GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4,3

Based on 5.601 opinions finded in 3 websites

4.3Ambience4.8Cuisine4.3Price4.3Service
site_photo4

comment_iconOpinions

Stopped in here for a drink after wandering around the Royal Mile. I'm not a huge cocktail drinker but do enjoy a Manhattan which was fine but definitely a fan of the 'Under the Hat'. Excellent cocktail!! Ordered a cold meat platter as well which was ok & staff were very helpful & accommodating.

site_logo

SpencerHorne . 2024-04-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Stopped for drinks on our way up to the royal mile. Cosy bar warm and welcoming. Nice range of IPAs. Seating area outside with blankets and overhead heaters.

site_logo

Paul C . 2024-04-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The most delicious food, beautifully cooked and amazing flavours. Absolutely stunning. Service was 5*. Choose to sit outside under a heat lamp, super cosy. Blankets also provided to keep us warm. Would highly recommend.

site_logo

Sarah K . 2024-04-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We intended to have drinks, stayed for food on the terrace under cover and with a heat lamp. Great food and atmosphere, really friendly and accommodating staff. I love the way allergies are managed with list of all for each item on the menu which makes it so much easier to order without feeling as though you are causing an issue . Went with 3 friends, We all had something different, all enjoyed our meal immensely.

site_logo

suzanne s . 2024-04-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Such a wonderful find in the heart of Edinburgh! This charming pub nestled in one of the city's characteristic closes, the Advocate's Close, offers a delightful experience. The food is excellent, with a wide selection to please any palate, and the staff is incredibly friendly and attentive. A perfect spot to immerse yourself in Edinburgh's historic ambiance while enjoying top-notch hospitality.

site_logo

DaisyDuck44 . 2024-04-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I seemed to pick every Whisky that they had ran out of. Great choice regardless of this with good service and atmosphere.

site_logo

Keith Muirhead . 2024-04-12

MORE AT Google

Nasty waitress. Apparently very angry they took us to her table.. no hello, didn’t ask for drink order.. ‘are you ready to order’ ? Made sure we understood we were not welcome.

site_logo

Deborah Hoffman . 2024-04-12

MORE AT Google

Stopped for a glass of wine. Bit cheeky to auto add 10% service charge when I was seated next to the toilets! WiFi works though.

site_logo

Kara Newman . 2024-04-12

MORE AT Google

Overrated for what it is and they look down on you if you dare to walk in for a drink without a booking 👎

site_logo

Christiana . 2024-04-11

MORE AT Google

Fantastic restaurant. For the last night out of our holiday, great atmosphere and location. The menu choice and selection of wines is very good. I will absolutely go back the next time I visit Edinburgh.

site_logo

Richard Booth . 2024-04-09

MORE AT Google

Big disappointment :-( The service was pulling us by the nose... After 30 minutes, when I went to ask if they had our order, I was told that they didn't have whiskey anymore... I don't understand why they made us wait so long... Never again - definitely go somewhere where the staff has time for you. I don't understand why the bar has such high references.. We're flying home at night, so I'm looking forward to drinking Scotch whiskey in Prague if they don't serve me in Scotland :-)))

site_logo

Tomáš Kvapilík . 2024-04-09

MORE AT Google

We stopped in here for a drink ( we had pre booked a table beforehand to make sure we got one). Our table was outside under a canopy. Luckily, although windy, the external patio heater at the table was burning away constantly (keep pushing the button), and by keeping our coats on, we were all able to keep warm in the April sunshine. The cushions on the bench were a bit damp as we found out when we left (damp trousers). Maybe it would be better to take the cushions inside at night to dry them off. We ordered our drinks, which came out a while later. The server did apologise for the delay as they were quite busy. Unfortunately, the cocktails that we had ordered tasted terrible. Let's just say the description on the menu wasn't what came to the table. Tasteless, apart from the long island ice tea and the expresso martini. The latte was small, full of foam, and tasted bitter the one shot americano was very strong and bitter. The servers were polite and a good laugh. Our bill had extra items added to it, to the value of £30! However, after we pointed it out to the servers, they immediately rectified it. Can't comment on the food as we were drinking only.

