GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
3.8

Based on 3.083 opinions finded in 2 websites

site_photo4

Nº 261 in 466 in Swindon

Nº 13 of 29 Chinese in Swindon

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..chickenchocolatesushifriedbeautifulriceduckpayfruitcookedorientalprawnspuddingprawnmustmeatoldcream

comment_iconOpinions

I never been there but just one we was eating there but the food it was rubish the kake it was no FRESH at all and no many to choice just a small place...the salate as well they don't have it first time there but we never eating there again rubish Chinese durtty no happy👎👎👎👎👎shit food

site_logo

Bogdan Andrei . 2025-05-14

MORE AT Google

Food quality very good, price was ok, bit more variety at lunch would have been better, and the robot clearing the table well good 😁

site_logo

728ikev . 2025-05-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Wow, what a find, especially when not from the area. Was looking for a Chinese buffet and struck gold. This is a beautiful place in a lovely Asian styled building, wonderfully decorated but most importantly, an amazing selection of Chinese food that was perfectly cooked, fresh and plentiful. To give you some idea of how good it was, my friend who came with me is married to a lady in the Philippines and said it was the best Asian food he'd ever eaten which is quite some accolade. Easily the best buffet I have ever had and can't recommend it high enough

site_logo

Mark Mclaverty-Locke . 2025-05-12

MORE AT Google

Charging a full kids’ meal price for a 3-year-old toddler is unreasonable, especially considering how little they eat. Families should be supported, not penalized, for dining out with young children.

site_logo

Placidinho Fernandes . 2025-05-10

MORE AT Google

This site pick number of people book online when we in 2 adults and 4 child so when we in on time they told us 4 adults and 2 children this is wrong told us child under 5ft my children age 6 8 13 15 our are children they think seek 13/15 adults we weren’t happy they make extra money all wrong. Should age 18 to be adults.. site is stupid!!!

site_logo

John Farrell . 2025-04-20

MORE AT Google

After booking ,I decided to read the reviews, some were so bad I was thinking should I maybe cancel I'm so glad I don't .. We were shown to our seats and drinks ordered straight away .. The lovely person who gave us our drinks was so polite, and told us we could go and get our food.. The food itself was hot and tasted delicious. Looking around I seen people go back for more ,which in itself was good, as I again I thought of reviews . Plenty of choice. The place was so busy on our leaving .. Ample parking and so easy to find. Would I go back, absolutely, and I can't wait to do so .No photos taken sorry, was to busy enjoying the food..

site_logo

Trek13805038346 . 2025-04-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Staff are really friendly, food is quantity over quality. Ideal for a large groups, bit of something for everyone.

site_logo

Ady Simons . 2025-04-19

MORE AT Google

The food is really nice in there and all the waiters are kind. They have an open grill where they cook a meat of your choice. Drinks come fast and filled right to the top. It is really well decorated and really clean everywhere. The toilets are clean aswell and have a unique design that looks really nice. Overall, this is an amazing buffet to eat at.

site_logo

Elijah Tuffin . 2025-04-18

MORE AT Google

Superb as always. A fantastic buffet. We visited last night to break up a long drive (it’s about 5 mins from M4 junction 16 so easy to get to)

site_logo

Jonathan Whelan . 2025-04-18

MORE AT Google

Not as much choice as there used to be hard to read information labels very old and small

site_logo

Sara Tozer . 2025-04-14

MORE AT Google

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great Value Takeaway! I went for the takeaway option and honestly, it's one of the most affordable and satisfying choices around. The portion size was generous, and the food tasted great! I haven’t dined in yet, so I can’t speak for the service or atmosphere inside—but for takeaway, it’s definitely awesome and worth it. Will be back for more!

site_logo

Rino Eldho Paul . 2025-04-10

MORE AT Google

The good place for a Chinese meal

site_logo

Anthony Jones . 2025-04-07

MORE AT Google

“Terrible experience at Hong in Oriental. I found a hair in my chicken, which is completely unacceptable. When I informed the staff, they showed no concern and didn’t even offer an apology. Instead, they were dismissive and acted like it wasn’t a big deal. Good customer service means addressing issues professionally, but that was clearly lacking here. If this is how they handle complaints, I can only imagine what their hygiene standards are like behind the scenes. I won’t be coming back and wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone looking for a clean and well-managed restaurant.” All it needed was just a Sorry!

