Isabellas in Sheffield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Fantastic service and beautiful food and drinks. We had the baked mushroom starter, which was perfectly cooked with a gorgeous sauce (which is a good thing!), the margherita pizza, and the mushroom tagliatelle. All of it was delicious and really well priced. I also had the margherita, which was lovely. The service was immaculate - both Amys were lovely, and Amy N was particularly attentive. Love it here!

Didn't eat here. Just had drinks. Nice place very friendly.

Candles, fairy lights, the loveliest staff and the BEST veggie food - always prepared fresh from scratch with delicious ingredients and always super-tasty! Our fave go-to for food. 100% recommend!

Popped in for lunch. Great service & great food Will return next time in Sheffield

Highly recommend, me and my partner went, it’s such a nice atmosphere, the staff are lovely and very attentive, they refilled our wine when it was low which was a nice touch, the food is gorgeous and very reasonable priced

Always quality food and service

The service was friendly and overall fantastic. The food tasted fresh, had lovely presentation, and was delicious. Myself and my family thoroughly enjoyed our evening here and we would definitely come back again.

My first visit with friends. All agreed the food was really good. The service was fantastic. Staff were friendly and welcoming and knowledgeable about the dishes. I would definitely recommend and will be returning.

Very nice atmosphere and food. The waiter, Gianni, was excellent, very welcoming and recommended us a very nice wine :)

The food was really strongly average. Very poor quality bruschetta as a starter. The dried salmon was swimming in sour water. The steak was rubbery - a well done does not mean dry, rubbery meat. Drink glasses were sticky and disgusting as the waitress poured drinks going to our table. No disposable tissues on the table (only the main ones)! The fries weren't fried, but cooked. We gave a small tip, but was it worth it? We won't return to this place again but wish it luck though. :/ By the way, it's inappropriate when the waitress takes the bill from the table with the cash we left behind and checks the money in front of us... This can make customers feel like scammers for not paying for their food. :(

We visited on Sunday 19th May for my daughter's 23rd birthday and took advantage of the glorious weather by sitting outside. We were quickly attended to by a friendly member of staff who knew we'd booked for a special occasion and offered my daughter a complimentary cocktail! The excellent service continued throughout by this gentleman (sorry I can't remember his name) and the food served was absolutely delicious and excellent value for money. We even had an extra scallop because we shared the starter between the four of us, which was a lovely gesture. The portions are very generous (don't be fooled by my photo's - the plates are very large) and the bread twirls that accompany the bread and olive sharer are to die for! Thank you for making my daughter feel special and for our group photo complete with fir tree hat 😂❤️

The food and the cocktails are fantastic. Our waitress Amy was exceptional. Nothing was too much trouble, service with a smile too. Would highly recommend this place and will be returning for sure!!

Gianni was so nice, really good service and amazing cocktails! would deffo come back !

Gianni was a fabulous waiter and our meal couldn’t have been better. Atmosphere was fantastic and cocktails were delish! We will definitely be back again, couldn’t of had a better experience!

Gianni was an excellent waiter and the food was incredible!

Stumbled on this place last night. Didn’t have a reservation but they were able to squeeze us in. Food was lovely, staff were brilliant and we had a great time. Will definitely be back. Highly recommended

We visited tonight for our Mums birthday and we had a wonderful meal. The food is just incredible, service and hosting was fantastic. We will definitely be returning and telling our friends and family about Isabella’s.

Lovely Italian restaurant. Reasonably priced..

Great wine bar with amazing food and service both in the bar and restaurant. Recommend.

We have grown very fond of it here. Standards are reliable and shown time and time again. Service is attentive, especially Gianni. Love the seafood linguine and the wild mushroom risotto. Bruschetta is always so fresh and tasty. Bread and dips always a winner. Negronis always on point. Also a nice place for a cheeky day drink In the summer!

Our first visit & definitely not our last! Lovely cosy atmosphere, friendly and efficient staff, and very delicious mains & desserts. The tiramisu was a big hit! Thank you for a perfect evening

Wonderful food and excellent friendly service. 2 mains with homemade chips and a bottle of wine £51

Lovely time with excellent food. Waiting staff are super friendly and accommodating.

Love Isabella’s. Perfect bar on Kelham. Great service and drinks.

Eaten here several times both with family and as a couple - it's been great every time. The staff are always kind and friendly, the food is tasty and the vibe is very chilled.

