The Witchery by the Castle in Edinburgh, City of

This is the 3rd year we have come to The Witchery for our valentines meal, and no doubt would come more often if we didn't live so far away. The atmosphere and setting are incredible in the secret garden, so romantic. We enjoyed a delicious bottle of wine with our meal from a huge selection, our choice supported by the really helpful waiter that served us all evening. We enjoyed delicious starter's that were beautifully presented and our main courses of steak and red deer that were of the highest quality and literally melted in the mouth. Freshly prepared desert of Tiramisu and the cheese and biscuits followed to finish off what was an amazing meal. The staff couldn't be more helpful, smart or polite, even offering to arrange a taxi if needed. We have already booked for next year and would definitely recommend this venue for style and quality of food and service.

We were her for our fourth consecutive Valentine's meal, and once again it was perfect. The welcome was warm, all the staff were polite and attentive giving advice if required, and we had ample time to enjoy our time there The food was excellent. As I said to the manager during the evening, my steak was probably the best I'd ever had. We have already booked for next year.

A delicious meal in an amazing setting near the castle in the heart of Edinburgh. Kind and professional staff and an otherworldly atmosphere. Fabulous design with cherubs, ornate candlesticks, carved and painted wood, gothic touches and even a vine! Perfect for my mum’s birthday. We were made to feel welcome and special. An unforgettable experience!

After dining here in July, having such an amazing experience from start to finish, we returned during our break to Edinburgh and again had a fantastic experience. We received exceptional service from Blair who was warm and friendly, lighthearted and made us feel very comfortable. We started with a delicious cocktail and also chose a bottle of wine to go with food from their extensive list, it’s the size of a phone book! Beautiful food, we had the very reasonably priced lunch menu and shared a fantastically rich dessert of dark chocolate torte. Stunning wooden panelled dining room, candlelit and so romantic, decadent yet relaxed, it was a truly wonderful experience and we can’t wait to go back again and again!

Once again a fabulous lunch in the Witchery. Lovely food and first class service. Highly recommend for a relaxing meal. Staff are amazing! We had the two course set meal and the fish pie was delicious. The smoked trout was also beautiful. Then followed with an Amaretto coffee!

I would have liked to give 2 reviews, just 3 stars for our meal but 5 stars for the hotel and all the lovely staff. Both our meals of 5 scallops was basically cold with hardly any real flavour. The scallops were cooked very well and the presentation was lovely but the taste was very bland. I would suggest adding garlic and ginger with the scallops on a bed of green veg, eg. spinach. The chef used kale but it was very wet and also cold. We could have sent the meals back but did't want to wait for more to be cooked nor for our meal to just be put in a microwave. We stayed there for one night and all the staff were really lovely, friendly and helpful, even the poor waiter serving our cold meal. Our room (Heriot) was amazing, where we were served breakfast in our room before we checked out. We dined in the Original dining room, which has a lovely atmosphere.

We had a lovely lunch here a few weeks back. Service is excellent and the food was fabulous. The wine list can be quite expensive but there are some relatively affordable wines available. We had a South African Pinotage from Springfontein that was superb. If you can get a seat away from the windows then that's the best choice as tourists tend to come right up to the windows to try and get a peak inside. It can be a bit unsettling.

I must start this by saying I have not visited this establishment recently (but have in the past) however on Sunday 2nd February I was walking past another establishment on York Place when I heard and witnessed a man harassing a bouncer. The reason I’m bringing this here is due to the fact I witnessed this man deliberately antagonise the bouncer, speak to him in a racist manner, and I heard him state “I work in the industry” and that he “works in the Witchery. I’m the manager” in an attempt to excuse his abhorrent behaviour to another staff member who had appeared to support their bouncer. I must say, if this is how this man speaks to another man, one that’s just doing his job, in the middle of the street? I then wonder how he treats his own staff.

We visited the restaurant for a friends birthday, the staff gave excellent service and the food was good, the only downside to the experience was the light level which was so poor you need to use your phone to read the menu and see the food when it arrived, guys I understand the lighting adds to the atmosphere but come on.

