Based on 457 opinions finded in 2 websites
Based on 457 opinions finded in 2 websites
Opinions
Really nice place. The food is great and the staff are really welcoming and friendly. Great experience.
stuart paton . 2024-11-03
MORE AT Google
Collection - Great food, friendly staff and really great prices
Emily Carwood . 2024-10-26
MORE AT Google
Please read on after the opening remarks.Probably the best take away curry I've ever had. Really delighted and I got poppadums and pickles included for free. Delicious. I can't wait to take my friend there; it has modern design restaurant and friendly staff. Top marks! Have visited since and was less impressed as my Korma was ridiculously sweet and horrid. It shouldn't be like that at all. (There's a warning that it's sweet). I was only able to eat the meat and left very disappointed.
Martin Carpenter . 2024-10-22
MORE AT Google
Fantastic food and really well priced, a nice chilled environment great for a family meal.
Sinner85 . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Wonderful service and good food. Staff were ready to help even down to informing us they only did soft drinks and told us we could purchase drinks from next door and bring them in
Lesley Whitehouse . 2024-10-19
MORE AT Google
Awesome food, atmosphere & people... Can't go wrong here & the Rezalla is amazing! 🤤
Matt Brindley . 2024-10-19
MORE AT Google
Never got to dine. So over booked queue out the door. No apology no nothing. Booked table for 7.30 Saturday. All tables full and waiting for their food. Disgraceful .
Matthew Brooks . 2024-10-12
MORE AT Google
We had a fabulous night here for my grandsons birthday. It was packed but that did not stop the great service we recieved. The food was fabulous, hot, arrived fairly quickly considering how busy they were and was one of the best curry's I've had in a long time. Highly recommend delebans
joy f . 2024-10-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Just had a takeaway. One of our meals went in the bin. Chicken was over cooked. Couldn’t eat it. Which is a shame.
Karen Brewster . 2024-09-28
MORE AT Google
We had a fantastic time here last week. It was a very large group of us and the food/service was outstanding! Would certainly recommend to visit. Great hosts and venue, we will be returning!
Aaron Nobbs . 2024-09-17
MORE AT Google
Rocked up as a group of 50 after a show and Islam pulled out all the stops. Great food, great atmosphere, stellar job!
Ashley Pearson . 2024-09-15
MORE AT Google
Fantastic food, great service and a beautiful restaurant! Definitely recommend!
osva milasius . 2024-09-15
MORE AT Google
Was part of a large group of Electricians on a Social event was made to feel very welcome Cracking food and a very nice vibe , Will be going again, Also really good service Murray
Murray M . 2024-09-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The best place to get a curry in coventry. It's that simple nothing is to much trouble for the owner who is a legend. Go there and eat
Paul T . 2024-09-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Absolutely fantastic evening few nights ago they let us take over the whole restaurant for a group gathering. Great food and looked after us all really well. Thanks again we hoping to be back next year
Michael Stott . 2024-09-15
MORE AT Google
Visited De Laban after a trade show at the Coventry arena with about 50 other sparks. We had pre-booked, I can’t take any credit for any organisation I simply turned up but Islam and his team were absolutely fantastic & accommodating! Amazing food and service and as a rather rowdy crowd I could not fault the food or service will definitely be back again when in the area. 10/10
Jay Harding . 2024-09-15
MORE AT Google
Great LGBTQ+ friendly place with excellent food and lively atmosphere. Also perfect for group events, recently attended a gathering of 50 people and amazing night had by all.
Kevin Smith . 2024-09-15
MORE AT Google
We had a fantastic experience for a curry night with over 40 people. Islam was an excellent host who made sure everyone was well taken care of. The food was absolutely delicious—every dish was piping hot (not an easy task with so many people!) Thank you, Islam, and the whole team for making our evening memorable. #ESK
Azzurri Electrical . 2024-09-13
MORE AT Google
What a gem and lucky to live in walking distance. The food is spot on and great value for money. BYOB is a bonus! You will struggle to find a better Indian restaurant for miles
Nat mccabe . 2024-09-07
MORE AT Google
Nice place, off the beaten track the owner was very welcoming and a nice bloke, the food was excellent as a group we had a variety of dishes and all were good and well spiced my only negative was I felt a little rushed by our waiter but the rest was great, and takin king your own drinks made it great value for money, we will be back!
