GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4.5

Based on 546 opinions finded in 1 websites

site_photo4

Nº 261 in 889 in Scarborough

Score
OpinionsNoteGoogle5464.5

comment_iconOpinions

Thank you to the lovely landlord, staff members, chef and locals of this pub. My partner and I had travelled 3 hours today and made it just in time for lunch (which they served us outside as an exception). Lovely friendly pub which we will be sure to visit again next time we're in the area. Thank you for the warm welcome and delicious lentil cottage pie and scampi- fresh and homemade, hearty food. Thanks everyone.

site_logo

E. P . 2025-04-20

MORE AT Google

Room, location,staff, dinner,breakfast, car parking 10/10

site_logo

Philip King . 2025-04-06

MORE AT Google

Our room was spacious and clean; the bed was really comfortable. We treated ourselves to dinner and breakfast, both of which were delicious. Location is perfect too, being within easy reach of Scarborough, Whitby, and the moors. Will stay again.

site_logo

Fiona O'Connell . 2025-04-06

MORE AT Google

Lovely pub, lovely food, good portion size. Staff were great. Also HM the Queen once visited, so that's all the recommendation you need!

site_logo

m52spy . 2025-03-25

MORE AT Google

We stopped for lunch here. The meals were very good value. £10.95 for haddock & chips.

site_logo

karen hopkinson . 2025-03-17

MORE AT Google

A massive thank you to the whole team at Blacksmiths Arms!👏👏 # a huge choice of breakfast ingredients # amazing home cooked evening meals # gorgeous room with 4 poster bed #very friendly staff

site_logo

Jackie . 2025-02-21

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely evening in the Blacksmith's Arms. Staff were excellent and food was very good. Took part in the Wednesday quiz, which was raising money for the local playgroup. All of our meals (there were four of us) were great value for money - ranging from Bacon burger to sea bass. There were good vegan options as well. Well worth a visit.

site_logo

Stephen Bassett . 2025-02-19

MORE AT Google

HOSTILE! No beers on tap. No food after 2pm. No decent bar snacks. Only public bar dog friendly. Wrong wifi code printed for customers. Pointed out the code error to older female bartender who neither apologised nor corrected it. Told me I was lucky to have been served as they usually close at 3pm. It was only 2.45pm! We finished our drinks & left - not spending time & money in such a HOSTILE environment!

site_logo

Sarah Garroch . 2025-02-19

MORE AT Google

Lovely food and the staff are great!

site_logo

Julie Shaw . 2025-02-09

MORE AT Google

Lovely meal, dog friendly- nice people working there and great food. Would recommend to anyone

site_logo

Lucy Rebecca Mooring . 2025-01-25

MORE AT Google

My wife and I booked for an Evening Meal one Thursday night in January 2025.I gad mushroom soup and forcthe nain course my wife had the grilled goats cheese sald I had the mushroom stroganoff. With 2 glasses of Merlot.Tge food was good,big portions which seems to be standard for this part of Yorkshire. The food was fine,Like the pub it had an 80's vibe.The food was very good but nothing spectacular, a bit like something out of a Mary Berry recipe book.So ir was fine food served with generous portions.

site_logo

STEVE MCGOWAN . 2025-01-23

MORE AT Google

We had a very nice lunch here. The staff were so friendly, food was piping hot and plentiful. . Good ordinary pub food at a fair price. Bar was warm and welcoming - but the staff made it special.

site_logo

Colin Dykes . 2025-01-02

MORE AT Google

Lovely Christmas lunch served with a smile 😁

site_logo

robert gray . 2024-12-21

MORE AT Google

Lovely country pub open fire excellant staff and landlord This pub is a jewel

site_logo

john price . 2024-12-20

MORE AT Google

All 4 in our party enjoyed a lovely xmas meal.

site_logo

Alan Bruce . 2024-12-13

MORE AT Google

Local and within walking distance to where we were staying Food ok and drinks A well run pub and the staff have been there years Quiet, warm and cosy

site_logo

Natasha Dunnachie . 2024-12-05

MORE AT Google

Always have a lovely meal here.

site_logo

Jayne Dodds . 2024-11-23

MORE AT Google

Great food Friendly service Lovely

site_logo

neil pound . 2024-11-13

MORE AT Google

Went for food as stopped in the village. Liked it so much I went back for drinks the next day. Great friendly staff and a proper yorkshire pub (everyone chats to everyone, locals and tourists mix well!)

site_logo

Jack Wood . 2024-11-01

MORE AT Google

I am on the fence with reviewing this place. I like the food and the rooms are fine this may be the most decent pub I’ve ever been to, but the last 2 times I’ve been here there was no fish. The customer service is very good but every time I go I’m really relieved to hear that we’re not eating in the main pub. Overall 3/5 stars

site_logo

Jack Barrington . 2024-10-20

MORE AT Google

Lovely garlic mushrooms, steak pie and scampi. Friendly, Yorkshire service and pub.