site_logo

Sidney Da Costa . 2025-04-04

MORE AT Google

Have a good experience in hongxin ast night!! The food was very nice and staff are very helpful but I thing I need to said to the next table customer! I heard that he found a hair in the food , immediately the manager come to the table and said sorry and gave him a free meal !! But the way the customer talk wast not polite and write false reviews ! That’s so bad!

site_logo

John Zhang . 2025-04-04

MORE AT Google

Went for a birthday meal and food was excellent staff were friendly and atmosphere made you feel at home

site_logo

Emily Loxton . 2025-04-03

MORE AT Google

Haven't been here for ages. Food was delicious. All the staff were super friendly and helpful.

site_logo

Rachel Davies . 2025-04-03

MORE AT Google

Terrible experience at Hong in Oriental. I found a hair in my chicken, which is completely unacceptable. When I informed the staff, they showed no concern and didn’t even offer an apology. Instead, they were dismissive and acted like it wasn’t a big deal. Good customer service means addressing issues professionally, but that was clearly lacking here. If this is how they handle complaints, I can only imagine what their hygiene standards are like behind the scenes. I won’t be coming back and wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone looking for a clean and well-managed restaurant.

site_logo

Sidney D . 2025-04-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

RJ ROQUE VAZ’s CULINARY ADVENTURES in ENGLAND : Visiting My Favourite Fab Chinese Oasis in SWINDON - HONGXIN 🇨🇳 ❤️🎈🚗❤️🎈☕️

site_logo

RJ Roque Vaz . 2025-03-31

MORE AT Google

Had the buffet lunch here yesterday and it was incredible. A huge range of food, all fresh, hot and plentiful. Excellant value for money.

site_logo

Debbie Henderson . 2025-03-30

MORE AT Google

I was longing to eat here for my birthday but it came as a disappointment as the food was not to my taste

site_logo

honey . 2025-03-30

MORE AT Google

Fantastic lunch experience. Wide variety of food - piping hot & every dish is really tasty and great value for money. Atmosphere is great with lovely view of the lake. Customer service is exemplary. The venue is super clean. Ample parking.

site_logo

Les . 2025-03-28

MORE AT Google

Food was nice apart from the teppanyaki. The person in charge was unhelpful. They run out of squid and I waited for 30 before he decided to refill. Then he switched for an inexperienced staff that burned my onions and undercooked the squid. Really disappointed!!!!

site_logo

David Montout . 2025-03-25

MORE AT Google

Been here twice in 2 days. Have the to say the food isn’t bad. However the staff ain’t. Very welcoming. Rude because we were filling up our tubs even tho we seen multiple people doing my day before, felt very disgusted. To make it worse 5 mins later we noticed the staff chucking all the food away which I thought was a complete waste. If it’s an all you can eat then common sense would think you can have what you want, I don’t seem the logic as if it’s on the plate why can’t we just out some in the tubs. As it wouldn’t have gone to waste. Staff then decided to watch us eat which was very intimidating at the least. Such a shame as the food was nice.

site_logo

Luke Morgsn . 2025-03-25

MORE AT Google

Lunch for 7, food selection was varied, hot and tasty. The service was attentive without being overbearing, used plates and glasses cleaned away ready for the next round. Prices were superb and the whole experience was first class .. we will absolutely be going back.

site_logo

Pete Clarke . 2025-03-23

MORE AT Google

Great selection and incredible food

site_logo

Steven Holt . 2025-03-20

MORE AT Google

Really worth a visit! A good buffet restaurant! Love it!

site_logo

Unknown . 2025-03-18

MORE AT Google

Yummy food with plenty of options and cool decor. My family My family has enjoyed dinner my sister birthday here 🥰🥰😍😍

site_logo

Lily Stevens . 2025-03-15

MORE AT Google

11 years old child was charged an adult price only because the child is 151cm tall. Won't come back

site_logo

Magdalena Muszynska . 2025-03-14

MORE AT Google

Luke warm food, but plenty of it, the place feels like it could do with a little TLC.

