That's Amore in Mid Sussex

Calamari straight out the freezer, spaghetti bolognese and pizza sloppy and flavourless. Service was superb but food was awful, shame.

Possibly the best gluten free pizza I ever had, great atmosphere and attentive staff. My partner and daughter loved it. Thanks!

We ate here many years ago when it was under different ownership, and it wasn't great then, so we hadn't been back since, but we saw the good reviews online and decided to give it a try. We won't be returning. Most of the food, apart from the pizzas, was disappointing. For instance, I ordered chips with my sea bass dish and they were extremely salty, plus I was handed sachets of tomatao sauce and mayonnaise (never a good sign), and the gnocchi dish was bland and did not feel like it was homemade. We love Italian food, but this did not feel very authentic. The one saving grace was the staff who were all very friendly and attentive.

Absolutely superb. Service speedy and friendly. The food consisted of all fresh ingredients. Just about the best Pizza I have ever eaten.

(Please note, I have eaten in more places all over Italy than most Italians!) My first visit here was exactly 11 years ago. I thought it’s possible that with so much time passing, they may have improved their food. Nope! Worse than 11 years ago!! I had the chicken mushroom truffle dish. The sauce was more water than cream and the chicken was more leather than chicken! The wine was like vinegar! English people have the most forgiving palate in all of Europe, so I guess people will continue to eat here blissfuly unaware that they are being mocked! Also, ridiculously overpriced!! The one thing I can say with absolute certainty, is that no Italian has ever been here twice!!!

Lovely meal again prawns, squid and w white bait to start followed by Pizza and gnocchi with pesto as mains., my Puzza could have done with a tad more sausage Good service

We ordered That's Amore on Deliveroo. 3 people--three pasta courses and 2 starters. Total over £71! One of the pasta courses was huge, another normal, and the third--the one my teenager ordered--was barely four bites. Not enough food for him! The calamari was undercooked and tough. The pastas were unremarkable and not particularly flavourful. Garlic bread was great. Food arrived hot, but we waited TWO HOURS to get it when the restaurant is only a five-minute walk from our house. This was mid-week, mind you, not even a busy Friday or Saturday night. This was the first time we've tried this place, and it will also be the last.

We have been to That’s Amore several times since moving down to Lindfield/Haywards Heath a year ago. The food is delicious: authentic Sicilian/Italian cuisine to die for! The pasta dishes and the Pizzas are world class, as are the seafood and meat dishes. We went there again this week for my granddaughter’s 11th birthday - 6 adults and 7 grandkids. Everyone was thrilled with their meal choices and the service was so attentive and friendly. The birthday cake we ordered for the occasion was baked and decorated at the restaurant and was first class. In my business career I entertained clients all around top London and World restaurants. When I go to heaven - hopefully not too soon - I want to eat at That’s Amore 4 times a week! 😂 Speak to Simona - she will fix anything for you! Celebrations, birthdays, or just lunch or dinner!

Restaurant has a nice feel with seating inside and out, staff were friendly and attentive. Starters were tasty especially calamari and garlic bread. Mains arrived sadly missing one - my Linguini Octopus was very bland with little to no flavour however our friends same dish that turned up 5 minutes later was a totally different taste and so much better. I will give the Restaurant another try as I feel I was probably unlucky that night.

Evening started slowly as the restaurant was PACKED! I can see why!! Starters were delicious and fresh and very generous in portion sizes. The mains were FANTASTIC!! I had lobster spaghetti and it was one of the best meals I’ve ever had. So generous with the lobster. Another of our party had the prawns which were huge and another very generous portion. Pasta dishes also wonderful. The bill was very reasonable! Service was slow to start but improved quickly. Im looking forward to the next time!

Very good Italian restaurant. Excellent pizza and atmosphere. Proper family oriented restaurant. Like being back in Italy.

A lovely little Italian restaurant tucked away off Lindfield High Street. Very friendly service and relaxed atmosphere. The food freshly prepared was delicious. Went with our son, his wife and our granddaughter all had different dishes.

