Casa Italia in Sheffield

Visited this restaurant for the the first time on Friday night with friends. The food and service were amazing, really nice restaurant with a nice family feel to it. The garlic bread starters were a good size, with a nice thin and crispy base and the picante option had a great kick to it. We all ordered different main courses (pasta, veal and salmon) and deserts - all of them looked and tasted incredible. Plenty of options on the menu to cater for all tastes. Highly recommenced, we will definitely be back.

Such a lovely Italian restaurant. We came tonight with our daughter for her birthday along with the grandkids. A lovely welcome from the waiter/owner. The food as ever was gorgeous. Empty plates all round. We had 2 garlic mushroom starters 2 belly pork starters and some olives. All super tasty. For mains we had 2 seafood linguine 2 pizzas and a salmon tagliatelle with som3 bread to mop up the sauces. The seafood linguine was really tasty and cooked to perfection. Everyone enjoyed their mains. 3 of our party had desserts which included tiramisu cheesecake and profiteroles. More empty plates. Can’t fault anything and we most certainly will return.

As a special event we decided to book here for our wedding anniversary. We were welcomed in by Fidel, and Admirali We both had a starter garlic mushrooms and bruschetta, main courses of chicken Valdostana and Filleto Rossini, the fillet was cooked to perfection and probably one of the best steaks I have ever had. Will always come here as the food and service never disappoints

What a great find. We were in Sheffield for the snooker and looking for a restaurant near to where we were staying. Our host was frankly marvellous and couldn't have been more attentive or helpful. The food was delicious, full of flavour, well presented and generous in portion. Having lived and worked in southern Italy, it was great to be reminded of the tastes of the country and be able to chat about the area with our host. The pricing was very fair and the food more than good value for money. If you are in the area please consider this family owned business.

From the moment we arrived the staff could not do enough for you. We were made extremely welcome and the choice of food was excellent. When our food arrived it was amazing my husband and I had our honeymoon in Italy and it was like being back there. We all had three courses followed by hot drinks and everyone complemented the chef on each course. Most certainly will be going back and highly recommend the place to anyone looking for a top class Italian establishment that serves excellent cuisine.

We dined out here as a family of 7 for my daughter's 16th birthday. It was our first time visiting and won't be our last. The food was lovely and portions huge! The service was outstanding and we were not rushed at all, spending almost 3 hours here. The waitress was outstanding and couldn't be more helpful - didn't catch her name unfortunately but she deserves credit! We will be back.

Really great restaurant always meets high expectations, all the staff are welcoming and the menu is varied. The food was exceptional. Always look forward to going here

Came here last night for my birthday and had an absolutely fantastic time! Exceptional service, amazing food (we practically licked the plates clean!) and a lovely atmosphere! We won't leave it as long to return this time, thankyou!

Booked a table for 7pm when we arrived all the tables were occupied, staff asked if we wanted a drink while a table became available. Unfortunately there isn’t anywhere to enjoy the drinks you have bought and you are left shuffling around busy staff go in and out of the kitchen. A table became available around 7.30 staff made the table ready and eventually came with menu’s and took our drinks order. Our wine arrived some 15 mins later with only two glasses and no ice bucket. Our order was taken but starters didn’t arrive for 40 mins, Very tasty, Our main dishes took a further 50 mins to arrive after our starter plates were taken by witch time we were all getting quite frustrated. It was very apparent that there was insufficient staff both in the kitchen and on front of house but they had continued to take bookings for the evening with the knowledge that they would struggle to manage a full restaurant. An extremely disappointing evening !!!!