site_logo

David Bradbury . 2025-03-12

MORE AT Google

The food is nice and tender and hot lots to choose from service is very good with a nice atmosphere had a remote waiter first one I have seen very clever to take away your dirty dishes

site_logo

Peter Wood . 2025-03-11

MORE AT Google

Good food selection, very good value

site_logo

David Dodd . 2025-03-10

MORE AT Google

This food is generally acceptable.

site_logo

Miguel Matute . 2025-03-09

MORE AT Google

Not very good food running out and not be re placed and being told you only had tenminutes left as next costumes were booked in and so many mistakes being made when trying to pay

site_logo

Susan Newton . 2025-03-08

MORE AT Google

Food was piping hot, tasty and replenished frequently. Staff were helpful and quickly cleared plates, etc. Having visited before, it lacked the 'surprise' element. Ours was the only larger group booking, when we visited. Many more people were there on the smaller 1-4 person sized tables at the back.

site_logo

Cheryl Beech . 2025-03-03

MORE AT Google

A population venue and good value for money, buy a lot of the produce was low on supply and the crispy duck was very dry.

site_logo

Will Stevens . 2025-03-02

MORE AT Google

This is my favourite Chinese buffet. Lovely food with a huge selection.

site_logo

Emma Jeffries . 2025-03-01

MORE AT Google

Approx £18 per person for an all you can eat buffet. Food selection is very good, chefs on hand to make special foods or help yourself to a good selection of dishes.... Desert selection too... With a couple of drinks expect to pay around £30 total. Plenty of free parking, staff on hand to help...

site_logo

john nld . 2025-02-27

MORE AT Google

Hi my friend mary Brooks went on a Tuesday lunch about a fortnight ago now and really enjoyed the food etc and the price she paid xxx

site_logo

Carol Commons . 2025-02-22

MORE AT Google

Good value and friendly staff. Fruit options for dessert 🍰 used to be better but have since been reduced in range. Larger chicken satay pieces sometimes undercooked.

site_logo

Richard R . 2025-02-21

MORE AT Google

This place is tasty and delicious, im coming here again

site_logo

jayden Ye . 2025-02-21

MORE AT Google

Delicious food good atmosphere and accommodate for large bookings

site_logo

George Willoughby . 2025-02-17

MORE AT Google

Wasn’t good as consumer was making me feel uncomfortable as a woman asking me about my pregnancy and personal questions Manager offsite basically said nothing they can do mindless complementing kids meal Was not happy at all felt unsafe as a pregnant woman about to give birth

site_logo

Ciara Batey . 2025-02-15

MORE AT Google

Tables and seating not very clean

site_logo

Stacy Knight . 2025-02-15

MORE AT Google

Very average. Food quality and selection is fair. Nothing great, but good value for money

site_logo

Alan Jackson . 2025-02-10

MORE AT Google

Food is reasonable. We have gone here many times over the years, but the menu never seems to change but the prices keep going up. Mind you, there is not much competition in Swindon, so you can't blame them...

site_logo

Neil Scott Hadwin . 2025-02-09

MORE AT Google

My first time here, it's been easy parking, good services and good atmosphere near the lake. The food is good, the starters and main were better than expected and experiences compared other London buffet places. Definitely recommend this place. It's best to have a few items and a good selection of choice on a plate rather than dumping all in one go. Dessert not so many options and could improve there.

site_logo

Selvan Selvakumar . 2025-02-07

MORE AT Google

Always visit when at my Uncle's...we love it

site_logo

Kerri Brazier . 2025-02-05

MORE AT Google

Food and service was amazing can't wait to come again!

site_logo

Jade Hill . 2025-01-19

MORE AT Google

HongXin redefines excellence in the Asian culinary arts, blending traditional flavors with innovative techniques. Each dish is a masterpiece, meticulously crafted to tantalize the senses. The ambiance is both elegant and inviting, promoting a unique dining experience, surrounded by traditional Asian inspired artwork. With impeccable staff service and extraordinary creativity, HongXin sets an unparalleled standard in fine dining.