Second time here and still good. Romantic and atmospheric. Unbeatable location and history.

Awesome culinary and atmospheric birthday experience Everything about this experience was class The staff, the setting, the location, the food....all amazing We went for the very reasonable 2 course lunch, the sea trout and pumpkin veloute followed by grilled rump and fish pie. Birthday girl had a cherry bakewel cocktail, and as a very nice touch, they brought a birthday desert with candle Even the coffee was awesome This was a very enjoyable bucket list treat and would definitely recommend,

An amazing lunch First time we have been here and it won't be the last. This is the best lunch I've had in a long time. First class service with delicious food. If you are in Edinburgh I recommend you go here for lunch or dinner. We are locals and have never been because we unfortunately thought it was touristy but how wrong we were because it's just absolute quality. Can't wait to go back. Sorry no pics of the main course but we were enjoying it so much we forgot to take pics of It.

My boyfriend and I had a lovely dinner in the secret garden dinning room. The food was phenomenal, and the atmosphere was magical and romantic. Our favourite dish was the lamb Wellington. Expensive but definitely worth the experience!

Fantastic place to stay where everything is just right ant the staff at all so friendly and can not do enough to make your stay the most unforgettable experience. Can't wait to stay again

This is one of the most beautiful hotels we've stayed at. we got the Sempill Suite and were amazed by how beautiful it was. It was the size of a small apartment. The attention to detail when it came to decorating every inch of the room was impeccable. Location could not be better, we were right by the Edinburg castle and the restaurant was absolutely stunning as well with great food. 5 starts and cannot wait to visit again.

My and my hubby had the most romantic and amazing lunch! The place is beyond charming and has very wonderful service ! The food is to die for, the menu is so incredible that you really want to eat it all the dishes !!! I’m in awe !

TL;DR: The Witchery near Edinburgh Castle is a charming upscale eatery with exceptional food, delightful staff, and a welcoming manager. A must-visit for a memorable dining experience. The Witchery is an enchanting, upscale restaurant located near Edinburgh Castle. The ambiance is as captivating as the location, and the food was absolutely amazing—every bite felt like a treat. The staff were incredibly delightful and attentive, and the manager added a special touch of charm to the entire experience. If you’re in Edinburgh and looking for a place that combines atmosphere, exceptional cuisine, and 10-star service, I highly recommend stopping by The Witchery. It’s a meal to remember!

Very delicious and stylish lunch

Exceptional meal food and service outstanding

I stayed at the witchery with my girlfriend we had the armory suite and couldn't fault it one bit absolutely stunning. Ok yeah it's expensive I would say could be a bit cheaper personally that's litterly the only criticism it's expensive! The staff were friendly and helpful and promptly provided everything we had requested. The breakfast was excellent and filling again staff service was excellent and attentive. We will personally stay there again.

We dined here as a celebration for my birthday, and couldn’t have been made to feel more significant. Guided down the stairs into the dining room, staff members welcome you warmly and you notice the gorgeous decor. Once seated at the table, the candlelight and gentle music peacefully greet your senses. Every detail is thought of and well placed, down to the fresh rose bouquet at each table and artwork on each menu. We chose rosemary bread with salted butter, and soft crab to start - served promptly, and delicious. And for the main event: deer, which was generously portioned, delicate and indulgent. We both selected a dessert, which again were delightful, followed by a cocktail for my partner and a Cardhu 18-year-old special release for myself. We could have had the entire meal twice for it being so enjoyable. I cannot conclude my review without thanking Holly, our vibrant server, who treated us as though we were old friends, and without whom the night would not have been so special. You are a treasure, your service faultless and your dedication exceptional. If it’s a romantic dinner you desire, you need look no further than here.

We ate there on 17 January and had philpo from Rome as butler. It is the most wonderful experience I have ever been a part of. The food was amazing and the butler was incredible. Magical experience.😍

We were not able to try the hotel, however as for the restaurant, we were in a very romantic, picturesque and charming setting, completely in keeping with the theme of the old town.