Carl Green . 2024-08-31
MORE AT Google
This is a great restaurant in that the food is always a high quality imo. The reason for 2 stars is that even if a table for 12 is booked 3 months, (yes, 3 months) and you go in to remind them at 5:00 the same evening, the staff don’t keep a table for you. It’s hardly worth booking. Moan over.
Jonathan Williams . 2024-08-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Reasonably priced, welcoming staff, rice portions are small, naan basket made up for it 3 choices plain, garlic & coriander & keema for £4.50. Its bring your own alcohol with shops that are located next door to the restaurant. Well worth a visit.
Simon M . 2024-08-22
MORE AT Google
De Laban is our favourite Indian restaurant in the whole wide world simply because their food is the best. We've had curries all over, including in some restaurants who claim to be the "best" but they do not come anywhere near De Laban's delicious food. Their Hydrabadi Biryani is a must try; simply the best ever. Everything on their menu is authentic and tastes so fresh. We live in Kenilworth which has an abundance of curry houses/Indian restaurants but we still travel to Coventry to have our curries at De Laban. Staff are very friendly and courteous. Highly recommend. Please come and open a branch in Kenilworth. Keep up the good work.
LoveToShop . 2024-08-17
MORE AT Google
Lovely clean and pleasantly decorated restaurant. Was a party of 5 ladies who all were happy with their main course meals, sides etc. However I was not at all happy with dips with poppadoms. Very small portions of onion mixture, mint yoghurt sauce, mango chutney which was hard to distinguish that as it had been so diluted in ran like water on the plate. Need more care when delivering very hot plates and dishes. But all taken into consideration would definitely visit again. Get the chef/s to learn from some other Indian how to prepare dips for poppadoms then might give extra star to review.
Jean M . 2024-07-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fancied an Indian last minute so tried to book online for an hours time and didn't get a response. Called up 30 minutes before I wanted to go in and asked if a table for two would be fine. Not a problem, no need for a booking just turn up I'm told. So I turn up as planned and get told its at least a 20 minute wait. I wasn't happy to say the least and I wasn't going to waste my time with anymore. Drove 5 minutes to somewhere that could actually sort out a table when they say they can.
Steve . 2024-07-20
MORE AT Google
Lovely restaurant, been twice now and the food is great, good menu too. Plates nice and hot, we loved the lighting and decoration.
Jeanette Baxter . 2024-07-15
MORE AT Google
Wow, a hidden gem, food was delicious, ambiance great. Service top class. Unexpected location, bring your own alcoholic drinks.
Ninafarina . 2024-07-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Normally can’t fault this place but we turned up on Friday for my birthday meal that my partner had arranged as a surprise. Ordered our food and was really looking forward to it. Over an hour later and still no food had arrived but the couple next to us who were regulars you could tell had there starters turn up within 10 mins of ordering. When asked where our starters were we were met with blank looks from one member of staff. The man than served up the approached us and decided to ask what it was we had ordered. After this we got up and walked away how can you forget someone’s order and not put it though. Really disappointed ruined what should have been a lovely evening out.
Rebecca L . 2024-07-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
A real find! Lovely curry, great staff, very clean!
Sue Hember . 2024-06-28
MORE AT Google
This is the perfect restaurant.....I'm vegan.....the gentleman always go out of the way for myself and my family and friends.....I have a brother who is down syndrome and autistic..... basically one extra chromazone......and a mother who has Cancer.....the gentleman are so sensitive and sweeter than the sweetest sweet.....both dining in and out.....I can not fault the Indian restaurant in anyway.....thank God there is a eloquent people like this today..... thank you so much indeed for your kindness and sensitivity
Lisa Roberts . 2024-06-18
MORE AT Google
Great food, service a little slow restaurant was full & lots of takeaways being delivered, but food well worth the wait
Neil Johnson . 2024-06-08
MORE AT Google
Lovely food, pleasant atmosphere and friendly service. We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner.