site_logo

Criz La . 2025-01-19

MORE AT Google

Food was cold and cheap ingredients. Sweet selection small and tasted awful. Very expensive , cost us near 50 pounds for 2 people drinking only water. Glass on lemonade was 3.50, won’t go again

site_logo

Steve Pritchard . 2025-01-18

MORE AT Google

fantastic went here for the first time and the whole family loved it such a variety

site_logo

Rebecca Johnson . 2025-01-18

MORE AT Google

Good for people who like to pick and choose their plate of food.

site_logo

Laraine Linstead . 2025-01-15

MORE AT Google

Yummy food with plenty of options and cool decor. There was even a candyfloss guy, which was pretty cool. The dirty plate robot is in desperate need of recalibration, he almost knocked over a table next to me but I got up in time to prevent the table falling and the glasses of the couple (who were off filling up plates) spilling everywhere.

site_logo

Becky Tyler . 2025-01-12

MORE AT Google

Lovely experience - ignore the rude guy at the counter 👌

site_logo

Lazarus Maha . 2025-01-05

MORE AT Google

Nice food loved it staff supportive with people in wheelchairs.

site_logo

Simone Walker . 2024-12-20

MORE AT Google

A Thursday night meal after 5 using £5 vouchers was pleasantly catered for by smiling staff and great selection of Chinese food cooked to perfection. Robot tray collector is entertainment for kids, and good selection of tasty foods entertainment for all. There was variety of dishes from spicy to savoury and s griddle where you can find shredded duck and meats cooked to your liking. Overall. best all you can eat Chinese I've been to because of quality of selection and yummy food to eat.

site_logo

Percy Scott . 2024-12-16

MORE AT Google

The restaurant is pleasant enough with good food at a reasonable price but walking past the slop bucket and dirty dish stack to get to your table, isn’t great. The service friendly and timely too. A big negative is the mens bathrooms; the last time I was here they weren’t great but this time they were disgusting. See picks. Bottom line I would come again but if the bathrooms are in that kind of state again , it will be my last visit.

site_logo

drew murry . 2024-12-12

MORE AT Google

This is the third visit to HongXin Oriental Buffet. Food was really good as always. Lots of variety and all fresh and hot. Staff were very attentive and cleared away our dirty plates very quickly. Will definitely be going again.

site_logo

Guy S . 2024-12-11

MORE AT Google

Most of food were oily and sweet. Completely different taste from other Chinese buffet restaurants.

site_logo

Bal Pun . 2024-12-10

MORE AT Google

The best all-you-can-eat restaurant in Swindon.

site_logo

explorer . 2024-12-08

MORE AT Google

This place has always been an average venue for Chinese food not brilliant but OK. Tonight we visited for the first time in months and it was very poor. Lots of Chinese looking food but not much in the way of Chinese tasting food you know that thing that it is not possible to recreate that authentic Chinese “something”. That was sadly lacking. The kids favourite nuggets, sausages and chips were probably better. Won’t be going back. It feels like it’s on its way out.

site_logo

Adam R . 2024-11-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Such a lovely settings, food is great and so are the staff.

site_logo

Mad Dogs and an Englishman . 2024-11-11

MORE AT Google

Wonderful restaurant, the kitchen is ok, the food is delicious, we are satisfied😃🫡👍👍👍

site_logo

Maris Susts . 2024-11-01

MORE AT Google

Good food and as much of it as you want!

site_logo

Nigel Allerton . 2024-10-31

MORE AT Google

Friendly service, wonderful selection of Asian food

site_logo

Peter H. James . 2024-10-29

MORE AT Google

Just had another lovely meal at this restaurant - the food is delicious and the staff are lovely.

site_logo

Lindsay Smith . 2024-10-25

MORE AT Google

Was a great menu with so much food to choose from had a great dine in experience

site_logo

Bobbie Lucas . 2024-10-22

MORE AT Google

Food was good but attendant hardly speak English and the environment was a bit dull. Maybe a change in decoration and definitely change the ripped seats. They don't look nice.

site_logo

Lady Betty Goncalves . 2024-10-21

MORE AT Google

Been here a few times when visiting family in Swindon, there isn't a massive selection of food but what they cook they cook well always lived coming here and will definitely come back in the future, don't be out of by me saying there's not a massive selection there's still a lot of food there

site_logo

Peter Martin . 2024-10-21

MORE AT Google

Visited for dinner midweek. Food very dry or it sodden wet.. Overpriced badly cooked rubbish food.. Tasteless.. overpriced.. food.