site_logo

Berglas71 . 2024-04-08

MORE AT Google

The service was zero. I came alone and they made me sit at a table at the entrance. They said they would bring the menu, I waited for half an hour. It's not worth it, there are more enjoyable places

site_logo

Dom TRk . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

Such an amazing restaurant! It was recommended by a colleague, and we visited for lunch during our time in Edinburgh. Make sure you book in advance as it can get quite busy. You can reach this hidden gem from High Street by the Advocates Close, a narrow historical alley. It feels like you're going for an adventure. And it was such a culinary adventure- the food, atmosphere and service were simply fantastic! Service was welcoming and friendly. They have a huge whiskey selection and wines as well. The food was incredible! We started with a small smoked fish sharing platter and the soup of the day. The soup was packed with flavour! My main was their beef burger, and although I'm not a big fan of beef, this burger tasted amazing! The beef patty was juicy, and the fries were nice and crispy.  My partner really enjoyed the fish and chips. The fish was delicious, sauce was tasty, and the chips were so crispy. I would highly recommend this restaurant and will definitely come back on my next visit to Edinburgh!

site_logo

Rosi Petkova . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

I saw this place as I was walking down the stairs from the castle to Princes Street, and it looked such a great place for a drink I had to go in there, it had a brilliant atmosphere and very friendly staff, it also had a good range of beers , wines and spirits, although we didn't eat here the food looked good too, you have to give this place a try

site_logo

Gary Schiavi . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

We ended up spending very late hours of the evening on a weeknight here and it was still busy which speaks for itself. The bartender are very knowledgeable of the 300+ whiskies they have there and we got recommended exactly the type we were after. We also tried a cocktail and it was good too, unique blend and cool presentation. Unfortunately, we didn’t have enough time to try some food but it looked lovely.

site_logo

Rhea Makhija . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

Worst dining experience in Edinburgh. Slow service, OK food, but we were enjoying ourselves nontheless. Then we were REPEATEDLY told we needed to leave the table by the manager, less then 2 hours after our reservation, had not even recieved our desert yet, or a bill. It was so uncomfortable and awkward, even our waitress seemed apologetic. We felt very unwelcomed. It should not be a customer's fault if the kitchen and waitstaff cannot keep up with the number of bookings. We will never go back.

site_logo

Paul M . 2024-04-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We always enjoy our visits to The Devil's Advocate when we're in Edinburgh. We tried the pork chop, new to the menu, this time and it was absolutely delicious. Great service, and really good beer. Thank you.

site_logo

Richard Lowe . 2024-04-04

MORE AT Google

This was a fun place. The ambience is lively to say the least and the food was very yummy. Will go back!

site_logo

Dayton Scott . 2024-04-03

MORE AT Google

Great service and fantastic food.

site_logo

Steve and Lenore Ale . 2024-04-03

MORE AT Google

Idk what’s the deal with this place, the wanted me to wait outside because the food wasn’t available yet, why when we could wait in the bar like we did but these gentleman really knows how to ignore people

site_logo

Matias Marton . 2024-04-02

MORE AT Google

New menu which was very good, I had the pork chop. It was tasty and HUGE

site_logo

Andy . 2024-04-01

MORE AT Google

Awesome restaurant with incredible drink selections. Food was fantastic and the staff was extremely friendly and courteous. Highly recommend this place to anyone

site_logo

Reid Stewart . 2024-04-01

MORE AT Google

Fantastic service and atmosphere. Had a scottish haddock - large portions and very tasty!

site_logo

Rene . 2024-04-01

MORE AT Google

Went there for dinner & whiskey tasting -Portions were not too big but tasty -Food arrived very late (in an hour) -Whiskey tasting and Old Fashioned cocktails were good I recommend this place for drinks but not for food

site_logo

Ir Yu . 2024-04-01

MORE AT Google

Exploring whisky here is an exceptional experience, complemented by a fantastic atmosphere.

site_logo

Luka S. . 2024-03-31

MORE AT Google

Great service, drink selection, ambience and music. Just needs another small bar table or two even if standing only.