We had a great experience here. The staff are warm and welcoming and were very understanding/empathetic to my husbands vulnerability. They made our visit relaxed and special. A big thank you to Simona and Sam who looked after us; it’s a day we won’t forget. Hats off to the chef too. The food was absolutely delicious, so much so that we ordered pizzas to take away to eat the following day. Thanks again. We look forward to eating with you again soon.

Truly excellent Italian food. We went here for a birthday lunch and thoroughly enjoyed it. The fillet steak was cooked perfectly and the prawns were full of flavour. Thoroughly recommend.

This is a lovely Sicilian restaurant with great food and friendly service. Nice for an evening meal for two but children are also made very welcome.

Had a mother's day lunch here and it was fantastic, very good quality food, children's. Menu and amazing service. The waitors and chefs came into the restaurant dancing the conga, made everyone smile and provided a warm fun atmosphere. We will be back!

Service super slow and had to ask repeatedly for same items. Food ok, portions could be bigger but tasty

Fabulous food and diverse menu. We were having a meal to celebrate my wife’s birthday. We both had starters which were great, but we went for pasta for mains. My wife had whole crab Linguine and mine was Linguine vongole (clams). Both were excellent

I was so pleased to book this place for my daughters pizza making party and not one of the chain companies serving cardboard. They are Italian for starters and the food was great. The chefs came out with various toppings and all the staff were...

We have not been here for nearly a year and this restaurana has a new owner. Food, service still excellent and we had an excellent lunch on a dismal Sunday.

Decided to give the restaurant another chance as it was very poor under the previous management. Not much has changed same menu, small portions and generally poor quality and over priced. You wouldn’t actually know it had new owners as most of the staff are...

This restaurant is now under new management with new staff and a new menu. Popped in there on the off chance last night and were soon found a table. A very extensive wine list and menu awaited. Plenty of time was given to peruse and...

Excellent food and the server could not have been more friendly or attentive. Original Italian food which we thoroughly enjoyed!

Went last night with friend but was disappointed with the service - it was terrible. Food was Ok but they need to improve on customer service.

Oh my goodness!! Our first time here, thinking that we'd treat ourselves to somewhere different rather than going to our local favourite place (which is always lovely) thought was a bit 'risky' (first world problems eh?). HOWEVER...'That's Amore' excelled our expectations!!!! Everything was perfect! The...

Arrived and informed them of our booking which they didn’t seem to know about. Asked to order drinks was told by the waitress she’d be back in a minute - she didn’t come back. So asked the waiter for drinks after another 15 mins of...

After booking a table many months ago for the 19th of June 2022, I double-checked recently twice that the restaurant would be open as they’re not normally on a Sunday. I was told as it’s Father’s Day they would be. This date also coincided with...

We had a fantastic lunch this afternoon celebrating a 30th birthday. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. All of the staff were so welcoming and friendly and nothing was too much trouble. As a lovely extra touch they gave the birthday boy...

I have only praise for the lovely welcome and fun evening we had at the restaurant to celebrate two big birthdays with a large group of friends. From providing extra decoration to ensuring that drinks flowed and we all had our food as required, the...

Very slow service, to the point of being forgotten about…. Starters were adequate, though pasta mains were lovely. However, long gap - about 30 minutes between finishing courses and next one arriving… asked for dessert menu which didn’t arrive… a larger table ordered & had...

We had heard good reviews of this restaurant but we were very disappointed. We were given a table at the back with a view of the toilet. Very slow service, felt ignored. Food was ok but nothing amazing, good size portions and very hot. Restaurant...

Went for lunch with friends. Had the seafood pasta and it was very fresh and good. They made a mistake with my friend’s main course. She had to wait 5 mins after our mains and they gave her a complimentary glass of wine. Service was...

It was a saturday lunch and we wanted to eat some nice fish. We stopped at this amazing restaurant where the fish is so fresh and tasty! The staff is amazing and we could not receive a better welcome! THANK YOU

We visited for lunch recently, the pizza was very good. Only comments were the restaurant was very cold when we arrived and had a strong smell of bleach which is not conducive to dining. It's good that they are cleaning it so well, but maybe...