Went here for our honeymoon dinner and couldn't have picked a better venue for our 1st meal together i would recommend this restaurant for the food and service made welcome from the moment we walked through the door until we left

We had the great pleasure to stay in the turret suite from 7.Jan to 10.Jan 25 after a road trip through Great Britain. Impeccable service, very friendly staff and the suite was the largest and most beautiful I‘ve ever had. I highly recommend the continental breakfast set up in your room, the sunsets and the smooth, discreet room service. Will definitely make a trip to Edinburgh again even if it means a big detour 😊

Celebrating our anniversary at The Witchery was an incredible experience. The romantic candlelit ambiance and gothic charm in the secret garden made for a magical evening. My husband started with the aged Scotch beef tartare, while I enjoyed the fresh, briny Cumbrae Scottish rock oysters. For the main course, we both had the grilled 28-day aged Scotch beef fillet, which was perfectly cooked and absolutely amazing. The service was flawless, and the sommelier’s wine pairings added the perfect touch to the meal. Every moment, from the warm welcome to the final bite, was unforgettable. Highly recommend for any special occasion!

Had a fabulous time dining here 2 years ago and decided to return for pre Christmas lunch this year 2024.. Reservation was made easily through a phone call, a table was given in the opulent medieval original dining room which is darker than the Secret Garden dining. Staff are attentive but seemed cold. Quality of beef is good but portion is very small for the 2 persons sharing cote du boeuf charging at £110 with pathetic grilled whole onion as sides,cod was fishy even though well cooked and presented, overall a disappointment for the price charged.

Gorgeous food, attentive staff, opulent decor. My fave place in Edinburgh.

Incredibly Captivating Place! Full of a distinguished atmosphere, charm and mystical energy. The proximity of the castle and at the same time a perfectly located entrance in a side street. Romantic mood of the late Middle Ages or Anglicanism. It's really worth it. Tartare in perfect Scottish beef. Pure pleasure for the senses. I recommend!

The short story is that you’re paying for the ambience and it’s probably worth it if that’s something you care about. The long story is that we didn’t love the food and the service was pretty dismissive of us. We booked in for Hogmanay night (expecting fireworks, but alas). The dining room is absolutely beautiful and we were basically seated in thrones. Candlelight and cozy music completed the vibes. It feels like being in another era. We ordered a bottle of Cava, two starters, the Beef Wellington for two and a dessert. We liked the Shellfish Bisque the best out of anything. That dish is well worth it. We didn’t love the Beef Wellington as the pastry kept falling off and the meat was so tough in spots that we couldn’t cut it with our knives. The spinach and garlic mashed potatoes were fine, but kind of like food you might get at a wedding. Everything needed salt and pepper. The dessert was yummy and we enjoyed going outside to ring in the new year with our cava. However, we didn’t have a great time with the service. We’ve been to many luxury dining establishments (we’ve both worked in the industry) and this was by far the most dismissive service. None of our servers seemed particularly happy to help us and we felt like they were being kinder to other tables. This was pretty shocking to us because Scotland has some of the best service in the world in our experience. But I genuinely had more personable and nice service at the chippy the next day. We still enjoyed our time because the space is lovely and it’s a very fun place to ring in the new year, but would probably not come again unfortunately.

We went to the restaurant and it was a great time! Unique atmosphere, old and perfectly preserved decor. The dishes offered are very good and refined. I recommend a must-visit address in Edinburgh

It's a beautiful room. One of those you say you did it places, the food was ok, but I've had better. If you have the money blow... go for it, otherwise skip it.

Beautiful ambience, incredibly good food and warm service. Perfect price-performance ratio. We were in Secret Garden and had a wonderfully romantic meal with very attentive waiters. Thanks also for the nice compliment on my necklace while walking through the cloakroom. Upscale, luxurious and yet human.

This was an amazing experience. We stayed for 2 nights, and we're already planning another trip. The service is like nothing you've ever experienced. The staff is incredibly welcoming and helpful. The rooms are luxurious and comfortable. I felt pampered the entire stay.