Pamela Barnacle . 2024-05-26
MORE AT Google
What a find! Tucked away in a residential area, lovely, lovely food. We're obviously late to find this place as it was really busy and takeaways were none stop too but food and service quality was maintained. Lots of groups, including families. Bring your own alcohol but there's a good shop next door, personally I prefer this option. We will definitely go back.
Sam Lennox-Dale . 2024-05-08
MORE AT Google
We have recently found this restaurant and love the food. Always deliver on time , and very generous portions. The chicken razella is incredible, never heard of it before , but its the best dish ever !
onlyonamonday . 2024-04-23
MORE AT Google
Very good food, nice atmosphere. Nice design
Eri Rubin . 2024-04-20
MORE AT Google
Pretty bad food , highly overrated . Shady atmosphere as well
Sam Dagar . 2024-04-06
MORE AT Google
We were invited here for a birthday celebration omg the food and staff and service is the best I have had in a very very long time. Will be visiting again very soon
Fiona Malhan . 2024-04-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My absolute favourite place to go for food. The paneer tikka is out of this world...
Sam Vincent-Hunt . 2024-01-23
MORE AT Google
It’s gone down hill for hygiene very bad report
Martin Payne . 2024-01-23
MORE AT Google
Tested by chance, this Indian restaurant was a very good surprise. Tasty dishes and pleasant service. We will come back with pleasure!
Caroline Ahern . 2024-01-11
MORE AT Google
Great food , not overly expensive . Very clean and tidy restaurant . I would go as far as saying, probably one of the best restaurants I’ve had food in Coventry . Staff extremely well, mannered and polite, but also willing to have a bit of banter with you . This restaurant Should go on you must try list . There is a shop seconds away to get your drink to take if that’s your thing . Myself, I will definitely be going there again. Parking outside was okay, but I could see it being a little bit of a problem on a busy night. But plenty of places to park over the road.
Stephen Bartholomew . 2023-12-28
MORE AT Google
We Always order from here and they’re always spot on 👌 brilliant service, brilliant atmosphere and most of all the food perfect. I Would and do highly recommend to everyone and anyone.
Ciaran Smith . 2023-12-20
MORE AT Google
Great place, great food and great service and delivery. I would recommend it to anyone who wants the best.
Frederick Kirkman . 2023-12-07
MORE AT Google
We took our daughter here for her 9th birthday this evening. What can I say. We were blown away by the staff they were attentive and so wonderful to her, calling her princess etc. Bought out a cake with us which they bought out at the end of our meal sung happy birthday to her, they let us decorate the table before we arrived with banners and glitter. So attentive and wonderul. The food was outstanding, staff exceptional, although the room is small but it doesnt matter at all as its beautiful inside and they all made her feel like royalty. Don't worry about bad reviews they are a false representation of this place. Its a hidden Gem 100% returning again in the future. Whatever the occasion your visiting they will provide a great atmosphere to enjoy fantastic food. Thank you De Laban for making our daughters birthday so special tonight xx
Tess Beckett (Mummy of 2) . 2023-12-03
MORE AT Google
Excellent food and great service, would recommend highly. 🏆🏆🏆
Deane Thomas . 2023-11-30
MORE AT Google
First visit and will be back, service between courses a little slow, but they were busy on a Tuesday evening, staff friendly and helpful.
David W . 2023-11-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Sorry to say that I found the takeaway to be pretty poor. £34 is utterly ludicrous for a small meal, so we won't be using this place again. I like onions, either raw or cooked; not half-cooked though, really not nice. They are the cheapest ingredient, and they dominated the meal. All about keeping costs down, I guess. The price though, wow. Not worth £25, let alone the price we paid.
Superbia . 2023-11-11
MORE AT Google
Amazing food, eclectic menu, fabulous fish dishes, highly recommend 😋
Anna Muir . 2023-11-11
MORE AT Google
Food is ok for a restaurant with one star HYGIENE back in feb this year and still not sorted a bit BAD.
lisa fox . 2023-11-08
MORE AT Google
Just brilliant however waited longer than normal because of home delivery service
Yvonne Parker . 2023-11-07
MORE AT Google
Visited this restaurant last night (Sunday 29th October) for the first time with friends who recommended it. Very friendly, great service excellent value for money and fabulous food. Looking forward to returning for our next feast. Thanks De Laban
LucyC2025 . 2023-10-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great food and service, second time we've been here in a big group and I could not fault any of the dishes. All very tasty.