The service was excellent Food was nice. We asked for non alcoholic and no parmesan. They actually took a bit more time than usual to serve the food but honour our dietary needs. The waitresses were very pleasant. One of them volunteered to help with our 9 months old child

Visited last Sunday for a booking of 8 people. Restaurant was very quiet for a Sunday with only 2 other tables. The restaurant has a big poster up for it’s Sunday menu - it’s no longer available. We were only informed as we started to order. Poster needs to be removed. However to be fair to the chef he did agree to cook something from the menu that wasn’t on the main menu. The waitress was very good - very attentive and drinks were good. Good interaction with our table. The problem was with the food - probably the worst lasagne we have ever had. Lacked meat, lacked substance and flavour and the pasta was way over cooked. The pizza was also poor. Second time we’ve visited - first was good food and poor service - this was the opposite.

We’ve been a couple of times now so thought with family visiting it would be a great choice. It wasn’t. Of the two staff working, one was really trying but had just over a months experience (as we were told) the other was a rabbit in the headlights and was more hindrance than help. We ordered mains only, two fish dishes, a pasta dish and a rare steak. This took 40-45mins with, at time of ordering, 3 other tables of two (one of which was already there) to arrive from when the order was placed so should have been out way before that and we had to chase when it was coming, even then there was a delay between the first and second two plates arriving. The food was ok, not anything bad but certainly wasn’t worth the wait. Really need to up their game, an actual manager front of house (or somebody with restaurant experience) could make things a lot better - but until this happens I’d give it a miss. Used to be good, now not so much.

The menu looks good with interesting options and the food was ok. The restaurant was not particularly busy for a Friday but food took over an hour to arrive, we had to ask where it was. We decided to leave rather than waiting on desert. We’ve been previously and it was much better. Underwhelming experience.

We have been here 2 times in the past already and this was our 3rd visit. We finally decided to leave a well deserved review. After being disappointed with italian food back on our holiday on whitby, Casa Italia was what we needed, delicious food from starters to main and amazing desserts. Italian food is all about flavour and if you don’t want to be disappointed Casa Italian your place to go. The Host/Owner is always accommodating and very welcome. This place deserves more recognition.. Bravo 👏

We were made so welcome by the owner as we arrived. The ambience, decor and staff were so friendly and accommodating. All four of us thoroughly enjoyed our food and said we would definitely return. I have told lots of friends about our experience, so hopefully will create more custom.

We go to Casa Italia frequently. Food is lovely and service good. Any earlier issues have definitely been ironed out.

We went there to have a late lunch early dinner. The pasta was delicious. I had white wine, house white delightfully smooth. We shared a freshly baked bread. They’re tiramisu and American coffee is the best in town. The owner is super nice. Tiramisu deserves five star.

Family get together for grand-daughters 17th birthday, fabulous food and well looked after by staff making a great afternoon party. Many thanks Casa Italia.

Been twice now and thoroughly enjoyed on each occasion. Service excellent and very friendly staff. Food very tasty with good choice. Would recommend

Absolutely brilliant restaurant, food is amazing, been here on numerous occasions and never disappointed if fact it gets nicer each time. Service very Italian and friendly best restaurant we have been too in a long time.

Great evening after a spur of the moment decision to visit. The staff found us a table in the conservatory and made sure the heaters where on so we were warm. Great food and great value all round.

Booked for a table of 2 tonight and was blown away with how good the place is and the service and the food was amazing would definitely recommend

Wonderful food and atmosphere at Casa Italia, we have had a lovely experience really enjoyed calamari for starters and steak for main courses 😋

We went for my birthday, a party of 7, we had to wait nearly a hour between the courses, the food was not up to standard and the price didn't reflect the food-Infact my daughter swears that her dessert was probably a bought in one....

Took the grandkids with us on Saturday. Lovely little place. The food was great as was the service. Lots of choices on the menu.

Cannot recommend highly enough. Fish is always fresh and tasty. All the dishes that I’ve ever eaten have never disappointed and the service is perfect.

The food was absolutely awful for the price. I paid £23 for a tiny bit of salmon with hardly anything else on the plate. I was still hungry after the main meal. Wasn’t fresh either. Overpriced and very poor quality food. Felt really ripped off!!!