site_logo

philip triggs . 2024-10-19

MORE AT Google

We were competing to fight the next day so this restaurant provided everything we desired. Good choices, clean areas and great service. Satisfaction!

site_logo

Culture-Zoo . 2024-10-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Does what is says on the tin and does it very well

site_logo

Carl Jones . 2024-10-10

MORE AT Google

The food was ok, service ok, price ok for Sunday , restaurant clean and atmosphere very nice. Around desert need more variety,for Sunday very less. Bathroom not very clean needs more attention, location nice parking plenty.

site_logo

Soca S . 2024-10-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Quite limited at lunch time now. They've turned off the chocolate fountain with the marshmallows etc. also no longer do the duck and pancakes at lunch time. But disappointing for the price you pay

site_logo

Amy Davis . 2024-10-08

MORE AT Google

Got a takeaway box last night after not eating anything all day yesterday so was looking forward to it , I’m now suffering today with the worst stomach with sickness and had to take the day of work. They do need to have fresher food on rotation.

site_logo

Laura . 2024-09-30

MORE AT Google

Good tasting food could be hotter. The staff are great, very fast and kind. The whole restaurant/buffet area is clean and tidy, usually there is a cleaner constantly keeping things tidy which is nice to see! The food and buffet experience is worth the price they charge. The drinks are reasonably priced too.

site_logo

William Dyer . 2024-09-29

MORE AT Google

Great options, although I found that the floors were fairly slippery underfoot and our drinks took a while to arrive. Our drinks order was also incorrect when it did appear at our table. The crispy beef was also cold when my step father helped himself to a serving ... Not great. For the price, I would expect much better. Good points? Great seafood and vegetarian options, allergens etc were clearly labelled.

site_logo

Kim . 2024-09-23

MORE AT Google

Best in town oriental buffet. Awesome Service and always very tasty.

site_logo

Val * . 2024-09-22

MORE AT Google

Best Chinese around, in a park so bonus…actual ducks, see them living before you eat them, horrify the children, ground yourself in the fragility of life

site_logo

Ollie Budd . 2024-09-20

MORE AT Google

Great food for the price. Loads of tasty options and variety. Good for pescetarian, more limited for vegetarian.

site_logo

Tobias Corrigan . 2024-09-20

MORE AT Google

As always food is great and restaurant is very clean. Staff were really friendly and helpful. Looking forward to next time.

site_logo

Michael Law . 2024-09-19

MORE AT Google

These places can be a hit or miss sometimes but this place was really good, it's been years under the old. Management since been here, a vast improvement and overall good quality food, good service as well despite being a busy environment.

site_logo

Johnny Clingham . 2024-09-18

MORE AT Google

These places can be a hit or miss sometimes but this place was really good, it's been years under the old. Management since been here, a vast improvement and overall good quality food, good service as well despite being a busy environment.

site_logo

Johnny Clingham . 2024-09-18

MORE AT Google

It always annoys me children are charged adult prices because of their height. Food was ok, I wish they would change their menu regularly but they don't. Not a brilliant choice at lunch time.

site_logo

Clare W . 2024-09-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The waitress's fake smile is annoying 😏

site_logo

Elise Angelo . 2024-09-15

MORE AT Google

Loads of food choices and very tasty. As always very nice

site_logo

Ioana Delia Antal . 2024-09-14

MORE AT Google

Food is OK but could definitely be warmer.

site_logo

Simon Dewey . 2024-09-13

MORE AT Google

Very pleasant evening with my sisters

site_logo

Sue Payne . 2024-09-12

MORE AT Google

Food was good for buffet style, restaurant starting to look a bit tired inside.

