Sarah's Pasty Shop in Cornwall, Isles of Scilly - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Well I don't normally do any bad reviews ! but yesterday we visited Looe and was exited to have another Sarah's pasty .I had steak and stilton and my wife had steak traditional! we are from Cornwall and are very proud of all the great pasties available in our county , but these were not notably good more of a disappointment ! size wise and price were no problem ,but all the veg was chopped into miniscule pieces and the meat must have gone into someone else's pasty because both our pasties had a minute spattering of steak ! so very disappointing it certainly was nothing like it used to be!

Very tasty Cornish pasty’s. Great choice of flavours. Friendly staff, good service. A pasty will set you up for the day 😋 A must visit when in Looe.

Two take away traditional Cornish pasties - excellent. They queue here for a reason - the bakery is so good and well worth it.

Without doubt the best pasty I've ever had and I've had a few! If you are lucky enough to find yourself in Looe then a quick stop off at Sarah's Pasty Shop is a must. Nothing beats sitting on a bench in Looe eating a great pasty and dodging the seagulls!

There is a reason why this is known as the place for the best pasties in Cornwall. Always top class, expect a queue and get there early before they are sold out. All created and baked on the premises, order and enjoy a traditional miners pasty!

Visited during a recent visit to Cornwall and popped in to for a take away lunch, I had a traditional steak and my wife had a cheese and onion. Both were delicious and well cooked. The pastry was superb crispy and loved the crispy brown bits on the bottom. Also nice to get a pasty that doesn’t burn the roof of your mouth when you buy it.

Usually excellent pasties which we bring home by the dozen, flavoursome filling and great pastry, but on our last visit they weren't great... No seasoning at all, really thick pastry (which is usually excellent from Sarah's) and one had hardly any meat in it at all. We've been loyal customers for years, but this year will be the last we get our pasties from Sarah's - we found the Malcolm Barnecutt ones to be much tastier. To be honest, we had pasties from Sarah's on 1 March, eating them by the beach and they were under-seasoned, too - but we put it down to an 'off-day'... Don't know what's changed, but it's definitely not for the better. And my sister noted that the bacon in the bacon, leek and cheese pasty was smoked which overpowered everything. Shame.

My mum’s favourite place in Cornwall is Looe she’s been visiting ever year since she was 18, she’s now 81. I always struggle to get something different other than flowers. We always go to Sarah’s Pasty shop when we visit. So glad you deliver she was over the moon with them. Thank you so much!

Top top top pasty. We had cheese and onion and it was splendid. I would have one everyday if I could! Took our to the benches on the seafront which is very close by.

Picked up a batch of pasties on our last day in Looe to bring home either us. Had one when we got home & they were some of the best pasties we’ve had for some time - wish I’d bought more! Superb!

Wow!!! This was hands down the best pasty I have ever had in my life!! I don’t even like pasties particularly but I plan to visit again on Monday. My husband loves pasties and he also agreed best Pasty he has ever had, so I hope that tells you something!! I had the bacon, leek and cheese and it was so flavoursome. We asked for tomato ketchup because lots of pasties we have had previously were dry and we absolutely did not need it! The pastry casing is soooo doughy and delicious. 10/10!!

Sarah’s make what are probably the most yummy Cornish Pasties we have tasted and we’ve tried a few. They are very popular, so getting there early in the day is recommended. Great value too.

Took friends to Looe and persuaded them to partake of the best pasties in the Town. There are many places in Looe that sell pasties but only one where there is regularly a queue outside. Says so much about the quality

We always buy our pasties from Sarah’s pasty shop in looe while on holiday and have done so for many years but on our last holiday in September we visited 3 times and on two occasions the pasties were very salty, they are made fresh every day by hand and I suppose every one will be slightly different depending on who’s making them but on this occasion I could not finish my pasty and had to throw it. Please be careful with the amount of salt used

The best pasties in Cornwall I’d say, really lovely pastry, good size and plenty of filling. Ended up getting pasties for lunch here on 3 of our 4 days in Looe, only reason it wasn’t 4/4 is because it was closed on the Sunday!!! Small downside is they have a big list of pasty options on the sign but often only a few flavours are actually ready each time, so prepare to have your second or third choice. I have seen you can pre-order though so may be an option to avoid disappointment. Love that you can see the pasties being made there inside the shop. Lovely cakes too. Would recommend.