site_logo

Will Ridley . 2024-10-20

MORE AT Google

Really nice place. Great food. Good service.

site_logo

Harriet Senar . 2024-10-15

MORE AT Google

Had Sunday lunch here great service and the food was very good.

site_logo

Trevor Easton . 2024-10-12

MORE AT Google

Stayed here last weekend for my partners birthday weekend. Checked in Saturday afternoon and had the gorgeous spacious four poster room with lovely view across the fields. Super quiet on the evening too. Booked a table for an evening meal which was superb, all cooked fresh. Breakfast was spot on..all fresh and best produce used. Tony the host and his wife made us feel so welcome throughout our stay as did all the team. We will definitely be visiting again soon for sure. Thankyou Carol & John.

site_logo

Carol Lee . 2024-10-10

MORE AT Google

Another fantastic meal here on Saturday evening, very accommodating for a fussy eater we had with us! Very dog friendly which is always a bonus for us and everything cooked to order so worth a slight wait Highly recommend, will be back next time we’re at the coast 😊

site_logo

Louise Penney . 2024-09-23

MORE AT Google

2 night stay , great choice for breakfast and a nice evening meal. Friendly staff and clean warm room to stay . Great location between Whitby and Scarborough 👍👍

site_logo

neil andrew . 2024-09-15

MORE AT Google

Whal, whal, whal. AMAZING PLACE. Stopped for lunch and loved the place, from the minute we walked in , to the minute we walked out. The staff were brilliant, attentive, friendly, well mannered The owner should be proud of his staff. The food was lovely and it was piping hot and generous portions. The place was clean, immaculately decorated and walls are decorated like a typical country pub, even proud to say they hosted the Queen and Prince Philip in 2010. And even now the place is fit for royalty. Whatever you do, don't pass by this pub . It's amazing

site_logo

David Clelland . 2024-07-22

MORE AT Google

We went here to watch the Euro final The food was dome of the best pub food I have had. Great size portions piping hot. Service great and friendly staff definitely would recommend.

site_logo

Ruth Mullins . 2024-07-15

MORE AT Google

Been here twice now , fantastic place , lovely food , lovely people , will definitely return 👍🏻

site_logo

Jennie Mallinson . 2024-07-14

MORE AT Google

Had a very nice meal in here, home made food not the standard pub grub, and they had a very nice bottle of whiskey available too which was a welcome treat. All in all a very nice meal, great service and pleasant early evening meal, definitely recommended.

site_logo

Kevin Guest . 2024-07-13

MORE AT Google

Stopped off for an evening meal (at 7.40pm on Friday 5 July 2024, noting other pubs stop serving food a lot earlier!) working our way back from Scarborough to Whitby on our holiday in Yorkshire. Lovely country cosy atmosphere pub with friendly staff. After a refreshing Grapefruit gin & lemonade (handpicked by the lady), my wife & I both had the Horseshoe gammon & all the trimmings. Very tasty it was too, and you could tell it was proper hand cooked and not the mass produced type. With our stomachs full, we carried on to our touring caravan campsite in Higher Normanby a lot for the better for a tasty meal.

site_logo

John Griffiths . 2024-07-08

MORE AT Google

Fantastic food. Would go back next time in Yorkshire.good service, friendly.

site_logo

Sandra Freer . 2024-06-26

MORE AT Google

Just popped in for a pint in the bar. Nice atmosphere and lighting.good location.

site_logo

Philip Mcgarrick . 2024-06-23

MORE AT Google

Great little pub with great food and friendly atmosphere

site_logo

Andy Eggleden . 2024-06-11

MORE AT Google

We always go for food at the Blacksmiths' arms when on holiday, but never again after being charged 60p for tap water..disgraceful...

site_logo

Carl Gallagher . 2024-06-03

MORE AT Google

Excellent food. Really tasty. Staff were very helpful and welcoming. Would definitely recommend

site_logo

Julia Allan . 2024-05-26

MORE AT Google

This is a great example of a traditional style Inn. The village is lovely, the pub is good, and everything is much better maintained and cleaned than most such places. The staff were super friendly and helped us out a lot. There is ample parking, and the road is quiet at night.

site_logo

Stephen Wattam . 2024-05-12

MORE AT Google

An unexpected stay away from our home in the Midlands due to a family emergency. Tony, Debbie & all of the staff (especially Claire) were very kind & supportive which made a difficult time much easier. Starting the day & getting back from daily hospital visits was just what we needed, a nice welcome, excellent food & a good selection of drinks. Thanks very much to you all. We enjoyed the area too, so if we came back we wouldn't stay anywhere else.