site_logo

Steven Shorrock . 2024-03-31

MORE AT Google

Came for drinks on a Wednesday. No smile when greeted. Told space at the bar only. There was a free 2 seater booth with a laptop at it. I asked to sit there, was told it was taken. Ordered margaritas- they were delicious. Seat at the bar - occupied by a staff member discussing menu not offered to patrons. Went to the loo. Saw it was a company laptop (had el cartel, DA, lady libertine etc stickers on) Asked again if we could sit there. Bar man said he’d check, he never came back to me. The laptop sat there the whole time we were there with no one at the table. We’d have stayed for more drinks had there been a better atmosphere. Not a good vibe. Disappointing. Went to lady libertine instead. Staff were wonderful, atmosphere was great. Drinks and bar snacks delicious.

site_logo

Susie . 2024-03-30

MORE AT Google

Cool place. BUT Staff was really unfriendly at the beginning. Would not go there again.

site_logo

Christoph M. . 2024-03-29

MORE AT Google

Lovely and cozy restaurant with top notch food and service

site_logo

Melanie Campos-Heffernan . 2024-03-28

MORE AT Google

Food was amazing. Sharing platter very generous and the main course venison was delicious. However the service was poor. Aperitifs came with the main course. The bottle of wine didn’t arrive until staff were reminded. Staff were kind and polite but very distracted on their phones so this slowed things down which is why the 3 stars. The food is five star.

site_logo

TEllieG . 2024-03-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Oh my what a wonderful new menu! My lady and I had the best time and the most wonderful food. A jem in edinburgh. Will be back.

site_logo

smiling pilgrims . 2024-03-26

MORE AT Google

I had a fantastic experience and rate this as one of the best restaurants I visited in the few days of Edinburgh. The restaurant is down a close and its seclusion made it a very cool place to get to. The service was good. They had a huge whiskey selection and prearranged flights. We tried one but this drink isn’t our favorite anywhere. Their service and knowledge of it was incredible and I trust this place if someone is looking for that scotch experience. The food was incredible. Truly incredible. The venison steak was my highlight for the evening. It was so flavorful and tender, plated beautifully, and matched with the right extras to bring out all the balanced flavors. The haggis was also delicious, only heightened by the red berry compote and arugula. Together, all the elements of the dish made it a superb dish. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who loves good food.

site_logo

Andy Wertz . 2024-03-26

MORE AT Google

Food was good but the service mediocre. Several reminders and appetitive served with main course. Not great at all and should have someone should be in charge to control the waiting staff

site_logo

guddet . 2024-03-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

All 9 of us had a delicious meal I had a venison haunch stag party from Wales excellent service.

site_logo

Mark Casey . 2024-03-25

MORE AT Google

Amazing food and whisky choice, my only criticism would be that it took too long to clear the table once we had finished eating.

site_logo

Michael Deakin . 2024-03-25

MORE AT Google

This place in Edinburgh's Old Town is wicked awesome! The Devil's Advocate isn't just some fancy restaurant - it's got a cool vibe and yummy food. We tried a few dishes, and everything tasted fresh and delicious. Plus, their whisky collection is great! The staff were super friendly, too. Whether you're grabbing drinks with friends or going for a date night, The Devil's Advocate is the perfect spot.

site_logo

Luke Sessions . 2024-03-24

MORE AT Google

Wonderful food and great atmosphere. Excellent

site_logo

Sharon Inch . 2024-03-22

MORE AT Google

First time in Edinburgh and Devils Advocate came highly recommended. The food and drinks and the atmosphere were excellent but the business was let down by our server. She was a young American girl I think, her attitude was horrible. I thought I was in Karen's Diner at one stage. Luckily one of her colleagues had an idea we weren't happy and she took over and we had a great experience. She definitely needs retraining and an attitude adjustment.

site_logo

Alan D . 2024-03-20

MORE AT Google

Very friendly staff. Food was excellent. Nice variety of local beers on tap.

site_logo

Michael O'Sullivan . 2024-03-20

MORE AT Google

Intimate atmosphere, excellent food and friendly staff. Absolutely recommended.

site_logo

Marianna Di fusco . 2024-03-20

MORE AT Google

Beautiful and very characteristic place. Great food and fantastic drink.