site_logo

Tim Cadle . 2024-09-07

MORE AT Google

Love this place, however food could be a little better. However exactly what I'd expect from a buffet

site_logo

Josh Whiddett . 2024-09-04

MORE AT Google

A complete rip off paid for three adults because one grandchild is tall for his age not a problem!!! The food was sparce not a very good selection didn't get offered a drink had to go looking for someone to take the order after finished main course headed for the deserts absolute disgrace, Dolly mixtured chocolate buttons,a quarter filled minute cup of jelly fresh fruit and sultanas a Swiss roll the bill was just shy of £80 ,after getting scored a very low hygiene rating and getting there act together thought we would go back .I expect a lot better

site_logo

Marilyn S . 2024-09-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We have been going to this restaurant over 20 years. This is the best value Chinese 🇨🇳 restaurant around Swindon. Please take some of the negative comments on pinch 🤏 of salt. You have to go and experience yourself. Staff are friendly and you will enjoy the foods.❤️❤️❤️

site_logo

Dillon Marcellus . 2024-08-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Good value for money , always get there as it opens eat as much or little as you like and good place to try new flavours

site_logo

Penelope Page . 2024-08-15

MORE AT Google

Do not go if you have ANY food allergies or intolerances as they do not cater for it. All foods including rice state gluten, hence no gluten free. The one star review is purely based on this and not the food quality etc, as my son loves the food here. Disappointed as previously they had GF dishes available.

site_logo

Martyn Nelson . 2024-08-15

MORE AT Google

Really enjoyable visit. Clean facilities and spoilt for choice for sweet and savoury food. All cooked food served hot. All delicious and fantastic value for money

site_logo

Emily Young . 2024-08-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This place needs to smarten up. Floors very sticky - are the kitchen floors the same!! Tired upholstery. Food just warm and not fresh. Not a good experience. Won't be returning.

site_logo

Steve F . 2024-08-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food was good, a little pricey to go on a weekend but much better prices for lunch or weekday. Chairs could do with a refresh as a lot of them are starting to wear out. This isn't the first time I've been there and it won't be the last. I always enjoy this place when I fancy it. Missed the lemon chicken today though :(

site_logo

Jon McBride . 2024-08-10

MORE AT Google

Plenty to choose from and the food is lovely.

site_logo

P R . 2024-08-09

MORE AT Google

Some staff seem miserable while others are happy and pleasant. The food is good and constantly being replaced with fresh

site_logo

Rub MadG . 2024-08-07

MORE AT Google

Food as always is soooooo good love this place

site_logo

charlene sims . 2024-08-07

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in South West

restaurant_img
3.6

1113 Opinions

location-icon119 Cricklade Road
Chinese
outdoor_seating_207055takeaway_207055delivery_207055

The food was hot and very tasty. Excellent value and would definitely recommend

restaurant_img
4.2

265 Opinions

location-iconDorcan Way Centre Dorcan Way
Chinese
outdoor_seating_197706takeaway_197706delivery_197706

Very bad food, shredded beef it's only sweet and sour taste,overwhelming sweeteners and rice is so poor quality, tasteless

restaurant_img
3.4

1056 Opinions

location-icon184 Moredon Rd
Chinese
outdoor_seating_146051takeaway_146051delivery_146051

If I could give a minus review I would. Food arrived late. Rice was so stodgy and overcooked. When I called for a replacement I was met with the offer to refund but no replacement (meaning all I had was some chicken....not exactly a meal!) when I asked for replacement they said I'd have to pay for delivery again....I don't think it's unreasonable for an error to be corrected at no extra expense to the customer. Manager refused to talk to me so had to speak via the counter assistant who, when I politely argued my point (I never raised my voice and I empathised entirely with how busy they must be) she hung up on me. I called back thinking it was a mistake but they just hung up straight away proving it was intentional. They then refused to answer my calls. I've had no refund and by the time the ordeal was over (not sorted) the chicken was cold. Appalling "service" and I will not be ordering from here again. I strongly advise others to avoid as if anything is wrong, they will do nothing to correct it.

restaurant_img
4.5

111 Opinions

location-icon74 Victoria Road
Chinese
outdoor_seating_324514takeaway_324514delivery_324514

Best Singapore fryrice ever🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

restaurant_img
3.1

95 Opinions

location-icon2 Hoopers Place
Chinese
outdoor_seating_210862takeaway_210862delivery_210862

The dj's were TERRIBLE all they did was take a famous song and add a terrible dnb remix to it. every song was the same. Every song was terrible. They should be sacked