Saj P . 2023-10-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The last three deliveries to our home. It arrived late on average 20 minutes and only after every time I had to call to say you're late before it arrived. Today, our food was . Late, barley warm, and tasteless. This has Been the same for at least our last 3 deliveries in the last 8 to 10 weeks. Won't use it again
Ccfc1986 . 2023-10-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent food and excellent service.
Junad Alom . 2023-10-10
MORE AT Google
Great tasting food, excellent service, could not fault the experience. Thankyou very much de Laban. Will see you again soon, Melvin
Venture461573 . 2023-09-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Bloody awful service, ordered a delivery at 5.55pm, told it would arrive at 7.20pm, phoned at 7.20pm to be told with a sigh it wasnt even cooked!! Never going there again!!
Amanda H . 2023-09-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The best Indian food I've ever had, (and i've eaten lots over the years) poppadom sauces were excellent, very nice staff and atmosphere
Jim Upson . 2023-09-22
MORE AT Google
The food wasn’t bad at all, but the main man who was serving is quite rude and I didn’t feel welcomed. They just need to employ professional staff. However, the other two young men were so polite and friendly.
Rebaz Samad . 2023-09-19
MORE AT Google
Regular takeaway from here, always a great standard of food, and the service is fantastic
John Neale . 2023-09-14
MORE AT Google
Had a takeaway from De Laban as I was visiting family in the area. Ordered online and collected 45mins later. The restaurant was full, but they got my order for me straight away. Food was fantastic, nice hot and spicy and the lamb was cooked perfectly. Will be back for a sit down meal next time I'm in cov. Would definitely recommend.
modscotsman . 2023-08-13
MORE AT Google
We haven't been for a long time here, We enjoyed the food and service and it wasn't over busy on a Saturday either so that was good. Great food on the night.
Craig Tonge . 2023-08-07
MORE AT Google
Ordered a chicken korai. What I received was a chicken tikka masala. Although it was nice it was not what I ordered. What a shame as we have had food from here before. Not a happy customer this time.
Chris Davies . 2023-08-04
MORE AT Google
Lovely curry house great staff beautiful food prefect setting and great prices 👌 👍 👏
Donna O'Sullivan . 2023-07-04
MORE AT Google
in my opinion the best curry house in cov spotless clean excellent food ,top marks well done .
John Southcott . 2023-07-03
MORE AT Google
Been here twice over the last few months and I have to say, so far it hasn't disappointed. Service has been good and the food is has had excellent flavours and has been served very hot, just how I like it. The venue itself is nicely situated and is clean with generally a good atmosphere. We will be returning soon! Very much recommended!
Dusty Fellow (Dusty) . 2023-06-16
MORE AT Google
Gorgeous food!! I never normally finish a curry but it was amazing! Lovely place and nice decor
OurHome . 2023-06-14
MORE AT Google
Second time I have ordered a delivery pre order just before 5 and still waiting1 hour and 30 mins later. Terrible service. Don't offer delivery if you can't fulfill them.
Diane Nicholls . 2023-06-09
MORE AT Google
8 of us..service was good, efficient and friendly....great Saturday night atmosphere..food delicious
Jo . 2023-06-05
MORE AT Google
Fabulous fine food. Great service and bring your own alcoholic drinks. What's not to love. Had a great night out with girls. Will be doing this every month. Great value at less than £20 each. Try it you won't be disappointed.
Sue Parker-Roberts . 2023-06-02
MORE AT Google
Table booked for 7pm. 7:25 still not seated as restaurant was clearly overbooked. Food looked great. Disappointed not to try it.
Miles Weaver . 2023-05-19
MORE AT Google
Just needs the chef to learn how to cook the prawns and shrims, instead of the 'rubber' ones that once again are being served up. What I find amazing, is that all the staff seemed to know the reason for the 'rubber' shrimps except the one person who cooks them.
Martin Green . 2023-04-28
MORE AT Google
Exceptional customer service each and every time. The staff are very polite and the food (curries in particular) are top quality. This place is a hidden gem.
