Pizza Pilgrims in Islington - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellentes pizzas, la pâte et la garniture sont au top. Aussi un menu enfant. Une belle pizza avec une mozzarella entière dessus Restaurant à taille humaine, service efficace et agréable Nous avons déj sur une table en terrasse au soleil Franchement je recommande fortement

After reading the previous few reviews, I’m not surprised we had the exact same disappointing experience. On a Wednesday night at 9pm when there are less than 15 customers in the restaurant you wouldn’t expect to wait 1 and a half hours for 4 pizzas. Unfortunately this was the case for us. After watching countless delivery drivers and takeaway orders come in and out for an hour, we knew something was wrong since we hadn’t received our pizzas (which take 15 minutes max to cook). Only after we checked on the whereabouts of our food did the staff realise they hadn’t bothered to put our order through to the kitchen - not once did they take the initiative to question why only our table had not been given our food after all this time. We finally received our food at 10:30pm (by the way, we all had work the following day and had to travel home, by this time it was very late and we were hungry and tired). The food was very nice but we were not happy to see on our bill that a service charge had been added for abysmal service. Had we not asked for our food who knows when we would’ve received it. I’ve worked in hospitality for many years and understand mistakes and miscommunication happen, but at no point did any staff member apologise for the error or offer any kind of discount. Instead we had to ask for this ourselves and when we were not satisfied with the ‘best offer’ he could give us of taking off the service charge, he said that if we kept removing items from the bill his manager would not be happy. Super unprofessional, rude service, nice food but not worth the poor experience. Senior management should have a review of this branch because it’s easily the worst one I’ve been to by a mile.

Regularly come in Pizza Pilgrims, food amazing as always! Came in on a particularly busy night where the kitchen was running behind schedule a tad. Our server Sara was incredibly apologetic for the situation (which was no issue at all, as we were told beforehand). So a great meal with fantastic customer service!

Arrived for our booking and stood waiting for 5 minutes before anyone decided to greet and seat us, despite multiple staff standing around and looking at us. Once we sat down, we waited 5 more minutes before anyone took our order only to be be told that half of the menu wasn’t available. After that was cleared, we then informed the waiter that a member of our party had a peanut allergy, to which he checked with the kitchen and then informed us that we wouldn’t be able to order anything. He told us the chef wasn’t willing to take the risk to serve us if we had any allergies. We left without any apology or goodbye from staff. Was a real shame because the place looked cool, however this was spoilt by the unprofessional behaviour of the staff!

In general I like pizza pilgrims but this time was disappointing. The service was impersonal and inattentive. We waited about 15 minutes for two soft drinks and when we asked about them we were told they didn’t have them in stock. Would have been nice for them to let us know that before. Our pizzas came out slowly as well (shortly after we checked on them) and were pretty lukewarm, so obviously not the best tasting. We also didn’t get the chance to mention this as no one came to check up on everything either during or after our meal. The prices are average and I believe fair, but we were pretty annoyed that a 12.5% service charge was automatically added to the bill given the service we received for the meal was substandard. As a server myself, I don’t think you should assume the right to a service charge without providing the service to match.

Great little find. Fresh authentic pizza at really competitive prices. Between us we had one with salami ( and honey !) another with nduja. Both great . Each was less than £13. Really friendly staff - lovely feel to the restaurant. Throughly recommend.

Just fabulous. Great service and great pizza. Plus a lively fun location. The waiting staff and manager were super kind and welcoming.

Lovely staff! Thanks Humi!! Great pizza, everything we were looking for. Humi looked after us really well and found extra space for us when we needed it :)

Fantastic pizza, cocktails and desserts and even better service. The manager and deputy manager were both in and really looked after us, and all the other customers - it was busy! Even one of the chefs asked about our meal as he passed with more ingredients for the kitchen. The Mac N Cheese balls were off the scale gorgeous. The two ladies in charge were excellent and really made my daughters night; they were so good we went back for lunch the next day before getting our train out of London. We will be back next time we go to London.

Such great pizza and Neghisti was brilliant and so kind to our dog! Drinks also fantastic. Great branch.

The pizzas were ok as was the kids pizza, the service was rubbish , they forgot part of the order, after reminding them it finally arrived after everyone else was almost finished eating. We were seated downstairs and had to keep going upstairs to find waiter.... however, we paid the £12 service charge, but will not be making a return visit ..

