Based on 446 opinions finded in 2 websites
Based on 446 opinions finded in 2 websites
Nº 1401 in 2913 in Edinburgh, City of
Nº 184 of 413 British in Edinburgh, City of
Opinions
If you are looking for an old school drinking pub with character, you couldn't pick better! Doesn't serve food to save confusion.
Mary O'Hara . 2024-10-02
MORE AT Google
Great local bar on the southside. Had come up from Leith for the day and had never visited the establishment. Quiet initially but quickly fills up. There is a cellar bar underneath for live music or private functions.
Paddy O'Connell . 2024-09-29
MORE AT Google
First time visit recently to see a jazz trio in the cellar bar Loved the place, cosy, intimate atmosphere, great selection of beers at reasonable prices and good service. Will definitely be back.
John Slater . 2024-09-17
MORE AT Google
The most unfriendly and cliquy pub I have been in. I’ve marked service as one star but the girl that served us was excellent however overall it really wasn’t the most comfortable place to visit as a first time customer.
Pam C . 2024-08-27
MORE AT Google
Quaint cellar bar. Stage for well-known and lesser-known artists.
Rainer Linder . 2024-08-20
MORE AT Google
Fantastic Cellar Bar for live music
Martin Selley . 2024-08-18
MORE AT Google
Good spot for live music, real underground old school bluesy feel to it. Decent craft beer
Ian Wilson . 2024-08-07
MORE AT Google
Some of the best bar staff in the city and hands down one of the best pints of Guinness you'll get.
Liam Quinn . 2024-07-23
MORE AT Google
Hadn't been here for years but a great edinburgh bar, really buzzing when went...
Jon Stembridge . 2024-07-08
MORE AT Google
Great place for a soul do indeed!
Thommy Rinke . 2024-05-15
MORE AT Google
The beer was good, and the toilets were clean. Great place to spend an afternoon.
Tom Petcher . 2024-05-05
MORE AT Google
A comfortable, cosy cellar bar with a nice atmosphere, helpful staff and good live music.
GB Audio . 2024-04-23
MORE AT Google
Booked out the cellar for a birthday party. Prices were reasonable, staff were stellar, and the whole place was very accommodating to any and all needs me and my guests had.
Ivan Wainwright . 2024-04-15
MORE AT Google
Hand pulled Scottish beers always on tap and decent keg range too. A nice corner of Marchmont with great staff. 👍
David Gardiner . 2024-03-09
MORE AT Google
Never had anything to eat .....but Le Beat Club Night(early evening 6pm) is a must with a great mixed crowd and choice of drinks. Ohh and Casey our "dispenser of drinks " was entertaining 😆
Hamish Mason . 2024-03-08
MORE AT Google
Great little pub, friendly people and good drinks!
Sorrel Allen . 2024-02-12
MORE AT Google
Was in the bar Friday 2nd Feb in the evening.. terrible service at the bar . If you are paying a high price for a pint u expect a full pint . Staff training needed I think.
Wesley gill . 2024-02-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Someone local took us here after we'd been playing at Marchmont St. Giles for Lucia. Lovely pub but not at all local for me😉
Phil Lyon . 2023-12-16
MORE AT Google
Live music on a friday night. Beautiful bar, good beers, great atmosphere. My friends and I loved it.
raffaele pigneri . 2023-12-10
MORE AT Google
Went on a Fri night, was packed, but bar service very efficient. Good drinks selection.
Simona Foscarin-Kosmetatou . 2023-11-05
MORE AT Google
Great bar staff. Good selection and nice old pub.
Mark Marshall . 2023-10-24
MORE AT Google
What can I say about here apart from stunning, its really hard to find a bar in the heart of Edinburgh that makes you think this is a proper old school pub. The staff are incredibly friendly and the manager fiona had us in stitches just a couple of drinks here and we felt like we had knew her for ever. We can't wait to go back here again ❤️ definitely our new fav bar, x
Joy Little . 2023-09-30
MORE AT Google
A great pub! Drinks were delicious, great casual and friendly vibe, staff were lovely, friendly and helpful
Daniel Cairns . 2023-09-06
MORE AT Google
Friendly staff, and my introduction to an excellent Belgian beet; Heverlee.
Nick Nugent . 2023-08-29
MORE AT Google
Cosy cellar bar, great venue for a flamenco gig. Tha bar upstairs looked like a friendly local but didn't stay on for another drink.
Jen Gillman . 2023-08-18
MORE AT Google
Saw the flamenco dancers. The venue was cozy but they successfully performed wonderfully. The atmosphere was great. Excellent bartenders.
Jerry Hernandez . 2023-08-15
MORE AT Google
Live music in an intimate cellar bar, with an excellent pub above
David Yager . 2023-08-10
MORE AT Google
Basement for a Northern Soul night, great.