site_logo

6th Floor Recording Studio . 2024-03-19

MORE AT Google

Very nice and welcoming place, with soft lights that create an intimate and relaxing atmosphere. Excellent food: I tried the venison and it was truly delicious, I highly recommend it! Booking is recommended, especially on weekends, as the place is often full. The staff is kind and helpful, always ready to satisfy every request.

site_logo

Filippo Corti . 2024-03-17

MORE AT Google

Fantastic dining experience! Super sweet service. We were allowed to taste the different wines as we couldn't decide which one we wanted. My husband had chicken and it tasted great. I got lamb on garlic puree and Israeli cous-cous (with tomato) and a boiled red wine sauce. It was simply so delicious. Since it's also a bar on the ground floor, it's a bit noisy, but it's only happy people.

site_logo

Tania Martina . 2024-03-16

MORE AT Google

Restaurant/pub with a beautiful internal area for enjoying a drink and an internal and external upper part for eating. A menu that is not extremely broad but with very well-made typical things. Abundant and tasty dishes. Quick and kind service. (I was surprised that we asked each other first if we had any allergies)

site_logo

Simone Criscuolo . 2024-03-16

MORE AT Google

My brother and I, on a spontaneous quest for an exceptional cocktail bar, were lured into the arms of Devil’s Advocate in Edinburgh, a decision swayed by its high praise and the allure of discovery. Nestled down a charming alleyway, this bar instantly charmed us with its air of secrecy and exclusivity, making our visit feel like a delightful uncovering of a hidden gem. Upon entry, what was intended to be a brief visit quickly unfolded into an evening of indulgence. Our initial plan to savor just one cocktail each was swept away by the enchanting menu of scotch-based concoctions. We found ourselves embarking on a flavorful journey, sampling around five cocktails each, in a bid to crown our favorite. The selection was not just vast but captivating, offering a deep dive into Scotland's famed spirit. While the ambiance beckoned us to linger longer, the seating arrangement at a high-top table, perched on stools, made the prospect of dining less appealing due to the lack of comfort for extended periods. This minor inconvenience, however, did not dim the glow of our overall experience. A highlight of our visit was undoubtedly the staff, whose warmth and professionalism shone brightly. They navigated our adventurous sampling with expertise and enthusiasm, ensuring each cocktail recommendation was a hit and contributing significantly to our memorable night. Although we did not explore the food menu, our experience at Devil’s Advocate was nothing short of spectacular, defined by exceptional drinks, exemplary service, and the thrill of discovering a hidden treasure in the heart of Edinburgh. It’s a must-visit for cocktail enthusiasts and those in search of a special night out.

site_logo

Nick Chislett . 2024-03-14

MORE AT Google

It's a sweet restaurant in a side street, we ate smoked fish small shared plate and chimichurri potatoes for dinner, it was delicious and enough for 2 people. The wines were nice, the staff was friendly. A place to come again.

site_logo

Asude Uzdu . 2024-03-12

MORE AT Google

We had smoked fish. It was delicious. Atmosphere was great. The only negative thing was music playing. Reggae music doesn’t fit that atmosphere. I would play chill out etc…

site_logo

Ismail Bozkaya . 2024-03-11

MORE AT Google

What a hidden gem! Wonderful selection of drinks and great food! Great service and decor was so cool! A must stop when you are in the city! Buger was to die for!!! Cant wait to visit again!

