Based on 4.380 opinions finded in 4 websites
Based on 4.380 opinions finded in 4 websites
Nº 1001 in 1330 in Cheshire West and Chester
Nº 198 of 252 British in Cheshire West and Chester
Opinions
What a great find in Chester. Walked along the canal to this pub. It was hopping asked if we could join a table with a two couples. Ordered drinks at the bar and stuck up a conversation with the people. A good craic as they say. The food was good and plentiful. Vegetarian mushroom pie and fish and chips. Both delicious.
robren88 . 2025-04-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Use to love this place and reccomend it to everyone up until today! I went there around 7pm with my friend and my sleeping 14month old in the pram to have a non-alcoholic drink outside in the sun to have a long catch up since having a baby but was told children are not allowed. Never have I felt so disgusted to hear this so we went to Hickory's instead who were extremely accommodating to my friend, Myself & Baby who was fast asleep, thank you to Hickory's! Won't be reccomending this judgy place again who are not young human friendly!
Denise . 2025-04-21
MORE AT Google
The food was decent. But I don't recommend the pulled beef croquettes. The atmosphere was lovely, the service was really nice and fast. Just expensive for the amount you get. But honestly lovely experience and would go again.
Connor Townley . 2025-04-20
MORE AT Google
Beautiful traditional building with warm and inviting atmosphere. Food was pinnacle of our visit, made to perfection, makes you miss home. Lovely place that has to be visited again.
roseified . 2025-04-15
MORE AT Google
As always this is a great pub. Extensive selection of real ales.
Mike McBride . 2025-04-15
MORE AT Google
This is a great venue with an excellent selection of real ales and good value. However, the service is significantly let down by several bar staff who consistently avoid eye contact and prioritize serving known customers, which happens on almost every visit. While some staff are fair and efficient, a noticeable number show clear favoritism and possess negative attitudes, even displaying a sense of superiority.
Phill H . 2025-04-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited here on a weekend break to Chester , it was really lovely and busy , as it was Saturday afternoon, we were greeted by a lovely member of staff , who managed to get us a table in a lovely room at the rear of the pub , we had a superb meal accompanied by good wine , and fabulous service , thank you all so much for a great Saturday afternoon
Susan Lewis . 2025-04-13
MORE AT Google
Another lovely Sunday lunch in one of the best pubs in Chester. On the canalside with lovely views and a beautiful outside eating and sitting area, some of it is undercover. The food is amazing and that's why we keep coming back.
Angela L . 2025-04-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Hadn't been for years loved going again I was having a look round planning on having my birthday there and it was hubbies birthday the day we visited when I was having a look round the far room.a young blonde haired girl started shouting full blast at me can I help you erm excuse me can I help you I felt embarrassed and said don't worry were buying a drink I felt like walking out there and then
Susan Ramsay . 2025-04-10
MORE AT Google
Great Pub on the canal bank. Great choice of ales and lovely ambiance. Always a good meeting place !
louis73 . 2025-04-08
MORE AT Google
Busy pub but bar staff were great. A fine pint of Champion Mild by @HobsonsBrewery supped.
Christopher Jazwinski . 2025-04-04
MORE AT Google
Never fails. Always worth a visit.
Gary Beigel . 2025-03-30
MORE AT Google
Great vibe and food looking great, definitely a menu worth trying.
Adrian Pembleton . 2025-03-29
MORE AT Google
The atmosphere is nice but the service is poor
Selcuk Arslan . 2025-03-26
MORE AT Google
Lovely locals pub.. fabulous nuanced menu and affordable, high-quality wine list…on quiet canal… will definitely be back
Gail Weinnig . 2025-03-23
MORE AT Google
Always a favourite of mine when in Chester. Great location, beers and food. Handy for the last train home as well 😁
Kevin Lawrence . 2025-03-23
MORE AT Google
Good food. Great atmosphere. Friendly service.
Ian J France . 2025-03-20
MORE AT Google
What a find! Walked from the Mill Hotel along the canal. The place was packed! We asked to join a couple of couples. Had a good crack! Food was tasty and plentiful.
Renee S. . 2025-03-19
MORE AT Google
Excellent service from all the staff, extra mention for the young man who went above and beyond every times. food was great and ambience was excellent. Looking forward to the summer and being able to drink a plum porter in the sun.
