The Piebald Inn in Scarborough

No I haven’t stayed here, but the conduct of the owners on Four in a Bed was appalling. “Claustrophobia” for a perfectly adequate shower and room and then grossly underpaid for what was a lovely room. Foul play and game playing. Awful conduct.

Wow if you like pie this is the place. This is the best corned beef pie I've ever had. There are 52 pies to choose from, so I'll definitely be back even if it is a 2hour drive to get there

I have drove passed The Piebald Inn before but did not realise it was dog friendly. The staff make you most welcome but it is unusual for them to take a name and telephone number as you arrive. ( Informed it was incase you left any articles ? ). There is a section for dog owners which is very good. The selection is overwhelming and was informed to take a picture of the board with the selection of pies and the availability. Went for the Welsh Cob huge portion of filling in the pie with chips and peas a little bit more mint sauce for me but apart from that very good. Will return when next in the area but will do more research of the menu before hand.

Fabulous place... awesome rooms. The food is really good.. The staff are all excellent.. & very helpful

Went with a large group for a family birthday. Amazing food, great service, fantastic value. Will definitely be returning!

Well what can I say…. We saw this place on TV #fourinabed and thought we must have a look next time we are on the East Coast (which with the sun shining today was the day) - 52 Pies on the menu and wow 🤩 what a portion I don’t think we’ll eat for the rest of the week. I had the “Wonky Donkey” and my partner had “The Shire” and honestly no horses in sight 😂 all the pies are named after horses - if ever you are out this way, it’s a little hidden gem of a place. Needless to say no room for a pudding 🍮

Not accommodating when you have a large dog .

52 pies to choose from, we had 4 different pies all came with potatoes & veg a very large portion but very tasty and filling. We sat in the dog area which I was pleasantly surprised nice comfort clean area. Even the dog had her very own pie. Definitely worth a visit but it’s a must to book.

The Piebald Inn has 52 different pies on the menu & Timothy Taylor's Beers, amongst others. It is dog friendly. They have an accessible room with en suite wet room with low level basin, and safety bars on the toilet and shower. For the more able bodied it is 10 minutes walk from Hunmanby Railway station which has services to Filey and Scarborough. Plenty of car parking for guests and visitors. helpful staff, would highly recommend this pub.

Cracking food nice parking for the motorhome

What a great pub. Never seen such a selection of pies. If you can’t find a pie to suit your taste here then there’s summat wrong with you. The portions are huge too. We even had the doggy pie for our pooch and he loved it just as much as we did ours.

Food was amazing. The staff were all very friendly and helpful

Lovely place was made vary welcome staff really friendly and the food is some of the best I've tasted, we stopped overnight in one of the rooms and yet again really clean and everything catered for, would definitely go again 👍

Stop here couple times with our motorhome loverley food

An amazing place to visit, customer service is excellent and the food is just as good. Our dogs especially appreciated the dog friendly pie on the menu, which just made our visit extra inclusive. Definitely worth a visit and really enjoyed our friendly welcome and the generous hospitality, would highly recommend if you’re in the area.. or not divert and indulge.

Great food great service will be back again but next time with the motorhome for a stop over .

Went in for food during a short break in the area. Plenty of parking, great service and even better food. Huge selection of pies and even one for our dog. Will definitely be back the next time we're in the area.

The food at this establishment is great. There's a vast choice of pies and the pie portion is BIG. The staff are great with advice and they are helpful too. If you don't want a pie there's other choices available on the menu. Overall the prices are a little high but the food is good so the price is justified.

Fantastic selection of home cooked pies. Friendly bar staff and a good selection of beer’s. Dogs are more than welcome.

Homely atmosphere, delicious pies and great service. Will 100% be returning.

Excellent food and drinks. The service was outstanding. We will definitely be back to try some more of the delicious pies.

Only used the bar for food but wasn't disappointed, fantastic service and food

Nice pub serving proper pies not a bowl of stew with a puff pastry lid. Decent portion of pie, probably too much and very tasty. Expensive for a pie meal though at around £20. Only let down apart from cost was the number of flies buzzing around. So only 4 stars. They would be better cutting pie portion and reducing price to suit in my opinion and invest in a fly trap!

If you like pie's this is the place for you. Spent the night in a campervan, food was good in the evening plus we had breakfast in the morning, staff were excellent very friendly and helpful.