Leather-boot level dry, chewy beef wellington made with rump steak instead of fillet, which we only found out after the food had been served. The menu specifies fillet. Still got charged £110 mind you. As lovely as the atmosphere is, the food was a complete disappointment.

Came for a family dinner recently where we had cocktails, mains and dessert. Have to say the cocktails were just excellent, kudos to the bartender and the table settings were gorgeous. For the prices on the menu we all thought the food could be improved to suit the rest of decor, as is the restaurant is mostly popular for the atmosphere, which is exceptional. For example, the flavors of the mains were very one dimensional, some even needed better seasoning. Not bad, but not great. Staff were attentive and friendly. If you’re a real ‘foodie’ maybe consider other options. Otherwise it’s a very pretty place for an ok meal.

I couldn't give this beautiful place enough stars. The ambiance, food, and service we're all absolutely stunning. Visiting them for dinner service the day after Christmas was magical and made us want to visit again next time were in Edinburgh. Make a reservation and enjoy this perfect setting!

A piece of fine dining theatre that everyone would experience at least once.

Travelling from Singapore it’s my first time in Edinburgh with my family . The secret garden restaurant is highly recommended by our Scottish friends.We had our dinner last Dec 19. The steak is one of the best ones I had so far . My husband is very happy with Haggis for his starter and my son tried venison for the very first time 😊 he enjoyed it . 3 desserts are delicious too. I had oysters for my starter oh that was fresh and delicious! If we come back to Edinburgh in the summer we will definitely dine here again 👍

We flew from Singapore for a short holiday in Edinburgh and this restaurant is recommended to us by our Scottish friends. We had our dinner on Dec 19. The food is delicious.Probably one of the best steaks I’ve had so far ! My son had venison for his main and he loves it.My husband had haggis for his starter and he said it’s delicious.Over all experience we are happy and we will definitely come back again in the summer to try the outdoor dining.👍

It was a great time celebrating birthday with the Witchery! The food (both the taste and the portion size) and the service were all impressive, would love to recommend it to everyone~

Here’s my google review I recently had the misfortune of dining at The Witchery in Edinburgh, a “posh” spot where they claim the ghosts of Scotland's past whisper in your ear... mostly about how much they regret paying over 150 quid for something that’s definitely not worth the price. Walking in, I thought I’d stumbled into a haunted castle. The decor was so gothic it looked like the set of a *Dracula* reboot—dark velvet drapes, flickering candles, and a floor so creaky it could’ve been a ride at a haunted house. I half expected the ghost of William Wallace to rise up and scream, “This is *not* the place to drop your pension!” Now, let’s talk about the food. I ordered the Beef Wellington, because why wouldn’t you when you're in Scotland and clearly have no respect for your bank account? When it arrived, the thing looked like it had been through some sort of culinary exorcism. The pastry was so overcooked, I could’ve sworn it was a piece of plywood disguised as a crust. Inside, the beef wasn’t so much tender as it was *teriyaki-flavored shoe leather*. The only thing "well-done" about it was my disbelief at how this was somehow £110. The waiter, bless his heart, was as stiff as the steak. He leaned in, all serious-like, and said, “It’s prepared with the finest Angus beef and wrapped in a delicate layer of pastry.” Aye, the finest beef, if by "finest" you mean the kind of beef that would make even a hungry cow rethink its life choices. And the bill? Let’s just say I’m still waiting for the heart attack to set in, and it’s not from the food. It was the price that nearly killed me.

It was my birthday, and I didn’t expect it to be this good! The Witchery made it truly special. All the staff were so nice and went above and beyond. I’d like to highlight a few names: McKinzie, Filippo, and Gersi, as well as the lovely lazy @the reception (sorry I forgot to ask your name!) A big thank you to all of you for making my day extra special. And thank you for all the pictures🥰 I will definitely visit again!

Location, atmosphere, service, very high quality food. I warmly recommend this very beautiful place.

Rating the restaurant, which is so incredibly charming, but the quality of the food needs some work. My wife sent back two dishes as the halibut was incredibly bland, and the s scallops were just awful. Could have been a bad nite? The service was top-notch, and the servers did all they could to accommodate, but I'm afraid Instagram has made this place a tourist trap. Would not repeat and very pricey.