Phil Spencer . 2025-03-15
MORE AT Google
Always busy here, good selection of drinks, great place to eat too. Good choice for a start of a night out.
Gail . 2025-03-12
MORE AT Google
Very busy vibrant place on a Wednesday evening. Loved it
rae rendell . 2025-03-12
MORE AT Google
Lovely canal side location for a drink outside.
S Sage . 2025-03-09
MORE AT Google
I love Harkers, have been going for years and it has always been my go-to when in Chester - its child-free and dog-friendly policy is great. However, the last couple of visits have been a disappointment for a couple of reasons. Firstly, the quality and price of the food recently has been a concern. I dont mind paying more when the food is great, but the standard has really slipped recently. Portions are smaller, and the quality doesnt seem to be as good as in the past. What youre now paying is restaurant prices for a pub meal and not a fantastic pub meal at that... Its a real shame. My second concern is that they really need to sort out the loos. On a recent visit we were sat at the table nearest the loos as one of our party had mobility issues. However, every time someone went in or out the smell has overwhelming. I understand that the loos have no windows, so its always going to be a challenge, but this was pretty awful (and it was January).... Our last trip to Chester it was suggested we go to Harkers as usual but we decided to go to a restaurant instead. Enough said. Come on Harkers, sort it out...
Sheila Walker . 2025-03-03
MORE AT Google
Only stopped for a drink on the way to the station. Lovely pub, food looked nice and staff very friendly and helpful.
Jayne Savage . 2025-03-02
MORE AT Google
We where a party of 7. 2 friends ordered the steak which was mediocre. We mentioned this to a member of staff and received attitude. No knowledgement and no response. Shame as the rest of the staff seemed lovely
Great Scott . 2025-03-02
MORE AT Google
Great traditional pub, with real fires
Michael Solan . 2025-03-02
MORE AT Google
This classic pub has loads of good old fashioned character. Very friendly staff and a wide selection of cask ales. I will definitely be going back.
Andrew G . 2025-02-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Very tasty food and friendly service. Go for the steak mmmm
maarten jansen . 2025-02-28
MORE AT Google
Good beer and food. Good selection of real ale 6 to 7. Busy on a Monday night! Worth a visit.
David Bowes . 2025-02-25
MORE AT Google
Didn't eat here Cracking pub ,great location , friendly staff & good beer My one gripe is that I ordered what should have been a dark bitter & the young man serving went to get it from another pump , but it was not a dark bitter he served me, however it was very nice so let it be
John Gallagher . 2025-02-24
MORE AT Google
The Old Harker's Inn on Russell street is an excellent upmarket pub and restaurant we visited on our two day trip to Chester.Its an excellent pub and restaurant thats housed in a former Victorian canalside warehouse on it's ground floor. The interior is superb with wooden flooring and many interesting fixtures and features and superb wooden furniture and when we visited here it was very busy.Its our first trip to here in about three year's and it's just as good as it's ever been. We visited many pub/bars and restaurants on our trip to Chester and this brilliant pub and restaurant was up there with all of the other superb place's we visited.On our visit we had a few glasses of beers from a really good brewery called Phoenix brewery that were perfectly served and were well priced considering the pub we were in and where this pub is located. The Old Harker's Inn is a fantastic pub and restaurant thats well worth a visit for a real ale or a tasty meal.(This is my 2nd review of the Old Harkers Inn). Opening Hours. Monday-Saturday-10.30-23.00. Sunday-10.30-22.30.
Stephen Kelly . 2025-02-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had a lovely sunday roast here with my family. The vegan wellington was so nice, and my family all enjoyed the beef. Great portion sizes and extra gravy available at no charge! Sides of pigs in blankets and stuffing were a little pricey but big portion. Everyone super happy and will definitely come back!
Charlotte Layton . 2025-02-24
MORE AT Google
What an amazing pub and restaurant. The service, beer and food is top notch snd added to the beautiful surroundings, it makes for a brilliant experience. There’s even table service for beers and our server Owen was attentive and friendly and great at his job, which topped off an enjoyable visit perfectly.