I have been here several times with all the family and we have never been disappointed. The food is lovely and the staff are fantastic.

First time at Tha'ts Amore and found it to be a totally wonderfully eating experience. Great service from all the staff and the food was gorgeous .. the collono dessert was fantastic .. will certainly go again and very soon .. recommended . .

We went for an early tea with the grandchildren and we will not be coming back. The cleanliness is disappointing and I am not sure when the place was last cleaned thoroughly. The floor was filthy. There were no sign of any Covid precautions and...

What an amazing Saturday afternoon lunch. Friendly service free olives and epic food. The fresh fish for 2 was very tasty. Can’t wait to return !

Smallish unit, reasonably small menu with generally simple options. A ?slightly unusually high amount of seafood dishes on the menu for an Italian but still plenty of staples. We had some pizzas and the breaded chicken - the chicken in particular was quite simple; breaded...

Celebrating a couple of family birthdays and menu had something for everyone. A nice buzzy place with bags of atmosphere. Service first rate and friendly. Food quality excellent and good portions. Very impressed with first visit and will certainly return.

Went here for the first time with my family last night and immediately was greeted from one of the waiters and seated, we had a lovely chat with the waiter about it being our first time here etc had a laugh about it too which...

Peter served us today, he was highly attentive, warm and friendly. The lady who was front of house was very kind, really wanted us to be there and provided perfect service. Thank you. The current chef has put the food on a new level of...

Brilliant Italian restaurant. I went last night for the 1st time with friends to celebrate a birthday & I will definitely go again! Lovely decor & good friendly service!💕

A fantabulous first night out post lockdown. Perfect choice for a lovely Italian feast! Highly recommend and can’t wait to come back! You should definitely preorder the crab linguini. Yummy!

We had our first post-lockdown meal here and are thrilled to have found our new favourite restaurant! The food was delicious, warming and authentic. Alongside superb service and hospitality, we will find ourselves returning for sure!!

Had a post-lockdown al fresco lunch here and loved it. Great menu, food was without exception delicious. Amazing homemade bread, calamari, pasta, seafood, chicken cutlet and ice cream. Good coffee too. Service was fantastic but reataurant was not too busy - hope service stays as...

We had two pizzas from 'That's Amore', Lindfield. Both were absolutely delicious- the bases were second to none and the toppings were great. How have we not been here before? Highly recommended.

The most fantastic pizza I’ve had outside of Italy. Highly recommend (they do takeaway). Also as a restaurant the warmest and most relaxed ambience. A great venue for dinner with friends and family with great service and authentically quality Italian food to make the whole...

Much better than its predecessor, this friendly , buzzy restaurant serves good genuine Italian dishes in a happy atmosphere . We much enjoyed their Bruschetta and the Linguine Mare. Staff are excellent and caring . Recommend having a table on the right and not in...

We had a family dinner here to celebrate our daughter’s 21st birthday and we had a wonderful time. The food was great, but what impressed most was the service. We had pre-advised of the occasion and without us asking they had decorated the table with...

We took our grandchildren out for a treat, they absolutely loved it. They are already planning a return. The service was charming and very friendly, the young ones felt special. Our meals were all excellent , authentic Italian, homemade, delicious. My grandson even commented about...

Wow once again another amazing lunch, food, service was top notch. Raffaella and her team have something special happening here, please keep it up. I opted tagliatelle carbonara which was cooked really well and very tasty. See uou soon !

Been here several times over the past months but our visit last week we found their Covid precautions were questionable. Their new mini masks in particular. Did not feel safe. Shame as we found service and food good

The service was warming and welcoming, we got soaked walking there last night! The food was sensational, 5 stars. My wife had Lobster linguine and I had surf and turf. Both plates empty. We will be back very very soon.

We have visited this place many times over the years, but this was our first 'sit-in' visit under the new ownership. We received a very warm welcome and attentive service throughout; the menu combines pizza / pasta options with a very attractive list of 'specials'...