Afternoon tea review only. Exquisite decor and ambience. Waiting 40 minutes for the afternoon tea to be served and was a little lacking. Cakes were bland and sandwiches options were very small. You're paying for the surroundings really as the afternoon tea was probably my least favourite one I've ever had.

Had dinner at the restaurant which was fab with great service. Not exactly cheap, but quality was high

Went for the afternoon tea, so I can’t describe the hotel itself but it was very atmospheric, with a great selection of teas and cakes.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Food was incredible. Services was great. It was my wife’s 40th birthday and each staff member acknowledged her birthday and the birthday plate was a nice touch. Will definitely be back.

What a fantastic experience! The staff were great and more than happy to answer any questions. The food was amazing with such great options to chose from and also a great wine selection. It was our Wedding Anniversary and it was made to be very special. Will definitely be coming back to experience the Garden Room next time.

Fantastic atmosphere, great historical setting, beautiful interior - a great Christmas treat! The staff were very friendly - perfect festive lunch ☺️

The Witcher’s is amazing. From the food to the service and the beautiful setting, everything is just really good. Can’t recommend it enough!

This was our second time in the Witchery, our first time in the secret garden. The service and the food were outstanding, we shall be back.

To put it lightly… don’t bother. Take photos of the outside it’s better than paying £100 + for a below average meal! The beef wellington which is £110 is made of the cheapest cut of meat rump!. You wait 50 minutes for this to come and have to waste most of the meat due to how chewy it is! A highly rated restaurant and they are using the cheapest cut meat but for maximum profit. Really disappointed, had huge expectations but massively let down.

A breathtaking setting with exquisite food. Perfect for a special occasion!

Had a lovely meal,the staff were lovely and the food was nice a fresh.

I went there with my husband about 41 years ago. Mr Thomson was delightful! From the cauldron, he gave me a book to peruse. The ambiance was excellent. Meal was scrumptious (escargots). Went downstairs and heard chanting. Creepy; but, it is expected in this restaurant and building. I highly recommend it!

We visited the Witchery for dinner and I must add I am rarely one to leave a review but I cannot recommend enough. The staff were fantastic, very helpful and quick to attend, the food was some of the best we have had for a very long time if not ever, and compared to other local similar restaurants and particularly restaurants London, the food is very well priced for its outstanding quality. I would like to thank the whole team for making our Christmas trip to Edinburgh so special.

Celebrated our wedding anniversary with a fabulous meal at The Witchery. Lovely service and great food. Everything I’d hoped it would be. Pricey, but a nice treat to mark 30 years.

We visited the restaurant and I can definitely say it was a top pick! Everything was perfect- the food was delicious, the service was excellent and the ambiance- amazing! Yes, it was a bit pricey but it was a great experience!

An amazing if slightly costly. Food amazing and the atmosphere is great. Save up your pennies and go for a lifetime's experience.

10/10 amazing meal, lovely service, thoughtful birthday gesture and stunning restaurant!!!

Excellent food and service my best meal in Edinburgh

Lovely restaurant with very attentive staff. We really enjoyed the food

Excellent food and service. There is also beer, just ask for it.

The restaurant was incredible, a unique experience! We loved the cozy atmosphere in the evening Very fine dishes Thank you for the attention for our 3 years

Lovely meal for my wifes birthday highly recommend

We had dinner in the secret garden to celebrate a graduation and it was fantastic. Service and ambiance were both incredible and every dish was delicious.

The food, atmosphere, and especially the service were magical! It is truly a special experience.

I really loved my experience at the witchery. The staff were warm and friendly and I really enjoyed the vibe and atmosphere. It's quite expensive but it's a great place to go for a special occasion. The food was excellent.

We had the afternoon tea. Slightly expensive however very much worth it! Beautiful venue inside with some very detailed architecture. Warm and cozy vibe with a delicious selection of afternoon tea. Staff were excellent and attention to detail was spot on! 10000% worth it!