Christopher Lewis . 2025-02-22
MORE AT Google
Everything was so delicious that I have no words. We haven't been to such a friendly place for a long time - the service was lovely! Thank you.
Bartek Kuryło . 2025-02-16
MORE AT Google
Used to be a nice pub for a drink, but when did it become so expensive? Eye watering prices and a real shock when it comes to paying! Ouch! London prices in Chester. A pity, because it's a nice pub for a drink.
Brian Brownbill . 2025-02-14
MORE AT Google
Had food and drinks. Excellent service and quality. Will come again. Highly recommend 👌
Ray Spinks . 2025-02-13
MORE AT Google
Always nice to come across a place that oozes history and is clearly a popular watering hole & eatery for many generations. A short walk along the canal from our hotel one weekday early evening, it looked inviting and was quite full, although spacious enough for noise levels to be perfectly acceptable. Very pleasant staff found us a table although we hadn't booked, followed by some very nice beer from a local brewery. Food was top notch, perfectly cooked, hot and pleasantly presented. A shared dessert completed a very nice meal. The history of the place as a former shoe factory is very nicely depicted, and an excellent guide explains how the Arms came into being despite some technical difficulties with the former structure! Not cheap, but very good value in my opinion for fare & ambience.Fascinating, and definitely one to revisit on a future stay. Plaudits to the owners & staff for creating this fine pub, highly recommended.
SolarPanelPhil . 2025-02-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Wonderful gastropub, great atmosphere (busy Friday night - glad we had booked!). Prawns and squid perfectly cooked, fall-off-the-bone lamb and the most amazing sea trout dish ever. Friendly and professional service. A very enjoyable experience - faultless!
Graham Rigby . 2025-02-02
MORE AT Google
3 course dinner.. Buffalo chicken wings with blue cheese dip: 5 wings..spicy, bigger than expected and oh so tasty. Rump steak with peppercorn sauce: Steak was beautifully cooked (medium), sauce was nice enough but no no visible peppercorns, crushed or whole. Tasted nice though. Sticky toffee pudding: Disappointing. The pudding itself was cold and dense, rather like a cake that was a few days too old, the sauce & ice cream were minimal...
Paul B . 2025-02-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great atmosphere as usual, very attentive staff, great food and drinks, many thanks. Can recommend the crispy beef salad.
Steve Hayes . 2025-01-31
MORE AT Google
An outing with friends, great location with a good wine and beer selection. The food can be improved on however we would like to try it again to give the venue a second chance, by ordering other dishes.
Brammetje . 2025-01-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
What a fabulous place. Excellent food and staff who understood our family group totally. We had brilliant service and total understanding regarding a family member who has special needs. Special mention to staff members Mark, Samantha and Hamish who were so supportive and understanding
Fi . 2025-01-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Everything a pub should be and more. Spacious, chilled, excellent beers on tap, food first class. I could and have spent hours in this place
Steve Savory . 2025-01-25
MORE AT Google
With a wide range of hand pulled beers and excellent food, this is an absolute must visit for anyone going to Chester. We were advised to book even for a Monday evening and could see why, as when we arrived at 7pm it was already full of drinkers and diners. The bar staff and restaurant staff were all very friendly and welcoming. The food was that good, that we decided to book for the Tuesday evening as well and just like Monday it was full again. Not hard to see why it was, the food was great and all the plates went back to the kitchen empty, which shows how good it is.
johnroberts26 . 2025-01-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fab traditional pub. No music, no TV. Busy, great food and drink choice and very sociable staff and customers. Loved it.
Allyson Daoud . 2025-01-23
MORE AT Google
Food not up to usual excellent standard. Chips very undercooked. Service slow which is unusal. Despite these glitches always recommend Harkers.
Dianna Ellson . 2025-01-23
MORE AT Google
Generally still a good place for a drink or food. Chips were not on top form on my recent visit, but the fish was very good.
Stephen Few . 2025-01-22
MORE AT Google
Came here for a lunchtime meal with a group of friends. Food and service was great. A very refreshing change to have an adults only pub without a load of unruly kids running around the place, ruining the atmosphere.
A M . 2025-01-20
MORE AT Google
Always my first port of call on my way from the station to the city centre. Good range of real ale on offer, decent food and good staff.