GSB . 2023-04-22
MORE AT Google
Used this restaurant before and food is good. Today we spent 2 hours there to get 1 course with lots of takeaway meals going out very efficiently while we sat and waited. The service has never been great and the main person in charge is just way too rude. Our order was messed up. We only ordered two dishes and yet one was not made as chef messed it up . We waited 1.5 hours only to be told that chef has messed up our order and he didn’t even cook our food . This is just awful. And the main person was not even sorry. Why can’t he be more polite and sensible. We paid and left and obviously never going back. They absolutely ruined our evening.
a2z buildings . 2023-04-05
MORE AT Google
Always a great food even when really busy.
John Nicholson . 2023-03-23
MORE AT Google
Lovely curry bring your own Beers makes it a cheaper night
Sandra Plichta . 2023-02-23
MORE AT Google
Outstanding service and Food Ordered Lamb Naga full of fresh Spices and meat, keema nan bread was fresh as they come. Best in the Area fresh and spice consistent 10/10. Ordered take out from Ibis hotel
Dean Hansom. . 2023-02-15
MORE AT Google
This place is very pricey however the food is good and consistently so, every now and again we will splash out a little extra and order here. The portions arent the best and the containers are not full. Delivery is about 45 mins and food has always been hot - well as hot as can be expected for a delivery.
Covmom16 . 2023-02-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Two stars is for the staff as they were good. Been before the food was really nice but other night it was so bland no flavour whatsoever nann burnt curry tasted really watery and definitely the worst I’ve ever eaten may be an off day but I won’t be returning anytime soon to eat that.
Wayne Mmm . 2023-02-05
MORE AT Google
Just a take away but once again excellent service and friendly staff. Food was lovely and affordable 😋. Well worth a visit.
Jackie Page . 2023-02-05
MORE AT Google
Great range of dishes and consistent cooking, we’ve visited a few times now and not been disappointed Really recommend you book a table at the weekend as it’s really busy from early opening The only thing I would suggest is they need to concentrate more on diners rather than the takeout business, we had a long wait between ordering and getting food But the food is worth the wait and good value for money Not licensed so bring your own beer
james101bos . 2023-01-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Really nice and friendly restaurant with delicious lamb dishes
Dirk Bink . 2023-01-09
MORE AT Google
Food was very good at fair prices
Keithy C . 2022-12-21
MORE AT Google
Had a takeaway delivered tonight, arrived on time and order was correct. Very tasty meal and would highly recommend.
Graham T . 2022-12-16
MORE AT Google
Great service from friendly staff, the food was good.
hal wells . 2022-12-13
MORE AT Google
2 hour wait ,cold when we got our food delivery, phoned to see where our food was and the missing poppadoms we paid for ,was told were very busy ,poor customer service
Allison Hadlum . 2022-12-11
MORE AT Google
Food was very very tasty as usual. The chef had done what I asked for and had cooked mine with no Ghee and no oil as I find this too greasy. I do think that the drivers should be issued with a bag to carry the food in as by the time it got to us it was luke warm which was such a shame. He had just got the food in the paper bag on his passenger seat as I had to go to the car so saw this. Didn't put me off this time but if happens again will have to rethink.
Chris D . 2022-12-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely food. I recommend booking a table I went at 6:45 on a dark November Wednesday and they were very busy, managed to fit us in through. No alcohol license but there’s a handy off-licence almost next door.
Robin Cornelius . 2022-11-09
MORE AT Google
Absolute rubbish food. Ordered chicken tikka and lamb tikka masala as a main. It was like chicken tikka and lamb tikka desert, very sweet. Raised my complaint to the staff but all in vain . Ruined my eveining. Don't go to this restaurant absolute waste of money.
Sonia Kumari . 2022-10-24
MORE AT Google
The quality and flavour of the dishes was excptional. Staff very welcoming and the cozy ambience was lovely too. We were amazed at the value, especially when the bill came. Will definately be returning soon
yppay . 2022-10-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Insect in the curry - contacted the restaurant but no reply
Kent . 2022-10-07
MORE AT Google
Average taste and less quantity compare to other nearby restaurants
Sivapragash . 2022-09-13
MORE AT Google
Seen this place in the evening telegraph after winning an award. Ordered online although it wasn't quite ready on arrival, the lad on desk was super friendly and chatty. The food was great. It is also a restaurant however doesn't serve alcohol so not for me. See you soon though for my takeaway.