Leonora was unbelievable from the start so accommodating The food was amazing and the staff were top notch

Great staff and what a great manager. It was lovely eating here and the manager stopped to have a chat with us and made sure we were enjoying our pizza.

First time at Pizza Pilgrims and tried the “Pepperoni and Honey” which was pretty amazing. My colleague had the Margarita which was also very good. A very nice lunch and will definitely return!

We ate here by chance but are so glad we did! The staff were so friendly and helpful, and the pizzas were just fantastic! I had the double pepperoni with spicy honey and added ‘nduja sausage and my wife had pesto pizza with added ‘nduja. The spicy honey “just works”, and the combination of that and the pepperoni and the ‘nduja was just amazing. We both tried each other’s and both liked both of them so much we swapped half and half! We also had their “crust dippers”, which were thickened dipping sauces, in white truffle, pesto and ‘nduja flavours. Our son had a small margarita which was likewise very tasty. Really cannot recommend this place highly enough - really delicious! The three pizzas plus two soft drinks each only came to £55 too - cannot recommend it highly enough.

Fantastic meal and I would highly recommend to anyone. Legit the best pizza I have ever had! Mark and Andrez and fabio the best hosts! Pizza pilgrim are incredibly lucky to have them! I will be Back!

17.8.2020 lovely see a friend in London! Eating nice pizza !!! #buffulo #pizza#cheese#italian#londoncafe #homemadelemonade #homemadedrink#cheesetomatopizza #dinewithzara @missemery89 Taste fresh!

Came here casually... good atmosphere at the sunset of an end of may evening.. fantastic mood ... happy days

Amazing pizza and very friendly and professional costumers service can't wait to go back. Antimo suggests to me the 8 cheese pizza super tasty I felt like if I was back in Italy. DON'T FORGET TO TRY THE NUTELLAMISU'.

One of the best launch in London Best service, Antimo served us and he was just amazing. Definitely coming back

proper italian pizza, super friendly stuff and genuine ingredients! very recommend for a day out with mates! :)

8-cheese pizza! Yes, 8! Great customer service! The order system was down unfortunately but the gentleman taking care of us dealt with it effortless. They even made a bear shaped marguerite for our two year old, brought a high chair and everything. Zero trouble, zero...

First time I’ve visited this branch & definitely can’t fault the pizza - tasty & not too bad on the wallet. Also very quick & friendly service. Only small issue is would be nice to have some starter options & maybe a better selection of...

A really tasty pizza but please leave your customers to eat in peace.It doesn't need 4 waiters to interrupt to ask if it's ok. Don't clear one plate while 3 people have yet to finish. Stop loitering and looking over our shoulder. I understand you...

7 of us turned up without a booking, and the staff were so accomodating and sorted us a table straight away, they were really attentive and welcoming. Myself and a colleague ordered the 'Smoked Napoli' we thoroughly enjoyed it, it was beautiful. The rest of...

The Scottish waiter couldn't have been more helpful and professional but sadly his service was the only positive to to this meal. The rocket salad was just a handful of rocket leaves. Nothing else, not even a dressing and the parmigiana melanzane was more like...

After a morning discovering the Rail Mail at the nearby Postal Museum our boys and I headed to Exmouth market. Pizza Pilgrims had outdoor tables and seemed nice so we went for it. The pizzas were delish - we had Margherita and Burrata. Really good.

Super staff and lovely pizza. Bonus that my dog can come in too. The staff are great and made our trip extra special, especially the manager.

We needed to eat before visiting Sadlers Wells and this was an ideal choice. There is a small eating area outside and also on the entrance level. There is further dining area in the basement, which we didn't visit. The Pizzas were lovely, my wife...

This is a small quirky little place that you could easily walk by without noticing . However they do really great pizzas with well cooked crispy bases which I really love as I’m not a fan of the pizzas with thick soggy bases drowning in...

If your will to que and wait then i would recommend this as one of the best Pizza restaurants around. We sat outside, got some drinks and got served by a really nice young French girl who i must say looked after us extremely well....

