Pizza1889 in Oxford

Ordered pizza today (Saturday 22nd of April 2023) for click & collect. Order accepted, paid. Went to collect and found the pizzeria locked although it is mentioned open on their website. I called and calls go directly to voicemail... I ordered 4 grande pizza to share with friends now all is ruined!! Order Num Z56

Oxford - no cheese and burnt. Ordered a margarita and had to ask for a new garlic mayo because it was all yellow and looked like it had been sitting there for a couple of days. Apparently all the dips look like that - why aren't there fresh dips when you have to pay £1?

In short - Best pizza take away in the area but be careful what you order! We have tried this pizza on several occasions. Although the sauce is very salty, the dough and cheese are really good. They often burn the base and are stingy with the cheese but we like it enough to go back occasionally. The other day I ordered one with rocket, and half of it was inedible. I understand a wilted leaf, but what I got was disgusting. Also, the middle didn't even have any toppings and was just burnt dough. I reported the issue, but never heard back. It was disappointing. We've really enjoyed the ice cream!

Terrible. Buffalo Mozzarella ordered. Got very little Mozzarella and no basil. Very uninspiring. Sent an email to complain and heard nothing back. Wont be going back.

Ordered pizza for click & collect. Order accepted, paid. Came to collect only to find the place locked. Calls go directly to voicemail. EDIT: I got a refund only after writing a negative review here. My email to the address below has been left unanswered.

Great pizza and super friendly staff! No.5 is my favourite on the menu

Great pizza, definitely the best in Cowley and the staff always remember how I like mine done (charred).

Amazing quality of the pizza and customer service. Been here a couple of times after work and always left satisfied with my food.

Great authentic pizza, my new go to pizza place. My favourite is the No.6, always great

Order pizza and garlic bread today - it was uncooked. Not recommended!

Lovely authentic food and good people. Lauren was a great help in showing me the menu and guiding me to a pizza I liked!

Went today, lovely staff and pizza was so yummy and such a good price! Will deffo be going again, even after the gym :)

Great pizza, friendly staff. Really delicious with good vegan options.

Could be great, but on this occasion disappointing. The dough and base tasted fantastic, nice char, great flavour. The pizza sauce had all the signs of a good sauce but fell short due to lack of seasoning. The pizza was very soggy with huge droop, toppings slid off when picking up a slice. The pizza booked for collection 930 arrived 928 and was already ready so shouldn't have been sat around to long The cheese had good flavour could have done with a bit more So much potential but didn't really deliver, certainly not bad, but wouldn't be rushing back either

Amazing good quality pizzas worth the visit will be going again 😁

Friendly, fast and very decent value for money.

Ordered pizza and it was very tasty! Would recommend

Randomly popped in for lunch after Christmas shopping. I had a buffalo mozzarella pizza and a peroni. It was INCREDIBLE, the best pizza I've had outside of Italy and by far far the best I've ever had in Oxford. Staff were super friendly and absolutely gorgeous to and elderly couple who came whilst I was there, helping them up and down the steps. AMAZING! Thank you so much!

Pizza tasted nice but barely any cheese and even less on the cheesy garlic bread which had barely any cheese or garlic. Not worth the money.

Amazing staf, delicious pizza 🍕🍕🍕🍕

great pizza, really lovely staff, enjoy visiting regularly

We had pizza number 6 from the menu. Delicious pizza and great customer service from the two young ladies working in it. I would eat there again :) I`m sorry I didn`t make a photo of the pizza itself, but we`ve been too hungry.

Great authentic pizza, good prices and nice staff

You know it’s good pizza when a simple margherita is 10/10! Delicious, authentic dough base, and great dips (especially the honey chilli) to go with. Highest recommendation and great addition to south Oxford.

Can't comment on the normal pizzas but the vegan pizza was not nice. The base was fine, but the cheese had the texture and appearance of globules of slime.

The Margherita 1889, extra toppings and a garlic Mayo dip?! Would highly recommend. The pizza was amazing, and better than the other oily choices. 10/10, will definitely be ordering again!

My son ordered pizza for a family treat and we were very disappointed. Order no Z82 consisted of a margarita which 1/4 of the base was so burnt it was carcinogenic and inedible and the second pizza of spicy salami which contained very little salami. Very poor quality and value for money.

Lauren and Amber made the nicest pizza I’ve ever had felt like Napoli all over again, great service would recommend.

Had the No. 3 Goats Cheese made by Lauren! Very authentic and better than other options, would recommend. Definitely coming again.

Great stonebaked pizza, the dough is soft n so good when it was eaten hot. Friendly staff. Vegan n vegetarian pizzas are available.

Lovely place, yummy pizza !! :)

We discovered this place recently and we love it! The staff is very amicable and fast, the pizzas taste amazing and the prices are reasonable. Strongly recommend!

Wouldn’t listen to poor reviews - not the worlds best pizza but really very yummy and great for the area. Refreshing to have something like this available. I would definitely get again!

I love this new pizza 1889 ,the pizza so nice, fresh and the guys are so friendly. I am definitely coming back !.xxooX

Great pizza. Great service. Friendly people working here. Would definitely come back!

Super friendly staff and tasty pizzas. Would recommend

Lovely pizza and staff. Would definitely recommend.

very good- doesn't deserve bad reviews so I tried out this place, and got a small margarita pizza and it was actually very good! yes, it did have a bit too much tomato paste, but that was okay as it tasted great. will be coming back!

We were excited to try the new Pizza 🍕 place we had pizzas, but unfortunately, we're Incredibly salty that we had a couple of small bites, but we couldn't have any more 😦😦😦

A nice little pizza take-out with a few tables to eat in, operating out of a nicely painted shipping container in Templars Retail Park. Including some picnic tables out on an astroturf lawn, which is nice. The pizzas are stone-baked, Neopolitan type, and have a nice range of Italian/Italian-ish toppings. They also have a nice range of dips. Prices are, if I am remembering right, £9-12 for full size (enough for one reasonably hungry person) or £5.50-7.50 for small (kids-size, basically) ones. We really enjoyed the pizzas, and it is also nice to have something a little bit fancier than the usual Costa-and-Asda-cafe to get lunch when shopping in the retail park. Possible risk of bias on this review, as we.went on opening weekend when everything was 50% off, so maybe if we were paying full price we would feel differently.