Pete Webster . 2023-07-15
MORE AT Google
Great La Beats music love it, great atmosphere
Lesley Hart . 2023-07-13
MORE AT Google
Awful place and rude staff There’s soo much better places nearby
Stephen Walker . 2023-07-08
MORE AT Google
A nice wee pub with friendly staff and a good range of drinks. I went in late at night during a quiz and everyone was lovely. Worth a look and away from the tourist trail
Darren Greenidge . 2023-05-10
MORE AT Google
Funny smell at bar, though might just be sweaty students…;)
David B. R. . 2023-05-09
MORE AT Google
Fantastic local with great beers and dog friendly too. One of my favourites.
Dan Halligan . 2023-05-05
MORE AT Google
OK but don't have my preferred 🍻
James Blackwood . 2023-03-13
MORE AT Google
Great local bar with a laid back vibe and good live music.
angela lamb . 2023-02-24
MORE AT Google
Good pint of Guinness before marching across the Meadows.
Gary Hyndman . 2023-02-14
MORE AT Google
This is a great wee local, good beers, friendly staff and regularly has live music in the cellar bar.
CarrieBarnes75 . 2023-01-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely pub, excellent choice of taps and really nice staff. There are comfy tables and chairs set up outside with a canopy overhead if the weather turns. Atmosphere always really excellent and cosy, the occasional very well-behaved dog, generally a really nice place to get a pint from.
A McCarthy . 2022-11-21
MORE AT Google
Gate crashed a private party. Sorry not sorry as the people where awesome
Emma Taylor . 2022-11-10
MORE AT Google
Cosy pub with a good selection of beers.
Raymond Antoni Balasca . 2022-10-30
MORE AT Google
I used to drink here in the mid 80's when the Brown family was always at the bar. Peter Brown and his family were also so nice to me and took time to help me navigate my emigration to Scotland.
Maryann Lucarelli . 2022-10-26
MORE AT Google
Cashless!!! On the boycott list for many
Andrea Silver . 2022-10-18
MORE AT Google
Lovely little dog friendly pub. Great selection of beers and really cosy.
Anne-Marie Copley . 2022-10-13
MORE AT Google
This is a lovely pub with great music at weekends. Good wifi and clean toilets. Sadly I don’t like to use ‘plastic’ so I spent my money elsewhere. Cash is legal tender and must be accepted.
Steve Wilson . 2022-10-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Not a good experience. They refuse to take cash....it's legal tender and should be accepted everywhere....plus by not taking cash you are costing yourselves more money by the percentage the machine supplier takes from you....clearly not very good management ..
Ruth Jones . 2022-10-06
MORE AT Google
Disgusting place. It’s so dirty here! The barmaid was literally picking her nose and eating it, then serving drinks! We were repulsed by her and her scabby cold sore. The main thing for me at any bar or restaurant is cleanliness and politeness. This place has neither. AVOID. Wish I could have given zero stars. They also refuse cash! Actual Scottish notes and English notes!! Maybe it’s because it gives the bar maid cold sores?
Fourteen Union Street . 2022-10-06
MORE AT Google
Great pub very friendly staff and good atmosphere
Patricia Rhind . 2022-08-29
MORE AT Google
Went to the Cellar Bar this afternoon to hear Charlie Wood’s “Memphis” show and it was brilliant. What a musical life he’s lead in Beale Street, Memphis. A great story teller, pianist and singer. The bar woman was excellent also. A lovely and smallish speakeasy type venue. After we went upstairs to their pub. Great service and relaxed atmosphere. Great selection of gins, I’d recommend the Scottish Raasay (near Isle of Skye). Haven’t been in the evening so not sure what it’s like. As a fairly local I’ll be back for their music nights downstairs.
Mo_Edin . 2022-08-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Skulle spise der, kunne ikke bare få et glas rødvin
Mogens Nielsen . 2022-08-21
MORE AT Google
I visited the Argyle on Sunday afternoon, they had a live music session, which was excellent. Country or Blue grass music, really great atmosphere. Very friendly bar staff!
pwjack55 . 2022-07-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Decent pub with a reasonable outside area, nice staff and performance area in the basement. Well worth a visit. Great pints.
David McClinton . 2022-06-26
MORE AT Google
What a nice little hideaway pub. Just what one would want from a neighborhood pub.
Daniel Biber . 2022-06-17
MORE AT Google
First time in this pub,loved the olde decor ,staff were nice and it was a descent pint. Still not taking cash and the ladies toilets bit disappointing.
Michelle Henderson . 2022-06-07
MORE AT Google
One of the few proper pubs in Edinburgh that isn't normally too crowded. Great beer and atmosphere.
Andreas Granmo . 2022-06-03
MORE AT Google
Lovely vivid place, good choice of drinks. Great music, great vibe. Come any see for yourself.