This is an experience that everyone should have at least once in their life . You get to choose from 52 pies with a range from beef all the way through to vegetarian bypassing pork ,lamb,fish, and Game. The quality of the food is amazing and is like a pie your gran would make you ( no frills piece that's been cut from a proper square pie) between the 3 of us there must have been over a pound of meat 😋 after lunch I didn't eat till the next day . It's worth at least a 30mile trip to eat so if you're in the area, get there if you can 👍

Do you love pies? Well, this is the place to be. My gosh the variety on offer is outstanding and even a doggy pie for your pouch! I would highly recommend booking as it was quite full when we got there. It is dog-friendly, and they do provide water for your pooch. Staff were fantastic, all had a great sense of humour and were very friendly with our little dachshund. The food was amazing and the pie, oh my gosh I need to go back and try another flavour. So much choice from not only the type of meat you want in your pie, vegetarian choices available, but also indian, asian, thai plus others. This is pie heaven!

Best Pie chart we have seen in year's 😅 Excellent food & service Great Team lovely to see. Looking forward to visiting again next year on return to Filey. Even our' Jack Russell 😅was salivating. Thank you 👌

Very welcomed by the people who work at the pub

Great stopover in my campervan, excellent pies and friendly staff , thoroughly enjoyed the experience will definitely be back to try another pie out of the 52 pies available

52 pies to choose from! How the hell I made the decision I'll never know. Something for everyone on the menu whether you like pies or not. Fantastic service, excellent food (very large portions) and very reasonably priced. Will definitely be returning to try another pie.

The pie was great. But the restaurant was too hot. The table was booked for 6.30, but we were not seated till 7.

Beautiful food. We reserved our pies when we booked as there was 7 of us (recommended). I had the steak and Guinness pie and it was gorgeous, so were the chips. They also keep track of how many pies of each variety are left on a whiteboard, so you can keep an eye on it there's any of your favourite left. It's great that they're also dog friendly if they're well behaved. Our furry friend sat nicely with us without us having to worry where we would keep her.

I just ate and did not stay but the food was great l.

Excellent service 60 odd pies to choose from if your on east coast of Yorkshire please call in

Brit Stops pub with great parking facilities.

About 15 minutes walk from our BnB in Hunmanby. The stroll gave us a bit of an appetite for the amazingly huge pies the Piebald serves. Prices from around 16-20+ pounds per meal. Booking recommended through their website.

I was good, food was really nice. Probably a bit pricey for what it is, especially as the mash tastes like the frozen stuff. But still, I love pie. And the people working there were ever so nice :)

Absolutely fantastic pies. Hard to choose from the 52 options! Dog enjoyed the "poochy pie" special!

Nice food but far too over-hyped. The pies have a bit too much cheese for my liking but the lamb was cooked to perfection.

Went for a meal and it was brilliant, good food (52 types of pie) and great service. Totally recommend.

Fabulous pies. You can have a different pie every week of the year. Gets busy. Book early.

Restourant with the Best pies ever with at least 40+ different fillings Motor home parking including most eith electric hookup

Very nice pub, staff are friendly. Really big beer garden which is well looked after.

Unbelievable choice of freshly made delicious pies. Friendly efficient staff. Would definitely visit again.

52 pies to try large portions needed to walk it off afterwards

Excellent food, friendly staff reasonably priced. Will most definitely go again soon.

Excellent food and an impressive choice of 52 pies as well as a regular menu, pies are out of this world. My only one small issue was a personal one in that the veg was not cooked enough for me but everyone else in our party loved them and ate everything. Friendly dogs are also very welcome.

Great beer and amazing choice of pies. 52 varieties!

Visited the piebald from the bay after a recommendation and we weren't disappointed. Great location with good parking. We chose to sit outside as the weather was fab, the whole place was super dog friendly and even did dog pies. The outdoor space was really lovely and comfortable. Massive portions for a great price. Would definitely recommend.

Spot on never stayed just went for the pie it's amazing cheers

If you like pies, you’ll love this place.

The pies were OKISH pastry was poor in my opinion the pie filling was good however, the vegetables were very hard and not athe menu options were available, we almost got charged for someone else's drinks so check your bill

Read about this pie pub extravaganza so went to give it a try. Outstanding so can thoroughly recommend

We recently held my dads suprise 80th birthday celebrations at the Piebald Inn. We had contact with Joe who helped us organise the event prior too and on the day. Joe was absolutely amazing and was such a help with the pre organisation and also delivery on the day! We held the celebrations outside in the lovely terrace area which was a great spot to have an outdoor party. The food, espcially the pies were fantastic and such a huge variety of pies! We really enjoyed the day and we thank Joe and all of the staff on the day for making the event such a smooth running great day! Highly reccomend this place for both small gatherings or just a quick bite to eat! Ruth & Andy Grayson

Spoilt for choice as the pub offers 52 different types of pie Very generous portions served Would advise you book on a weekend as it was very busy at the time we were there Dog friendly and they offer pie for your pooch

We hadn't booked a table but we were still managed to get a table, but probably best to book in. The staff were friendly and because we had a young child with us the waitress asked if we'd like to have child's food to come out when it was ready as the pies took a bit longer. When the food came the portions were huge! Lovely tasty food!! Pies bursting with filling! Only by looking at other reviews, did I find out that we could have asked if we could take the rest home that we couldn't manage to eat! It would have been great if I could have enjoyed it for second time! Thanks