site_logo

Megan Robertson . 2024-03-10

MORE AT Google

Expensive for miniscule cocktails. Lovely building though

site_logo

pat jackson . 2024-03-08

MORE AT Google

They ruined our evening and our visitors evening ! Rude manager, non-trained staff ! I have been there several times I have seen kids 7-10 years old .... We arrived with our 2 friends they were visiting Edinburgh for first time and thought to take them somewhere nice after we had a dinner somewhere else. I am 60 and my son is 18 in 2 months. The girl at the shop said we couldn't be at the bar as we had the minor with us . I explained that I am his mother and we wouldn't anyway have alcohol for him .She found a space for us upstairs and outside a nice area with heaters. 15 min later another girl comes with menus. We explained we had dinner already and we only came for a drink. 10min later another girl comes for the order... adults ordered drinks and for my son we ordered an non alcoholic beer. The girl didn't bother to mention anything about ID or that my son couldn't have a non alcoholic beer. 10 min later 2 drinks and the non alcoholic beer are on the table one drink is missing. 10 min later the first girl from the door that found us the table comes with the last drink and she takes away the non alcoholic beer , saying that it is no possible for him to have that drink (??) he can only have a soft drink ... I am already annoyed with all the delays and all these people coming and going without to know what they were saying.... We order a lemonade for my son. When the lemonade arrives ,the girl says that they have another policy (so far only them know their policies but they do not mention to us from the beginning !!) that we should have some food on the table as we had a minor with us !!!!!!!! (A new way of upselling ??) I am furious by then and ready to go .... my friend asks for the manager... the manager comes.... No apologies for his staff that didn't know what they were doing and saying... he says they have this policy that with a minor we must have food on the table (??) or we couldn't be there ... Our drinks are there as we had no time with all this people and talking to have our drinks... my friend says that we already explained that we had dinner elsewhere and she is not going to pay for a drink that she didn't have... the manager says we cannot be on the site !!!! We left ... I work 26 years in hospitality , I travelled many countries .... I never had a worst experience. They ruined our night, they don't know what they are doing , they do not respect the customers and they do not apologise for their absence of training !

site_logo

ΜΑΜΑ mamamia . 2024-03-08

MORE AT Google

Left: fresa fresca Right: B3 The staff is a bit in a hurry, but the service for drinks is quick. Upstairs: dinner is inside, drinks are outside.

site_logo

Ky . 2024-03-08

MORE AT Google

We were charged over £13 for two half lagers. We were gobsmacked 😕

site_logo

Helen Butler . 2024-03-04

MORE AT Google

A lovely wee pub. We had one drink and had a seat but had to give up when we went to the bar for another round. Customers were standing up around the bar drinking and my husband gave up after 10 minutes waiting as no one was moving to enable him to get anywhere near the bar to get served. We ended up leaving which was a pity as it had a nice wee atmosphere.

site_logo

Margaret Henry . 2024-03-03

MORE AT Google

Called in for a drink on the way to our hotel looks fab will call for food on our next visit.

site_logo

Graham . 2024-02-29

MORE AT Google

What an amazing place, we had the most delicious cocktail because we were a bit early. Food and service was great! Totally a must to visit when in Edinburgh ❤️

site_logo

Esther van Anrooij . 2024-02-29

MORE AT Google

Good dishes well served, a very nice atmosphere and decoration!

site_logo

Mickaël Hamard . 2024-02-28

MORE AT Google

Pork belly awesome and pesto mushrooms fettuccine WOW. But that coaktail Under the hat, would of drank 5 of them.

site_logo

Pedro L. Barroso jr. . 2024-02-28

MORE AT Google

Very nice atmosphere with helpful staff. As for the food, good but very expensive. It is not possible for a 230g steak to be charged at £32.

site_logo

Giorgos . 2024-02-27

MORE AT Google

We had a great time! The drinks are amazing and very reasonably priced. Our service was great. He made some excellent suggestions for drinks. The place was busy on a Saturday night but we were able to get a table upstairs. All in all, it was a lot of fun. The only bad parts are the steps to get there but get, that's just part of the experience! Well worth it for the craft cocktails and extensive liquor menu.

site_logo

Tricia Alletzhauser . 2024-02-25

MORE AT Google

Excellent food, served by very friendly, attentive and knowledgeable staff. If you like comfortable rustic this is the place to go.

site_logo

Cnoc 500 . 2024-02-22

MORE AT Google

Modern and fun location. Beer was good, benches not too comfy for a long stay. Staff were friendly and they had good music.

site_logo

cristifrancoe . 2024-02-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The food was nice, the service was ok, but we had to wait so long for our main course after we had our starters and our drinks. It was very loud and difficult to have a conversation, sorry to say that we wouldn't return.