Gavin Marsh . 2022-09-12
MORE AT Google
It was our first time visit. Ordered Nan basket, stuffed Paratha and lamb tikka masala. Everything tasted great and worth the visit. They also provided pappadams (both plain and spiced with sweet, spicy, tangy condiments) Definitely recommended to visit if you haven't been there for North-Indian cuisine taste. Ensure you pre-book your table during Friday nights and weekends. Also, it's BYOB restaurant 🙂
Gayathri GK . 2022-09-06
MORE AT Google
Always a pleasure to go to De Laban, very friendly staff and amazing food everytime 5*
Michael Evans . 2022-08-25
MORE AT Google
This food is absolutely beautiful, very tasty and fresh. One of our favourite places to go for curry. The reason for only 4 stars is the atmosphere, its a lovely venue but the staff seem immature and rude. This don't stop me returning as the food is so good.
Martyn Johnston . 2022-08-23
MORE AT Google
Consistency of food and value…. Always good, who could complain? Been here for many years, good service good food, bring your own drink… an expensive night £15 a head….😀
Stevmal1 . 2022-07-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Naga dish curry with galick nan very testy
Mohammed Ahad Miah . 2022-07-15
MORE AT Google
Delicious food, amazing staff and fabulous decor! Highly recommend!
1rvmxn . 2022-06-27
MORE AT Google
Always good food, nice interior, reasonable price. Service can be hit and miss but one of the waiters in particular is really friendly.
Francesca Berlen . 2022-06-12
MORE AT Google
I had booked then the manager phoned and asked if we could come 30 minutes later to make sure we had a table which I agreed. When we went on time as agreed no table and no chance of one in a reasonable waiting period as all full. Very disappointed why accept the booking?
pauloO4033IA . 2022-05-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
These schedules may not be completely accurate on special days. Please always confirm with the restaurant
Similary restaurants in West Midlands
5948 Opinions
I visited MyDhaba with my family after seeing several positive reviews, but unfortunately, our experience fell far short of expectations. The staff did not behave professionally, often staring at us while we ate, which made us very uncomfortable. Additionally, the taste of the food did not live up to the glowing reviews we had read. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.
1155 Opinions
Firstly we had arranged to go to my brothers for an Indian ( ideally would have went out for one) however with small children we decided to just stay in. I suggested we tried this place as it was only down the road and was probably going to be nicer than your standard Indian takeaway. We get no signal in the house what so ever so I had to go up the street to phone them to make an order the lady on the phone said to me the compute system is down I’m going to write your order down is that okay I said yes then it appears she walked off and just forgot about me as I could hear the restaurant and everyone placing orders for the next 10 minutes so I cut it off. We thought it’s down the road we will just drive down and order and wait. So my partners gone in to order came back out ro the car we probably sat for 20 minutes and I said to him you should go back in now..I sat over 50 minutes with a screaming child in the car ( phone dead). This sort of time is not acceptable. We are talking nearly 8 o clock now so I’ve gone in to see what’s going on and it looks like there is no organisation what so ever! Asked the lady where the food was and she found it just sat on the side. Why would you expand your businesw to just eat/ Uber eats if the customer service is going to end up like this. The food was ok::: tbh we had gone past it and it had ruined the night. not worth £60 not really that special so this will be the first and last time il be visiting the place absolutely shocking
1494 Opinions
I have not been here for years but visited early evening before an event. The menu is good and drinks list decent (no alcohol). The surroundings are good and the staff are very friendly. The starters we ordered were good although the aloo tikki was a bit oily. The mains were good but again one of them was a bit oily. Flavours were good though. The manager is a nice guy and gives good advice and makes sure things are as you expect. The bowls for the curries were chipped though and this cant really be acceptable in a restaurant as its unhygienic. Please update these, use a bit less oil and and a bit more attention to presentation and it would be really good. I would want to give it currently 3.5 but would be 4 with those changes