Beautiful restaurant, very attentive service. The Orkney scallops were amazing.

We had a gorgeous meal here. We had the light lunch menu and added chips, cocktails, and dessert. The only thing I didn't love was the fish pie, but only because there was so much topping. I would have loved more fish and leek. The chocolate torte is heavenly. The staff are lovely and discreet, you don't feel rushed and can relax and enjoy your food.

We didn't stay at the hotel, but ate at the restaurant. It was a great atmosphere and the service was fine, but the food was not up to standards. We sent 3 of 6 main courses back as they were over cooked and not up to the price tag.

We ate lunch in the Secret Garden restaurant which is as beautiful as it looks in pictures. The staff were also very friendly and welcoming, but sadly my compliments have to stop there. The menu was incredibly disappointing. I know the lunch options are more limited than dinner, but the options that are provided are shockingly not varied. If you don’t like or want fish or mushrooms, that’s 50% of the menu. Then 30% is veg only, and then 20% is red meat, (all beef bar one.) It left me with no starter options, and only 2 from the main courses. The restaurant was only 1/3 full when we ordered, but somehow it took over 50min for our only course to arrive which was shocking. People came in after us and had their starter and main before us. I was about to ask if our order had been lost when it arrived. The food was nice, but our main of lamb wellington came with mash and creamed spinach, both of which are the exact same consistency (mouth-feel) which made it feel extremely boring to eat and not worth the steep price-tag. All in all on their own these things I’d normally let slide, but stacked on top of each other I feel compelled to warn people that as beautiful as the Witchery is, it’s not perfect. So maybe double check the menu before booking. Might have to say it’s verging on being over-hyped by social media, but if they balanced their menu better I’d be tempted to give it one more try.

We didn’t stay here but had dinner here. We booked a month or two ahead to be sure of a spot here. Staff was very friendly and at times funny. The food was really good, I loved the presentation. Maybe a bit pricy but you also pay for the location and this really isn’t just a restaurant.. it’s an experience. We loved the starters (steak tartare) and the steak as main. For dessert we had the cheese platter with port and this was a great opportunity for us to get to know the Scottish cheese. Would surely come back.

We had a wonderful and enjoyable “teatime” in The Witchery. The price level is very high, but the ambience, the quality of the food and the exemplary service are worth it. Thank you for this great experience! We didn’t have a hotel room and “just” went to The Witchery for tea.

This is a first class venue in every respect. We could not fault any aspect of the hospitality or food provided, perfect, thankyou.

Fantastic stay!!!! What an absolutely stunning room. We stayed in the inner sanctum for our honeymoon, the room is a whole experience. We didn’t want to leave!! We had breakfast brought to our room and it exceeded our expectations by far. I cannot recommend the witchery enough! The restaurant is absolutely fantastic as well.

The restaurant was I think the worst experiences in my life. The food was terrible and quite expensive.

Just awful and pretentious. They abuse their staff by giving them no cafeteria they just rest on the tiny stairs. I have autism and did my best on a trial run but the "guy" in charge didn't give me a chance. I hear he has a bad reputation though

Just tried the restaurant. Location is funky, a mix of Harry Potter +Titanic + Irish pub vibes. Staff was very friendly. Food however is really boring and tastes blend. Overall a bit overpriced. But nice location for a drink and some pictures.

Restaurant only... 2 years ago my husband propose to me in this place. He wrote to resraurant that he intent to do it and we didn't receive nice place in the restaurant. During the proposal waitress interrupt us. It is still in my head. But for balmoral pegeon you could die for and i will be back some day just for that.

Came here for a meal, and it did not disappoint. Great location, with an ancient & mysterious feel. Small menu of traditional choices, beautifully presented and tasting amazing. Attentive but discreet staff. Huge wine list! Perfect for a special meal or romantic dinner for 2.