site_logo

hollydog1 . 2024-02-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I was recommended the Devils advocate by a work colleague and it did not disappoint. The food was excellent as was the extensive drinks menu. Staff were very friendly but a big shout out to Declan, who in my opinion, went the extra mile for us. Incredibly knowledgeable and extremely attentive which added to a great night. 5 out of 5. Definitely will be going back

site_logo

Nickichick05 . 2024-02-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We didn't eat here. We just had some drinks, although the food did look good. Lovely place, nice and cozy. Great selection of drinks.

site_logo

Louise Sparrow . 2024-02-18

MORE AT Google

The bar itself is really nice. It’s just located up some steep steps on Advocates Lane. When we entered it was busy so we remained standing with our drinks. After a while we noticed some people leaving from up stairs. I decided to walk upstairs to check if a table was free. No longer than 10 seconds and I was being chased and then interrogated on why I was up there by one of their staff. The little blonde man said “Can I help you? You must ask me for a table before you sit down” and on that note, I was ushered back down stairs. Finally found a table downstairs after a couple left which was ideal. Within 5 mins , the same guy was back berating us for bringing in some chocolate treats which hadn’t been opened.(they were just on the table rather than storing them on the floor). This same guy also took a bottle of water off another couple even though they’d bought drinks at the venue. I mean, you go to a pub to relax and drink and within 15 minutes, we’d been told off twice by the guy who was running the door entrance by the computer. This chap is in the wrong trade unfortunately. We’ve done this pub now and from first impressions, have no reason to return. Cheers ! One love .

site_logo

Andrew T . 2024-02-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We came here two years ago and absolutely loved it, so much so that we wanted to visit again on our return visit to Edinburgh this month. This time it was such a disappointment. The starter was nice but the main courses really did not reflect the expensive price tag. Both mains we ordered were quite underwhelming. I ordered the hake (£23) it does not come with a side and as you can see from the picture all you get is a mid-sized piece of fish with some sauce, 2 cherry tomatoes and a few stems of broccoli. (I had eaten a small mouthful of the fish and half a tomato before I decided to take this picture!) unfortunately we didn’t get a picture of my partner’s main but again, we felt it overpriced. This was our experience and our opinion but each to their own!

site_logo

JbirdTN12 . 2024-02-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great fun had enjoying the Scottish Road Trip whisky flight, along with some much appreciated Whisky education from Bar Manager, Ross. He really helped me to zero in on the flavours I enjoyed most from the many whiskies. Highly recommend.

site_logo

Peter Lanfear . 2024-02-13

MORE AT Google

What a fantastic accident! Partner and I were wondering around Edinburgh while on holiday and discovered this wonderful little space. Good drinks, knowledgeable staff, and fantastic food. Gave an incredible first impression for Haggis! Undeniably on the pricier side but so damn worth it!

site_logo

FireWarrior2013 . 2024-02-12

MORE AT Google

I booked a meal for my husband's birthday, when we arrived I was surprised by how loud the music was downstairs. I guessed it would be less so in the dining part but I was wrong, as it is open plan it was so loud that we could not talk whilst we were having our meal. The food was good and tasty, the portion sizes were great. My smoked paprika & garlic picanha steak was cooked to perfection and the truffle and parmesan chips were tasty. Hubby had the vegetarian option red lentil ragu aubergine, feta, herbs, toasted focaccia which he enjoyed. The service was attentive and efficient. We were going to stay and sample the whiskey flight and some cocktails but we ate up and left. Overall disappointing as the music was way too loud, it spoiled the occasion.

site_logo

Joolsybabe . 2024-02-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Loved this place. So trendy and cute and the food was great. Really good service, and just all around a great vibe. Highly recommend!!

site_logo

Cassie L . 2024-02-11

MORE AT Google

We ate in silence. SILENCE. The food was that incredible and delicious. We had the Steak and the Hake and garlic chips and oh my gosh. Personally this was the best dinner I've ever eaten, we have not stopped talking about this meal since Friday night. When we come to Edinburgh again this will be our first stop

site_logo

Danielle Shaw . 2024-02-11

MORE AT Google

Our servers were so nice and helpful and were able to give us great recommendations for food and wine!! The food was really nice and the atmosphere was amazing!