We visited here for the first time tonight. The decor was very welcoming. The host was delightful, friendly and added to the atmosphere of the restaurant. The food was delicious. Can't wait to come back again.

We were excited to try this restaurant on the basis of local mentions. The restaurant looked pretty busy when we arrived at 7.30 on a Saturday evening, but there didn't actually seem to be anyone with any food on their tables. We felt kind of...

My Sisters took me out for a celebration meal following my Cancer Surgery in June. We went to Casa Italia which was absolutely beautiful the restaurant was cozy and the owner Gino was extremely welcoming and attentive. The starter main meal and drinks were absolutely...

The waiter Fidel went the extra mile to make us feel welcome and accommodated. We arrived an hour before closing and wasn’t expecting much. We were pleasantly surprised. Fresh, authentic Italian delicious food. It made me feel at home again, and brought back many happy...

To the eye, very pleasing looking food but the taste did not match I had the scampi ravioli with king prawn and seaweed, too saucy and the salty taste was overpowering. I couldn’t identify the flavours in the food. My husband had the chicken pizza,...

Beautiful food, possibly one of the best steaks we've ever had! And the service was lovely too :) great selection of wines and we enjoyed sitting out on the terrace bit pretending we were in Venice

A big group of friends and family visited for a 21st birthday and it was absolutely gorgeous.Amazing food,the restaurant itself is beautiful,they had tvs with a live stream view of Venice which I thought was a lovely touch.Customer service was exceptional and the owner made...

We recently made our second visit to this local restaurant and as before had a very enjoyable evening. The front of house duo made us very welcome and provided excellent service throughout. Our meals were exceptional in terms of presentation and quality and my wife...

We booked a table for the family for 8pm .. we were still waiting for our main courses at 10pm . There was another party who were served a little before us but they waited nearly as long. The food was lovely but we were...

I’ve been twice now and I think the food and service is really good value for money. The place is clean and neat and catches the sunset nicely through the windows. The only thing I will say is the music was too loud and not...

Absolutely amazing experience. Both the food and hospitality was far beyond expectations. Truly enjoyed and would recommend for everyone.

My partner and Daughter (11yrs) dined here on Sunday the 14th of March. Fidell (The boss) was on duty and made us feel incredibly welcome straight away. The restaurant was reasonably busy with a lovely warm vibe. The service was professional and attentive. Drinks were...

I went to this little italian secret in Sheffield today The interior was lovely, really well done and cost, for such a new place the wine list was very good. I had muscles and sword fish as my main, the food was delicious. In house...

Cannot comment on the food because after a wait of a very patient 85 minutes we vacated our table and left this very poor establishment. We should have realised early in our visit having to ask the waiter to take our drinks order. Twenty minutes...

Went on valentines with my girlfriend. Tried to charge us £60 for 3 course set meal each. We had 1 starter and 2 mains... he convinced my (naive) girlfriend he was doing a good deal by taking £10 off, charged £56 for what would be...

We visited on Saturday as a group of 4 having previously visited on a Sunday and a weekday evening. We all had a lovely time and the food and service was excellent. Having had a variety of meals over the last 3 visits I can...

Booked last minute for yesterday evening (Sunday 6th Feb ) and they accommodated us, no problem. The restaurant was quiet, as predicted for a Sunday at 8.30pm, but the service and food were fantastic and we walked away full and contented! The Manager was welcoming...

Incredibly long wait for food, not even any reason given for over an hours wait on a quiet weekday evening. It was clear other tables were being served before us, seems you have to know the chef in this ‘restaurant’. Such an unfriendly atmosphere, cheap,...

The worst restaurant experience I have ever had, please read to the end. Waited over an hour for the starter. I had muscles, they were mostly closed, but I tried a few and they were off. This gave me a bad stomach the following day....

Booked for my 60th birthday. At the time no mention of a revised menu ie NO pasta! What Italian doesn't sell pasta?? Of course this was so you paid more for meat and fish, but on request they did make me a lasagna all be...