When in Cornwall what better lunch to have than a freshly baked pasty. And to buy from Sarah’s was the best decision. The traditional pasty I chose was lovely and hot, and the delicious meat filling encased in an amazing rich golden pastry. Will definitely be back

I have been coming to Looe for many years, but never have I tried a pasty from Sarah's before. These pasties and Sausage rolls are by far the best I have ever tasted, Absolutely beautiful. I now know where I'm getting my pasties from. You must try these beauties...

Excellent pasty especially if eaten warm, big que but soon get served, the smell let's you taste them the closer you get

Stumbled across this hidden gem. Beautiful food, friendly staff, fresh food, well priced, great location. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the area. My husband visited twice during our stay in the area.

A lovely little shop with the best ever pastys. Everyone loved theirs and with so much choice we could pick what we liked. Will buy again.

Absolutely brilliant pasties. We discovered Sarah's pasties a couple of years ago. Wow! They are absolutely superb proper cornish pasties! Always a good helping of excellent quality beef and lovely sweet turnip! Essential in a good cornish oggy😁. We make a definite date every time we are in the area of visiting.

We ordered gluten free pasties from here on Monday to be picked up today (Wednesday). We were not disappointed my daughter who is allergic to wheat and me being Ceoliac. Wow.... they are truly the best pasties we have had in Cornwall. The look on my 14 year old daughter was amazing. Thank you and we will be returning next year. Xxxx

We took away 4 delicious pasties our only disappointment was very few of the flavour on the menu were available but we understood why. The lamb mint and rosemary one was delicious I particularly liked the pastry and the fact that it wasn’t overly thick. The traditional ones were nice. A little on the pricey side at £4.50 each but they were a good size.

My wife & I were visiting Looe on a sunny weekday, and we took the opportunity to have our first taste of a Cornish pasty (heard about them for years, but this was our first chance to try them). Fresh pasties were being prepared by several young members of Sarah's staff when we entered the tiny shop on busy Buller Street in East Looe (maybe a training day?). The very friendly lady at the counter suggested as first-timers that we try the traditional style pasty (potato, swede, onion and Cornish skirt); we ordered two without considering the volume of the product - splitting one pasty would have been enough to satisfy us both. We sat on the East Looe Quay & thoroughly enjoyed our freshly made Cornish treats. We would definitely return to Sarah's Pasty Shop, and we recommend you save room for one of their pasty varieties the next time you are in or near Looe.

Sarah's Pasties are the best in Looe and probably for some distance beyond - takeaway only and be prepared to queue but well worth it. Does some delicious looking cakes too but couldn't try as trying to keep my cholesterol down and a pasty was already on the naughty list

Sarah’s regularly appears on the best top 10 pastie places in Cornwall. I don’t know if it’s the best pasties in Cornwall or even the UK but it’s dam good !

By Far the best pasty shop Looe. Amazing pasty filled to the brim. They also don't contain Any milk so our Lacto free girl could enjoy one too!! My other daughter had the sausage roll which she absolutely loved albeit a bit on the salty side..lovely staff. Can't wait to go back.

Tried a different pasty shop in Looe town, everyday of a weeks holiday, Sarah's was by far the best cheese and onion and traditional meat pasty. Next visit will try some of the sweet treats which looked delicious. Ordered some by post when I got...

Popped in today to get a couple of pasties for lunch on the beach,advised by locals as being the best in looe we weren't disappointed with this hot treat, if you love a pastie go try..

Best pasty’s in Looe! Gorgeous little take out shop. Amazing pasty’s with lots of fillings, get there early to get a choice of flavour. Ignore if it says closed on Google in the afternoon as it was still open for us.

We found this pasty shop on a whim while walking through Looe and are so glad we found it. We visit Cornwall every year and have done for years and this has been our favourite pasties of all the places we visited. They tasted authentic,...