Lovely authentic family meal would highly recommend! We are local residents and are lucky to have so many restaurants on our doorstep. However, having just dined at Isabella’s Italian restaurant, we felt that we should share what a wonderful and lovely experience it was. Straight from the beginning, the staff were extremely accommodating, they ensured that we were sat in a nice area and swiftly brought us a high chair for our daughter. The menu and food was great, there is so much choice and despite not having a children’s menu they offered us some alternative. They were extremely attentive, and the food was absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend it to anyone that visits Kelham Island and local families in the area.

Had a really lovely meal here. Service was excellent and will definitely be coming back.

Didn't eat here so can't comment on the food but the service is very friendly with reasonably priced drinks. Called back in at 11 for more drinks after we'd eaten elsewhere but they were closing, shame but i assumed this was down to the area being quite residential.

Excellent address for very good Italian cuisine.

Always fabulous. The food is amazing and so are the staff.

went here yesterday at 6pm, for some reason there was a dj which was way too loud for us. was abit confused as to why a dj was playing on a sunday evening as it sort of ruined the mood and atmosphere and it was hard to hear. asked if we could be seated upstairs to avoid the loud music and amy sorted out a table for us with a smile on her face and she made our entire evening such a pleasant one. she is clearly great at her role and we were glad to be served with someone who was so kind and helpful and understanding. really made the whole experience a lovely one. hope she gets the recognition she deserves

Had an absolutely delicious meal, lovely atmosphere

We visited Saturday 11th November, 9 friends booked a cocktail table for two hours followed by a meal in the restaurant, the venue, service, drinks and food was fantastic quality and really good value, we will definitely go back, we all had a really nice day and the venue is beautiful, staff all lovely, a real good find in Sheffield Kelham Island.

Very pleasant afternoon spent here

Great place to go foods always fantastic, I would highly recommend

Absolutely brilliant The staff Brooke,& Fin both gave us exceptional service. The food was amazing, the atmosphere was perfect couldn’t fault a thing Can 100% recommend the brunch ❤️ Thank you

One of the best restaurants in Sheffield. Gorgeous decor, fast service, tasty food. Lots of variety in the menu and the team are always helpful in ensuring that everything is perfect throughout. Not my first visit and definitely won’t be my last. ☺️

Food was delicious, the staff were lovely and the overall atmosphere was brilliant. Really warm and inviting

Lovely food. Great location. Decent prices for a meal out in the up and coming Kelham Island! The staff were very talkative too. Would definitely return and recommend the Pizza Royale ! X

Absolutely brilliant! This place deserves 5* and no less, we came for bottomless brunch yesterday & its by far the best I've been to. The food is beautiful & the drinks are amazing!! Worth every penny & to top it off your staff are so lovely & couldn't have been better. Thanks for making our first experience a good one. We will be back for sure🥰😍

Lovely place with great food and atmosphere.

Says you’re open til 10pm. Twice in a Sunday I have tried to get a table (whilst you are actually taking food out infront of me) and your staff say you’re closed. It’s a joke. Put a sign out saying she. You stop serving. Just because I am one person doesn’t mean I don’t deserve food

We have visited Isabellas many times before and everything is always consistentlly fabulous. Delicious food from a very tasty menu, fabulous cocktails, amazing wine and great service always. The wine list is particularly good and staff have a great knowledge about the wines they sell. All the staff are friendly and helpful. Lovely atmosphere and a great place to go for dinner or just drinks. Highly recommended.

Really enjoyed the meal. Great pizza and garlic bread by the way!

Superb service, drinks and ambience.

Great food and excellent staff!

Could be my new favourite Italian restaurant in Sheffield. All round excellent evening at Isabellas.

Lovely place very welcoming, excellent food & very helpful & friendly staff, will definitely be back 😀

We had a lovely evening here. The restaurant upstairs is cosy and the staff are friendly. The portion sizes are generous and we felt like we got good value for money. My partner had the mushroom pasta which was delicious! I had the red pepper and goats cheese risotto which was quite disappointing as it was very bland. I would highly recommend the mushroom pasta as it is some of the best!

Beautiful place and amazing food. Really can't wait to go back 🙂

Really nice spot in Kelham Island. Food is of a really high quality with very generous portions. Service friendly and attentive. Definitely a place to try. Only issue was the smoky atmosphere in the restaurant from the kitchen which left our table with sore eyes and smelly clothes.

Was nice food for a baby shower event :) the homemade chips were lovely.

Great food and atmosphere lovely staff.

Went there for a family dinner, we have got a table book but when we got there we needed to wait for 20-30mins for our table because it wasn’t ready. When we got our table, we waited over an hour for the food due to short staffed, understandable but unacceptable honestly, cuz you could have told us earlier. Food was okay, staffs are nice and friendly, but I don’t think I would go again.