Lovely place and the wides range of pies ever

Horrible middle aged female member of staff with dark hair took great pleasure in making us stand in the rain to have a cigarette with our drinks when a shelter was available and not in use. We went to check out the venue for a family remembrance event but due to her attitude (and the unapetising looking food) we decided on the Horse Shoe inn where we all enjoyed wonderful food and the staff were so friendly. The Piebald gets a "surprising" number of good reviews but also some very disgruntled low reviews regarding the rude staff and poor service. The owner will probably reply to this review to deny or defend as they seem to be in denial to negative reviews

This place is amazing, so many pies to choose from - but go hungry We have been a couple of times now and each time brought home a box with leftovers The pies are to die for, really fantastic quality and although not cheap you certainly get plenty for your money The staff are very welcoming and friendly and efficient and if you have a dog you can take them too (separate section) Thoroughly recommend

Came here for one of their delicious pie meals. Excellent food an incredible choice and lovely friendly staff.

Had a pie here today absolutely delicious, you'll have all on to find another like piebalds Inn.

The Piebald is amazing, but not for the reason you might think. The staff were welcoming (and hah-ha funny) from the moment we walked in, telling us how the menu board worked and showing us to our table. Our meal was great to look at, delicious vegetables and gravy. One of us ordered the spicy Mustang, which had the right level of heat; unfortunately, it all seemed to have a big handful of salt in it. We informed the team, who sent the manager, Tom, over. Tom was great. He told us he had tried the mix, and even the pie I had left and agreed it was overly salty and that something was amiss. He treated us with respect, listened, and even adjusted the bill appropriately. I wish places with bigger brand names knew customer service like the Piebald. We WILL be going again! Oh, try the "Karbadian" ... that WAS a hit!

Popped in got a table food was absolutely outstanding over 52 different pies as well as other normal stuff on the menu Staff was lovly n friendly to

Pies were generously portioned and delicious. Me and my family were impressed with them in every way. Even though we don't own a dog, it's also dog-friendly which is always lovely.

Had better and fuller pies for less money and good quality

Excellent, tasty pies. Do expect big portions. An amazing selection too

Ok food nice. But we ordered ours then had to pick another. Not the same then

Brilliant place with every sort of pie you could wish for. The portions are huge but very tasty. Loved it

Excellent pies, great real chips, good service.

We were a group of 4 adults, 1 child and a dog. We were made very welcome. The beer garden is fantastic. Staff where all very nice. But...... the food......Oh my goodness. Absolutely fantastic. Could not fault any thing here. We all loved it. Will definetly return. Thank you all so much.

Stayed here with my partner for a fatboy slim gig in Scarborough. Lovely room, amazing staff (even gave us a lift to the train station) We’d definitely stay here again & might even bring our whippet next time. Bravo! 🙌🙌🙌🙌

Had a drink saw the food ordered a pie,well worth the price,best pie I've had,that says a lot from a 70yr old devout Yorkshireman! 52 more to try.

Lovely friendly pub, great staff, very helpful with my motorised chair as I didn't have a clue. Also sorted us out with a taxi. Lovely, hearty meals and a brilliant outdoor seating area and large garden. Well worth a visit

We hadn't booked overnight accommodation. We were booked in for an evening meal. Wow! What an amazing choice of pies !! 52 types of pie to choose from. Chicken, beef, lamb, goat, cheese, vegetarian selection, fish, and haggis and blackpudding!!! Different sauces, different accompaniments with the various pie choices. Severed with chunky chips, mash, or baby potatoes. Peas, mushy, or garden, and finally a choice of seasonal vegetables !! Wow, it was delicious 😋

Amazing!!! Food and service incredible even my pooch enjoyed her poochie pie.

What an amazing b&b. Comfy rooms, lovely staff, super pies

Amazing choice of pies, has to be seen to be believed.

What a great concept! 50 pies or so to choose from. Have to say they were really good and packed with meat and/or veg. Service very good too! Will definitely be back but it'll take a while to digest the last pie!!!!!

All I need to say is 52 pies. Fantastic

Great service, friendly and welcoming staff. AMAZING PIES and FOOD. Well worth a look.

Went for a Father’s Day meal. My goodness, the pies - 52 to choose from - were amazing, from the delicious light pastry to the fillings. Accompanied by home-cooked chips (proper chips!!), mash or new potatoes, peas or seasonal veg, all delicious. Portions are generous so take a big appetite with you - although they are happy to pack it up for you to take home if you can’t manage it all. Staff were very pleasant and even though it was busy the wait wasn’t long. Booking a table is advised though not necessary.