Lovely cosy restaurant with outdoor seating. The service was very good and our pizza came out in about 10 minutes. The pepperoni with roasted pepper was delicious. Not overly expensive and they were a good size to share.

A nice cozy restaurant, the atmosphere was very chilled and the service attentive. We had to wait under 10 minutes for a table for two on a Friday night! Food was marvellous, the waiter suggested us the pesto pizza with burata which was great. We...

I had the honey and pepperoni pizza which was incredibly tasty, nice twist on the traditional pepperoni that everyone else does. The cocktail was a real miss for me however the service was super fast, our waitress was lovely and it had a nice atmosphere.

I'm pretty clued up on pizza and make my own sourdough and ovens... Very happy with experience here. Dough was tasty, not over seasoned and authentic neopolitan style dough, nice and floppy with great leopard spotting. Quick service as was dining solo

If like me you prefer thin and crispy pizza, then it won’t be for you. They are very thick, more like a big naan Bread. Service was excellent and all staff very friendly. Very interesting toppings though so it’s a question of choice whether you...

Nice to visit Exmouth Market and sit outside this place in the sun today. Very nice staff and good service. Tasty pizzas x2, both a bit too soggy though- possibly the neapolitan way, but I'm not convinced myself! Turn the oven up a bit, get...

I really enjoyed eating here. The choice of pizzas was great and my colleague and I both chose one from the menu with a couple of modifications. When the pizzas arrived we were very impressed - they looked really appetising. Thankfully, they tasted as good...

Excellent pizza, super dessert and great service. Nice people who just love serving pizza and they serve a lot of it!

Friendly staff, cool, laid back and unpretentious setting. Really enjoyed the pizzas here and everyone said we’d come back again. Soft, doughy and very fresh without being sloppy or greasy. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area. Lots of decent pubs and bars...

Nice place - funky urban dining. Managed to fit me in at 8pm within a few minutes! Had one of the pizzas recommended by the waiter as I thought I'd give something new a try, glad i did along with a salad and a glass...

I have been going to Pizza Pilgrims for years and I can say I have never had a bad pizza and I am extremely fussy when it comes to pizza. The food has always been amazing I highly recommend Nduja with fresh red chillys if...

This restaurant came highly recommended to me so we decided up try it out. I enjoyed it, but I think maybe my expectations were too high. It was good but not great. I've definitely had better pizza. Felt like it wasn't "baked" properly, toppings felt...

This place was awesome. I came here with a friend and we were craving for pizza. We have heard of bad ones in the UK so we were hesitant. It was a busy night so it was expectant of service to be a bit hectic...

First time in Exmouth Market and I'm glad we decided to eat at Pilgrim. Very nice Pizzas, light dough and nice toppings (I recommend Nduja with extra chilies).

Lovely little pizzaria! Reasonably priced and pizzas gorgeous. Very light and tasty. Also had the buffalo mozzarella which was so tasty! Not a glamorous place but so worth it for the food always very busy which proves how good this place is!

I never leave any review as I have been working in hospitality and I know how hectic the work can be especially on a Saturday night. This wasn't the case as when I went to get a pizza with my friends the restaurant was almost...

If you’re looking for a friendly place where to eat a good Neapolitan-style pizza, that’s the right place. Absolutely my favorite pizza restaurant in London. They don’t have a wide choice, but the price is convenient. Highly recommended!!

Okay, so not EVERYTHING in Exmouth Market has sold out and looked to the buck as the only defining factor. This laid-back eatery based on that most quotidian of dishes—pizza—is one of the few remaining beacons of light in a pedestrianised street beset by greed...

Had a great time, the staff were very accommodating and managed to fit me in with no fuss when they were very busy. My waitress with the glasses was very helpful, gave me good recommendations and was always quick to attend my table.

Its a really good pizza, with fresh ingredients. They cooked the pizza in a stone oven! Great experience!

Just happened to pass by on a Saturday afternoon and decided to a have a pizza for lunch.. Great decision! Pizza was fantastic. Staff were amazing! Would come back again.

Could not organise a piss up in a brewery! It was full and we were told 20 mins. 30 mins later and there were 14 chairs free and no idea how to seat people. Lead waitresses needs help as no organisation skills.