site_logo

Andrew Lewis . 2024-05-11

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely stay, would definitely stay again

site_logo

Lee Hugill . 2024-04-28

MORE AT Google

£18.25 for 2 pints of Madri shandy, a pint of coke, and pint of lime and soda And an unfriendly welcome

site_logo

Huw Thomas . 2024-04-28

MORE AT Google

Just home from a 2 night stay at The Blacksmiths Arms, Cloughton. We really enjoyed our stay. The staff were lovely, food very good, cleanliness great. The atmosphere was relaxing. Will be back. Thanks guys.

site_logo

Jayne Hall . 2024-04-25

MORE AT Google

All the staff were lovely and welcoming. Great food and service and the place was spotless. Really enjoyed our 3 nights stay.

site_logo

Carol Durand . 2024-04-14

MORE AT Google

Didn't stay over but popped in for food after a walk. The food was fantastic, and the service was amazing. Couldn't have done any more for me and the dogs. Absolutely recommend for anyone in the area

site_logo

Laura Harris . 2024-04-13

MORE AT Google

Good local village pub. Great beer, great food, friendly staff and a great atmosphere.

site_logo

Paul Dalby . 2024-03-16

MORE AT Google

Very nice meal indeed. Highly recommended !

site_logo

Alan Brown . 2024-02-20

MORE AT Google

I didn't stay for the night, I was there for a family meal. An excellent atmosphere, great Landlord & Landlady. A wonderful Sunday dinner, good portions, fairly priced. Very professional waiting-on staff. All in all a great experience, recommended.

site_logo

R3 Real Road Racing . 2024-02-13

MORE AT Google

Just stayed for two nights room excellent staff amazing food delicious highly recomend will definitely stay again.

site_logo

Kathryn . 2024-02-05

MORE AT Google

Attempted to make a lunchtime table booking for 4 at end of February. All I got as a response is 'we're open between 12 & 2 via e-mail. That, in our opinion, is not good marketing or customer service. I would suggest avoid.

site_logo

Jeff Looby . 2024-02-02

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in Yorkshire and The Humber

restaurant_img
4.5

688 Opinions

location-iconMain St, Seamer, Scarborough YO12 4PS, United Kingdom
outdoor_seating_344333takeaway_344333delivery_344333

Great service and the food was nice

restaurant_img
4.5

1203 Opinions

location-iconNewlands Rd Scarborough
British
outdoor_seating_153609takeaway_153609delivery_153609

We booked a table as this was a highly rated place for a roast dinner near Scarborough. I had called ahead and enquired about vegetarian roast dinner options for my girlfriend. On the phone I was assured there were multiple options and although this technically was the case, neither were necessarily the best accompaniments for a roast (stuffed pepper and stuffed pasta). The service was great and we had a lovely table in a corner and the atmosphere was cozy and great. I ordered the beef roast dinner and my girlfriend ordered the stuffed peppers with a roast. The food came relatively quickly. The selection of vegetables was nice and was a welcomed change to have red cabbage and cheesy leeks although they would have been a bit more generous with the portion size as it was to share between the 2 of us. It would have also been nice to have some optional extras on the menu like a portion of cauliflower cheese. The roast dinner also only came with 2 roast potatoes which were really big but would have preferred 3 or 4 smaller ones. It came with a jug of gravy however it was meat gravy and there was not a vegetarian alternative but luckily my girlfriends stuffed peppers were quite saucy so her dinner wasn't dry. My beef was nice however it was slightly chewy and could have been hotter coming out and was only kept warm by hot gravy. Bit of an irrelevant side note but the loos were really nice! Everything else was really lovely and we did have a nice meal and I appreciate it is a small country pub in Scarborough but if you advertise as vegetarian friendly then I think it needs to follow through fully - for example being advised they don't have a veggie gravy upon ordering the dinner or even having a veggie alternative. I'm sorry to be negative, especially when we did have such a lovely time (hence the 4 stars) bu my girlfriend has been vegetarian for 5 years and situations like these feel very frustrating and easily avoidable if staff are more aware and informed.

restaurant_img
4.5

3574 Opinions

location-icon161 Church Street
Italian
outdoor_seating_149846takeaway_149846delivery_149846

Great place can see why it’s busy. Food was brilliant and the staff were lovely. Would definitely recommend and return.

restaurant_img
4.5

18106 Opinions

location-icon14 Pier Road
Seafood
outdoor_seating_151044takeaway_151044delivery_151044

Superb food , with excellent, friendly and helpful staff

restaurant_img
4.5

291 Opinions

location-icon4 Mitford St, Filey, YO14 9DY, United Kingdom
outdoor_seating_355360takeaway_355360delivery_355360

Come here every week and without fail service and quality of both food and staff are excellent.