Paul . 2025-01-15
MORE AT Google
Expensive pub excellent atmosphere and staff
Cameron Evans . 2025-01-15
MORE AT Google
Great place for a drink and food
simon tipping . 2025-01-14
MORE AT Google
Great pub. Decent food, (had a delicious Lamb dish this time), good beer selection, great atmosphere and service.
Craig . 2025-01-13
MORE AT Google
First class service and food. Impressive selection of drinks. Highly recommend.
Emily Jones . 2025-01-11
MORE AT Google
Always great!! I come every time I visit Chester, just perfect! Congrats and thanks for a excellent friendly service!
Carlos Villota . 2025-01-06
MORE AT Google
Had agreat new years eve there. Atmosphere and food was superb. Highly recommended 👌
Sammy perder44 . 2025-01-06
MORE AT Google
Excellent food, friendly staff and lovely atmosphere.
Mark Price . 2025-01-06
MORE AT Google
Great pub. Good beer, food, atmosphere and no kids whooopeeee! The staff were brilliant to
Tracey Leake . 2025-01-04
MORE AT Google
Great popular pub for relaxing by the canal. Excellent food, drink and service.
frank carman . 2025-01-03
MORE AT Google
My daughter booked us a meal for two here. Good food choices for our dietary needs. Great veggie fish cakes , gluten free steak pie plus g.f sticky toffee pudding were hot,tasty and enjoyed. Good choices re wines too. Set in a very cosy,welcoming environment Plus very friendly and attentive staff . Our celebrations for my special birthday were indeed special 🥳❤️,thank you all at Harkers .
Julie Robinson . 2025-01-02
MORE AT Google
Best Sunday roast I've had apart from the ones I cook myself. Can't recommend this enough - perfect
Paul Glover . 2024-12-29
MORE AT Google
We enjoyed a terrific meal, starters were novel and delicious, and halibut perfectly prepared. It’s not fine dining, but great value and the service and atmosphere there are always the best we have found in the area.
Phil Pitcher . 2024-12-26
MORE AT Google
Came for a family meal on Saturday 21st December and although it was packed the atmosphere was lovely, the staff were fantastic and the food was delicious. The brass band coming into play was a lovely festive touch too. We'll definitely be coming back!
Barbara Guest . 2024-12-23
MORE AT Google
Fantastic meal Fantastic Pub and even better staff cannot fault it in any way
Robert Shaw . 2024-12-15
MORE AT Google
Always great service here and prices are reasonable for the city centre. Recommended
Steve Quinlan . 2024-12-13
MORE AT Google
Place was really busy but the helpful staff managed to squeeze us in. We only wanted a light lunch but it was excellent, just what we needed. Even though they were very busy the staff were extremely pleasant
Pamp . 2024-12-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We booked a table for Saturday 7th 12.30 till 14.30 great service great food and great atmosphere, even though they were very busy the staff worked very hard and had time for us ,we will be back every time we visit chester many thanx jon and karen
Jon T . 2024-12-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Always an enjoyable and consistent experience at Harkers.....cosy ambiance, super food and friendly professional service. However...our experience last Saturday lunchtime marred by a group of very loud and ignorant men at the next table, old enough to know better than to behave like childish yobs. Would be good if staff could be trained to deal with these louts who spoil the Harker's reputation.
OZZY L . 2024-12-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My wife and I had a very nice dinner...food was lovely...but the staff were fantastic...we had some noisy people near us and the staff bent over backwards to help and offered to move us to a quiet table. Beer was jolly nice too. Overall very impressed...thanks.
alan h . 2024-12-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Old Harkers Arms on the canal near Chester Train Station and the Mill Spa Hotel is at the heart of Chester.Excellent!
Mumbo14U . 2024-12-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Having made an error on our booking I believe the young guy may have been the Manager fitted three of us in to what was a very busy night. Food was excellent and came quickly allowing us to get to our gig on time. Thank you,
Gary Johnstone . 2024-12-07
MORE AT Google
Good selection of drinks. Friendly staff. Ideal for the Train Station. The food selection looked good.