I am a regular customer of Pizza Pilgrims and I am always excited to come back! Not only for. E delicious and affordable pizzas but for the service as well. I would totally recommend to all waiters to be as nice as Marc and Carmen...

Not sure what the fuss is about with the -3 star reviews, I come here quite often and receive excellent customer service and the pizzas arrive quickly and are always top quality. Its nice to be able to see the pizza oven with your pizza...

Very nice pizza and came very quickly! The base and crust was so soft and delicious when folded in half, since the base isn't very hard. I had the Smoked Napoli pizza with anchovies which turned out to be really salty, so definitely needed a...

We tried the salami pizza. The toppings were fresh and plentiful and the crust was thin and crisp. The service was friendly and the our order arrived quickly. The pizza was delicious and a perfect size for lunch. Fair warning, this is a small restaurant...

Came here for something to eat mid afternoon. Very down to earth and basic but pizzas were really rather good, service was fine and it was excellent value. well worth going to if you are passing by

Reviewed PP before but wanted to review again because this is consistently the best pizza in town. This more so as the nearest competition seems to be growing fast and maybe losing the independent touch. Excellent service from Marianna this time.

I visited this place in late evening and tried to order Nduja Pizza. I seen on menu and hey do gorgonzola pizza as well, so asked to put extra gorgonzola as well. Because I know both of these ingredients (Nduja and gorgonzola)are very strong taste...

We had fantastic takeaway pizzas here. All the toppings we had - aubergine, mushroom & truffle, nduja sausages, salami - were great. The only minor gripe is that the pizzas could be a little bit bigger - I had to have one and a half!

No apology could possibly make up for our terrible experience in this restaurant. We went in for a quick meal on a very quiet sunday afternoon. The staff were so rude. First, their loud chatting and generally messing around whilst we waited for our order...

Went for early dinner on a Tuesday. Ordered 3 pizzas and were promptly brought out. Pizzas were good and service was fine. Would visit again.

Tried Glanfranco Gorgonzola. Its delicious.Marerita is unique. ambience is good. Usually fridays are crowded. Staff is welcoming and polite. Good thing they remembered my preferences once I frequented

I had heard a lot of hype about this place for a couple of years but had never gotten round to visiting. I don't know if I'm missing something, but for me the pizza was just ok with tasty enough ingredients but overly greasy and...

We are addicted to this place and used to get takeaway from there almost once per week. Pizza Pilgrims is one of the things I miss the most about living in the area. Absolutely great.

I was looking for a nice place to have a quick bite to eat, whilst solo. Haven eaten at a lot of pizza places, this has to stand out as one of the best. I had a salami pizza, which tasted fantastic. The base was...

I'm slightly obsessed with sour dough fan and have tasted many, maaaany of London's offerings. The one I had here the other night was one of the best ever. The base, sauce, mozzarella and toppings were so bloody tasty and fresh. I've been to the...

Our first night in London we decided to eat there which is close by where we are staying. Abbie and Gabrielle provided outstanding service. The cute seating outside is a done deal at night and to top it off, great bottled beer and good pizza....

Have you ever had Naples style pizza? No? Do yourself a favor. It will be the only kind of pizza you ever go back to. Pizza Pilgrims has an amazing variety of these pizzas and they're so delicious. Ready minutes after ordering, and just the...

Our family of 6 had just arrived in London from the states and we had checked into our rented apartment and were looking for a quick meal before heading off to see the sites. The Exmouth Market area had been recommended to us as a...

Pizza Pilgrims provides some awesome pizza at a fitting price. You know exactly what you're getting- nothing else to say really!

Margarita pizza was out of this world. and the staff was very cool. Pizza was like the pizza I use to eat as a kid in napoli

Best pizza we have ever tasted !!!!! I read about this little gem online prior to our trip & I am so glad we made the effort to find it. Staff were so lovely & friendly, cocktails were to die for & the pizza was...

We were walking past on a Sunday afternoon and were tempted in by the look of the pizzas being eaten by those sitting outside. We were greeted warmly, given options of where we wanted to sit, and were served in a friendly, cheerful way by...

I found this place by shear fluke when as a family we wondered to the food stalls on Exmouth Market for a bit to eat and ended up heading hear. My son does not eat cheese and I am not a massive fan but I...