Having read all the great reviews we wanted to give this place a try, so when friends gifted myself & my partner £50 as a birthday treat we decided to visit last night (weds 8th dec) with our son. Being midweek the place was not...

What a fantastic dining experience! This was the first time we visited Casa Italia, and it did not disappoint. The restaurant was clean and welcoming. Staff were friendly from the outset. The owner and host was wonderful, chatty and polite. Wine recommendations were spot on....

Less enthusiastic Italian experience We visited tonite, it was our first time. We waited ages to be served and our meals came out very late and separately. The lasagnes were so small. The meals were nothing special which was so sad. Our main meal dishes...

We went here with friends on Friday the 13th August. Having read the great reviews we were looking forward to going. All I can say it was probably the worst meal out that I can remember. The service was very slow and inattentive, the guy...

This is a really lovely restaurant, large menu of pizza pasta and traditional Italian dishes. The food was beautifully cooked and presented and service fantastic. We shared a divine home made tiramisu for dessert. Good value

My husband felt he’d earned a treat after doing well in today’s 10k so we decided to call on spec at Casa Italia. Service was great with friendly staff and the food was lovely and good sized portions. Couldn’t have asked for anything more and...

Went here one Sunday after passing it many times since its opening day. I walked in to be greeted by a very friendly lady who gave exceptional service thought out our meal. It was extremely clean and tidy The food was very tasty and good...

My family visited for my birthday there were 7 of us 2 of our party are Vegan We received a fabulous meal each of us the Vegan meals were delicious and varied really this restaurant is superb I had a brilliant evening our attention from...

Went on a whim when driving down Chesterfield Rd, so glad we did!! My partner and I eat out a lot at many different restaurants and this stood out a mile, could not believe how nice the food was. Super amazing quality food and the...

First time visit tonight 090721 restaurant very modern staff very welcoming and friendly food absolutely amazing couldn't fault it at all would recommend to anyone 5 stars 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Was due to go with a bunch of friends but when I saw the one vegan option of a slice of cauliflower, a bit of veg and a piece of bread for a tenner I decided against it. They need to up their game particularly...

Been to this restaurant several times over the past year and every time it has been outstanding. My husband asked if they did cheese board (they don’t normal) but they made a special enough and it was so inventive- especially the honey with cheese and...

Very good. Thanks. Really enjoyed. Friendly staff. Relaxed. Great steak. Will defo be back. Only comments are its not a great wine list, and also that there is no need for paprika and balsamic glaze on every dish. Looks a bit tacky and flavours don't...

Heated outdoor seating. Friendly and welcoming staff. Great steaks and gluten free options. We will definitely be regular customers.

Wow what amazing food ! Fantastic friendly staff that take time to care about their customers . I can’t recommend this place enough if you want to treat your taste buds give it a try !

What a lovely evening, lovely food and excellent service fron Danella. And able to walk home rather than messing around with taxis. Can't wait to go again.

We visited tonight and I have to say food was great and waitress was lovely - we had starters (bruschetta and calamari) , main (halibut and a pizza) and dessert to share along with a bottle of wine for £66! Super recommend! It was nice...

Authentic, friendly and great food. “There’s a new Italian opened down the road”. How often are these words said but never live upto the standards us brits hold Italian food. Casa Italia did just that and Jackie our host was brilliant. This was our second...

What lovely food, reasonably priced, scrupulously clean and very helpful and careful waitresses. So good to have a good Italian in Meersbrook! The portions are quite big - maybe share a starter ?

My partner and I have wanted to try here since they opened. Tonight we took the plunge, and I'm so glad we did! Absolutely gorgeous food, excellent service and overall fantastic hospitality. Cannot fault it at all! My partner had the ribs for starters, and...

Really disappointed as the restaurant looks so appealing. Friendly staff, BUT didn’t seem to be Covid safe at all. In fact we felt quite vulnerable especially when comparing with other restaurants visited. The waitress had her mask around her chin, no contact details taken, customers...