Keith Evans . 2024-12-04
MORE AT Google
What's not to like. Absolutely amazing food drinks and atmosphere
Keith Ryder . 2024-11-30
MORE AT Google
The Old Harkers Arms, Chester. Quality pub and restaurant. Superb selection of well kept real ale. I had the Cheshire Cat bitter which is a lovely pint. They were doing a ‘pie week’ and what a menu that was - absolutely delicious. Needs to be on more than once a year it’s so good. A very well kept place. Bar man / owner had been there 12 years.
William Blower . 2024-11-24
MORE AT Google
We had a lovely meal last night. Everything we ordered was extremely delicious, we were not disappointed. The staff were very friendly and attentive. They made sure we were satisfied with our meal and nothing was too much trouble for the waiter. I ordered the Goan Aubergine curry. It was divine
Clare Theresa . 2024-11-17
MORE AT Google
Our favourite pub. ADULTS only...great atmosphere...amazing food & super friendly staff 😋 our go to place when in CHESTER.
Trish Griffiths . 2024-11-17
MORE AT Google
Great service, good food, lively atmosphere, only downside is the noise level which can be a pain at times definitely a great location for an evening out though 😉
Steve Holloway . 2024-11-10
MORE AT Google
What a fabulous pub - a great selection of pump beers, lagers, ciders and wine plus a fabulous selection of food available. A very welcoming pub and I chose a walking guide from there to do a walking tour with. Yes, it was printed in 2013 and started inaccurate as there was pavement works going on but it was a good way to spend the day. Also ended up here with my mate Steve going back in for more of the Cheshire Cat!! Lol
Mark P . 2024-11-09
MORE AT Google
Never been here before, but it was great. They have a great selection of beers including zero alcohol Guinness..! We didn't have any food, but the food that wizzed past us looked very nice. Great atmosphere..!
Alan Davies . 2024-11-09
MORE AT Google
Consistenly my favorite place to meet up with friend
Katie Bristow . 2024-11-08
MORE AT Google
The Old Harker Arms in Chester is a charming, canal-side pub located just a 5-minute walk from Chester railway station and around a 15-minute stroll from the historic Chester Cross. Known for its classic British menu, I tried the Beer-Battered Fish and Chips and opted for garden peas instead of mushy peas, which was a nice touch. The fish was coated in a crispy, golden beer batter, and the chips were thick and perfectly cooked, balancing a crunchy exterior with a fluffy inside. The pub also boasts an impressive selection of craft ales, which makes it easy to find a great pairing for your meal. The combination of traditional fare, great beers, and a convenient location makes The Old Harker Arms an excellent choice for anyone visiting Chester.
PF . 2024-11-05
MORE AT Google
A lovely place for a drink friendly staff
Russel Green . 2024-11-04
MORE AT Google
Great location on the canal, great beer, and food lovely served by very friendly staff.
Michael Edwards . 2024-11-02
MORE AT Google
Lively pub Crowded and noisy in a good way. Dogs welcome if well behaved Staff attentive and friendly Food good Good beers and red wine We went early in the evening Prefer daytime as it's quieter Dog loved it! 🐕🐾🦴
Revd Jo Pemberton . 2024-10-31
MORE AT Google
We had a fantastic evening. Nine of us, ranging in age from 30s to well over 70, and all enjoyed it. The staff were friendly and super efficient. The food was gorgeous, in generous portions. Thank you so very much for this very special time.
Sara Cass . 2024-10-28
MORE AT Google
Lovely meals in a really quaint pub. Excellent service too. A must go to place of every in Chester.
Evesy . 2024-10-27
MORE AT Google
Great pub, staff were amazing, food was amazing highly reccomend!
Sam Hughes . 2024-10-24
MORE AT Google
The Old Harkers Arms in Chester is probably the best pub in the World! Scenically placed by the canal, with great food but it's the staff that really make it. They literally can't do enough for you, always welcoming and attentive. I started going about a year ago and now travel to Chester every week just to visit this pub. I don't know how they maintain such a level of service across all staff members but I'm never disappointed. Special shout out to Mark who, having finished his shift, with coat on and half way out the door, spotted my nearly empty glass and came back in to pour and deliver me another pint before he left! I tell all the Uber drivers that take & fetch me about how good it is and they always agree it's got a great reputation!