Josip Mateljan . 2022-05-21
MORE AT Google
Nice Bar and very Friendly Staff
Debra Turner . 2022-05-20
MORE AT Google
We Visited the argyle hoping for a few drinks on a Friday night. We often stay in Marchmont and have visited this pub before. We entered the door and not sure of the current seating policy following Covid relaxation. We waited for guidance from the staff. Two female bar attendants were at the bar. They both looked at us and then turned their backs and ignored us. I approached the bar to ask what we were to do. One was pulling a pint. The other was doing nothing. Both looked at me again and gave me the stink eye. . I started to speak. The one doing nothing turned her back and engaged the other In conversation. I waited for a few mintutes. Still no service or acknowledgement from the now rude bar staff. So we went to the pub over the road and spent our money over their. The bar staff at the Argyle and Cellar need to have a bit of customer facing training. If these two rude females are working another night together I recommend that you immediately go to the Earl of Marchmont over the road. Staff their will at least serve you a drink. !!!!! The crisps are delicious too 😊😊😊😊. Would have given a zero score if that were possible.
ClariceSurreyEngland . 2022-04-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great bar. Excellent, attentive staff. Good beers and friendly locals.
Roddy Strathern . 2022-04-03
MORE AT Google
Great bar and great friendly staff. Drinks were table service ordering and paying for these when they arrived at your table
Drew Gray . 2022-03-19
MORE AT Google
Nice place friendly and considerate staff.
Carly Simpson . 2022-03-19
MORE AT Google
Real small Pub but great for catching up with some friends and sharing good times.
Michael Wollmann . 2022-02-24
MORE AT Google
Friendly staff and nice atmosphere. Shame that the beer selection is limited
Argy R (ArG) . 2022-01-20
MORE AT Google
Good Atmosphere. Traditional local pub/ bar.. Seating outside on the corner under canopy in the summer. Cellar bar club also a fringe venue. Good beers been many times for beer n a chat with friends n family. A local local. Delightful licensee!
Graham Collin . 2021-12-14
MORE AT Google
Nice, traditional pub, warm and friendly. They serve Timothy Taylors Landlord and scampi fries too!
Arley Stuffins . 2021-11-09
MORE AT Google
Top pub. Lovely service, great range of beers.
Edward Lowy . 2021-10-22
MORE AT Google
I was showing my brother around Edinburgh, and wanted to give him an example of warm and welcoming Edinburgh hospitality. I thought this pub would be the place to give him a really good impression of what this city has to offer. It looked like a great place from the outside and I was hoping for a fun and cosy place to enjoy a quick drink with a good atmosphere. How wrong I was. Sadly, this establishment has taken enforcing compliance with Covid regulations to a ridiculous new level. I wasn’t prepared for what happened next. As we came through the doors, the lady at the bar barked ‘mask!’ at us, like a primary school teacher scolding naughty toddlers. Immediately rattled by this, we reached into our pockets and put our masks on as we approached the bar. Because of the aggression of the tone, we were suddenly a bit on edge but we complied with the command. But it wasn’t enough for the lady at the bar! She told us with great moral indignation that because we had forgotten to put our masks on upon entry, she wouldn’t serve us (even though we put them on straightaway after she barked at us)! It wasn’t enough to appease her, and we were refused service! She seemed genuinely outraged that we had made this innocent mistake. Even though we went along with her orders the moment she shouted them at us (and she really was rude), she still threw us out! I understand that this is a difficult time for us all, and that we all need to do our bit to help the fight against covid, but this really was crazy. It was a genuinely awful experience. Instead of a warm welcome, we got cold, arrogant, self-righteous officiousness. Instead of an enjoyable evening, we were treated like either criminals or disobedient children. It left a terrible taste in our mouth, was an unbelievable failure of service. I took my brother to another place to restore his faith that Edinburgh was a welcoming city, but this place left both of us with a horrible impression. They really let the side down. I thought we were all in this together? I gave this place two stars because in fairness the atmosphere and the decor looked quite nice. It’s just a pity we didn’t get to enjoy them. And maybe it’s just one bad employee creating this hostility, not the entire establishment. I will definitely never come here again, and won’t ever recommend it to others. We had an awful experience at this place.
G4991LTalang . 2021-10-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great bar, great selection of beers, largely Scottish ones. Can be busy, need to get in early to get a seat sometimes.
Graeme Go . 2021-10-04
MORE AT Google
Great night northern soul 1 st Fri month
colin walton . 2021-09-26
MORE AT Google
Great staff, great pint and quiet outside tables!
Alan McEwan . 2021-08-31
MORE AT Google
Dog friendly and a great wee pub anyway. Cellar not open due to covid but will be back! 🍻
G Tan . 2021-07-06
MORE AT Google
Traditional pub, tables outside, quiet street, great beers, friendly staff, good prices. What more do you want?