Watched them make the pasty, from rolling out the pastry, filling with the vegetables and meat to crimping them ready to bake. There were loads of shops that advertised 'baked on the premises' but they brought them in already made. SARAH'S didn't. By far the...

Without a doubt the best pasties in Looe, so much choice, been here in looe 2 weeks have sampled many of Sarah's different flavours, and each one is sublime, that homemade taste is unmistakable. The staff are fast and loveky even when the line is...

Amazing place the most beautiful pasties we have ever had, staff so welcoming and friendly it’s a must to go to when in looe

What can I say , I’m 62, been going to Cornwall since I was 3 and eaten Pasties all my life. Never have I experienced a nicer example of a pastie. This is a must do experience if in or near Looe. We will definitely...

We were recommended this pasties, they are gorgeous, such a perfectly balanced filling and the pastry is glazed and gorgeous, we previously had other pasties there was no comparison!

We came here last year after tasting lots of pasties and yes it's still the best pastie we have ever had. Good value for money as they are huge & full of filling . The staff are making the pasties in front of you too....

Whenever we are in Looe this is the only place where we go to get pasties. They are excellent. They are made fresh on site. Highly recommend

Amazing Cornish pastie. More like home made and doesn’t have a huge crust around the edges. Good value at £4.50 each

I visited the shop twice and rang once to place an order, on each occasion the staff were unfriendly and not very helpful. Felt like an inconvenience rather than a customer. A real shame, I wouldn’t buy here again based on the way I was...

I’ve had pasty’s from many places over the years and this one from Sarah’s was the best. I’ve been attempting to make pasty’s for years and thought I’d finally cracked it until today when I realised I was nowhere close, what I’d give for the...

Simply the best pasties I have EVER had Crispy light flakey pastry Delicious fillings. Filled to the brim I have one ever time I come to Looe

Well, suffice to say we had the best pasty either of us have ever had. We don't say that lightly. Beef and stilton. Stuffed to the rafters with tender beef, loads of veg and potato. Pastry was flakey, light and delicious. We could see the...

I'm sure I would have given five stars IF I had been able to get some pasties. I phone up the bakery twenty minutes ago and they told me that they were CLOSED. The pasties were always delicious and I was hoping to take some...

Every time we come down to Looe, it's the only pasty shop for us. We absolutely love the pasties from Sarah's. We made 2 visits on our latest trip to Looe over the New Year period, the first on the day we arrived, and again...

We have walked past this little pasty shop on many occasions. In the summer, people queue down the street for their handmade pasties. Today, we found out why!! The nicest Cornish pasties we have ever tasted.

We had a vegetarian Thai and sweet potato pasty and all I can say is that it was delicious, the pastry was perfect and plenty of delicious filling. Well worth a visit at this lovely pasty shop.

Called in on the off chance in the summer as I could see them being made by hand. Was back down in Looe again last week and had to get my brother and his wife to try them. I must say we were not disappointed...

Had a traditional pasty but it didn't have much meat in it. The pastry and veg filling were nice but just very little meat and all at one end. As I was passing the shop again later I thought I would let them know about...

We have been coming down to Cornwall now for about 10 years and we have NEVER EVER found pasties like these. They are filled to the brim with delicious fillings. I can definitely confirm that these are the best pasties in Cornwall and could probably...

Quality pasty! Packed filling. Large. Tasty. YUM!!! What a find - we were so lucky to choose to buy our Cornish pasty here. Very happy to recommend.

Cornish pasties are lovely and tasty, they come with a variety fillings. Go early as they sell out quick.

There is no better pasty that I’ve ever had. Great pastry, full of filling I just can’t fault in any way. As far as I’m concerned the best pasties in the world! I love pasties and have tried many over my 47 year lifetime but...

Visited twice during our stay. Sarah’s pasty’s don’t scrimp on the fillings. I was really pleased to find they do gluten free pasty’s if you order the day before. My partner felt the steak and kidney was the best he’s ever had but the second...