site_logo

Sarah Cudd . 2024-02-06

MORE AT Google

Stunning! Perfecting hosting and service, we had pork belly starter, smoked fish sharing platter and bread&butter pudding, with cocktails and Prosecco. All of it was absolutely gorgeous and worth every penny! Probably the BEST fish dish we've ever had, the cooked salmon was just perfect... we didn't stop talking about it for the rest of the evening! Couldn't fault a single thing, decor, service, food and atmosphere was so delightful even on a Tuesday night! Absolutely would recommend to a friend and won't be hesitating to visit on our next trip!

site_logo

Nisha Arum . 2024-02-06

MORE AT Google

Beautiful place, unfortunately had to sit outside as they were full however this was our decision and the outdoor heaters were enough to keep us toasty - drinks were lovely, maybe a little on the expensive side - my drink corpse Reviver #2 (the white/yellowy drink shown on images) being £9.50 (only reason for mark down as I'm a broke b×tch) Waiters/Waitresses were lovely, friendly, couldn't have asked for better

site_logo

Hayley . 2024-02-06

MORE AT Google

Fantastic hidden treasure! Amazing food and drinks menu served by friendly and knowledgeable staff who couldn’t do enough to help. An absolute gem of a place and we will be recommending to others who visit Edinburgh!

site_logo

Hannah Coupe . 2024-02-04

MORE AT Google

Went in here for a drink. Good choice of beers, and a great selection of whiskys. Friendly staff, relaxed atmosphere - if only I lived closer (in the same country at least) it would be a regular.....

site_logo

Simon Brooks . 2024-02-03

MORE AT Google

Can't comment on food as we only had drinks and very good they were too!

site_logo

E R . 2024-02-02

MORE AT Google

On a trip from America. Absolutely fantastic place. They do a great job of walking you through all the types of whiskey and they offer over 300! I ordered a flight of whiskeys from all over Scotland, called the Scotland road trip, and they were each delicious and awesome. The wife ordered a couple different cocktails and loved those too. Wish we were here longer because I'd come back every night!

site_logo

Luke Neilson . 2024-01-30

MORE AT Google

Staff where amazing, knowledgeable in food and alcohol fanatic knowledge in whiskey. My husband loved this as he is a big whiskey drinker. Food was amazing. We had pork belly to start. My h7sband had the venison, I had the hake. The venison was sooo good I ordered a 2nd plate of venison. Yes I ate 2 mains (please don't judge) 😋 highly recommend folks. 👌👌👌

site_logo

Lisa Kenna . 2024-01-30

MORE AT Google

The food was amazing. Starters are very big. Drinks are well prepared. Service is great.

site_logo

Ebru Tuay . 2024-01-29

MORE AT Google

Visited The Devils Advocate on a Birthday trip to Edinburgh with my partner and we both thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Great staff, friendly and very knowledgeable about Whiskey. Would highly recommend and when we return to Edinburgh once more, we will definitely visiting again. Thanks.

site_logo

Scotty Fury . 2024-01-29

MORE AT Google

Food was good however, it took ages to arrive. Small menu and comparable to an ‘elevated’ pub. The first waiter took my order and at the end of taking everyone’s order proceeds to tell me my dish isn’t available?? Could’ve told me that from the get-go. The staff were very unpleasant from the moment we got to the restaurant up until we left. The American waitress was rude. Apparently this hasn’t changed since August last year. We met a girl at the mall on the same day who said she had the same experience back then. Funnily enough, I’ve seen more smiles from strangers in London than this place. Save your money, not worth the lack of customer service.

site_logo

MOSO Agency . 2024-01-29

MORE AT Google

Beautiful restaurant in Edinburgh with attentive service and great ambiance. They also have a great whiskey selection.

site_logo

Pierre Rainville . 2024-01-27

MORE AT Google

Horrible staff attitude!!!! They all look and behave and talk so uninterested and was acting plainly miserable. All 3 were chatting away most of the time while we waited and waited to get drinks initially. Then we were told burgers have all sold out but 2 tables next to ours got their burgers after us. We asked for a bag for our take aways and server was quite rude and dismissive to tell us they didn't have any. Have gone here many times before but will never go back again. Food is good but service and the wait, half hour for food was just not worth the money spent.

