dishes were excellent. Jeremy and the team make it look so easy. We came early this time and they were all fully up to speed. It's simply a thoroughly nice dining experience. We will be back.

Nice looking restaurant, professional staff, but the food wasnt to our taste as we found the food too oily for us and service was slow.

This is a hidden gem. It is the best place to eat in the area. Food is amazing and all cooked fresh.

Excellent food and brilliant service

Four of us celebrating our wedding anniversaries dined here on Saturday evening. The food was phenomenal and cooked by the owner in her open kitchen. You can have a drink in the well stocked bar prior to being seated. Beautiful reasonably priced house wines. Prices...

Great good excellent service. Visited with friends everyone enjoyed it. Well worth going. Will definitely go again.

Great food in fair prices. Lovely atmosphere!!!

Our first meal out after lockdown and Plesters as it's now called was spectacular! We were a family of 4 adults and although it was hubby's and my first visit, the in-laws have been several times. It's a family run restaurant with a high quality...

Fantastic food & excellent service, would recommend this lovely restaurant 10/10.

This is a real hidden gem. The food is home cooked and fresh and the restaurant is family owned. Please support this great place and a local business.

Simply amazing and having used this restaurant before during lock down/ take away service, I cannot praise the food enough. Tried the dish of the week - RIB EYE STEAK and it was one of the best steaks I have had for sometime being so...

The best restaurant in Sheffield for an amazing dinning experience. The food, staff as well as the atmosphere is second to none. Would recommend to any person who happens to see this review. 10/10

Excellent food and service. Well organized for covid

Good deal through Groupon, starter and main course. No sirloin staek available for 2 of us so they 'upgraded' us to rib-eye, which was quite grissley but cooked ok. We had the extras, mushrooms and peppercorn sauce, knew we had to pay for this but at £4 for each extra, the quantity of the sauce and mushrooms was tiny, wine was expensive...ok we didn't have to have these but what we thought was going to be a cheap-ish night out turned into an expensive one, seems they are taking advantage of groupon by offering a decent 2 course meal but then charging over the top for drinks and extras left that 'ripped off' feeling.

The food was lovely, we really enjoyed the evening. We were shocked at the price and size of the side dishes, a ramekin of 4 mushrooms £4, a small pot of peppercorn sauce £4. The meals are worth the money but the sides are not.

So pleased to be able to visit regularly following the re-opening after covid-19 closures. Has always been a favourite restaurant and the quality remains excellent value. Have visited several times following lockdown and we feel very safe with all the changes made.

Always a warm welcome and absolutely fabulous food

Lovely restaurant with great tasty food. We thoroughly enjoyed it, so nice to get out again. Thank you for a lovely meal, look forward to returning

One of the best steaks I've ever had. Came with my family and we all got steaks, absolutely fabulous. Perfect for an occasion or an evening meal treat.

Excellent food and service. Will definitely be returning

Amazing resturant lovely food and staff, hope to be back soon.

Visited following the re-opening of restaurants. Made to feel welcome on arrival and felt safe in a well organised environment. Good value food, steaks are excellent quality.

It was good to be able return to a favourite restaurant. Whilst fully conforming to the new virus rules ,especially with the hand sanitising packs, there was a warm friendly welcome from Jeremy and Toni and there was a feeling of calm confidence throughout the...

Massive thanks to the guys at Surf and Turf! Went this week for our first outing in months and thoroughly enjoyed our evening. Amazing value, lovely wine and beautiful food. Felt very safe and was a 'normal' welcoming environment. The restaurant is elegant and the...

Delicious food. Portions can be a little underwhelming depending on what you order though and its a little pricey but definately worth a visit.

Amazing place , really good food - steak cool perfectly ....just lovely

Booked last minute for a group of 6, excellent value we had the 2 courses for £18, I believe the restaurant also accepts Groupon vouchers on advance bookings. Highly recommended

Went on a groupon deal for friend's birthday. The standard of the food was exceptional! Proper smoked haddock, not the yellow stuff, and great mussels, all cooked to perfection. My friend had the pancakes which she loved. Too full up for desserts but they looked...

Had a lovely 3 course meal at surf and turf was excellent food amazing thank you

The last time we visited here,it was pretty quiet to say the least,but when we walked through the doors this time..WOW,it was PACKED(even @ 6.30)and we also noticed they,d had a bit of a refurb.We were quickly shown to our table and our drink orders...

Fantastic food and excellent service, a hidden gem of a restaurant

Lovely place, amazing food, friendly staff. Just had a meal at this place and loved all of it, starters, main and desserts plate all empty not a crumb left. Would definitely recommend this place.

Have been to Surf and Turf several times now and have always been meaning to write a review. Visited here as a family of eight and the whole experience was fantastic from start to finish. The whole family thoroughly enjoyed the starters, mains and desserts....

We do not usually go out on Valentine's Day for a meal because it is always very busy and the food can be hit and miss. As we eat at the Surf and Turf most months we have confidence that the food will always be...

A warm welcome, friendly Management and the most wonderful food to boot. We know ourselves just how much work goes in to running a restaurant, and these guys do it between two...and the service and food does not, on any way, suffer. Food as before...

Meal was fantastic the mussels delish, the staff very friendly and professional, definitely will revisit delightful

Whent tonight 2 time and will be back again. Food is amazing service amazing. Place amazing chef amazing gentleman who served us amazing thanks x

Delicious food and very friendly visit. This restaurant is definitely on a high level of freshly cooked delicious food and if you are thinking about going there don’t hesitate, you won’t be disappointed. We are working our way through the menu and returning to our...

This was our second visit and my second review. Absolutely wonderful food in a pleasant environment with lovely staff.

This is our second time at the amazing SURF&TURF and it was even better than the first time& the first time was brilliant in every way!!!!! The food was excellent& the staff were too what more can I say, please visit so you can have a great night in so many ways, thank you SURF&TURF we will be back very soon!!!!!!!!!!

Visited with friends as part of their groupon offer. Enjoyed two great courses with all four of my party opting for the obvious surf and turf option (sirloin steak) for main course. All the food is cooked fresh and in full view of all diners,...

We had a reservation at 8.30 on a Sat night. We had never eaten here before so did'nt really know what to expect but it was def a pleasant surprise. The atmosphere is relaxed and you can see all the food being cooked which means...

Well I suppose there any many words to describe the food here amazing, fantastic, special, etc etc!! Me and my wife whom have travelled to many different countries both said this was the best food we've eaten in years absolutely fant2vant wait to go back...

We visited this restaurant after hearing from others that it was a nice establishment, however we will definitely not be returning, due to the rude and aggressive owners. Our starters to be fair were lovely so was looking forward to our mains, both opted for...

You can tell that Surf and Turf restaurant is a top performing place. It’s always busy so booking well ahead is recommended . And it won’t disappoint . This was another return visit , 2 couples. We ordered different starters all of which were excellent,...

Went here with a group on that was bought for us. Starters were really nice. Unfortunately the mains were poor. Fish stew then steak for me. The y were basically what you could coook quite easily at home. Service was good. A real shame that...