Delicious traditional pasty at excellent prices. Sarah was very friendly. We were told she sells out fast but luckily when we went in the afternoon she still had some left, maybe because we were more in the off season.

Don’t look anywhere else. You’ve now found it. This is definitely the place to get the world’s best Cornish Pasties. Forget about “best pasties in Looe” - these are the best in Cornwall by far - the best in the world. Top quality meat, perfect...

One of the best gluten free pasties I have had and was also very lucky that there was just one left - so my advice is order your gluten free pastry in advance - my partner enjoyed his and said it was terrific so thank...

Omg only one place for a pasty in Looe and that is Sarah no need to go any were else moist tasty filling and reasonably priced 10 10

rude staff couldn’t wait 5 seconds to move out the way before shouting excuse me no pasties left and not making anymore at midday???

Found this little gem of a shop when we saw the very long queue of people all waiting for the fresh made pasties. The pasties are made on site and are scrumptious! They make lots of different ones but we chose traditional meat and veg...

Although we visit Looe every year as a couple, and always enjoy a Pastie from Sarah's Pasty Shop daily, this year our extended family came along with us. We are aged from late 50s to 18 months old. Every day we visited Sarah's, everyday we...

First stop when we got to looe on our holiday on Fri And they are with our doubt the best pasty’s in looe We both had traditional and the apple pasty Will be back time after time for the best pasty’s ever I have tried...

Beautiful food! Pasty and cake was delicious! Bought a cornish pasty and two slices of lemon drizzle and it was just delicious. Worth a visit!

Stopped by for a traditional Cornish pasty. The queue was long and slow moving but it was definitely worth the wait. Amazing pastry and filling. We also had a cheese and bacon puff and that was equally delicious. Having sampled a few Cornish pasties over...

I tried several pasty shops during my trip to Looe, but only Sarah’s was worth writing a review for - and waiting in a 30 minute queue for during the lunch rush! If you’re coming to Looe and want to buy a tasty, reasonably priced...

We had one of these every day for 5 days and they were perfect. We were racing a sailing dinghy each day in National Championships. This is was a welcome treat after coming ashore tired exhausted and in need of Carbs. Enjoyed every bite, every...

You’ve got to be quick as they sell out daily. Testament to the quality of their pasties. Only criticism is the steak & Stilton wasn’t as awesome as a Barnecutt equivalent

Probably the best pasty I've ever had is my wife's comment to the Lamb, leek, mint & rosemary, which when we first visited was 30 mins away from being ready.. just so tasty & surprisingly moist. When we did return the queue was 20 people...

I have been coming to Looe since 1985 and wasn't really a fan of pasties. So it was a bit of a surprise when about 10 years ago my wifes mother. Who is a local bought me a Sarahs pasty and told me to eat...

Well I looked up pasty shops in Cornwall and Sarah’s was the one five stars so off we went there were 15 people in front of us so yes it was the right shop to go to well how wrong we ordered two pasty’s both...

Fantastic pasty yum yum. Definitely worth the wait in queue. Really tasty pasty and great variety. I would definitely get a pasty there again if I was in Looe.

Really disappointed today Monday 29th August. As an annual visitor to Looe for far more years than I would like to admit, one of my favourite lunchtime visits is to Sarah’s pasty shop for a traditional patsy. The first one this year was on Saturday...

Loved the constant queue as we wondered the streets of Looe. Went when we were ready for our lunch and queued. Didn’t take long, good service and pasties a plenty. They were perfectly warm, well cooked and full. I had beef and Stilton and my...

So Sarah's has a legendary status in Looe for the Pasties it serves, which, are to be fair excellent. I not expert enough to say the best but when you can see people making them from scratch it gives you confidence in the method that...

Visited on Tues 23rd and the pasties were without doubt the best we have ever eaten. I had the traditional Cornish pasty and my husband had beef and stilton. Both were absolutely brimming with tasty and succulent filling, including plenty of delicious meat, and the...

great pasties, original (this includes a proper miners pasty that is savoury and sweet) and a good choice for veggies as well

Very disappointed all round. Had to queue which wasn’t a problem however the pasties were very dry and the fillings were very average on the taste front

Words can’t describe my sentiment for Sarah’s Pasties. I came to Looe for 1 week and tried pasties from various competitors but nothing came close. I am emotionally attached to the beef and stilton pasty! Genuinely mouthwatering and packed to the brim of fresh flavour....