We all loved the pizzas, soft and tasty dough with flavoursome toppings. Lovely staff too. Daughter less happy with toilets but it is only a small place I thought it was great food and amazing value!

I have been in this pizzeria Saturday 25th of March (evening). the pizza was great but I am very disappointed about the service. the staff was disorganized and uncaring, more like a game than a job. The curly waiter and the other one also with...

A great find a few minutes from our hotel, located in vibrant Exmouth market. Good atmosphere, good service and excellent pizzas! Enjoyed by adults and children alike. Really enjoyed this meal (even the Nutella espresso).

We're pizza lovers. I mean, we are Italians in London and we need that "fell at home" flavour. I honestly think this trumps a lot of places in Napoli (i don't even mention Franco Manca, that is quite good anyway). We were impressed. Staff is...

We dropped in for a quick pizza. My wife and son found the pizza rather soggy and we were immediately offered a replacement that was cooked longer in the oven - at no extra charge. Excellent service indeed.

Having visited the Dean Street branch before, this was a no-brainer for lunch whilst wandering through Exmouth Market. Pizzas are reasonable and generous - made in the Neapolitan style. I chose the Mushrooms with Truffle oil white pizza. Washed down with the obligatory San Pelligrino....

I went there with my sister and her boyfriend, the food was awesome,really good quality for the price,never thought I could find something so nice so far away from home,Italy. But still,why just one star out of 5? Well because one of the waiters called...

Great spot for a tasty cheap dinner. The pizza tasted really authentic and the staff were really friendly

Came in for lunch with the rellies and had such a great time. The blonde waiter with the ponytail really knows his stuff. Best negronis in town and real authentic pizza!! See you next time Pizza Pilgrims!

Tried it with a friend for a first time. Service was amazing ,pizza delivery was super fast and a good quality beer.Thank you Fabrizio for making a great night

I've been here before and enjoyed it so thought I'd have lunch here with my grown-up daughter between hunting for a bargain in the sale (fruitless) and going to The Palladium to see the panto (excellent). We were lucky, there was a table for two...

If, like me, you're a fan of pizza you could a lot lot worse then to try a pizza pilgrims. Popped into the exmouth market store for a quick beer and pizza. Restaurant was cosy and comfortable with friendly and engaging staff. Ordered and with...

Not being a huge pizza fan myself, I didn't expect much, but was not left disappointed when a few friends and I went. The pizza is, hands on heart, one of the very best I've had and also very reasonably priced - I paid roughly...

I had the guest pizza, with pumpkin and an amaretti cookie. Very original, one of the best pizzas I have ever had! The location is amazing, great atmosphere and the service is very good as well! Will definately come back here when I am back...

We sat in a cramped upper interior, at a sticky surfaced table.My hands and napkin were almost glued to it at times.Not cleaned at all well ,confirmed by the piece of pizza also attaching itself to my right foot,which when investigating, was soon to be...

We had an excellent pizza here this week. Great outdoor seating and attentive, professional service. Definitely recommend this location for one of the best pizzas in London.

Casual atmosphere with attentive service. Great, authentic Neapolitan pizza made to your liking! Don't miss desert.

There's a bit of a buzz around this new no frills pizza company which now has half a dozen outlets in London. It may be one to try before they get too big and quality suffers! For the moment though pizza bases are handmade and...

This was quite a good Pizza but I had better ones. Maybe is because I am a fan of thick dough in pizza (and here was ultra thin...)

We decided to try it, but unfortunately, I couldn't eat the pizza as it was too burnt for me. I enquired if I could have a less burned one, but was told - similar to another customer/reviewer - that due to the oven it would...

The pizza here is good. You can't really go wrong with any of the choices and the calzone is a hefty size pizza that hits the spot when your hungry. However, the service on this visit was disappointing and let Exmouth Market branch down. Went...

Trust an Italian, you will not find a better place to have pizza in all London (even though pizza in London tend to be way too expensive for Italian standards). Top quality mozzarella cheese. Not to miss!

Phenomenal pizza. So far removed from a lot of the poor attempts we get in the UK. As close to an Italian experience as I can remember in this country.

My expected pizza experience is "nice topping, shame about the base". Highlights of Pizza Pilgrims for me was the light, fluffy, moist base which complemented my "ndula" pizza perfectly. Delicious.