The mashed potatoes tasted like they came from a bag of powder. Bit of a waste of my money. Ultimately paid €200 for 2 drinks and 1 Lamb Wellington to share…

Romantic restaurant in a very special setting. Staff is well trained and friendly, food well prepared and served, albeit a bit slow. Price wise it’s on the higher side as expected but overall a solid lunch and great memory for us

Had a lovely lunch at the Witchery, we opted for the light lunch menu. The pumpkin soup was absolutely divine, I didn’t want it to end. The restaurant and decor was an experience in itself, it felt very harry pottery. The service was really good, they couldn’t have done more, the noise level was very quiet but you adjust to it. I’m glad we came for a birthday lunch here

Vegans avoid! Had this place booked for months as the setting looks so beautiful, but the atmosphere was off. Felt like we weren't fancy enough to be there, and there and inside it was pretty quiet and a little awkward. My partner had a steak and loved it, but the vegan moussaka was nothing short of a slab of aubergine with some flavourless tomato sauce on top. I had hoped for 30 quid it would be a real showcase of vegan cooking, and taking simple ingredients and flavouring and layering them beautifully. It was very disappointing. Was more flavour in the bread roll. For comparison, had a meal at Makars (highly recommended) that was simply mushroom and potato, but just knew how to make it amazing, and it was half the price. A beautiful space, but unfortunately a rip off. Luckily we were sat in the smaller dining room too as when we checked in at the larger restaurant room, it had a strong smell of drains too.

Really nice place ! Eery atmosphere ideally located!! Book way in advance the place is small and demanded !!

Unfortunately they are unable to accommodate 10 people for dining in the restoran because maximum capacity per reservation is limited to 6 people and they do not accept reservation for two tables(5+5) or (6+4). Very disappointed!

Wonderful time and the service was top tier.

We came here for the ‘Light lunch’ menu after we landed in Edinburgh for the start of our mini moon, and what a start it was. I had a pumpkin soup to start, followed by a mushroom risotto, they sound light but let me tell you that risotto was rich, creamy and cheesy! My partner had Parma ham/melon starter and a steak to follow. She was very full! This light lunch was great. I followed it all with a ‘Rob Roy’ cocktail which packs a punch. It’s strong, full of flavour and sweet. Thanks to all the staff during our lunch that made it so lovely.

The ambience is great. The food was rather disappointing. Three out of four meals were served lukewarm. The Price-performance ratio is not right. Not particularly tasty. SHAME....

We came to the witchery for our last day in Edinburgh to enjoy tea for lunch. I was worried that this wouldn't be enough food but oh was I wrong. Everything was excellent from the service to the ambiance to the food. Perfect way to end our trip!

Afternoon tea for a birthday celebration. Plenty staff but taking very little interest in customer. Food was nice At 130 pounds for 2 I expected some atmosphere but felt staff were just pushing in a few hours before dinner.

Initial thought The Witchery was too dark but my eyes adjusted and I realised its for effect. Staff were very courteous and friendly our waitress was lovely. The food came in a timely manner but we never felt rushed. All 3 courses were excellent and the house wine was very good. Its a bit expensive but worth it for the level of service and the quality of the food.

Fantastic service felt a bit rushed at some points had had 2 courses with an hour but asked to hold off for dessert for a bit to slow it doen the red deer main was amazing!

We went for a special dinner yesterday night. I had high hopes for this restaurant because I loved the vibe in the pictures and the experience surpassed my expectations. Friendly staff, good food, good music and nice atmosphere. Thank you again for a lovely evening.🤍

As I suffer from coeliac disease I had forewarned the restaurant when we booked and was told I wd completely catered for. Well I am afraid that was NOT the case. I was handed a menu that basically had the allergens on each item and there was next to nothing without gluten for me to eat. Considering this is a VERY EXPENSIVE place and had come well recommended online to say I am disappointed is an understatement. In the past the when I have eaten out most of the dishes can be adjusted to my needs. Here all I cd have were a few dishes and literally I was told that was it. Had I have known this there is no way I wd have booked and paid what I did when I cd have gone elsewhere with more on offer and at a more reasonable price. U asked of many of the NORMAL dishes cd be adjusted in anyway for me and was told NO. So all in all not a great experience and I shall not be recommending

Beautiful place. Excellent service and delicious food. Great wine selection as well.