Lovely place in the centre of Kelham Island. Has a nice atmosphere with friendly staff. Food was great, as were the prices. Will definitely return.

No complaints about Isabellas at all, great food and lovely place, just a little bit more attentive service instead of me doing the chasing after it is letting you down

Great Italian restaurant, food was delicious and the eating area was trendy and interesting. Staff were lovely and the facilities were clean and tidy! In the photos are the Meat antipasti and the mains were the Diavolo pizza and Wild mushroom risotto. Absolutely delicious would definitely recommend!

The food is incredible here. Thank you to Salvador, Ailisha and Linda for the amazing service. They deserve a pay rise and truly a credit to this business.

A wonderful cosy bar and restaurant with absolutely phenomenal food. Massive thank you to the chefs for making excellent recommendations and being able to accommodate my dietary preferences. Also to the wonderful wait staff and bartenders for conversation and accommodation. Especially big thanks to Chef Sal, Wait staff Linda and Bartender Alysia Will definitely be back again and whole heartedly recommend, be sure to book in advance because man is it worth it!

Good selection of drinks Great food Nice background music

Nowhere to put your coats. Long wait for drinks

What a gorgeous find. Lovely trendy area,gorgeous chic decor, beautiful cocktails and extremely well priced and lovely friendly staff

Been here on 3 occasions every time it has been great, food fantastic and excellent wines

Food great, staff friendly, lovely place just to sit and talk after the meal, would recommend

Lovely bar we went there last night with my husband for a drink.They are making their own cocktails.....Honestly Issac and his team are making a variety of different kind of cocktails (MUST TRY)and my favourite one Basilico.Excellent service!!

Booked a table for my birthday, total disappointment:/ Although we booked the restaurant, couldn’t sit our reserved table, told that the restaurant was overcrowded due to a party. we could only sit at the bar and no notice of change was given before arrival. On top of such unwelcoming start, they couldn’t serve the starters we ordered again, kitchen was too busy! we had to order main courses… just to find out more bad surprises!! Risotto (l shall rather call it soup) was not edible at all. To be honest, worst risotto l ever had in my life. My friends had salmon and seafood pasta, again no one could finish the food. It was absolutely disheartening experience and l am sorry to say but TERRIBLE FOOD.

Great food and friendly staff. Love the wide selection of cocktails. Can't wait to return.

Unfortunatelly No nice food. Old potatos from microvave instead to be roasted. Every single meal even starter has had issue;((( Just drink nice. Definetly I don’t recomend food there.

Really lovely spot. Good food, nice atmosphere. The mushroom risotto was superb.

Beautiful place but doesn't cater for disabled I'm not in a wheelchair but struggle with stairs was told don't serve food downstairs after 5pm & disabled toilet is not in use as used for storage so I had to go to fat cat to use their toilet

Read really good reviews about here but left underwhelmed and a bit disappointed. We were waiting over half an hour before being and to order our food due to a back log in the kitchen. The stuffed pepper was meant to have lamb shoulder but instead was substituted for mince meat at the same price. The food was nice however but wouldn’t rush back.

Excellent. Warm and welcoming from walking through the door. Good food menu and a great selection of wines. Service was spot on thanks for a great vist.

Very good address, very good dishes, friendly and available staff, attentive! Great discovery in the Kelham Island area.

Fantastic food and fantastic service. I highly recommend this restaurant if your looking for an Italian cuisine

Very friendly staff, good service, we were only there for drinks but a very nice place to visit.

Lovely ambiance, friendly polite staff exceptional food and reasonably priced

Amazing Italian restaurant, with amazing Italian head chef and pizza chef, had an amazing meal today, I'll definitely come back and recommend to everyone

We were meeting friends nearby so randomly found this restaurant, the great smells, tastes, presentation 😋 delightful. We will definitely return. The toilets were so clean, staff brilliant and the pricing was ok too

Well my partner got recommended this place from a friend and we are so glad that we went. The service was super friendly and polite, the food was cooked to perfection and delicious. Me and my partner have found our new favourite restaurant and we will definitely be coming back for more.

No better analogy to describe this place than "A diamond in the rough". Absolutely amazing food fit for a King (or Queen). Beautiful decor and such a great team of staff members. Couldn't be more friendly and helpful if they tried, 100% going to be a returning customer.

Food was deicious. Lovely dining area and bar. Would recommend and would definitely go again.