Really loved our meal and so much to choose from on the menu. Staff really friendly and helpful and very welcoming of children too. Definitely recommend.

Went for a birthday dinner last night, first time we have been back since it changed hands. Fantastic food, great wine and excellent staff. We will be back.

First visit since the name change from Paolinos and a new team. The restaurant is bright and with attractive yet unfussy decor and layout. We booked for the last possible slot via Qandoo (1945!). Choice of tables = selected one by the window. Attentive service...

We had heard good things about this restaurant and planned to book. However when passing yesterday decided to pop in for a coffee. Warm and friendly welcome, delicious coffee and surprise Italian cookies on the side! So we decided to return for a light lunch,...

Tasty food, lovely atmosphere and perfect service. We came to Sunday lunch and had a wonderful meal. Nice to see options for dietary requirements including gluten free pizza and pasta. The service could have been better, very welcoming and friendly. Can’t wait to return!

My daughter wanted pizza for her birthday lunch and we wanted to support a local business so booked via Quandoo. This was great as we moved our booking several times and it was super easy to keep doing that- so great they use that booking...

I am normally very critical of food establishments as they don't normally meet my high standards and are way over my budget. However, That's Amore was a breath of fresh air today and much improved since the surly staff and crap menu from Paolinos. Our...

Now that things are returning to normal, the new owners of this local Italian have finally been allowed to open properly. Naturally, on a Friday evening the service is perhaps a little chaotic, but always friendly and helpful The food is pretty good too, with...

The ladies that served us were very polite and helpful, great overall service. The food was delicious. Thank you! Masks and visors were used to follow current Covid guidelines.

Unbelievable lunch super service super food! It was friends anniversary and we opted for a super lunch at that’s amore great service and yummy food. I had squid to start followed by a top Pizza the owner was the waitress and she served with a...

I order one pizza takeaway last day, was fantastic and I enjoyed that !! I'm sure I came back to eat in for dinner !

This restaurant has new owners, staff and name. It is now called “That’s Amore”. It was reopened about 4 weeks ago. We popped in today for lunch and to try it out as we hadn’t been in since the new regime took over. First impressions...

We went for an early evening meal with our two kids and grandparents. The food was lovely - pizza, pasta and meat dishes between us - and the staff very friendly and attentive. The waitress in particular was great with the kids and, despite the...

The food here was tasty but very small portions. Head waitress was incredibly rude and condescending towards my mother who politely asked if portions could be a little bigger given the price of one of the dishes.

After having a lovely dinner when we first moved to lindfield, we were happy to suggest going for pizza on the arts festival weekend. We booked a table although they were busy they assured us it would be fine. We were sat at a table...

We have been to Paulino's every month for the last 3 months! Really pleasant service - once the owner served us, and on our last visit he was cooking and came out to greet us. Good menu choice - not just pasta and pizza. We...

As soon as you walk in you get a lovely feeling, can't really explain but you notice how clean the place is, very well laid out also. The staff and I guess owners are really nice. Everything went to plan great meal .. Would we...

I visited for the first time and it definitely won’t be the last. The staff were friendly and the food was superb. The customer service was fantastic! Thank you for a lovely lunch

Friends took us here for lunch and what a surprise. The staff were very friendly and helpful. We chose from the set lunch menu and all agreed the food was excellent and the portions were just right. The price was also very reasonable. It was...

Welcome back Paulino!! We sure have missed you the few months you have been closed. Faultless service from the moment we walked in the door, we had pre-booked but there was plenty of room for walk ins which is no reflection on how fantastic this...

We have now visited Paolino Italian Restaurant 3 times, having originally spotted it whilst driving through Lindfield. All 3 of our visits have been exceptional. Capturing the real spirit of Italy, the restaurant is clean, welcoming and atmospheric. We are always made to feel extremely...

We went to the restaurant at short notice and without a reservation. The restaurant is definitely family orientated and friendly. The food was mediocre at best - a tuna steak requested medium rare but was served over cooked. The service was pretty good but could...