Darren Tye . 2024-10-22
MORE AT Google
Found a waitress curt in service. But didn't let this spoil our meal.
Inge Bevan . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Nice canal side location. Busy on a Saturday afternoon. Quite expensive. Didn't eat but the food looked good. Staff attentive. "No energy drink" policy which I admire and am frustrated by in almost equal measure. Will go back, but not in a rush to do so.
Jamie C . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Enjoyable pint, good selection of ales. Was nice to sit outside by the water. Did not try the food but prices looked reasonable.
Nigel Wright . 2024-10-21
MORE AT Google
Always enjoy the atmosphere here. Beer and food are excellent.
Philip Gent . 2024-10-20
MORE AT Google
A busy pub with good selection of ales/beers. Didn't have food but plenty of punters eating.
Graham Ford . 2024-10-20
MORE AT Google
One of the most authentic destination pubs in Chester. Housed in a an old canal warehouse with many original features, sensitively restored. Canal-side outdoor seating, great service, extensive menu. Allows dogs throughout, but not children.
Ben Edwards . 2024-10-20
MORE AT Google
Good beers. Nice ambiance. Gets busy and noisy
Roger Langhorne . 2024-10-18
MORE AT Google
The Old Harkers Arms in Chester is probably the best pub in the World! Scenically placed by the canal, with great food but it’s the staff that really make it. They literally can’t do enough for you, always welcoming and attentive. I started going about a year ago and now travel to Chester every week just to visit this pub. I don’t know how they maintain such a level of service across all staff members but I’m never disappointed. Special shout out to Mark who, having finished his shift, with coat on and half way out the door, spotted my nearly empty glass and came back in to pour and deliver me another pint before he left! I tell all the Uber drivers that take & fetch me about how good it is and they always agree it’s got a great reputation!
Daz T . 2024-10-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely pub, nice outdoor seating w. Heating
Dougie Nightingale . 2024-10-16
MORE AT Google
Adequate menu - not all items were available. Food was mostly enjoyed though some vegs were a little undercooked. The brownie was far far too sweet. Portions were a decent size Very good service despite being busy. A popular eatery, Booking recommended. Rather too noisy in some areas
301lisa33 . 2024-10-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Sunday roast was lovely, and the lady who served us was really attentive
Laura Brown . 2024-10-13
MORE AT Google
Great gluten free choice, as well as beer. Typical English place
Tabitha Tschumi . 2024-10-13
MORE AT Google
Travelled 2 hours as a friend said the food was nice got there to be told they dont accept kids !!! Nowhere on google dose it say no kids !! If your looking for a nice family pub this is not the place to go
hayley fallon . 2024-10-11
MORE AT Google
These schedules may not be completely accurate on special days. Please always confirm with the restaurant
Similary restaurants in North West
5539 Opinions
I cannot thank the Architect enough! We had one of my friend’s hen party dinners with you and we were so impressed. I dropped off a few decorations the day before and when we arrived, we were shown to our private room and everything was perfect! The staff went above and beyond. As always, the food and drinks were amazing and such great quality. Thank you for a perfect evening!
1468 Opinions
Food was amazing staff as well .location is beautiful by the canal with a beautiful beer garden .prices are just right and good range of beer
1350 Opinions
What a great few days we spent in the Pub. Tasha(and staff) were absolutely brilliant. Great atmosphere, cheap drinks, sports. What more could 35 men want. I hope to be back there soon. Well done Tasha.
3055 Opinions
Food was lovely staff was rude we had 7 drinks all was flat so i pick up the tray and walked up and seen the manager who then told me to take them to the bar instead of taking them off me she was very abrupt the bar man said he would make fresh these where also flat when he brought them over to us we said they was still flat we was told there is nothing wrong with them and then said if u got a problem im getting my manger who came over with an attitude problem and offered us a refund on the drinks all in all the staff are not friendly at all and hygiene needs to be desperately looked at as staff was taking out food with hair not tied back and picking up glasses from the rim instead of using a tray then on there phones then proceeding to carry food out also there was one guy wearing blue gloves on top of white heat protective cloves who was clearly a food handler in the kitchen handing out knives and forks thats a big no no in my opinion