Andreas Granmo . 2021-06-26
MORE AT Google
I have visited this pub on a number of occasions and have always been impressed by the excellent service and the friendly staff. The customers like the establishment and the local area are upmarket but not unfriendly.
Colin Gillies . 2021-01-27
MORE AT Google
Proper homely pub with really friendly staff. Good drinks and good selection of students and locals.
Felicity Ap . 2020-11-16
MORE AT Google
Open during covid, great pub near the meadows, live music once the lockdowns over.
Peppermint Pig . 2020-08-10
MORE AT Google
Unchanged, almost, in over twenty years. And why would ya
Ray Johnston . 2020-02-28
MORE AT Google
Wonderful Bar, great atmosphere, great beers.
Derek Pearson . 2020-02-26
MORE AT Google
Cellar bar is great, especially on gypsy jazz music nights
Kieren McGrotty . 2020-02-14
MORE AT Google
Lovely, friendly bar for the residents and students of Marchmont. The only thing that lets it down is that it is always freezing cold inside. If only it had an open fire!
George W . 2020-02-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Auckland/Sydney prices without the weather or scenery.
Thirsty Jack . 2020-01-15
MORE AT Google
Very good food and reasonable price.
GARY CHOONG . 2019-12-12
MORE AT Google
Just go there you'll know!!?? It's the best bar around these parts folk's. Very good staff. What more do you need?
Johnny Munro . 2019-11-18
MORE AT Google
Great pub and love the quiz night
Lisa Wilson . 2019-11-10
MORE AT Google
We booked the cellar bar downstairs out for a private event on Friday. The staff were so accommodating and welcoming even though there were a fair few of us there. It is a lovely place and we were looked after well. Can reccomend highly!
Jamie Munro . 2019-11-10
MORE AT Google
Went for a Fringe show. The had a good selection of beers, and live music.
Gary Shaw . 2019-10-21
MORE AT Google
Good friendly staff great atmosphere
Irene Hood . 2019-10-13
MORE AT Google
A great little pub in Marchmont with regular tradition music sessions by musicians who really know what they’re doing. Slow in the afternoon but picks up around 4:30. Nice German beers on tap.
Sean Errey . 2019-09-09
MORE AT Google
Lovely setting and great space but just missed something. No audio or TV screens, if they do I didn't hear or see any of it.
Ross Paterson . 2019-09-04
MORE AT Google
Great space, good drinks and live music was excellent
Thomas Nicolas . 2019-08-27
MORE AT Google
I really enjoyed the craic and the bands who were playing there tonight.
Padraig Hartin . 2019-08-23
MORE AT Google
Nice welcome and went to a gig.
raymond daly . 2019-08-12
MORE AT Google
I'm a regular visitor to this great pub. It's a busy place with a mixed crowd and a good friendly atmosphere. Bar staff are very great too. Good range of ales, lagers, wine, whiskies, gins etc including non alcoholic beers. Regular good quality music events downstairs ranging from soul nights to live jazz, country, blue grass etc.
Stuart White . 2019-08-10
MORE AT Google
Nice wee bar, well placed. Staff seemed lovely.
Louise Young . 2019-08-05
MORE AT Google
Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Very dog friendly!
Donald Sinclair . 2019-07-25
MORE AT Google
Popular local with relaxed atmosphere. Good selection of beers. Excellent Gypsy Jazz downstairs every 2nd Wednesday of the month.
T.H. Woth . 2019-07-19
MORE AT Google
Excellent, friendly, great to sit outside and an amazing pint of Tennents!!! 😁
Robert Cleland . 2019-07-15
MORE AT Google
In a lovely spot of Edinburgh with a small but affordable selection of beers!
C R . 2019-06-30
MORE AT Google
Nice local pub atmosphere, with occasional live music. Older kids fine if you're early doors.
awmoore77 . 2019-06-24
MORE AT Google
Nice wee bar! Great that its dog friendly!
Deborah Knipe McGregor . 2019-06-02
MORE AT Google
Not really the best place to watch the footy.
Paul O'Hara . 2019-04-15
MORE AT Google
Nice little local bar. Staff always very friendly and a nice crowd of students and locals.
Tom Reid . 2019-03-04
MORE AT Google
These schedules may not be completely accurate on special days. Please always confirm with the restaurant
Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian
772 Opinions
Another excellent lunch put on by McRae's Battalion Trust, excellent speakers and fantastic Company
655 Opinions
Really amazing food, so glad we stopped by. Sunday lunch is 10/10 and the macaroni cheese was delicious. Will definitely be back.
2052 Opinions
Great place to eat, food was delicious, will definitely be back, all the staff are very friendly and pleasant, nice to see staff who actually enjoy there job
5944 Opinions
I adored the atmosphere here! The food was cooked perfectly, and I would highly recommend the pork belly!