Very comfortable with a great selection of food and drink in smart surroundings

Last minute reservation as we have been trying to book this place for while. We were so excited to finally give it a go, but we were so disappointed. The service was terrible. We waited about 15 mins to order drinks, even after making eye contact with the waitress several times on an evening that wasn’t even busy. We then finally managed to catch someone’s attention. When drinks were empty we weren’t asked if we would like more. The food was very over priced for the basic meals we received. I don’t usually mind paying £14/15 for a meal. But for a bit of chicken with tinned tomatoes with a few spices thrown in just wasn’t for me. It was like there was no effort out into the dish at all. My partners meal was okay, but again, a bit pathetic for the price. Certainly won’t be returning

Great selection of meals at good prices, friendly staff and atmosphere. A great addition to kelham island

Had a beautiful pizza. Good price and pleasant atmosphere.

Absolutely great food and wonderful service in a very friendly, warm family environment. Great value for money and excellent food and wine. Cannot wait to go back!

Kind and amazing staff, from the bouncer to the waitresses. They suggested me the Arrabbiata Pasta as vegan option. Perfectly cooked, tomato sauce super fresh. Great wine too! Highly recommended.

Really nice food, lovely place, friendly staff

Brilliant food and steve is really helpful with large booking we had .

Visited recently for a bite to eat and a few drinks. We went on a Friday around 1pm and were the only people there. I think they had just opened as it was a little bit cold when we first sat down. The food was great though, really enjoyed it. We ordered a few bits to share (between 3 of us)... A meat antipasti board, pepperoni pizza and some garlic roasted potatoes. All of it was delicious, the pizza was done how I like it, crispy and not swimming in grease, and the potatoes were perfect! They have all the usual alcoholic drinks plus a few craft ales on tap, which is always a welcome addition. The staff were friendly and the prices are reasonable, plus dogs are allowed.. Which some may not approve of, but I do :) Definitely worth a visit and we'll be going again soon!

Absolutely loved it here! I booked this place for a company Christmas Party (sorry the review is a couple of weeks old) we had the upstairs area just for our party. The food and service was spot on! Best Italian restaurant we have been too in Sheffield by a mile! The service was really quick, we were a large party of 14, but all the food came out together and no one had to wait. The food was brilliant quality! The meatball starter was to die for! The staff didn't mind us staying in the area and they were great!! Booking a meal for a large party - this is the perfect place to do it!

Just stopped for drinks but had a lovely visit. Great service and very pleasant surroundings, will be back to eat.

What a fabulous find! As soon as the door was opened I had a feeling this was going to be an amazing night. We had a cocktail at the luxurious bar prior to heading upstairs for dinner. There was a beautiful blossom tree creating an atmosphere of relaxation. We had a table in the window and Steve (owner) talked us through our likes/dislikes and made some recommendations. I’m so glad he did. The food was beautifully presented and tasted delicious. The staff were really friendly and helpful. It’s not huge upstairs and you’re not crammed in, so you can hear all of your party’s conversation which is a rare thing now. Don’t hesitate to go as you’ll definitely not be disappointed.

Beautiful food & friendly, relaxed atmosphere

Absolulty fab food and fantastic staff and atmosphere we visited 20th November 2021 nothing was too much trouble we wasn't rushed at all we visited as a couple and had a great time the owner was lovely and was hands on will definitely be going again Thank you for a lovely night isabellas

Lovely place, good atmosphere and good service but poor food & customer service 😢 4 of our 8 meals were pizza & all 4 were awful. Either the dough or the tomato base were seriously over salted. So much so we couldn't finish them! Plus the Lamp pizza had never seen lamb ! So when I complained, they sent over the youngest & least experienced member of staff to offer apologies even though it was an open kitchen and nothing was deducted from our bill. Poor effort 👎

My partner and I went here for a date night. We were seated upstairs by the fireplace. They’ve added a lovely tree upstairs since my last visit so the general aesthetic of the room is so very cosy. I had the red pepper and goats cheese risotto (yum) and my partner went for the penne pesto pollo dish with a rocket side salad and focaccia to share. The service we received was great, and an extra note was that the chef also spoke to us on his way downstairs. Something simple in passing like ‘enjoy your meals’ but it meant a lot as chefs are often unknown and hidden away. So I would recommend a visit, and we’ll certainly be back.

My gosh it is amazing, so tasty, food is made with high quality ingredients, the cocktails are also exceptional and reasonably priced, interesting choice in music but still loved our stay

Had a great pizza, staff very friendly and helpful, recommend

Organised a hen do to at Isabellas last night, such a perfect venue, the staff went above and beyond for us all, nothing was a trouble for them. The pizzas were delicious. Drinks were reasonably priced. Would definitely recommend. Thank you Isabellas for making the night so special