This place is a real hidden gem and well worth a visit. Staff was very friendly and helpful on our arrival and the food was served in good time. The pie was on a whole new level and both the wife and myself was both very satisfied with the meal. Would recommend highly.

Yum yum very nice the pub the food and the staff very friendly

I love it here! Great staff, food is excellent, and pick a sunny day and the beer garden is a great place to be. Why the 4 stars? We stayed in our camper for the first time. The lack of toilet facilities after 10pm was a bit of a problem. I appreciate it's not cheap to build something like that but it would make a massive difference. £30 for electric hookup with a £10 voucher to redeem against food/drink. Very dog friendly.

We accidentally found The Piebald Inn. We were looking for a tasty Sunday roast, but in my opinion, we found something superior. As we entered, we were greeted by the staff who were happy and friendly. We sat outside in the beautiful garden in the fantastic sunshine. It was a challenge to decide between the 52 different pies offered after being given the menu. The pies were served in a portion that I can only be described as American-sized and had an incredible taste. It was great to visit The Piebald Inn and enjoy fantastic food at a fantastic price with generous portions.

Been today for the first time, Sunday lunch father's day treat 😋 and what can we say it was divine, and not just the food, but the service was excellent and the staff all worked as a brilliant team, full compliments to all x definitely be back when we're in north Yorkshire again x

Visited the Piebald with our friends, on Wednesday evening. First time we've been, certainly won't be our last. We were greeted on arrival & the menu & some handy hints explained to us, before showing us to our table. We each chose a different pie, which was no mean feat as there were only a few out of the 52 that we didn't fancy ! When they arrived, they all lived up to our expectations. The portions were extremely generous & the pies were absolutely delicious, best pastry ever ! Despite being more than full, we managed to have cheesecake for dessert, they were to die for. The whole experience was perfect from start to finish. The Piebald has a lovely atmosphere. All the staff were extremely friendly, efficient, & knowledgeable about the menu. It's fair to say, everything about our visit surpassed all expectations, perfect sums it up nicely Looking forward to our next visit.

Great pies and can stay in the VW camper in the car park for a fiver.

We stayed in our campervan, had food and drinks in the pub, great atmosphere, friendly staff, dog friendly too even have a pie for the dog😄. Great portion size and there is a pie filling for everyone. Recommended place to stop by.

Great choice of pies. Very friendly staff. The pies we had where very nice and very large portions so go hungry. Definitely worth a visit. We went at lunch time as walk ins but can imagine it does get busy later on.

Excellent selection of food for pie lovers , great service and dog friendly

Pies here are second to none, both the pub room as well as the restaurant room in the back both have a lovely environment, friendly and hard working staff, just keep in mind the pies are piping hot so you will not get them fast but they are worth the wait.

Second time I have been here. Excellent food and reasonably priced. Good service, pleasant staff. Like the availability board so that you can see what pie's are available before you order. Definitely going to go back for those b e a utiful pies.

Fantastic pies. Plenty of vegetarian options too. Also dog friendly and lovely staff.

We stayed one night in our campervan after ringing at short notice. We had a drink when we arrived as too late for food service. We were impressed with allowing us to stay so we booked a table for lunch the next day. The choice of pies is out of this World! We had a lovely beef and Guiness pie made even more special as our little rescue dog Toby enjoyed a pie of his own and we were all made to feel very welcome. We highly recommend this lovely Country pub

Arrived by bike, and the staff were more than happy to unlock their side gate so they could be stored safely. All of the staff were very welcoming and we were quickly shown to our table. 52 pies are available, one for each week of the year. There is a board that is regularly updated with the number of each pie available. Each pie weighs 0.5kg and is served with mash or chips, peas and gravy. Between us we had beef mince, steak and potato and a Christmas dinner pie. The pastry is light and the fillings enormous, we were so stuffed it was hard getting back on the bikes. Staff are more than happy to box up any pie that you can't manage. My advice is to go hungry in order to finish your plate.

Pies are great and 52 choices will be going again

I have just had the Welsh cob pie. It was the best pie I've ever had. I'm no expert when it comes to pies but the portion size was very generous, the pie was packed full of lamb and it tasted absolutely amazing. Myself, my partner and my 4 year old daughter all came out feeling stuffed and satisfied. I would definitely recommend and we will be going again!! I would ring up and book because it does get very full. I did think it was a bit pricey but it was worth every penny

We came for the pie, or pies. 5 Adults and two small children. We each had a different pie filling and all of us were impressed with the quality of food served. We had a table booked so getting a seat wasn't an issue for us. The portions were a good size, and should be more than enough for 99% of people. Great choice of fillings to choose from, so again, everyone will find a couple of choices they want to order. We all came away full and happy. Great service was the icing on the cake.

Loved the fact you can take your well behaved dogs in and enjoy one their wonderful pies...was a lovely experience 😊