We tried most of the pasties and the sausage rolls and they are the best we have ever tasted - you really do notice the difference between here and the other pasty shops , a must to visit if you are in Looe !

Sarah’s pasties have amazing reviews online and deservedly so. We went for the traditional flavour which was full to the brim with filling - and delicious. Just make sure you keep an eye out for seagulls dive bombing you 😂 We will be ordering a...

I think over two weeks we tried pretty much everything; trad pasties, Beef and Stilton pasties, apple & cinnamon pasties, sausage rolls, chicken pies, scones…all of them have been perfect! So fresh and clean tasting, proper wholesome food that’s perfectly seasoned. We’ve totally made our...

I was told this was one of the best places to get a Cornish pastries from and I have to say it 100% is great pastry so so full of filling and defo one of the best if not the best I’ve had from Cornwall...

Truly the best pasty we have ever had. We’ve been back a few time during our stay in Looe. All food looks great and fresh. It gets very busy but worth the queue.

Every time we visit looe, we get our pasty fix from Sarah’s, these are the best pasties by far, the cheese and onion is particularly fantastic, big, full of flavour and just simply enjoyable. As always highly recommended

These are definitely the best pasties in Looe or anywhere! High proportion of tender tasty meat to veg with beautiful golden pastry. They are delicious!

Amazing pasty’s well worth the queue! Unbelievable cheese and onion and cheese and bacon pasty’s - the whole families loved them. Best in Looe!

We woke up to the smell of Sarah's pasties every morning - Really hard not to go and get one for breakfast - I know 🤷. If Carlsberg made pasties they would get Sarah to make them. Go try them for yourself, don't take my...

Beautiful light pastry. Nicely seasoned filling…heaven. !!!! These pasties come straight from the oven and sell so quickly they are never less than piping hot.

Take away only, but the best pasties/pies in Looe. Had a pie and a cream tea on this visit, as one of us didn`t want something savoury.

we joked that every pasty shop proudly said 'award winning pasties' but they all looked a bit dry. Sadly we waited until our last day to discover Sarah's Pasty Shop and they really were the best we've ever tasted. We will definitely be back!

When we visit Looe we always visit Sarahs Pasties, friendly staff, amazing pasties and cream teas! Tip- get there early, when there gone..there gone! thank you, we have enjoyed them at home 2. 😉😊

I ordered late on the Wednesday night for an early collection.. I saw the little shop and knew this was the place to make my purchase, my partner walked down for them and saw the ladies making them in the back... Simply put if you...

The food is amazing!! A pasty lovers dream. We were taking requests from people at home to take back with us :)

We had pasties from another shop in Looe and we were so disappointed. So I googled best pasty shop in Looe and settled on Sarah’s after reading the good reviews and I wasn’t disappointed. Absolutely delicious. We had the lamb and mint and cheese and...

I saw a queue outside shop, so I think better buy one to try, I have tranditional pastry but not much taste, need add some salt and pepper. but they make pastry there fresh and hot.

Best pasties ever. All made fresh too. Not to far to walk to from beach. Staff really nice and an assortment of pasties DELICIOUS 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

I’ve been trying to get hold of Sarah’s traditional pasty all week since on holiday as I’d read a lot of recommendations for them. They are so popular they sell out by midday every day and now I’ve managed to get hold of one I...

No1 pasty shop in cornwall. This place is Amazing real handmade pasties and real friendly staff. Drove 250 miles just to get my pasty fix from this place

Recommended by the staff of Polraen Country House Hotel. Didn’t disappoint. We ordered some to take hime with us.

I had a lamb mint and rosemary pasty today. Wow best pasty I have ever had. They make them on site and you can see them making them! Also had the apple caramel flapjack. Another wow! So soft, moist and tasty I will have to...