We visited Paolino's for lunch and without exception everything was excellent. The food was tasty, fresh and well presented and the staff were attentive but not overbearing. We noted that Paolino's was able to offer vegan and gluten free meals too. The restaurant was very...

We came here with friends and family a couple of times now. We love everything. Food in is Top quality, lots of choices with pizzas and delicious main courses. Staff is always smiley, kind and professional. I will never stop recommending this place.

This is my very first review on trip advisor and felt I had to express how much we enjoyed our experience last night at Paolino’s. Food was fantastic, we asked twice for something not on the menu and was no problem. Atmosphere is great, staff...

We visited Paolino’s last night for the first time since it reopened last week with Paolo, master chef, once again at the helm. The meal was lovely, we both had veal with a really tasty sauce, starters also excellent. The service was friendly and efficient....

We chose Paolinos as it was so close to our accommodation and reviews were good. It’s a lovely open and airy restaurant, and the waitress was so lovely, but the food was a bit of a let down. The starter was fine but the mains...

Paolo is back and his cooking is amazing. We went for a midweek treat and the food was really really lovely as were the staff, who were very friendly and very attentive. We cannot fault anything at all about our evening and would definitely recommend...

We use this local restaurant regularly and have never been disappointed. My advice is to stick strictly to the Italian menu dishes; going off piste is not recommended. Nice wine list, especially those from southern Italy and Sicily. Service is consistently cheerful and efficient under...

All round Italian restaurant serving a large variety of food with a friendly welcome. The pizza is very tasty.

Really lovely Indian restaurant with more than just the usual British curry dishes. The specials really are special. The Chicken Village in particular is fantastic! The staff are very friendly and made our 5 year old son very welcome. He’s only brave enough for a...

We chose here to celebrate my daughter’s 12th birthday and from the moment we booked they could not have been more helpful. We had quite a big table and so talked about the best way to plan the menu etc before the event itself. On...

Love the food, a good range, very nice ambience, I just relax when I'm there. All the staff very polite and warm-natured. I sometimes get a hug!

6 of us ate at this fab restaurant. They sat us on a round table and have great service. Fredrico was our main waiter and he was excellent. We all had a different and enjoyed the natural ingredients. Can't wait to go again.

It’s a lovely looking place with great and friendly staff. Good service. I found the food a bit oily and veg not that fresh... My friend liked her pizza

I honestly do not know how this place has such positive reviews! The quality of the meals we had here today were really poor, and certainly do not match the high prices they so boldly command. To begin we had some drinks and olives, the...

We were made so welcome by the staff, we had a lovely meal from an extensive menu, promptly served by efficient staff. Everyone agreed that it was a brilliant meal for such a memorable occasion

Hi, I had the pleasure of dining at your restaurant last Friday evening 12th October. The food was absolutely delicious and the Owner great. She was very attentive and I complimented her on the food which I enjoyed very much. To my surprise, she led...

We had a one course meal here -I had risotto with prawns. Excellent food and other members of my party really enjoyed their food and wine too. Very friendly service too

I’m gluten and wheat intolerant and to find anywhere that does this is very hard to come by if you do it’s not that nice but you don’t have a choice... NOW i won’t go ANYWHERE else but HERE. Most incredible food. The other girls...

It is wonderful to have an independent restaurant in the village that serves proper Italian food including great pizzas!

Pleased with our choice of venue. We were looking for somewhere different to try in the area and liked what we found. The food and service were to our liking and we will be returning.

Had lunch at Paolino's today to celebrate mum's 82nd birthday, lovely food, great prosecco and wonderful atmosphere. Service was excellent, we will be back soon 😃

The food and the service are outstanding! My husband and I enjoyed a lovely, evening meal here two nights in a row. We highly recommend this restaurant.

I stumbled across this restaurant while briefly working in the area, first meeting a friend after work and was so pleased with my "find" I took my mum over for lunch. On both occasions I received a warm welcome, the second time having been recognised...