site_logo

cristina currie . 2024-01-26

MORE AT Google

I almost don’t want to leave a review for this amazing little bar because it feels like a hidden secret! However, do yourself a favour and check it out - it’s a great little bar tucked away on Advocates Close off the Royal Mile. The staff are super friendly and it has a great atmosphere if you just want to pop in for a drink or eat one of their delicious meals.

site_logo

Liza Shaw . 2024-01-25

MORE AT Google

Great whisky / cocktail bar with very knowledgable staff. Welcoming and friendly to newcomers to the city and excellent cocktails on offer. Left feeling warm inside.

site_logo

Ellery H . 2024-01-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Booked for 12.00 yesterday having the Jan set menu and arrived at 11.53 and was told by the guy behind the bar who was lounging & talking to 2 young ladies that the place wasn't open yet so I couldn't come in. Not a great 1st impression as the rain and remnants of storm Isha were still blowing outside. At 1200 after saying we had a booking for 3 people he showed us upstairs to a table for 2! Told him again that there were 3 of us and he pointed to another which we quietly changed as it wasn't great (despite no one else there) when he went back downstairs. The set menu was good, I had soup of the day, friends had chickpea samosa to start and we all had the mushroom pesto linguine which we enjoyed. We had teas/coffee to finish and enjoyed our food and the service from the young American girl upstairs. The same guy from downstairs barged in the front door as we were leaving and my friend commented that older ladies like us were invisible to him but if you're going to include service as you did, then he could take some lessons from the young American lady upstairs.

site_logo

Kat Burnside . 2024-01-23

MORE AT Google

We have been in a few times for drinks and always had a lovely experience so we decided to go for dinner with some friends the other day. On arrival we were told to wait at the bar which was fine and having not seen...

site_logo

GrandTour63830951346 . 2024-01-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We went previously about 2 years ago and no doubt about it loved it. This time however the music was far too loud and sounded more like I was in a nightclub than enjoying a nice dinner. Steak was good no doubt about it and...

site_logo

909kirstyh . 2024-01-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Been here a few times now and every time it’s been amazing. This time we visited with family as a group of 5 on a busy Friday night and everyone loved it. This place has the best atmosphere, food is amazing and service is 10/10....

site_logo

cmallaf . 2024-01-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great experience. Standout haggis with fruit compote .

site_logo

d r . 2024-01-21

MORE AT Google

I really enjoyed the food, the drink and the atmosphere. Service was excellent and the staff were very knowledgeable and professional. 5 stars!

site_logo

Anthony Carruthers . 2024-01-21

MORE AT Google

Edinburgh is full of mediocre, and edging towards expensive restaurants. This for me epitomises that genre. Nothing special, tables small, tables too close together, mains expensive and nothing memorable. I wont be back.

site_logo

Ian H . 2024-01-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great place to take wife on a date. Very nice cocktails and food. Book in advance, was there on a Wednesday night and they had to turn people away.

site_logo

Scott Knight . 2024-01-20

MORE AT Google

Excellent good value meal yesterday. The pork belly with fennel starter was absolutely to notch.

site_logo

Alasdair Loudon . 2024-01-19

MORE AT Google

Highly recommend! Great drinks, food and atmosphere

site_logo

Paige Russell . 2024-01-15

MORE AT Google

Visited this venue a bunch of times for both food and drinks and never left disappointed. Food is always fresh and made to order and the selection of whisky is incredible. The last time I’ve been to Devil’s Advocate I had a picanha steak and...

site_logo

melethronedinburgh . 2024-01-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Really friendly and efficient staff (especially Amy who was our waitress), fabulous food and great atmosphere. Particularly enjoyed the hake which was melt in the mouth. Loved it

site_logo

Vicxx143 . 2024-01-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

First thought, beautiful restaurant down a famous and fantastic location. When we arrived, our table wasn’t quite ready, so we sat at the bar and had a lovely old fashioned each. We were then sat upstairs, at a great table, and recieved lovely service from...

site_logo

Curiosity64356008404 . 2024-01-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian